Channel: Waleed Basyouni
Bulugh Al Maram Series presented by Sh Waleed Basyouni at the Clear Lake Islamic Center
This lecture was presented on May 02, 2017.
Lao salatu salam ala rasulillah.
Chapter Three, the nature and cleansing of
vinegar out of alcohol. He said no, it is prohibited
by Muslim activity and the latter created Hudson good and authentic analysis
sudo su lies have a lot of audio or send them
a project similar to
this chapter, which is valuable, he's added in the jaw city.
Chapter Three, the nature and cleansing of an adjuster. That's how we translated. But it's not a very accurate translation of what
the author lost, if you're going to translate what exactly he said, he said, the name of the chapter of the cleansing of NASA and its nature.
started with the cleansing, then he followed by some athletes nature,
which is the translation goes to what is supposed to be you identify an adjuster? You mentioned, what's the nature of that adjust? Then you follow that by telling us how to cleanse yourself from it. That's right. But he himself, but the author of this chapter, kind of put it backwards. He said Babel is ality.
And that's something I criticized him for. He said he should have said Babel, they I mean,
the nature of an advice on how to cleanse yourself from it, but he did, did it the other way around. And maybe the reason for that, because in the previous chapter, as we covered that you can go to our website and listen to the previous classes. He talked about the nature of the ninjas, he mentioned so many other net josas before
like he talked about before about, for example, that urine and he talked about the dog and the saliva of the dog. So he talks about what's considered notice what's not considered methods like that. So the saliva of the cats and the mouth of the cats, you know if it's bought or not bought, so you mentioned already, he talked about previously about the nature of then adjusted that's why this chapter is a continuation and focusing more about how to remove that adjust.
impurity is two times Nigel's idea when adjust the hook me, Nigel says impurity in itself, that something impure
and something No, then adjusted something appear.
So what is then adjusted in itself? Like the urine, like the feces, come on, come on. It's not just in itself. Nothing can in that in itself is nothing but an adjustment to me that something became nachus chanson became this like, what? This garment this though, this surface, it's few, you put a blood on it, it became not just with a urine head, this became matches. So originally it was it became madness. So that's what you call your chameleon. How can you purify, then adjust
what is whatever is natural in itself, whatever ninjas itself only can be purified with one way we call an str when you transfer that necklace, from its original state to a new state
Okay. And Previously, we give an example like
The skin of the dead animal it's nervous because it's a blood and it's not
but what happened we died that skin. So the die have transferred this to a new introduced by let's say you take the urine and the feces and you put it in a chemical process like what many cities do today and this chemical process basically transfer this niches or sewer water and to purify and go through chemical process then you get out what a pure water
that the only thing can purify. The Niger spore itself is through what we call is the hollow means transformation, Transform, transform it from one entity to a new entity.
As for that adjuster komiya, which is something big be big become or became edges,
like surface or anything like that, you can purify it with what with any method in any way that it would remove, then adjust. It could be water and that's the best way it could be sand. It could be chemical, it could be the sun, like let's say you have a land or a piece of
like let's say
in your carpet
then the sun hits this carpet until completely make a drop out this garbage became
so the sun purified
Okay, so anything like the air comes and the wind over days and days and days with the heat disappeared. So that spot to begin once
so Aaron while for him online, this chapter, he's gonna talk about all the nuggets out and how can you cleanse it? How can you cleanse yourself
and he started with something that is consistent, consider
and sharper consider like majority of the bow on hormone, as something to be nudges. Okay, in pure. So we start with this handy dandy mnemonic or the alarm line that the prophet SAW someone was asked about making vinegar out of wine and he said no. So the longest prohibited
why the profits are solid permitted that according to
the reason he brought me here. He said because he believes it is next.
Because he believes is next. And that's why prohibited from using it in any form any one. Then you mentioned that this article was about email Muslim, a lot and an email to me and an email to me the said that this is heavy.
I mentioned that in the previous class but
until everybody ketchup and mustard they're
here it's a I asked before we're going to go review we've studied this before it's gonna go quick review over the word hazard loosely, is useful.
Okay, it's a problem out.
Why? Because the word person is different than the word
I give example. If I asked you, are you what is your grade? You said to me? A and B.
Or a or b? That's right. You can be a and b students at the same time.
That makes sense when you're here.
makes sense to you. Man. Can you say I'm
so here it became an issue.
How did what he means by that when he said hassles
And for the record, it can be known for that. But it's not to us that there is another great scholar for example, who among
The third century yeah Corbin shaver
Jr. has one great blog, he had a book at colon Muslim, one of the greatest Muslim we have, you know, this Muslim is in 13 volumes that I think just yeah.
He used to say this also he used to use this terms has
he lived during it he
had a was not very
young he the
for theology reasons, but there is no doubt the greatest law when you walk into this man's house, he used to have 40 we have 40 beds in his house 40 beds in his house, you know what,
for the one who made copy and write his Muslim,
copy his Muslim 14 writers, just all their job is to transcribe what he says and these to stay in his house just to write down
the honey the teeny rates, and he was one of the most richest people and
one to one, anyway. Yeah.
