Adnan Rashid – Removing Doubts Againts the Rightly Guided Caliphs 03
AI: Summary ©
The conversation covers various topics related to the shia school's actions, including Omar's actions towards Omar and Omar's actions towards Omar. The speakers emphasize the importance of reading and writing during busy days, including resources on YouTube and websites. The conversation also touches on the confusion surrounding shia's use of shia's names and the misunderstandings of Muslims. The speaker discusses the definition of a doctor in Islam, citing the use of smoking pipes and the lack of belief in Islam as reasons for the definition's accuracy.AI: Transcript ©
Errani Rahim. Alhamdulillah Alhamdulillah Alameen wa Salatu was Salam wa ala thoughts on the Lumbee our say you didn't know serene. While Ollie he was hobby he'll have already my Amin Foreman Tabia son in and Iommi Dean about how old Avila is Samir alumina shaytani R rajim Bismillah R Rahman r Rahim. Yeah, you and Adina Amano for the fotofestiwal Mika Vannatta who Tati Shaitan in the hula kumawu Moby bahcall are from LA he said Allahu alayhi wa sallam Guney or Islam Allah function. shahada tienen la ilaha illAllah Muhammadan rasul Allah. Muhammad sallahu wa eata is a cart, what had you Asami Ramadan? Oh, come on Allah salatu salam, respected brothers and sisters, this is the
third session on our
topic, the topic we have been covering in the past two episodes have already been delivered. And this is the third one in the series. And what is the Series The Series is entered into an introduction to
tafa ethna Sharia this was a book written by a man called Shah Abdulaziz had this Abdallahi who was the son of Shah Wali, Allah almohadas, Abdullah we, both of whom lived in Delhi in the 18th century. So Sharpton, Aziz was a great scholar, and he had written this book,
to respond to some of the Shia doubts raised about the characters of the companions of the messenger of allah sallallahu, Sallam and other topics. So it is an overall treatment of the Shia
ideas, or Shia criticisms of Sunni school of thought.
So this is one of the best books written on the topic. I believe this is one of the best books in the entire history of Islam, written on the topic, how do we respond to the Shia questions? And the Shia criticisms? Or how do we refute the Shia positions on Aqeedah on history, on fake
on almost every single thing we believe in,
we have differences with the Shia school. And the purpose of writing this book was that in the 18th century, the Shia influence had become very prominent. And in in the Indian political landscape.
A lot of the generals and even the Kings, the Mughal kings were directly influenced by Shia thought. And shotgun, Aziz writes in the preface, that there is not a house in India that hasn't been affected by Shia propaganda. So for this reason, I write this book, to put the record straight. And by the grace of Allah after this book was written,
and this book became immediately became a very popular book and hundreds of 1000s of people had changed. Some of them even from the Shia side came to the sunny side. Okay. And those who were considering some of the Shia ideas to be authentic or to be valid, change their minds completely because they had no idea as to how to respond to some of these questions. That's why the opposition, so we were talking about specifically some of the accusations or some of the
objections raised by the Shia school classically speaking on the characters of the companions of the Messenger of Allah sola, sola. In the previous previous episodes.
We went through the accusations against Ovako Rhodiola. One
and we gave responses. Today in this session Inshallah, we will talk about the accusations against Amara Macatawa de la Hwan.
And how do we respond to them? On a worker, we covered a number of different issues or a number of different topics, important topics.
One of the objections against a worker was that a worker actually, you know,
on the Jaya Posada, sending the army of Osama near the death of the Prophet sallallahu ala more after the death of the Prophet salallahu Salam, Abu Bakar was not as diligent as he should have
mean. So he went against the Prophet.
Then our backers via it was taken in a non Islamic fashion. His Pledge of Allegiance
was given to him in a non Islamic fashion. Also aboubaker
raviolo Juan did not give the inheritance to Fatima inheritance which was left behind by the messenger of allah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam aboubaker deliberately did not give this inheritance to Fatima Rhodiola Anna and the garden of product which came to the province, Allah Salam and the Prophet was managing it, that garden was not given to Fatima in inheritance. So responses are given to these questions, responses were given in the previous previous episode, you may go and watch the previous episode
part two of the introduction of tafa ethna Acharya. Today is part three and we will talk about some of the Shia accusations against Omar ibn Katara do lajuan. In fact, these two individuals of a worker and armor
are the worst characters as far as the shields are concerned
to the car over and Abubaker both of them shaking
or not
better than how do biller somehow the biller shaitan.
To them. They are the heads of copper. And I'm not making things up. This can be found in the classical literature of the Shia school. In fact, some Shia, even curse Amara boubakeur with others in the Salah, in the prayers to this day
in the Majelis.
And this is not spreading hatred. I'm not trying to spread hatred here. These are statements of fact stating facts is not spreading hate. Okay? This is what the Aqeedah Is this what they believe in. And they give reasons for these beliefs to be fair with them. They claim that aboubaker And Omar aeromar, and Ayesha and Hafsa all these people and more Avia
all of them they deserve our curses for reasons.
And we disagree with the reasons of course, we believe the reasons are completely
invalid.
They have no grounding in reality.
And they are extreme in the hatred towards this hour. As we will see in sha Allah. Some of these things they claim about this hour are completely made up lies to inflate hatred against them. This is why shortgrass ease or her Talalay wrote this book, what I have in front of me is an auto translation. The original text is in Persian, it is an encyclopedia of information on this topic. Unfortunately it hasn't been translated into the English language yet it has it has been translated into the language entirely and into the Arabic language partially what we need is a huge a complete translation with footnotes with research in the English language
and inshallah it will be coming
soon.
So Shaka disease dealt with many topics in this book today we will talk about Ramadan Katara, viola, Juan, and I will deal with these accusations.
