The Battle of Jamal

share this pageShare Page
Mohammed Hijab

Channel: Mohammed Hijab

Episode Notes

Episode Transcript

© No part of this transcript may be copied or referenced or transmitted in any way whatsoever. Transcripts are auto-generated and thus will be be inaccurate. We are working on a system to allow volunteers to edit transcripts in a controlled system.


00:00:03--> 00:00:04

Hello, Serato Sula.

00:00:05--> 00:00:33

Of course today inshallah we're gonna be talking about market in general. And, of course, in the previous lecture, we went through the background of market in general, which happens to be McDowell earthmen. And if you haven't seen much on Earth, man, you really should check out my other one because that's the whole context. And you're going to be lost when it comes to in general. And if you don't know what happened to Earth, man, that's the first thing anyone here not watch.

00:00:34--> 00:00:41

sham. You watch it? Are you sure? Okay, we can wait. We can we can wait for you to watch it right now.

00:00:42--> 00:00:43

All right. So

00:00:45--> 00:00:50

now first of all, just a very, some basic minor notes that I want to share.

00:00:51--> 00:01:09

If you're ever going to be looking into a German, because it's one of those topics is so controversial that you have multiple points of views. You have conflicting reports everywhere. So the first piece of advice is never stick to one basic primary source, right? Because it's just going to confuse you.

00:01:11--> 00:01:12

Now,

00:01:13--> 00:01:36

the thing is about a gentleman. I never wanted to lecture about the gentleman. I never wanted to, but I need to. Okay, because jemelle has been abused as a political point against the Sahaba has been abused. The topic has been abused and abused against the listener.

00:01:37--> 00:01:38

And SubhanAllah.

00:01:40--> 00:01:53

The people who are using it against the Henderson have absolutely no clue what happened to jemen absolutely no idea what happened in Yemen. And if you were to ask a Shay,

00:01:54--> 00:02:08

tell me what happened to the gentleman. Maybe he'll quote some narrations against you from your sources. But if you were to ask them, Why you present to me what exactly happened in your view, from your books?

00:02:09--> 00:02:40

So I'm going to happen they don't have the information. And if they have information they don't have authentic reports. Yes, of course they have information they just don't have authentic reports. They can't piece it together. That's something I have to get across it. Yeah, buddy. If you have an issue with the swing narrative, have you been provided the sheet a narrative? What is the shooting narrative Arsalan? So this is Jani. My challenge is Allah to the she has who want to use jemelle as a political point against a sham Balkans. Well,

00:02:41--> 00:02:45

first things first, of course, we have to get this out of the way what are the sources of fuel jemelle

00:02:47--> 00:03:06

Henderson often use the why of Seth banal model Tamimi A lot of us down they shouldn't be doing this but they keep doing this because safe report is the general common pro Sunni reports and this is an issue this is an issue inshallah we'll get to that.

00:03:07--> 00:03:24

Now, there are of course, multiple sources you have to work with these a source you have a manifest a source that oh Billa heaven movie, there's a source that you have these lengthy narratives that are very problematic, extremely problematic. And these are these are

00:03:25--> 00:04:13

described as rewire. Right? They say rewire seminoma timimi, however, is it really safe when Omar's rewire? Is it really his rewire? Because at the end of the day, speedometer is now racing through chains through is much higher. So isn't it really his mesh is rewire on these the narrations of his machine? How about enough, isn't it his teachers rewire? Or the last person that changed isn't it his rewire for example. So the reason we say this is the Wyatt this person, it's because it simplifies things. And there's a general trend, there's a general tone prosci personally, etc. And you'll notice this when you actually go through these rewire there's this general tone.

00:04:15--> 00:04:25

Again, when discussing a topic like in general, I have to always not just a gentleman anything but any any any controversial historical narrative,

00:04:26--> 00:04:27

historical topic,

00:04:28--> 00:04:51

I always have to coach him because he says we have to apply the methodology of them had the theme when speaking about these controversial topics in history, because if we don't use them in our head of quality management or anything, then we're stuck with every innovative sex using using reports that they like that appeal to them.

00:04:52--> 00:04:59

They probably will use this machine a will use this. There's so many will use this and everyone's gonna say

00:05:00--> 00:05:05

History says, okay, history says only Why are

00:05:07--> 00:05:23

the authentic reports say this? Yeah, well, most people will say this. They don't even know what they're saying. They don't know what they're quoting. Everyone's appealing to his view of history and what's his view whatever suits his beliefs by

00:05:25--> 00:05:30

Yeah. All right. So let's, yeah, there's so much to go through.

00:05:31--> 00:05:41

Okay. So firstly, this the main source of a gentleman for Arizona alum Stan Sefton, Omar Tamimi, right. He's mainly quoted by

00:05:42--> 00:06:26

and he guesses Iowa much allelic poverty. Okay, so now again, what's the main issue with sentiment Ahmad? He's weakened by the scholars. That's the first issue. second issue his his teachers are usually module the narrations are disconnected, but almost done. Now, what's really interesting about sippin Armada is he will say some things that are very anti Sunni that no Sunni will accept. Okay? So for example, at the Manhattan macpaw, a, who's a loved Sahabi is one of the instigators of the fitna. Now no Sunni Shia will use this. Okay, this is a very This is the issue. If you're going to use safe bin Omar Tamimi use everything else he don't use, don't pick and choose don't cherry

00:06:26--> 00:06:31

pick. If he's reliable for something, he can be unreliable for something else by far the number one.

