Session 28 The Halal, Haram & Doubtful
Channel: Munir Ahmed
File Size: 57.45MB
humbly layer below the mean
Salatu was Salam.
ala alihi wa sahbihi wa.
Salam, O Allah, Allah.
Allah to Allah.
And you're the puppet min
Ruben de Anessa yet in a lesser sallahu Brandman Nafi what is come was here are the network while you know you Massoud
well a Hollywood La Quwata illa de la isla de la
we begin always as prey by praising Allah subhanaw taala asking please help and guidance and forgiveness and sending Peace and blessings on his messenger Muhammad sallallahu alayhi wa sallam
we asked him to accept from us
our efforts and our deeds
we asked Allah subhanaw taala to
give us beneficial understanding and knowledge like
we depend on Him and to Him is our golden return and but there's no power mic except that of Allah.
We are on Halley's number six.
We're moving on
my father, Mr. Minogue and ABI Abdillah
and no man in number should not be Allahu Anhu Mofaz semi to the SU La La he sallallahu alayhi wa salam ala good.
Anil Hala Yin. Were in the Haram Abba Yin may know well more than water shall be heard.
La ya la Mohan NACA see room minuteness. Family Takahashi will hurt faculty stab Rollatini he was the
woman Walker official who had worked on Phil haraam.
Karachi how I'll hammer
you SQL and your taffy. Allah what in what Allah what inelegantly Mullikin Hema, Allah in hemiola Hill Maha Remo Allah ineffable just to be more law is Salah had Salah hell Jesu Kulu what is that faceted? Festival Jesu Kulu Allah wa el cual roba will Buhari roba who Buhari you are Muslim?
Will do the translation says that Abdullah
Abdullah and no matter have never shaved.
Well, I've been pleased with them both said that he heard. He said I heard the Messenger of Allah say salAllahu alayhi salam? Surely
the law firm has been made clear and plain.
Surely the prohibited Haram has been made also clear from play.
And between them both are issues or doubtful matters.
Most people don't know about them. Leia Amana, Cassie Cassio Menendez. Most people don't know that.
And whoever avoids and stays away from doubtful matters, then he or she has cleared they've cleared themselves in the guards to the to his or her dean. And in regards to the honor,
whoever falls into doubtful matters, falls into haram.
Like the shepherd grazing,
meaning grazing his animals
but the shepherd who graze our pastures around the sanctuary, all book grazing veteran surely
every king has a sanctuary.
or Truly, Allah sanctuary, Allah sanctuary is his prohibitions.
And truly, then the prophesies, I'm truly in the body, there is a morsel of flesh, if it be whole, whole wholesome, healthy, then the whole of it is wholesome, unhealthy meaning the body, if it be
then the whole of it is corrupted
the whole of the body.
Truly it is the heart.
Some translations of putting this translation here, for example, says is disease, then the whole of it is diseased. facade, facade is less to do with disease unless you want to use disease in a metaphoric sense. Green fast facade means corruption.
So not disease in a physical sense, what I'm trying to say
this hadith, as I said, is reported on Bihari Muslim.
this is one of the Hadith that
we said that I will hold for example, as mentioned, the famous transmitter of the sun, the collection of Hadith without a CG Stanny and said that
there are four Hadith
on which the whole of the deen is best. Remember, I repeat this a few times in the Malama Lavinia the first one that we did every day is just by its intention.
And then what are the other ones was
the one that we did last at least number five last time, about Bedarf because that was countering all that which is wrong to innovate in matters of religion to bring new things in regards to which we've been not given authority and permission to
that was one of them. And this is one of the other ones from the fall in the Hala Yun
because it's it's covering the whole of religion, halal haram and something in between. Okay. So that's why it's such a fundamental Hadith. This is reported by a non Muslim neighbor, she, we don't know that much about a non Muslim membership, except that he was young Sahabi and he was ALLAH Ma said around 10 years of age, only about 10 years of age, when the prophesied Salam passed away sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, so it was young. Most of his Hadith which are around all of our Hadith about 116 Hadith are reported in various compilation only about six in Behati which doesn't mean I said all the rest are a week by any means.
