Channel: Bilal Philips
Series: Bilal Philips - Best of Tawheed
© No part of this transcript may be copied or referenced or transmitted in any way whatsoever. Transcripts are auto-generated and thus will be be inaccurate. We are working on a system to allow volunteers to edit transcripts in a controlled system.
law is above and beyond its creation, we looked at the evidences, we naturally have difficulty accepting the idea that the creator of this universe in his magnificence would be inside ourselves with our own weaknesses,
and our in consistencies. That doesn't make sense.
Furthermore, we looked at the evidence is from
the Quranic texts, and we looked at evidences from the statements of the Prophet sallallahu wasallam. And having looked at these, we are now rounding out our evidences by looking at the logical evidence, and what the position of the early scholars were towards this from a logical perspective, either God created his creation, inside himself.
Oh, he created it outside of himself. Some people say, Well, no, he didn't create it inside himself or outside himself. Well, what else is there? No, that's just illogical. Either. He created it inside himself, or outside himself. So if he created it inside himself, then it means that Allah has within him, all of the weaknesses, the deficiencies, the filth, the everything of this world,
contained within himself, that is something which goes against our natural belief in who is God, God is pure, God is good. You know, God is not weak, he does not contain weaknesses, he is the mighty, Allah Jesus, He is the mighty, there is no weakness involved here at all. Right? We are the weak, we are the fulcrum, we are the needy. So he doesn't have any of these qualities. Once these things were created inside themselves, then it means he has them. So the only logical conclusion is to consider that he created the world outside himself. That's the only logical conclusion. And if the world were created outside himself, either his below it, and below, in general is subservient to what is above,
or he is above it, and beyond it, and it is below him,
and subservient to him. Again,
logic tells us, he must be above and beyond it, and it is below him. And, of course, worship
everywhere in the world, when people turn to worship call on God, they naturally call on God
upward, somehow God is conceived as being beyond beyond not just up up in all aspects in from all perspectives.
beyond being beyond that, the creation is not above him. So, this is the only logical conclusion that we could come to in this regard. And it is consistent, of course, with the evidence is that we have been looking at
whether we looked at the evidence from the nature of human beings, to not accept the concept that God would be in filth in the filth of their world, or it'd be from the
Which prayer has been prescribed, that we are not allowed to pray,
to start us to objects, to anything that is created in this world that is in and of itself proof that God is not within these things. Because where he within it, if that was the correct concept of where God is, then there should be no objection for us to pray to objects, wherever it may be, whether it's a statue that we create with our own hands, or it's a tree, or it's a stone, or a star, or whatever, the moon, the sun, there should be no problem, even praying to each other. As we said, some heretics of the past, had even proposed those who promoted the idea that everything was a law. And the law is everything. A law is within everything. So if God is within you and me, then I can
pray to you, and you can pray to me. No problem. And they actually propose that, you know, I've been araby as a famous individual, from the 13th 14th century who made this proposal. And there are others before him and others after him who shared the same idea promoted it. Until today, we still have people in different parts of the Muslim world who make this claim also, we also looked at, we said, from the perspective of the Mirage, the ascension, the prophets ascension into the heavens, and what he described what information he gave us.
We judge it, you know, it's not because of course, you can perceive the ascension in one way and I can perceive it in another way. You know, you can say, Well, that was in a dream, you know, I can say, Well, no, it was actually body Lee, the profit went badly, and argue about that, etc. But what the prophet described to us, of going up into the heavens, not going down,
not walking into the Kaaba, he
left this world is Ascension involved living this world. And he described it. And at the end, he reached the seventh heaven, above which was a laws, footstool and throne.
And we all know from the various texts that the lies above the Throne, this is mentioned in so many places in the Quran. So all of that points to Allah being above and beyond his creation. And of course, the Quranic verses and the heady thick proofs,
seal the picture, but we have one more look to reflect on the position with regards to a law and his creation. And we'll do that after the break.
Welcome back from the break salaam aleikum, we concluded that really the evidence is of the Quran and the Sunnah should really be enough to close the case. However, adding all that went before we can also see in the statements of the early scholars, which have been gathered by a number of leading scholars like Mr. Darby, he wrote a book called aloo lilla, Li, la vim, the transcendence of the Most High the magnificent. In it, he gathered numerous statements from over 200 major scholars of the past in support of this idea. We spoke earlier of
Imam admittedly humble, being the scholar of his time who withstood those who tried to portray and to promote the idea of God being everywhere. That was a period in time which a deviant philosophical sect called the Morteza lights had gotten control of the Muslim leadership and force this on the oma on the Muslim world. But Mr.
