Islam, Music & Singing – Part 3

Munir Ahmed

Channel: Munir Ahmed

Episode Notes

share this pageShare Page

Evidences from Hadith

Episode Transcript

© No part of this transcript may be copied or referenced or transmitted in any way whatsoever. Transcripts are auto-generated and thus will be be inaccurate. We are working on a system to allow volunteers to edit transcripts in a controlled system.


00:00:32--> 00:00:42

You're talking about walking the supermarket with us explain or any of the stores. You're talking about watching the news. And it starts with music and ends with music.

00:00:43--> 00:00:58

You're talking about when you're talking about music watching even a documentary, or wildlife and the lions chasing the gazelle, and it has music. And I think to myself, sometimes the music goes off imagine how boring

00:01:00--> 00:01:07

but he talking about all that if you're going to include all those situations, and more when you say hello,

00:01:08--> 00:01:22

funny thing is that, including heartbreak and others, they even then go on further said because if the neck music ROM don't say, therefore beatboxing, which is making music,

00:01:23--> 00:01:36

I can understand if you're going to say yeah, I would I would agree with them, because otherwise they will be playing tricks. Now those will say Well, as you know, there are those who from machine singing, the thought will make it slimy, we won't have really musical instruments, I'll do it with my mouth.

00:01:37--> 00:01:59

That just about the same idea of singing, singing as melody. So to instrument instruments musical melody, so you can't use the issue of and this is one of the things he uses and others, others like him, which I found really distasteful from Solomon scholars use the idea of tolerant, if it has melody, that it is how

00:02:01--> 00:02:06

it reads a melody it is wrong. So a lot of singing, but it must have melody.

00:02:07--> 00:02:25

And we don't have any instruments because it has melody Duff all along. It's not as not much melody. This is a silly argument. So again, the idea is beatboxing making music with that will also become the heart of the world. And in funny thing, I found that many of these

00:02:28--> 00:02:37

brothers, I'm not going to use the term for that motherboard. Either program on the same logic is on the introduction to YouTube video is a musical singing.

00:02:39--> 00:02:40

Melody, you know,

00:02:42--> 00:02:44

and they're saying on their video music and singing is around

00:02:45--> 00:03:05

your introduction itself, you must make an album as well though, before the program comes on. Anyway, so when we say music, we have to include all those situations that we find ourselves steeped in actually, that's how we find ourselves. So you'd have to in that sense, be good committing haram all the time.

00:03:07--> 00:03:18

All the time. That's the consequence of when you say that's not a reason for not making it around. I'm just putting the scenario to you the consequence of saying this is haram. This is what it means for us all.

00:03:20--> 00:03:28

Secondly, Allah subhana wa Taala going back to what I said earlier, created for us sight, vision and hearing

00:03:30--> 00:03:54

and also created in the nature for us to look at beautiful things and listen to beautiful things we like to hear it's a blessing, isn't it Allah I like to get the stream and the bird sing and nice anything that a nice voice a nice voice which is melodious prefer that than the shouting or screaming like my lecture now not melodious is it? So I don't I couldn't sing it two years ago, but

00:03:55--> 00:03:56

now we really controversial.

00:03:57--> 00:04:13

So we like to hear that. And therefore the Quran says in Carroll workiva So to me, showing that the worst of sounds is that of a donkey brain or donkey.

00:04:14--> 00:04:26

But it's not donkey that you have to go kill it because it's brain don't get that idea. But you compare the donkey brain to a bird singing and the lock singing. Yeah. That's a world apart.

00:04:27--> 00:04:36

So Allah blessed us with hearing not to shut it. Yeah. Anything, anything to do with sounds nice.

00:04:37--> 00:04:53

And hence, even though as I was saying for brothers, you know, I mentioned this, but the promise I saw in many of them can be more than one. He said, say you know, zainul glanbia, Swati home, beautified abroad with your voices. That's not only for males, by the way.

00:04:55--> 00:04:59

As we often take it with that male chauvinism or that for males, women

00:05:00--> 00:05:12

hear some of them, they said there's no difference between a woman singing, singing a song, whatever it is and reciting the Quran where the answers come from.

00:05:15--> 00:05:18

Because you know the men can get sexually attractive

00:05:21--> 00:05:39

the problems in the man who's listening, if he's gonna get sexy attractive when the crowns being recited, I'll return on this doesn't understand Arabic, right? Because that will make him shake and not think about that, which is what you should be. That's what that's what it means listening to a grant. So in fact, some art

00:05:41--> 00:05:48

or diseases in the heart, and that sort of explains it in the ground in regards to women as well.

00:05:51--> 00:05:53

In regards to women, in fact, speaking,

00:05:55--> 00:05:59

the issue of the war is the woman's voice older or not.

00:06:01--> 00:06:04

Those who try and use their time use a verse in the Quran.

00:06:11--> 00:06:12

Talking to Omaha to move money in his

00:06:14--> 00:06:21

alma mater says fella that will totally pay the fee on beanie Mama.

00:06:23--> 00:06:24

What?

00:06:30--> 00:06:54

It's there to give you everything that you don't need to go off into tangents. So it says undo law. bilko can in simplest terms mean same to all Mahajan. What many of us who don't mean directly by the way, you are not like other women, Deming, Allah says, Do not superficial translation means do not lower your voices in speech. Some said do not lower your voices

00:06:55--> 00:07:16

in sound, but athletes in billabong and it's not lowering your cost you can't lowering your voice is to do with sound lowering your speech. It doesn't make sense. So hada here, also, I found when I was thinking about this for years, actually, I kept on saying he can't just me lowering your voice.

00:07:17--> 00:07:29

Don't Lower your voice voice voice tends to be lower intensity anyway, what's he gonna do with it? So sunset came out with he actually needs to speak like a man. Oh, speak like that to a man. So he doesn't get any attraction?

00:07:30--> 00:07:36

Because it's saying that you have to make some act. He said the woman has to make a voice masculine.