But around 116 over 100 IVs are reported from the Prophet SAW sent by ignore my name never ship even though it was such a young age. And unlike other young companions, when most of the Hadith they got and when they're so young, from other senior Sahaba when they say the prophesy some said Yes, they've learned from other as a harbor didn't lie. So got it the prophesy some said but this heavy if he says summit to summit to I heard meaning I heard he heard the message of Allah service, okay. And he is said to have been killed in the Sharm in 64 after hijra, so he was about 64 years of age really, because
the publicized son passed away and 11th After he dropped when he was about 10 years of age or even say 10 Going on to 11. So he must have been born. Yeah, very soon after, around the time of the migration of Rasulullah Salallahu Salam Yes. So this is a non binding membership
this hadith is reported in various other places in atma double gold accuracy and decided the merger as well. And as always, and also reported from the likes of Alma
run Java they've never sold and Abbas has various transmitted transmissions and slight variations in words, but the meaning overall is this hadith itself
which unknowingly decided to pick
the words of Bucha mentioned Bukhari and Muslim.
in the law Hello Allah you
the halal all that which is halal has been made clear
and in contrast well I know haram of a year, surely that which has been prohibited has also been made clear been made clear by who,
by Allah, His Messenger
by Allah and His messenger
and then webinar well more on watershed we have between them both are doubtful matters.
come away with the idea that there's so many things which are doubtful.
So many things that are hurtful, okay, and some scholars give that kind of answer which leads people into thinking there's so many doubtful matters. So the best way is, like the have you think staying away?
That's the wrong conclusion. Actually. Allah serwotka didn't send this been full of doubtful Metris.
Quite the opposite. It didn't leave most of our life in dark format. We were wandering in the darkness. Should I do that? Should I not do that? What kind of religion would that be? How can Allah smart Allah says as he says, In the Quran, Allium acmo. To lacantina Kumar atman to Aliko near Mati what are the two la Kumala Islam Medina today this day I have
perfected Yeah, your religion for you. Complete in my favor upon you perfected your religion for you completed my favorite upon you. And I'm pleased for you with Islam as the religion way of life so perfection of religion towards the end of life as soon as I mean he's given us guidance completely we need to live by not know we spend most of our life teetering and tottering around or is it is it is it now is it not? And then who okay then just out of precaution and still with just our precaution, life is a blip by Muslims out of precaution.
Some people got this understanding from this reason we'll see Shewhart what it's actually meaning. So, in contrast to the picture we may get that life is full of doubts, actually it isn't Allah smart Allah made our way clear. Quran makes that clear the prophesy Sullivan said to that to come. Allah.
Allah Allah VEDA Nokia 10 LELO ha Kalahari her Yeah.
I have left you. He's saying on on a clear and clean
way. Allah by law by that means white lit up. Yeah. Nothing here. Clear. Clean.
LELO Hakuna Hadiya its day is like it's night meaning in the clarity, this theme, Leila Kannadiga la Yos ego unhappy la Horicon. And no one who goes astray from this light. Day and night has been lit up. Yeah, this is the kind of Dean I left you on. No one but goes away from this Dean except they'll be destroyed in LA Helicon. But first and foremost, know who I am and what tagliani disbelief is in Atmel and famous and important studies of how the Prophet SAW Salem has left Yeah, this Dean a way of life which is not full of that filmmakers. But it's nice he's clear this day. Yeah. Yeah. So even here night and day you go Babs, sometimes contrast a night with clear the day is prohibitions and
eight is clear this
that which has been made Hello. Both have been made clear.
So when that's the foundation, and that's the understanding we must have first before we look at this
because if we're not clear
about how ALLAH the messenger the prophesy some came and lived all those years to complete the deen all his foundation on all these little things were left. The Quran came to do to been Allah Swami says
Well Alexander I like a victory a little by little Reina Lin. Linares man who Zilla Elaine him And We have sent down to you or Muhammad Sallallahu Sallam that reminder.
So that you may explain to human beings what has been sent down upon them. Explain means you get rid of that you clarify. So you may clarify how they are to follow it, and he's
come out all at me Nina? I Shalonda kinda Hulagu who? Hulu Quran. His character is the Quran. He was the walking talking. He exemplified it. Yeah. And that's what I was was saying about the TBR then Vanessa Lee cookie taba, TBR Nan liquidly shade. Yeah. And we are set down to you the book, the Scripture the revelation to clarify everything for you think beyond the liquidly shade.
Yeah. So now when you have that's the outset you must approach this Hadith from
Tiana liquidly che so you're gonna think well, not too shabby. How can there be lots of water Javea then doubtful matters when Allah saying we've clarified everything that you need to know for you?
