Channel: Munir Ahmed
Series: Munir Ahmed - Fiqh us-Seerah
The Conclusion of Badr
ala l mursaleen. Wa wasafi huduma II
and your filament lobanovsky
were less Allahu
beguilement nerfed what is kowalska
Wali Hinata workaway illegal mercy has been a law one at Milwaukee. What are how La quwata illa Allah Illallah de la creme allama solid roboticle Muhammad Ali Mohammed kamasan later Baraka Allah. Allah Allah, Allah Hema Majeed
Praise be to Allah we praise Him we seek His forgiveness, guidance and mercy we send peace and prayers on his final messenger Muhammad. We ask Allah
for useful knowledge and understanding wide sustenance. We ask his forgiveness and his mercy. We ask Allah to Allah we utterly depend unto him is our goal and return
and there is no power mic except that of a law. We were last time towards the end of what will boggle
buttero Cobra is as is known
and also known in the Quran as normal for on in Surah. Allah and burn, which abaza told you about Ilan Omar, I said, this is a surah of butter. On number eight is full of it about the happenings.
So in that last part I mentioned,
do you the first word to bother Yeoman for on the day of distinguishing that was the battle between gopher and the most distinguished battle as I mentioned to you last time.
So as you remember, if you remember from last time, we mentioned about numbers and we mentioned the battle at the end of the battle. Of course, we briefly mentioned that 14 of the Sahaba were martyred and 70 of the mystics were killed and 70 were captured as well.
the prophet SAW some of his companions stayed for a few days.
And it seemed the eventually the bodies of the disbelievers were thrown down. It seems like disused wells because there's more than one wells.
And that's authentic ahadeeth mentioned them being thrown down the wells wells as well.
a few things we mentioned last time.
for clarification was the idea of looking at the evidence from the idea the idea of did they come up for the caravan or did they come not expecting the various views amongst Allah is come evidence and I said to you emulated the strongest opinion is that they came out with a view for facing either one. And the consultation was done in Medina and hence the answer came out in large numbers amongst us 300 plus. Okay.
So that's a crucial point to remember in the background of warfare. And now as the
captives are being taken back to me now, just before that, I mentioned to you briefly at the end of the last session that when the bodies of the moshtix a display were thrown down the well that the prophet SAW Salem
A silicone adna come to la hora Sula, it would have been easier for you. assassins calling down the wells, where they've been strong would have been easier for you to follow and obey Allah His Messenger.
Fang Na, Na Ma, na buena for surely we have discovered and unrealized What are loaded promises for
Hello virgin to my water Rob buku Have you found and discovered what your Lord has promised you? meaning from? From ye from Russell alive is already promised and punishment if they carry on their way bacala Homer radi Allahu trabajo de la he said jasola these are dead bodies. Yeah. And there's no souls of departed so members they can't hear you.
So why some of us have well enough say Mohammed Bihari by by him in whose hands is a solid Mohammed.
Man anthem bs ma
Lima fool Minho? You're not hearing any better in a day hearing better than you what I am saying. This is reported in Buhari Qatada who's in the chain of narration and it's Tevye reporting from him the hour earlier lavonne Omar, he says afiya who will love a smart home?
He's saying Allah met them alive just for that time when messenger of Allah speaking so they could hear.
In other words, he's saying as a general rule, the Quran says it
the Quran says what an eye sutra quartzites saying.
in the color to smell Mota, surely you cannot make the dead here. Yeah, and another part where my anatomy moves me in my field COBOL and you are not able to make those in the graves here.
So that's why I bother saying this. There is a special miracle for Rasulullah
Ilaha which is reported in a Muslim which is authentic to her. When it was mentioned to her about what Omar had said in this report from Omar Abdullah one that that's what happened at bother and also another famous report again mentioning from Omar,
the son of two Rasulullah saw Salam in which it says in the mighty attack.
In the maggia turn you double feel Aubrey he Boca Lee,
people Chi li la,
which is also authentic, at least reported from the Isilon ha says in response to that she says
in in other races, they were mistaken. A message of Allah didn't say that. What is that? He said, that surely the dead person is punished in the grave because of the crying of his or her family.
On the grid.