A lot use that terms. Like explain what that means. And they have many different ways of explaining maybe 15 different opinions, what has some slight means.
And among the strongest opinion, since you can see a reason is
good for you to know.
The set up man, he said that the text the meaning is authentic. So even though the is not of the heavy the generator is hasn't it's not that good. It was kind of weakness, but that the actual content is authentic, because there's other durations, we'll take that to that level, take the text to that level. Okay, so he's talking about that this study has multiple snap, one, two, snap more than one more than two, some of them are authentic and
that's why he's it's
important this way and that way, that's among the best way it was said about what it didn't mean he means by that.
It outcome is a word
comes from ha means covered, concealed, because it intoxicate you, it basically cover your upper so you don't function properly. That's why we call the woman's
headscarf cannot because it's covered her head
what I would like to mention here and I mentioned this in detail in the previous class
A lot of people mixed between alcohol that chemical element substance and accounting
and there's a difference between the two
is a not a lot of people think because it's alcoholic or alcohol that element alcohol you just see it means come that's not true.
Alcohol is many different types. And there is synthetic alcohol which is completely has nothing to do with karma which is you will find it in the perfumes
or what we call or the chemists later on advanced colon became a boot camps constantly call the methanol alcohol. The mythical alcohol is not is not some methanol is a poison. You drink it you get poison. So it's not a Hummer and it doesn't take the rules of thumb. That's why it's a very strange for me when you see all this debate and all this talk about some Muslim raised isn't allowed for Muslim to use a cologne or perfume that has alcohol. As a disclaimer. This has nothing to do with that be completely nuts like you know Santa Lucia live button most of them have already been shut down.
They said yeah, and he has gone to the east and you go to the west he completely different cases here. All the argument about commas nudges above is not applicable to these perfumes because that type of alcohol, the choosing the perfume is not the same one, not the effect.
To know that you find in common that people drink the spirit drinks, completely different elements.
Now, that's why you find the methanol exist in detergents, and cleaning,
basically supplies and things of that nature. But you don't find it in that.
That is not the same hormone that you find it in that
the one that people consume, for the purpose of, you know, the, what do you call
for the purpose of wild
intoxication, good, good way to put it for the purpose of intoxication, that's completely different. So, from the beginning, I can tell you that they are not in the same lines of them. We don't apply the rules of heart to these perfumes. Somebody told me, Chef, but some people use the Cologne. in certain countries, in some places, they use clothes to get drunk.
You know, I grew up in overseas, for example, I've seen people like that, you know, those people who consume this, it's poisonous, dangerous for their body. But just because they drink it and they get high, it doesn't make what the drink come.
It's like exactly other ages, okay, they will go to the glue and to the pin unit, and they will start smelling it until they get
another idioms, they will go to the benzene, the gasoline, and they will smell too good.
Nobody will say that the typical camo, or the glow became camo, or the Cologne became camo. That's not that's not true. You know, nobody would say that. hashish that drugs, because it's made them hot and intoxicating. It means that it will take the same rules of how it became medicine production, according to the strongest opinion among the other now that shisha is not is not nice to touch, it does not doesn't. If you touch it doesn't make your hand touching, adjust and so on. So, I hope that people can any realizes because alcohol can be existence so can be exists in many different products cleaning products today, as well as perfumes.
My wife and I have allowed the author bring this honey to support his view that how his niches is infused. That is it true that alcohol, alcohol, the beer, the wine, the liquor, is it true that it is niches? Because they said it is not just a tool and images in itself? So that means the drop of alcohol in your film? You cannot pray? Okay, Is this true?
No doubt, that just humbled the impurity of home is the position of the overwhelming number of scores. Gemini, the majority of that amount, believe it is
the hanafis the Sharpies the magic is many of the sharp
Then many famous scholars, Rahim Allah among the
Muslims believe in the Gospel.
What's the evidence? What's the proof that they have those majority?
Because it's very important to agree if it's legit or not from the beginning, because that will affect how we see the
Have to understand why he's saying why the process of upset what he said.
They said because
when unsolvable when a slam will reach some in hammered shaped by the pitch table, that the last hour so
that it is reached from the action or the work of the shape bar. So avoided, according to the law said and the good and not understood from the word rich. Notice,
understood that the word race means next, and that regardless in Jersey, seventh
question, does really this verse
bridge means ledges is the word rich in Arabic language. Next. If you look at the Arabic cruise now, the word bridge means mastaba disgusting, but it doesn't mean
do the Vancouver rich we'll buy your home here
in a minute to shape on a new era Nakamura dow wild Bow Bow Bob, the company would mace it with the command said the law. He said
go back to the word rich is really rich means matches.
I said the word rich in Arabic language doesn't really
doesn't carry the meaning of ninjas. That's why last month alone he said about salt.