Follow me. So that's the foundation then we approach this hadith and it will become clear for us so ALLAH SubhanA den says haram Halal has been made clear
and Haram has been made clear so
when we come to Halal
is a wider area because if you look at
for example the
in jurisprudence the legal rulings from the Sharia then we find that they've been categorized into that which is why did
fun we can say well, and I'm summarizing we're gonna go into details of these yeah
Oh, anyway, the 100 fear who add to this I'm not going to go into it. Overall this is it. They just divide this into two and they divide the HaRav into mcru. Definitely in the FMz depending on how they how it came in. It was in 130 for example, but we don't need to go into that
when we look at Halal
which categories of Halal cover
in those five let me explain briefly.
The first one watch him have to do it.
And you do it rewarded if you don't do it. Sinful haram. Okay, which is back here. Yeah, but really watch it do it must do it must do it rewarded for doing it. Not doing it punish Mundo. Almost the hub
recommended to do but not obligatory. Do It rewarded. Don't do it.
No. No punishment, no reward but no punishment. No sin.
MOBA it's all up to you. Most of life.
The biggest area
MOBA, as I explained to you previously, as well, lastly, the same thing. Most of life. Yeah, we don't go for crying references Hadith when I'm going to get up and stand up and walk around and go to work and come back and have my meal and spend time with my family and go out for it. I don't keep referring to the Crown Khalifa that neither did the Sahaba they were already doing all those things when it came to adjusting certain things. All right, most of that MOBA. Okay. But do it with the intention, even MOBA. Go to sleep? Have good so that I can have strength? Go to sleep
Earlier I want to wake up on time I need to rest my body because Allah wants me to rest my body. I eat all the foods MOBA but I stay away from conceive and, and dead meat etc. And don't drink alcohol or drink all the other drinks. I've got that from being rewarded even in the mobile process even that cancels you better than
even the mundane things becoming. Alright? But that's so macro. Just like dislike stay away from it rewarded do it.
No saying very important.
Haram, stay away from it, absolute prohibition, do it sinful stay away from it, which is obligated to stay away from it rewarded. So
that's a revision whereas Halal done
and Haram, this family
that in itself shows you the mercy of a Muslim
Most of our life Hello.
Yeah. Because most of it's covered in what is made haram there's only a small
follow me. So Halal doesn't necessarily mean some people think Halal means that which is MOBA.
It includes that it but to pray five times a day
is Hello, of course it's a lot because it's font. It's actually more than that.
But how covers all that all that field meaning those things that we are not only allowed to do maybe that were recommended to do we have to do and don't think we are disliked for them, but they're still okay to do. There's no sin in them. All right.
Now, when we come up with a show via this is something that we need to have a little think about. Okay. So,
hello, we'll come in any of those categories. So when we talk about Halal most of life is halal.
We don't need text. That's why and I mentioned it to you last time I think that Allah, Allah ma, when they look at evidence for dealing with situation in more analog, of course, which is dealings and doings and social life, not to do with the bad and appealed and beliefs, remember, they are very special fields. But most of jurisprudence is to do with what's going on in everyday life on the Look at that. It's that don't find anything in the Quran, in finding a new situation, right using a credit card, for example, instead of money using money nowadays, which is not like what was used in those times
where they used to trade with crop with crop dates with dates and etc. That's how people did all over the world, we have a different scenario. So now Allama look at see, is there anything in the Quran? Is there anything that if they don't find anything? Yeah. To show that something that they come across is prohibited, for example, or look at chaos, even analogical reasoning, find some link with something new is already mentioned that can't find anything that that then they say, well, what's the original ruling about anything? They say is this hub
is this hub, meaning it is everything is allowed except that which is prohibited
which is allowed.
So MOBA is that field where everything is allowed in life except you find evidence to say well, it's not the onus of proof is on the person.
That's what is halal for example.
So we don't have to have texts from the Quran to say specifically this is allowed for you sitting down like that slide for you. When you get home, you have to stand up, we'd have to go for text.
We don't have to find text doing but actually,
somebody will think that so there is no evidence in the Quran or sunnah for MOBA,
actually there is the fact that Allah is messengers stay silent about something on purpose.
isn't evidence is enough?
