Authority of the Sunnah – Part 2
Channel: Hacene Chebbani
File Size: 44.28MB
Similar Mr. Haim hamdu Lillahi Rabbil alameen wa salatu salam ala l mursaleen sagina. Mohammed
Ali he was Safi as you may know.
This Allah subhanaw taala philosophy will Cody will Mr. melas pantah Allah grant us security in all what we do.
So today we'll continue with the same topic which is the authority of the Sunnah of Prophet Muhammad sallallahu alayhi wa sallam.
And now this is,
this is just an example of the material that is now shared online.
And the purpose of sharing this material is actually to degrade the status of the Sunnah of our Prophet Mohammed Salah Salem, whether they do it with a good intention, with a bad intention, it doesn't matter, the end result is the same, they will be confusing some Muslims about the status and the role of our Prophet Mohammed Salim and his sooner engineer. Now this question here, how can the Quran be considered perfect if it requires the Hadith to explain itself? Or to explain it?
Right? So got to deal with this question. And basically, the answer that is provided by this person here, you will find that repeated in other answers in other forums, and other websites. So this is Cora here. This is a forum where people harass and question and rip other people who take it upon themselves to answer these questions. Now, here, the guy is saying that's a valid question. I have always asked the same question to myself. And that is callers. Needless to say that I have never been satisfied with the answer served.
I'm not going to deal with this part. But I don't because I don't know what kind of answers this person received, right? So I'm not going to talk about something that I'm not aware of, I'm going to deal with the material, his own answers. That is providing for people trying to tell people that sooner, there is no need for the IDs of Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam,
he started with a very strong message here with the ayah in Surah.
Surely the wolves of beasts in in the Gar in God's sight, those who are deaf and dumb, and did not use their reason.
So basically, he's trying to do something here.
Could you tell me what he's what he's trying to do?
It is out of context, because this is an academic research. It is supposed to be an academic discussion here. So you don't use this, if that is you that was used in the Quran about those who don't use their intellectual power, we don't use their brain their reason to reach the truth to know Allah subhanho wa Taala. So they don't want to listen to the message of the truth here. This discussion is between Muslims who believe in the authority of the center, and between other people who don't believe in the authority of the center. So it should be an academic discussion, right? And we're not supposed to use this is here in this discussion here is trying to humiliate those who
disagree with him in the beginning.
So basically, if you don't disagree, if you disagree with me, you are the one of those who do not use their reason. Basically, this is the message for young people don't have knowledge, they might be actually shocked in the beginning or surprised. And this is humiliation tactics. This is what I believe. Now he said so one who uses reason would ask why Allah would say something which people did not understand.
He needs a human to interpret or explain surely Allah is capable of saying exactly what the interpreters say, and could have added in the Quran if it is really required. But Allah Subhana Allah says, In the Quran, and then he's saying using this ayah from an RF that Allah subhanaw taala brought a book that is based on knowledge. In this book, he explained in detail, his guidance, and it is a mercy to those who believe. And of course, this
is about the kuffaar who will be in Hellfire, we will talk they will send a message to the people of agenda. We will tell them give us some water or some of the bounties that you received in general
and the people in general will tell them will reply to them that these are forbidden for the
Have the inhabitants whatever pleasure we have, or need, or bounty we have in Jannah. Allah maybe made it forbidden for the people of hellfire. And then he will continue the last panel attached to talking about these people who are in Hellfire, or who will be in Hellfire that we have sent to them a book that is based on knowledge which is the Quran right? And which we explain in detail, a guide and a mercy to those who believe the owner of Allah Sunnah. They said, the guidance that is needed to accept the message of the Islam of Islam to accept the message, to believe in a loss pelotonia to believe in his prophets and messengers, to believe in his angels to believe in the Day of Judgment
is well explained in the Quran.
The guidance of al Qaeda, right?
The main guidance for someone to accept the message is well explained, which means for someone to accept Islam he doesn't need soon is or an should be enough for him. If he reads the Quran, he understands the message of the Quran, it should be enough as a proof for him to accept Islam. And it will be a harsher proof against him if he doesn't accept the message of the Quran on the Day of Judgment.
But when it comes after he becomes a Muslim,
when he wants to pray, he wants to pays a cat he wants to fast then he has to go back to the sooner to know these things.
But the first step, because the last point I wanted from these people first to accept the message.
There is no point of asking them to pray or to offer the cat or to do or to fast the month of Ramadan if we don't have belief for them to become believers. This guidance is well explained in the Quran. And this is what the last pantalla meant by us. Actually, as I said, this
is a response to those who will be in Hellfire that means they rejected the message. They did not pay attention to the message of the Quran.
Is that point clear one?
Now the first part when he said why would Allah say something which people do not understand? People understand the who those who want to understand the message of the Quran. The Quran is clear.