00:07:39--> 00:07:44

Really, they did. And they still believe that there's some data we'll call

00:07:45--> 00:07:50

atomic superheat one of the classical scholars of

00:07:52--> 00:08:09

early language says katakolon Isla Jani da boo, boo, ha ha here can be lowering. But in this case, I always thought it means talking in a way of

00:08:13--> 00:08:14

what do you call it?

00:08:16--> 00:08:16

Black

00:08:20--> 00:08:23

not quite provocative. That's a bit strong but

00:08:25--> 00:08:29

to try and induce No, no.

00:08:30--> 00:08:32

Nice and tight stuff.

00:08:33--> 00:08:37

Yes. talking like that to him. Don't do that.

00:08:38--> 00:08:41

Yeah. enticing voice?

00:08:42--> 00:08:51

Yes. So um, yeah. When he says it's not Weiss, actually, Bill all. All that means enticing words.

00:08:53--> 00:08:57

For da da, da, da da, Bill. Oh, don't use enticing words.

00:08:58--> 00:09:10

lovey Fie, a bumpy mud, even in that case, the problems elsewhere, you know what the problem is in the mind? Yeah. So let's say for the one who has disease in the heart might be looking for some hope.

00:09:11--> 00:09:15

So when you hear the woman reflect on the mother's day in your hearts,

00:09:17--> 00:09:59

and why is it? Why is it that when you put it the other way around, and the man recites, do women have no feelings? That's another problem with our history of scholarship. When you know what scholars does the male chauvinism, you get this feeling on every subject that you study, that women are like creatures what no sexual desire feelings, it's just men. They're just sexual objects and men are just sitting there hunkering. Right. So as the man recycling program can also produce feelings and the females as well. Wanting postdoc to that as well. And here, lacuna column alpha st the women speak as you normally do

00:10:00--> 00:10:40

youfa means as normal here not to speak wahconah means speak as normal conversation otherwise you will not have normal conversation with men. Exactly saying it speak and explain it to the wives the prophet SAW some speak to men. For them screaming came more than any other woman because you were never going to marry anybody else after a pseudo was a special case and even for them it's Allah ordering them call them Matter of fact speak meaning to the men as you know as for normal things just speak everyday things are you allowed to speak with the opposite sex thing? Yes you are even for a woman

00:10:43--> 00:10:45

so what about the new

00:10:47--> 00:10:54

Quran vs logical beautified with your voices male and female the prophet SAW some in

00:11:09--> 00:11:17

in 100 easy in the highly publicized slum says Navin alarmingly shame I'm Nina Linda B and yet and yet that one available

00:11:18--> 00:11:30

but Allah Alina here is listen a lot doesn't Allah likes to listen to nothing better than listening to the Prophet singing the long

00:11:33--> 00:11:34

run singing

00:11:36--> 00:11:37

is singing

00:11:38--> 00:12:12

with melody and not with words with beautify the ground with your voices some tried to change that but they didn't like it which is not authentic say you know as a home builder on beautify your voices with the province not saying that it came in many report is good for the crown with your voices yeah and other Have you came to clarify that but the prophet SAW some like you said in this one he's talking about in one version it says Matt I mean a lovely shade Maggie now Linda B has an assault get a handle on the beautiful voice singing the

00:12:14--> 00:12:14

singing

00:12:16--> 00:12:31

so there you have melody in actually singing of the Quran. It is a music it is a melody that Tom Bennett yeah ma'am recycling going up and down in emotion in the melody affects the heart

00:12:33--> 00:12:38

and some some are not able to speak even against that

00:12:39--> 00:12:58

the sad Oh no, this is ill Han ill Han is a word you will hear it is used by Han has multiple meanings. One of the means that we'll have clearly is Melody but another meaning of Latin oil Han is to pronounce the Arabic words incorrectly. Get the grammar wrong.

00:13:01--> 00:13:31

Get the ground wrong. Yes. So if you're recycling and you're grammatically making mistakes, then you also are doing is wrong that kind of your hands on acceptable as much as you're able to but the melody of recycling you find that even with the alarm, don't we in the Hadith the Sahaba came up with lightning the rug wasn't trying to give the anonymous he even though he's the one who got the word from his dream focus Aslam said now give those words to below. What do you say? Who are under Minka so

00:13:33--> 00:13:36

his voice is more melodious than yours.

00:13:38--> 00:13:53

So some try to translate that and say he's got a louder voice in your wall so he can shout louder. I'm sure the rock was sharp top of his voice as well if you're standing on a pillar because well, nonsense this has to do with melody, His voice is melodious.

00:13:56--> 00:13:57

Now we come to the hobbies.

00:14:00--> 00:14:07

And I'm sorry I haven't put the translation in for next time. We'll try and sort that out but it doesn't help you much. The first one

00:14:09--> 00:14:24

the publicized one said this is an amateur without these hubby's all authentic site which I'm going to mention now. Later when you left out that mulawa to Reginald Allah word tat de de fossa work lumea to be calm see

00:14:25--> 00:14:27

here folks are saying that

00:14:33--> 00:14:40

but if he's not from LA where these things are acceptable level pastimes, that's what he's saying. So

00:14:41--> 00:14:44

there are three things which are acceptable pastimes.

00:14:46--> 00:14:57

Acceptable types of Muse muscle relaxation walk. My lab with Abdullah Abdullah here doesn't mean family playing on the husband with his wife. That means vice versa as well, isn't it?

00:14:58--> 00:14:59

Yeah. When you see them

00:15:00--> 00:15:32

Playing with his wife being a Spock of acceptable amusement, it means the other way around. It's not to say the wife's not allowed to play with us. But it's always awesome to play with the way. She's just the recipient. And this play has wide meaning brothers and sisters, from intimacy to leisure time spending husband and wife, like a five star racing with his wife, or my woman in it. And you don't have to specify you don't come from this. And say from the hadith of Isaiah, the only thing the husband's allowed to do in play time with the wife is grace, because that's what the prophet SAW somebody doing.