00:06:33--> 00:06:35

I might have been the Austin is one of the killers.

00:06:36--> 00:07:15

Okay, according to me, nobody is going to use this. Right? So if you're not going to Okay, so and then of course some other matters, which which Misha Henderson often quotes, and whenever you hear lecture, where a historian uses this, or a chef use this in a lecture, it's always you keep this in mind that this has been our motto. Hmm. So like what I'm loving said that I Beloved. And so it did this. He did that he calls the fitna, he killed it with mine, he made the issues in general. That's all seminoma a carbon, carbon hammer me. He's the one who created us trying to create peace between both camps.

00:07:17--> 00:07:19

Save me time, I mean, these are the two signs.

00:07:20--> 00:07:28

Now there's there's some other issues with siffin armadas narrative, for example, there are some contradictions between what he says and

00:07:30--> 00:07:34

what is historically accurate. So for example, the time of the battle.

00:07:35--> 00:07:40

The duration of the talks, there were talks between the bus lilies and the coupons.

00:07:41--> 00:07:54

And finally, the amount of people that were killed. safes, numbers are quite exaggerated and shallow, we're gonna get to that. Michelle, I'm gonna go into detail when we actually get to these

00:07:55--> 00:07:55

events.

00:07:57--> 00:08:33

Now, the sheet a source, the main sheet, a source? Well, there are two main key sources, but one of the more important ga sources, the rewire off leukopenia here, the main narrator of the history of Karbala, or excuse me, the the events that occurred in Kabbalah and the mortal sin. Now, who, of course, we've lost this book, we've lost the book of Obama enough. But it's been preserved his narrative has been preserved by Edna beheaded and particularly the author of Sharpton he Bulava and does a great job. And it

00:08:34--> 00:08:47

is a great book for preserving historical reports. Honestly, it's a great book for preserving historical reports. However, there's an issue with double mcdonoughs chains. And if she is want to come and they want to

00:08:48--> 00:09:11

use the narrative above enough as the reliable narrative, well, this could create some problems for everyone. And let me get to why. Of course, first of all, there is an issue with chains. There's an issue with both neffs teachers and his teachers, teachers, and it's filled with anonymous and weak reports.

00:09:13--> 00:09:21

There's a historical contradiction of what mcdonoughs report describes as an urban alley as a young child. Okay.

00:09:22--> 00:09:23

And at the time, he was

00:09:26--> 00:09:31

almost 40 what was well 30s he was in his 30s. Yes, he was he was in his mid 30s at the time.

00:09:34--> 00:09:39

Oh, he has this really crazy false addition and shall I'm going to get to him and talking about narration later on.

00:09:41--> 00:10:00

He has this an hour in this office narration says that I really hated power. He didn't want the power. Of course this conflicts with the Shay narrative because the Imam is supposed to have power. You can't back away from power and he has a very, very strange

00:10:00--> 00:10:11

reports that no one would accept. And he basically says that he had an issue with homosexuality. And we're gonna get to why later, but basically he sends a letter to a boss allegedly

00:10:12--> 00:10:16

cursing him, okay, and saying, Oh, you son of a tailor

00:10:17--> 00:10:26

Oh, you who bites his father's penis. Okay, so I don't think anyone's going to accept that as something that Sally would say.

00:10:30--> 00:10:32

I know it's such a weird thing to say.

00:10:34--> 00:10:53

But then you have a she a leaning source, you have a sheet a leaning source, which is the report of a doctor D. Now we'll walk these technically as certainly, but it's a very [???]ty leaning report. This report has been actually it's been preserved by animal feed. And his book, The German mafia, of course, is a shady scholar

00:10:54--> 00:11:15

who passed away in the fifth century. Now, what's what's strange thing is and what the D is a liar. According to Edison, he's a liar, according to Murphy himself. So again, he's not the best source for a gentleman. Of course, there's an issue with the chains. He has some contradictions. For example, there's a soldier called Ahmad bin Abdullah

00:11:17--> 00:11:29

and in one reported walk and he says that he's with alien one reports he says that he's with a shadow hand Zubair. Of course, this also shows that contradictions are not necessarily from the

00:11:30--> 00:11:36

historians themselves, but rather from the narrations that they presented their from the their chefs and their chefs chefs.

00:11:37--> 00:11:38

He also has some strange

00:11:40--> 00:11:42

things he adds like it's about a fled away.

00:11:43--> 00:11:51

During the Moscow he fled, he fled after defeat, excuse me, he fled after defeat. He also adds that she admits to killing with money.

00:11:52--> 00:11:56

Okay, so that's a very pro Shay.

