Authority of the Sunnah – Part 3

share this pageShare Page
Hacene Chebbani

Channel: Hacene Chebbani

Episode Notes

Episode Transcript

© No part of this transcript may be copied or referenced or transmitted in any way whatsoever. Transcripts are auto-generated and thus will be be inaccurate. We are working on a system to allow volunteers to edit transcripts in a controlled system.


00:00:00--> 00:00:07

hamdu Lillahi Rabbil alameen wa salatu salam ala Sayidina Muhammad wa ala alihi wa sahbihi Ishmael.

00:00:09--> 00:00:14

So tonight inshallah we'll be dealing with the same subject, the authority of the center.

00:00:15--> 00:00:30

And then at the end of sha Allah who will talk a little bit about Bihari, and what some other people are saying about Sahih Bukhari. Those who have a good intention, and those who have an evil intention.

00:00:32--> 00:00:38

But before that, we need to talk about the compilation of the Hadees during the time of the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam,

00:00:39--> 00:00:55

because there are many people who don't believe in the authority of the Sunnah. They said the sooner was only written down in the third century, or maybe 100 years, 150 years after the death of our Prophet Muhammad sallallahu alayhi wa sallam,

00:00:56--> 00:00:59

no soul, butterflies, I sell them.

00:01:00--> 00:01:01

Of course,

00:01:03--> 00:01:06

he did not read and write.

00:01:07--> 00:01:37

Allah subhanaw taala did not give him this ability for a purpose for a good purpose. For good purpose. If he was someone who was able to read and write, then many people will say what they will claim that he wrote the book. He just met some Christians and some Jews, he learned about the stories of the prophets and messengers, and he wrote the book himself. So now illiteracy, or not being able to read and write is in his favor as a messenger of God.

00:01:40--> 00:02:08

By now, we'll talk about the compilation of the Hadees there are some dictations from Rasulullah sallallahu wasallam, will dictate to some other survivors and they would write whatever he tells them to write. One of the things that he used to dictate to his companions is some books that he would send to his Governor's amend method. And he This is a famous book, the book of sadaqa. He wrote it to his governors. He wanted to send it to his governors at the end of his life.

00:02:09--> 00:02:24

And he left it in his house he was planning to send it to the other cities and other provinces. It is founded sooner, maybe there are other sources of Hadith, but he died before that. So who received this book, I will walk so they call the Allahu Allah.

00:02:25--> 00:02:27

And he acted upon this book.

00:02:29--> 00:03:18

Right It will add the sadaqa here what it means. It means zakat. Zakat is called mandatory sadaqa. Allah Subhana Allah and sort of Toba says in Masada to linfoot Cora, and he's talking Ally's talking about the cat in the a 60 if you go to is 60. It tells us about the recipients of Zakat, those who are eligible to receive the cat, right, Allah subhanho wa Taala does not use the term Zakat in this ayah he used the term solder cart which is the plural of setup. So here when we say the book of sadaqa it's a script that Russell Lysa Selim wrote about the rules of solder as a cat, but he did not write it himself. He would ask one of his companions most likely obey, you know, cap, or some

00:03:18--> 00:04:08

other sahabas he had around 30 people around him Who were they were helping him out he saw out to a seller all the time writing either the Quran or writing some other method, a hadith or other books with her in some letters that he sent to other kings and other leaders. So one of them is this book, his famous book of South Africa, and one worker of Saudi Arabia low and who died when he passed away. He passed it to Oman, we hopped up and I will use the term hot tub usually during his collapse of the Allahu anhu. He acted upon him until he passed away. And then who was taking care of this book, his son Abdullah his his children, I believe, no matter and, and, and then Salim Abdullah who

00:04:08--> 00:04:24

was the grand son of Mr. Malhotra and Tilly, Mr. Missouri. He was a great scholar. At that time he died in the year 124. After the digital financial loss SLM, received this book, and he used to teach it to his students.

00:04:25--> 00:04:59

We have also the script of amueblado has this book was very famous at that time. That's all I sell them, send it to his governor, when Yemen was conquered, or it became under the rule of Muslims. Also last SLM sent to them Americano hasn't his companion with the Allahu anhu as a governor, and he sent to him a book. Of course, it was written by one of his companions. But this book is famous. Many scholars said it's mutawatir mutawatir means it was known by

00:05:00--> 00:05:36

great number of scholars have Sahaba. So there was no need to look into the chain of narration, the chain of transmission of this book. We got also what is called the written directives to other governors, this doctor here Hamidullah, he has a book a lower fat EPA cscl, the government documents and he counted in his book around 141 documents. So those government documents were dictated by the prophets, Allah law and it was sent to his governors in the different areas and provinces.

00:05:38--> 00:05:43

Tie so all these books were written during the time of Rasulullah sallallahu wasallam.

00:05:44--> 00:05:51

Now, also, we have something called written directives for certain delegations Who are these people.

00:05:52--> 00:06:01

After Makkah, became a Muslim city after the conquest of Mecca in the year in the eighth year after the hegira of Rasulullah. Selim,

00:06:02--> 00:06:27

the different tribes in the Arabian Peninsula, who are watching, they were watching the conflict between the Muslims in Medina, and between the Americans. And of course, at that time, they used to respect the American people. They used to recognize their leadership. They are the custodians of Al Haram. They used to look at them as the descendants of Abraham La Silla.

00:06:28--> 00:06:46

So this is how the US to treat the Americans who were highly respected in the Arabian Peninsula. And now one of them who is Mohammed sallallahu alayhi wa sallam claimed that he is a prophet, and he's a messenger of God, and He has a conflict with his own people. And he left to the city of Medina.

00:06:47--> 00:07:06

And there was this conflict between the mccanns and the people of Medina, the Muslims of Medina, right. So the Arab tribes were just watching. Some of them, of course, help the mccanns they were involved with them in boycotting Medina to certain time some of them

00:07:07--> 00:07:51

participated in the Battle of 100. But all of them were defeated. No, they were not victorious and hamdulillah Allah Subhana, Allah saved Muslims. So in the eighth year, of the hatred of Rasulullah sallallahu, the Muslims were able to enter Mecca, an army of 10,000 Muslims, were able to enter Mecca now Makkah, who is the religious center in the Arabian Peninsula became under the rule of Mohammed Salah Salem and his companions. So now the rest of the Arabs decided that he must be a true messenger of God. He's one of those mannequins, and he's still respecting the harem. He's still respecting Makkah he did not bring a new religion.

00:07:52--> 00:08:36

Not so the V used to think that they were following actually the religion of Ibrahim La Silla. Now they realize that Muhammad sallallahu alayhi wa sallam came to rectify the religion of Ibrahim Ali Salah. Right? He did not bring a new religion. It was easy for them to accept Mohammed Salim as a prophet as a messenger of God and as a leader. So they started sending what delegations every tribe, will appoint a group of people who said you go to El Medina, you meet the Messenger of Allah, you stay in Medina for 20 days for a month for two months. You study the Quran, you learn about Islam, and then you come back to us and you teach us Islam. That was their job.

00:08:37--> 00:09:23

And it is called in the books of Syrah. It's called the Emmylou food. The year of the delegation. That was two years maybe before his death, le Salatu was Salam in the knife year after the seizure of Rasul, Lysa Silla. So these people start coming from different places. Some of them individuals will decide to go and go and meet a prophet Mohammed Salim in Medina, as sometimes some tribes would send a group of people, and they are called wufu delegations. So some of them were kings were leaders in their people like what he did. He came from Yemen here. He was a leader, he was a kink in his people, and then he came to us with less accepted Islam. He was very happy, actually told us how

00:09:23--> 00:09:29

this guy will come one night before he came in have phones didn't have any way of

00:09:31--> 00:09:59

any means of transmission of communication at that time, right. But he knew it was a way from Allah subhanho wa Taala knew that this man is coming. He came accepted Islam and he gave him three documents. One of them was personal. The other two were sent to his own people to teach them about these documents. They contain some rules about salaat about Zakat about Islam in general. Right. And some of them were about some issues that they had in their local area.

00:10:00--> 00:10:08

Right, some drinks that they had and sort of soulless, excellent gave them the rulings regarding this issues right? These are ahaadeeth this is not karate.

00:10:10--> 00:10:21

These are hadith of Rasulullah sallallahu wasallam would ask obey no capital write down this document and send them to this people motive below here. And also he came for from Abdullah case another tribe.

00:10:22--> 00:10:27

He came he Metro. So last SLM, he asked for a document. So

00:10:29--> 00:10:35

the it was written for him. And he took it to his people. But he didn't want to read it for them.

