Compiling the Quran and Bible 3
Date:
Channel: Mohammad Qutub
Series: Mohammad Qutub - Compiling the Quran and Bible
File Size: 57.60MB
Related
- Akram Nadwi – The Majesty of Allah
- Hacene Chebbani – The Major Signs Of The Hour Part 4
- Muiz Bukhary – Drowning in Addictions and Steps To Overcome Them
- Abdullah Oduro – Manners of the Mindful – Have Mercy
- Taimiyyah Zubair – Taleem al Quran 2021 J03-036C Tafsir Al-Baqarah 268-270
- Aarij Anwer – Umrah Series – Episode 03 – Dua Prayer
- Taimiyyah Zubair – Taleem al-Quran 2010 – Juz 29 – L293D
AI Generated Summary ©
The conversation discusses the importance of the seven main receptors in the Bible and their relation to modern writing. It also covers various narratives and recitation sources, including a recitation of a woman named Hamza and a recitation of a woman named Al Ko union. The speakers discuss the pronunciation of various words and the importance of keeping in mind the difference between the Bible and the American English pronunciation of "naught." They also mention a study on the topic of "health" and its relation to the American English pronunciation of "naught."AI Generated Transcript ©
hamdu Lillahi Rabbil Alameen wa salatu salam with this Limon so you didn't know what Imam you know had been a middle class in Mohammed Abdullah Abdullah early will be here with Tabby from antibiogram BSN 11 With Deen Subhana Allah and Milena Elana Alam, tena, Inaka Interlimb Hakeem. Obviously surgery was silly Emery will have data Melissa nipa who Akali I praise the Lord mighty and I send prayers and blessings upon Prophet Muhammad sallallahu alayhi wa sallam his noble family righteous companions and all those that follow them with the right guidance until the day of judgment I mean, glory be to you Allah, no knowledge have we accept that which you have taught us Indeed you are the
All Knowing the all wise idea brothers and sisters as salaam aleikum wa rahmatullah wa barakato.
And today Insha Allah we will continue with our seminar on the Quran and the Bible, comparison of compilation and historicity
last time we spoke about the revelation of the Quran we spoke about the compilation of the Quran during the time of the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wasallam. And we spoke about it as well during the time of Abu Bakr, Radi Allahu Allah.
And we started speaking about the seventh roof right, very good.
So today in sha Allah,
we will continue we will learn more about the Quranic recitations
and then try to understand
what are the difference possibly between
the hero and the recitations, some of the main differences also
that we see very minor differences in the difference Quranic recitations, and in sha Allah, Allah willing, we will start also with the compilation of the Bible.
Very good.
We mentioned some of the Hadith, talking about the seven Ashraf most importantly, that these seven Ashraf are all from Allah subhanho wa Taala
revealed to Prophet Muhammad Salah Salem through Gibreel. And as some of the Hadith showed us were upon the request of Prophet Muhammad Sallallahu Sallam very similar to his request for Allah azza wa jal to ease the obligation of the Salah when Gibreel came to him with one heart,
he asked for more.
So the idea behind the Azure of in the first place is making things easy on the OMA that does not read or write.
In large majority,
undo,
but the large majority does not read or write. So now,
having more than one way will make it easier rather than
going after this one half, which may be a little bit different than what they're used to, and having to study it, and so on. So having another heart of another way,
as we said, is possibly the more correct and more common opinion about what the heart means
that this will make things easier for the OMA.
And this is what was happening. And we saw we mentioned some of the Hadith,
such as what happened between some of the Sahaba were they notice that there's a slightly different recitation, but when they went to the Prophet SAW Salem, he said that both are correct. Okay.
Again, I underline minor differences. And we will see in sha Allah some of those differences today. That was with regards to the seven
there'll be four we get into a sort of comparison and understanding of a hero as opposed to recitations.
The different Quranic recitations. Before that, let's go into the recitations and understand more about that. We said the first one to write about the recitations was the great
color
long ago,
evade al Qasim even Salam.
And after him was the great scholar Ibn Mujahid
who wrote some time around the fourth century
about the different Pirot
Interestingly, even Mujahid wrote about the seven main recitations
seven Clara
how many Kira do we have today? Brothers and sisters
you went through the synopsis. You did your little bit of research maybe a little bit late
Okay any other opinions?
How many people that are accepted
as genuine Quran that anyone can recite
given
the other opinions
No.
Okay. So it will Mujahid said seven he wrote about the seven and he wrote about the seven main reciters.