In brief, basically not at the my my treatment today is not going to be detailed. This is an encyclopedia of hundreds of pages, it is impossible for me to cover this book and what this what this book contains, and 45 minutes, it's not going to be up. The reason why I'm doing this lecture is to introduce you to this book, so that you can go away and read the book. In Persian if you know Persian or in Urdu if you know or do or in Arabic. If you can find the translation and possibly work on translating it into English. It will be a huge
service to Islam online. Because in this day and age currently,
a lot of confusions have spread. Most Muslims unfortunately don't read the books. They don't know how to answer these questions, answer to these questions I hear
shark disease or how to lay systematically one by one response to every single accusation.
Every single criticism, every single point raised by the Shia school of thought and he completely dismantled it.
This book
instigated 25 responses from the Shia school at least 25 responses.
So heavy
was the impact
or so, hard was the impact of this book in the 19th century on the shears, that some of the shears they attempted responses unsuccessfully, they responded they did write books, but when you read those responses, they actually failed to address most of the points raised by shark disease, because there are no responses, there are no responses. This this is so important this book is
so there is a section in the book and the contents when you go you see and you see a section
matane
armor or accusations against armor when Kufa okay or tan tan is basically condemning or cursing of Omar based upon the following reasons number one accusation against Omar is the incident of care pass.
You know what that is? Who wants to help me What is past the incident incident?
This was his last day basically last time he was writing basically what you want some
write something
so good. So the prophets Allah Salam was near his death SallAllahu sallam, in the final days of his life on a Thursday, the messenger of allah sallallahu sallam.
He was surrounded by his companions. And this report is in Sahil Bukhari, okay. And he said to the Companions, that give me a pen, and a paper
and an input so that I can write something for you. Right? And I'm wondering if the power of your loved one who was present at the time he said jasola husband, aka tabula hast monoket Allah for us Kitab Allah is enough. So please do not disturb yourself, do not worry yourself. Other companions. They said, No, no, no, let the Messenger of Allah write what he wants to write for us, because it will be it will be advice for us almost said he is not well, the messenger of allah sallallahu Sallam is suffering, he's in pain, so we should not disturb him. The others disagreed of course and there was noise, There was noise and the Messenger of Allah Allah Salam became disturbed by the
noise, and he told the companions to leave his presence. Allahu Akbar, now the Shia school or Shia scholarship to paid Omar radula one in bad light. They came up with some theories on this issue. Listen, Omar was deliberately preventing the Prophet salallahu Salam, the Prophet was going to write something very important which would we to this day do not know what the Prophet wanted to write some Shia. They claim that the Prophet was going to obviously write that Ali is my successor, okay, or some instructions to that effect. And our prevented that knowing where I was the prophet was going to write all my armor deliberately prevented that so they read the mind of armor, even though
Omar has died on the lower one centuries ago, they still continue to get into the mind of Amr, and they continue to get into the mind of Rasulullah sallallahu Sallam evidently not knowing what the prophets Allah Islam, one two wanted to write. So now this is the nutshell this is in. In a nutshell, this is the accusation that Omar is guilty of
depriving this OMA of important information which could have helped us right. Now, how do we respond Shankar Aziz has written a long article in the book. And to see the details you must go to the book, but I will summarize his responses. Shah Abdul Aziz responds by saying there are a number of things we have to consider. Number one, if Omar is guilty, because the Shia scholars say Omar is guilty because he
went against Islam in a number of ways, and what are those number of ways? For example, number one, Omar, he
opposed the Prophet sallallahu sallam, the prophet commanded something and Omar opposed the Prophet. This year, the Shia scholars or scholarship claimed or claims to this day. Why? Because the Prophet sallallahu Sallam as you know in the Quran, does not speak for himself. The Quran tells
In Surah Kannada we will learn Chicago regime is Amanda Rahim Omar young people Anil Hawa in her Ella, what do you have? That the prophets also speaks from Revelation Therefore Prophet commanded the companions to do something and our prevented them from doing it. Okay. Another accusation is that Amara was commanded by the prophets Allah Salam, therefore, it was a command from Allah, and whoever not does not follow the Command of Allah at a disbeliever woman, Mia commander, Allah Gouda, who will come through road. It's a verse of the Quran in surah Majda, that those who do not follow Allah commands deliberately do not follow Allah's commands, then they are disbelievers. So
therefore, therefore, for that reason, our deliberately ignored the command of the Prophet sallallahu sallam, he became a disbeliever.
Then another issue about the Sahaba, the Companions who started to make noise, because those who thought differently to Amar
asked the pen and paper to be brought and let the profit right. And the voices were raised the Hadith stage, clearly, the voices were raised. By the way, do you know about these caddies? How many of you roba let's have these.
So why, why don't we start by reading our own sources Insha Allah,
you know,
shuba had
doubts about Islam.
And sometimes we doubt these doubts lead to cover, you know why this happens? This happens because of your lack of knowledge.
Because you do not indulge in studying your sources. You do not know what Islam is seriously, most Muslims unfortunately, have adopted Islam as a habit
or as a cultural, you know, comfort.
They don't study Islam.
And because they don't study Islam, they easily become victims,
to doubts, questions, and attacks against Islam. This is very simple, we must understand that we must indulge in our literature, so that we cannot be easily misguided. Now, any Muslim, who does not know his sources,
doesn't understand them.
doesn't know how to defend them, and doesn't know where to go.
To get answers. Such as live in a sitting duck.
You're sitting, you're sitting duck.
For any of the hunters out there, any of the wolves out there.
Where the arrow of the bullet is coming from the Shia, or from the atheists are from the Christian, Christian missionaries. It doesn't matter where it comes from. You are a sitting duck.
So we need to understand our sources. That's why we did these lectures so that you can actually see there are sources that contain answers to some of the accusations and questions raised by others. And you can powerfully answer them and put them right in sharp.
So the voices were raised in this room in the presence of the Sahaba what happened? The Shia let's say it is haram to raise your voice in the presence of the police or somebody why because the Quran says yeah, you're Latina Manu, Latifah, who a swatter kinfolk I thought Nabi sallallahu alayhi salam, or who you believe, Do not raise your voices about the voice of the Prophet sallallahu Sallam Do not be disrespectful.