00:15:34--> 00:15:57

And I'll tell you scholars do that. They'll do it with when we come to some of the musical instrument is limited for no reason. Rather than getting the message from it, even when it's saying three, it doesn't limit to three because we also have another written narration which mentions for anyway, the other thing that this relation is horse riding training, horse riding

00:15:59--> 00:16:21

the other ramier to become sick, which is target practice, if you can say you know his bow and arrow but luckily for binary now you can use rifle the rifle in those days. Yeah, target practice. So can we add to this list of course you can. Of course, you can wear this benefit. That's what the idea is, and benefits sometimes in

00:16:47--> 00:16:55

benefits in one of these, which is authentic, nice in the sight of Ronnie, similar to this the pocket size slim set for things not three.

00:16:57--> 00:17:00

And he mentioned they're walking between two goals.

00:17:01--> 00:17:06

Anything for doing have a purpose, in other words, the venture for a purpose.

00:17:09--> 00:17:13

learning to swim, he added to that. So you can add to that.

00:17:14--> 00:17:21

If I sick for example, at home, which I sometimes will ask him do I'm told, just let that home

00:17:29--> 00:17:31

now, I'm just doing nothing. This is

00:17:33--> 00:17:34

what

00:17:35--> 00:17:35

is that?

00:17:43--> 00:17:47

Think of nothing empty here. Which is easy.

00:17:48--> 00:17:48

Just

00:17:50--> 00:17:54

10 minutes, 20 minutes? Is it also? There's no

00:17:56--> 00:18:00

normal? This is low as well. And I love to do that. Of course I am.

00:18:02--> 00:18:18

Yeah, so we need to think about some of the scenarios here in this study is showing you again, this is to show you that interpretation of law will hubby's the level as blatantly and across the board being harassed against the study

00:18:19--> 00:18:50

and all the possibilities under the heading of things that you can do which are useful now. In the same sense. Even those these past times of being missing letter time has good writing. I love writing hos math, I ride the horse and gamble with it. It takes me to a different category. The horse riding is not the problem isn't we must this one must differentiate between the two to realize what the ruling is coming from. It is that gambling where the problem is

00:18:53--> 00:19:08

same confusion they run into in regards to chess and backgammon. Some who made chess and backgammon along they couldn't see that it became wrong. Either it could be Baku because you're wasting hours and days and days of playing right.

00:19:09--> 00:19:21

Then it become the Khurana especially if it takes you away from other good things that that thing you could be doing. But it becomes haram if you betting with it. Not per se just as an amusement.

00:19:22--> 00:19:31

It's this this is what all our money to think about about where where the situation what is the situation here? What are we actually talking about?

00:19:33--> 00:19:37

This and easily is it Mojave and others. This is

00:19:38--> 00:19:56

the most famous of these even though even Hassan rejects this be Elisa being authentic. The most popular opinion amongst Muhammad defeat is this and he is authentic. But we need to understand this adiz with all the other ahadeeth have a sort of assassin which will come to

00:19:57--> 00:19:59

the pharmacy Islam was heard

00:20:00--> 00:20:01

hobbies according saying

00:20:03--> 00:20:13

saying they are cool mmm Almighty aplomb and they will be a people from my own map yes the hill in Allah Hara well honey who will make halau?

00:20:15--> 00:20:21

adultery, silk How about alcohol and mahasi was my

00:20:23--> 00:20:36

musical instruments when I Angela formula Jim B Allen and they will be a people who will be descended to the side of the mountain. Yo who are like him bizarrely happy

00:20:37--> 00:20:57

people will come shepherds with their flocks to them. Yeah, to him, ya know, forget the poor from amongst them will come to them for their needs for your kulu these people who are living at the side of the mountain must be rich and well off. And they say if Elena hadn't been up for you hit a homerun law.

00:20:58--> 00:21:02

Well, you know, Alan Williams, I mean,

00:21:03--> 00:21:05

I know Milka.

00:21:06--> 00:21:11

So they will instead for those poor people asking, they'll say come back tomorrow to us.

00:21:12--> 00:21:25

At nighttime, during the night, Allah will throw the mountain on them, destroy them, others, Allah will change and metamorphosize into monkeys and pigs till the Day of Judgment.

00:21:26--> 00:21:28

This is the heavy viscerally feel Thank you.

00:21:29--> 00:21:33

And what is the meaning of this? Firstly,

00:21:35--> 00:21:49

this study is a hub of what was covered with information. It is not coming in the form of insurance declared in Arabic, which is when the Quran or Hadith come and say, You must not do this.

00:21:52--> 00:22:01

You must not do this, right. Or you must do this. That's an order, you must not do this, that's forbidden, somebody hasn't come in that.

00:22:03--> 00:22:28

In that form is coming in the form of information, not only information, sometimes you can have hover, which comes in the form of a commandment as well. But that is something like an example got one more now let me sir, be my fundamental law. That is an example of that. Men are the protectors and columella protectors and carers or women.

00:22:29--> 00:22:58

Because what are extra Allah has given them and because they spend of their wealth on them. That is a statement. It doesn't say, men, you must be protected. He's saying men are the protectors of women as a statement. But that statement the weight comes as the meaning of an obligation. That's where well Am I getting the obligation of men being the providers in Muslim family and household are not the woman they're not responsible? In this case, however, it's talking about prophecy for the future.

00:22:59--> 00:23:05

You do not find in any prophecy for the future something where a legal ruling is given

00:23:07--> 00:23:37

a legal ruling being produced in this format. If you look at each of the things which are mentioned here, and the ones who are against music, musical instruments, this is the main source of that evidence natives. They say look, Bobby's Assalam said yesterday Luna, they will make holla they say yes the hell can only be used for that which is haram. They're making a buck. But that is not so because we have another Hadith

00:23:39--> 00:23:42

where the prophet SAW slum mentions about

00:23:45--> 00:23:51

a person and this is a sunny adiz in Amsterdam tirmidhi.

00:23:58--> 00:24:18

with a focus on Islam says you Shaka Rajan Tachyon Allah, Adi kepi he you have to be Hudis midha dc for your cool bhaineann our VEDA funkita la familia Jeff nafi even Hello is tough love now who will not be here we'll have her on problem now.