When he said about adding bait, that is the Vancouver rich. So he take the rich away from you. Is that means matches. Now, it means he takes away any anything that is not appropriate, not good. Something that is not right to be said about you to make you absolutely pure
canonica LaHood. Restylane leadin allow you to minimoon
allow put the rich upon those who don't believe rich in a lower put than a castle no
punishment and I have to read Superman punch
in rich Swan Johanna
about the farm, that they are rich and they go to the Hellfire that means they are literally legis No, it means their actions is something disgusting. Their Khufu is a disgusting act to be on acceptable
for tenable reach semi net, which then he will publish or
stay from the rich of the idols. Nobody ever as far as they know. Nobody ever said among them of a city or Sahaba in the past or in the present, that the idols were literally
literally making these idols that they used to worship. Nobody ever said that literally in this necklace,
as well as the verses in them and some of the many civil ensemble Islam.
All these things often
are items that they use for gambling and things like pick a straw, nobody ever said that these items are notice.
I can add to that,
I could not find a single one among the setup from how ever interpreted the word race in this verse in particular, as
a fact the Sahaba interpreted the workers in other words, if an acid a saw
Miuccia many of the tambourine and the Sahaba. And the successors and the followers never interpreted this word as niches.
And not because the law says stay away from it, it means it's not just
that's not true, because I've also said stay away from the gambling not because the gambling machines are matches. So if you touch a gambling machine, oh, you know, I need to wash my hand. Nobody said that. Okay.
And also what our panel data said, mean ama is shaped by that are coming from the work of the shaper. I've met gambling from the work of the shape bar. So that means the work of the ship. This is talking about something intangible. So we're not talking about jassa, which is something tangible if you touch it, or you're coming you're the whole entire context of the verse has nothing to do with an agenda.
Believe it or not,
that's the only proof that
the whole plan.
That's the only living proof of
All our proofs are not like secondary
So you can see that the main proof that the majority has is something that challenge by many other scholars.
The others, the second prove that is the used the set of also than the
people who get it again, a lot given the people of Jenna Harmon which is pure. So that means the Hmong of the dunya is the opposite not because when a lot describe the hunger of the afra, it is the opposite of everything they do.
So that's why in the humble Africa, no headache doesn't intoxicate you, the dounia intoxicated you and give you a headache, the afternoon it is pure. So that means the Jimmy is not viewed means.
But again, that logic is very hard, any
kind of secondary evidence, it's not really the way to stop this ruling and an important building like this. Because if we open this door, is that means when a loss of Hannah what I wanna
talk about that
What's up, boom Chava goes to the water goes to the milk goes to that in a minion to the honey is that means the honey of the juniors
and the water of the juniors not all it means that the food is taboo in the in any variable pure in the in the agenda, it means that the fruit of the dunya is not you can say the opposite is that that doesn't make any is not a very good argument. That's why there is another opinion among the house which is I go I choose that outcome is not in itself.
And that's the mental health of man.
I lose any
we don't have ye and showcar law scholar
subarea Pass upon a moment
and shama chocker. Roth very good
about this issue of support to this position as well have been hasn't been in your handout. Anyway the city of Hong Kong is not an among the biggest argue that they have they said this
the default rules in everything and that it is pure and to improve the odds
Okay, there is no correlation between provision of something and making it that is not because everything HELOC means there is not no connection you can make you cannot provide that conclusion there are so many things haha but not because
you're not allowed to eat cats not because this matters.
There's many things you're not allowed to talk free to enter to consume, but doesn't mean it means it's not just so he said. So the default rule is that everything is held up until you bring a proof job and you fail to bring any proof to say that because mentors
activists have originally comes from something completely held out which is the fruits and doesn't it's not coming from the jossa
So that's number one. Number two, they said
in the Bissell a lot he said that when he told the companions that hormone is magic.
What does anybody knows?
Anybody knows what the Sahaba did when the process of total cost? Completely
they spilled the wine in the streets of Medina
if this is niches with the Sahaba spill the light in the streets where people walk
and these ones will touch the union of the steps and will come to the in these houses not profit house like what we have today a
new way is it a lot free to take a urine and just to store the streets now because you make an adjustment to the street or not. But it's the habit of the line is filled the line. So if that was common, we would not spill it like that in the streets of Dallas of Medina. They wouldn't go on down and dumpsters or fall away from the city where they make sure that they will not make an adjustment to the rest of the area that makes sense. So that
They're the approval also deserved. Then the Sahaba used to drink cover before
hamo the perfect number came in stages. That's right. Was it notice before the third stage?
If you say no, and now you see it became known as where's the proof?
You know, he prohibited drinking it was the proof that that entity and you think that this is. So it's like, if you're going to say it is not just that means Allah allowed us to drink something that just before
which is something unacceptable.
So you see that the argue of majestical karma? It's a very good argument.
I also don't believe in majestic.