Okay.
Interestingly, however,
other scholars may possibly have
felt that one of the great Imams of Kerala, who wasn't mentioned amongst the seven of Ibn Mujahid, but even Mujahid wrote before him, he would have said actually, he deserves to be mentioned amongst the seven more than this one.
So, this was the opinion of Ibn Mujahid. And he restricted it to those seven main reciters
which is to a large extent why there might be some confusion between the seven Clara Act and the seven a roof
and which would cause some to feel that the arrows are the carrot and the carrot or the arrow.
Today we talk about 10 main recitations
that anyone can read as genuine Quran
and we call them the 10 recitations that are mutawa till
they have the quality of the word term and we said tohoto
is that quality which renders authenticity in the sense that it was narrated by so many that it could not be wrong or a fabrication
which you hear always in the science of Hadith as well.
So these are a Pirot Allah Asha l Moutere, where the Iraqi
10
And we talk about four others
which we might call anomalous.
We do not recite them today
as bonafide Quran
and I'll speak about that a little bit more later. However, when we talk about the seven main receptors
the seven main receptors are
helped me to list them now.
What is the one that is so popular and common? That it is the he is the most popular or common?
Pyrrha
in the Islamic world today
Yeah, house, you will lose your house right? Okay, very good.
Is helps the car is it his camera meaning?
Is he the one to whom the camera is attributed to?
Or is there another name we need to mention there?
The leading question it's very clear that I'm telling you this another name.
Half son, our son
of son us.
Meaning haps is a narrator are awesome. The car is awesome. Arson Ibn Ebina, Jude al Koofi
from Kufa.
Right, the car it to whom this recitation is attributed, is our son of an ebbing. Ledgewood Huck's is one of his narrators. There's another
Hafs analysis was the most popular one. So we have of course, awesome. One of the seven
The other
very important reciter is Na
Na al Madani from Medina is whether you're writing for the review
you are memorizing everything
Oh, okay. Oh, okay. All right. Different people. Study differently
we have Nath out from Medina very important.
You always give the camera of worse you hear that name wash.
Wash is not a part of
what wash is one of the narratives of NAFTA. The era is attributed to NASA.
NASA from Medina very important.
Another car, even Castile even conceive?
Because he is the one who did the Dipsy.
Yeah, yes, no.
Let's try to
get our chronology.
Right.
Now does it and sisters these poor Rob
proximately. When are they? In which period historically?
Maybe even the online participants would like to answer not sure how you would, then we would probably need help from the tech department.
Or up approximately.
Let's try to place them in history.
Early, very early.
In fact,
these are raw, the seven main recyclers according to Ibn Mujahid, or 10, as we will see now, these 10 are all either heavy or even the color old
right after the Sahaba
or at bat February, the generation after the taboo
except caliph, Al Baghdadi, the end, the rest are all tambourine or atma tambourine.
Oh, so could it be even Cathy's the officer? Absolutely not.
Kevin is many, many centuries later.
Even cathedral matki even conceived from Mecca to see with seeing the reciters and where they are from Amon casein. McKee the Cadbury is one of the third
generation to come right after the Sahaba
right another important reciter besides mentioned as one of the main seven
everyone
have Warhammer from Basra?
Okay, another very important one
they've been there
from a Shem what is a Shem?
Syria
Lebanon
Palestine? Which one?
That whole that whole area you are all correct. Syria, Lebanon, Palestine and Jordan. That whole area is called a sham.
The prophets of Allah mentions a sham he's talking about that whole area.
Last area
known in history as the Levant
we didn't have these borders before brothers and sisters, Syria, Jordan, Lebanon, it is a sham
law a couple
lines drawn in the sand are on maps more correctly, that we still respect today
that still divide us today.
an hour from a sham another
reciter from Al Khalifa al Kufa had any reciters also Hamza
Hamza as a yet
and LK
is E
L Kisa II also from Kufa
have these three of the seven all from Kufa
and one from Al Basra and these two in Iraq were known as the tour robots, masala and Kufa.
Now interestingly
some of these researchers were students of others of the other reciters
just like the Imams
so as we know
are the Imams of fifth Imam is Shafia is a student of Lima Malik
greatly respected him and loved him.
Imam Ahmed will humble is a student of an imam Shafi.
How can they go and start another web hub?
This isn't something they're really starting brothers and sisters these are opinions. This is their he had and what the hell come what the verdict is.
So they may have had a different opinion than their teacher.