00:11:57--> 00:12:43

reports or pro shooting narrative. And it's senator Walker, the SGA or Lahu alum. I believe it's Eben Nadeem, who mentioned this, who mentioned this interest, if I'm not mistaken, he mentioned that it is she a who's doing it yet. But you know, Sunni scholars have never said this. So we take this with a grain of salt. However, in walk these reports are quite Shay leaning again. And will feed has two books on Gemini one, isn't it Paul Tobin Harper, and the second is a gentleman Of course, Gemma is quite a lengthy book. But again, the challenge is to produce a narrative he or she will produce a narrative where you gather the authentic reports of a demo according to you, so that we can learn so

00:12:43--> 00:12:53

and then we can see if how your narrations conflict with us and reality. I strongly believe that it's not something that you can possibly do. So

00:12:54--> 00:13:27

we're almost getting through with inshallah, guys. This this background. I know I'm sorry. What is the authentic source of gemel authentic sources of real German. Mainly You have various narrations here and they're usually quite short. There's one lengthy reports of a German which is the report off KoolAid Jeremy which is preserved in and which is preserved in muslin fnma shaybah. terracotta body. And Victorville for what? by a battery.

00:13:28--> 00:13:45

So here's here's a question for you guys. What do you think is the best book for example with Max on earth Monday remember what it was? Eva? Mashallah Cathy two out of two today Hmm. So the best source for Gemma is anyone

00:13:47--> 00:13:47

know

00:13:48--> 00:13:51

anyone? I mentioned the book last time

00:13:52--> 00:13:54

I think I mentioned I mentioned it today as well.

00:13:55--> 00:13:57

Actually I mentioned it just No

00:13:58--> 00:14:13

no, it's Muslim there have been a ba ba. So even though ba ba has a chapter a lengthy chapter with many reports of a gentleman many of them are authentic. So

00:14:14--> 00:14:17

it's a very very important source

00:14:18--> 00:14:19

by

00:14:20--> 00:14:41

I don't want to go through the reasons why earthman was killed we went through that last time let's save some time. Again if you haven't, if you don't know why. You should check out that with mine video. So I'm gonna go past this with a man passed away or he was killed in the year 35. If that hinges on Okay, now have the now we can start streaming data about him.

00:14:44--> 00:14:52

How did the Le receive the Pledge of Allegiance when Earth man was killed the people that killed Earth mon wanted halifa

00:14:53--> 00:14:59

wanted to put someone to power. So they went to multiple people. They didn't just go to Allie. They went to Las

00:15:00--> 00:15:10

They went to bin Omar, they went to Baja. And when they went to bin Omar they actually threatened to ban Omar Yama. If you don't become halifa, we're gonna kill you. I mean, Omar

00:15:12--> 00:15:13

did not accept.

00:15:15--> 00:15:32

Allah Himself was very, very hesitant to accepting the philosopher. And he was advised by an Ibis and Muslims in masala rasa. And he was advised by Allison and Wilson who maybe shaybah to not accept the philosopher. Why?

00:15:34--> 00:15:34

Any ideas?

00:15:41--> 00:15:43

One more time, and one by one.

00:15:50--> 00:15:54

Ah, yes, it would have been more details.

00:15:56--> 00:16:09

Exactly, exactly. So it would be accused, or he would have to bear the responsibility for the man's death. Okay. Susan has sent them an alley. And they've been a boss both advising it.

00:16:10--> 00:16:30

And they've been serious and resulted in Masonic behavior says, I highly was not accused of killing a man until he accepted the buyer. When he accepted the buyer, there were some people who spread this rumor. And yeah, they accused me of being with those that killed earthman. Any idea why

00:16:34--> 00:16:42

was because the people with me, his commanders, generals, people that were higher ranking around him, were some of the killers the first month.

00:16:45--> 00:16:49

They put them into power. So that was the assumption.

00:16:50--> 00:17:05

So basically, what happens let's fast forward a bit a few months down the line, I Chabot has where they they were actually was actually in Macau at the time. But it has a bit of a leave Medina, they had to Mecca, the mirror Asha and they

00:17:07--> 00:17:12

agreed agree that we have to do something about this, we have to adventure with one.

00:17:14--> 00:17:17

And they decide together to go to bussola.

00:17:18--> 00:17:24

Now on the way to bussola. There's a very, very, very important narration which is narrated by Muhammad.

00:17:25--> 00:17:28

When I show reaches basava or excuse me on our way to bustle she

00:17:30--> 00:17:47

arrives at this water source cold and how and when she reaches the water source, she hears dogs barking and she asks them where are we? And they say we are at an how a and then she says I think we need to return back.

00:17:48--> 00:17:51

And she quotes also la Selim who said to her

00:17:54--> 00:18:00

who from among you, he says to his wife who from among you is going to be barked at by the dogs of how

00:18:02--> 00:18:10

that's basically it's there's there's no more additions to that. So she thought this has a negative implication.

00:18:11--> 00:18:17

Now there's an addition and Muslims bizarre through the path of

00:18:18--> 00:18:22

Islam been Kodama from academia from urban Ibis

00:18:23--> 00:18:24

in which

00:18:25--> 00:18:33

the prophet SAW sent him says who from among you is going to be barked at by the dogs of house and the men

00:18:34--> 00:18:37

on her left and on her rights are going to be slaughtered.