Is it not? It is. That isn't evidence,
because some people ask, and this is a discussion amongst also even amongst people of jurisprudence amongst themselves well, from time immemorial, saying MOBA shouldn't really be there because we don't need to look at text for that. But there are others said yes. It is a ruling said well, there's no rule here. No other said there is a rule here. The fact that the Charette the law giver stayed quiet about it purposefully is a ruling is a ruling in a wisdom and actually I believe the secondary that there is a wisdom to show also the mercy of Allah's father the vast majority of life is left to you.
is left to you.
Left to you to do as as you please, to your to your choice. So
Allah sua says el el mal Halal Okamoto de Burgh this day
all good things have been made halal for you
have held along with the local Moutai but as in Surah, Allah in the Quran, Allah Swatara says and this came later
that itself is a principle. We don't actually need that text because it just doesn't then list all the time.
Yeah, we understand. Unless one says L Yo Ma hayleigh Lokomotiva ya Allah what are they? It doesn't give you a list.
Today, this day, all good things have been made lawful for you.
Allah gives you a list of that which he has forbidden you so now you know which are things which
which are the good things because you only forbid you from things which are not by you.
Understand, it works the other way. So hailer field is wide open for you.
What am Alladhina Autokey taba Hallo lagoon something else was added in this verse in surah. ALMA is that and the food of the people of the book has been made halal for you. What are Muslim halal, the home and your food have been made halal for them? Yeah. And of course this has discussions on it we're not going to go into that today
because this will be linked specifically to do with meat.
We're not talking about rice and vegetables and things like that. Okay, whether it's allowed or not meat now
when we come to meat
it's an interesting meat itself has a slightly different situation for believers. How
which doesn't apply to the rest of food
right? That same principle don't apply to Rice vegetables crops, anything else but when it comes to meat
something specific happens and it changes
because because now we are allowed to eat that which is slaughtered
that which is slaughtered only
so it turns the other way. It's not all meat so out for you. So you just go in any old house stop eating anybody's mean? No, it's the other way. Yeah. However, that principle is still there.
All meat is allowed for you.
Yeah, all the types yet except conceive and then
that can apply as well. Yeah, all meat is allowed for you. But in another sense when you're talking about depending on specially in the country that we live in, if we live in a Muslim country.
If we live in a Muslim country, all my neighbors or society except 1% 2% are all Muslim. All sorts are Muslim. Now he goes to somebody's house and says is this means slaughtered?
There'll be an insult. So now you can play that principle. All meat is allowed for you. You don't go around asking in household are you serving concede today?
That is the height of insult. Yeah, you don't do so that principle still holds all is allowed for you except that which has been forbidden and you don't need to ask them. You don't need to ask
But if you're not in that situation, and you have significant people and we live in a specially non Muslim environment, then the idea is the turn tables turn now you want to check, is it been slaughtered?
Yeah. Has it been slaughtered?
That's the question.
And when you've got idol worshipers and people, then he goes further than that.
Yeah, then he goes further than that. Not only is it slaughtered, but you have to check now, not just for me now, for idol worshipers, even the rice and the vegetables, etc. And the lentil? If it has been all if it has been offered at the altars of
their gods, are you allowed to eat it? No, no, no, you're not
altar that that not just the meat then applies to the rice. Yeah, so he's taking it to a different level because of that specific thing.
They've taken the lentil and you know, offered the lentil and blessed it of the altars of the the statues. And now they bring it back has been blessed by their priests.
That is not the same. Otherwise the lentil they cook, Hindus, Sikhs, are you allowed to eat as you
see Sikhs don't have idol worship anywhere, but certainly, you know, Hindus, Indian, Hindu, you know, go to the house and they serve lentil and vegetables and things go to Indian restaurant not to eat.
Yeah. And of course, again, the general idea, you don't go to any Indian restaurants. Did you take this to the altars of your idols? You don't do that. You don't do that. But generally they don't. They do it a special things. And actually, yeah,
they do as a special thing. Okay.
So in regards to meat and altars and offering the changes, yeah, but he changes in an environment. I told you the Muslim environment you don't you don't ask that because this is as a country as a society.
Knowledge l maloom. Fit Dini, Ventura. Everybody knows from Muslim Dexys knowledge that no Muslim can have an excuse that they didn't know about that I'm not Am I allowed to eat this or not allowed to eat? Or I didn't know I was I was allowed to not allow to eat pig.
in a Muslim society. I've been saving it all my life who could say that?
in a Muslim society. You all are said perhaps in a non Muslim society, especially when Muslims started first arriving.
