Channel: Jamal Zarabozo
© No part of this transcript may be copied or referenced or transmitted in any way whatsoever. Transcripts are auto-generated and thus will be be inaccurate. We are working on a system to allow volunteers to edit transcripts in a controlled system.
Sorry, the manuscript from the ninth century up to the agent
with this nod back to upgrader
exists, as we're talking about
and the burden using
how it gets there
i think you know, during soldiers returning
By the way,
but what's his most famous book of hate?
And as we will talk about later, how is the Muslim arranged
the range according to the hobby, who originally narrated
So, what we can do in the Muslim, this is one of the larger later works, we can go to the section of operators headed
permit the must not arrange according to the Sahabi who narrated the heading. So, in other words, all the heavies that will be under
will not be under the care to this kind of thing all the convenience
these all of this 123
and from there and through different students we have also seen
So, this book exists this book exists this book exists
and they did not realize until recently but this book also exists
and we can study them to see how the earlier works were integrated into
ad 137 heavy also tells us by the way
something about earlier collection has 137
by the way how do you how do we count them we count them by what
we killed them by
so for example the Profit System system thing and once the hobby narrated the best did on another hobby narrated anybody's ever gets down here we call that too heavy. The same statement the same incident would cause too heavy
This is my son's cause they memorize 500,000
we're really talking about change. But with respect to this paper when we say 137 How did we meet actually understand some different statements and reports from the provinces and because the chain was one command from operator from the
some of the scholars
claimed that the actual recording of Star Trek 400
why I actually have
these like mama Papa, obviously
there's an easy way to spice it
while I prefer my way of repeating the
homeless you can see the
of the different statements
another broken chair.
Discuss the budget committee meeting.
29 of them
on both sides, audience
29 of these 137 MBAs are both
with the exact same wording the exact same thing.
22 of them
are recorded, and just the same audio
was exactly the same wording.
And 48 of them
are Muslim but not the same quality.
That means 99 137 Have you ever
found their way into a party?
What's even more interesting in the Muslim world
through this chain
through the cipher chain
for this chain,
and 135 of them
are exactly 371 of them does not
originate, okay, let me just make a clusion about this
is assuming the best hours.
The conclusion from this is that we see what happened to those early works. I mean, they were basically incorporated into later works. Until last century or the century before the modern day Western scholars, they only had these works, and did not realize that this work even existed.
I mean, they read about it in the in the site, but it was referred to but they didn't know it was still in existence until it was done, I think in some library in Turkey and then it was taken to the museum in Berlin. But after was found it proves the fact that they are here works that were not lost. But they were simply incorporated into the later works like some nothing.
Okay, in the most amount of
when this chain is 136 135 of them are exactly the same.
So in other words, there's two pennies here, which are not there.
And there's also one heavy and must know that myth, which is not
from those energies.
me it was not their intention, and almost more of the audience to include all those edits wasn't there.
Yeah, because both of these books are called the animals.
As you'll see in this section, we all traveled a lot.
But here we're talking about
spent much of his time in Medina and also in
But he also spent during the time of during the time, he was the governor of what's known
as a mom I don't remember where he's from, but this one is from
Danny they used to travel a lot this was he was common and it's time to travel
and take heavy from different schools and as you travel
new way when it comes
to the number one.
Many have read as many other students.
And even he had many other books besides what the
show how the earlier works are simply absorbed into the manual. So what that what I'm saying is that you cannot argue that since we don't know where they are works or that they didn't exist.
I don't think a small number because for one
for one student to take it from one hobby, as your as your show here, as we'll talk about here in a second, it could be much easier for the later scholars to get 1000s. But for one student for one salary, this is a good
deal on some topics. Because we
want to we don't want to cover the material in just a superficial way. Otherwise, I think there's no purpose.
So we'll go and challenge to some
some decent, with respect to the recording of headin
beyond the beginning years.
Earlier collections of headsets were basically just meant for health and personal memorization. They were not organized the collections of headings.