00:10:36--> 00:11:19

He was not one of the leaders, his father in law was a leader in the Kabira. So he did what he he did not show them that book, because they were not Muslims. But he worked on his father in law. When he his father in law became Muslim, it was very happy he gave him the book, said you read it to them. This is a message from Rasulullah sallallahu wasallam. Now his father in law stood up and he said, This is what the law says Selim sent to you. And he read the book, and this is how the if not poorer, right. And then they became all Muslims, all of them because one of the leaders accepted Islam. So it was easy for them to accept Islam. Another example, the delegation of the tribe of

00:11:19--> 00:11:28

Mohammed became, and the state was also lost. I sell him for a short period of time. And he said, Yes, we'll Allah we need something, writing

00:11:29--> 00:11:50

something, a document so we can take you to our people. And he again, he commanded or requested from obey, obey minicabee requested available capital, right? Something for them. He told her what to write. And he took it with them. And there are some other delegations who had the same thing. Who did the same thing. They said, people, as I said, you know,

00:11:52--> 00:12:09

I'm not sure if these documents were included in the 141 that were collected by Dr. Hamidullah. I'm not sure about that. But these are some sort of official documents coming from Russell as I sell them and sent to other tribes and other people in different areas in the Arabian Peninsula.

00:12:10--> 00:12:19

So anyone who says yeah I need the The sooner was not laughing from the sooner was written down during the life of our Prophet Mohammed Salim. He will be making What

00:12:21--> 00:12:21

now?

00:12:23--> 00:13:05

a false statement. Yeah, he will be making a false statement. Anyone who says this is something to begin with. So never never think we'll say that nothing from the sooner was written down during the life of our Prophet Mohammed Salah. Now, the compilations of Hadith by some companions that are the lower animal have Abdullah Ramadan, as I told you the story, some people told him, how come you are writing everything that Rasulullah saw Selim says and he's just a human being. Yeah, we recognize that he's a human being but he was a messenger of God. Right. But this is their statement at that time those people are that was their understanding. He might be angry and say something out of

00:13:05--> 00:13:11

anger. So the man's that this not this cannot be considered part of why he right.

00:13:12--> 00:13:29

Abdullah Amara thought that he maybe they had a good point. I told you about historia de la and I'm Ross, and he went to Russia last I sent him and he told him about what what these people said. So he said he pointed to his mouth le salatu wa sallam

00:13:30--> 00:13:37

he said will levy nephew Mohammad in beard la rue Minho, lol. He said by the one

00:13:39--> 00:13:54

who the soul of Mohammed is in his hand was the last panel to Allah right? Nothing comes out from this mouth except the truth. So write down and continue writing. So he wrote something called a Sahiba. Assad.

00:13:55--> 00:14:00

He called it a cipher cipher descriptive of truth, or the truthful script.

00:14:01--> 00:14:04

Mujahid Mujahid was a great professor.

00:14:05--> 00:14:25

Those who study to see you know who is Mujahid. He is one of the famous student of Abdullah at best but he was a student of Abdullah grammar class and he used to go to his house. And he used to read this this scrolls and these scripts that Abdullah us collected from the hadith of Rasulullah saw Salaam right.

00:14:26--> 00:14:34

And one time he found this one. This Asahi facade under a pillow or something he wanted to take it Mujahid

00:14:36--> 00:14:47

and Abdullah Ahmed, he said so stop, don't take it. Don't touch it, please. He said you never stopped me from anything. I mean, you shared everything with me. That's his student.

00:14:48--> 00:14:59

He said no. Yeah, they'll tell you something. You know, I called it a Sunday for Savita all the ahaadeeth in the script, all of them. I collected directly I wrote them directly from Russell

00:15:00--> 00:15:43

As I said them, there is no other narrator between Me, me and him. That means sometimes you will take it from another Sahabi. Another Sahabi would be sitting down with him, it would hear added from Rasulullah Salim and then after a few days he would meet Abdullah and he would tell him about the Headey. So there is a narrative between Rasul Allah says Allah and Abdullah, last, but here in this script, he said, No, no one was between me and him. These are handy. I took them directly from Rasul Allah as I sell them. So this is a special book, don't touch it, please. And then he made the statement. He said, If the book of Allah subhanaw taala. And this script of truth, and a piece of

00:15:43--> 00:16:06

land, he used to call it and will have an agricultural land. He said, If these three are are secured for me, I don't care about what's happening to the rest of the world. He says, I don't care these three things, the Book of Allah, this script, the truthful script, and maip, the his piece of land his land, it was his source of income may be allowed to our land.

00:16:07--> 00:16:14

Anyway, so you're the historian, he said that this script of truth contained around 1000 hadiths

00:16:16--> 00:16:44

and a subpoena Malik may Allah be pleased with him. There are some reports that he had some notebooks in which he collected some Hadith some of his students said, when we insisted upon Anissa bumalik, and we keep you know, asking him about the Hadith and we annoy him a little bit, he would go to his notebooks and show them that these are the notebooks that they got from Russia last lesson. But I have to be honest with you here. And as you know, Malik, the reports that I checked and not authentic.

00:16:46--> 00:17:02

So they were not classified as authentic reports. The reason the only reason I included this information about NSV pneumonic in this presentation is just because this Hadeeth or this story is found in mustard, Rachael Hakim

00:17:03--> 00:17:51

in a book and it was not able to verify this report in mustard, Oracle hockey, which could be authentic over there along to Alan, because we when we when we talk about historical hacking. We also talk about the comments of the amount of the heavy amount of heavy, he reviewed the book of hacking, and after is each Friday he would either agree with a hacker or disagree with him, and who reviewed the work of the heavy lm a Sheffield l Bernie Rahmatullah alley. So we have a three works here. three layers of security. We have Lima been hacking, Lima, Valerie and Sheffield Advani Rama to lionni I did not have time to verify this report in that source. So I said it could be it doesn't

00:17:51--> 00:18:38

affect the conclusion of this presentation. Whether NSW Malik had some you know, some ahaadeeth in a written form or he didn't have it doesn't make a big difference. We have the script of jabiru Abdullah may Allah be pleased with him in our Muslim he narrated from this script is called a they used to call it sahifa jabber and Abdullah he narrated there are 30 Hadees within the chapter of hedge only the chapter of hedge. No we have although we have solid we have cm we have hedge we have marriage we have divorce we have you know politics we have seen we have many things right many chapters in the book of Heidi. In the chapter of hedge only an Imam Muslim narrated from the cipher

00:18:38--> 00:18:41

the cipher of Jabir ibn Abdullah around 30 hadiths

00:18:42--> 00:19:10

I didn't know he thought he had his own script, some more unusual and some other scholars. Here the purpose is not to, you know, collect the names of the sahabas and, and try to, you know, collect this information. The purpose of this presentation is to say that these are habits so hobbies were allowed to write down a hadith and it was written during the time of Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wasallam.

00:19:13--> 00:19:19

Now, here, we have something called official or the first official order to collect headaches.

00:19:21--> 00:19:25

And this official order was made by Omar Abdullah xizor the Alon

00:19:26--> 00:19:28

Omar Abdul Aziz was

00:19:30--> 00:19:36

was an immediate Calif Yeah, and he was not he's not is different than Omar.

00:19:38--> 00:19:44

He died in the year one a one after the history of Rasulullah sallallahu ellefson.

00:19:45--> 00:19:59

But he was a wonderful Calif. A wonderful leader. Many people many scholars classify him as the sixth rightly guided caliphs who are the other five abubaker

00:20:01--> 00:20:02

Mr. Motta,

00:20:05--> 00:20:08

an algebra Vitara who is number five

00:20:09--> 00:20:09

now

00:20:12--> 00:20:14

Allison Mashallah

00:20:15--> 00:21:02

hasn't even rallied we thought if he ruled for around six to eight months so that's the fifth rightly guided Calif. And then of course we had the the kingdom of omega or the caliphate of Bernie omiya. Among them is Omar bin Abdulaziz. He's the one who gave the first official order to he sent a letter to his governor of Medina. His name is Abu Bakr and he was the grandson of amaroo hasm. The Sahaba, who was a ruler, a governor over Yemen, as well as SLM sent him that letter, right. I mentioned in the first slide, second slide or the third slide. So he was his grandson during the rule of Omar Abdul Aziz, he was the governor of Medina I sent him this letter, start collecting the

00:21:02--> 00:21:16

hadith of Rasul Allah says Allah Morita, the sooner will be lost. That was his reason. Right? So who was heavily involved in this process and Mmm, even though she had wizardry, who's who died in the year 124.