So these companions, including Omar, they were being disrespectful to the Prophet sallallahu ALA.
So, this is how the Shias
carved this argument. The story based upon the incident of catharsis.
So what is the response? She Abdelaziz Talalay writes pages upon pages in front of me, you know, and I cannot possibly go through all of them, but I will summarize his arguments. He said Firstly,
when Rasulullah Salah Salem uttered these words that give me the pen and paper. Omar was not the only one there. There were many companions there. Right. Among those companions were who among those companions are who?
Ali and Abbas. Both of them are present. So if you accuse Omar of
being malicious and not
enabling the prophet to write and advice, a piece of advice for the companions that you must accuse a boss and Ollie of the same. Why? Because they were present.
Why did it why did they not obey the Prophet sallallahu Sallam who is more important overall the Prophet brothers? Hello?
Are you sure? Yes, right who is more important?
The prophet or Amara? Yes, tell me the Prophet Luca young brother Masha Allah Allah cow literally is and you know the answer.
Masha Allah
the Prophet sallallaahu Salam is more important. Who did Allah say in the Quran to obey?
Who tell me
the Prophet, after Allah is the prophet. Now this is where the crux of the matter is, brothers and sisters. When you think of an incident, there are ways to respond to the job that is the law a does a great job and I will add some few points from myself as well.
So who does Allah say we have to obey your your Levina or do Allah Allah do Rasul? Allah remain calm.
For interest to Vijay in Farrotto in Allah rasool Allah Akbar, it's in the Quran surah Nisa, right over you believe, obey, obey Allah and obey His messenger and those who are power among you who are in power among you. And if there is a Kannada if there is a dispute for interest to V Shay in your dispute in something Farrotto Allah Hora su so then refer back to Allah and His messenger. So the messenger Allah is the ultimate authority alive in front of the companions in that room. Agreed? Yes. Who is present Ali and Abbas? So now our probate the member said no, no, no, don't bring the pen in the paper. The messenger Allah Azza wa sallam is ill. He is not feeling well. Don't burden
him.
Now there are two options Ali and Abbas who are also present in the room. They have two options. They either follow the messenger of Allah or they follow Omar.
Apparently, from the reports, we know that no one brought the pen in the paper.
No one brought the pen in the paper. So if we assume for the sake of the argument that AMR was malicious, Amr was deliberately trying to prevent the progress also known for giving some important information. What happened to Ali? What happened to Abbas
Why did they not obey the Prophet sallallahu sallam was scared of?
Of course not. We don't believe it scared of armor. No.
In fact, any I believe stood up when Omar did not stand up to fight aber hood
in the Battle of
the Battle of conduct when every one of the strongest fighters of the Koresh he came forward across the ditch and he came over and he challenged the Muslims for Mubaraka
Is there anyone among you who wants to fight me everyone is quiet? Because they know who I know who this
you know if you watch Khabib and McGregor, did you watch people MacGregor brothers? Hello? Hello? Yes. Did you watch the fight? The youngsters maybe did Imagine. Imagine if Khabib or one of them UFC fighters came here in the masjid today. And he challenged you in the masjid then you know who he is. All of you know who he is what he can do? He can break bones, you can snap your neck, he can put you in a lot and he can destroy you in 30 seconds, you know? Right, right. You know, would any of you would? Would any of you stand up to accept his challenge? Unless you want to die?
No, right? Similar situation there. everhot crossed the bitch is challenging. And all the Muslims are sitting there.
All even Ali stood up. Ali said Yara so Allah as a young man, he said I will fight him. And the messenger of Allah says Sit down. Sit down. Because even the messenger of Allah knows who everyone is.
And he knows Ali's a young child is a teenager. He will be killed instantly. Again, he challenges is there anyone among you? And as he stands up for the loved one, the Messenger of Allah tells him to sit down, sit down. He sits down again. Again, he challenges no one stands up and who is there? Oh, Paul Ha so bye
I'm not these big fighters are there but they are no match for him because they know they are not they are not a match for him.
And then the third time he challenges and Ali stands again, then Rasul Allah, Allah Allah
allows him to go. It is about the honor of Islam and Muslims go.
And when Ali went in front of underwater, Emma Rose said, I know you are the son of the fallen,
and I don't want to kill you.
You're a child. You're a young boy, or a young man, go send someone who is of my stature.
And he said, My mother called me hider. My mother called me lion, and I will show you what a lion can do. So it would attack him cut the long story short Ollie in a very short period, he dealt with Ebner woods, and all the Muslims of St. Takbeer. This is Ollie when
you think he was scared of armor? No, he was in the room. When this incident happened. Where do you put him? What category would the she asked put Ali Muhammad Ali? When did he not disobey the messenger of allah sallallahu Sallam if Omar did if Allah did? Why do you let off Abbas and Oliver we call everybody Allahumma. Why? Because our
brothers and humanity to Shia, they have blind hatred towards America.
So now it's clear that
they were in the room.
Also, if you love someone, if you love someone, and that some someone or the person you love is going through pain is ill?
Would you burden the more or you would you comfort them? So they are the Shia brothers and sisters in humanity.
When I say in humanity, I believe they are our brothers and sisters in humanity. Not in faith. I don't believe we follow the same faith. Okay, we do claim to borrow we do claim for the same faith. But in reality, when you look at the understanding of the Shia School of Islam is completely different to Sunni understanding on major issues on major issues, even the Quran, even the Quran,
the Sahaba, the Hadith,
even Allah,
we have differences.
That's why I say brothers and sisters in humanity. So
in this case, Oliver with our labor, the Alwan is also also to be blamed. In fact, if anything, Omar was kind to the Prophet sallallahu sallam, he gave his reason that the Prophet of Allah is in pain. He is suffering, do not overburden him, despite what he said because he feels for us. He loves us so much that he wants to go to extremes in advising us, you know, he would even even put himself in pain. He will put himself through so much trouble to advise us, but we should be merciful to him Rasulullah saw amazing pain and we should comfort him. It is very possible that Omar will power the Allah one was wrong in this maybe the other Sabo, right? Perhaps they were right, perhaps I'm saying
perhaps they were right that maybe Rasul Allah says, should be a you know, we should give him the pen and the paper so that he can write the advice for us. Okay, perhaps, but let me tell you why. armor was not wrong.