I'm not trying to convince you with any one of the two opinions, but I want you to be aware of the debates between the scholars for him on low data.
So for whatever reason, shall never happen but reasonable to have somebody that will help you to determine if the Hummer ever touch your hand or anything that means is it necessary to wash it out? Not that the jostle missile or not, and so forth? Especially taking consideration some of us maybe have none of some family or family who are below maybe consumer Come on, conform the floor, so at least be aware of that whole entire thing.
Another issue that I want to mention in relation to our farm,
what is the ruling in regard to uphold the fifth next with something else?
If you mix
alcohol with something else, what will be the rule?
Mr. Human well, masa, if the mixing
in a very, very, very, very, very small percentage, and modern days, we put it in a percentage 0.05.
Okay, that means that this max would never be impacted by the hump.
And if you have this percentage, and you consume it, Max, no matter how much you consume from it, you will never be intoxicated.
Okay, so that's what scientists saw. And it could be a lot of loss or more unibit. That's what the measurement is to meet the
highest Council have felt have taken from the scientists. So they said, this makes this so low. To that extent, it has no impact. So that means that next we don't call a common theme.
Here, a lot of people don't understand what the process of the meant by saying, NASCAR, NASCAR
this heavy if a lot of it was intoxicated, so a little bit, just a little bit, a little bit. It means here what it doesn't mean, if it's in the percentage has no impact. No, it means let's say someone, okay, if he drinks, one glass of wine will not get drunk. So they said, You know what, I'm allowed to drink wine. No, because if you drink two, three wine glasses, you will get, you know, one kind of beer, I'm good, I'm fine. But if we get like, you know, six pounds or something, or 12, he will get drunk.
We said it doesn't matter in this case, a six car or 12 or one spoon. It's hard. Because a lot of it making a drunk or a little bit drunk. And it will be a lot. But now we've talked about the mix that point 5% that does exist in your medicine, for example, alcohol is shallow, if you drink from it from now until next month, you're not going to be intoxicated, you're not going to get drunk,
which does not come up anymore.
So, here we are understanding this because we found that the ethanol alcohol is involved in certain elements today in food and drinks and medicines use but it has no impact of making the persons intoxicated. So if this the percentage is very small percentage and the mentioned it in a local point
05 percent it will be permissive.
The next point
is the winner
the Vietnamese they asked him jasola can I make vinegar out of this compound that we have? You know they still have powerful the old days because wasn't How can you can we use a sort of spell stallion? Can we use it for making vinegar?
vinegar today, you have three types of vinegars.
Natural vinegars were naturally it's processed, and a human being has no panda. At least during the process of time, in the old days, it is known that, you know, it goes to the stage because let's say you have
grapes in this syrup, Tim
in with the yeast and the bacteria growing transfer from just a juice to became
then after a while with certain bacterias and grow the transfer from some of the what? vinegar.
So not all of them agree that if it does, if it happened naturally without human being speeding the process, speeding the process, it is
it is hard.
There is another scenario in modern days.
Okay, which is synthetic vinegar, it's completely chemical has nothing to do with
acid that we put and we make the whole as instantly. And by the way, I have some of my students who work in factories like this, Texas, and they were telling me that
there is no process at all. It's a chemical process has nothing to do with. It doesn't go through that stages. Okay. So this is what became something how it's not as long without discussion.
But what about when the call when he tells you know, this vinegar is made from
or made from foods, you know, and this fruit, the human being were involved.
So that will raise the question is,
in this case, we know that the prophets of Salaam said
the best dipping is vinegar.
basically this hannity reported by nine of the companions, seven men and two women.
As he said, I wrote about him, we'll all agree that the natural type of vinegar that no human being involved with it, it is
asked for the one that there is human involvement and
some scholars said it's not allowed.
Why the process? He said, he said, it's hard because
he said, because of how his niches impure
whatever, because you have to put some fruits, you have to put some stock whether you had a juicer to transfer, then you put it in the right temperatures. So whatever you're going to add to this mix, because it's not just the new things will be so the result also will be in edges. So this is this. This basically an edge is an impure and that's why it's not allowed.
Some said no,
it is not allowed.
Now, because in the visa someone said to that companion, no.
And he asked
us to sit down. So it is no not because of nudges or impurity because
which is I think that's
involved scars, me took that approach.
There is other groups gossip now
is held up regardless you process it or not, you will find some hot like now. If you move it from the ship Sun to the shade, ship to the sun
Only that would be permissible if you have a limited human involvement.
But again, this all details there's really no proof for it. So the third position said it doesn't matter you have involvement into not you make the process of known as a human being. As long as the result is hung, it is held up. While this is because the current it's a new entity.
And new entity means new rulings.
Question the hammer what's the ruling of the hammer? Hello Ha. Ha. Before it was common, what was
The vodka before it became what Kurt was what? Potato
a beer before it was a beer It was a barley, barley
wine It was a grape juice etc. So when it was just juice, it is henna. When this entities transfer and change to come in it got worse and you rooms. And when this change in its entity and its nature and it became a new entity, we have to give it also a new factoid the prophets of Allah have used it
and used it in his house.