00:24:19--> 00:24:21

In this heavy focus on said.

00:24:23--> 00:24:33

So, a person will come who will be leaning back on the questions and hobbies will come from one of my hobbies my not one of my hobbies will come to him.

00:24:35--> 00:24:42

And what will he say? He will say between us and you is just the book of Allah. In other words, he's rejecting the view from the properties.

00:24:44--> 00:24:59

And he goes on to say whatever we found in the book from Hello, is that level now we made it Hello. In this case, is saying whatever we found halau we using the word step Hello now

00:25:00--> 00:25:22

So the argument those who use that making haraam into halaal is the time that is tackled, that form of word is used is defeated. Because here, the promises from using it from hello to Hello. So it doesn't have to be that everything that's mentioned that they're doing is that law of his harem.

00:25:24--> 00:25:49

You follow me some of you follow me it's a bit technical is to do with the word making halaal is the hella word. Okay? It's that level. And they're trying to argue if you only use it, it's only used when something Haram is made into hollow, but I'm showing you how the where halaal is made into hollow by the book that starts being used in language. So you can't use that argument number one, number two.

00:25:51--> 00:25:59

Here, you can't use this heavy because we don't get the fact that Zina is haram from this hubby's

00:26:01--> 00:26:20

doing this in the wrong way. A lot of Rosina, do not go near Xena and other da da da da, which make it clear that Zina is wrong, not from this study. We don't get the fact that Hamas is haram from this heavy. We already know it's Haram in this study from other texts.

00:26:22--> 00:26:24

Other texts, silk,

00:26:25--> 00:26:28

silk is mentioned the wearing of so is it haram for everybody?

00:26:30--> 00:26:46

No, it's hard for women. And can you imagine when you put this together if you're going to accept your face value? How is wearing of silk even for a male the same level of sin as doing Xena and drinking? How is it

00:26:47--> 00:26:54

for those who understand the past they know all about with deep thinking that seems to know all the same level other

00:26:56--> 00:27:10

than have different levels. But here that we put together all this one group and look at the punishment, the mountain being thrown on in this world and being turned into monkeys and things in this world. It's a big punishment for just wearing silk.

00:27:11--> 00:27:19

When the proper size for men even allowed it for somebody with eczema, or you know, skipping is not the life and death reasons just for discomfort. It's fine you can wear it

00:27:21--> 00:27:26

so you've got that there in there. And it has a ruling government which is hard anyway.

00:27:28--> 00:27:36

Then you come to massive now if you're going to say that this is making it haram remember what mas it means all instruments,

00:27:38--> 00:27:43

all instruments, then you're going to have to understand this studied from other hobbies I'm going to bring you

00:27:44--> 00:27:50

that will make you realize that you cannot single out here the instruments here and they're around because of this.

00:27:52--> 00:27:56

What is ICC and it is clarify that there are other reports of it

00:27:58--> 00:28:07

as well. In one report these also authentic from the chamber before we start some sentences same Hanif with different words which gives you a bit

00:28:09--> 00:28:21

more understanding of what's going on in the other one say a quarter of your material hustle for muscle Well, there will be from my alma Michael ma from the believers eponymous islan yet metamorphosis.

00:28:40--> 00:28:40

Yes,

00:28:41--> 00:28:54

fake una phenol McHale hasa that's been swallowed by the the earth that massive metamorphosis into monkeys and pigs and cognex that is the mountain being thrown on people on

00:28:56--> 00:29:14

the Sahabi same book I said fee my god I saw a lot for what reason or messenger of Allah on Solo Solo behind the kingdom of Fina was should be he wasn't alone because of them taking gynaec are women singers and drinking comma

00:29:16--> 00:29:23

so if you just take this a different song from this when it's cooked with hammer, you could come to the conclusion that having a woman Sing us a song

00:29:25--> 00:29:45

but you haven't finished Lila have used to verify now. This last one makes it even clearer. He had noticed before we go to the last version of it was sort of a hippo hormone. Not a standalone ah but drinking combo. They are from my own map. And in one version, he says

00:29:46--> 00:29:52

they say La la la la. But they're involved in this kind of thing. Drinking karma. I'm here is

00:29:53--> 00:30:00

awesome. When will this happen? When instruments and drinking of alcohol and wearing a skirt will become

00:30:01--> 00:30:02

rampant

00:30:04--> 00:30:07

it'll be everywhere, amongst to amongst the sama.

00:30:10--> 00:30:15

look underneath context and that we understand the whole of the picture that you have a context in which

00:30:17--> 00:30:35

alcohol is flowing, adultery is being encouraged and happening. Yeah, and in that some people are wearing silk as well and then mixed in with music. So that kind of setting which is a setting of most nightclubs. Yeah is the setting which is being actually punished.

00:30:37--> 00:30:47

So take the whole picture. So those scholars who said this is not individually to be taken, it is taken as a full picture. And that's the only way you can take it.

00:30:48--> 00:30:58

That's the only way you can take it. I'm gonna put it to you because we'll see from the other hobbies, it cannot be from this study that is singling out making instruments.

00:30:59--> 00:31:03

You can only understand that by looking at other authentic

00:31:04--> 00:31:05

following

00:31:07--> 00:31:13

a we have something that is reported by imagery with Nigeria covering the famous professor

00:31:16--> 00:31:25

from the Saudi Canon jawatan Nick Abu can we have more room to cover well, Masami? trochu mangabey sallallahu alayhi wa sallam by even a member

00:31:26--> 00:31:30

while you're doing it, for Angela Lo,

00:31:32--> 00:31:36

one you got out you got a leveling, fun to eat. I have a couple of Voluma.

00:31:38--> 00:31:46

This Sunday is mentioned by the juries is is authentic about the context of the verse to do with. So that sort of job.