Right? But the Quran itself is telling us for some part of the guidance that you need to go and listen to Mohammed sallallahu alayhi wa sallam and follow his Sunnah if you want to completely completely because we are Muslim now we are Muslims. Now. If we want to completely follow the guidance, the divine guidance, we need the Sunnah of our Prophet Muhammad sallallahu alayhi wa sallam.
Now, the second he had a book where of the verses are explained in detail, a Quran in Arabic for people who understand again, the guidance is the guidance of the day for people to accept the message of Islam is well explained. Part of this explanation is to follow the Sunnah of Muhammad Sallallahu Sallam the problem with these people here, they bring only the ayat and the verses, which support their view.
And this is I would call it intellectual dishonesty. I would call it I call it until because Allison nojima because they want to truth our rule Emma, they always seek the truth. So they do what they bring all the A at that that concern one specific subject.
We don't choose and select and pick only the verses that support their views and ignore completely ignore their ad This is not honesty.
I would call it intellectual dishonesty if not crookedness.
Now here these are the same.
The same is the same message here.
matter we have this area here in Salton masala
then in what statement, Allah Allah Allah said for ba Hadith Allah use the word howdy This is very important pay pay attention to it for being a hadith in back there who you know this is the last if you want to check it in Surah till masala in what statement between practice Howdy.
Howdy because there are some people instead of writing statement, they write Heidi in bold
to scare you away like this. Allah subhanaw taala is seeing him what had he
After this Qur'an will they believe
that means, after listening to this for a while, they should reject every Hadith. But what does Hadees mean in the Arabic language?
What does Hadith mean? He won't tell me
So Allah Subhana Allah is saying if you want to be honest, he didn't use the term Hadith, which is good. But the Arabic term is Hadith.
He translated into statement, there are some people who put Hadith into bracket to give a message that you know what is meant here is the hadith of Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam.
Now, as I said, Here, it is obvious that Allah subhanho wa Taala is talking about is he talking about any speech
or a speech that contradicts that opposes the message of the Quran?
If there is a Quran and there is another speech that confirms the message you've declared, do you think Allah Subhana Allah will forbid us to listen to this speech that is confirming the message of the
man you want is serving the same purpose. So last penalty, Allah is talking about those people who listen to the speech of those who oppose the message of the Quran.
Do you see what I'm saying here and you can check it yourself. This is the last ayah in Surah t in Surah till more Salat.
Now here at the end, there is something very believe it's very crooked here.
I will read it to you. Allah subhanho wa Taala has taught Adam
when he has said to him to dwell in the garden,
but not to eat the fruit. The fruit of course, if one tree when Satan had come in, and convinced him with his persuasive explanations
to eat from the fruit, despite Allah's clear commandment to Adam alayhis salam,
he believed Satan
and ate the fruit.
As a result, he had to leave the heaven.
So Allah says in the Quran, and certainly we gave a commandment to Adam before, but he forgot, and we did not find in him any determination.
The guy is making a comparison. Yeah. It's a very dangerous, very crooked comparison. Because the question is about Hadith, right?
The question is about the hadith of Rasulullah assassin. So he's saying Adam received the revelation, a command from Allah, not to eat from the tree.
Adam was supposed to listen and follow the guidance, the only guidance that received from her as he received from Allah. But Adam listened to someone else.
And this person came and told him you It's okay, that's fine, you can eat from the tree, nothing will happen to you. So this person who is shaitan, we know he's shaitan he advised Adam to follow something other than the guidance of Allah subhana wa know to listen to Allah. You'll be fine. Just eat from the tree and everything will be fine.
So what kind of comparison these guys making? Do you see? Do you pay attention?
He's comparing between the worst worst of shaitan. And between what
And the hadith of Rasulullah assassin.
He didn't clearly said, but the question is about the head if
we can easily conclude that this man.
He's comparing between the West versus shaitan and between the hadith of Rasulullah sasl.
We can easily refute his statement here and say that Allah himself in the Quran, which you are inviting us to follow, telling us to follow Mohammed Salim to listen to Mohammed Salah allow us to obey Muhammad Sallallahu sallam, and he's telling us do not obey shaitan there is a big difference between the two.
It is not fair to make this comparison here, this analogy
and it's very crooked.
This is a massive This is the kind of knowledge that is shared online, unfortunately.
And many of our youth are sometimes not youth, adults who are educated this guy is an engineer, chief engineer.
So he's not specialized in Syria, as he doesn't have the right to give this guidance to people right. But now everything anyone can write anything on the on the internet online and share it with other people.
Sadly, he said by this the same is happening with us. We reject the Quran and accept what the earlier because Allah, Allah talks about ODF guardians scholars say
So based on this person, we are not allowed to listen to scholars.
And we're not allowed to listen to a hadith or follow the hadith of Rasul Allah says, he didn't mention that as soon as I sent him but the question is about Hadith. So he's combining between Hadith and the guidance that we take from our scholars.
Right now we have in the Quran the answer to this regarding scholars and Hadith.
Before you go to Surah tunnel, I have the I think I'll show them to you. Here maybe we'll show them now before we continue.
