Channel: Waleed Basyouni
Bulugh Al Maram Series presented by Sh Waleed Basyouni at the Clear Lake Islamic Center
This lecture was presented on Feb 15, 2017.
He was a happy human. What about shallow Tada. Today? We'll try to finish to Hadith eight and nine, but we'll start reading number eight first.
Yeah, one Abbey harati Allahu anhu Kala Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam por hora de comida wa t Hill kalba Yoshida who Saba Murat, Willa hoonah Vitara Raja who Muslim have a love for the law who anti muslim failure will return me de
la hoonah una
Abu hurairah hora de la on reports Allah's Messenger sallallahu alayhi wa sallam said the cleansing of the utensil belonging to one of you after it hasn't been licked by a dog is to wash it seven times using soil for cleaning at the first time. This is reported by a Muslim another version in Muslim Muslim has he should spill the contents the version in thermos he has using soil as the first at the first or last time
What do you guys think of soil is a good translation
a terracotta soil
dirt, soil, sand,
dry dirt. Okay.
This had it had it ever heard of a lion? Ma'am? Then hijaab Rahim Allah, Allah mentioned it as one of the Hadith that speaks about what keep the water pure and what's impure make the water impure. Now whether the unit juice will map one or the other.
And this hadith is authentic, as you heard reported by the Muslim or himolla and that the Muslim whenever he narrate Hadith in his saw here with this not it means he believes it's authentic and the Lima Muslim Rahim Allah one of the most trustworthy scholars or trusted scholars when it came to authenticating the Hadith. By the for the sisters if they want to come up, we have the partition setup.
Here you heard him saying and there is an aeration and Muslim he should spell the contents file FL euro spell the contents. This even though this additions came in one of the narrations and so Muslim, but many scholars talked about the authenticity of it like an amendment nessa Rahim Allah was a member of na Abdel bar Amanda Pardo this additions is shad the the narrator of this edition, he many people narrated the hudy only one of them mentioned this edition, spoil the content, but the others never mentioned it. So they said that means he basically narrated something
contradict what did the other people narrate? Well, so that means we call this had a shot in the heart of a thicker, much more I see a cart oh man who Oh supplement.
this is what the set but to be honest with you this objections is not a very strong argument. Why?
Because in animal Hadith, in science of Hadith, we differentiate between two things when the trustworthy narrator narrates something that contradict or something as an addition, that does not contradict
Can you tell the difference? Any I should do laser and nearly theater. Madam era will a hurricane. We're in an era mahali freeway, Arkady as an imam of Raja Rahim Allah said then shalina tirmidhi. He said that when the trustworthy narrator narrates something that contradict that's weak, but if he just bring in addition, an extra meaning that they didn't mention, and no contradictions, that's not a weakness. That's extra information that Allah subhanaw taala have saved the deen through these different durations. They appeared when the prophets or Salam said, let the person
spoiled or basically spoil the content, spell the content, the content, spell the content, is that something contradict the other generations
Half of unhedged Rahim Allah hota. Allah said no, because if you believe that when that dog put his mouth inside the water, and that water became impure, you're not allowed to use. Okay? So that means you have to get
thrown away. It's obvious. There's no contradiction there, right? So obviously, nobody would say the prophets of Salaam telling us to walk to wash it seven times, but by the way, you are allowed to drink the water.
Yeah, they said that's not that's obvious. So no contradicting here between the two generations. That's why the narrator audio news her the two narrated this throne airmesh is a trustworthy narrator Bukhari Muslim Ahmed been in many scholars consider him as an authentic narrators. They
also hear he said that in a tournament, he there is a version which he said using soil at the first or last time. So one of the narrator kind of doubt it isn't the first or the last. There is one duration explicitly said the first and it telemedia as well. So one explicit, the first one explicitly said it's the first or the
last. Okay, so here allama Rahim Allah have a question. When he said, when the Hadith said using soil at the first or last time, this or from the prophets of Salaam or from the narrator.
Can you tell me what will be the difference?
How that will make a difference?
That how that will make a difference in the ruling?
of the profits are seldom said that that means the profit giving us the option to do the cent in the beginning or the end. But if it's the narrator who's confused, or the narrator said or that means that's the narrator's opinion, is understanding that this can do the first or he himself for God. And it was not sure about and most of the time I said it is actually a statement from the narrators and from the narrator himself. That's why the majority of the narrator said the first should be with cent. Except another narration We'll talk about it later on, which is also an eternity. He said, Well, I fear over a minute a bit tore up
views, the sand or the soil to basically rubber rub the the container with it and the eighth time
he said, PAHO in a honeycomb. The Prophet sallallahu Sallam said, the cleansing the purification of you the utensil belonging to one of you. So the purification before so that means is not pure. That's why we purify it. So that means if it's not pure it is
there's nudges that's how the aroma rahimullah took it.