You know, centuries back and coming to a environment where it's totally non Muslim. And there's somebody who embraces Islam from that society. Perhaps they could say for some time, I didn't know. I didn't know. They could maybe have an excuse but not living in a Muslim society. Okay.
So, for example, Allah somata says, Holy mackerel, he will Mater to what dumb who will ask milkins Eve? What has been made haram for you all is the dead, the blood?
Well, Mackenzie, and the flesh of swine, the pig, we're all mentioned the word pig by the way.
If you translate it saying pig
Okay, so there's no problem saying pig. And I said in one lecture about 15 years ago, I have to say, from the lecture, people have issues for using the medicine say definitely PNG
or the animal with no name
is very common in our community, you know that.
It's been common for since I remember the child as a childhood. In childhood. I remember my sister if they want to call it anything big. They won't say a big
my parents didn't teach that but there was this this culture.
I said what the Quran says the word pig what you do when it says how do we matter like well, they don't know what demo Well, half moon be WeMo Hill lelling You don't say that?
I'm saying it was that? Of course they get mixed up with the idea of insulting each other with the word pig or dog is insulting, isn't it? When you don't say for a dog, therefore don't call say dog to eat. So there's so when the word dog comes out, we go bleep. But they did it with the pig.
I remember when I gave this talk as
during the talk I said big big big big big
to stress on the point there's no problem here
don't call each other pig that's different. That's just insulting you know don't be Don't insult each other but to use the word is ridiculous that you're not allowed to use the word.
It's not even from the macro. It's not from the macro.
Quran is using the word Subhan Allah
Okay, and the flesh of pig or swine and that which has been Mao Hillel, the real lobby, that which has been slaughtered for others besides our
now slaughtered by naming hooba or naming the elephant God or naming ROM or whatever, you know.
And then even if it's slaughtered then yeah, to let the blood drain out even if it's thought is haram.
Yeah, well, more than honeycombe and that which has been strangled
the rehab even if you say Bismillah Allahu Akbar. Strangle Yeah, the farmer strangled the chicken not allowed
Yeah, even the meat of the People of the Book Oh ALLAH Mara greed is allowed as long as they are
doing slaughter and which is what all of Europe does actually.
Yeah they all slaughter
been slaughterhouses I can tell you is part of them European rule that they cut the neck to let the blood flow
so that's what slaughter means. Allah mad disgust for and I'm not gonna go into the details of it but I just mentioned all a man discuss even if one of the
Crockett sides was cut some said no both have to because some said both after we got both sides and the esophagus and the trachea other said no one's enough the idea is the cup to the neck and the blood flow flows out
so these would be better but anyway 100 Struggling is not the same it's not acceptable it's not the Bihar is not
tense KIA 10 KIA not test Kia
this test here. What does that mean?
With a Zed or z
what does that mean?
To the key him to purify
to purify Tez key as the car comes from purification the chi is from that same thing, but 10s Kia
is a totally different word
well not with a zap this means ritual slaughter
This means slaughtering Okay? Slaughtering by cutting the neck letting the blood drain that is called key
even that's a question mark. It means that
Yeah, well 100 got strangle well moku rattle that which is hit with a violent blow and then dies can't have that animal dead. All these are under the category of dead the strangled hit with something and died dead they'd all be covered by maintenance which has already been mentioned. Now it's giving you different ways of what's called Death Yeah, well what are what are the that which has fallen down and died from a mountain or an animal and you find it that you can't have it has not been slaughtered and it's not been hunted. Okay. What what what not to do that which has been gored by the horns of another animal that's been killed some of these animals sticks it's all again
another way of being killed so it's dead. Yeah wama Accola several and that which a predator is eaten animals. Lions half eaten it you can't turn up and say we love someone I know.
Cheers up the lion is dead. Okay, it counts is dead. Illa Mazda Mazda katoen the katoen except that which you slaughter
set that which you slaughter now
one that will be Harlan
Allah nossob and that which has been slaughtered at the altars
been offering to the gods.
What antastic SEMO bill as lamb Valley conviced. What also is prohibited? Is that you divide the meat. Yeah, according to drawing arrows ruffling.
Allah says, No, that's not acceptable.
Something again, they used to do in Jalili times as well, again, to do with their superstitions, linked with their superstition of beliefs, Jalili beliefs, okay.