But basically people used to record headings, so they themselves would know
that in the future, they could return to those headings and read them and help them. Remember,
after that, they begin to be more
systematic, or collections of headings. For example, when certain did our certain innovations appeared among the Muslims,
the Muslim scholars collected on both topics in particular. So after the personal elections are headed, we begin to get into collections of headings on certain topics that were important.
So the first collections of regular collections. First we have personal collections.
Basically, these were to help the person memorize the headings that he learned.
And then we had glitches
on specific topics
that were important at that time,
for example, and if there's some bizarre disappeared, someone would collect the idea of showing that this action is against this and that he would present what was the
actual heaviness or actual symptom of the problem.
After that, we got a collection
our collections on general topics,
collections of general topics and in general, the early collections included
as well as statements of this hover and the main
one of the earliest of those that we do have existence is a
collection of heavy
bass based on separate topics that include headings and segments of The Hobbit domain.
have many North Africans so the answer should be
And he isn't with us within 50 years.
Within 50 years, anyone
died in 179. He was born around the year nine.
And his collection still exists today obviously, is basically a collection of topics. But it's not just edits. It also includes statements of the Sahaba and
then after that, we have collections
but the arrangement isn't, isn't very good. And it just been collected from different sources and put it in one
And then we have collections
arranged according to the Sahaba.
to the companion,
ordinary headed and a classic example of that
we discussed what we discussed one last time
a dyed in what you have now the Saudis
COVID before to run the fort.
Basically the difference between this what's happening now is we're getting collections now just a penny
and finally, we get the what are called the standard collections are the well known collections today.
Basically, they are just collections of headings, some only contain authentic edits,
organized based on some
organized based on
what the fisken
pronounces name and
a device, a device this history into three categories, basically,
the first category equals is the period of
and then finally,
I think less than we just said when and
what's the difference between them Why is he calling the spirits that awaited this one
Basically, just putting them together
and making them more like like a book and this table
this table basically summarizes what we went through
of the types of headaches and help, how there was a progression basically in the types of collections that appear.
This topic of recording is important because, as I think I mentioned at the beginning
with respect to many of the specific pain This is one of the one of the topics in which they tried to attack the sense of heavy heavy recording for a long period of time.
So, let us just summarize basically, what are the conclusions we can make about the recording of heavy
This is where now the students are getting involved
like what are the conclusions we can make?
The conclusion we can
no recording of it
even before that, so if you one of the claims of the orientalist.
First point is, we have to point out that
the Arabs has the ability to record.
And as we said, just because they had the ability doesn't mean that they did.
And we also said that to preserve something recording, it isn't necessary. While recording something isn't sufficient.
Here's my economics background.
So number one, we had
had the ability to record.
Second conclusion, as I
stated, if we want to make we should make it more general, though,
that the provinces send them
even number one, he did not make a general prohibition, of recording it, or it was prohibited at the beginning of Islam, but later the profit permitted. So the second conclusion, the province
headed to be recorded.
From the time of the provinces, the provinces to the more being being recorded.
What's another conclusion?
What did we what's one of the things we talked about at the end,
we had all the numbers
going down, we had some
more simple importantly, what that was a sign of or what we're talking about is the the companion
and the followers
had their own many of them had their own collection of headings
And this is the simple automated his PhD dissertation he lists
something like 400 years from the first two or three years per student centers and
has their own collections of recording
what did we say about what happened to those
what happened to those
Okay, they disappeared but what happened to their head you
we're not lost, although the
although the book itself may have been lost.
But they were absorbed,
And the classic example of that, which has just been discovered missing.
Episode pointed out after meat
was pronouncing it with a hat that was wrong.
the final conclusion then that we can make is a theory that was held by many Muslims as well as non Muslim writers about Islam that were not recorded in the earlier
series as the headings were not recorded in the early years.
This theory was helped by both Muslim and non Muslim
we're not recorded in the early years.