Ahmed stood his ground. And eventually after being jailed and tortured, and all these other things, eventually, the wave was halted, Abu hanifa himself, he made statements, very strong statements. And when people asked him or expressed that people were unsure of whether a law was above his creation or not, you know, above the Throne, as it stated in Koran or not, and I will honey for saying, one who denies that Allah is above the heavens, is a disbeliever.
Because the Quran and said, He's above the Throne, and the throne we know is above heavens. So to deny that or to have doubt about it is equivalent to disbelief. If a person is doubtful about a laws existence, I'm not sure that there is a God or not. You're a disbeliever. You can't say I'm a believer in our Muslim, but I do have doubts about whether a lie exists or not know that these two don't come together.
If you're a Muslim, meaning you believe in God, you believe in a lot. That belief means believe without doubts. But the basic issue allows existence, if you have doubt about that, you don't believe in God. It's as simple as that. You just don't believe in God, but you have a doubt that maybe does exist. That's what it is. You know, you don't believe in God, but you have a doubt that he might exist. That's what it is not that you believe in God, but you have a doubt that he doesn't exist. No, it's not that one. You don't believe in God. That's the reality. So this is why I want if I said, You're doubting about whether God's above the Throne or not, means you don't believe
you don't believe
in God. So he, as I mentioned, was only one of many scholars and his main student, Abu Yusuf, who tackled one of the leading scholars of the mortality lights of his time. bisher al Murray, see, he debated with him. Bashir was promoting the idea of allies everywhere and the other concepts that they held, Abu Youssef
told him to repent because he had denied that the law was above the Throne. Michel de Medici, denied it. Okay, so what did you do with the vs where law says, a rock man, I'll allow the Most Merciful, a rough man is Allah, Allah rush stoah is above the Throne. What do you do with that? He would say, well, either it gives some explanation that
doesn't mean throne, it means something else. Or it's metaphorical. It's a metaphorical expression. It's not to be taken literally. And that's what those scholars of that background did with all the other verses that we mentioned before, which clearly indicates the velocity of his creation. They said, these are all metaphorical. And then they went through most of our last names and attributes and said, Oh, this one's metaphorical. That one's metaphorical to the whole crime became metaphorical. metaphorical meaning that you can't take it literally. So then, what do you do with the Quran? The Quran says, we're going to prayer, you know, wash your hands and your face. Okay,
this is all metaphorical. We wash our hands metaphorically, we wash our faces metaphorically, you know, where do you draw the line? Because you did have actually some sex which came out and said, for example, one of the extreme sect which came out and said that the five times daily prayers are metaphorical. That if the fudger really is representative of Muhammad,
Lahore is Ali assar is Fatima malherbe is Hasson and Asia is present. So if one just says these words, Muhammad Ali Fatima, Hassan Hussain, he has done his five times daily prayers. Okay, this is insanity, it will actually reach that stage. Yes, there are people who made these such claims. So, you know, of course, you lose track of everything. Once you get into that state then nothing is real anymore. It's just whatever the person who is
is telling you this story. If you accept it, then it's whatever he tells you,
you become a slave to his thoughts. And of course, there are no end of people out there who are making such claims. So there is no reality to anything coming back to the real world.
In the real world, the Quran was real.
The Quran was revealed in Arabic. And the Arabic language was such that people understood things literally, unless the circumstances demanded that it be understood, metaphorically. And that's how we speak basically, in all languages. When we communicate, we don't communicate metaphorically, in our general communication, we may use metaphors in our communication. But that's not the general communication that we do. Our general communication is literal.
So when a boss tells his
assistant to do something,
the Assistant doesn't stop to think, does he mean this metaphorically? Or does he really mean for me to do it?
