Abdur-Raheem McCarthy – Does vomiting break your Wudu

Abdur-Raheem McCarthy
AI: Summary © The speakers discuss the issue of vomiting breaking rules and whether or not a large amount of vomit would break the window. They mention that while some people believe that vomiting doesn't break the rule, the experts say that it does. They also discuss the importance of having a strong will when vomiting is considered a factor.
AI: Transcript ©
00:00:00 --> 00:00:33

Does vomiting break our will do? And is there a difference between a large amount of vomit and a small amount of vomit? Or do both of them break our will? Do the scholars have different regarding this issue? Some of them say, yes, it breaks the window. And some of them say no vomit doesn't break our will do. If we want to determine if something breaks the will do or not how we're going to determine there has to be a video there has to be an evidence from the Quran or from the Sunnah, that this action breaks our will do. But if there is no delay, there's no evidence that we cannot say that something breaks a rule, there is a Hadith that he mama Tirmidhi narrated the hadith of

00:00:33 --> 00:01:09

abode there there will be Allahu and that the Prophet daddy sent out to a Salam that he vomited. And then he made will do. However, this hadith as many scholars mentioned, it is not authentic, it's vibe, it's a week narration. And that's why the scholars of the Maliki and Chef Emeth have they said that vomiting doesn't break the will do whether it's a small amount of vomit, or a large amount of vomit, because there's no clear evidence from the Quran and Sunnah. That proves that vomiting breaks tool in the hands of V and humbly a meth head, they say that the large amount of vomit breaks the window and meaning the difference of opinion here. If it's a small amount that comes up in your

00:01:09 --> 00:01:39

mouth, as it happens to some of us, this doesn't break the window, the scholars who say it breaks through will do they're talking about the large amount of vomit that comes out. And they differ themselves determining what is a large amount and what is not. Some of them said he goes back to the order for the custom. And wherever people consider to be a lot that's a lot. Other ones said if it's like a mouthful, then that's considered a lot and that breaks the window. So the fact that the Hadith itself is not authentic, and even it was authentic, the scholar said even if it was authentic, it doesn't prove that it's false. It's compulsory to make although if you vomited if he

00:01:39 --> 00:02:14

had vomited, and then said when you vomit make whoodle That would be clear that you have to make wudu after if you were to vomit, however, just as action, the fact that he did it, the scholar said that's not clear proof that you must make although after you vomit, therefore the opinion that vomiting does not break. FUBU is the stronger view when it comes to the delille the evidence from the Quran and Sunnah. And Jacqueline SNAM even told me he takes the opinion that it's most to have that it's something praiseworthy to do, and you don't have to do it, but it's better if you do and if you were to take this opinion, to get away from the color of the difference of the scholars, you

00:02:14 --> 00:02:23

could do that. But it would be something that is good, something's praiseworthy, not something that's a must. And Allah knows best Allahu Allah. Allah wa sallim wa barik ala Nabina Muhammad

Share Page

Related Episodes