Why I believe armor was right or the Alwan.
What day was it when this incident took place?
Anyone knows? I said earlier, Thursday.
It was the day of Thursday. What day did the promise Allah pass away?
Monday. So how many days are between Thursday and Monday?
We are Friday.
Three
we are Friday, Saturday, Sunday, three complete days.
And the Prophet left. He even went to the masjid. He was taken to the member where he made the statement lon Allah your hood wonder Zara. If the Hulu rom via him misogyny
May Allah curse the
That Nosara those who make masajid above the grave of their Gambia,
the prophets. This statement was made by the prophet of Islam on the member before he passed away.
So we have clear evidence the Prophet sallallahu Sallam advised the Companions
between Thursday and Monday. So why the Shia accused AMR of preventing this Omar or depriving them of important important information?
Why? Why?
Because they hate America power. They love why you don't when you hate someone, since childhood when you have been conditioned from a very young age, to hate someone, right? From a very, very young age. It is very difficult for you to fall in love with a person you read. From a very young age you have been conditioned our tomorrow Maria, a lot Allah, Allah and Allah, everyone is cursing on but everyone is cut, you know, it's very difficult to you know, for example,
fall in love with that person.
So that's why
reasons had to be called. They had to be carefully crafted to justify irrational hatred towards America to justify unjustifiable hatred towards America. Now it's clear that Omar retort deprived almost anything. Why? Because from Thursday to Monday, the Messenger of Allah Azza wa sallam and plenty of time to tell the Omar
what he could not write down in that room on Thursday.
It doesn't stop there.
In fact, indirectly
the Shia school accuses the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam of not doing his job.
How
they are claiming that Omar had the ability to oust the biller, from Allah to shut the Prophet
SAW Allah when he was alone, just because Homer said don't or don't break the pen and paper because the Prophet is ill is going to pay, the Prophet went quiet, and he sent them away.
Even though the Prophet was perfectly able to speak, because the Hadith clearly states the Prophet said, Leave me he spoke, the Messenger of Allah spoke, he could easily say that I want you to write this, this, this, this this down.
Or in the three days he had after his illness between Thursday and Monday, the province of Prophet of Allah on the member, he could have said all the things he wanted to say in that room. So in fact, the accusation goes against the Prophet himself. So Allah, Allah is the prophet who is tarnished in these attacks against our North American Katara the Allah one.
Another accusation is that the Allah one, he disobeyed the Prophet sallallahu Sallam and Allah tells us to obey the prophet, a few Allah wa to Rasool Yes, yes, brothers. Allah says Allah ca for our A to lava deal soon. And Omar disobeyed. Okay, if Omar disobeyed
we take a Shia brothers and sisters in humanity back to the incident of the via what happened in Bolivia. What happened
in the via
Rasul, Allah Azza wa sallam had to
agree to a treaty with the operations. And when the treaty was being returned,
what do the reports tell us? Who was writing the treaty?
And even call it a
similar situation and see how it works out how people deliberately ignore information. If Omar is guilty of what we what he did, if your accusations are true and correct, and, and credible. Then let's see what led
when the treaty was written,
it was set to write Muhammad Rasulullah
sallallahu sallam. So here we go.
So had been our who was the man representing the operation he said, We do not accept your lawsuit Allah. If we accepted you as Rasulullah we wouldn't fight you.
So right Mohammed bin Abdullah,
Mohammed, the son of Abdullah, this is the Mohammed we know we don't know how others Allah and then the Messenger of Allah so compared to Ali, and he said to Ali Ali, cross out
Soula crossarm Rasul Allah What did he say? What did he say? Allah? I will not do it
I will not do it.
So will you apply the same verses to Ali Muhammad Ali Baba Mala Mala Mia Combi ma Allah via command or log file like normal coffee room
when you apply that verse to him, like you applied to
Ali was directly commanded by the prophet to do something and Ali refused to do it. He said, You're gonna live and not do it. You're gonna live and not do it, Wallah, he will not do it. He only to an extent where and he said, Allah will not do it, I will not cross. Why? We have a view on this. We believe Ali did this out of his love for the Messenger of Allah not to disobey, not to disobey Allah even with all Iraqi Allah one loved the Messenger of Allah and its status as Rasul Allah so much that he could not do it himself. And then the professor, show me where it is. And the Prophet cross start with his own hand Rasul Allah,
to compromise to reach terms with the operations to our peace, to have peace, but Ali did not do it. Two options. Number one, you make an excuse for Allah.
That Allah the prophet does, why he did not do it.
Number two,
he was disobedient.
And he was one of those people who the verse is talking about all of your commands or love or Lycoming Kakeru. Now the biller Tomorrow's a biller, if we apply the same standard that she has applied to hammer to Ali, in this case,
it would be the same as Omar so whatever excuse you may for any hair in this incident, make the same excuse for Mr.
Especially when the progress Allah Salam had three extra days to deliver the information he wanted to deliver, and he did. He did we believe on the member he gave plenty of advices to his companion. One of them was lon Alaia hood, Lon, Allah yahood, oneness, all right, Kahuku rhombi, I'm massaging. This was one of his advices.
So this is how we respond to this particular accusation. And will lie there's a lot more detail, which I did not cover
in this lecture, which is my time. Can you believe in oil you spoke about Omron nearly 14 minutes ago. Can you believe this? So this book is an encyclopedia of information it contains so many powerful and beautiful points that you can easily I mean, read this book you can easily answer and respond to all the accusations of the Shia against the Sahaba but the Allahu Anhu much
what other accusations they have against our cutout of your loved one that our ricotta Rhodiola Juan threatened to burn the house of Fatima
or our cutout of yellow one actually struck Fatima on her stomach and she had a miscarriage.