00:18:39--> 00:19:12

So this report was it was graded as a moon cutter report by ohata mallozzi. And his sons and and the reason is, well Lahu lm is as somebody who damn isn't really the strongest narrator especially from academia submitted to the Mr. Coffee economics as a major students with an Ibis where all the narrator's from academia How come as somebody who damages only personnel rating this, this narration has an edition that was not in the original hadith of placement to be hasn't from Arusha and wasn't ahead, and that's why there was some doubts about this.

00:19:13--> 00:19:20

So where it gets really interesting is with double McAnuff because abamectin f

00:19:23--> 00:19:24

Okay.

00:19:26--> 00:19:55

All right. So abamectin f has an interesting addition to this, and an addition to the narration of assemble Kodama, he says, as something Kodama narrates, to me from eczema from a bus that Rasulullah saw Sam said, Who from among us going to be barked at by the dogs and men from her left hand and on her right are going to be slaughtered and all of them will be in hellfire.

00:19:56--> 00:19:59

So this is the addition of a woman enough clear cut proof that

00:20:00--> 00:20:17

But McAnuff is tampering with the reports adding something to the report that was never narrated by a subject Kodama Of course implying let's the jaysh the army of Irish are all going to help basically this is one of the reasons why you can't really trust them enough.

00:20:18--> 00:20:22

Again this exact same chain I mean it's from someone who dama okay so

00:20:24--> 00:20:42

so now let's let's head back to the reports of Kool Aid. Jeremy now Kool Aid says the bus or an army This is during the time for the man they're going to head out to a vendor and then they heard they received news that nothing's going to happen and earth man basically

00:20:43--> 00:20:54

negotiated or things were settled with the rebels and everything was settled and hamdulillah and then all of a sudden they received were that Nope, he was actually killed by the rebels so I'm alone.

00:20:56--> 00:21:01

And basically, it all has weighed on a shelf a sudden show up and bussola

00:21:02--> 00:21:27

and cable and Jeremy mentions that I shall Of course spoke to them and she said she provided her reasons why she came out to the to Basra. Now, of course, some of that was covered in the previous lecture with mustard mustard with mine. So the question is while bussola Why did they go to the bustle in the first place? Any ideas?

00:21:34--> 00:21:35

so bad?

00:21:36--> 00:21:38

Not bad. Anything else?

00:21:39--> 00:21:49

So the brother said it's a stronghold for one's family. Well, more like you they had they had they could find support and bussola they felt like they could find some support and bustle.

00:21:50--> 00:21:56

And there were of course a lot of available men that would be ready for battle in Wasilla. Now,

00:21:58--> 00:22:19

we have Vaughn, who is the teacher of Halliburton hayyat one of the best books of tarrif. Summarize but really, really useful. mentions that sort of mundane who knife meets Paul Hanna Zubair, he makes peace with them. And they agree Of course, if my wife is the representative of Eileen bussola, and they decide to wait for Eileen.

00:22:20--> 00:22:21

Now,

00:22:22--> 00:22:40

Erin said there's a letter that sent to Allie describing why Pelican Zubair, and, of course head over to bussola. Now the Boston's asked her why he came, and how he's acting in a way without the approval of Allie.

00:22:41--> 00:22:55

Allie is not is not given these people to march to bussola and to gather troops to avenge it with money. So what exactly is happening, but has says a sword was put to my neck.

00:22:56--> 00:23:00

I gave back to alley because a sword was put to my neck.

00:23:01--> 00:23:02

That's what he says.

00:23:03--> 00:23:09

Now, keep in mind that this was how chaotic things were in Medina.

00:23:10--> 00:23:37

I mentioned a few minutes ago, even if Omar had the sorts of his neck, and they were trying to force him to become Khalifa. And inshallah there's there's some more that's coming up, but that will that will show how chaotic things were. So it basically sends a bust to make sure if this thing even happened because I really had no idea it happens. So my boss goes and he looks for someone who can affirm this. He finds Osama bin Zayed right so some have been zeds

00:23:38--> 00:23:47

confirms that palha was forced to to give back to it and Osama bin Zayed for saying this was beaten up

00:23:48--> 00:23:57

for just affirming that stylehaul was forced beaten up by who by the haters the fourth one again, so never been a shaper

00:23:59--> 00:24:09

so now we don't really have too many details of what happens in the bustle. We have a lot of weak reports we have been providing a very personally reports we have

00:24:11--> 00:24:18

a boom an F and then some other is providing a very pro sheet your report. But basically some

00:24:21--> 00:24:28

there's there's there's some issues on the bus law and some fighting occurs and some people get killed, and basically

00:24:29--> 00:24:32

balaghat and Zubair and I should take over labasa

00:24:33--> 00:24:59

and at around that time, there is a battle that occurs which is called the minor Gemini. So we have the normal regular Battle of Gemini that we all know about. And then there's the minor Gemini. Now in the minor battlefield gemel. We don't have too much information for what occurred there. But we do know of who came Benji Bella being killed in the Battle of the mind.

00:25:00--> 00:25:03

Gentlemen, do you guys remember who who came in Java is?

00:25:10--> 00:25:17

No idea. So okay, Ninja Bella is the head of the killers of Earth man from bussola.

00:25:19--> 00:25:30

So this is one of the reasons why they even went to bussola to kill the killers of earthman in bussola, and they were successful in this.