If he's going to be thinking like that, and no system is going to operate? When he said, do it, he meant do it. And we take this literally, although I might say to you drink lots of water. This means
physically, you should drink lots of water. It's good. I'm a doctor, I'm telling you, you need to be hydrated, you're in a hot climate, drink lots of water? Or
should you take that now as an order, which you now start to drink? And you keep drinking until you can? yourself? No, no, lots here? How do we take lots lots is defined. There's has to be some clarification a definition, you as a patient will ask the doctor Well, you know, okay, what is lots, five glasses a day, 10 glasses a day, two gallons a day, what what slot, you get those details, but you're not thinking in this general and prescribed way. Our general communication is literal. For example, we have phrases like the walls have ears.
We don't literally mean this. The circumstance tells us that we don't take this literally what we're talking about is that people might be listening. Or we might say, time flies, you know, again, we don't mean literally, time flies. So if somebody said for example, you know, I'll be flying out tomorrow. We don't stop to think does he mean literally is flying out tomorrow or not? No, we assume when he says he's flying out tomorrow that he really is flying, flying out of the city flying out of the country. We take it that way. And that's how we normally communicate.
So when we look at verses, all the body of material which point to a lie being above and beyond this creation, that is the vast majority of material, then we have to say that's what it literally means. Now, there are some verses for those who try to claim that it is not literal. They take the verse, for example.
This verse is in Surah, cough 30th chapter verse 16 welaka de la Canal in Santa Monica lemuel moto Swiss will be enough so we're not no Accra, boo la mina have little worried. Indeed, I created man, and know what is sold whispers for I am closer to him than his juggler vain. Now, we know the juggler vein is inside of our necks, the human head and closer would mean somehow inside is closer than that. But the context in which it said a law says I created humankind and know what their soul whispers know what's going on inside the hearts. So he's talking about his knowledge that his knowledge is closer. We don't take this one literally because we have such a huge body of material
indicating otherwise. Or, for example, another verse, in which Allah says Alam Tara and Allahu Allah Allah ma ma ma Hua tomorrow.
Fill out. My akuna Minh najwa, Salah fatin illa Hurrah boom, voila hum certain Illa was this room will add Nam indolic? Wa Xsara Illa. Who am I home? in America? No, don't you know that the law knows what is in the heavens and what is on Earth. There is not a secret consultation between three, but he is their fourth, nor between five. But he is their sixth, nor fewer nor more. But he is in their midst wheresoever they may be. So we don't take this to mean that when two people are together allies, a third person with them know, the context is that a law knows what is in the heavens on the earth. He's talking about his knowledge, again, is knowledge encompasses everything. So this is the
way we take those verses where people might want to use them in a literal sense, where that literal sense contradicts the literal meaning of the majority of the Quran. So we don't want to say okay, in this case, it is metaphorical. In the other cases, it is literal, they say well, no, those other cases are metaphorical. And this is the literal one. Well, reality is that the vast majority of cases in the Quran indicate that is above creation. So either the vast majority should be taken as the literal and the minority as the metaphorical. The other way around doesn't make sense, because as we said, our normal conversation most of what we speak 90% of what we talk about is literal. And
the Quran was revealed to us in our language, and literal language for the most part, with some metaphorical references. With that. Their viewers would like to thank you for being with us in this segment of our episode from the best of our heat, and we hope that you will continue to be with us in the coming episodes as we continue to look at different areas in which Muslims today as a result of some actions of the past some beliefs, some practices, have strayed away from the main belief in the unique unity of a law and they have compromised and they have violated
some of the major principles of telehealth. We'll see you in our coming episodes. today. Kumara to LA he co barakato
Islamic online university prevents you with the golden opportunity to study the various branches of Islamic studies from the comfort of your home.
Now, you get to study at your own time schedule and at a pace that suits you best
I owe you is the brainchild of Dr. Bilal Philips,
who envisioned an institution that would offer undergraduate and postgraduate courses online and completely tuition free. Choose from the widest range of programs that you can ever imagine. bachelor's in Islamic Studies. Intensive Arabic program, global Quran memorization program, bridge to masters in Islamic Studies, bachelors certificate and Diploma in psychology, education, Islamic Finance, Business Administration and information technology and the crown masters in Islamic Studies.
Our syllabus is based on the bachelors degree program of Medina University, Oman Islamic University, Al Azhar University and other reputable Islamic institutions. Your journey to acquire Islamic knowledge is just a click away. Islamic online university is
changing the nation through education.
Register now and get started. Visit www.io u.edu gm for more details.