The dead person in the grave is punished because of the crime or those real life or the family. So I said earlier now says she says
that this cannot be the misunderstood miss her the Messenger of Allah because it contradicts the Quran. The Quran said well, a person who was enough was enough to withdraw Oprah, no person no soul shall bear the burdens of another, which is a general principle, isn't it? Why would reject original sin in Christianity, claiming that the sin of Adam is carried throughout the children of Adam till the family and reject all that is saying, why should the person in the grave if they're doing wrong outside be punished for their own?
good argument, isn't it? I should say that the Mr. Bhalla must have said
he must have said in the Who are you available? behati it he ob zombie he was in a hula, hula kunaal.
must have said that he's been punished and punished because of his sins
in the grave, and now the family are crying over the grave.
That's the scholarship i said earlier on. So that there is difference in the Sahaba report. I should lie is correcting and saying some so there are all a man who followed her view and their Alemao said, Well, we can we can still debate what he actually said.
But it's, I think, I think it's the best view
says now, then she comes to the second part to do with
this hearing in the grip of the debt bubble, which is reported and she says they made a mistake.
Must have misheard or misunderstood in a home layout Ala Moana an American to a kulula home. Ha That's what he said.
When he said in the home last my own amount acun? Surely they definitely hear what I'm saying. If the Messenger of Allah when he said that what he meant was in Nam la la una and American to akula.
How? Surely they know now, what I used to say to them before is truth.
Yeah, and then she calls the Quranic ayah, which says you can't make the people in the grave hear you and those who are dead. So this is inside Muslim. So for completion, I thought I should mention the two verses relevant to this issue. And the whole debate amongst Allah. Can the people in the grave here? Yeah. And we have authentic hadith about the footsteps.
Yeah, so that Allah who is split into two groups, those who say that, even if this was actual hearing, yeah.
of the people who were Muslims who were killed the mother, it was only just for a civil war. So look like photography. And those who say ISIS opinion, no. And what he meant was that, that they know now, what I used to say was true, right. And the footsteps is also only at that juncture, when the body's being put in the grave. And at that juncture, the footsteps walking in a way that said, there's no more hearing beyond that. So you go and visit the graveyard of your family, father or mother or wherever, and you go and say Salaam Alaikum. They can't hear anything.
And there are those others who say, No, they can.
Because using the same evidences, they say, our low footsteps is mentioned. So that means they're hearing and hear the prophet SAW some tokens that have been correcting, almost saying, No, they can hear you better than I can. Yeah. And the fact that you walk the graveyard and say assalamu Aleikum Yahoo board, they say, well, they can hear, because they probably saw the eyes. Yeah, what is the situation with you and soon we will be joining you. Both opinions are there, okay. And both have interpretation based on the same evidence is interesting.
Now, the captains.
And amongst the captives
are abass the Uncle rasulillah salam, and I mentioned that somewhere, somewhere there, it seems, but I've been forced to come there, etc. So Abbas, the uncle Rasulullah sallallahu Sallam is there who's always been supportive.
He wasn't like a blue lab. And I will have interesting wasn't there was he? He paid for somebody to come. And he dies soon after him because he's not there, either.
And, but also captured is,
I will ask
son of I'll ask him the way, most speaking, leaders would ask, and what's special about I will ask,
I will ask is married is the is the son in law of the Messenger of Allah, by the way,
is married to Zeno.
is the limit?
And what's the situation will ask is the believer a Muslim
So I will ask is captured
and he has to pay the ransom as well. probably saw some video is my son in law will let him off
a bus actually, his companions on the unsolved, said jasola. It's your uncle and he's related through the Messenger of Allah with the banana jar. Medina Disney promises and got family
family there as well. So they say it's alright, we can let him off. And of course a bus is trying to get his way out of pain. And Trump is awesome. No, he's one of the rich ones making pay more.
So what kind of fairness is this that he talks about in Islam
having to pay more, so he tries to argue the case.
Now, some have said that
a bus and this is in
toppling the fate of the famous Tafseer of the Quran, who claims that a bus said at this juncture that he embraced Islam, the boys our sin still didn't let him know this is not authentic, the most authentic
is that Abbas embraced Islam very near Fatah Mecca many Few Years Later yet okay. So
So he's still Muslim, and he has to pay the ransom. And one of the interesting things here, which is Mexican authentically, in Mohali, actually, that abass when he's captured doesn't have a shirt so he's bad back to bare chested.
And he's, and some other reports mentioned he was a big Manta couldn't find a shirt or a garment to fit him. So he'll give him a shirt.
no, he's not likely to give him you know why he's not going to give it you ask his opinion why he thinks they should be done with the captives. Not gonna give it to him.