I'm going to briefly address these points and the details are in the book again. Firstly, threatened
to burn the house of Fatima is a completely separate issue to striking Fatima Rhodiola unhide the stomach and causing her to have miscarriage there are two different incidents with the Shia usually mix up. Okay. The threatening part is not actually the house of Fatima is actually anywhere the dissenters were getting together after br had been given to Abu Bakar and the Muslims had united upon the bow of a worker some people did not give by including Ali even with olive and some other individuals and they were getting together in a place to discuss this and Omar threaten them to keep the unity he did not threaten for tomorrow the Allah wanna he could not possibly threaten Fatima
Raja la Hana out the villa from Allah Bella Radha Omar said anyone who will try to dismantle our unity, we will fight them and we will burn the place they get together.
She has, again using
the dark lens. You know, when you read someone, you have two options. You can read look at someone through a clear lens and the lens will show you clear clarity. Yes. And then you can make the lens dirty. You can put all kinds of feces and urine on it. And then you start looking at someone through that lens. Are you gonna see feces or urine, right? Yes. So this is the lens of the she asked the use on the Sahaba especially over and over Bucha everything they did had to be malicious. By default, they will guilty until proven innocent.
And even if we prove the medicine, they're still guilty.
We will not accept any of the
justifications of the actions. So Omar was trying to maintain unity in this turmoil.
The turmoil was apostasy is in Arabia.
After after the death of the Prophet sallallahu sallam, many Arabian tries at apostatized,
the apostatized and they were planning to attack Medina, there were rumors. On top of that there was a threat from the Romans.
And then within Medina, this internal strife almost said we will not tolerate it. So this was the point. That's the context. Omar did not threaten Fatima Viola on her. Rather he threatened those who may be thinking of causing division. And of course, there was not a vision of 100 loungers, Hava united in the leadership under the leadership of Ibaka. To an extent that we have references that Ali will have not only fought for Abubakar Viola one in battles, he accepted me accepted provisions, the booty, the war booty. In fact, one of the sons of Oliver Vitali was called Mohammed
bin Han Ophea.
Muhammad was when Hannah via
Noor Muhammad Ali, because Mohammed Abu Hanifa was a mobile he was a child from Algeria.
A captive a war called Hannah via who came from Peru Hanifa Balu Hanifa was the tribe of Musella. Calcutta Musa Lama when he was fought by the army, the worker Ali was part of the army. And as his share of war booty was given this Jharia this wall captive called Hannah via who bought him a son called Mohammed bin Hannah via. So Abu Bakar Ali were on good terms, this clearly shows that they were in good terms of Ali had some vendetta against a worker in his heart on his mind, he would have said, I don't want anything for you.
You know, Gandhi.
Gandhi, was Gandhi.
Yeah, Gandhi. I wouldn't call him Mahatma Gandhi. Okay. Right. Gandhi was a freedom fighter against the British Raj.
In the early 20th century, most people know him. You know, the British imprisoned him. And they offered him all kinds of things, all kinds of things. Gandhi said, I don't want anything from you.
I don't want anything from you. Because of his principles. He was a principal man, he said, You are DRM me? I will not take anything from you. And the British Empire was far more powerful than aboubaker. The British Empire in its might was far more powerful than Abu Bakar materialistically. Materially speaking, but realistically speaking,
but even without him didn't do that. He actually took out all the presidents all the things coming his way from the long run.
Why are you telling me Ali was less of a man than Gandhi, Aldo Billa, Amal, the biller who don't believe that there is something wrong with your understanding of Ali and his relationship with the boubakeur and armor and the rest? So
at this time, our was trying to do that now second accusation that Amara hit Fatima so hard in the stomach that she had a miscarriage Wallah, he a lot of the Shia, they foster this misconception.
This lie
and by the grace of Allah Now some of them have started to come forward. And they have started to condemn those who use this use this argument because they themselves know it's a lie. It cannot be found in any of the Sunni books, and any of the Shia authoritative books. These are some late accusations made by some late Shia scholars against Oman, Qatar made of things live.
It's like today, in the year 2018. I write a book on
on
on behalf of the Shia and in the in this book, I write that Omar. In fact, you know what he struck fought him out of the lung on her on the head with the sword, and she bled and she was treated for this wound and she was injured by Oma. Right. It is an accusation. Now if I put it down in a book in 2018, Two centuries later, some she has read this story in my book, and oh, look, look, look look what amounted to Fatima. Look, look, look. Oh my god. Oh my God. Look how evil Omar was.
But there is no chain. There is no source to substantiate this accusation and it's so common. It is so common among the Shia. You will be shocked
that armor and think about it, look, use your rationality, use your rationality.
Most of you are some of you may have wives.
If you if you were to
abuse someone's wife verbally, let alone touching her, let alone pushing her like this. What would be the normal reaction? What would be a normal reaction of a man? someone's wife has been abused verbally on the street.
What do you think would be? It would be anger. It would be possibly a physical fight. Yes.
Most people would fight for their wives to defend her. Right? I can give you so many examples.
You speak bad or someone's wife? You're looking for trouble? Yes.
What if you touch someone's wife?
You might get killed.
If you touch someone's wife, you punch, slap kick, push someone's wife, you might get killed.
Doesn't matter whether the person is a Muslim or non Muslim? Because all people in most cases they love the wives.
Right. You're telling me Ali Vitali was less of a man
hider the one who fought a battle would the one who killed marhaba in the Battle of favor the one who fought fought Autobahn shaver
you telling me that man having seen what Omar did to Fatima as you claim you lie or some of your liars claim Ali would be standing idle Can you imagine that you're telling me how to build them all Willa Ali was was not a mad enough he was not mad enough to stand up for his wife
sisters can can you please the church take the children out inshallah outside
in short, I take the children out of sight sister because this disturb is disturbing the lecture.