But
after a while, also shows you Subhanallah the the the amicable relations between them.
He didn't become persona non grata just because his student had a different opinion than his own teacher
and eventually became popular for his opinion. Similarly with the karate, he took the Corolla from his cheek
and more than one era
and then he became popular for it because he concentrated on that and he focused on that.
So
it said he was the student of Hamza
Okay, both from Kufa.
Calif Ibn Hashem
is one of his narrators.
Aleph is one of the narratives of Hamza
yet color also Akira is attributed to him
because Hamza Haut several recitations as well
as Nila Isla learned from arson,
yet he himself has Akira attributed to him
and the awesome and so enough recited to Abuja Nerja al Madani recited to Abuja fundamentally and both of them are considered kuruva because they taught several cameras, as well. So when we said the arson, we say half son us and right, I'll send his the one who to whom the recitation is attributed. ALFS is one of his narrators. Another narrator is shorba Surbana awesome.
And he will find some minor differences between Hopson Shoba
both narrating from ransom so often recited in those two different ways
so don't get confused all of these for Rob
awesome. It's been a been a dude.
Great caught it. We're talking about Sonos awesome, it would have been a dude and all of these potluck they all had their Senate Bill ijazah all the way up to the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wasallam
where did they get these recitations? Why is it attributed to them simply because they concentrated on that era and taught it and therefore became popular for it?
Okay
otherwise they all recited to their shifts so awesome, even Urbina dude at Highbury, nevertheless, recited to the great one of the greatest tablet read and the destined for an hour of development, the tsunami
and the tsunami recited to the great Sahaba Abdullah bin Massoud
was ready with a third eye even every time over you've been calm say they've been sabbat these five great ones
to have some urban urban the dude recited these Corollas based on what he heard about the Rama, the tsunami and then to the sahaba.
These are kind of ads from the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wasallam.
It only became attributed to them because they focused on it and taught it and then they became popular for that at all.
And then possibly as we said, one of the students of the car
concentrated in one of the Corollas he got under he became popular for that era
and he became one of the bands of the pillar art as well.
Okay, so who are the other three who's left now?
From the 10. Let's mention now who is the TBI and who is not TBI and then you will see the other three that are there in our Evan cathedral Mackie as we just mentioned, awesome ibn Abi nujood al Koofi,
winner from the mesh user Alta Berry
and algo Allah from a Muslim
and Abu Jaffa from Medina. These are all Tabea.
Then you have the ones who are the next generation nerfed from Medina, who we mentioned also before, Hamza from Kufa,
LTC also from Kufa. Yaku from Missouri
Yeah, who from Basra
and Salaf
left well, Calif is even one later generation. Okay.
Very good.
Now,
we said that some of the recitations are not motivated.
We call them an Arabic shed, chives.
They'd be anomalous didn't reach the level of touto.
Does that mean that the Senate
is not correct or that the camera is not authentic? It is authentically narrated by that person.
Yes, the Senate is authentic and acceptable. Did it reach the level of Taiwan No.
And therefore, we were considering it anomalous.
But otherwise, the Senate is authentic.
recited such an era, the great February
known as the greatest of the time, Al Hasan Basri, Allahu Akbar, but his Clara is shared. He couldn't sit anomalous
because it didn't reach the level of Toto.
So even then,
it's not that, oh, it's not part of luta water, so therefore it is bad.
Well, Hassan Versary.
And it is aware of an authentic chain.
And you can say the same for the others.
The Corolla of solace really reminded me one an Amish a great name.
But it is schuff
not considered part of the mortality.
But as it is authentic.
We can benefit from that sort of sees.
Not for Kerala, we don't read it. We don't recite it as Quran.
But we can benefit from that narration that there are sorry,
the four after the 10
intercedes possibly in understanding and explaining
the Quran.
Any questions about
the clear art
Before we get into
some of the minor differences that we will see in the Torah
okay
okay
let us look at some of the minor differences. We mentioned last time one of the most common and popular examples
of a slightly different recitation is in Al Fatiha itself.
Right. Our Shabbat assumes Mullah Raha Rahim, Malik el Medina and Maliki Yomi. De, by the way, this actually,
if you were to read it, in terms of how minor a difference it is, and how major it's actually somewhere in between, it's not the most minor. There is even more minor than that you think to yourself up, I'll be difference medicating with the mannequin with the there is more minor than that as well.
Which is in a lot of the situations where it's just a slightly different pronunciation.
In this case, there's differences in Elif
medicale with the Maliki on with D.