Okay, this is in Surah chapter 16. What is the law saying women sell them in public enlarged L and nuheat la him.
We have not sent before you except man, whom we reveal to them.
First ellu Anna Vickery in quantum lateral Mo, this message for those who don't believe in the message of the Quran, Allah is telling them ask the people of knowledge, if you do not know.
And this message is for everyone.
So there are scholars who follow the right guidance, who follow the true guidance of Allah Subhana Allah to Allah, and we are supposed to go to that.
As a matter of fact, our odema they said someone who is not a student of knowledge, who don't have sharing knowledge, he is he had his duty is to
find Muslim scholars, whom he trusts their knowledge, their qualification and their taqwa,
right, their piety that people who fear Allah subhanaw taala number one, and number two, the follow they have knowledge, when he finds peace, when he finds this Muslim scholars who have to these two qualities, it is his duty to ask them about the methods of the deed.
And this, this actually, this masala is raised. When people talk about the obligation of following a certain method or a particular method. The Sahaba did not follow any particular method.
I'm not here to degrade the mother, he burned the lemma established the matter at a bar great scholars. And we have established to establish this balance between respecting them and learning from their knowledge. And also an and at the same time we have to uphold the truth and to always try to follow the truth. So if you want to know about the truth, you have your duty is to know whether I mean no who are the scholars who are fearful as panel attallah. And they are knowledgeable and you need to ask them about the methods of the DEA, this water loss criteria, let's say ask the people of knowledge. So who are the only yet that's the last panel attalla is warning as to follow those who
will send us who will guide us, give us a different guidance than the guidance of the Quran. He will they will tell us don't worship Allah subhanho wa Taala don't obey Allah subhana wa Taala obey me or obey this leader or obey this, whatever I mean there are many ideologies many, many religions. So these are the earlier that the Lost Planet Allah is telling us the guardians that are telling us do not take them as supporters if they invite you to conform to this belief to reject the last panel to Allah as your Lord. Now in the next area is talking about our Prophet Mohammed Salah Salem
as he and his mission will be in it was super Of course it is related to the first ayah that the Lost Planet Allah said these prophets and messengers with clear proves bayonet Zuber scripts. So the so they were given scripts and scrolls were zelner la kavika and he after them after these prophets and
messengers will reveal to you the message, that you may make it clear to the people what was sent down to them.
So the explanation of our Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam is highly needed to understand the message of the Quran.
Otherwise, there is no point that the last printer Allah will tell him we appointed you, as a messenger, we sent you this message. So you can explain to people what was revealed to them, what was sent down to them,
will allow you to for korone and that he might give thought.
Now let's go back to the
if it seems that there is a conflict between this ayah this editor telling us that the Quran is complete,
and it was explained in detail,
but from the other side,
Allah subhanaw taala is telling us to listen to the prophet SAW Selim, he will explain the Quran to you. Do you see a contradiction here?
You need to deal with this issue tonight. Sharla
Do you see a contradiction between these verses we're talking about verses in the Quran, not a Hadith, not something we're not talking about an external source. In one side, Allah is telling us, Mohammed Salah is supposed to explain the message to the Muslims
in this is that these people are using this letter saying that this core and the message of the Quran was explained in detail.
How do you solve this problem? Do you see a conflict or contradiction between these?
These people are playing with this, saying I mean the Quran does not need any explanation. Of course they are ignoring the other ayat. And we don't want to ignore any verse. And this is the right methodology. You cannot ignore any verse from the Quran. And there is no contradiction in the book of Allah Subhanallah tan.
If you believe that there is contradiction, that's a different story, then you have doubt about your faith.
You know, you don't have doubt about some knowledge, you have doubt about your faith. If you believe you, you doubt the accuracy of the Quran, there should be no contradiction between the verses of the Quran.
So the contradiction sometimes is not between texts here what
the contradiction could be between our understanding to the text and between another text.
So I come to one text.
And I understand something.
And it stands something from this text from this verse. And I bring another verse. And I believe what I feel that there is a contradiction between the two verses. Wherever reality, there is no contradiction between the two verses. The contradiction is between my understanding to the verse, the first verse, or the first group of verses, and between the other group of verses, or the message of another verse, or another group of verses.
Because there is we have, on the other side, a huge number of versus big number of verses telling us that we need to obey and listen to the Messenger of Allah, and that his mission was to explain the message. But this is what these people are using here. They're telling us that the Quran was well explained.
So as I said, I told you that the owner said, I will repeat this, that the guidance for a person to accept the message of the Quran or the accepted message of Islam and become Muslim. These guidance is well explained in the Quran.
For the person to accept Islam, he doesn't need the sooner you see now the difference after he becomes Muslim, and he believes in the message of the Quran, the Quran will tell him what tell him what a chemo solid
established the prayer, the person will ask how do I establish the prayer?
How I need to know the right way to pray. And the Quran tells him no the right way to pray is not found in the Quran. It is found in the Sunnah of our messenger sallallahu alayhi wa sallam.