Any questions about what we've covered above the recording of headings before we move on?
Think the conflict is resolved?
If you mean by the conflict that we don't know exactly the reason that the prophets are hesitant the recording at the beginning, that's okay. But it's not important for us to know that we, what we know is the fact that so many of us in this recording,
especially at the end of the day, and from what
me from permitted this important thing, why did he first prohibited
Any other questions coming to court in
the early years?
And now we move on to the study of this net?
What is this net
chain of authorities back to the provinces?
What's the by the way? What's the root of this word? What does it mean?
I wouldn't say the word doesn't
you basically, it has to two minutes.
to read upon something.
Don't give it some poetry to
evidence of what I'm saying.
to restaurants something.
another meaning means to
Meaning of a sense.
Now, what's the what's the what's the relationship between these two meanings of the word? And the way we use the content? And what how did they come up with this term?
As a chain?
And it is taking the statement and sending it more or raising it back to the public. Okay, that's the chain. They've been erased and then back to the
the risk, I mean, in conjunction with meaning.
So that relationship between them and what about the enemy?
Everyone relies on the rest of
The relationship to the other part has no meaning is that the authenticity of the heady to a large part rests upon the chain of thoughts.
Very clever. That was an honorable sound to throw in the
meaning of that
get Why is this not important?
Why do we consider important so much we have to
sense of motivation
it says this negative parts of the religion
not as part of the religion, if it were not for this net, anyone could say whatever he wishes.
In other words, if it wasn't for this man, anyone could just say
without giving in Europe, even this kind of thing is still existing today. Someone says something you asked me What's your? What do you think?
So delays he continued in his statement.
He says, We're not for this note, anyone would say whatever he wishes to see. And then if you ask the person where he got that he would become set
up as No, it's not if he had no authority for what you're saying. Then he would have to become set
up an authority who died in 161.
He said this man is the sword is a believer without his sword was with him with what's when he killed?
And what do you mean by that? by the use of this net, the Muslim scholars were able to kill
fabricated ideas and innovations and forgeries, and so forth.
So this plays a very important part. And as many scores early scores, they said that this
is your religion.
This is our religion. So they said, this is your religion. So be careful from whom you take your religion from,
you should make sure that you only take your religion from people who have knowledge and whom
you can trust.
So therefore, it is the essential aspects of hedis.
Now with respect to the preservation of Hadees, though, there's another important question we have to ask both.
Similar to the question we asked about the recording,
which was one of the first questions we asked about the recording.
Or the third question we asked about.
Well, when when did we asked when did the recording of headaches start? It's very important also to ask when did the use of this Nestor suppose it started 200 years after the problem.
It means that love couldn't be
alive couldn't be there. Well, it means it's useless. It means that it really wasn't really something used to preserve the headaches of
so many of the orientalist
especially following one German
the famous chef
from this century,
were projected backwards.
Do you mean by
that all of this net
or projected backwards
pretty much is a wonderful thing. Check along with one of the people that worked the most to refute
his book refuting the use of shock shock.
Less than someone else and they put
my last name they put out there
What did he mean by this?
The one that you have slides?
Yeah, kind of what he claims is this is not was not used for the first 200 years.
So what for example, what he would do
is he would take the heavy,
heavy and then he would create this nut section from it.
And he has a statement the meaning of it that are remember exactly what you said. The great thing
you said the better than not? The stronger the proof that the heavy does fabricate
better there's not the stronger the proof.
Most of the orientalist they follow him.
Many of them what they do is they say they tried to show that what he wasn't quite correct.
But then when it comes to the conclusion, they accepted theory almost.
So people will study anyways in the schools in the United States they get this theory and theories of students
discuss when, when exactly this net began, you won't have any ideas for the use of this net begin.
And the other
profit from the profit.
Yeah, but when did they start?
Talking about the happy hour? Oh, I mean, instead of up Have you
been in there with language with the first
time perfect, awesome.