He think they should all be killed.
Because it becomes very relevant. One rule of thumb does many years later Mr. Mahoney mentioned they know scientifically. It was Abdullah obey
graphics at this stage is still mushfiq
is only a month or so after battle. And he
he outwardly embraced Islam. We can say that for sure. Because we're told you can't say that anybody else now?
Okay, hold on one.
sec. said while the prophet SAW Salem alive. We had believers monastics and disbelievers right after he left. We only have two categories. What's that?
believers and disbelievers because we can't open the hearts of people to see if he's been African or what he told them through what he they knew somebody was Manasa. In other words, don't go around now claiming that somebody's been African things. I'm very careful. And I've said it for years.
Some of our young people, some of the old ones who got wisdom are very quick to make judgments are now fake this some people on YouTube and so called sitting there like shapes and hardly you know, grown a beard in the 20s or 30s calling Chef katavi other big shoe because they don't have the same harsh opinions on that. Oh boy traffic shadow him and Africa and stuff. And a lot of these people. I mean, it is pure ignorance. That's all it is. ignorance. We don't call them enough exactly, which is ignorance. And it's not the Islamic way. Anyway. So interestingly, he gives Isha
and the promises and never forgot that. And that becomes very relevant when Abdullah and obey dies, which is mentioned
as his son, Abdullah Abdullah Abdullah yvalain obey a saloon was believer from early on. So when he's when asked Father, what did he ask
for the pain?
What did he ask for? What do you think he has for
He asked for the profit shirt for the cuffin.
Imagine that cup and being the promises, the promises from giving readily.
Gave it readily. Now we'll come to that story later on.
So this is it. It was because of this. He never forgot what he did, even though he's most likely remember what he did. And he's doing it as a Muslim.
So he gets a shirt and the prophet SAW some taking no compromise and yet the prophet SAW someone when his hands are tied at nighttime. in Medina. It's mentioned in good reports that he was groaning it's his uncle, and the function can sleep all night.
Until then, the the believers that relax the ties of the hands of all the captives, including
bus and then the province also was at ease because he still couldn't see people suffering and it was his blood. uncles always supported him as well.
Even though it didn't become a believer at that stage. So I will ask his story. had to pay a ransom. So his wife is the profits daughter for the law.
She has to send money and she sends money and a necklace
for his ransom. And the necklace is a gift that was handed down from her mother to sign up from Khadija humble mini for the ohana. So when that was brought to Medina on behalf of Xena, the prophet SAW some saw the necklace and tears came into his eyes. His wife's necklace isn't a
He's always remember what we mean. Really daily attendance.
And it mentions that it was a letter wife and she used to get jealous of it. How used to remember
And he used to treat her friends who used to come and visit her daily because of her
take his cloak off for them and get them to sit down on his claw. The friends he knew and laugh about a smile, who is mentioned authentic report I said I was watching and he's talking to this strange woman put his clothes down for her and I got jealous. What is it, and he told her this was a friend of hers. We were catching up on old times.
Some of our
some of our
again, a very natural sort of environment, the promises and creating none of this rigid idea that many of our people from religion have got a complete separation women that were men that were in so they lived in separate streets and marched around and never saw each other. It's just it's alien to if you look at a hadith and the life and truth picture of society of the sort of Muslim men, Medina is a very natural relaxed society.
With all etiquette, of course and higher, and now thought
the following saw some asks the captors, would they please give the necklace back at least two. And they readily agreed and took the ransom and was freed and he went back and if he said that the publicize them asked him to send a note to Medina. That was a condition.
Okay, so it goes back. Sanjay Gupta from Sloan will ask a few years later, he was attached. He was a businessman going on his trips to Syria and back to the shop. A few years later, he's going on one of these trips and on the way back, he's captured again by the unsolved murder marine unbelievers. So they take all his belongings of him because the war still going on. This is during the war years still before they be okay.
And the tape is blowing. And this they share it with themselves undertaking Captain back to a lot that tries to take him back to the captain back to Medina. But he manages to escape the captivity and where does he go?
He goes to Medina to his wife's place and takes hiding in there.
Exciting in the text cover in there.
And the promises from fines up. And above we saw some sad look is and now in this situation say this is my daughter's husband. Perhaps you know what you've taken off and if you could give him back, they realized who he was because it's messenger of Allah. Everybody gave everything back to him.
And the way he was treated, had a real effect on him.