00:21:17--> 00:21:39

A Missouri was a great scholar who lived at the time and as he is used to trust him and trust his knowledge. So all of them with some other scholars from Medina, they were involved in the collection of the Hadeeth for soul as I said, it was a general collection without any classification system. What do I mean by that?

00:21:40--> 00:22:25

There are headings that are known the books of Hadith, the sources of Hadith that are known to people for say, Bahasa Muslims in an abdomen and telemovie. When you open the book, you find the chapter of fubu, the chapter of Salah, the chapter of Eman, the chapter of Ye, right. So all the Hadees that are related to weevil tawakkol related to Toba, they are classified and collected in one chapter, right? And how these methods that are related to uovo collected in one chapter. So this is what I mean these are the books of Hadith that we know we are familiar with. Now, during that time, they did not classify them, it was a general collection, whatever had if they knew about us from

00:22:25--> 00:23:01

Rasulullah sallallahu they will put it in some books, right and they were collecting this hadith in the second century now azuri died in the year 124. Now we're talking now we are done with the first century, the second century, a century, people started Muslim scholars started, you know, continue these efforts. They started continued collecting, you know, they had so we had in Makkah, someone called ibnu shoresh. Abdul Malik amateurish. His grandfather was a Roman. So, who accepted Islam, but he was right he was born in McCain

00:23:03--> 00:23:17

and he became one of the good scholars of Makkah. So, he he did some work with hops at Aruba in Medina, Imam Malik who died in 179. And he wrote his book, what is the title of his book?

00:23:18--> 00:23:39

And what is a famous book? It was written before Sahara Buhari before Sahara Buhari, but it was it was not only about the heady the statement from Lhasa Ceylon, it included the Hadees of Rasulullah Salim and non prophetic Hadees what are the non prophetic what is non prophetic Hadith

00:23:42--> 00:24:28

from so Hobbes and from Tabby in their students, so if a statement is coming from Sahaba we still call it a hadith but we call it Hadith malkuth. It's a terminology that the scholars of Hadith used to use. So when we say malkuth that means that Sahabi is not attributing the hadith of Rasulullah Salah it says it could be a statement of Abdullah at best was to hobby kebab so they say howdy mo Cuf. Imam Malik included some of these statements from the Sahaba and their student, the tambourine and his Hadith his book contained around 1700 to 1800 Hadees half of them were formulas from Lhasa sell them the other half was were from hobbies, and their students topiary.

00:24:30--> 00:24:38

We had Hamad bin Salah in Basra, in Kufa, we had Sofia theory, so Fianna 31 was of the best teachers of women Buhari.

00:24:39--> 00:24:45

So here we're talking about teachers and students taking from each other Buhari did not come from the street.

00:24:47--> 00:24:59

Buhari did not come he just wake up, woke up one day and say I'm gonna write a book about the Hades cell. He traveled in the land, he went to Baghdad, he went to different cities. He went to Mecca, he went and he met the scholars.

00:25:00--> 00:25:18

Spend time with them he studied under them. And then after he collected a huge amount of knowledge, he started collecting this book that was dedicated to the authentic hadith. So for us, Allah says Allah will tell you about what some people are saying about al Bukhari at the end.

00:25:19--> 00:25:27

a share we have a moment I was there in the area of a sham in Egypt, who had length of massage who lived during that time. So all these people continued,

00:25:28--> 00:25:35

with the exception of Mr. Malik, I don't know if the other scholars had books that are known or or printed nowadays.

00:25:37--> 00:25:56

I'm not sure some people will say 30 had a book left a book and it is found nowadays, but I'm not sure about it. I'm not sure about this information. But of course, everyone knows is familiar with the book of Lima Malik. Now, the third century compilation of the Hadees during the third century here the compilation flourished.

00:25:58--> 00:26:44

So the scholars learned from the other scholars who lived during the second century, right. These scholars he said we have to now organize the sooner for us, Allah says is a matter of organizing the wealth of knowledge that the collected from the other scholars, we had an Imam Mohammed who died in the year 241. He wrote his book and Muslim so huge collection of Hadith. But not everything is authentic. He did not mean to include only authentic Hadees. We had his help Nora who here who was the one of the teachers of Imam Bukhari, he wrote around six or seven books one of his famous books is in Muslim also. And Muslim when we say Muslim, we will come instead of classifying the Hadith

00:26:44--> 00:27:33

based on subjects worry revelation knowledge, Eman, faith salaat. Well don't know the classify the Hadith. Based on their narrators. The compact among the companions, they said this is the Muslims of Ababa Casa de so he will come to the hadith of Abu Bakar. So do all of them and he would put them and in one chapter, he would come to the Hadith narrated by Abdullah and he will put them into one chapter. This is what Mr. Mohammed did, what is happening or who he did. And then say mojari amendment Buhari, he wrote some other books before he wrote before he authored his or collected his books I hate Buhari, he wrote about the biographies of the narrators. And they are huge books made

00:27:33--> 00:27:56

of six seven volumes before he wrote his Buhari so he was familiar with the science, but he meant to include only authentic Hades in this site in his book and started collecting his book in the year 216 to 16. He was done in the year 232. I've talked about the history calendar here.

00:27:57--> 00:28:01

So it took him 16 years to complete this book.

00:28:02--> 00:28:07

To complete this book, so hail Buhari. Okay, now Muslim,

00:28:08--> 00:28:09

did the same thing.

00:28:10--> 00:28:13

He included only authentic hadith and in his side,

00:28:14--> 00:28:22

he imitated his teacher. Muslim, a Muslim is the student of an Imam Al Bukhari sulan Abu Dawood

00:28:23--> 00:28:31

died in the year 275. He did not mean to include only authentic hadith, some of them are weak.

00:28:32--> 00:28:57

And he he wrote a letter in introduction to his book to the people from Africa. before publishing his book, he sent a letter to the scholars of Mecca, telling them about his methodology in his book, and he did not claim in this letter that every head he thinks this book is authentic. They were honest, they would mess up and come to some Hadith. He said, this is the best headset that I have related to this topic.

00:28:58--> 00:29:01

I know it's not authentic, but this is what I have.

00:29:02--> 00:29:15

So he would include it and he will make a comment sometimes about it. About the headies. Same thing for NASA, he told me the independent measure, and some other some other books of Hadith.

00:29:18--> 00:29:27

We have some other books they are these are not the only ones we have most American hacking will have, as I said, Walter Malik, sunanda deryni we had

00:29:28--> 00:29:59

a ban we have we have Simon hoceima some other sources of Hadith. But this is not I mean, this is not a workshop meant to talk about in details about how we're dealing with one issue here. Some people are shedding some doubt, you know about the way the sooner was collected, and therefore attacking the sooner for less Excellent. So this is the purpose of this program that the sooner was collected during the time of our programs SLM and their odema had

00:30:00--> 00:30:04

Clear methodology when collecting the hadith of Rasul Allah says Allah.

00:30:06--> 00:30:08

Now let's talk a little bit about Buhari.

00:30:10--> 00:30:26

There are many people who will talk about Buhari these days believing, believing, and I this is what I feel. And this is the feeling of many scholars, many Muslim scholars. We believe that these people think that if the degrade if they are successful in degrading

00:30:28--> 00:30:39

or destroying the reputation of science Buhari, then we will be able to destroy the authority of the sooner. That's why we focus on Sahara Buhari.

00:30:40--> 00:30:44

Why? Because there was an agreement, there was a consensus by Muslim scholars.

00:30:46--> 00:30:59

Now, how do you reconcile Buhari there are more than 7000? More a little bit more, you don't reach 8000? Around 7600, I'm not sure about the exact number

00:31:00--> 00:31:08

if they are reduced. Yeah, without repetition, the Hadeeth around a little bit more than 2600

00:31:11--> 00:31:16

if you avoid repetition E and E, because somehow these will be mentioned in some in a chapter of

00:31:18--> 00:31:38

the same Hadeeth could be with a different chain of narration will be mentioned in the book of Salah for example. The same Hadith would be mentioned in a different chapter method Tafseer. Right. But this is what had he the end one meten one story some diversions could be a little bit different but is the same story the same Howdy.

00:31:39--> 00:31:43

Now is there a general agreement that every Hadith in Sahih Bukhari is authentic?

00:31:46--> 00:31:55

Here there is a problem. And to be honest with you, some Muslim scholars from international Jama have contributed into this problem.

00:31:56--> 00:32:15

There are suits to statement to statement here to say bother, as Martin Amato and as a hottie Murphy Sahih al Bukhari, the various is an agreement, a general agreement there is a consensus that every Hadith in Sahih al Bukhari is authentic.

00:32:16--> 00:32:20

Sometimes some of our Muslim scholars make the statement.