But in many of the differences between the throw out they are a difference in pronunciation. Do you pronounce the the route Mufasa is it a heavy sound? Or is it more kaka rock or era
these are some of the very minor differences that you will see. Okay and the different
than I thought I want to actually mention to you some of the bigger differences the liner are
quite easy and
it's a slightly different pronunciation you know, what's the big deal doesn't make a difference what may confuse some some of the again slightly
larger differences right.
Which we will also look at otherwise in pronunciation there is very minor differences in the different Tirat Okay
similarly, these very minor differences exactly okay
when you hear sometimes you may hear Musa and you will then hear musei okay, what you do with the LF as well.
And similar examples, I won't go into all of those because like I said, those are the fairly easy ones. And I don't think anyone is going to confuse a Muslim about the Quran because here it's pronounced like this or there it's pronounced like that. But if something's a little bit more different than maybe then we need to kind of look at it. So one of the examples Allah subhanaw taala says in the Quran one I found you mean hiring fairly Faru
one may have had a woman hiring fellow you crew there we are using the
the or using the board
here
well
yes TyLoo
okay, we write the whole thing. Maybe it's better
because we'll see a difference at the end as well.
And then
you look for all
the other recitation what will change this this
it will be
a file who
took photo
oh here
and what they do?
Yeah, they
What they do is good
they will get the reward of it
will not be squandered
in the tap and what you do
you
you to a group again we're talking about a group here the people but here he's talking about them
about them here he's talking to them about the following say he's addressing them Elon took sorrow and then attached here
Oh huge difference totally changes the meaning
does it brothers insists
absolutely not a
simple example of a minor difference in one serif as opposed to another
both Quran or on that we recite
okay
all right
by the way
this other Corolla
with the top is the recitation of
many reciters including
Abba
about an
awesome hola como. So I will say that we read half Santa's awesome, which is the app
is other narratives short about
the sizes with the test. So remember Housen that we all recite, have son awesome.
Even in both ways.
One narrative narrative like this short binaries, the other one
from the same car,
and other researchers also read it with a tap, not only shorten the analysis,
and you will find some of these interesting minor differences between short about and perhaps the two narrators of arson
al kofi, the great Imam.
Similarly
the idea there's a
sudden dichotomy Kelly Murthy or Bihar worku to be
talking about Maryam Alayhis Salam
just writes maybe the where the minor difference is was on the Cardi B Kelly Marcela behalf what could to be he
Arabic experts
what could to be
meaning
Oh, so Kitab what is Kitab book Koto books
were called to be
some of the researchers would would recite it or anything of it. Some of them would write it or recite it wacky tabby.
Now books in plural but book and his book
he believed in the Lord's books in her Lord's book,
slightly different meaning and the problem not at all.
Again, one of the ones who read it that is shown by himself
so our sin, the Imam of the Terra sometimes when it became a matter of Bihar wakatobi and sometimes it became a matter of Bihar workI Tabby
and the same thing for the other payees CG Lillian Kutub
little cafe ECG li little key tab in singular.
All
automatic
from the mama awesome. From a what up the roof man a salami from the Sahaba from the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam.
Another one
See
how the board or the board all right
okay like that that's good
Yeah
great, but then our audience will not see it either like that that should work
well i Lima Anna,
he can love
and he knows that there is weakness
in you
Abuja al Madani recited
more often
this is considered a more major difference this is not just a pronunciation this is a slightly different word I'm trying to give you some of the more major was so that you see that even the hospital quite minor okay.
So he knew there is weakness in you
Botha
go as an African go I thought that there are weak ones amongst you
I wonder
does it make a difference does it
this is the miracle of the Quran
that with these seven Ashraf that were revealed to the Prophet salallahu Alaihe Salam
there's no contradiction in meaning
is that clock Correct? Okay, that's good
the other
one and the rule Tuca
stand me up Lima you will have I have chosen you
chosen
Musa alayhis salam
according to how does that
well
we have chosen Allah azza wa jal refers to himself many times
the plural of respect
national and
white difference
notice some of these differences are just due to the
issue of the dotting the dots. We saw on the first one you look for oh and took Faro.
Originally, the skeletal script didn't have dots.
Put the dots here.
We'll put the dots there. Yeah, or tap
okay.
So you can kind of see some of these
minor differences where it has to do also with the dotting of the skeletal script.
This one is an interesting one.
And one of the major ones
the famous idea
that Agia confesseth Woombie never in fertile baby. No.