All of this is Fiske, all of this is bad, all of this is wrong. This kind of meet, the exception has been given. So when we say I'm only giving us an example,
to show how the Haram has been made clear, and remember Haram is limited. Not only is it limited as one category among the five, but the number of things which have been made haram, in all categories are life a very limited.
If you think of all the mushroom bath and all the drinks, there's only one called Hamid, which has been prohibited everything else you can have. It's not the other way around, is it? And then people focus on that.
So difficult this a religion, we can't think we can't have a drink alcohol.
So if we had 100 drinks, you've been stopped from one and you think he's difficult.
That's why, as I mentioned in my hotbars, when I mentioned before to you, when the promise is that I'm said,
he said, Well, man, a man to come
on man, and not to come.
Fat to meet Mr. cartoon. Well, man, I hate to come and who Fanta who fights Tony boo, whatever I've ordered you to do, then do it. Have it as much as you can, meaning you'll never be able to do everything.
But he didn't say that phone prohibit prohibitions. He says, what I have forbidden you from then stay away from it. Full stop.
Because if you've got 99 drinks, and then once being forbidden, is it is easier to do, isn't it? Yeah. But if you've been ordered to do 99 Things you will not you'll find difficulty doing all of them to the to the level of the province. So hence
that to mean who Mr. Daptone then comes, then do as much as you're able to keep striving to get better, better, you never reach the pinnacle. Yeah, but prohibition, you can stop them straightaway. You can stop. When I says straightaway, even Hamid had its way.
There's a wisdom behind it.
However, because of the nature of hunger and alcoholic drink, which was fogging the mind of that which affects the mind anything like that drugs, and people are used to it, addicted to it, you will not be able to stop it straightaway. And the crown didn't do it like that anyway. So when you've come to remedies, people who have been doing that, yeah, you also give them time to come off that
to come off. That's part of the wisdom.
That's part of the wisdom
of that. So keeping that in mind.
you probably saw some said and between the both doubtful matters law Yamaha NACA zero minuteness.
Most people don't know about the downfall letters.
Does that mean everyone
said it on purpose what you said still alive?
What does that mean? Most people don't know about that. What does that mean? In contrast?
If we take the opposite of that meaning what is he saying? A few people some some people know about them.
That some people doesn't mean Allah and His messenger by the way. He didn't say that. He didn't say all of humanity don't know about them. Only Allah his Messenger know about them. He's saying most people don't know about them, which means some people know about them. From the same thing, we get the meaning. Yes. In other words, they're not being left doubtful for the whole of humanity.
Who are the some people who know about them?
Allah facile who Allah Vickery income to Allah Tala moon, then ask people who have knowledge people have no if you don't know, Quran saying that yeah. So there will be people who are who, whose field most human beings believers when he says most people won't know about them the God regarding doubtful matters. Know what I know from these doubt they're doubtful because they don't know whether they fall into halal or they fall into haram. Hence the become doubtful to most people, most people who people here doesn't mean the whole of humanity actually. It means believers here because they're the ones who want to find out whether it's because of the disbeliever that couldn't give two hoots
what what? What do you mean by allowing me
doesn't really matter to them if it says hello label on it and don't look for it outside. So He says I'll mate let's go there. You might find the opposite reaction actually nowadays. Perhaps why Nando's here in ultrium was not made halal because they thought society community some people say oh well selling allow that. I'm not going there.
They hang them upside down. Let all the blood drain out. All right, I went to the slaughterhouse these are the non Muslim that's exactly what they do.
That's exactly what they do. Beef, lamb, sheep, all the ones they're eating exactly the same timing upside down loads draining out and shoving all that beef down didn't realize that actually the beef you're reading the cattle was hanging upside down with blood running out there. We've just never been to see it. You think it comes back?
it's amazing. Just somebody needs to speak in over there Eisley? Yeah.
So that's the kind of comments I've seen a newspaper you hear it, don't you in the media. That's the comments away. Hello. That's where they let blood drain out and it made
evil cruel Muslims.
Not knowing that that's what he's eating every day. Same thing.
halal and haram here. Most people don't know about it was talking about the believers.
And they're the ones who are going to want to find out.
Like Hola, la ya la ma who NACA see you don't mean a nurse
there are those who became very cautious about this.