00:31:48--> 00:32:34

When unless mica says what you thought it Jonathan, and when they see Business and Commerce going on, on Lahu, both in the same book, or amusement. In fact, de la ha they go rushing away towards it. So what happens in your thinking is that it is mentioned that like this study, that somebody's getting married, so Kyle jawai, the young ladies from the Assad are coming out with that double siding, drums and what else, Masami flutes, they're playing them in the street, because there's a wedding going on. So, those sitting in the masjid and the publicize them in the member is doing quite well.

00:32:35--> 00:32:38

They leave and come out to see what the commotion is going on.

00:32:40--> 00:32:56

And in one report, which is also authentic, it was one of the Sahaba coming back after a business trip. And people wanted to know they have to be, they have to call be famous companion and people came rushing ways being etc, etc. Same context.

00:32:58--> 00:32:59

Leslie

00:33:02--> 00:33:03

the Quranic verse,

00:33:04--> 00:33:13

criticizing This is criticizing it because people are leaving the Prophet sauce alone at slotland gym to come out.

00:33:14--> 00:33:23

That's what the problem is not the singing of the flutes and the drums, which are already encouraged by the prophesized slump in other hobbies for marriage, and not.

00:33:25--> 00:33:56

So when they're doing it here, what's the problem? The problem is when you leave with profits or self study new hochma not any man, the Messenger of God. So the Quran therefore has a go look at those who do that, but it doesn't leave it to musical instrument includes in that to Java. So all I'm now saying if you're going to use this to criticize music, then you better also say to Java and commerce is also wrong. Because it's in the same context is saying, Yeah,

00:33:57--> 00:34:13

what is our old teacher and I would love one in fact good Elena when they see Business and Commerce or amusement, both in the same book. So if you're going to make that haram because of this, then you must make the other haram because of it as well. You follow me?

00:34:16--> 00:34:37

And we know business is not around. But it becomes around when Saku Juma is going on because of the context same with the amusement for the winning especially. But he shows you all saw that flutes are being planned as well as drums not as though the flutes are not being criticised. It's what the purposes

00:34:41--> 00:34:42

okay this one

00:34:46--> 00:34:59

as well in his psyche to collect your hobbies and a critical buddies and not a mole like Nemo not very famous at least from now fat owns a sled Oklahoma enough is a scholar, report from hobbies perform, most famously

00:35:00--> 00:35:13

chain link with Mr. Malik from him the oma not fair to Malik the Golden Chain Nikolic in this case we're not on about that, but it from him that on that and now you've never sent me a song zamana karate

00:35:15--> 00:35:15

that

00:35:32--> 00:35:36

notice with him in companionship and as they're riding along

00:35:38--> 00:35:42

that in Omaha is the sound of the flute of the shepherd.

00:35:44--> 00:35:57

The one that was that was why He called on it. He puts His fingers in his ears in the orders. And he diverts the animal he's on Well, this camel or horse away from the salmon.

00:35:59--> 00:36:27

Well, I don't know who and it can be one way of saying Yeah, no, that's not another way. He keeps asking him Can you hear and still laugh? He says yes. So then he asked him again. A little bit further. Yeah, a Tesla until he says, but what if he then he puts his fingers out of his ears when nothing says I can't hear anymore. Why?

00:36:28--> 00:36:32

electronic and then he brings back back to the original the roots of his animal

00:36:35--> 00:36:36

salon

00:36:37--> 00:36:49

was something as a monocot Ronnie for Sonata mikhailova it almost says this is what the Messenger of Allah did. In a similar situation when he heard the the shepherd playing the flute. This is what you did.

00:36:52--> 00:37:04

Those who say the flute now is haram music is haram, the youth is worse. Those who say it's allowed strongly use this. This is well. I'll tell you how those who says that I'm saying look,

00:37:06--> 00:37:09

he's doing this and the professor some did this.

00:37:10--> 00:37:10

Wrong.

00:37:12--> 00:37:12

All right.

00:37:14--> 00:37:21

That's one thing and he's diversities animal fine. Okay. Let's look at a different way.

00:37:23--> 00:37:31

First, we didn't honor who's with the message of a wall? Why is it the Messenger of Allah is doing this and in the oma. He returned to do this?

00:37:32--> 00:37:52

Is it normal? Not Muslim? If it is wrong, is it haram only for the messenger not for Abdullah? Why is the promise is them not deviate? And tell the owner also to do this if Excel Not only that, as the number tells not fit? prophesize some code in there as well? Can you listen out? Please? Why is listening?

00:37:54--> 00:37:58

Yeah, he's listening. Can you listen out until it stops?

00:38:00--> 00:38:14

It can't be haraam. Otherwise, he became the Oh by the way, this is wrong. You need to do this as well. On and then in the other room, I've told nothing the same thing is nothing all Muslim is a Muslim scholar for goodness sake. But even then Omar doesn't tell him to do this either.

00:38:17--> 00:38:18

doesn't currently do this either.

00:38:19--> 00:38:23

Number two, why did that? Because if you can handle a fluke.

00:38:24--> 00:38:50

So he said why didn't publicize them. And then after that, go to the shepherd and say, I suffer all I've been sent to destroy flutes and, and stringed instruments, as you find in a very weak leaf. Why did you go and do that and destroy his fluke? Some of the ones who are opposing said, Oh, well, it was a bit far away. That's why I didn't go. Come on, you can hear it.

00:38:51--> 00:39:16

That'd be that far away. And if it's so hated and so hard on then you go and stop the shepherd as well. Or why did he clarify at the time to in the overflow? They didn't. So why did he do this? The best explanation for that is the pocket size. So as you see similar situation with another handy on the day of Eve, the prophet SAW Salamis in a different state,

00:39:17--> 00:39:29

but he allows us a hammer to carry on, including his life. Same here like we will move on to the proper size, Tulum, his preference was to remember Allah cool.

00:39:31--> 00:39:35

Gotta be some Allahu la semiotica la Ha.

00:39:36--> 00:39:53

The promises on us to make remember Allah all the time sitting like you would expect that this is a messenger of God. So he's doing something. That's why they want to suggest if he's going along and doing this, you must be doing something better. And he didn't want to be disturbed by the sound of the flute of the shepherd.