Baby and you.
Sorry. You can see I'm a typist. I don't believe in handwriting.
All right.
The other recitation
that led to
oh, we have a different word.
Sprint word
doesn't look very different. Because again, if you write it skeletally It's identical.
It's about the dots, the, the, the set
set of about that.
And then the TAT
instead of the noon. Oh, this is a different word.
Oh
we have a problem here.
What does Fabian mean? Either a competitor can be another task.
immoral person comes to you with some news
Tobiano.
investigates.
Or to clarify,
don't just accept it immediately. Let's obey you.
32 Confirm?
Is it correct are not
synonymous.
synonymous words.
In fact, if you were to ask for a synonym for about a year, you will probably say that better the other word
synonymous with every year new fettered by two
different words but this is the jazz this is the inevitability of the Quran.
Very good.
Now
these focus with me
another very interesting example.
Last panel, data sets and maybe
it's even cooler I'm not gonna write the whole thing I'll just write the part that is important.
And yet Tim in Kona
refurbishers mobility above the fascia tin.
Okay
you're gonna turn
your loss
off
look at this word, you will draw off
the verse is saying, Allah subhanaw taala was telling the wives of the Prophet salallahu Alaihe Salam, whoever Have you
would commit an immoral act
they are the furthest from such a thing as Allah speaking whoever of you
if you were to commit an immoral act
her punishment will be doubled
these are the best these are the wives of the Prophet SAW Selim.
They're the ones who should have the excuse
in our world today
oh, they're the best so they can get away with immoral acts and crimes and all kinds of things you laugh punishment will be double our even
though they are the furthest from such a thing
you lost
you lost lehle ASABE the punishment will be doubled or her like that.
Now
the other
recitation Clara
or this word is
your bar if
the Shuddha and without the Elif.
Are you better off sorry, you will lock up
loss
Oh, different words or looks different? No. And if with a shudder, you laugh. So here you will laugh. You laugh. Just another
way where you have the shutdown.
Okay.
As opposed to the LF
but otherwise, it's still you.
Delay Yeah.
And it is in the passive voice. It's not telling us who will double their punishment. The punishment will be doubled. This is the passive voice not the active voice. In both EULA I feel
both
here on earth Water Watch Euro okay there's a third one
Oh welcome
nobody
huh no look noon Thursday yeah
noon instead of yeah
similar to this one with the shutdown
no Elif but now active voice no but if we will double law will double their punishment
so now for you logic
on a sewers experts
okay there's a fourth logical possibility right so you laugh doula off the air
Nobody's life which is similar to this the fourth posit logical possibility
no ball was the new now this one two years now with the noon but looking like this one it will be no boy ice
this is not put on
it's the fourth logical possibility it's not put on you cannot recite it as this is shad anomalous
it's not by logic
about where you think it's not something you make up. Okay, so we have the three so we just take the fourth logical possibility No, this is shad. This was not recited as mortality.
Similar meaning no dice we will double but only in this form without the Shuddha with NF
we don't consider this Quran today
so give this to the orientalists and those who cast doubt about the Quran
it's not about what you think about what has been recited what is mortality? Okay, it's about the science of the Quran. What the Quran narrated and what they accepted only as mortality
it's only these three these three are all Quran and you will hear the 10 reciters recite them
but not alive Do you honestly think someone hearing it will immediately record recognize it the way of operational life? But no, it's not acceptable. A scholar of Quran or someone who knows the tensor RT immediately said no no no not know why this is not part of the 10
meter what is Pirot
as you see
every
area Subhan Allah as you see
a lot of the differences in the Quran, a reminder and usually not this big, I'm showing you the big ones most of them are in the diacritical marks with this key but ha kestra shed the NAMA simple stuff like that
most of the differences are like this. So the next time someone tells you there are different versions of the Quran, them sit down let let me let me teach you
okay. And most of the time, you will what kind of differences will be it might be like this from active to passive
from first person, second person, the third person may be Singular plural, simple stuff.
Not the glaring differences that we will see
that you find in so many texts including
the holy text, okay.
So these are
A big part of some of the differences between the different era
as we
say that
this is Quran
we benefit
from those slightly minor differences for the tip see
if it is Akira that is mutawa Tierra enriches with obscene and it enriches the fix
that we derived from the verses
without contradiction.
So, when we talk about these differences, we talk about it not as contradictory differences, but rather differences in slight differences in form that only enrich do not
lead to contradictions.