00:25:31--> 00:26:02

According to the reports of safety now I'm going to Timmy. He mentioned another Navy ministers he mentioned proposed Ebenezer Hale. Remember how postman's who had is also is one of those that were exiled by earthman and proposed admins who had basically escapes his escapes death, basically. And he finds refuge in one of the tribes, I'm guessing his tribal law item. And they basically can't reach him and triple spins who had lives on to the time of nada, one where he joins the high wattage basically ultimately.

00:26:05--> 00:26:20

So yeah, so So why did they go to bussola? One, they found support there, they knew they could find support there. And two, they went to kill the coders of earthman. And three, they actually did kill, they did kill one of the instacare instigators against southmont, which is okay magenta.

00:26:21--> 00:26:26

So at this point in time, it sends some of his main

00:26:27--> 00:26:41

companions to will Kufa in order to rally the troops in order to gain support. Because you have an army being built up in the Basilica. A lot of people do join a shuttle Hans's battle, of course from the bustle ends.

00:26:42--> 00:27:15

So it gathers the troops and when he's trying to gather troops from from Kufa, Abu Musab ashari, who is Alys representative and in Kufa tries to prevent this from happening. He says my Bay Area is the bay upon my neck is my battle with mine. And my halifa got killed. And we will fight we will join this battle after you kill the killers of Earth one. And this is narrated by a buddy

00:27:17--> 00:27:34

Amar. And it hasn't been and it hasn't entirely. They in a very, very famous Hadith insider Buhari. They rally together some troops as well. And I believe Mr. It goes on to the member. And he says the very very famous Hadith he says that Alisha

00:27:35--> 00:27:50

is the wife of your prophet in gender. However, however, Allah wants to see, are you going to follow him? Or are you going to follow her? This is how Amar

00:27:51--> 00:27:57

saw it. And basically, you had a lot of people who joined early due to this

00:27:59--> 00:28:04

and it at that point in time enters the art which is between the muscle and Kufa.

00:28:07--> 00:28:19

Now we have to go back to a cool a bit Jeremy's rendition. Mashallah, it's a good report any a couple of pages long, small fonts, so

00:28:20--> 00:28:21

great information.

00:28:23--> 00:28:45

Now quill ape says that he actually meets it and he actually meets them both. He meets him it's first of all he meets the shuttle has where he meets it been a pilot, and it sends him gives him some letters, he asks him, Are you the CEO of the funeral home? Are you the leader of your tribe? And he says, No, I'm not. There are some people that are more

00:28:47--> 00:29:04

higher than me in rank, but I am someone who's accepted him from amongst my people. So I asked him to send some letters to the tribe of vinyasa and the tribe of Benny Kodama and kill Abel. Gerald L. Jeremy accepts. And before he does this,

00:29:05--> 00:29:07

he asks early, how do you feel about earthman?

00:29:09--> 00:29:22

Now before even even before I was even able to answer, his people started to curse, Othman and Kool Aid says I could see in his face that he hated this entirely. On the other hand, he would praise

00:29:23--> 00:29:24

When this happens,

00:29:26--> 00:29:34

which also suggests something, it shows that it doesn't really have complete control over everything that's happening.

00:29:38--> 00:29:54

Now, one of the two letters that Calais brings to the tribes, again, these are bustle and tribes, one is accepted and one is rejected. So basically, what you have is you do have some bursaries, who do eventually end up with Alli.

00:29:56--> 00:29:59

So the the army as well has

00:30:00--> 00:30:17

jubair are completely bustling. While the army Valley is a mix, mainly of coupons, but you do have some facilities as well. So now there's some discussions that occur between the camps between the camps off Ali and Papa Bear. So for the sake of

00:30:19--> 00:30:25

clarity, I'm going to be referring to the camp of it as the cufon camp and the camp off the bat as the bustling camp.

00:30:27--> 00:30:39

And abus goes to Isabel. And he says that it was really unjust to you, did it wrong you in any way? Why are you doing this? And as Rebecca says, This is due

00:30:40--> 00:31:10

to fear. And this is due to greed, implying but it was Alys fear that caused him to act in this way. And Sally's greed, the cause, in fact, in this way, I mean, you have to accept this from Isabel. But this is this is Roberto's point of view, this is the best justification, at least fear from the killers of Batman and his greed for khilafah. And this is not this is not a problem to to believe that the Sahaba wanted high positions that they wanted.

00:31:11--> 00:31:16

rule this is not this is not controversial at all. It's human nature.

00:31:19--> 00:31:20

Significant labor,

00:31:21--> 00:31:22

between

00:31:23--> 00:31:33

between between muscle and this is this is this is I think this is an example if I'm not mistaken, which is closer to the Basilica.

00:31:34--> 00:31:37

Okay, so the discussions lasts for three days.

00:31:38--> 00:31:42

And during this time a man comes to Isabel and this isn't wasn't

00:31:44--> 00:31:53

a man comes to Tibet and recording. Okay, so a man comes to the bear, and he says to this bear, I have an idea.

00:31:55--> 00:32:03

I'm going to kill alley for you, basically. So Zubair says, How can you kill it, it has an army with him. It's impossible to kill it. So the man says,

00:32:04--> 00:32:06

I will join this ranks.