And that's what those color set. So what this means when he said no, because this is a Muslim, random I said the prophets are some of them said no to those people. So no one would purchase Hummer or mix camo at home. So he can make vinegar and make money out of it. That's not a lot.
But it has nothing to do with the outcome, the vinegar itself these together. So should we keep the hammer, he said no spell, because in the visa sanlam this is in the beginning of legislating the ruling of what an outcome of harm and you know this addiction. So let me just sort of want to cut the heart attachment to outcome up completely. So let's spell it all.
And not opening the door for people to make come. And when you come on as a winemaker come on to make vinegar, who you didn't know who's making
who's making vinegars, and we get into the hum of businesses a lot. So that's what this hadith is about. And that's very strong. Any argument if this scholar and especially taking consideration, that if you don't believe in the nature of the humble itself, it no matter how Allah was were asked, like, for example, in the management of 50 and others about the medicines that contain alcohol, coffee, medicine and things of that nature. Can you use it? And that the
perfect summary of it? Yes, I'll hamo a sort of the pure common was not allowed to be used in the form of medication, unless it is necessities. When Islamorada the correct opinion, it's a lot to eat.
But these medicines, which is the coughing medicine and all these things, that percentage is very, very small. And it's not called home or medicine. It's not the same as camo. And he did not give it the same learning Apollo, but the encourage the muscle world in some countries and pharmacists to start looking into other elements more pure and more kosher for the
So the bottom line people asking me about vinegar, it's a lot to you, even if it's a wine vinegars or
because actually we did not do any part of the process and most of us actually done chemically in factories and is not like even the way that they talk about it and the books are filled with the human being to it. process more or less done today's chemical process, even if it's a natural comes from great, the correct premium the outcome is a new thing. Because these vinegar wine vinegar nothing. There's no alcohol and it does not come up not why it used to be but now became something new, which is the venerable. Yes, I was going to mention that you can find in the grocery shelves it says red wine vinegar. So initially I wouldn't buy it.
But after any vinegar will come for at one point from some unless it's completely manufacturing completely factory yesterday good
ended I must have been modeling for all the long run the alarm on the day of favor love messengers the law final setup
to announce a lot is messenger prohibited for you eating of the flesh of the domesticated donkeys for it is unclean
can I oh
so lice have a lot to say about
Fernanda in the law of sudo enhance
enhance cocoon and the human human earlier for inheritance with de la
heady anisul the law and agreed upon and that's one of the greatest level of authenticity when the agreed upon by the party were Muslim both reported from and so they allow
the narration in their body and I said we woke up in the morning and the reason behind this study that the Sahaba of the lawn cabinet in Dong Xiao they were so hungry you know this around the table for a while and they run out of food and they became extremely hungry
have no food to eat. Then the found high bar is a city where a lot of like farms and so they found these donkeys so they took them to kill them and they start cooking them to eat them
okay for assaulting them in the human human while they are really in the pots and one ration it was completely cooked and ready to be served
Can you imagine they are hungry majah like so hungry didn't eat anything for a day
and now it's no it's cost ready to be
someone to call someone which is a Buddha and he told them that in a lot of pseudo Yun Han come under to human human that a lot has messenger sallallahu Sallam forbade you to eat this meat the meat of the Mr. Galan donkeys because it is rich. And it's a Muslim Fein read some outrageous
it is rich or impure. Not clean, impure, disgusting. All this can be
in the day of labor.
Okay, hi, Bob. The Conqueror, the Piper took place in the seventh year of his job.
poker Pro. And the single is he not means a donkey.
And there's two types of donkeys in the Arabic language or the Arabic culture, the domesticated one and the wild one.
Okay. The wild ones, like the one that you see today in Africa, which is zebras.
You know, I know, like old people, like, let's say the grandfather, my grandfather, age and great grandfather, they use the set that it used to be in Arabia, these type of, you know, zebras and these type of donkeys like why we call them wild donkeys. And if you read in the history and the poetry It was a common thing that the hunting the eat these wild donkeys. And that's what Jabba the line said, we were the prophets of Salaam, and we hunted a wild donkey and we ate it. The Wild donkey here it means these, like the zebras that we have today. asked for the donkeys that used in farms and in towns. They are friendly to human beings, they live with humans.
These are domesticated donkeys. So if you have that, what we call an English donkey, but lives in the desert by himself. It doesn't mean it's hard to eat it. It's still a duck called domestic domesticated donkeys, and we're worried that in English translation, you will feel that the ruling has to do if he have that don't you live in cities or live within a farm or a barn
or not, there's no it means that type that kind of donkeys, that species, okay? It is not a lot because all the species can be domesticated.