00:39:54--> 00:39:56

And that's the best way to understand

00:39:59--> 00:39:59

now

00:40:00--> 00:40:02

coming tomorrow more interesting ones. So many.

00:40:03--> 00:40:14

This comes in many, many forms this idea of people hiding Muslim as I come to this, let me clarify something else. There are various hobbies you're going to see. And we saw one already.

00:40:22--> 00:40:25

See that one can on Giovanni

00:40:26--> 00:40:32

Giovanni, this is the definition needed again, what is your work? Or jharia?

00:40:33--> 00:40:39

Giovanni ajaya has various meanings. Well, I'll tell you what the meaning is, in this case,

00:40:40--> 00:40:56

some of the meanings of Giardia Giardia can be used for a ship on the ocean because it comes from john which means to flow or to sail along go along. So, jharia is used for a ship on the ocean journey as us m

00:40:58--> 00:41:01

l jawai. Goodness is Sora

00:41:06--> 00:41:17

Yes, Queen, Giovanni goodness, the plural of janee djawadi is a star which is going to set is flowing in the direction of setting the standard sets.

00:41:19--> 00:41:20

And generally

00:41:22--> 00:41:40

in this case, he claims that jharia always means well, it only hobbies means little girls, little girls, which means not darling. No it was a little girls that can do whatever they love. They're not answerable for anything other.

00:41:41--> 00:42:07

So he'll try and use this translation here. But I beg to differ very strongly with that comment. And I'll show you why. Javea can be used for Anna, who's a lady and adult which is a slave woman. A slave adult woman. The word jharia can be used for her. Yes Julia can be used for a little girl as well. But Julia can also be used for our young lady

00:42:09--> 00:42:11

for a young lady. Why?

00:42:14--> 00:42:21

So he will translate in this study Canon djawadi little girls were going along I say no young ladies we're going along actually.

00:42:22--> 00:42:23

Because

00:42:24--> 00:42:26

the hobbies that we're going to deal with now.

00:42:27--> 00:42:42

Here again, is the deal eat and it comes in lots of narration disobeys very famous that if nobody can deny they try and get around it. But other ways that I sell them on what we need reports that it was

00:42:43--> 00:42:52

the enemy and just two young ladies were with me from the unsolved they were singing and playing the Duff

00:42:53--> 00:42:58

in the house of the Messenger of Allah. This house is not five rooms

00:43:00--> 00:43:14

is ISIS apartment or mobile meeting where when the officers are used to pray it used to be lying in front of him is that small when he wants to go down and said that used to tap on her feet so she was pulling legs? Oh, we could go down to do

00:43:15--> 00:43:34

in that place. Those two young ladies are playing the drums and singing songs. What the scene machine? Let him know law learned he learned that you know some will say that's what you love to see. You know, Muhammad Allah know the singing from the singing song from the Battle of

00:43:36--> 00:43:49

the backlog was is that was checked place for the husband and Assad ganzar when they fought against each other before the officers arrived to Medina in times of jack Leah that's the battle they're thinking about.

00:43:51--> 00:44:00

They're singing that song they're singing about but obviously with no shirt and wrong in it but he's not praising Allah His Messenger always he's singing the song.

00:44:04--> 00:44:12

And the police officer is in the same apartment, same room and he's got his back to them in one report. He's laying down and he's got his head covered

00:44:14--> 00:44:17

with his back to them, but a lot more secrets and doing

00:44:21--> 00:44:56

a MOBA I should say as a father walks in and he's shocked with this Miss model shaped on the baking the blew up we making the beat, they the instruments. The instruments have checked on in that the house of the messenger. Here Masami is being used in a musical instrument sense because they work without me they're likely playing drums. Without me it means flutes. For us using an instrument sense. The instruments of you know checkbox in the house of the Messenger of Allah.

00:44:57--> 00:44:59

So the prophet SAW some heard him say that

00:45:00--> 00:45:14

Keep this in mind he used the word check on promises incorrect abubaker on that, but he corrected what he was trying to do, which was to stop them. So the prophesised actually took off the cover and turn around said, dot home, dot bonga leave them alone.

00:45:16--> 00:45:25

Leave them alone. This day is the day of weed. Every people nation has their festivals and this is our festival. Leave them alone because

00:45:29--> 00:46:07

this report and another report which is linked to the same day comes at the end of this series. And sometimes it's separate these on the same day. In the mosque. I saw mommy mentioned that she and the messenger was sitting down suddenly they heard a loud noise in the masjid of the hairbrush where I was singing that come and they were playing and dancing. Yes, we know now jumping up and down with them and playing with their soul and their spears and their shields. And you know when we've seen any hollywood movie, how they make sound with that noise of their shields up they do that.

00:46:09--> 00:46:15

For folk dance, traditional dance, you call it full time dub, dub kathakali in Arabic.

00:46:16--> 00:46:40

Dr. Shabbir, so for Africans that's the kind of thing that we're doing in the masjid. And we heard a loud noise of Serbian young children. We're also you know around them because it's entertainment going on. So the prophet SAW some asked me Do you want to watch the the other simians doing that performance in that play? And the question and it was the dailies? And I said yes. And I was the Johnny at the time.

00:46:43--> 00:47:08

Wonderful. She says I was ajaya at the time. Let me if it means little girls as he claims it's not possible. She's already moved in with the Messenger of Allah and he's a wife to the Messenger of Allah. So Giardia can is not limited to little girls. She's a young lady. She's a married woman, and she's saying I was ajaya at that time, you follow me?

00:47:10--> 00:47:19

So Johnny Jaya is not limited to little girls want to reach Beluga maturity because she's already in with the puppy sighs I'm living with him as his wife.

00:47:21--> 00:47:23

And you know what? In one report

00:47:24--> 00:47:32

in a nice, she says fuck with it. Oh god, oh god at a hadith that is sin. Halley's at the other level.

00:47:34--> 00:47:38

This is in the same manner. She says. Imagine

00:47:39--> 00:47:49

the value for a young lady like myself of young age, for her excitement and desire to listen to amusement.