Okay, so the point here I'm trying to make is that Oliver with Ali was not a coward
and Omar was not an evil barbarian barbarian to do that to Fatima della Juana
sisters control the children because they're making noise and I get disturbed because I'm thinking while I'm talking and when there is noise I cannot think
if the sisters can take the children outside and get them to go quiet inshallah and if they're quiet didn't come come back any child at all. Okay, I request that sisters take the Yeah, okay. The kids are quite there. It's okay, inshallah. Okay. So the point I'm making is that Oman, Qatar was not a coward. So this is one thing. And I think that point alone in itself is enough to deal with this accusation that you are here trying to paint AMR as a hater of Fatima do lawanna But at the same time, you are condemning Ali to cover this. You are condemning Ali to cowardice that Ali was a coward who could not defend his wife, the daughter of the messenger of allah sallallahu sallam, the
mother of Hassanein.
Other accusations against American Katara the follow on one of them is that he did not punish Mohammed Shabaab for Xena woolgrowers, Yaba committed adultery in Iraq, and witnesses were established against him and he did not punish him. This is again a lie, because when we read the story in detail, we realize four witnesses came forward, three of them witnessed and the fourth one slat the fourth witness basically could not complete the witness and all four of them were lashed for slandering movie Robin Sharma. So this accusation against our Katara Allah one is false. In fact, if anything, Omar wanted to carry out the punishment, Omar is the one who taught movie Robin
Chava to come to Medina from Kufa because movie era which was the governor of Iraq, he told him to come to Medina with those four witnesses who accused him when they came, almost said Okay, witnesses witness number one, what did you see? Witness number one said I saw this number two said I saw this number three sure I saw this. Number four wasn't too sure. Number four wasn't too sure. Omar said because of this. All four of you will be last for slandering for slandering and Valera, which was freed because of that not because Omar not Because Omer wanted to
To be free, rather Omar was very angry with movie Robin Sharma.
Another accusation, a source of hatred is that Omar forbade Martha. You know, Mata Mata is temporary marriage. Temporary marriage basically what is not are the Shia school. They believe in it and they practice it as well. Mota is a practice in which a woman can be married for either 10 minutes, over 10 hours over 10 months, over 10 years, depending on the situation. So the marriage can be for 10 minutes, and it can be for 10 years. So it's called temporary marriage. And it was allowed in the pre Islamic times. In the early part of Islam. It was also allowed to some of the Sahaba were doing a Rasulullah himself allowed it no doubt but at the time of agita, Allah rasool Allah, Allah Allah
Allah Sallam forbade the practice of mudra until Yeovil Kiama until the day of judgment, He said, You cannot do what are what is haram until the day a judge so Rasul Allah says ammonia louder in extreme circumstances three times, he allowed it three times, he forbade it three times, it was allowed at the time of Hatanaka. It was allowed at the time of fiber, and made haram at the time of fiber.
And there was another one, when the Sahaba had become so disturbed by the distance between them and the wife. Some of them they came to the Prophet salallahu Salam, and they said, Yars Allah, shall we castrate ourselves? Shall we castrate ourselves they man was so important to them, they could no longer take the the you know, the distance between them and the wives the pain with that and and the urge the sexual urge that there's a Shelby castrate ourselves as the messenger of Allah. So someone said, Why would you do that? And then the Messenger of Allah, the principal, the lesser of the two evils, he allowed Mota temporarily. And then at hudgell vada. There are reports into Asita one of
them in Santa Ana without the Rasul Allah, Allah, Allah, Allah, Allah for bed water until the day of judgment, but it was Omar, who applied the ruling completely
Omar had realized some people have still not got the message. Some people still have not got the message and they still indulging in moto. So Omar Rhodiola Juan, he based upon the Hadith the commander of the messenger of allah sallallahu Sallam applied the ruling that Mota is haram until the Day of Judgment. It is now a Xena. It was not seen before like calmer, calmer.
wine drinking was allowed in the early time of Islam right brothers? Yes. How do we know Allah says in the Quran?
Yeah, are you under the Rama no naka caribou Salah one Sagara oh you believe Do not come near Salah when you are drunk. So in other words, outside a Salah you can be drunk. It was okay to be drunk outside a Salah. But when you come to Salah don't drink, okay. So there was a half hour drinking in Medina. Wine was allowed in the early part of Islam. It was forbidden in Medina when the verse of Surah bromide was revealed. Yeah, you have Latina Armano in number kamaru One Maizuru one Islam one
and one sample resume anomaly shaitan fudge study who who are looking to fly home or you believe in toxicants are with other things, the working of shaitan the doing of shaytaan abstain from intoxicants. So that you may prosper. So likewise mukha was allowed in the early part of Islam and Muslims was gradually growing in Eman and then one was forbidden. Likewise Muhtar was forbidden and out to being forbidden. After being forbidden. It has been
like hover intoxicants, wine after being forbidden. It is haram.
It is from the Kabyle it is from the Kabyle so when sometimes when you say Mota is actually Xena that she has no no no, no, no, no. So what we're doing is, of course they were doing it of course because it was allowed. But when it was made haram they stopped doing it. Okay, some Sahaba had not got the message. So Oman, Qatar Rhodiola Guan, he made the decree Why'd he said anyone who does matar now we'll be punished. With Xena Mota is haram. The suit Allah says forbidden. Okay, so the Shia school has a lot of you know, enmity. It was almost one reason
Just because he is the one who, as I say, laid the smackdown
he is completely disallowed it. So these are some of the accusations against America talk among others in this book, Shark disease extensively deals with them and destroys a lot of their arguments.