Okay? But you don't do the zebra the zebra is a wild animal. So
basically the domesticated donkeys, which is the last word Allah mentioned in the Quran, while high level view of Allah when hemiola the top kabu ha, he said the horses, mules, donkeys that you're right, that's what the moment men are We are human, why is it
the one that can be domesticated and living in villages and you know, it has honor and it is called insia. Just in case somebody reads in the books you decode in SR and the opposite is washy in ca means it will it's so used to in human beings, okay.
Ask for the one that I said love some deserts or wild or, or live in the jungles. It is hot out to eat because jabil the Alon said, We ate in the tongue of the prophet of salaams horses and
wild donkeys, a cabinet a high lap world human and Russia and in the basis of them forbade us to eat domesticated donkeys reported by Muslim and the only eight horse even though the OB never eat horse before, just because of the hunger they were so hungry. So
that horse is allowed to be eaten if that is neat.
Okay, enough, are different than enough so you can eat the horse because almost what I said
the some of the canopies, the little bit strict about that because they sort of all said, let's talk about our zebra so you can ride upon them and it is a beauty for you. It's not supposed to be for food, in some capacity of thin air is more honorable to be used as a source of food, it should be used as a source of you know, beauty and for riding it for war and things of that nature. But anyway, the head is authentic about eating the horse. He said rich, against rich, as I said earlier, it means not to be noticed but in Muslim he said our niches rich or niches as rich can come in many different meaning like what I said
before in the main read aloud allow UT Banco rich
to purify you unabated from any type of friction any inappropriate or bad or things that it is said about you
what this means and why he brought this heavy. He brought this happy to tell you that I have to tell you that among the adjuster that is the meat of the donkey, the donkey. donkeys are not just impure, and you're not allowed to eat it, you're not allowed to touch it. You're not allowed to,
to cook it or to consume it.
Therefore, the prohibition of eating the donkeys is something without water in and Heidi, more than 12 companions reported that a Hadith of the prohibition of eating domestic donkeys and I don't know anyone this agree among those companions, that there is permissibility in eating donkeys except in advance for the allow. He said something that some
start questioning an ambassador was asked about is it how long to eat donkeys? Even at best said it was prohibited. But I wasn't sure if it was prohibited because
because and hamona I'm an adjuster. Yeah, and it because in addition, I want to save the donkey so people can ride on it can load stuff on it can be used in domestic use, or because it's niches
kind of give a question mark, okay.
And the shaft is the handles. Obviously,
food will also help. The Manik is allowed eating
some of the mannequins not all of the mannequin to be any accurate given how far we can go in this class.
You guys, but the Maliki has three generations three positions one there was a lot of one car one cars. So we have three different positions among the Maliki themselves. They why it is not allowed for you to eat donkeys? Why the process of them for bed the donkeys meat? Is it true because donkeys are niches?
Is it because they are impure?
Is it because of this? Or because killing donkeys will harm people? In a sense, because people use donkeys for transportation for loading stuff on it, they use it to farm so we start eating the donkeys and killing them for food who is going to carry all this stuff? So it cause hardship for people?
Okay, so in the visa some that didn't allow them to do just because it will make the life difficult. That's why Allah forbid if this was the real reason behind it, if that's true that the problem stopped them from killing and eating it because it's needed in transportation and it's needed for loading and carrying stuff. That means in modern days it's a lot to eat
because we don't need for transportation anymore That's right We don't need a lot you can have a truck no
those who said that the use a hadith to say that this is the reason and if valid Abdullah
he said he came to the prophets of Allah to serve them and he said you're sort of law US law
we are in drought no rain, no grass and things so bad. And we're so hungry and I don't find anything to feed my family with in less the man who Hillary except my fat donkeys.
Can I use them to feed my family for me? Then the Prophet told them up in a legacy man hobo link feed your family from these fat donkeys?
So this howdy this and it told those people that the prophets are
only prohibited in Hiva only because in high bar, the donkeys was needed.
But there's not
is this understanding correct?
The answer is no. Why? Because this feed your family from the fat donkeys that your heart is very weak, heavy, absolutely weak. It cannot can predict the Hadith in Bukhari and Muslim and use the very clear evidence that shows that donkeys are how long to be eat or ledges to be consumed. Okay, I want to see among you guys
a smart person and you're smart.
But he wants some of you told me that this
is weak even without even without looking at the snap even without looking at the generators.
I can see how weakness leaders earlier myself, then they criticize this honey just by looking at the tax.
variables. How can he said shenana family there are five donkeys under the drought. There is no grass that has nothing to eat. Nothing to feed anyone. On the other hand, there must be not.
That's why I
said that this handy is not only that the generator filled with weakness. It's also the text of it makes no sense. Okay, that's why it is wrong.
And in the B cell alladia send them
told them not to eat it. If it's true, just because it needed that day to transportation. It's already killed and it's already cooked. And the only way the only reason was about so he said don't eat don't eat anymore. Don't kill anymore. But what did I like to do? Look at all these times.