Do you see here the this is the view of Allah Sundar will Gemma
So this people here they have an understanding
and that the Quran is rejecting any head if any other speech they are not excluding the speech of Rasulullah Salah, after this Quran you shouldn't listen to any Hadith. How about the Hadees of Rasulullah sallallahu should be excluded because the universal law says Allah is confirming the message of the Quran.
Allah says Allah is not opposing the message of the Quran
and I'm not sure you're looking at me but I'm not sure if you
if you understand what I'm talking about, well I need to I need to maybe to ask you
is that clear one
Because this is very important. You need it you need this this knowledge. And after as I said after I did the halaqa last Friday, some people came to me and said yeah, we know some families who have this problem. Some people who actually they are not praying
the way we pray.
And they said we pray like the way Ibrahim Ali Salim Okay Where is in the Quran? Where is in the Quran that explains to us all the tells us the way Abraham used to pray,
what kind of prayer you are offering.
And we've come to Zakat is the same thing, how much are we going to pay?
The Quran does not give us this, this is guidance, how much you going to pay, how do you calculate your Zakat
and so on and so forth. There are many, many issues, these details and one of the reason I believe a las panatela decided not to include all these details in the Quran. Because if he included everything in the Quran will be a
huge book and it will be difficult for people to to memorize it. Now Allah, Allah has made it easy for us to memorize it this way. 6300 is right around, I don't memorize the exact number,
maybe 6232 or something around that number. Versus, but how about if we have like 20,000 versus 30,000 verses, it could be difficult for most of us to memorize the whole Quran right?
But the last panel to Allah included the fundamental principles of Islam in the book of the last panel.
So to know your aqidah your belief system system, the tenants of your faith, they are well explained in the Quran.
belief in Allah was plenty is a major theme in the crowd, a smoke alarm, the names of Allah, his attributes, you want to know, Allah subhanaw taala go back to the Quran.
Right? You know that you want to know about the message, the mission of the other prophets, their stories, what happened to them with their people go back to the
the Day of Judgment, the details about the Day of Judgment genda not everything is explained in the book of Allah subhanho wa Taala and that is enough. This is the explanation that the last panel to Allah is talking about in the Quran, well explained.
And there is no need for the Sunnah to understand this message about our aqidah.
But when it comes to the other things, the details, the Pillars of Islam.
The prayer has, has also the same thing. Allah subhanaw taala told us about few things in the Quran, but the details of how to perform hajj, we took them from Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam. As a matter of fact, when he wanted to offer harsh he sent letters and messages to different tribes and different places. He wanted people to come to attend has with him so they learn from him.
They learn the way we do hedge properly. There's a famous Hadith from jabber the alarm. And he was with us last I said and he described his hedge in a long Hadith is how you will watching him was doing things and watching him la salatu salam, a learning a learning from him, and this knowledge is found in his sooner AlLahi salatu salam.
I think that's enough with this message here.
There is another post from the other guy that Mohammed wants, the sooner his sooner to be written. I'll talk about it today. inshallah, I'll tell you about some ahaadeeth and what happened during the time during the profession.
Era It is time for Prophet Mohammed Salah la Newson
here the same message another person answering this question the same thing but the Quran is explained in detail. So we see here in bold explained in detail and the message is there is no need for the sooner sorry
the book was explained in detail, so there is no need for the sooner
okay the same thing but this guy is putting the word anything bold to scare you away.
Who can tell you a more reliable Hadith saying that God had he here? Of course it means the Quran not the hadith of Rasulullah Salah this I have 487 in Surah Nisa
I have here certainly Sir 487 here who can tell you a more reliable
than the saying or saying than God or than the saying of God? So the word howdy This is a proof that it doesn't mean the Hadees of Rasulullah Salim only the Quran is called howdy here. But we are answered to them that this reliable Hadith which is the Quran is telling us to follow them Hamad sallallahu alayhi wa sallam and to obey Him and there is no contradiction. The contradiction is between your understanding and between some other verses of the Quran
in what happens after this poor man will leave and believe the same same surah or the same message you know the sort of that he told you sort of more solid
in what had he after this call and will the then believe same message
is not the same surah This is so
the other surah which I mentioned in Surah Masak but the same thing but the Hadith here when he when the person writes it, bold here, where is it?
Okay, on the top here, yeah, what it is bold capital written in capital also send a message here that you shouldn't follow the headache of work. Before a social life. I sell them but how do you hear me in the speech? And it means any speech who opposes which opposes which opposes the message of the Quran?
That is our answer and the answer of Alison ojama. It doesn't mean that Hadees of Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam is excluded from this ayah because Allah in other Ayah told us to believe in Him and OBEY Him and listen to him and follow his Sunnah. Is that clear? I think I don't need I emphasized this, right?
I don't need to waste time with this right?
So let's go to the other question. Now.
There is another fallacious argument. Another specious argument, you know, the, I'll tell you something.
There is called something called tubal head.