00:47:50--> 00:47:51

That's what I was like.

00:47:53--> 00:48:04

For amusement, he won't use the word love we're here. harissa de la liga for amusement. Why? fasudil lesson the lesson? Am I saying this?

00:48:05--> 00:48:07

So when the bonus lesson Do you want to watch them?

00:48:08--> 00:48:16

Forget to be around? Do you want to watch them? This is after they've been playing also music and singing in the house of the promises of music and singing?

00:48:18--> 00:48:19

How can you make it around when it's happening?

00:48:21--> 00:48:23

You're following the messenger of God.

00:48:25--> 00:48:53

Read the message of a leper incorrectly and leave them alone. And then this is going on in the messaging of a syllabus. I said I'm a mobile mini and I says he says so he covered me. So the last lesson we should a doorway. Some said there was a curtain in the doorway. There's no evidence for it. We're still in the doorway, and I had my cheek next to the cheek of my beloved touching his cheek like here while I was watching the other singers perform.

00:48:54--> 00:48:56

And while they were performing this

00:48:57--> 00:49:18

up this time Homer walks in before it was over working nights overscan seeing this happening in the masjid, jumping up and down and doing this with the shields and thinking right so almost says he tried to stop them telling them off even in one report is throws pebbles at them. So the prophet SAW some season. He says leave them

00:49:20--> 00:49:25

leave them alone. And he says sallallahu alayhi wa sallam

00:49:27--> 00:49:30

Dahomey Allah wa

00:49:31--> 00:49:36

in you know have a shot well home yeah, no no that's not good.

00:49:38--> 00:49:44

That's nice. You're saying why not have a shower home yellow one that will mess you up on a journey. You know? When she says I was

00:49:51--> 00:49:59

time, let the pump start slow said let the year hold see the juice. See that in our dean.

00:50:00--> 00:50:00

We have

00:50:02--> 00:50:03

TV, not

00:50:05--> 00:50:06

TV, not pasta.

00:50:25--> 00:50:42

We have wideness in our Dean, and I've been sent with the dean, which I mentioned earlier on. That is upright and liberal. Somehow. Yeah. Which is flexible and relaxed. I told you, I'll tell you the context. It was in this context, he said that.

00:50:43--> 00:50:45

So all being corrected,

00:50:46--> 00:51:03

leave them alone. Let them carry on. So lovely. So until I said, I look tired. He kept asking me I'm getting off now. Have you had enough now? I said, I kept on saying no, I'm not having this. I wanted to carry on being close to my beloved with my cheek, I want you to take best, as much as I could at that time with him. So a lot.

00:51:07--> 00:51:11

So some some, including him said

00:51:13--> 00:51:17

they weren't songs really. There was some to do with wall.

00:51:18--> 00:51:23

And this playing in domestic it wasn't playing. They were training for wall

00:51:24--> 00:51:30

training for wall. Why would the other seniors come all the way around a senior to come and train for one emotion?

00:51:32--> 00:51:38

Because he can't deal with the fact that they're playing under dancing? So it's a no no, no one playing and dancing. They were training for warfare.

00:51:40--> 00:52:00

If you were trained for warfare, why was almost throwing pebbles at them? Because he could have seen that we're training for warfare he'd love it actually will join in one Navy was warfare he was doing they were training for why did the prophesies that we were training for warfare said let the horse see that we have wildness in our religion. What you who don't train for warfare?

00:52:02--> 00:52:30

Yeah. Why would he say that's the lesson? I know we have liberality in our religion. Why would I sell a lot? I said that. Imagine a young lady like me, who has eagerness to be involved in amusement. Why would you say that? It's a warfare. So this is trying to play games with the evidence in front and now trying to dodge it somehow. So let's make it into a worse thing. Nothing to do with amusement. This is love. This is amusement.

00:52:32--> 00:52:33

prophesized.

00:52:37--> 00:52:38

Oh, here's another one.

00:52:41--> 00:52:48

What was that some came back from Germany when you came back Java, Java, Java two sold up on

00:52:50--> 00:53:16

Java. A black woman came in one report, it mentions that there's a woman interchangeably with Julia. And that reports authentic so you understand jharia can mean woman? Yeah, who can you she said You're so lucky. If you can turn the lotto in Rebecca mom, sorry, honey, I made a vow that if Allah brought you back safely, then I would play the drum. Yeah. And I would sing

00:53:19--> 00:53:26

prophesize on sector if you made that as a vow, then go ahead. But if you if you didn't make a vow, then don't go ahead.

00:53:28--> 00:53:35

We know from other Hadith the prophet SAW So instead, there is no fulfilling of vows in Maxi Attila.

00:53:37--> 00:53:40

If you made a vow for something which is haram, you don't say I've got to fulfill it.

00:53:42--> 00:53:46

So if this was Haram, why focus on stopping and say no, no, because

00:53:49--> 00:54:04

you're a woman's going to sing so everybody's there. Everybody's there not as the prophet SAW slow. Okay, so, so she's talking. She's talking, playing the drum and saying, I will walk okay, because I'm playing the drums singing.

00:54:06--> 00:54:12

Ali came off mungkin Chi Gong. Singing Ali came same thing that Omar came.

00:54:14--> 00:54:18

I was coming. She quickly threw the drum underneath and sat on a

00:54:23--> 00:54:34

desk that was under a bottom that's like saying, literally saying that none of us were under a buck on and sat on it. For others who left us alone in the second half. And when kayama

00:54:35--> 00:54:38

Bama shown even shaitaan is afraid of you on

00:54:41--> 00:54:46

me. It's nice to see. So this is the last lesson that we have here.

00:54:47--> 00:54:59

The hunter Alavi Masuda karate Kawasaki, New Year's Eve. This is a Tavi reporting that I came upon and entered upon three of the Sahaba syllabus was along with Giovanni yesterday.