Did you hear
basically the three things, but when the heavy
or when the snag begins to be
after the business
what's your process?
The Austin from
Well, basically the evidence for this is the statement that given city
when did even
as you get into VPS start now knowing when people die and when they live
under the magnetic disk.
He didn't want to end the statement from him is even sitting said they did not use to ask about this net.
But when the fit now occurs, the people would say state your authority in other words picture
and they will look for the people of the simnet acceptor. And they will look for the people who have innovations and rejected. So he he says that they did not used to ask about this.
Now shocked again.
Nice. Chuck doesn't accept this. It doesn't like this statement. As an argument again, we talked about the Fed now what's the
if you just turn in the city statement? What would you assume the fitness
as we said Yang is the word fitna can be used for many, but in general
in semuc history. He just used the word fitna without switching in 30 years without any
any other words Yeah, it's like using the word assume that we say so. Now what do we mean?
They said fitness during that time with the baby.
Okay, in general, they're talking about either the death of man or the battle between
found in the book of history, I think it was a fabulous book
and the top of his book history it refers to a leading disease
and it refers to the fitness during the demo what he
found in the history book one statement saying that during this time, there was a bit
so he concludes that what even serene is referring to this fitness
so he says this paper from Evan serene is referring to the fitness what do you do
with this logical argument doesn't stop.
When did when he died? By the way? When was this?
No. What do you need
was in the year one point?
Yeah. So he continues so he said, Well, that was good.
was dead. This must be fabricated.
He is logic.
Danny isn't sitting we know the statement from him and sturdiness isn't many books, there's no question.
But he's saying no, no wasn't 126 and said he died in one thing. So therefore the statement
is one of the
inside domain family there was a conflict, and he tried to overthrow the government. I
think his uncle was the ruler. He wasn't.
He wasn't Yeah, he wasn't the
not talking about
someone who makes
so much for the argument that
the first opinion does not begin during the time of fitness or after the
it could be we'll discuss that more detail.
Okay, we'll get to that opinion a
during the time of
One person reports.
The average anyway is one of the major domain events many Sahaba
he died in early after 124. there
was evidence for this opinion.
was the first one to use this.
And the third opinion
comes from amercia.
and when did he live?
In one of the domains he lived from 17 to one.
Yeah, this is based on the statement that we get here.
And he said this, I'm going to shut up he was the first one to
investigate this Ned.
One of the students have
read a heavy for him
read ahead of Shelby, and our told him whom they really just you. And he has an American mamoon. So yes, yes, yes.
Now with respect to the first question, is actually kind of obvious. The answer to the first question. If for example,
the first Habiba says the power.
What does it What is it? If you heard it directly from the positive? What does it
have the limit goes to zero.
He heard directly from the processor. So he's mentioning his source department. So he's mentioning this net.
So one of the Sahaba mentioned, the heavies, they heard from promises.
They actually mentioned this.
But in addition to that, of a book in particular, and also I thought they used to insist on checking the narrations as
they used to as many times did you hear this directly from the
So, what we find is this man in general was first being used during the time of
this habit, but
it was not rigorous
was not a rigorous use
from the beginning.
Either way, the time was the
official ending of the sandwich.
Now, when was the last
in, there was a hell of a living.
But, of course, in general many of our most of them died, let's say like
70, between 70 to 90 miles.
Most of them had died.
But they were still alive until
we get to him on the chapter smothered.
Now, what I mean by this wasn't rigorous from the beginning some of the younger Sahaba like an assembly medic. And even at birth, they used to narrate at least some promises to them that they did not hear themselves.
They heard it from other Sahaba.
So, in other words, they will not mention these.
But pneumatic said,
it says that not everything we narrate you, we heard directly from the power system, but we are narrating from people from other companions, and we did not used to live in our in our heads.
So some of the youngest, however, wouldn't narrate any but this time without mentioning this
fact instead about even our best if he only narrated forehead it directly from
all of his other headings.