And Vera Bozo is one of them. And his tertiary of Arbaeen, the one that's in English with the big three volumes. And interestingly, he took his position more from although he doesn't agree with everything the Imam Shamkhani says Imam Shah carne
was is a great scholar
obvious on rates and came and analyzed back to ground sooner rather than a mother the scholar and showed that this was the way for all Mr. Suddenly to come to conclusions rather than just follow a single mother.
But shall carne in regards to doubtful matters,
I believe made life very difficult for the believers. It gives various categories of what he calls under doubtful matters. What I find the strangest of those categories. And suddenly even Roger doesn't use that kind of category. Yeah.
Is when a show Carney says
if a scholar is saying something is forbidden, yeah, and another one is saying bye there is to had, actually this is allowed. The lead person must follow the forbidden pit because it's doubtful.
So it's almost canceled difference of opinion among scholars and put it into the bin.
You can't do that. That's not true. But he's counting that as you will have. In other words, you can't follow if you've got an opinion. So all right. Let me give you a real example. Guy says to lock the lock lock to his wife, present day society in this country three times all at once.
So he goes to
a Mom Mom sad
What do I do?
He said your divorce completely. You cannot even come back together with a finished
that's been a majority of scholars and a three year included especially the 100.
you he didn't really want to divorce from a forever he fought. You know, he just wanted to get a break from when he was told yesterday and three times the divorce doesn't count any divorce. That's why I said three times. Sorry, nothing we can do. You are finished. I'd like children moms. I don't want divorce. My My wife doesn't want me to divorce says he wants to be staying with me. Our children and my family. I didn't really mean it for permanence.
No, I think we can do. The guy looks around saying is there any scholar who can help me the situation? Is there a different opinion on this? Or is this the only opinion so it goes to another alum who he trusts. He wants to find the truth? He feels this is a bit harsh. Yeah. Now because of his desire. Don't don't make a few extra pennies or pounds from the fatwa. He's stuck in a situation he wants to be with his wife and he's going to harm his children because he'd been told that sets finish she has to marry somebody else. And if he divorced, then you can get my daughter again. He won't do that. She didn't want to do that. Okay, she's saying he said at the time, why am I being
punished and told African American sleep with somebody else and come back to you? Alright, so this guy is stuck with this situation. He goes to another Alamo scholar, not Joe Bloggs corner shop man. They're always experts. Of course a hairdressers are the experts. They know everything about what's going on. So to speak, people sitting in the head Ross's shop. The conversations you can have they're the experts in every field, including religion. Anyway, I don't mean he goes there to ask what to do. So the item he goes to he says no. When you said a lot first time you already became divorced. So the second tutor laksa. You said we're on a woman who's already divorced that the
superfluous. Okay. So he's analyzed the situation sale case, want Allah she has to wait the in that right. And you can take it back without marriage and during that entire period. Okay. Now, ma'am, so counting, if we apply his ruling,
what the guy have to do according to mom, so Kenny,
this is the first you have to follow the prohibition. Yeah. Sorry. It should have. Yeah, it's doubtful. So I'm stuck. That's nonsense, really is it makes a mockery of differences of opinion, obviously, how the scholars?
Cathedral in a NASA told you some people know it means the ALMA who are qualified to do is to hand it is incumbent on them to remove the shuba the Shubha from an issue not to increase it.
So counties approach to this would increase, you know,
majority of the issues away from the main things which are absolutely copy and the absolute majority we choose in life, this difference of opinion amongst Allah ma, you may as well cancel all difference of opinion. Because every time you can have a difference of opinion, you're gonna Shubo hot, I'll take the harshest.
He's always asked just
can't do so out of Shabbat. I'll stay away, because he's going to apply this hadith. He's telling you to be to be cautious. Stay away. That's why use his house is to approach your stay away and follow the one that's actually prohibiting you. So that's not the approach Allama never said that, too. I disagree. agree strongly with that stance and that understanding of Schubert actually the whole point here is off scholars to remove the doubt and clarify, especially in new issues. And in this clarification,
in this clarification,
the Super Hub
the shobhaa on a doubt, maybe maybe because
the scholar now we're talking this is not for the clarification is not for the Layperson.
layperson may be in tact, maybe in depth on an issue. So they go to ask the seller,
the person who removes the doubt in the first place. The layperson may not have any doubt. Most of life is not full of doubts, is it?
But when a layperson has doubt or a whether this is how long are they going us scholar?