And there is a more Miuccia shabby hat. Sometimes when we speak in English we try to translate the Quran and the Sunnah.
The Muhtar, Sharpie hat are doubtful matters, things that are in the gray area.
So when it comes to these methods of disagreement, sometimes we translate them we call them doubtful matters. They are not this argument is fallacious arguments and not doubtful matters. They are cleared for alysha no Jamal.
So we shouldn't call them doubtful matters. Rather, we should call them specious arguments are fallacious arguments, because they appear to be correct. which appears to be plausible, but in reality, they are wrong. You see the difference between them Allah, Allah Azza wa sallam actually said there are things that are clearly halen and other things that are clearly haram right? And between them or more Miuccia shabby has doubtful matters. You come to gelatin, beef gelatin. So Marina Murthy, say it's Helen some Rola Maddy said it's Haram. So this is a doubtful matter in the gray area here. Maybe it's better to leave it at all and only consume, you know, vegetarian gelatin,
So this is a doubtful matter, you're not sure about it, if it is Helen and Helen. So these matters, we should not call them doubtful matters. We're not we have no doubt about them. They are fallacious arguments. They are specious arguments, they are meant to deceive Muslims. Now here, there is another group. They say the sender has a binding authority, but it was not preserved in a trustworthy manner.
Another false argument
because these people did not study the work of the early scholars, when the will have the sooner was recorded and preserved and collected from the time of Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wasallam I will give you an idea inshallah, next halakha Bismillah, we'll talk about it, we have to finish the subject. Third halaqaat will be about the subject too. But we'll give you an idea about the history of preserving and collecting the sun from the time of Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wasallam. We'll talk a little bit about this today. But let's deal with this job here.
hour that he said, So basically, you are saying, we were commanded to fold the messenger. you agree with that? Because they were saying in the first part of the statement, the sooner has a binding authority, they accept that.
Right. Basically, our rules are saying to them, we you're saying that we were commanded to obey the messenger to follow his Sunnah. But we can not carry out this obligation.
Because the sooner was not recorded was not preserved in a trustworthy manner manner. We don't believe in the authority of the sooner or the accuracy of the sooner therefore allies commanding us to carry out an obligation which we cannot do.
And this is clearly against the verse in the Quran, Allah spent Allah said, Hey, you can leave alone absent in Lavasa, Allah subhanho wa Taala does not burden a soul beyond what it can it can bear. Right? If you can't do something, Allah will not command you to do it.
If the sooner is not preserved in the right way, that means we will have doubt in the sooner we will ignore it, we will reject it and we cannot fulfill the commander philosophy cannot Allah, Allah will be asking us to do something in reality, we will not be able we will never be able to do it. Because the sooner was not resolved in detail in a trustworthy manner. Do you see here the argument and the counter argument of our own ummah. And of course, this this is in general, our older man, he said, If Allah subhanho wa Taala made it an obligatory upon us to follow the sooner he has certainly preserve it for us in a reliable manner. Now, this is not a mere statement. It's not statements that
you can make. And that's it. Now, our owner looked at these two things here, which we're going to look into them in Sharla. The history of the sooner preservation the way it was preserved, the way it was recorded, and written down from the time of Rasulullah sallallahu. I'll tell you about some Sahaba, who used to record and collect and write down howdy from the time of Rasulullah, saw Selim, but we will talk about some other issues because in the beginning, I sent him he said, don't try it Hadees I will tell you why.
And the second thing, we look at the Hadith methodology, which we call sciences of Hadith, or masala Hadith, so we ended up having a knowledge, a branch of knowledge, which takes care of the ahaadeeth
you know, the way we know what is authentic, what is fabricated? What is very if it's a knowledge by itself, it's a branch of knowledge. Right? And it's called muscala had had Eve or the sciences of Hadith. So the owner may explain these two things in detail. And through this knowledge, or, you know, this studies and this research, they were able to come up with this statement, that if Allah Allah made it an obligation upon us to follow sooner, then he has certainly preserve it for us in in in a reliable manner.
So we have 15 or 20 minutes left
the writing of the center during the prophetic era here
let's deal with this too heady
to Hades for muscle loss SLM, but before that, there are some haddish.
Before that, I would like to emphasize the same idea that it was talking about.
That we said, Our owner said that Allah subhanho wa Taala told us that Muhammad sallallahu alayhi salatu Nan was supposed to explain the book. Right.
And Alaska. international agenda Vicar we're in Allahu la Vito Verily, We reveal the vicar which is the Quran.
And surely we will preserve it. So Allah, Allah is giving us a promise that he will preserve the vicar, which is the Quran.
The name of allah sooner said, Does it make sense? And in the other I said, We reveal to you the Quran so that you explain it to people, does it make sense to preserve the original book and not to preserve its correct explanation?
Because when haematoxylin was supposed to explain the sun, the plan that means his explanation, Allah subhanaw taala made his explanation in necessity for us to to correctly understand the Quran, you see the argument here.
his explanation is a necessity is highly needed without it, we cannot correctly understand the Quran.