And then we have other companions of the messenger of allah sallallahu Sallam who are accused of other things by the Shia school. Inshallah I plan to cover Shia accusations against aasmaaN Rhodiola on an eye shadow, the Allahu Unha and some other companions, and the last of our episode, episode number four in the series, and inshallah I don't think I have time to cover the accusations against a smart and responses to them, and the accusations against Ayesha and the responses to them and the Sahaba for example, I'll quickly read some out, read out some of these accusations and responses will be given in the next episode, part number four of the series. So one of the accusations against
us man is that he appointed oppressive rulers, oppressive governors in the Muslim empire. One accusation is that
Marwan father Hukam, was kicked out by the prophets Allah salam from Medina but Osman brought him back. Okay, postman another accusation is that of man used to favor his compound his relatives, his cousins, and he had given governorships of important provinces in Islamic empire to his cousins, right.
And other accusations are for example
aasmaaN forgave Abdullah bin Omar of kisses a case of sauce you know, when you are punished against a murder, so do loving Omar was not actually punished against a murder. So there are many more accusations like that against ottoman. One another accusation or other claim is that Sahaba they were actually happy by us man being killed, but it was definitely not happy. And we will see how when we talk about this in the next episode, you will see Ali was definitely not happy with the murder or with Monrovia lajuan And Ali went to extreme lengths in protecting with mom to an extent that he appointed two of his sons, Hassan and Hussein the most beloved grandchildren of the promise
of Ursula at the door of man to defend him against his murder. Why would you do that if man had no value for Islam or in Islam, against the law on how there are many accusations again, I shall Allah Juana she disobeyed the prophets, Allah Islam by leaving her house to fight and even returning in another report. There's a report in Makati that the sola pointed towards the house of Isaiah and he said that fitna is there there is fitna there is fitna again, this is a lie because when you look at the context, you will see the prophets Allah Salam was not talking about the house of Isaiah rather, he was pointing towards the east. Also, Ayesha is accused of other things such as
she fought Alabama with Oliver the Aloha, and she was jealous of Korea, etc, etc. So there are many more accusations against the Sahaba as well as Sahaba, which we will cover in part four of our series of this introduction to tafa Isn't Sharia Today we discussed their accusations against our authority lajuan And some of the responses that are more accusations in the book and the responses but for that, you will have to read the book, Make dua for us, that Allah enables us to translate this book into English language. It will be a huge service to Islam and Muslim. Thank you so much for this link, but humbly liar of anatomy. I will take questions. If that's okay, inshallah. I have
another 10 minutes 15 minutes, so I can take questions. Do you have any questions about this? If you want to ask any questions
in this
moment, that is still permissible. Yes. These days? Yes. The brother asked, do the Shia still allow matar to be practiced to this day? And the answer is absolutely emphatically Yes. If you go to Iran, there are matar centers there where you can actually do matar Mashhad is a city known for that. And unfortunately, our I don't want to get into grim details. But there's a lot happening in Iran. A lot of the Shia women are leaving Shia Islam because of matar because of the treatment they have received in the hands of men, those who abuse this so called privilege. There's a reason why I was forbidden by Allah Subhana Allah and His messenger because it's an evil practice. Like comedy was
evil. Hammer was evil Allah, but it was allowed in the early parts of Islam. So the Muslims
can gradually grow any man and once they are strong enough to resist it was made haram. Right likewise Mata was one of those things. So it was made haram for a reason but she has still continue practicing. It is like imagine some group claimed for a wine to be halal. Okay, wine is not clear. Maybe it was. So we will keep drinking. We'll keep drinking. So it doesn't work. Still being practiced anyone else?
Yes, go on please.
Yeah.
The title Why did the Prophet cross out the title Rasul Allah from the treaty. The Prophet sallallahu Sallam crossed out this title because he wanted to make a treaty. The Qureshi is we're making a big fuss about it. They were saying that we do not accept you as Ursula, which was true. The Qureshi is did not accept the Messenger of Allah as the messenger of Allah. So the Prophet realized that maybe it is not appropriate for him to put down is titled Rasul Allah, because the Quran is not accepted. They only accept him as Mohammed bin Abdullah, but that's why he wrote Muhammad Abdullah, instead of writing, Muhammad Rasul Allah, okay. Likewise, when Ali Ali refused to
cross it, the Prophet said, you will, you will be in the same situation.
So, and that's what happened to Ali been a
Christian.
Sorry,
sisters, can you please, please, please request again, take the child who's crying outside
the commitments on the purpose of human validation? We do commend, reading leading the
show.
I can't hear you Sorry.
Yes, go ahead and shuffle. So people know, of course, the busier commitments, would you recommend? People read the motorcycle?
Yes, that's a very, very, very good idea. The chef asking Is he asked that nowadays people don't have time to read long, lengthy books. So shall we read an abridgment or a shortened version of this book? That's a very good idea. I think we should have a complete translation. And then at the same time, we should have an abridgment for people to read. Alternatively, you can
read short articles on websites like trover dotnet, 1212, Assia dotnet. There's a website, you must consult is an academic website. They have a lot of these things summarized in the English language on in articles. So there's a website I recommend starting from day one is Twelver shia.net. Okay, you will find a lot of these articles from there. And even in Nigeria, I think you can find it online, translated some parts of it in English language, not all of it some parts, but you're right. I think if tasar or moto Sir, should be available for people to consult those who cannot read long, lengthy volumes, they should start with shorter books, and then make make their way up each other
slowly. As you know, there is only one
which is called moto moto certified natural. Yes.
Yes. into English. Yes. Yes.
No, I agree. Yes. Yes. Just a question. And also many comments regarding the narration about the Hadith or kita. Yes. The narration I came across, there's not specifically state a pen, a and the paper, right? What it says is like how to do how to act,
which is not like bullying or prepare, so that I write for you. And this is not an easy the word up top. This is this. This assumption is that he's asking for some material. Yeah. Because we know that even not being not very explicit. It can be interpreted in a deep stage for you to write. Yes, yes. And the reason for this is some of the, of the communists and enemies of Islam Yes. have also taken this hadith in order to misinterpret it to other people or to the Prophet can right. Yeah. That how come people say that is illiterate. Yeah. Look what happens. Yes.