So the scholar may have a clear answer already, the need to do is to hide why because the layperson didn't even know about the Quranic text about or the Hadith, which is authentic on a particular issue.
So what they thought was doubtful is actually not even doubtful, clearly from the text without any Easter Have you following me? I'm giving you different great gradations now, but only because this guy was more knowledgeable as a scholar pointed out, actually, the heavies is telling you this is okay.
There's no show here at all I didn't even need to do is to hide I just need to I knew the verse in the Quran under heavy.
the layperson goes and says, Well, you know, I think I'm not sure about this. So now Hey, Scott situation was scholar who
has the evidence,
but he may not may or may not have Hadith with another scholar has that happened even with Sahaba and Praveen Hadith, which clarifies the matter may not be with the person, the scholar. So he may be still in shuba, the scholar may be now because he didn't have the authentic hadith, which clarifies the matter actually, just from the text. Yeah. Now, if he didn't have it, he may still use these to have
to come to a conclusion and remove the Shubha for the person who's stuck, which is the role and responsibility of the Allama they have to use is the head they cannot say Oh, I'm not gonna use this the heart in case I make a mistake. That's against the Hadith of the Prophet SAW Selim. Which is an encouragement for them to do is to have is it not is x is the straddle Hakim fower our sob fella who fella who as Ron
was in after fella who
when an alum do this to help
Yeah, uses dal
li reasoning. Yeah, sincerity with the ability they've been given as an alum. And they come to
a conclusion which is correct. Correct before Allah, double reward, one for striving, fun coming to the to help the people with a with a conclusion. And second for getting it right. But if they make a mistake before Allah, the island doesn't know how to make a mistake is is. But this is an encouragement for the island not to say no, no, no, I'm not going to do it. Because our Mecca mistake prophesy. So I'm saying if he or she makes a mistake, rewards single reward, not double per single reward
as an encouragement that you must all him do is to have here to give an answer to the person not coming mostly students. Oh, no, no, I can't do it. How do you don't have ability to do is that okay, that's different. We're talking about Alamo has the ability to
that they must come with an answer for the day, which
another ally may actually have a text, a hadith which this one didn't have, without having to do is to have they've already got the text the answer there. Is that possible? Yes, of course, it was always has been. Yeah, they didn't know about the other Hadith, even if he was there. Another one may have thought this hadith is authentic, and actually it's weak. And they'll come to a conclusion on that, which will be a mistake, but that's the best they could do. And another scholar may point out this faith is weak and therefore remove the doubt from that. Look at all the different stages of removing them
of removing depth.
Now beyond that,
all Allah MA and their intelligence and cleverness solving situation application of Quran sunnah are not all the same level same level are they
all professors and all teachers are not the same level. All people have intellect and we don't have the same level all different category. Yeah, same is the case for our lemma. So one who can't do it, remove the Shubha Yeah, but another one may do.
So shall carnies principle will be terrible here. This guy can't remove it when an hourly was greater in that field.
in that particular field has removed it. So you'll be stuck with Sacani you can't do anything about it still schubas There's no point, no point of scholarship.
I find great problem with with that stance of Ashoka in describing shuba know that Arlynn or he actually asked me,
Allah ma, us not only have colleagues or alumni, they know each other
and then there are teachers and students as well. And then
what did I say? Imam Shafi was a teaching of Imam Malik Imam Muhammad Muhammad was a teacher of Imam Shafi.
So when they have that, and we have there are more than one teacher, so if one alum says I can't remove, I don't really know. But I asked so on So
yeah, as the duty or go to song. So in this matter, he's very knowledgeable.
You understand? Because all of it is to remove the shuba for the for the people, for the people.
I'm going to finish there, we're gonna finish with the topic. Here we'll draw a line and I want to mention next time Inshallah, the further meaning of this and when does therefore this super hot and how to stay away from government, when does it apply? And who does it apply to? Yeah, and then we look at last part D, which is beautiful again, to do with the heart. But why is it mentioned at the end of this? That's the question.
I called a goalie how there was stuff going on early on in level four for Rahim we stopped down Sharla unless there's a very pressing question on what we've covered. We'll call it the rest of the next time inshallah.
I should give you more time for questions. I always feel guilty and we always end up right at the dawn time. So next time, I'll try and finish remind me to finish a quarter to to give 10 minutes or so for questions because it helps you clarify a
lot. A lot of people will do that one in somebody that one company