He embraced Islam that he embraced Islam but he didn't say anything. He took his belongings and went back with his business back to Mecca. There he gave whoever they invested back their wealth etc. And then he declared that he became a Muslim and when he left for Medina, St. Louis, I didn't want to embrace a stain Medina in case you accused me of running off with all your possessions. So he
gave back everything and then he went back.
That's really the gist of the story what we have detailed. Sometimes people write and it was about a year ago during the newsletter here and I was with
Dr. Nasir cookie saying all this fancy story about love story of Zeno, as we only have very little information. We've done all sorts of hearsay and makeup stuff that people like to make. So we should be careful. Yeah, this is just a story. But anyway, we'd have various we have very little information about a sort of last lesson and his life story. Yeah, we have little snippets nevermind i will ask sensative and you know, have a long two page three page story that you could write a novel on and we got information though we have carved out you know, people's imagination running away and trying to make it into something which we don't know. We don't know. Yeah, we believe they
love each other because you know, that's all we know. But the cover story and also
some here's the difference in Allah. Some Alomar use this story and a week report to show that when Allah subhanho wa Taala said wha wha tunku shrieky nahata moussaka Tato min wala Amma to move Mina to Hiram Mimosa cutting Walla Walla
Walla, Walla, Walla como Sakina Hata. You know, while Abdul Mohammed on hydro Minwoo shrieking wa Jabba Khun la aka de Luna Illa. Now who
La Jolla had the whole Illinois agenda Hill agenda to allow fear to be evening. So this area is so Baccarat Allah smarter when it came he came in Medina. But notice what the IRS
Allah saying and do not marry mushrik women
for surely a slave woman who's a believer is better than a free woman who's
Muslim, even though they may be pleasing to you, beauty otherwise etc, etc. And do not marry a Muslim man, a slave Muslim man is better. A slave a slave, believing a man is better than a Muslim Freeman. Even though the mystic may be appealing and
attractive for you, they invite you to the fire.
Why align is calling you to gender and he's forgiveness.
So I'm gonna use that and say, all right,
and this is a very popular prayer and he seems amongst majority to be the only opinion now but rarely, rarely on this issue, that if we have two disbelievers, one of them, the husband or wife becomes a believer what they're supposed to do. Majority now say the marriage is dissolved.
They're divorced. How can she live with a disbelieving husband and vice versa? That's the most popular view out there that is the view as though there's no other view practically there isn't a view. And classically, there were other views not modernist view, by the way.
hamdulillah teacher said this 1311 or 13 different opinions in of this scenario from classical time from the time of Sahaba and Tavi.
Anyway, this story, why do I link it with that because some said that when I will ask him to Medina, he had to get a cane back together with Zainab on a new kneecap.
We have no evidence for this. Our blind abuzz his comment on this is the is authentic hadith says they came back together on the original kneecap
they came back together on the originally
Furthermore, when these is revealed we have no evidence at all from Quran or Hadith authentic that the that the prophet SAW some dissolve the marriages.
of all those where there was a mushrik and a believer in a marriage. We have no evidence that ever happened.
This is talking about the future. Well, I don't care. Do not now. Marry Muslims not saying those of you married them. Your marriage is dissolved. It never happened. By the way. Forget I will ask them Xena. We just sent somebody else back called a bus.
Promises some sent it back as a non believer. He's already been living with who his wife called Aman fuddle. Was she a believer?
Yes, she was. She was a believer very early on in Mecca.
publicise one could have said in Mecca I knew when he left Medina, for Medina after 13 years that Omen fuddle is living as a believing woman with a bus for so many years. Yeah, nearly 13 years one of the early Converse. He never said now you need to dissolve the marriage before I go to Medina. He left them there. Yeah, and his children, father and Abdullah our bus was still young. They were believers as well. So a boss is being sent back not saying sent home and funneled back to Medina because she's a believer and your marriage is dissolved. as some people say weave into the story of
Xena battle and I will ask they said the proper size for them said they say claim said to us after he's given ram ransom and relief from can go on Send sign up to Medina now because now I've been ordered to dissolve the marriage You can't be married to anymore because you are both shaken. She's a believer. Why do we say to a bus as well then? You understand what I'm saying? No. He's asking for him to come Why?
Why is he asking for sign up to be sent to Marina? His daughter is missing.
He left some alone What did he not?
He only left there with the same husband. He must have been treating her well for the father was
So love to leave this beloved daughter in Mecca he must have must have treated the world with evidence for that reason, otherwise would have taken the time.