He was exposed. hassled Yes, yes, yes, I understand. Yes. Yeah. Again, you're right. Absolutely. There is no doubt that the prophets Allah Islam did not know how
to read and write the prophets, Allah Salam, to our knowledge, there is no evidence that he was able to read and write. And this is why we interpret this hadith in the way that the promise of CERN is asking them to bring something, because again, this is clear from Surah havia. So havia, who is writing, it is writing the prophet is that and even when he says,
I want to cut out show me where it was ALLAH, he did, he doesn't know where it is, he can show me and then he will show they showed him and then he crossed it out with his own hand. So there is plenty of evidence to this effect that also Lhasa son did know how to read and write and this these cannot be used in that regard, because there is no clear cut evidence to the Prophet himself with his own hand ever wrote anything? It would have been well known to the Companions if he did, but it was because right reading and writing was like having a PhD. If there was a PhD doctor in the masjid, you would know who he is, right? Yeah. Likewise in the Arabs among the Arabs, those who who
could read and write, they were like PhD doctors. What was the condition of the Messenger of Allah Salah Salem
for the Qureshi is when they were caught in the Battle of buzzer those of you who can teach my companions to read and write will go free. If the providence of new Adrien right would you know be teaching them and so?
So it's clear Rasul Allah says, Never wrote, and he never read a book. Never he didn't know how to read. He didn't know how to write he was unlettered, not illiterate, we don't call him illiterate, illiterate literacy is a completely different question. He was unlettered not illiterate, because the one who is receiving the Quran cannot be illiterate. Okay? When he said Ma Namikawa in MonaVie are a means I cannot read I cannot look at book books and read. So Rasulullah says Ron was not one of those people. And the Quran actually addresses that point. So his Companions would be the first people to acknowledge that that he knew how to read and write but they are the ones who acknowledge
that he did know how to read and write. Yes.
When you mentioned that the other group considers them to be pressing humanity
that we don't you consider limited? Muslims, obviously, they are not Muslim and the brother has asked me when I say
coffee
listening is to
either way
the brother is asking when I say Shia are our brothers in humanity. What do you mean by that? Are you actually considering them? kuffaar Are they are carriers or they are Muslims who are misguided. I believe that the awam the general masses of the Shia, they are misguided. Okay, and I this this is the view of Scheffel, Islam, ethno Samia, and I believe is the strongest few that alarm the masses of the Shia they are misguided, right? But they are all among those who have studied and they know the weaknesses of their faith. And the arguments are not Muslims. I don't consider them Muslims. They are deliberately disbelievers deliberately display that show that choose to disbelieve okay,
because they know what they believe in is false. They know for a fact but they believe in this is for example, some of them are not even practicing. You know, the one of the major scholars are Hui Alko. He was a chain smoker.
Can you believe shackle bunny chain smoker? Can you imagine shackled body? Or one of the Allamah from Egypt or world on our shoulders? Smoking in front of everyone smoking away like a train? Can you imagine that? Yeah. I'll Hui who wrote one of the most important works on El Mirage on our margin mercury. John was a chain smoker.
And homenaje who is the supreme leader in Iran now has a huge collection of pipes. You know, smoking pipes, Sherlock Holmes pipes, you know those pipes. You know what I'm talking about? Have you seen those nowadays people don't smoke in them. He loves pipes to an extent that his collection consists of millions of dollars worth pipes.
He has the largest and the best collection of smoking pipes in the world common he is a pipe smoker. So a lot of these people, these are the people you cannot accept them as Muslims because they know what they're doing. For them. It's all power. It's all about power and money. It's like the Catholic Church. It's like the Catholic Church. A lot of the Catholic bishops. They don't actually believe in Catholicism, they don't believe in Christianity. They may be atheists, but they just have this uniform and this this office and the money that comes with it. That's why a lot of them are abusing children. Child abuse, you know, scandals in the church. Why?
Do you think this happens?
Is it because of strong faith? Is it because their faith is strong? No. It's because they don't have faith. So a lot of these people are like that. So my view is that they are brothers in humanity, because they come from Adam and we come from model or when it comes to Islam, they view Islam is completely different to us. And this is not an extreme statement. This is a factual statement. This is a fact. No one should be iffy about it. No one should be uncomfortable about it because this is what the facts on the grounds on the ground are. We have a different understanding of the Quran they do. Okay, our seminar is completely different to this. They don't follow Sahaja they have their own
four books. They have Kotova, larva Alkota wah wah, coffee listhub, sar, Mullah guru faki. A Talib these are the four sources of
fic jurisprudence, the tradition, and their Hadith actually doesn't go back to the Prophet they at least go back to the Imams, mainly to Imams, Imam, Jafar sodic and Imam Muhammad Ibaka. And they don't go beyond as long as they get to the Imam to them. It is as good as the Quran or as good as following the monsoon, the infallible Imam. But even a lot of these reports are attributed to Imams or lies. Imams, didn't say most of these things, when you see the change, when you study the change, you will see that there are liars and mojisola and heretics in the change. People you cannot trust unlike Bukhari and Muslim
in the chains of Bukhari and Muslim we have, we know the people, we know who they are, they were Imams, they were known figures, they were public figures, the characters are known. But a lot of these chains the Shia books have you don't even know people are mature Mirja Hill, you don't know who is who some reports even started Colorado, Ron Ali Abdullah, all alone. And Abdullah a man said that above the law, the Imam you know, said such and such cassava but the question is Who is the man who is the man who is reporting from the Imam you don't know. It could be anyone. It could be Joe or Tom or Terry or you could be anyone you know, so we don't accept it.
My time is up.
Related Episodes
- Wisam Sharieff – The Perfect Day 10
- Abdul Wahab Saleem – The 10 Commandments – EP07
- Shadee Elmasry – These People Deserve Hadd Punishment
- Abu Bakr Zoud – Achieving Taqwa (Piety) In The Sacred Month Of Rajab
- Shadee Elmasry – The Power of Dhikr & Du’a
- Bilal Philips – The Best In Islam #27
- Saad Tasleem – Search For The Soul Mate When Where And Why For Muslims With Sister Suzy Ismail