So the first one the first point is that, in general, it was began during the time of the hubbub because anyone wants to have a drink me from the, from the buffet.
And he's mentioned
when we're the narrator is forced to mention that.
When did this occur?
I just actually mentioned
during the time of all,
this is the time that they were,
in general, people were forced to mention who they got to hang out to this includes shopping that we mentioned
it also wasn't
necessarily all the time, but if this started that thing,
but what about this, then when the narrator himself insists to mention this was this by the way started during the time of purple book Under Armour, and increased dramatically, dramatically after the business
started doing this?
and increased dramatically after that?
After the fitness some scores of hate they used to they used to blame
things to blame people for accepting me without
the last one. By the way, the fitness between the audio quality or the death of Walkmans What do you
have manners around 40?
So we're still talking very early. This is how many years after the death of the promises.
So we're talking just 30 years after the
when Ben did the narrator's themselves and system mentioning that
well, it's after the fitness journey, have you started narrating it every time you never have you after the video, they're gonna start asking you know, where did you get?
What is your net?
So after being asked what is your net worth? Then they say
To assist them
Okay, so basically a called on the
mat itself and the use of this method from the early years,
not like oriented was trying to show is from much later.
By the way, you should
keep in mind that there's many,
the scores of headings, they used to differentiate between different times different types of
For example, during the football, there were a score of eight was giving a hook book that would be different than his.
So he may have mentioned this not during the book, but while during the hate session, he wouldn't mention this. But sometimes they will mention this note, while other times
they will not mention this that, for example, in the case of Qatada
this story shows that sometimes they would, they would not mention this,
although they know that,
for example, another one to use.
And in order to save time, give me headaches with the same sentence as you would not give this.
So, sometimes we have new students, okay, every time we get the headache, and say, what's the what's the headache? So it has to go through all this. And the old students used to get upset. are you wasting our time by always asking him, we know that. So he knows it's not even though he doesn't mention it.
So just because you might find someone who died, for example, 118. And you find some reports that he did not mention this note. That doesn't mean he doesn't know this, or he didn't mention it on other occasions.
And the last people to insist on this one number see, that people do insist on is not with the people of a show
that he wants to them.
What do we say every day
as I visit them, and he said, what's wrong with you people that you give the headache without the
the head of the matter.
And you can give the headache without this not
so insistent on them to use this mat. And they were after that they begin to
test the meaning of a medic statement. That was the first system using the Saudis talking about the first one in the show, to insist on
By the way, there's one thing that
let me just mention this point, I will not I will not go into detail on this point. But the one thing we should notice is that this is something that is the scientific use of this method and something that is unique to the Muslim.
This is something that is actually perhaps the proof of the finality of the public.
Can you all the prophets before them before the problem,
their teachings were not preserved in this manner.
Even has them in this book.
In this book, he just described the different types of narrations from the different prophets. And he breaks it into six different sets.
And he says the only the only ones that had a complete mess for all the generations back to the boat that send them back to their province was this.
So there's something unique to this. And as far as the fact that the purpose of the last prophet and his teachings are to remain sensitive gentlemen, and there's no profit to come after him to correct any mistakes. So therefore all the data, preserve the teaching
And one of the ways
the copy of that page in my book. So, continue
with my book
questions will end at this point
recently traveled in search of
another one of the new unique
characteristics of the alma
mater, which we mentioned earlier lesson also travels in fiction pay for something or travels in search of knowledge or something we find
that we do not find the earlier
give some examples for families for pennies on
for one month in order to hear a single ad from
and Ronnie records the same it says this used to hear this ad from some of the marriages from someone in Egypt, but he went directly to the person in Egypt to
travel to Egypt to us
about what happens
once we get this woman Medina to go to Damascus
to confirm also what he says he heard from the Sahaba
you want to see are the ones when
the time the time of the rain for the similar situation?
What needs to go through without the rain especially, for example, many of the people
they used to hear any
marriage from people on the authority of the husband.