00:55:00--> 00:55:22

to Laguna, and the young women were playing the Gulf, and they were singing for the Sahaba the woman was singing for the Sahaba. And I said, You're the Sahaba of the Messenger of Allah and you're allowing this to happen. They said on one of them said in the whole office, Elena in one version, they said if you want to stay stay if you don't have to go up and man,

00:55:24--> 00:55:39

we're okay with it. The Messenger of Allah, I love this photos, especially in the case of a wedding and it was a wedding night. And he also allowed us to cry during for the death of someone without lamenting. This also gives you a little something about trying

00:55:40--> 00:56:21

another one. This is about the pasta sauce alone, a woman came to the Messenger of Allah and the Messenger of Allah said no Ayesha, and I said with him. Do you know who this woman is? atomic Tina Javi. Do you know who this woman is? She said no. The post Iceland's ended up playing a very full on she is a professional singer from such and such a pride. She's a professional singer. She is known to be a singer. Then he gets after that. haram to her she'll be going to hell fire men, the sentence taker character PCs etc. Blah, blah. What did he say? He says I said would you love would you like that? She thinks

00:56:24--> 00:56:31

to him Bina and Dominika Tunica, Allah nom. I said yes. Call us a little less than a

00:56:35--> 00:56:35

minute.

00:56:37--> 00:57:00

So they gave her a plate. Again to play a melody with this time is not enough is to play anything that you can play some melody with. And she started singing with this. And the publicise and then said, But enough of a shakedown three min, hooray. Hmm. So the shutdown is blowing down her nose. So that links would shut down being measured by boubakeur and we'll come to why this has been mentioned here yet the parmesan and I shall watching.

00:57:02--> 00:57:15

Yeah. So music and singing around how can the pocket size I'm actually is asking the singing woman to sing. And another report we have and I'm bringing up a time I just want to

00:57:17--> 00:57:22

mention that what was also famous at the time and we have

00:57:29--> 00:57:40

here's another one to publicize some of them came upon an agony sucking their place. And the young ladies started playing with the drums and singing songs for the people who had died.

00:57:42--> 00:57:44

And then

00:57:45--> 00:57:51

that goes I mentioned to the floor already. That's about the augustinians will tell already mentioned to you

00:57:52--> 00:57:54

this is about another one

00:57:56--> 00:58:26

young ladies in the street who are playing with the drums and singing and the Messenger of Allah goes by them and they're singing We are the that the the the neighbors have been in a job or we are the girls are finding a job yeah hi Bala Mohammed min min jar, how wonderful it is to have the hamlet as a neighbor. And so the puppies are so upset to them. I love all yalom and me allow him to come now.

00:58:28--> 00:58:30

Surely Allah knows how much I love you.

00:58:31--> 00:58:32

So

00:58:33--> 00:58:36

not break this and break down also

00:58:37--> 00:59:17

matters singing. The men singers were especially famous for doing Buddha which was camel riders, and it was famous in janelia. And he carried on it was encouraged at the time of Brazil. last lesson. Going to hybrid is authentic. today. There was a man who was singing for Mr. Musk, who is this army. He was famous for singing these songs and they said the songs made it easier for the journey and met the camels go easily on that journey and go to a rhythm. So that's what we used to do is called for that. So what is our son when they told him a song so because he's his poetry he was singing was beautiful and apologized and said Man, I love mercy on him. In this authentic a be a singer. In one

00:59:17--> 00:59:30

version, there is the singer called Angelica who is famous. This is authentically and the public doesn't have his wives with him. And he was leaving their camels and I'm just singing with a beautiful melodious voice.

00:59:32--> 00:59:48

So now the women are listening to them man singing as well. And the pocket size for them said we have come up with a way that Yeah, I'm just shocked. He's saying Whoa, take it easy slowly. I'm just shocked because you you're leading on the camels.

00:59:49--> 00:59:50

Like

00:59:51--> 00:59:59

like glasses. He's describing the wives ladies on Camelback like fragile glasses because some of them

01:00:00--> 01:00:34

My settings because they may be mostly affected by the beautiful melody of a hunter shop. So he mentioned that metaphoric sense that you might emotionally affect them. But he didn't stop him. Even if you take that interpretation and say oh, you're going to cause a fitna for the women on the camel but you better stop it's her arm he's still carried on singing is saying this other setting means that the camels were going too fast now and then that on the whole bench that women were going this way and that way three centuries take easy Yeah, when you're singing a slaughter come on down. So that's all there is law.

01:00:38--> 01:00:40

Those are all authentic IDs.

01:00:42--> 01:00:51

And I'm not gonna have time to go through all the non authentic and there's a lot there's about 70 odd very weak and fabricated

01:00:52--> 01:01:05

doors that are giving you a full of times outside even of men singing in front of women and men women sing in front of men true both of them

01:01:06--> 01:01:07

both of them

01:01:08--> 01:01:13

and and that's important to get the full picture from the time of assume muscle

01:01:15--> 01:01:36

all the I had these to do with a weakened fabricated and a famous ones you'll hear about the message of coming to break the string instruments and break the the flutes and break this and break that and put led being poured to the in the area of the one who listens to music and singing all none of them Assam they are not just weak they are very weak or fabricating

01:01:38--> 01:01:43

lots of them and I've given some examples in the book as I said I'm not going to have time to

01:01:44--> 01:02:05

somebody who listens to music and singing to shake hands are sent to dance on their shoulders and they keep on dancing on their shoulders and finish up so perfectly stop singing again not authentic. So anything to do with string instruments and and to do with instruments all these to do with a death beam haraam and

01:02:06--> 01:02:17

signs of you know I'm warning of the fire some mentioned the one who sings or listen to singing or music that Salah has not accepted for three days on this and in this category.

01:02:18--> 01:02:27

It might be somebody sang and then for three days they carry on brain is not accepting what nonsense. So

01:02:28--> 01:02:39

I'll stop there, though well over the time, keeps telling me I'm about to give you a break, and I'll try and conclude inshallah, there isn't a conclusion next session or event.

01:02:41--> 01:02:46

But there's a special and then I'll try and round up things how I bring them together and then