Were this donkeys are cooked in it, throw it away
and break the
parks, the city of sola brachiopods How about we should only is it okay what
we one question since the profits of sunlamps said wash it that shows you that it is
something not right.
That's right. And that's one of the evidence that needs to say that the meat of the gum trees are legit is not allowed to
eat in and in order for them to spill.
Other aromas said
maybe the reason behind
not allowed to eat the donkeys because donkeys eat everything
they eat even feces you know? No donkeys that's why you know
saw they said that because of this it's like what we call Lj law you know what's the law is the chicken when it doesn't have any food? It stopped eating its own feces of the other chicken pieces. Are you allowed to eat this chicken? No, you have to lock it and to give him good food for three days and after that you can eat that chicken
soup because these donkeys are basically eating all this bad thing in the desert Southern forbade them from eating
and they said because in one of the relations ahead hot in the US car
that's one way or the other reason it was set in one generation and why people want the process of them said you're not allowed to eat it spill all this meat through the meter wide. He said in the before paid us from eating it
because these donkeys the taken from the people of high bar and these donkeys are supposed to be among the word foodies. And the word beings were not distributed yet. So you taking money doesn't belong to you has nothing to do with this being nudges or allocator lock and pod. And some other company said no. He said it's not allowed because it is niches because
this said because it eats then adjust it eats the faeces.
in Omaha they allow an
insane hearty Muslim, they've been almost said the word forbidden to eat it because people needed these donkeys. That's what that opinion again, it's perturbation because the so now you have three some companion said it is because it eats the faeces. Some companion said because it's part of the war Buddhism was not distributed. Some said because people needed for transportation.
And the fourth opinion that it is forbidden because it is nudges. Listen to what
was said in
his commentary on senate at the devil. He said all these three decisions. That's right. All these are guessing, guessing what is that reason? And he said why would we take the guessing of someone and you leave the statement of civil law is horrible. So someone said like with the brother decided on a red in maybe so some of them said don't that it is forbidden because it is rich. It is magic. It is impure. The Prophet sometimes stated that it's not any more someone guessing.
So nothing about him or myself. And that will shows you that the right reason behind it. It is because it is Neches harder for her that leads to happiness. And now we're in Mr. Nelson.
winning the visa someone said regice something disgusting something impure to eat.
Allah said all sorts but after that
is that means the dunk is obnoxious.
I'm sure it must have I see a few guys
old enough to know villages that's right
that means donkeys networks
that mean if you wipe over the donkeys back and it's wet your hand we can let you put your hands on the donkey saliva it's became nudges
those who said the meat is noticed and that's why it's hard on the SIR it's niches if you touch your and that your saliva it's an entity cannot you cannot you have to wash your hands
but I this is an opinion among the chef's opinion among the Hinata the dissent the actual donkey is his sweat, saliva like whatever it comes from his nose it's
obviously everybody agree that the urine and the feasts of the donkeys talk about the other good amount and amount of time
the meat itself they just needed solid cook is
net rich not many scibridge means disgusting that's why you're not allowed to eat it
it's like agenda it's not registered chicken but it's disgusting
because it's eat the pieces so
why what you might say shift but it looks like medicine is the evidence of support the customer How can you say it's not even a padana Latino law said it's not just what he said because donkeys used to be
domesticated and used to be among the companions a lot and in the visa Sunda never reported that she told the companion washer and from it Be careful when you and he said many of the people used to write the donkeys without anything in the back of the donkeys
and there are muddy they always want the donkey without anything it's not like you put down saddle or anything like that you're either on the donkey and the donkey swept and never
told the companions or the prophets as I'm sitting with you when you're right in the top of his donkey or his mule never ever been reported that the process washed himself or is it make sure that you put something on the back of the donkey now and the Muslims been doing this for a generation and nobody consider this as a majestic and that's why you'll find that many other scholars will go to that direction and many of them will say it's not Nexus
but even if they said the meat itself that cooking that it's disgusting that's why it's fun to eat it but the donkey itself does not
what do you think of the donkeys milk
Have you heard now oh my god it's all over the internet
no donkeys no giving you How do you know it's very good for your health blah blah blah you never heard of that.
cockroach they have not
because in a cockroach pieces it's actually evaporate and
and basically air and that you smell if you have an area to cover their their their pieces goes on it goes to the air that's why it's not healthy to live what are the odd because he keeps smelling all this stuff? Are you breathing any of that? But this morning I seen a lot of advertising for it and people say that there's like healthy blah blah blah. And the law said that the milk of anything take the same ruling of the meat of that thing.
So the meat because it comes from the meat the meat of that the color so the milk over the top. So the milk of dogs is hard because how long did he die? The milk goats Hello because hello to eat goat's milk of camels Hello because you are allowed to eat.
So if somebody said hey, let's have a milk. You know somebody want to go to Africa and someone to milk for you.
Linus Thank you.
Okay, because it's hot. So
I love this rule that the milk follow that meat. But that's not agreed upon just for the record. Alfa powerboost zubiri great loss of scars allowed milk of donkeys and other things that's not allowed to be eat. They don't agree with that.