We mentioned in the very beginning one of the bigger differences
root
and taboo.
We have a different letter altogether. They weren't just a different letter.
What we said this is a different dialect. This is the dialect of Abdullah bin Massoud dialect of Hubei and as we will see in the compilation of Earth man, what was left was the dialect of Quraysh
because the Quran first was revealed in the dialect of Quraysh so some of the other
slightly larger differences more major ones
and one idea was Sadie
and hasten the other one Sadie
what's the difference?
Whoa
and basin or Heysen huge difference isn't it? I'm kidding. Okay.
But hear considerably when you compare two diacritical marks that differed? How Oh yeah, it is a big difference. There's a letter there's a Whoa there
meaning it's it's nothing but compared to some of the other ones Yeah, this is more major This is a different a different letter
What do you mean
Okay, so what's your question
right, this is one of the cameras this is one of the actual
one of the 100 of one with one on one without
and
you will see that
this is available in the
one of the many mishaps
okay
so we said some of the other art
we put on the site simply because it didn't reach the level of collateral even if it was a giant in Quran such as
Al Hasan Basri or Abdullah bin Massoud or Buddha or whoever
it may be
okay
Having said all that,
oh there is another one
what was Salah Oh saw we have seen this one as well
just a different form of the word well we'll saw what Elsa
this one has a shudder.
Okay,
another interesting one
is
you might have heard this one as well perjury.
The hull and HA
and the other one is tragedy men that Elena
gardens of Paradise under which rivers flow
Oh
god men from under or without men
rivers flow under it
no difference but this is quite major
This is now another word men from
Kara
I'm with Ella Tierra
and recite is recited it but how would you get it
from the Hispanic scripts because we know when we get to the compilation of man of the Allahu Allah that he eventually
compiled everything into one script for the different dots we can see
if it was skeletal
we can see how we can go read differently and get those different ones.
But how would we deal with another word? We'll get to that remind me if I forget
this is to say that
when the scholars were
deciding what is going to be acceptable as Quran and only Quran, which are part of the 10 Otowa to Pirot. They said first of all, it has to have reached the level of toto an obvious condition
number two,
it has to somehow conform to
the Arabic rules of grammar.
And number three, it has to this is the crux of the issue. It has to conform to the earth Manik script.
If there's something that does not conform to the US Manik script,
it will not be accepted.
And I think this is the
an excellent segue into the compilation of worth man will probably take a small break. But before that, I want to answer the burning question in all of your minds.
Which is
we heard about the seven growth.
We heard about the seven here or at.
But we said, Actually, we have 10. There are a lot, right.
So the question becomes
what's the difference between the Ashraf and the Corolla? Are they the same? The simple answer is no. They're not the same.
The Corolla is not a half, per se.
We said that our ways of recitation. Okay.
And interestingly,
Imam Mohamed
MlJ Serie A great father of Pirot, whose name you will always hear,
especially amongst the students of karate,
late scholar
only about
five centuries ago or so, four to five centuries ago.
He actually quotes even Taymiyah who says that there is no difference of opinion that the Khaira are not the Ashraf
they are not the actual So then how do we understand and how do we differentiate
you see the example I gave you there.
I'm sorry.
When talking about the punishment being doubled for the wives of the Prophet sallallahu, alayhi wasallam.
There what you see what you see is not a minor difference in pronunciation.
There's a difference in the letter and the haircut.
So, each of those would be a half
would be a half when you're talking about a how you're talking about a difference
in the word itself, not in the pronunciation.
So these three which are acceptable, or how in the house that
Three, three of the seven
recited by all 10 reciters
all of the 10
not each all of the 10 recited one of these three harps
the recitation is not a half
you had several reciters
using one half there
we are not exactly the same.
Okay.
So sometimes
recitation will involve a difference in
our of but sometimes it was not, might be just a small difference in pronunciation. In this case, it's a different it seems to be a different half
but the three out of the seven are recited by the different and recitals that we mentioned. And similarly
in one of the is I don't think I have time to maybe write it on the board and sort of rod it's a very similar example to the idea of Surah Al Hassan where you will have those three different possibilities and not the fourth logical one.
So that might be a different health
so health does not equal Pyrrha per se Okay
any questions before we take a small break and talk about the compilation of us man around the law one?
That's why Saturday Oh, Saturday Oh, and I'll get to that. When I end Inshallah, the compilation and Earthman.
can remind me if I forget, but I think most probably I want because that's a critical point.
We take a small break every five minutes.