And by the way, he said enough, enough is your turn. So and that goes to cups goes to anything that you use like utensils. So let's say the dog lick the spoon, let the knife look
anything like that it will take the same ruling okay. So it doesn't need to be a ball or a plate. So anything that the same concept, the cup or anything like that, if you want to if you want to use it, you have to wash it seven times the first one of them should be with set from this hadith Rama Rama mala said that an adjuster impurity can be divided into three levels Naja to move her lava extreme and adjust extreme impurity. Okay, and they said this is the impurity of the dog and pigs listed the pigs similar to it. And they said impurity which is regular like the urine of the human and the feces and they said these are basically regular type of ninjas. When adjust them
and adjust which is lighter, nudge as light and adjust light and adjust that they should Like what? Like the vomiting because the vomiting you do need to wash it completely.
Just by spraying water over it will be enough or like the Prophet sallallahu Sallam said about Elma V which is the discharging that comes out of sexual activity other than the sperm so the the said that many that comes out it is half of it that's why the problem said just basically put your make your hand wet and sparks on water and it will be enough to clean it or the set also like Bowl jharia you know if you have an infant female and she urinate you don't need to wash it the process of them or us to spray water over it
so these things these considered and adjust them for light and adjust
as for any the issue of the impurity of the dog and is it true that this the dog saliva makes the water nudges?
Is that something what I just said earlier? Is that something like agreed upon? Or this is something that I read about him a lot debated over this issue has a lot of neat
there is a lot of information about it or summarize some of it I put together some points to fortify it for lithified
First I want to say that human beings generally speaking naturally rock climbing to like dogs
that's something natural that's why it's been man best friend. That's right. And been best friend of human beings since a long long time ago. And we know the story of Adam calf the story of the cave where they had their dog with them what kaboom Bassett on there I believe was seed oven Cathy Rahim Allah said even the dog was mentioned in a positive manners because he was in the company of good people.
Also, I'll kidnap known to be a hunting method. That's why I Lost Planet Allah said, Our alum to mineral jawara himachali been
what you taught from algebra McKenley been with mocha Libby means the dog, the trained dog for hunting, as Mujahid and biohack. And it's so deep and others set.
Also, especially here in the Western society, dogs are very common
in the culture that we live in, in in America here. It's a culture where dogs are basically part of the culture, part of the concept of civilizations. You know, that's why they said, between 37 to 47% of Americans are an American household owns dogs that make it from 72 million to 80 million people in America owns dog.
He can walk the street anytime you see someone in the neighborhood, have a dog and a very rare to find someone in your neighborhood don't have a dog. That's right. So that's something why I'm saying this because it means we interact with dogs a lot.
In the airport, you go there is a dog sniffing your, your body or your bags, you know, a canine. in this society, we deal with dogs a lot in a more friendly manners, I guess.
So that's why I think it's important for us to understand the rulings, the Islamic rulings related to dogs. And the first thing is, what's the ruling in regard to the purity of the dog's saliva?
Okay, so no matter human, the law said the saliva or the sweat of the dog. Okay. Like for example, if you notice that the nose of the dog all was wet, that's right. So they said what's the ruling in regard to this? Is that what tennis and in the the dog's nose or the saliva in some dogs are so slippery, you know, as this something impure or nudges?
The majority of the alcohol the set, we don't differentiate between the dog's saliva, or the dog, the witness of the nose, or the if you put your hand on the dog's back and it's wet, because sweating. They said it's all nudges. And that's a Shafi Rahim Allah has madhhab and one narration from Allah.
Abu hanifa Rahim Allah also said it's
is not just okay. And the witness of the nose is also not just a name of law one notion said that what that what is the proof their proof the said when the prophets also said either voila Cal woofie Ny haidakhan What's Walla Aloo it means when he put his mouth inside the Ethan's so he put his means his mouth and his nose okay. So this is nice these two if it comes into a content come contact with the with any utensils it will turn this utensil to something need to be purified. So the said that means it is nudges. So it means it's not it's not the hoard because the process of them said bajo the purification of it. So that means Miss Luba, Yanni that utensil is not pure. And the only time
we call something not pure, if you have one of two,
I said that last class to
if you are missing one, if you when we consider this person is not behold,
if you What if you have no jassa impurity, or you break your rule? That's right. You can pray, obviously breaking the law and how does the US law our act, what is not something applicable to what and how that is not applicable to utensils. So what's left impurity? So that means that utensil is not part because of Nana jassa. Not because of the hottest obviously,
it makes sense. So that means that's the enema rahimullah said that's basically what it is.
And they said that that's what our proof that this the process of said, purifying this utensils is by washing it seven times, not only one time seven times, that means it's absolutely not just
so the Shafi said and that's one generation from the Hanafi and the hammered. They said the following. They said since the prophets of Salaam said that about his mouth and nose that apply to his tail apply to his Paul apply to his back apply to his hair to everything in the dark.
We said since one part of it nudges so the rest is also
the second opinion which is the official opinion of the HANA fees. And one donation from Rahim Allah.