00:32:21--> 00:32:32

But there are some other scholars who are very careful, and they make a different statement. They're close very close to the first one. But it doesn't confuse people.

00:32:33--> 00:32:43

Which is the second one here. Are you able to see it? So the second one here, the one that is bold, there is a consensus between Muslim scholars I'm talking about Sunni Muslim scholars.

00:32:46--> 00:32:56

The scholars of Allah Suna will Gemma that Sahil Buhari is the most reliable source of Hadith. What is the difference between the two of them?

00:32:57--> 00:33:05

And they actually Moroccan oma to Allah Azza Hockeytown Halima Buhari. What is the difference between the two statement?

00:33:09--> 00:33:11

Do you see the difference? there is any difference?

00:33:13--> 00:33:35

So the first stage of his statement is not right, that every Hadith in Sahih al Bukhari is authentic. This is not right. Because we have some classical scholars with a good intention, using the principles of Hadith and the rules of Hadith. And they criticize some Hadith in Sahih Bukhari mama Dada corpening has an adult report a great scholar

00:33:36--> 00:33:39

from the pier from the city of Baghdad.

00:33:40--> 00:33:49

You know, this this scholar Mr. Derrick Courtenay, he has some books but he's not famous like Buhari because he didn't write a book like Bihar, but he was a great scholar.

00:33:50--> 00:33:55

He was an expert in this field he used to tell the people of Baghdad he said oh people

00:33:56--> 00:34:02

he said No One No One among you should have a wish that he can fabricate a heady

00:34:03--> 00:34:19

no or make up a lie against a certain lifestyle sell him I am here as long as I'm alive. He was very confident about his knowledge to the to the extent that he would approach his people and tell them don't dare Don't try to fabricate any Hadeeth

00:34:20--> 00:34:30

because there are some people who mean they used to fabricate a hadith for different reasons right. So, this this scholar, Muslim scholar about Hasson is respected scholar musala.

00:34:32--> 00:34:38

Some other scholars, she's well Barney in the in the in the contemporary scholar,

00:34:39--> 00:34:59

some of them criticised and I'll tell you about the groups of people who criticize Buhari and what was their intention and a difference between the two groups. So these are groups of scholars, they are qualified. They had the good intention. They do it with respect. They do it with respect and they criticized some of the Hadeeth some

00:35:00--> 00:35:13

A few ahaadeeth as I said, following the rules of Hadith 90 disagreed with a Buhari with respect. Their intention was not to degrade Sahih al Bukhari or to attack the authority of the sooner

00:35:14--> 00:35:41

so and he wouldn't make the statement. They recognize that there are some headings that could be criticized inside a bar. But we say the second statement is true. There is yes a consensus between Muslim scholars that say hey, Buhari is the most reliable source of Hadith as, as I said, Here, I'm saying, I'm talking about the Muslim scholars answer no Jamal, because there are some people. I'll tell you

00:35:43--> 00:36:02

what I would mention, usually I don't mention names, when I when I talk about the opinions of other people speakers will, but sometimes I think I should. There is a speaker a man who lives in Europe, his name is Adnan Ibrahim, he is known to the brothers who speak Arabic because his hotel bar in Arabic.

00:36:03--> 00:36:12

He is a and he has some knowledge he collected was able to read books and everything. But he's one of those who attacks saya Bukhari

00:36:13--> 00:36:17

and he made the hood were complete hood about about a Buhari

00:36:18--> 00:37:00

in many hotels actually in many hotels. He would criticize a Buhari one of one time he said our brothers from the zedi a Shia do not agree that saya Buhari is the most reliable source of honey. Our brothers from the army Shia do not agree with that cycle. Buhari is the most reliable source of Hadith. I mean, their agreement is not relevant. This is the answer of an assumed ojama. Why their agreement was disagreement. Why? Because these people they believe that it's not actually the mammy Shia. They believe that all the Sahaba became Kufa after the death of Rasulullah Salim except for seven or eight,

00:37:02--> 00:37:05

a share of the olana for many of them, she will be in Hellfire

00:37:07--> 00:37:18

to scaffold for them, or at least a sinful person over time, same thing. So if they don't believe in this habit, do you think they will accept their heads?

00:37:20--> 00:37:35

So they had a veto, they only take the hadith of Alabama every Parliament Fatima Zahra and their family those members from the family of the Prophet sallallahu wasallam or those who have his who believed six or seven did not make up for after the death of Rasul lies as well.

00:37:37--> 00:38:04

So when we when we talk about the status of Sahil Buhari, the opinion of the other sex is not very relative relevant. That's why we have to focus on our ruler man, the majority mainstream Muslims, the 80% or 90 or 90% of Muslims in the old days within half Shia at the time of Rasulullah sallallahu there was no Shia no is my new card here Nice. We didn't have sex. It was one

00:38:06--> 00:38:06

right?

00:38:08--> 00:38:29

So anyway, all to say also the most correct book after the Quran is okay. The most correct book after the Quran was that we're not saying it is like the Quran after the Quran. There is no doubt that the Quran is the book of Allah subhanho wa Taala right and everything in the Quran is true and authentic. But after the Quran, if you say it's a hell Buhari,

00:38:31--> 00:38:38

it is okay, but don't say that every Headey that would be wrong, because some of the Hadith were criticized.

00:38:40--> 00:38:42

Now the criticism of saya Buhari.

00:38:44--> 00:38:48

Now as I said, there are two groups those who criticize al Bukhari

00:38:49--> 00:39:03

there are two groups, some of them are reliable, qualified scholars in the field of Hadith, some classical scholars, some of them who live during this time or live during this time, Mr. Bernier passed away

00:39:04--> 00:39:10

those who are not specialized, were concerned with this group of people in this area of study.

00:39:11--> 00:39:19

The Quran is for example, I gave you the example last last halakhah right the way the play with with the A at the interpretation of the,

00:39:20--> 00:39:53

the way the manipulators for the sake of what serving their view, serving their desire, they have a However, this view becomes a desire however. Right. And, you know, I had a student novel Gemma, they collect all the proofs, all the headings, all the texts, when they study something, they don't hide some of the texts, and they show people only one part of the story, one side of the story, if you do it, that means you're trying to promote

00:39:54--> 00:39:59

an ideology that is different than the ideology of Allison ojama.

00:40:00--> 00:40:21

Some of them they have an evil agenda and some of them are atheist. I read some of the articles written by a theist going into zaharie. And trying to find some faults inside Buhari. And most of these people don't have knowledge about that head even they make silly mistakes. I'll show you some of them that they don't use the principles of Heidi are rules of honey, the science of Hades.

00:40:22--> 00:40:26

They don't use the roadmap for it. They had rules they had principles.

00:40:27--> 00:40:37

In order to come when they come when it comes to the classification of a Hadith, or verification of a Hadith, they have rules and principles or mission, some of them some of them tonight.

00:40:39--> 00:40:49

We'll go to one of the websites we have 35 minutes left, right. My right. Actually the time is in front of me here is 755.

00:40:51--> 00:41:02

Okay, now some examples. I'll give you an example. This example was mentioned by Adnan Ibrahim, I have to be frank Mallesh and his hotbar on the member.

00:41:04--> 00:41:07

He was telling people that this had if

00:41:08--> 00:41:16

a group of people came to us last element they asked him about a cell when when is the hour when the hour will be established.

00:41:18--> 00:41:33

Saurus Allah says lm looked at a boy who was with them a young boy he said if this boy lives until he becomes an old man then the hour will be established will be I must be here or the hour will take place. This is ohare

00:41:35--> 00:41:36

so this

00:41:37--> 00:41:43

found this Heidi was very happy Oh mistake is a hell Buhari went to the member and making

00:41:45--> 00:42:02

a strong hotma he was very excited. This is not a methodology for the ruler whoever good intention when we talk about Buhari or criticize Buhari, he was very excited about this hadith. What is wrong with this hadith? Tell me Help me here.

00:42:03--> 00:42:08

Now it's not we it Is Buhari. And it is say

00:42:09--> 00:42:10

now

00:42:15--> 00:42:17

I am Muslim some of them but most of them are.

00:42:18--> 00:42:21

Right? But this hadith is Hey,

00:42:24--> 00:42:30

here we're gonna deal with the understanding of this man on the member with his understanding

00:42:32--> 00:42:34

whether he did it on purpose or

00:42:35--> 00:42:46

or he didn't pay attention to his mistake. That's a different story. Allah knows his intention. But the problem is this person is knowledgeable he must have. He knows he knows what he's talking about.

00:42:53--> 00:42:58

Yeah, so this boy was 10 years at the time, 10 years, 11 years during the time of muscle loss as well.