You understand what I'm saying? So he's not he didn't give a general order for all of you who are married to believing men and women are women over that they have to all be sent here. No such order was given.
She's a very important thing. And it is very clear. Not even in week reports that a boss or woman fuddle Yeah, ever separated. Yeah. And had to have a secondary car. Yeah, no evidence. Absolutely Zilch. And neither is different. The story I will ask and
except a week report which is not acceptable and countered to it is as a good report, a summary report authentic products are buzzing, they came together on the original marriage.
So that you see changes situations for when somebody comes to you and say, I'm embracing Islam. My husband's still disbeliever
the Mufti and the Imam needs to be careful just saying, oh, you're just a dissenter. You're married? No. Your marriage is a marriage contract. Islam. Islam. didn't ask all the Sahaba came from mushrikeen they came from ship. Is that true? Yeah. Also have a came from Sure. When Islam came? Yeah. Did Islam accept their marriages and ship? It did? Did they all embrace together husband and wives? Did they
know where Islam said to them, all your marriages from the past of Muslim times are all dissolved? Let you all have to go and have noon because starting with the Messenger of Allah with Khadija true or false never happened, you understand what I'm saying? So here again, the idea is the contract is is actually contract. Actually, the reality is the contract in Islam is a contract. Yeah, it's been established that yes, a new marriage is different. The verse is saying
that once you're a believer, you don't go and marry a Muslim. But you were emotionally you're a disbeliever one of you embraces Islam as a different scenario. You follow me?
So this is for cosida learning lessons from Sudan, the story there as well.
Some of the captives ahwazis, who was a
special report was the brother of Muslim women who may Mousavi Nicole May was the famous standard bearer who held the the the flag or the standard for the believers one of the standard bearers of the believers in the battles in Sabine Baba and often
and most of them then amaze brother Abdul Aziz who came out to fight he's as a captive with an Ansari from Medina. So Musab is saying to the underside ties hands tight, meaning my brothers are Boise's. Because his mother has lots of wealth, we'll get a good ransom for him. So was he saying, You're my brother?
This guy's come out to Fight. Fight means killing Muslims. So how do you think he sees him? So Musab said the one who's tying your hands tied is more my brother the newer?
This is belief. And this is because this, this is not treatment of somebody who's your brother and you become a believer, and they're still disbelievers. You say, nasty character. He's more my brother. I'm having nothing to do with you. Why is he saying that?
He came with a sword to kill. This is war. War changes eight, not because he's a believer, etc. And he's treating him badly because of that. Despite that,
rather than sisters, the prophet SAW Selim when the captives are called give quite clear instructions to treat the captives. Well. Yeah, to the extent What did the Sahaba do? They treated them better than themselves. They have to keep them captive. It can't say it's all right, off you go.
Because the nanny was agreed that they were gonna have to pay a ransom. Yeah. So the and those who couldn't afford the ransom, they could teach children of Medina to read and write. And if they did that, they were allowed. That was their ransom. That was their ransom. And despite that being encountered prophesized them, so Sahaba,
they used to have the cooked food they would give to the captain's while they do some days
and I will this ice
The brother, he felt so guilty, and I felt ashamed
that they were giving cooked bread and food to me and there were some eating days. So I said, No, no, no, you eat it, you eat it. I insisted, but they kept on insisting back. They didn't say, Yeah, all right,
off you go, since you get to know this the spirit of have no preference of others. And this had an impact on the other the captains, of course, they went away with that kind of treatment, you know, even as captives are at the mercy of Allah and said
so, in regards to captives, this is an important issue needs a bit of clarification. I think we'll just probably just get through that today.
for finishing with Baba, messenger of Allah when I took the captives, he asked the opinion I mentioned last time of Abu Bakar and former and then some siding with the opinion of bucha from the Sava some with Allah.
What should we do with the captives?
abubaker so jasola they are relatives? Yeah, perhaps Allah will show them the way as you know us, let's ask ransom for them and freedom.
To give them opportunity to do that. I said, jasola we should kill the wretched machetes Yeah, and let each family kill their own motion.
Why? Because no family member can see some other family members are killing their families saying let us kill our own.
So he's not going to give his shirt to our bus. He's asking him to kill us.
