Refuting ‘Loud Dhikr’ in Group
Channel: Karim Abuzaid
File Size: 9.40MB
Alhamdulillah wa Salatu was Salam ala rasulillah eyeshadow ilaha illallah wa The Who? lashari Kala
was shadow and Mohammed and Aveda who were a solo
mighty respected brothers and sisters in Islam. We welcome you once again to Colorado Muslims family Council.
We posted a video regarding ivig
after the Salah.
We received a question by brother Headey,
our local brother from Boulder.
Regarding the view of Abu hanifa on the matter or the school of thought of Abu hanifa
Rahim Allah on the matters.
First of all, the question was not about Vic in congregation or not.
The question was about
raising the voice with the car after the Salah.
That is the question.
And we mentioned that raising the voice.
There is a ground for it in the Sharia.
And this is the view of ma'am.
Madam no humble his school of thought. These don't have the type of light now that sort of your loved one woman
but is not to be done in a congregational manage.
But of course,
a lot of the jurists the scholars
have mentioned that this was abrogated. If you go back to the video, I furnish the evidence that only the man may
do that to teach the people or to remind them of the car after the Saba
talk to be done.
You know in a loud way, a lot of them mentioned that it was abrogated with the verse in Allah and Milan and Hadith Abu Salah Sharia law one
regarding that you don't call upon a deaf
or an absent God. He's nearer to you than the reign of your rights your camel, the hardest football fan.
So that was the question brother heavy is the debate whether
make this car loudly, individually or silently. And we furnished the fact that if you are to stick to the school of thought of some of your hanifa Imam, Ahmed Mohamed, el Hannah Villa, then you do this individually. And also you make sure that you're not
loud in a way that you are
causing people around you to lose their for sure.
Or to lose their focus in the
worship as well whether it is the Salah, or whether it is the remembrance of Allah subhanho wa Taala. But the majority said you should do this silently and individually.
Now your question is about
vicryl Gemini making Vic in groups
telling me that naff have their opinion regarding this matter. And you sent me
some posting of
an Imam or a school or of the school of thought of Abu hanifa with a recent or I don't know exactly what it is. Now addressing your question.
There is no such a thing of difference of opinion between Abu hanifa O'Malley questions
regarding the matter
Have Vicar in congregation
there is no such a thing I mean there is out there but it's a made up.
Vic in congregation is a bita according to everyone,
when we speak of difference of opinion we we base this on evidence
when they define the Buddha they said the VEDA is a cartoon feed the name of Tara
is an act that is introduced into the religion invented has no model before has no precedence.
You tell me
one single evidence that the companions gathered in a manner similar to what we see these days in order to make Deke
all the Hadith about Victorian machine in a congregation
is to be interpreted modality leylandii, someone is sitting and teaching talking about Allah subhana wa tada and lecturing and and and so forth but there is no evidence we have actually an evidence that speaks against that and after Abdullah have nematode the mature fish only anamod dairy me and others the the story of Abdullah have never sold the masala Sharia or the alarm because of Al Hassan the story of the pebbles so it speaks against it.
And Abdullayev numbers oh this is a hobby and I believe number so it is the foundation of
the teachings of Loch Ness in general it was an Kufa
there is no evidence for that. Yes, there is an evidence for VIXX EC when when when when they
categorized the DA they said bid da whether it is happy pa
or LR fi what is happy POS Leah has no origin has no is an alien
has no basis.
the second type is the type with the subject of victories mentioned that bit about fear is something that is added. Yes, there is a mention of remembrance of Allah subhana wa Taala they use the famous verse alladhina kurunegala pm on odawara Juno v him those who mentioned Allah His name while they are standing and sitting down and that's how they legalize dancing while they are saying Allah hi Allah, Allah, Allah, Allah, Allah, Allah and all of that and, and no one from Allah Tafseer with a look at here explain the verse in that manner and they said while they are standing while they are standing, while they are walking and standing while they're sitting down while they're sitting down
the size of Panama and from de la, whether La la la Allahu Akbar hola hola well, while they are laying down on their sides, or in the Salah,
like if because in the Salah if you cannot pray standing you you you pray sitting down or if you can even pray sitting down you pray on your side had if
Milan novel side, solid high EMF Atlanta South Africa I definitely
pray standing if you can. So you remember a law you make mention of a loss of Hannah Vicar of a law while you're standing in the Salah. Now if you're unable then while you're
because that's the next step down all while you are in your sight. But nobody mentioned is the dancing up and down is nobody explained that verse in that manner. You know we we explain the Quran. The Quran explains the Quran and the Sunnah explains the Quran. The Sahaba explains the Quran, the the predecessors, the best of the best of the generations, the three braised generations of the oma explain the Quran. But we don't rely on on base lists,
views of people in order to establish
an act of worship for once it comes to this. It's a bit of a fee meaning what the origin is there. There is
a foundation, a premise for it, but how it is done.
Yo yo holla Deena Mr. Guru la has the Quran Kathy Ra. You see, I'm not debating whether we make dhikr of Allah subhana wa Taala or not, but we're debating the manner of doing it, how it is done. That's where the beta is
just for you to understand
the second type of video because this is really the majority of innovations in Islam are of that type that something that has an origin in the religion, but how it is done of the live now Omar Robbie, a loved one who might one day he was sitting down and a man was sitting down beside him.
For the live demand, sneezed, he sneezed and when you sneeze, you're supposed to say Alhamdulillah or in Hamdulillah, yada Callaghan. Those are two established ways of of breathing and boxing and hamdulillah after you know, you sneeze, but the man said something very interesting. He said Alhamdulillah wa Salatu was Salam ala rasulillah. He said that, he said that hamdulillah wa Salatu was Salam ala rasulillah. This is what we call about a year. I've lived at home I looked at him and he said, Well, what a cool was Salatu was Salam ala rasulillah. And I can say, WA Salatu was Salam ala rasulillah to send the Salah, and Salam upon the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam,
but not in that particular situation. Not in that manner. This is a bit odd it now if you if you argue and debate with somebody, he will say, oh, you're stopping me from saying salat wa salam O Allah Rasool Allah when Allah subhanaw taala said in the Quran in Oklahoma Iquitos for Luna and NaVi and Edina Minnesota It was a Muslim. Allah has commanded us to make salah and asleep upon that, yeah, not in that occasion. Not at that time.
Brother, howdy May Allah Subhana, Allah bless you for your question and your feedback. But when we discuss views of ima of meva, of school of thought, on established acts on established evidence, but we don't go after what this person said and what that person said.
When there is no base on the Quran and the Sunnah for it. You see, we're discussing the subject of Africa after the Salah, should it be done in a loud manner? Or should it be done silently? Both have evidence for that. And we analyze the evidence and we said if you are to stick with those, it should not be done in a congregational manner and it should not be distractive to those who are praying. I hope the method is clear brother he does a lot here so panic alarm I'll be handing a shadow Allah Allah halen stuff for quite a while. hamdulillah horrible Island