So they were not satisfied with this long chain.
Between them there's someone between them so they used to travel to Medina to get the headache directly from the Bahamas and
one of the survey McColl he went to Egypt and Egypt and Iraq and Syria. So you can just watch the cartoons and one
of the one of the devayne he was nicknamed father.
Okay, for example, story, have
you heard any?
And yes, the person who did what did you get paid from? So the person stole from someone and
so he was the boss. And he asked the person, where did you get it from? So he said, I heard it from someone cynical.
So he went to that study, and the person pulled him I heard it from someone other than so he went over there. And he asked the guy, where did you get it from?
So he said, Egypt, Egypt.
remember that? Yes. And where did you hit?
By the way his name was not the one who married.
Anyone know that? Just by the name you should know that.
I could not have known Mary and wife and said
to him, okay.
And this is the area that you find some of the books that succeed.
things for the one
that talks about a resource
than words you get
what he says,
I found the people getting busy when soap was
So I made the Teddy's up in order to encourage people to eat.
that that's one of the benefits of traveling.
And you can check the source of the day.
Me if someone tells me her to head east, you can go to his source and find out what's your work.
Make sure you've heard directly from him. And make sure it also has in this case, the person beverages. What are some of the benefits, he says?
hate you get to you get to see the narrator who never
recorded this before. But he would take it from anyone who goes to live in the city and study the person, see how he lives and everything. And then after you satisfied with his character, then
it gives you the opportunity to meet the person who was the source of
we'll have another chance to hurt you.
If you have
promise you go and travel you meet him. What are you doing?
you make the change? And
what's the benefits of making the change?
The shorter the shorter the better.
Let's just repair the fewer in between the less chance of
traveling to meet the person that you have heard
You'll be able to hear many more.
And this is one of the reasons why
our finger which needs some work. And
by the way, before we get to this point knows that
this shows us something about how we
felt about the problems
that exist they're willing to give up money, you're willing to give us time to set up them this one editor. So this shows you how eager they were to learn the editing process and make sure
make sure they are correct.
will work on
one of the advantages of
traveling such a headache.
later generations to have very large collections of headings.
And if you're if you imagine for example,
from the Roman
Each one of these two have been
each one of these
and one of the domains for example
one of the domains
and met all four of these
we also have someone over here
does the same thing. So on the next generation
he travels in both of these domains
now if you take this example you multiply
things to think about
that are so you can imagine how it would be possible for the later generations to have very large collections of edits compared to that
now, tell you about one person
we only had 10 heads with one of the submissive angels happening
Well, what you're doing is you're benefiting from the cells of the earlier person he fell so he gave his losses
So, now if you just use one person
and this is what why what are some of the latest scholars were able to compile large
large collections large collections
and also let's do one person having many
not uncommon for someone to have more than 1008 or more
because he goes to a different city
let them come
Another benefit of
okay not the
different way that was one of the reasons that led to some unification among the
among the Muslim
if you have refused to have a who knows
let's say they all moved to Boston
and all the others
maybe need died doing the proper
So what you have is you have invested
you have people love the following. There's only ones who know that
you remember to talk with them and even the most of them, those
are the reasons religious opinion amongst
tourists. What was it some people knew it it was other people did not know.
But if you have someone going around and collecting heavy from here and there and putting it into one book,
this will allow differences to be the most
important Unfortunately, it did not eradicate all of the differences. Because
there's some differences. There's some differences but there's even some invalid differences which should have been
a personal readings in one
or another benefit.
well, because of human beings sometimes.
Some people come to us dumb enough, like bow the heads or follow the judgment.
are we eating
But usually what was the piece by the way with respect to
usually you have a when you're young
and when you're young from the observe or the mannerisms of
your young one you don't teach
so you come to the city and you listen to this your
family your system your city and then you start thinking
about checking the memories binaries How would this have
you heard it from
as soon as people who are watching
some of you
you check to see if he narrated the same way that they are
so checking this is one way of checking to make sure that there is we're nearing the property we're not making welcomes it's also a good way of spotting
buying or buying
because many times what the fabricator will do is they'll say oh I heard this from so and so.