That's what our his opinion is not the level and
so those opinions came and the messenger of a lot took the opinion in our back.
it is a set in a few reports that after that,
Allah subhanaw taala revealed
unless one as I said,
maccarinelli Navy in a cocoon Allah who saw your screen or fill out to be the owner, Raja dunya huanglong regal Pharaoh. Allahu azeez on the hockey team. Lola kita boom Mina la he set up Allah Miss sacrum FEMA dome as one of the
law says it doesn't it is not right for the prophet to take captives
until he has Justina filled out.
You see now Phil
has until he has Justina Villa means done a decisive battle to completely suppress the enemy.
Some said that use in armies until he has made great slaughter.
But Mr. Bahari
I prefer his opinion and actually
sahana Justina has that meaning is to overcome. Yeah, overcome the enemy in
in a clear manner, so they don't have ability to come back at you again. decisive victory in the sun.
So you've been up, Mr. Buhari said means that they overcome them decisively that there's no chance of the enemy coming back again. Is the weapon other. It didn't. That's why all the battles came afterwards again. Yeah, it seemed. It seemed that the battle there was some 70 were killed seven and can seem that some of the believers were quick to capture.
Because we're thinking of the ransom. That's what I was father's indicating. Yeah. And that's what that's what I was criticizing.
to redo Narada dunia Allah Fatah saying you you mainly seek the gains of the world. Who's he talking to? He's talking to the Sahaba actually not the Messenger of Allah. But Mr. Bhalla because he allowed that to sort of happen, saying that you were seeking the gains of the world but Allah desires for you the good of the hereafter. Yeah, well, what will you read laughter. Well, love was easy. And Hakeem allies making wise Lola kitanomine ally Subbu had it not been a previous decree from Allah that a stern punishment would have afflicted you for what you have taken.
What you have taken meaning
What you have taken as captives for ransom?
And that comment is to who? To the Messenger of Allah.
Lola kitanomine. Allah Subhana, Allah Masako, the Messenger of Allah and the believers in plural. Yeah, female a hustlin. Thorough in what you have taken of captives for ransom, allow the sense of punishment to you a severe punishment. So the allama said, was it not for decree before means that something must have been decreed before about allowing, taking ransom
allowing taking down some from captives or taking booty? Either things there's debate on it.
And because of that, Allah smart ALLAH forgive an overlooked and then made halau for them for pulumi ma on him Tom halaal and Paul Eva, so each of the bounty that you collected as halaal and good what taco law and federal law in the love of fool Rahim surely ALLAH is forgiving merciful and less forgiving him. Now.
some say when they say our comes, because in one heavy thing mentioned which is authentic as well, now you've seen Hadith, and therefore, Imam tirmidhi says is also because you find various hudy
a little bit contradictory.
Yeah. Because in 108, they mentioned that Omar from Omar rhodiola until he came after this is revealed after he's given his view, and he comes the next day and he finds a messenger of Allah and ibaka crying, and he says, will you let me know what you two are crying about so at least I can join you in crime and love the promises of Allah revealed this verse.
Yeah, severely criticizing that's why we cry.
So indirectly for some that indicates and if you read the center it majority give you the view that Omar's opinion was right. And Abu buckers was and also supported by Allah and an Abu Bakr his opinion was not supported by Allah, Allah forgive them.
And that's not the only view. I don't accept that you personally. Okay. I'll tell you for a while.
Now, I might have been hot Tom also says in a few reports in Bukhari and Muslim
He says, In before it was up to rob beefy thalassa
My Lord agreed with me on in three matters. This is almost stature.
that hour when Fatah was sent to the Messenger of Allah, why don't we take Muhammad Ibrahim as a place of doing salon worship?
It was a suggestion and a lot revealed a verse confirming that take the place Muhammad Ibrahim for Salah I'm pregnant as one. So in one report, he mentions three and another report he mentions for their authentic that's not the contradiction. But he mentioned various in in this one in Mohali. He said the second one was the teacher for a job not for women in general believers. Job meant screening for the wives of the Messenger of Allah, that's all over went on about. He never talked about his wife. He never talked about his daughters. He never talked about the wives and daughters of the believers. Omar said Yahshua used to screen your wives all kinds of people come to your house
and reveal the verses of hijab when we say hijab is used in a different sense nowadays, but hijab only came for the wife of a soloist.