00:32:07--> 00:32:21

And I will act as if I'm one of them. And then I'm going to betray alien I'm going to kill him. And Zubair prevents them from doing this. And he quotes the Heidi thermosensors lm in which also some prohibits killing a woman through treacherous means.

00:32:22--> 00:32:23

muscle damage.

00:32:25--> 00:32:26

Now, kool aid

00:32:28--> 00:32:29

is very, very interesting.

00:32:30--> 00:32:48

NARRATION by Kool Aid, he says that, when he went to when he went to meet the cool friends, there, they came to him and they were laughing, and they're like, Is it really possible that the bus runs are going to fight us? These are our brothers inshallah, when we sit down with them, when we meet them, everything is going to be fine.

00:32:49--> 00:32:56

The idea that's a word of war would break out was not even something that anyone expected.

00:32:57--> 00:33:00

He went back to the bustle, and he spoke with bustling.

00:33:01--> 00:33:05

And they'd say, What did the coffin say? And they said, Tell us what's going to reconcile.

00:33:06--> 00:33:14

So nothing was expected at all. And then Kool Aid talks about how the battle started. He said, first of all,

00:33:15--> 00:33:19

the boys young boys from both camps came out, and they started to

00:33:20--> 00:33:36

curse each other. And then they would throw stones at each other. And then the slaves from both camps came out and started to do the same. They started to curse each other. And then the idiots super hot. They came and they started to do the same. And all of a sudden, it was a battle.

00:33:38--> 00:33:47

It wasn't something that was intended. Now, what's the proof for this? This is bad. It's something very interesting. They've been working on who is with alley.

00:33:48--> 00:33:51

He says the bustling started the battle.

00:33:52--> 00:33:53

Okay.

00:33:56--> 00:33:57

Who's with who?

00:33:59--> 00:34:04

Nope, he's also with a la. He said, I really started the battle.

00:34:05--> 00:34:09

You have people, you have two different people, both with Ellie

00:34:11--> 00:34:15

contradicting each other in regards to who started the battle.

00:34:16--> 00:34:17

Alice said.

00:34:21--> 00:34:36

He said to me, this will happen when he saw this happening. He said, I see the people have started to march against one another. And I see no hair on this and hasn't said be quiet. If they hear us, they will kill us.

00:34:38--> 00:34:39

Referring to the people around him.

00:34:41--> 00:34:44

And they will say you have began to doubt

00:34:46--> 00:34:47

Muslims are going to be Schaber.

00:34:51--> 00:34:56

Now, what's happened to palha so the battle basically started

00:34:57--> 00:34:59

and this is one of the more controversial things

00:35:00--> 00:35:21

happened in the battle. So tal has tried to hold the forces back. He's trying to hold his men back from completely breaking out and going, you know, into a full fledged battle mode. And Paul has tries to stop them tries to slow things down they start to throw stones at him and then he's shots

00:35:22--> 00:35:26

with an arrow by Marwan will hack him.

00:35:28--> 00:35:29

Now what's strange about this?

00:35:33--> 00:35:44

Yes, yes, that's the strange thing but one bill hack him is with palha he's with the buslines and he shoots

00:35:45--> 00:35:56

and this is reported by alpha Larrabee. I've been Siri in case if anybody has them and Geraldine AB Sephora, Sephora. Yeah have been sades uncle. So contemporary sources.

00:35:58--> 00:36:05

Five Five tambourine, all narrators now you can argue that this is weak. But

00:36:08--> 00:36:11

I personally I'm personally not convinced. I think that if you haven't seen

00:36:12--> 00:36:19

and then you have you know the mama turban and you have placement of the husband who most likely was there. And you have three other

00:36:21--> 00:36:23

one uncle few have been saved. I believe being

00:36:24--> 00:36:28

an eyewitness as well. It's fair to say that my Womble haccombe did kill Bella

00:36:30--> 00:36:34

the reason why he killed her any Any guesses?

00:36:39--> 00:36:40

No.

00:36:48--> 00:36:48

worries

00:36:50--> 00:36:56

the reason why Marwan kills foil hat is because they'll have did not do enough to save us money.

00:37:00--> 00:37:03

So Marwan held that grudge within him.

00:37:05--> 00:37:06

Now Isabel

00:37:07--> 00:37:14

was approached by an Ibis, this is before the battle even begins, and they've been obsessed to Zubair.

00:37:18--> 00:37:21

What would Sophie have been Abdulmutallab say

00:37:22--> 00:37:24

if she saw you fighting,

00:37:25--> 00:37:28

as he been every time when I've been with pilot

00:37:30--> 00:37:30

who's Sofia,

00:37:31--> 00:37:33

Zoomers mother.

00:37:34--> 00:37:37

And when Zubair heard this,

00:37:38--> 00:37:41

he just left. He left the battlefield.

00:37:42--> 00:37:46

And he headed over to Addis Ababa, which is very close by

00:37:47--> 00:37:50

and he was basically killed by unproven GMOs.

00:37:52--> 00:37:59

Now, what is about today, in Iraq's new bussola the whole city is called the zoo ban, by the way.