00:42:59--> 00:43:16

When he becomes an old man, I had the age of 80 or 90 years, it would be 100 years maybe let's say 90 100 years, 90 years, 90 years after the death for a solar cell. But the hour did not take place.

00:43:17--> 00:43:19

How do you solve this problem?

00:43:22--> 00:43:47

Are you going to say okay, here you go. I got a heavy sigh Buhari song. So Buhari is not a reliable source of headache. Look at this headache here. Buhari did not pay attention to this headache. And he said it he said Buhari brought his head if look 200 years after the you know the death of Rasul Allah says you should have paid attention to this this boy must have died

00:43:48--> 00:43:55

right eight years or 70 years after the death of Rasulullah Salim and the Sierra did not take place.

00:43:57--> 00:43:58

So our owner

00:43:59--> 00:44:04

when they come to something like this is take the time. Look at different versions of this hadith.

00:44:05--> 00:44:19

Like check this hadith in Sahih Muslim check this hadith in tirmidhi Let's check this hadith again inside Buhari in different chapters. And they collect all the versions here I brought another version here is a Muslim, are you able to see it? Are you able to see it?

00:44:21--> 00:44:24

So this had the headache of Asia will solve the problem.

00:44:26--> 00:44:36

Identify she said the big ones. And the way she said it? It says that happened many times. The big ones those who come from out of town

00:44:37--> 00:44:46

used to come to the Messenger of Allah and because they wanted to learn about their Deen part of the deen is to know about the hour

00:44:47--> 00:44:47

right.

00:44:49--> 00:44:52

So they used to ask us for less I said when is the our meta?

00:44:54--> 00:44:59

meta saya Rasul Allah. So he would, that was his habit, Allah salatu salam

00:45:00--> 00:45:02

He would look at the youngest among them

00:45:03--> 00:45:13

and say if this boy lives until he becomes an old man then your hour will take place your hour will take place

00:45:15--> 00:45:19

there is a big difference between the hour and your hour

00:45:20--> 00:45:33

an Imam I have COVID another great scholar emammal quarterly they said this had even say a Muslim would solve the problem with remove the confusion Why? How is the confusion removed?

00:45:38--> 00:45:46

You're our is your death we have okay I'm on Cobra the major and the minor Kiana mighty ama is when I die.

00:45:47--> 00:45:50

My sir my hour is when I die.

00:45:54--> 00:46:00

So that's one last element your hour in the first Hadeeth. But how do you this is honest.

00:46:01--> 00:46:14

Buhari remember he collected this heavy with this words. So he included his he made he verified? How do you say the problem is solved by looking at different versions of this hadith another so he had it inside Muslim.

00:46:15--> 00:46:33

These great scholars said problem is solved. These are good, great classical scholars. mm portobay has a big theory we have we have a copy of it here. As written many books go to the other iaV and other scholars, they said no, there is no problem here. It's all

00:46:34--> 00:46:39

that's all I say lament your hour. So I guess this man,

00:46:40--> 00:46:48

we no knew about this. This is my guess because he knows what he was talking about. It's just the problem is when you come and he sent up on the member

00:46:50--> 00:46:52

and you start collecting things here and there

00:46:54--> 00:47:03

and try to make the point. People are intelligent, you know, they know your purpose. You try what you're trying to do with the hotbar or a speech when giving right.

00:47:05--> 00:47:09

Unfortunately, there are many people who listen to this man and the follow him.

00:47:12--> 00:47:15

I had a disagreement with some people here in our community.

00:47:16--> 00:47:21

Because they listened to him about Medallia he made a series of lecture about my idea.

00:47:23--> 00:48:09

Why do you waste your time trying to degrade our fear of the unknown he was as a hobby. If he made a mistake. by appointing his son after him as a colleague or he had a disagreement with Eleanor Vitali is not my problem. He's as a hobby. And as a hobby. I know that Allah tala is better than what I have in every Sofia and there is no doubt about it. Right? But Allah will take care of that will will take them to account on the Day of Judgment is not my job to judge my area. I live in the 21st century. I did not live with them. And it was not a witness about what happened between where are we and Alabama Vitara. And they were cousins from the same family from the same tribe. I mean, I mean

00:48:09--> 00:48:11

from the same tribe, right? kurush

00:48:12--> 00:48:16

somehow related to each other, and they were so hobbies.

00:48:17--> 00:48:40

Because when you open the door, you start criticizing the Sahaba and there is disrespecting the Sahaba what will happen to will be easy for anyone to criticize all the Sahaba and who brought the deen who passed the deen down to from generation to generation there are the Sahaba for sola sola. If we if we have doubt about their

00:48:41--> 00:48:52

about their Adana, you know about their status, about their truthfulness, then we'll have doubt about our Deen I'll tell you because they are the one who would memorize the Quran.

00:48:54--> 00:49:09

And they are the one who taught the Quran to the generation after them a tambourine and he taught them the hadith of Rasulullah Salah. So people who try to do these things, actually they try to know to solve our problems as Muslims to create more problems and more confusion.

00:49:11--> 00:49:34

And some people I had a disagreement with them here in the City of Calgary, because they believed in what he said about him how he was feeling but what what why are you wasting your time unless you take them to account for what they take care of yourself. Take care of yourself while you used to right way for us to last I said he was one of the disciples. One of the writers of Revelation.

00:49:35--> 00:49:42

He lived with us in Lhasa, his sister she was was the wife of Rasulullah sallallahu his sister, um Habiba

00:49:43--> 00:49:51

and his father and mother Yes, they fought with the messenger against the Messenger of Allah with Sophia, but he became Muslim. After that. He accepted Islam

00:49:52--> 00:49:54

and his mother accepted Islam.

00:49:56--> 00:49:59

So these people accepted Islam. Allah told us that the people who say later

00:50:00--> 00:50:14

I will be saved from the Day of Judgment but these people lived with us. And they did some work. They contributed, contribute and they were hobbies they lived with us unless I sell them and to me so hobbies are a red line

00:50:15--> 00:50:24

I would never approach as a hobby it's not my job almost pantalla Allah told us in the Quran that he's pleased with them in general right. He stopped there.

00:50:26--> 00:50:50

And he taught us to go to certain hasher I attend a study I attend what Allah subhanaw taala folders because he mentioned in eight and nine, the Mahajan nine and answer the excellence of measuring the excellence of Landsat eight and nine solid hashing. And 10 told us about what should be the behavior about those who come after him after them and we are included, that we make do that for them.

00:50:52--> 00:51:02

We asked last pantalla to forgive our sins and forgive them and don't keep any grudges in our heart. Don't don't no,

00:51:03--> 00:51:09

clean our hearts from any grudges against those who came before us among the believers

00:51:10--> 00:51:14

and the Sahaba are the best of those believers, the best generation

00:51:15--> 00:51:16

anyway.

00:51:17--> 00:51:21

So now this Hadith, this masala is it clear to you What?

00:51:24--> 00:51:27

It's clear. This is the methodology of those people who

00:51:29--> 00:51:31

who deal with Al Bukhari.

00:51:34--> 00:51:56

Another another person, I believe he was an he's an atheist. He lives in the state. He works with a canal TV channels called hoorah. This Connect was established actually to promote the view of the United States of America about Islam and Muslims and what's happening in the Middle East. This TV channel was established for this purpose.

00:51:58--> 00:52:01

And this guy brought it from

00:52:02--> 00:52:16

the introduction of one of the chapters of Buhari I'll tell you about what is the difference between the introduction of any chapter and between the main headings in every chapter. I'll show you a website now. suna.com.

00:52:19--> 00:52:45

And in this introductions, Al Bukhari would not include those ahaadeeth that are meant to be authentic. He would include some as from the Quran, some stories, some reports without his net without a chain of transmission. And in book in the book of Nika marriage element Buhari narrated a statement from someone I don't want to tell you about it.

00:52:46--> 00:52:48

It's a weird statement about marriage.

00:52:49--> 00:52:53

What Is Buhari say? He said, This man is not known.

00:52:55--> 00:52:57

And many scholars have disagreed with him.

00:52:58--> 00:53:10

What does it mean? This man is not known to be a reliable scholar, or reliable Narrator The man who made the made the statement and many scholars have disagreed with him.