You of course mature someone far away.
Hopefully no one will ever go and check to make sure you
I never said this
before they can ask his students around and
so this is one also one of the ways
spotting forges of
Yeah, I think we missed
one of the one of the points by the way that we
or alluded to,
According to the orientalist are many of the orient
the soom now is not important is when
according to the according to the
many of them playing
they claim that the sooner was not considered to be something important by the
time I recorded. This as soon as self was not important, it is not considered an important source of law.
is a claim to claim and it was the son of
so it wasn't important
to them and still
170 Something is wrong running
government work this week
205 Exactly. Yeah.
You can't believe.
now what, what's the point is occurred to me that we refuted? Or what would they say that? What was the actual goal?
That's worse than saying it was recorded this time, then it's important only this time it was done with that one, because there was a
I mean, that
was not important to me.
Because this is what we were talking about.
Again, it's not important, they didn't consider important you think they preserved
Sooner wasn't important to hear that. That means the Muslims didn't care about recording and are not recorded. And that's, that's the goal.
But we would like to ensure if we go back to our discussion of importance of the center, one of the sections that have on their view towards
assume that the most the second to the Quran, when it comes to
And also, we discussed another example today, and this
journey is in search of heavy feminine surgeons, it was important, they were spent one month to pick one or
And because of the legal
so their goal was a fantasy. And you see this also in some Muslim writings, who've been influenced by
the terms are very important. And what they are. Therefore,
we show that the hover
from the time of travel search of headings, we showed this
they recorded the heading, we should also
use this method to make sure that the Hadees was transmitted properly.
I could give you some examples, but they're mostly meant that they don't
Though, the thing that
shows us what the SEC from the earliest periods of is
something that was important. They felt the searches hate to make sure it
make sure they memorize a property or they have property records. And they also use
try to prove this before
they bring some stories that look there was this problem and no one said any heavy regarding this problem. And then we get just the
theory of the
you just the series that we discussed last time because he said well, it was important.
So then they had to create a business back to the problem.
And as he says the veteran is not strongly the
question about these. These are some things that are not really mentioned that much in the books.
Today we're going to begin with the normal.
They are very important when we consider how the something that was preserved
as a lesson
Then we're going to discuss how the how
to pass on from one generation to the next.
Scholars have discussed in detail how someone passed at ease from one person on to the next.
This refers to how it was passed on from one person to the next.
During the time of the film, what were the ways that the buffet system conveyed this to his folks?
How does the public doesn't have given it to this folks?
Someone asked him a question. And he did not answer
when he just showed him the answer.
What about the one who came to ask him about the time
minutes from the time of finish
the first day and at the end of the second day,
for the prayer.
And he did not ask him directly, but he told him the first day he prayed all the first
and then the second day right older versus the latest time and he said was the one who asked he said between these two times
and also the
also the salaries to do the thing.
these delays may go on they are going to go on exactly the same way promises in the middle.
What's the third way?
3d is another
now the hava from the time of the public
domain they were very careful about that.
many Sahaba who did not admit it,
they very rarely would say anybody was
Many of them
are attending because they're afraid to add even just a letter to the
many of them used to perspire, when they're nervous.
And always at the end, when they're finished news to come upon
the tradition goes back to them
know, what's happening was among the, among the Sahaba themselves, we had people who specialized in memorizing
and one of those hobbies
How come I don't use every penny
is that there was I went to the same place that they went to, they heard the same thing. But I did not study after that. So therefore, I lost something while
for example, used to split the night into three parts. One third for sneaking one third, for branding with the city.
Also some of the most obvious
studying watches for
repeating with him.
So they're very careful and careful. Let's do this. Same thing. But how exactly should
idea came up, come up with eight ways. Eight ways to test