00:38:03--> 00:38:06

Also, this narration is narrated by besides

00:38:08--> 00:38:31

our budget when I busted my bus went to Allah and he said, Where is the killer or to where will the killer of Zubair go, and that he said for not in hellfire. So even though they were on opposing sides, there was a clarity in this, I really did see that the killers are bad was from the people of hellfire.

00:38:32--> 00:38:34

Now, one of the

00:38:37--> 00:38:39

perhaps one of the more emotional

00:38:40--> 00:38:42

events that occurs in Yemen

00:38:44--> 00:38:50

is the martyrdom of Hamad bin palha, who they used to call a sad Judd because he was an avid

00:38:52--> 00:38:53

Mohammed bin Bhabha.

00:38:54--> 00:39:14

When he saw that everything was chaotic, he went to Russia who was on the camel covered, of course in the house edge. And he said to her Yama, or something along those lines, The Omen momineen. And she said to him, be like the best of the two sons of Adam.

00:39:16--> 00:39:20

And when he heard this, he put his sword away.

00:39:21--> 00:39:25

And he defended himself with his hands and was martyred.

00:39:31--> 00:39:39

The reports in poverty mentions that Hirsch's heritage was filled with arrows spears

00:39:40--> 00:39:55

and Hamad bin obika and ammonia, so they finally got to a German they got to the actual Campbell and they cut off its legs. And that's how the battle ended. When the Campbell of Arusha was killed. The battle basically ended

00:39:59--> 00:39:59

yes

00:40:02--> 00:40:04

So they attack the camel basically to end the battle.

00:40:06--> 00:40:12

It's not just ends of the battle, because Zubaydah is dead or Isabella is gone, Bo has killed.

00:40:13--> 00:40:35

Like there's no there's no other symbol left. I by the way I shall is not the commander, I she's not the commander of the army. I was there for moral support, I should assemble. But she's not she's not a commander of the battle I shot is actually she's covered away from the bounce, she doesn't see what's going on in the first place.

00:40:36--> 00:40:50

So basically, when when the bat, towards the end of the battle alley shouted out, don't chase those who are retreating. If there's someone who was injured, don't kill that person. If someone goes into a house, don't enter that house.

00:40:52--> 00:40:56

So those are the Those were his rules. Basically,

00:40:57--> 00:40:59

it of course prevented the

00:41:01--> 00:41:04

the victors the coffins, from taking

00:41:05--> 00:41:23

the women as captives as well. And in the reports, I'm not sure about the authenticity of this report. I think it is authentic with low lm. They said, they said to him, you are allowing us to take away their lives, but you don't allow us to take away their women. So and then he said, Who wants to take away the wife Rasul Allah.

00:41:24--> 00:41:24

So

00:41:25--> 00:41:27

of course, that ended it basically.

00:41:30--> 00:41:44

They real, they all realize that they are in the wrong and this is not something that can happen. So kill a bill kill a bill, Jeremy says is very interesting. He says, By the time I got to rally, the battle had already entered.

00:41:46--> 00:41:49

This implies a signifies the battle was very short.

00:41:51--> 00:42:04

And in the reports that we saw from the VA, but the battle lasts from war to matter, but it's not something that lasted for months, or years. It was a few hours long, the whole battle,

00:42:05--> 00:42:08

the number of bacillary that were killed

00:42:10--> 00:42:11

Any ideas?

00:42:20--> 00:42:21

2500.

00:42:24--> 00:42:32

But you know, that's, it's nice that you had the small numbers in mind, because some reports say 20,000 30,000.

00:42:34--> 00:42:40

So yeah, the most authentic report says 2517 out of me says 10,000

00:42:43--> 00:42:53

Yeah, good question. Shall I'll get to that. And do remind me if I forget. Also some things that I forgot to mention safe but I'm going to tell him he says that the discussions the negotiations between

00:42:54--> 00:43:04

the the coffins and the bustle ins lasted for a day. In reality, they lasted for three days. So if we don't want to say he says the battle started at nights, the battle started at

00:43:06--> 00:43:06

shukran

00:43:11--> 00:43:24

there's nothing about the night, all that night stuff. That's all the love and service stuff. So forget about that. This thing happened during the day. So quick analysis. Why did the coffins when

00:43:31--> 00:43:32

Mashallah a three out of three today.

00:43:34--> 00:43:48

Okay, so the so the leaders that the general thought, I'll have By the way, he's he's running the cavalry, okay, he's leading the Calvary, he gets killed, Isabella leaves the buffalo immediately. There are no leaders. Well, there are leaders but the two main leaders are basically that

00:43:51--> 00:43:58

lives with Eileen versus with Allie. Yes. Okay. So some other some other things.

00:44:01--> 00:44:20

Now, it seems like in one report and stuff and let me say but it implies that the bus ones were reassured and they they expected they expected it less to happen. There was a bad there, there was an agreement, there was General peace, no one's prepared for war. So that's another reason why

00:44:21--> 00:44:22

things ended so quickly.

00:44:23--> 00:44:33

And there seems to be another reason and I haven't seen anyone argue this, but it seems like the bus lines were smaller number

00:44:35--> 00:44:52

according to and hate them, but I do not hate them. And it is a terrible source By the way, but it seems like he got it right when it came to the numbers of men on both on both sides. He argues 12,000 for the coupons, and 8000 for the bus lines. So 50% more.