00:53:11--> 00:53:28

Now this man, this guy who lives in the United States who will take this weird statement about marriage from salvo Hari not from the head of the main howdy from the introduction. I'll tell you the difference. And without telling us about the common to Freeman Buhari is that honest

00:53:30--> 00:53:32

Buhari is against the statement

00:53:33--> 00:53:34

is against it

00:53:35--> 00:53:47

but this man would not tell us that Buhari is against it. He was just this is cut and paste right. cut and paste he would cut this statement which is weird and crazy

00:53:48--> 00:54:18

related to one of the methods of marriage Buhari did not disagree with it but he included in the introduction different views different stories different Okay, I'll tell you about I'll give you an example here he did not mean that this head is not added anyway it's a statement made by someone but to ignore the other part where Buhari said this man is not known to be a reliable narrator or reliable scholar and other scholars have disagreed with it. You ignore this part this is not this is this honesty

00:54:19--> 00:54:39

this these are the what are the people doing quite attacking so but some of them now introduction of chapters. Okay, I have to leave this presentation here and show you a website. example here this is pseudoknot.com I don't know if it is clear to everyone okay, it's good.

00:54:41--> 00:54:42

Circular table this

00:54:43--> 00:54:44

is very helpful.

00:54:47--> 00:54:49

method and I'll show you something here.

00:54:52--> 00:54:53

He definitely man.

00:54:54--> 00:54:59

Okay he terrible man. So, this writing Of course it is not translated by cerner.com the only time

00:55:00--> 00:55:09

translate the headings, the main headings, but this is an introduction to the chapter. So this is chapter of belief faith. This is an introduction.

00:55:12--> 00:55:37

Bahar is saying who are called on warfarin. It's a statement verbal statement and action talking about a man definition of a man. Yes, either way. Oh, because it increases and decreases. We know that a man increases and decreases. This is the update of Allison ojama. This is his statement is not the universal lesson. This is the introduction. And then here he would say what Paula Ibrahim will actually add Martin Nickleby, who is Ibrahim

00:55:40--> 00:55:49

Ibrahim La Silla and Prophet Ibrahim alayhis salam, this part of the ayah from Surah Al Baqarah. Lima in Nickleby when he asked for a proof or Allah give me proof.

00:55:50--> 00:55:52

Right, I want to increase my Eman.

00:55:53--> 00:56:12

So this is a proof that the man goes up and down right? And we are allowed to ask for proofs so we can have communists we can have to mean a confidence in our Deen. Well, Carla, my wife is not a messenger is this been an omen Say hi Sahabi but he's not giving us a tray of chain of narration

00:56:13--> 00:56:20

Bollywood no not do that. This is not his job. This is just an introduction. Okay, what are the headings that Buhari meant

00:56:22--> 00:56:24

to be mean his main work right?

00:56:26--> 00:57:01

This is the this is number one. For example, in this chapter is the Hadith. Are you able to see it of course in the English translation. They don't mention the chain of narration. But the chain of narration is mentioned here had done Abdullah Abu Musa para banahan Villa NaVi Sofia and a cream of the harlot and if you're Omar of the Allahumma, kala, kala Rasulullah Salah. So, this is the chain of transmission is not translated in the English part here. English it says narrated neuroma they mentioned only the Sahabi unfortunately,

00:57:02--> 00:57:06

because the we believe that Muslims are concerned with the text of the heady

00:57:07--> 00:57:32

nowadays Muslims want to know about the text of the head if they are not concerned this is for specialized people for students of knowledge. But here this is how Buhari collected his head if he didn't bring them from nowhere before he said had their hand up to obey the law of Noosa. He said Abdullah have been away to live in a Moosa informed us who would be obeyed to live in the water he would be his teacher now.

00:57:34--> 00:58:17

So Buhari got this hadith from this man, obey the law have no Moosa These men are waiting they have no Moosa, he told his Buhari, Burnham Villa to boo Sofia handle of NaVi Sofia and told us he informed us these people have trustworthy narratives for Buhari that's another story I'll tell you how they deal with that. And a crema from a crema Ebony harlot from a crema Avenue Carlin. So handle of NaVi Sofia, he said we got this hadith from Rick Rima, Abu Khalid, so there is a chain of narration right? And then he can remember Ohara he said I got this hadith from Abdullah Omar, who is the Sahaba of the olana so how many people between Buhari and Rasulullah sallallahu Obaidullah Musa

00:58:17--> 00:58:27

100 Allah be Sophia and to record him of Nohara three. And then Abdullah have number four. So for people between Buhari and Ursula sasl.

00:58:29--> 00:58:45

Okay, now Buhari has to make sure that these people are reliable narrators. And I'll give you an idea here. Rival narrator he is a techie. You have any people have studied his biography, Muslim scholars, scholars have Atif.

00:58:46--> 00:58:54

He's attacking. And he's someone who has taqwa. He doesn't lie. If we experience one life from him, he's gone.

00:58:55--> 00:58:57

He's had these will not be accepted.

00:58:59--> 00:59:31

They were very strict with this, and handling obesity and the same thing. And he has to be a half of half of the army. His memory is very good. How do the test that we look at his mid 30s generated many hatidze compare them with the narrations of his peers, these who got the same idea from his teacher handful of NaVi Sophia, the next line will be his teacher. This teacher had students many student who got the same head if we compare these ahaadeeth

00:59:32--> 00:59:41

for narrated by different students, and then they see if they are the same or not. If we found that obey the law abnormal so this guy is making some mistakes.

00:59:43--> 00:59:46

He's adding some words deleting some words

00:59:47--> 00:59:59

that are different than his peers and his classmates. I would say. They said he's not a half of his setup. They say he's a he's a techie. He's a good man, pious man. But he's

01:00:00--> 01:00:04

memori is not strong in his head, it will never be good. We haven't sometimes

01:00:05--> 01:00:17

has an is another level. And there's the Hadith that are accepted, they are classified into hash and sound and say authentic viiith is weak is not accepted. Right.

01:00:18--> 01:00:26

So if this man has some problems with his memory, he's highly enough accepted, but this is a rigorous work. Yeah. Well,

01:00:27--> 01:00:48

you know, some of them are scholars have had if they were very strict, one of them was passing by the House of one of the narrators, and there wasn't music in his house. He stopped taking, collecting his ID, because there was a music in his house, and never his color. And if he traveled, he went to another city.

01:00:50--> 01:01:27

Another city, and then when he went to meet him to get some advice from him, he found him you know, these people used to wear these kind of long robes. And sometimes he would no, carry it, you know, would take it, fold it, fold it up, and put some methods, some grain in it. When he wants to. They had some animals. And these animals, their horns are attached to a piece of wood. And this piece of wood will be if these animals will go around. There was a

01:01:28--> 01:02:10

I don't know it's it's a it's a water well, it's a way of taking water from from wells, right. So he would put some food, some grain in his in his dress on his garment. And then he would call the animal to come. And then they go, he will go backwards, back when this animal is following him. So basically, he doesn't want to feed the animal. He's trying to do what to make the animal walk around that well so he can get some water. So this color of Hennessy came and started watching him doing this. And he said, you know, you are lying to this animal.

01:02:11--> 01:02:16

You're cheating. You're cheating this animal. And he stopped. He didn't take anything from it.

01:02:18--> 01:02:32

Some of them were very strict. That's very extreme. I'm giving you extreme examples, right. Some other scholars will say okay, this is not cheating. I mean, this is the way you do it. This the way you get water from this well, right. But but some of them were very extreme.

01:02:34--> 01:02:50

And a man Buhari, he would make sure that if someone say and here handful of nervy sofian and a crema from a crema if he used the term from he has to make sure that he met him and he studied under him

01:02:52--> 01:02:57

a Muslim it's enough for them for him to the live that the Met.

01:02:58--> 01:03:37

But remember how do you know he has to make sure that he studied under him and got some ahaadeeth So anyway, these are so that's why the head is the finishing of Sahih Hadith mythos Allah sallallahu pinaka largely verbally and mentally he mean murder in Hades ceilometer obedience de la Mancha what kind of Holly and Amina should do the will Allah so they include in this definition around four to five conditions. They said the heading has to be connected. So all the narrator's have met each other. The the study, every student studied from his teacher, It is well known that they were dealing with each other and they were studying together.

01:03:39--> 01:03:42

All of them are reliable narrators.

01:03:43--> 01:04:07

It's not disconnected. If they have doubt about the meeting between a teacher and a student. They don't take the headache. And also it's not shared is not a regular narration irregular is not irregular, irregular. What is an irregular haddie that was narrated by a reliable NARRATOR But he his student, his classmates or his peers disagreed with him.

01:04:08--> 01:04:37

So he added a word that is not found in the other narrations now that are authentic. All of them were supposed to take the headset from one teacher, but this student added one word. They said this, this is an irregular had he had he shared that they respect the scholar they respect the narrator but they said he must have a made made a mistake. I found this mistake method inside a Muslim one time we were reading

01:04:38--> 01:04:39

Rio de Sala him.