So if the Quran itself the text was preserved, but the right explanation was not preserved, then the the preservation of the thicken will not be complete.
That is the argument of our scholars. Now let's talk about one of the arguments. Let's talk about the the writing of the sooner during the prophetic era. We'll deal with these two three ahaadeeth and then I shall continue in the next halaqaat will give you time to ask questions if you have So in this first Hattie's inside Muslim
said letter to an ni
woman catered by Nero Quran folium who had this one knee while a harsh woman cassava a matcha. mitten foliate above makhado hoomin so this hadith in Sahih Muslim
he said do not write from anything.
So which means don't write my statement, my sayings don't write them.
Right? Woman ketchup and the viral Quran and whoever wrote anything besides the Quran, he should erase it.
Match. Okay, these people who follow this ideology, they will bring this hadith
And they will ignore the other three,
which I'll mention now.
As he don't try to know why. And also last I sell them.
Why did he forbid Muslims from writing the Hadees in the beginning, they don't they don't try to understand this. We have this proof to support their view. And that's enough, and they're happy with it. That the messenger himself and he salatu salam told Muslims to the Sahaba denote right Hadees woman ketubah and the halal Quran and whoever wrote anything besides PR and he should erase it had the through annual he said narrate from me narrate my sayings, without any hesitation. Woman Kesava la mucho amid unforgettable makaha homina na and whoever attributes a lie to me, then he should secure his seat in Ghana.
It's a very dangerous statement right? You have to be careful about sharing fabricated howdy
on WhatsApp and Facebook
have to be extremely careful. These headings by the way is mutawatir. I'll tell you what is mutawatir
which awatea There is no doubt that this hadith is authentic. Right?
By the other hand, if
this is Hadith, Abdullah Abdullah Ramadan, alas.
Come to actor bucola Shea, whom in the Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam will read to him. He said I used to write
everything from the Messenger of Allah.
And I wanted to memorize this Hadeeth his sayings fella Hackney parish some people from koresh, they were Muslims. But we were from kurush Moroccans who lived in Medina.
The tell him he told him you should not write anything you hear from Rasul Allah says Allah. What was the reasoning? We said he was he's a human being, who gets sometimes angry.
Who gets angry, he's just a human being who gets angry. You might be writing something that is not part of the religion.
Something which he says la salatu salam were in the state of anger, right? That was their argument. Those Muslims didn't know but that was their argument.
He said for insect, I stopped after class.
And then I went to law school licensing.
And I told him, this is what people are saying, I used to write everything I hear from you write it down. So I want to memorize I want you to memorize your Hadith. But these people are saying, Do you notice? You're not supposed to write everything you hear from us? Allah says Allah, because he he's a human being. And he might say something while being angry, for example. So it also last SLM pointed to his mouth.
He said, Well, Levy, levy nafsa Mohamed in Ba, les hoomin, who in fact,
he said by the word, the soul of Mohammed is in his hands. Who is Allah subhanaw taala his swearing by the name of Allah, lay hoomin who he pointed to his mouth and he salat wa sallam, he said nothing comes out of it except the truth. So write and keep writing.
But now, and there is a third story here, a be shocked to Buddha. I wish this guy is Yemeni.
He came and attended Hajj with us all as well.
And also last I saw him was giving
the speech the sermon, you know, the last sermon, it's a famous sermon
in Makkah in his hash during his hash, and it was a long speech. This guy was not able to memorize everything Rasulullah Salim said
said the RSO law I want you to write something for you I want to benefit from this knowledge.
Because he was not able to write himself. So what Rasulullah Salim did he said look tabula avintia he told some of his companions write this speech for avishka who is Boucher as I said he is a guy who came from Yemen. He attended the the Hollywood with Rasulullah assassin and there are some other ahaadeeth in which also Lhasa Salem allowed the Sahaba to write down his Sunnah by you tell me she has and there is a contradiction between the first Hadith
and the other hand is
how do we how can we solve this contradiction?
Do you see the contradiction?
You see it?
So in the first half he said don't write
Don't try to make Hadith.
And anyone who wrote anything besides the Quran he should raise it. Right? The other hand he allowed of the love No Iman Ross, he said write down. Don't worry, said nothing comes out from my wife in my mouth accepted truth.
How can we solve this problem?
Do you have an idea? This is a famous story, by the way and Rama have an answer they have an answer for that. Remember, as soon as you have an answer for that, what is what is what is vicious what is not fair is to select the first Hadith and ignore the other Heidi and claim that the sooner was not recorded was not recorded during the life of our Prophet Mohammed Sasson.
Is that fair to ignore? Take some had eaten ignore some other ahaadeeth Oh, this added don't support to our view by views, I will just use these ones because you have a desire. However,
when you follow a false ideology, you only bring those a decent at verses that support and endorse your false ideology. But if you are a truth seeker, if you follow and hack and you follow you seek the truth, you bring all the proofs together, right? All of them and you try to if there is a contradiction, then you try to solve it or you read what the scholar said about this conflicting reports. There is a clear contradiction here. You don't have an answer. No one wants to help me with any answer sisters.