00:44:53--> 00:45:00

Now the reason I believe this is because you have some reports, one in subway shut off the other I believe

00:45:00--> 00:45:00

In

00:45:01--> 00:45:34

tabari, from humble hanafy, at the son of alley, which state in the narration and submission of states that the coffins were 12,000. So it hit them and it was correct in one number. I do believe that that means that he was most likely correct and the other number, meaning the bathrooms were 4000 less. And also keep in mind that the army finally had coupons and bustle ins, while the bustling army was just bustling. So it's logical that they'd have a larger number.

00:45:36--> 00:45:46

We're almost done guys. reactions. What were the reactions of those that took part in the battle? They had been so hon. Does this name ring a bell?

00:45:51--> 00:45:56

They've been so hung was one of those that that was exiled by earthman.

00:45:58--> 00:46:03

Now as it was so hands on his deathbed, and they said I'm sorry, about salmaan agenda.

00:46:04--> 00:46:15

Glad tidings yarrabah salmaan. The agenda Chava is where you're going to go. And he says, We don't know. We don't know we came to a land. We killed the mayor.

00:46:18--> 00:46:22

And it would have been best if we just were patient when we were oppressed.

00:46:26--> 00:46:29

This is an pubblicato inside Arusha.

00:46:31--> 00:46:32

on her deathbed,

00:46:33--> 00:46:39

she said bury me, with the wives of Rasulullah. Saw Selim, because I did something after him.

00:46:41--> 00:46:44

Applying her participation in this fitna.

00:46:46--> 00:46:47

I'd been there before Allah

00:46:48--> 00:46:53

used to say, I wish I died before this by 20 pilgrimages

00:46:56--> 00:47:00

I'd have been a bit while I was approached by embrun, palha, the son of Allah.

00:47:01--> 00:47:02

And

00:47:04--> 00:47:17

as he said, in Sha, Allah, me and your brother, me and your father, are from those that a law said about them. When is that in a mafia, so dirty him mineral?

00:47:18--> 00:47:21

One and Allah sorauren with Abilene.

00:47:23--> 00:47:29

And we will remove from their chests, any bitterness, brothers

00:47:30--> 00:47:33

facing each other upon Thrones.

00:47:34--> 00:47:36

When he said this a man from him done.

00:47:38--> 00:47:45

When he said this, a man from him done said, Allah is more fair than to do this, than to put both of you in gender.

00:47:46--> 00:47:47

And the alley said,

00:47:49--> 00:47:51

then who is it about?

00:47:52--> 00:47:56

Who are these verses about if it's not about me and about her.

00:47:59--> 00:48:00

And now

00:48:01--> 00:48:05

we get to the end of jemelle.

00:48:07--> 00:48:23

And the most ironic thing in the jemelle, and the whole scenario and all the events, which is, in my opinion, one of the main characters of a gentleman, that I didn't bring up yet, any ideas who I'm referring to

00:48:31--> 00:48:33

an STL. Okay.

00:48:34--> 00:48:37

And ashtar was a relative of Calais, Jeremy

00:48:39--> 00:48:42

and Calais. Now, Lester got hurt in the battle.

00:48:44--> 00:48:50

He says, and this is a very, very famous narration. He was he was in the battle, he was fighting with them.

00:48:51--> 00:49:11

And basically, they clash with one another and then and then they start to wrestle one another, and they start to like roll on the floor. And Abdur Rahman said, kill me and kill Malik kill me and kill Malik. And people had no idea who Moloch was. Everyone knows that he doesn't know knows his name is Malik. So basically,

00:49:12--> 00:49:16

an ester survived because of that confusion.

00:49:17--> 00:49:21

So while he was injured, Caleb said to him,

00:49:25--> 00:49:42

yeah, I shall give, you know, give the mayor of Basra I put a good word in for me, basically. And then he said when the mayor of El bussola says you don't worry about it, your your matters will be fine.

00:49:44--> 00:49:59

Now he was saying Kool Aid says bill Ashdown felt that he was going to become the mayor for bussola and he was going to appoint them as they may have been possible. So Calais left the room, and a man came and he said

00:50:00--> 00:50:07

The mayor has appointed a blob and a bus as the representative of early on bussola

00:50:08--> 00:50:10

Kool Aid goes back. He says

00:50:13--> 00:50:17

I've been a bus is the representative

00:50:19--> 00:50:37

alleged are basically shouts at him and then another man comes in affirming this and less steps as you hear it. He says no I didn't hear it. And then I tub will definitely be comes in and he confirms this.

00:50:39--> 00:50:42

And Esther says

00:50:44--> 00:50:45

on the lemon

00:50:46--> 00:50:49

Obaidullah been a bus

00:50:51--> 00:50:54

on Hejaz authen been a bus.

00:50:56--> 00:51:01

On bus surah Abdullah bin a bus on Kufa alley

00:51:04--> 00:51:05

Why did we kill the chef in Medina

00:51:12--> 00:51:21

Fela nidri Allah ma Katana Shaban Medina. We don't know why we killed the shift in Medina, if this is how it's going to be.

00:51:25--> 00:51:27

And I'm not even going to comment on that.

00:51:30--> 00:51:30

What happened?