It means complete screaming,
means complete screen. So that was just an honor
to traverse accordingly. Thirdly, he said
in this one he says when he got to the wives of the Prophet size for them after they were jealous and causing fights with the Messenger of Allah is separated from them. He mentioned that perhaps that he'll divorce you if you carry on like this and Allah will replace you replace with those who are obedient good, you know, not like you being disobedient, etc. And a lot smarter revealed a verse or two he said, so he mentioned those three, but inside a Muslim. In one of the reports he mentioned that one of the three has been in regards to the captives.
in this regard difference of opinion came November This is not the sort of last awesomes words this is almost interpretation that's important, almost saying Allah greed or meanness. However,
if we look at
if you look at the issue of Muhammad Ibrahim
almost suggested something and Allah smartlock confirmed it and it happened before me Ibrahim. Abraham was taken place over
second almost suggested about a screening of the wife of the Messenger of Allah I A came and omers opinion is implemented true
if we say that this is in accordance when the IR comes regards the captive
regard the captives almost opinion is to kill them
our workers is to not kill them let them furnaces they still there the captives.
So if Allah agrees with Omar's opinion, what should have happened?
They should have all been slaughtered. Is that right? But they weren't.
They weren't. And that for me is a strong evidence that this ayah didn't came come to agree with Omar about killing them. This ayah says that you as I mentioned it to you again. Look what the IRS says that's what we have to go back to because that's where we find the answer. Makana Linda Elena V in an akuna la asfa Hata Justina fill out, it is not right for the messenger Yeah, for the profit, that he takes captives until there is a decisive victory.
decisive victory means in battle.
But that's already gone. When this is revealed, is criticizing the hastiness of the believers in bothering taking captives and booty and capitalist for ransom. What Allah saying you should have fought even more killed as many as possible in the battle, so that they wouldn't have a chance to come back at you again and again.
You understand? Not that you kill the captives is no sign.
But there's difference opinion on this. Most of the senior writing, you'll see give you the impression that Omar's opinion about killing the captives was right.
And Allah the IRA support is that I don't believe so. I is not saying that.
I was not saying that. And even if that was the case, it was it should have been implemented. Why was it could have still been implemented. The capitals hadn't been released and gone. It was still there when the I came. There's only the next day. You understand what I'm saying? You follow me? Yeah. So almost printing could have still been implemented. It wasn't. It wasn't. Which means it wasn't to do with that. It was to do with what already happened in the Gospel, the battle.
Interesting report intermidiate.
That mentioned from the prophet SAW Selim, that the promises on said that gibreel has come down. And he's saying,
he's giving you a choice.
He's giving you a choice in the site as well, which gives another angle to it, of either you can release and release these people for ransom, or kill them. If you're going to release them for ransom, then expect a similar number of your people being killed in the future, as theirs were in this battle.
That's what happened. That's what they accepted the Sava agreed to the second. So what happened in offered
70 Sahaba got killed equivalent to 70.
That's an interesting report as well. Mr. tirmidhi, he says, when we bring the reports together,
and he's saying this is a the also the opinion of Medina, humble among family says that it is up to the government and the ruler, either to release the captives for ransom, or to kill them, depending on how much of a threat they are.
Right depending on how Mr friendly which is also a good point as well. Now, if the world unites together, and makes a agreement that captives are going to be treated well and return
Then it's not against Islam. It's not against Islam. And that's an agreement that you make you follow that through as well. But this is talking about at that time. Yeah, I'm not familiar saying at that time, one way of understanding it is the government the ruler decides, yeah. And that has some
credibility in it.
on the way back to have the captives, the promises from ordered for them to be executed,
execute, there were some of the worst mushriks to the believers, not just the Messenger of Allah and the Messenger of Allah, in how they killed tortured, and persecuted believers in Makkah. Akbar in Emirate
was one of them. And another April's Harris was the other one. So they were executed. They were not given Shanshan a choice of ransom.
So you can see the movie where he's coming from, because they were so dangerous Not only that, they are committed terrible crimes already.
Yeah, crimes on humanity you say about war crimes will be they were criminals. And they will not just they're in a battle they were criminals. So they were given the death penalty by Russell versus some holders. The rest will take them capital as I said, and and then released little by little a story what I said to you, and that really is the end of butter, and the Profit System comes back victorious. That creates real hatred among some of the Jews and we'll see what happens especially the bunny, bunny by no cop
and others like carbomer Ashraf, the hatred it festers and spills out from them and and moshtix in Mecca,
eliminating and and wailing, etc trying and already thinking of vengeance etc. So we'll see what is the build up to this next part, inshallah next week, a whole lot of stuff that will