Okay, that's exactly the right answer. Our odema gave in the beginning for salasar salam was worried about the Sahaba they could be writing and mixing Quran between mixing between Quran and the Hadith.
And this will be a disaster. Right? Our our sources of guidance will not be will not be
preserved in the right way, right, in a trustworthy manner. Actually, this is a sign of his trustworthiness, Allah salatu salam, that he was a true messenger of God, he wanted people to clearly separate between the words of God and between his own sayings. So he wanted Muslims to be familiar with the different styles, with the style of the Quran, and B and in between his sayings, a hadith when he felt that Muslims now are well aware, they know the Quran, they are able to distinguish between the Quran and between his sayings. Then he allowed them he said, Now he can write.
But they used to narrate and they used to memorize before that he had Italia Salatu was Salam. And many of them would hear it from another Sahabi and he went he still he was still alive. They used to go to the zoo last I saw him and verify those howdy from him and he is Salatu was Salam. But this is how the lemma solved this issue. They said in the beginning, he commanded the Sahaba not to write anything from him, until he made sure that the Sahaba are familiar with the sign of the Quran. Then he allowed them to write a hadith and some of them some of the Sahaba they had scrolls, which included the route 1000 Hadith once a hobby would have 1000 Hadith in his in his house, so it's
part of the Sunnah it's a big part of the sooner was recorded during his life Elisa to Sarah will talk about it.
Next halaqa inshallah now, do you have any question regarding what I what I talked about tonight? It's very important, the one because I know we want to deal with this issue. And that's it. We don't want to be confused, right? No one wants to be confused in this life. You want to meet a Lost Planet Allah with your cane. Right? With your cane with certainty should be confident. Actually, there is a crisis, confidence crisis within our circles nowadays. And the way we read our scripts, the way we read the Quran, understand the Quran the standard of had had either first or last SLM, we're facing many challenges. And the problem is goes back to lack of knowledge. We're not we're not giving
enough time to this area, the knowledge of Sharia, the brother raise his hand before you further that this is enough. The brother is saying that you know to respond to the specious arguments of this guy and all the other guys who are you know, who are attacking the authority of the Sunnah could be this ayah in Surah, Allah Emraan which is mentioned surah
number 31. Cool in quantum to a boon Allah phetchaburi Rooney, Allah were very lucky novacom say all Mohamed, if you really love Allah, then follow me. Allah, Allah to Allah is asking your proof.
What is the proof? He says the UK you claim that you love Allah subhanho wa Taala I want to prove
what is the proven here in this ayah
not love is it follow me?
There is a difference between loving the prophet and following his Sunnah. Both of them are required right? But the asset for Toby Rooney Follow me Follow what
he said Allah salatu salam
ala what will happen to you that Allah will two gifts, you get two gifts, you're welcome Allah, Allah will love you and He will forgive.
forgive your sins, two things, you get two things. So for our brother here, which is Allah Harris said, This is enough for me. I don't need to waste my time with this but you are not that's good handle the leg of this guidance from the Quran. The problem is our youth don't have access to easy access to the Quran.
The reading these things on the internet. So we have to deal with these things. We have to prepare ourselves. I mean, I don't want to, for someone to come with this, you know, these arguments in front of you? And he said, Ah, I don't know. I'm not sure you know what to do that right? You need to be prepared is what we want to do. Yes. Okay. So they are actually they are saying the Quran, the Quran saying we shouldn't listen to any other speech, but at the same time, yeah. Just listen to the Quran. Don't listen to any other speech, but at the same time, they're bringing a different speech right, an explanation we're bringing, so they are telling us Do not listen to the explanation of the
Messenger of Allah. But listen to my explanation. This is good point.
Baraka lofi. Yes, brother
are saying, also don't listen to the explanations of the scholars. So you are actually doing what? saying I am? I mean, who are you? I mean, we don't listen to the Prophet, we don't listen to the scholars, but who are you?
So, if you are a scholar, you should be included in the group of scholars, all the scholars, right? We didn't listen to anyone besides the Quran, so we shouldn't listen to you. Yes. Did you understand his argument? Or his point? further? Yeah, I mean, it's, we need some you need to do some effort.
Some effort here, if you want to have a clearer idea. Of course, you will not be a scholar of Hadith. And you are not supposed to be a scholar of Hadith. You have your own specialty, your own family, your own business. But as a Muslim, at least if you have some doubts about, you know, this must Allah before you adopt this conclusion, the conclusion of this people are you allow their arguments you allow to come into your heart, you know, and create some doubt about the authority of the sooner when you study what the owner of Arizona said about this methodology, Hadeeth methodology and the history, at least you get an idea that there was a process, there was a systematic approach.