01:04:41--> 01:04:43

I see at I see in Edmonton trail after

01:04:44--> 01:04:59

and we were reading a hadith in Sahih Muslim about those who will enter agenda without being taken to account without without going through the account the last pantalla will not take them to account they will go directly to gender

01:05:00--> 01:05:44

Some of the fat and Mr. Muslim collected the head if one of them is layer cool. Last couple days lesser cool and layer code lesser con D don't ask for raffia. This is very famous while verified. They don't ask for Rokia that means he has they have to work on. They do Rukia to themselves. They don't ask other people to do, which is Helen, it's hard to ask for someone else to do Rukia for you. But these people, they will go to gender without being taken to account because their tawakkol is pure. They will have the highest level of token in this life. Right? One of the signs of this debacle. They don't come to ask people to give me a Rokia or do Rukia for me, which is okay,

01:05:44--> 01:05:54

permissible, right. But this is not one of their habits. They do it to themselves. They believe in Allah to Allah they have to work on Allah. We read Quran on themselves.

01:05:55--> 01:06:06

But there is heavy inside a Muslim says layer who don't do raffia or oakway. Stop here. We know that it's permissible to do Rokia. What's wrong with this.

01:06:07--> 01:06:46

And this is a hadith in Sahih Muslim. So we read it earlier, the Salah heat, I told the brothers I need to verify this hadith. I did some research about this Hadith, I found that this hadith is shared. And in one of the Hadith, inside Muslim that has some issues, shared what is shared is an irregular narration because we have other authentic hadith in which he said do Rukia cecropia Europa for yourself this way. That's okay, it's permissible. Right? And all the ahaadeeth all the other headings which mentioned those who enter gender without his app, didn't have this problem didn't have this term.

01:06:48--> 01:06:50

Okay, now, let's go to

01:06:51--> 01:06:56

so you know the difference between the introduction of the chapter and the chapter itself.

01:06:57--> 01:07:41

In the introduction, Buhari did not follow the strict rules, he would sometimes include the headings without a chain of narration. And the head, it could be week, could be week that some scholars could come to the Hadees and say, This is weak. But this is not in the book of Buhari. This is not one of the main Hadees. It is a narration found in the introduction regime. It's called terashima in Arabic. So those people who don't have a knowledge, they are not specialized in the field, they come to this and even this generation, oh, look at this. This is a weak Hadith in Sahih Bukhari and they think that Buhari actually is lying to people he's including, he had it in his in his head. So there

01:07:41--> 01:07:48

is a big difference between the two of them. And this is a good example here. Let's go back to the the

01:07:52--> 01:07:52

now.

01:07:54--> 01:07:59

So another problem here that some people are saying nowadays, how come

01:08:00--> 01:08:15

and remember how he was able to collect 600,000 Hadees within 16 years, because the remedy said he memorized 600,000 Hadees. And among them, he selected the headings that he included in his site,

01:08:16--> 01:08:23

which is, as I said, without repetition, they would be less than 3000 Hadith. But they said How come

01:08:24--> 01:08:58

within 16 years, from 216 to 230. And these people they don't know about Buhari, they don't know about his life. They don't know that he wrote books, which has volume six volumes, these books have had six, seven volumes about biographies of the narrator. So he was familiar with this knowledge. Before he came to this site. He decided to dedicate this book to only authentic include this only authentic hadith in this book. So before that he was familiar with this knowledge.

01:08:59--> 01:09:24

And he selected he did not collect the 600,000 Hadees. Now within 16 years that's wrong number one. Number one when we mentioned these numbers number two when we mentioned these numbers, sometimes one text would have different chain of narrations. You're familiar now when we mean chain of narration now, we'd have 10 chain of narrations in their methodology of aroma and Hadith.

01:09:25--> 01:09:30

Every Hadith with a different chain of narration is a separate Hadith the text is the same.

01:09:31--> 01:09:41

So it could be one text, but because it has 10 or 20 or 30 chains, different chains of narrations, then the consider them 30 heads.

01:09:42--> 01:09:59

So at the end, if we look at this, they are not 600,000 but Buhari used to memorize these different chains of narrations. I'll give you an example. One time he went to Baghdad, the city of Baghdad and some people had has a jealousy sometimes some people mentioned this

01:10:00--> 01:10:09

was done maybe because of jealousy will love to Allah Allah. He became very famous, famous scholar of adif the people of Baghdad

01:10:10--> 01:10:15

were not happy with us, not from them said we're gonna test him.

01:10:16--> 01:10:30

So they sent some of their scholars. So sit down around him make halaqaat and invite people, the invited people and they wanted to test in the moment Buhari v selected how many 100 and hadiths

01:10:31--> 01:10:45

100 Hadees. And the selected 10 people among them, and he told everyone you have to integrate elbow to elbow hari 10 Hadith, but you change and change of narration, change them.

01:10:46--> 01:11:12

So move around this change of narration method you take a hadith instead of reciting the right chain of narration put another chain of narration fake one yeah, another. Another one that belongs to another Hadith should be with another Hadith, change it put it with place it with another Hadith and do the same thing for all these 100 Hadees. So he stood up, the first one stood up, and he narrated the 10 hadiths

01:11:13--> 01:11:16

with the wrong chains of narration.

01:11:18--> 01:11:20

And whenever he says the Hadith Buhari said I don't know it.

01:11:22--> 01:11:36

No, I don't know it. Nope. not aware of it. No. And the people around him around them. People who don't have knowledge about the head if you don't have this man, this Many claim that he's the best, one of the best scholars of Hadith.

01:11:38--> 01:11:46

And he would say for the same Hadith, every Hadith 100 Hadith? No, I'm not familiar with this. I'm not familiar with this.

01:11:47--> 01:11:53

And what happened? As I said, all the people who are not specialized in the field of Hadith said this man is ignorant.

01:11:55--> 01:12:00

But the scholars among them, they told each other he paid attention. He knows what you're doing.

01:12:01--> 01:12:18

At the end, he said, What do you think? He said, as what you said, As for the Hadees that you mentioned, emerged the first Hadith. This is the right chain of narration for this Hadith, and second, one fifth, this is the right chain of narration. And the third, Heidi, this is the right chain of narration of this Hadith, and said, This man is amazing.

01:12:20--> 01:12:33

This man is amazing. palace, they recognize his status as a great scholar of hiding. Now, I'll tell you something, if I tell you someone memorize 600,000 harleysville, is it possible or not possible?

01:12:35--> 01:12:37

I can give you a proof from this time.

01:12:40--> 01:12:42

Is it possible or not?

01:12:44--> 01:13:08

It's possible. I have seen myself children on TV, on YouTube children. One child, he's from Algeria, there are children. I'm not mentioning this child, because if it is Algeria, from Algeria, but this is what I remember. I remember this child and there are some other children from from Saudi Arabia from Egypt. from other countries. I saw one time a child from

01:13:11--> 01:13:21

you know, one of those Russian republics Kazakhstan or was Pakistan? I'm not sure. It was amazing competition in Mecca in Macau.

01:13:22--> 01:13:48

So they invited these young people. And then the teacher will tell him or the people who are testing this children will tell him Okay, besides this, I will give him the first word. And then he will decide the idea that what is the ad before it, and he will tell him the air before it? What is the air before it will tell him the air before? What is the air after it? What is the air in the beginning of the page? And it's amazing.

01:13:49--> 01:14:02

Amazing. This child that I mentioned from Algeria, humor, as many hobbies I don't know. But he would recite them in Arabic, English and French. Of course, he has accent in English. But he would do it.

01:14:04--> 01:14:09

And I don't know how many how does he memorize but he's on YouTube. Anyone can see it nowadays.

01:14:10--> 01:14:35

And I saw Chinese children Chinese. answering those math complicated math questions that you need. It's impossible that you or I can do it without any what is called mental math. You do it like in few seconds, a few seconds he will give the answer. And he's on TV. He's on TV without using any calculator or anything.

01:14:37--> 01:14:59

So it's possible. Now that headed here 600. Again, it doesn't mean all these Hadith are prophetic Hadith. It could be also non prophetic Hadees only the statement of the Sahaba the same amount of data that will be hundreds of 1000s right. The column headings but McCool Tabby Mako from Sahabi mo poof. This is the terminology of this course.

01:15:00--> 01:15:10

I'll tell you about this. This is a personal experience. The last experience Muhammad Sallallahu Sallam committing suicide. And this is inside Buhari.

01:15:11--> 01:15:17

Right? I have to be honest with you and tell you about it. But this is something that I had a personal experience with it.