So you will have a debate between the scouts but the karate opinion that the milk follow the meat? Yes.
Yes, you cannot eat the eggs of any animals you're not allowed to eat. Now buy eggs as well.
What about new?
Does new take the same ruling of the donkeys? The answer is yes. You know, the view is the outcome of what
horse and a donkey like the horse is held up according to the donkeys Ha. No handed to him. We take the side of the heart. Okay, so that's why it is not allowed. And it might give example of
the wolf and the hyena.
I don't know what that call it the English but we call it Arabic a semi
some is the outcome of the hyena and the wolf, the meat eater
the hyena there is ministers allowed allowed for food to be eaten. Okay, but the wolf everybody also talk you see the tick the side of the Parisian said it's not a lot so that's why the mule is not allowed to be take the same rule of the donkey
and there is
a Tadahito law said men in the Hema
he said them you is a donkey symbol. Okay. And Ben reported the jabber or the llama and said in the day of high bar I told you this was very hard to swallow because they were so hungry on the back burner. Hi.
Why behind what have you but I had also lice allow me to send them under human behati when
we second we killed horse mew and don't induce asylum forbade us to eat the mule and the donkey and he did not forbid us from eating the horse willemijn hana on a hike Salalah
in the Hadith it came that he said young Han Kuma in allow suta in half in half, that align has messenger for vade you both forbade you from eating
from the domesticated animal
that comes in the verb now should
remind us of an incident where a man stood next to the Prophet for Sunday and he was giving a speech
and this man he said
may use a LAO or a soother who
were men meow see him
whoever bet a lot and obey His Messenger okay and the messenger have
yeah I need rushed means
sucks succeed succeed.
Well, Miyagi math whoever this obey both
have been misguide piling bits of people and worst hobby. You are
Speaker you are.
What a bad speaker you are what a bad speech you give.
Say, when ya see Lao Tzu
said say who ever discovered a lot and messenger. misguide. Don't put any me out a lot in one pronoun together.
Don't say and whoever this obey them.
Don't put me with the law in one pronoun, then refer to say this will be a law and disobey His Messenger.
what the prophets have
taught this man is just was he objected to this man is just mentioned in the Hadith. Yan Hakuna they are both forbidding you
that's became a problem.
And we have another heavy that has
an akuna wha wha so I have put in a min mercy
put them together. This one is messenger both more beloved to him than any other. He put them together one foreigner
and we have the film
and in it
woman you play in our pseudo
woman ya see him out for in a liable in Linux or whatever.
And we were disobey both
harmoniums this is exactly what the process objected to. That became an issue and said how why the process would have sent that to this speaker given Coco. And here in other news, the same thing
became Michigan Michigan
needs to solve to be solved.
Some enemies said this is only allowed if the Prophet Mohammed is the speaker.
So the Prophet only can refer to him on a walk in one pronoun together.
If the Prophet is the one making the speed, yes, but someone else is referring to the messenger and to a lot. No, it has to separate them.
But to be honest, we're claiming that this is only for the prophet Elijah proof. Next thing I can tell you what the hajer the process of them taught us to set
an entity put the profit out of one one pronoun. Yeah.
So that's really not a very good argument. The second one would the vast majority like unknowingly and an ally you have an ally and so many Haha, sir Tara, they said that willingness or someone submits a copy will help me and the worst. This is the worst of speech or this is bad speech. in Ibiza, someone was objecting to the way he put it. Because when you give a speech, you should give details.
When you give a talk the set because you should not cut it short, you're not just refer to them in a pronoun, you're supposed to talk about to praise Allah to mention Allah to make it so distinguish. So you should Allah and His Messenger, it's an honor to mention a lot, not just to refer to align the pronoun and to refer to the Mohammed in the Pro, you should mention them in detail. linguistically, that's the right way to talk. So it was not saying it's hot, but he said, But you say that is not the best way in Arabic language to address people.
Because it is it's the process from when he mentioned this habit, it was not a hopeless speech or sermon, versus this man was giving a sermon. Yes.
I found some said, the man said
I need more assertions, but some element said why the processor was mad at this man. Because he said when they use a law or pseudo Russia woman yasui email that he stopped.
You need to know a little bit Arabic to understand what this she said whoever obey Him on His Messenger
achieve success in those who disobeyed him
that he stopped. Then he said, and those who disobey them misguide.
That stop at misguided is a very bad one.
Because give complete different meanings, right? So that's why the person is the worst speech and that's not how we should talk. Someone that said that's maybe that's what the processor objected to, and almost
knows that. Anyway,
time for slot. So thank you very much and
show off the slot you have any question? I'll be happy to answer it. Otherwise
we'll see show on Next. Next
For those who follow my class, it will be shift command there'll be a class in line that will be done by sakamaki. Same time for me, not next week, the week after shala will continue whatever left and this chapter