There is something called a snared system and the odema they have the they have their own, you know, way of recording a heartbeat and verifying ahead if you're not going to do it. I'm not going to do it. But at least if you have a conclusion about it, Buhari you study about it Buhari and the historical Buhari, and the way it was collected, and you are happy, right? So you use harissa sauce, it's easy. You can get easy access to all Buhari go to solar.com find the Buhari their Muslim soon and tell me the sooner you measure. But if you want me to give you a quick answer, the best sources have had either Buhari and and Muslim. Right. When it comes to other sources of Hadith, they contain
what is authentic and what is weak. Some of them even have some fabricated Hadith. But the main sources of Hadith is the six of the books the six collections of added Buhari and Muslim
soon until maybe sooner libido sooner. And sooner and unnecessary, right? And besides these six collections of IDs, we have Muslim Mr. Mohammed, we have more palaemon Malik and we have you know, some other some other Mr. Dracula, ma'am, hacking some other sources? No, here, as I'll tell you about my methodology, for example.
I have my own websites in Arabic And I have my own books. When I want to verify the authenticity of a hadith.
If it is in Bukhari Muslim, that's enough for me.
I don't I don't double check the authenticity of a hadith. If it is found in Bukhari and Muslim, I have enough confidence that will Buhari is an excellent book. And it is the best book of Hadith after the Quran. It is the best book of Hadith. The best. This is some sort of there is some sort of consensus about it. Within the Muslim scholars of Allison ojama.
When had is not found in Bukhari and Muslim soon, and Timothy, for example,
Timothy, He will give His own statement conclusion about the Hadith.
Who will tell you so he or her son, or her son, he hasn't sorry, right. But I know that there are some weeks ahead he in a chair meeting. So I go to method, and this is a website called the daughter.
NET dotnet. But it's in Arabic. But then I'm sure that there are some other websites as soon as the.com is in English, for example, or the headings are translated in English. And there are many sources. But I'll tell you, they are this website, I use it. And they give me details. They give me the conclusions of many scholars about that specific Hadith. And I'll find in this website with about one headies, maybe 10 or 11, sometimes 15 versions of the same Hadith. And one of the contemporary scholars that I trust his conclusions about the Hadees and emammal Alberni, Rama to lyerly.
Many people recognize his authority and his scholarship
and his status in the field of Hadeeth among the contemporary scholars,
so and he has done a lot of work about Hadith. And so these would confirm method and howdy that is found in Sudan determining who will tell you he would confirm it will tell you he is authentic, or he will tell you it's very safe. And then I don't stop there. I have to look into the other conclusions that the others
sometimes up to 10 years, sometimes other scholars of Hadith.
And I look into their conclusions and come up with a conclusion about Hadith before I include it in my hotbar what I included in my speech, this what they do is I don't want to use a weak Hadith, but if there is a difference of opinion sometimes some scholars they said it is hard It hasn't sound that the other scholars said is that if, if it is about four vital ml about and supplications It is enough for me that some qualified scholars said it hasn't. And it's only about some beautiful do as well it's not a big problem is not a big issue is not like a pizza or a matter about smell or suffer for lost power to Allah or a very important matter in business or a very important matter in math
and in other issues that are very important. You know, before you a marriage, for example, divorce, you know, before you make a decision about how you should you use it or not, you know, you cannot just be okay, if this are some scholars who said it's the eighth, then they have to spend more time with this Hadith, trying to reach a conclusion about this is what how we do it.
Right. When you spend more time with knowledge, you will you get used to it.
But you need to at least get an idea Shahla next halakhah I'll tell you about what happened about the recording of the Sunnah and give you some idea about Michelle Buhari and Muslim and the other books speedily lighter. Well, the the this brother is saying how do they interpret the Quran those who are rejecting the Howdy. They said no the Quran. So basically they are saying Muhammad sallallahu alayhi wa sallam was a mere messenger,
like anyone who would deliver a message, courier right deliver a message. And he has he was not supposed to,
to tell people about it or explain it or there is nothing else. The Quran and that's it. And it's enough, it will explain God is saying it was well explained. So the Quran should be enough for us. So we understand it the way when we read it will just get to whatever guidance we get it from the Quran, right?
So they don't have to go to the books of Tafseer. They don't have to use the Hadith. No, he used their own interpretation. Or basically they are telling people use your own interpretation, your your own understanding to understand the Quran.
Does it make sense?
It's impossible. It's impossible. There are there are Arabs who don't understand the language of the Quran. Not everything but there are some difficult terms in the Quran. They are not Arabs who speak the Arabic language. They're not familiar with these terms
in English, studying it in English.
I know I know, I know. I know, what was the second part of your question? Which other types of law any
other branches of knowledge?
No, they are not applying any security they are not studying because if they study really study the sooner and study the poor and I mean, if we don't ignore the other verses, which we mentioned in the last halaqa if we don't ignore them, recognize those eight and try to follow the guidance of those verses halus the problem would be solved.
Right? Because he cannot come to the Quran to any subject in the Quran, ignore some verses and take only some observers he can do that. This is not honesty,