01:15:18--> 01:15:25

We have a book here it's called Reichenbach tomb. We have some copies here, right? One of the best books of Syrah

01:15:26--> 01:15:35

written by an Indian scholar Mubarak fury is originally from India, but he lives in Saudi Arabia. He died in Medina, I met him personally. May Allah have mercy on him?

01:15:37--> 01:15:39

There was world Muslim World League,

01:15:40--> 01:15:51

organize a competition. And they said we want people to write books of Syrah. He wrote his book of Syrah. It's a beautiful book. He was one of the winners. I'm not sure if he got the first prize or second prize.

01:15:54--> 01:16:07

First prize right? Okay, but nothing is perfect. So included the seed of Rasulullah Salim during the time of war he when he received Lhasa Salim he told us about these narrations one of them is in Buhari

01:16:11--> 01:16:19

that was in Lhasa Salem, the debris came up when debris came to us last SLM. You need to pay attention to this spend time with it.

01:16:21--> 01:16:27

Debris came to us from last SLM, he revealed to him the first five verses of sort of Accra.

01:16:29--> 01:16:30

And then he quit.

01:16:32--> 01:16:41

There are some scholars who said he didn't come back to him until two years or three years had passed. I said it's impossible when I read it.

01:16:42--> 01:16:44

I did some research.

01:16:45--> 01:16:51

I found a member he said no, that's not right. No way. He quit he didn't come to him only for

01:16:53--> 01:17:07

stayed away for only for a few days. Few days. I said to myself, it's impossible that gibreel would get bring him some effort. And then he will come back after two years to bring him the other is America I mean, it's impossible.

01:17:09--> 01:17:19

So no matter who is classified the great scholar he said this is not right. The right thing Yes, he quit he did not come to him for few days.

01:17:20--> 01:17:24

He wanted to give him a break because there was one last SLM was shaken

01:17:25--> 01:18:03

was shaking, he was afraid he was surprised. Imagine your any someone coming to you into your you're by yourself in a cave. And some sort of creature comes to you and said and hugs you and tells you read and then you don't know how to read. And then he gives you some five verses from the Quran and he tells you are the Messenger of God and you have no idea that you will be the Messenger of God. He went to Russia he went to his wife and he was shaking. And he said you need to thoroughly Cover me cover me cover me the middle Nizam Milani also Yeah, you lose a million would

01:18:04--> 01:18:09

cover me cover me and I do not I said Did I say Ayesha

01:18:10--> 01:18:18

Khadija his wife haha. Of course Khadija made a very beautiful statement at the time to come forth to comfort our Prophet Mohammed Salim

01:18:20--> 01:18:27

beautiful statement about his job and about what he used to do and everything. This is something a different story in the books of ceto find it there.

01:18:28--> 01:18:31

But jabril wanted to give him a break for a few days

01:18:33--> 01:18:35

when he can digest what happened.

01:18:36--> 01:19:25

Right. So in, in the books of Sierra, it says he was deeply depressed. He was waiting for jabril. And he wanted to commit suicide. He would go on the top of a mountain. And he would try to throw himself from the top of a mountain gibreel would come to him. And he said, Yeah, Muhammad, you are really the Messenger of God, don't kill yourself. And this happened many times. And I found some a brother here from IRC. He was reading this book, this story. And when he came to this story, he put a big circle. And he looked at it the origin of this story, he found side Buhari, a big arrow, and he said How come that means this guy is not happy. I don't know who is this brother? But this is

01:19:25--> 01:19:33

what he wrote. How come? This is ohare and this is out of character he is trying to kill himself.

01:19:35--> 01:19:59

One day I received a call from a brother from Edmonton chasin there are people who are adding things suicidal Buhari online, you need to do something about it. Okay, what's wrong? What's the problem? There are some people who are adding some fake stories about him and saying that he was trying to kill himself and commit suicide. Okay, I said, Okay. hamdulillah I did some work about it. I did some research and

01:20:00--> 01:20:01

Explain to him I'll explain it to you know,

01:20:02--> 01:20:11

this is inside Buhari The head is authentic from Asia. The story is authentic about the beginning of Hawaii.

01:20:12--> 01:20:31

One of the narratives of the Hadeeth easily Missouri, I mentioned the Missouri who was involved in collecting the Sunnah of Rasulullah sallallahu when it came to this part, when it came to this part Rasulullah saw Selim trying to kill himself, he said female Bella, no, this is what it has reached us.

01:20:32--> 01:20:40

The owner said one and Mr. Massoud he added adds this statement. That means he is not confident about the narration.

01:20:42--> 01:21:15

And they have had he said all the bannerghatta vizuri are weak. All this disconnected the report when he's not confident about the report, he said this is what it has reached us. That means he is telling people I'm not confident about this part. But a man who hurry because he is truthful and honest. He didn't want to play with the Hadith and take this part out. That is the whole hottie The story is authentic. There is nothing wrong with it. But in Amazonia included this part in the middle of the Hadith. Mmm Buhari did not want to take it out.

01:21:17--> 01:21:27

In one of his chapters, he left it as it is in a Missouri is a great scholar. And he knows what he's talking about. And he's telling people I'm not sure about this part.

01:21:29--> 01:21:37

So some odema when we looked at it, he said this is a disconnected report from Missouri, Missouri. He knows his narrators very well. He was great scholar.

01:21:38--> 01:22:19

When he's not confident about any narration, he would use this statement. And Alhamdulillah I said I'm fine now I'm happy. I believe this story is not correct is not authentic. But this is inside Buhari, but I didn't get become excited and came here and tell people Oh, I found something wrong with ohare. And trying to attack the Buhari I understand what Buhari why, while Buhari left it because nobody wants to be honest and truthful. This is how the Hadith is narrated. And Mr. Missouri's honest with people and telling them I'm not confident about this part. Part of the Hadith hamdulillah everything is and I believe

01:22:20--> 01:22:36

it doesn't make sense. But you breed would come to him that he will try to kill himself or many times can but the problem is when someone who doesn't know about the science of Hadith, it comes to this book method to read them off to the seals maximum knowledge. I'm sorry, brothers who came for selected Asia. We're sorry.

01:22:38--> 01:22:43

Because this is the last halaqa It's okay. You are okay with adding two minutes, three minutes right

01:22:44--> 01:22:45

now,

01:22:46--> 01:22:47

it's windy outside anyway.

01:22:50--> 01:22:52

You need to take some time before we leave, right.

01:22:53--> 01:22:58

So just to three minutes, because this is very important to me, to me and to you should be important.

01:22:59--> 01:23:09

I understand what Buhari did and what Mr. Missouri did, I did not take advantage of this. I didn't I don't call it a mistake. I know what he's doing.

01:23:11--> 01:23:21

I know this part is not authentic to me as a Muslim Rasulullah sallallahu was not trying to kill himself. That's it. Because any disconnected report from him and zuri is not authentic.

01:23:22--> 01:24:04

And I included it in the main in the main Howdy. He's not in a thermal introduction. But he This is the headies the whole Hadees is like that, and this is in the middle. He is a truthful. He didn't want to take it out. He left it as it is. But he knows that he remembers who he is making the statement and that people have knowledge. We know that this part is not authentic. And I believe that is not authentic. Right. So cinema is not trying to kill himself. He would not do it. And it's only few days. Imagine it's only a few days. I mean, within these few days of loss SLM will understand what happened. Actually, she took him her DJ took him to his to her cousin

01:24:05--> 01:24:49

who was Christian. He was familiar with these things. And they said this is the novel's the angels that used to come to musasa lab and Teresa, he came to you and brought what you are the messenger for this oma and actually most many Muslim, many Christian scholars used to know at that time, that it was time for a new prophet to appear in the Arabian Peninsula at the time. So he was not surprised when I come to Nova. And he said if I am I wish that I will be young and healthy when your people move you out or kick you out from the city of Mecca but he died after a few days. Now. So last I saw him later on. He saw him in his room in a white dress said I hope that he will be in

01:24:49--> 01:24:59

gender. I thought he said if he was not in gender, he wouldn't be wearing a white dress. We'll learn how to add an atom. That's another story. But you see the point here

01:25:00--> 01:25:16

But there are people who try to look into these things and be happy What are you happy with them with something that you think it's a mistake to harden you go stand up on the member and say pour is full of flies and full of fabricated Hadeeth and cutter.

01:25:17--> 01:25:24

This is not fair. For me it's not fair. I mean we will be just creating more problems

01:25:26--> 01:25:45

within our oma and creating more confusion chisako credit for coming Danny I was hoping we thought that we're gonna get a small crowd because of the weather outside but hamdulillah is akula Hainan. Allah spent Allah bless your time. Bless your efforts and bless your families. The salon Hello Thailand you will feel canaliculi here