And that's the choice of Islam Jamia Rahim Allah,
they said that the only thing nudges and the dog is his saliva,
but his back his saliva, and that basically the part of his nose. This is the nudges part.
But they said anything else on his body is not nudges.
They said, What's their proof? They said, Because simple reason.
If everything in the dog is nudges, if touching the dog's back, or the hair or anything else on the dog nudges
it, wouldn't the prophets or southern inform the companions about this? That's right. He informed them about the mouth and about drinking from the water or utensils. So if also, what he walked over with his feet is also nudges. He would have tell us any place where the dog walk, you should clean it. That's right, any place where he said he should clean it, but then there be sallallahu Sallam didn't do that. And we know that the dogs used to be very close to people in Medina, for instance, Abdullah negroamaro, the lion said, couldn't do an AMA FIM STD Rasulullah saw Sodom, I used to sleep and mustard Rasulullah sallallahu sallam. Welcome to fatten Shaban as when I was a young man, a
young single man. Okay, well can attend Killa Buta boo, boo, beautiful mustard.
He said dogs used to come in and out and urinate. Or it doesn't necessarily have to be your you know how the dogs they may not Mark places. So maybe he saw them marking some places in the dogs and I don't think the dogs of the Sahaba is different than us. You know, dogs his dog. Okay, so he said they used to make that while I'm sending the message and watching them and nobody used to kick them out. Nobody used to watch
That after they do this, and that's the most here. They happier him a whole lot. guts. So yeah. And he confused about this headed and a little bit irritated about that the word, taboo, urinate, and he said this addition must be weak.
Why is it because it's impossible logically that the Sahaba will let the dogs urinate and the master but they'll help people Baghdadi Rahim Allah said no other interaction is authentic you can argue, but maybe even Amaro they allow and was describing the case when the mustard has no walls okay when the mustard was completely open, and he meant that they urinate around the mustard
because there is no walls on the sides so basically if there are outside like like out the door here is is not necessarily where the people really pray and gathered said maybe it is outside and that's what an emammal Rahim Allah
dead said but he said later on when the build the walls and the doors the dogs cannot come anymore
anyway she's gonna sell him on law said interesting point he said the Hadith only spoke about what Lulu putting the mouth inside Dayton's. So if there is anything else is haram or need to be purified, he should have said a lot of settler mentioned other than the mouth but the Prophet sallallahu Sallam didn't mention that.
Also they said since the prophets are allowed is allowed dogs to hunt.
And that means you hold the dog you let the you interact with the dog. And then these are some didn't tell the hunters By the way, make sure that you if you touch the back of the dog, it's not just you wash your hand or have it sit on your carpet. It's make it haram to pray there. He never mentioned anything like that.
They the third opinion
that the dog is absolutely pure. The saliva, the nose, the back, the hair, everything and the dog is pure exactly like cats. There is no difference between cats and dogs when it comes to the purity of its body. And that's the position of an Imam Malik Rahim Allah and the great Imam of the shama emammal ozai and the grips color of Kufa, imams of yarn authority, Rahim Allah and emammal Tabby in the grid scholar of Medina Eman Mohammed even Shihab azuri Rahim Allah and it can go on and many other names as well.
And remember, Abdel Rahim Allah said, that it is agreed upon that Malik and his students, that the dog is absolutely nothing but pure.
And the only reason we wash the utensil seven times it is taboo, then it is not because of impurity, it is because the prophets of solemn order us for a reason, that it is just a pure worship a pure following the sooner but not because of impurity.
And he said
they What about the process of spill the water,
the spill the water,
they said, if this water is not impure, why the person would waste the water, especially in the old days, water is very valuable. They said that the promise of Solomon he said spill the water. Lisa Mr. Lupo in MLA Ned lilla Tillis techradar they said it is recommended because it is disgusting to eat and drink from the dog's food or the dog's water to drink from the same water that the dogs drink.
And you might say, but the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wasallam didn't say the same thing about cats.
So I found an interesting thing.
First of all people will hate to drink after cats. That's why I told the man who drink with his left hand he said our did to ensure you have America here. Would you like it if you drink with the cat? Is it No, no. That means something nobody likes it. So it is obvious. It is mistaken or something nobody would love to have it.
It's also annoying.
thing that I found a research paper.
You can look that online. What's the difference between the dog and the cat when they drink?
They said dogs when they drink they return back the water to the
to the utensils. Cat never do that.
Cat when the drink it never spit back spit anything in the water while dogs do that.
And if you ever had a dog, And you notice when the dog drink, the water became murky, because you spit inside the water. Cats Don't do that. Cats is much cleaner than dogs. Like how a woman and men Exactly. Woman are much cleaner than dogs are most likely the men sorry.
it's a joke. They said Why? You know, even they said they have a cleaner mind than
men. Because they always change their mind.
Just anyway, so going back to the point which is
the the dogs and the cats there is like difference between them. But anyway, they said it's let's take that because it's something people will not be interested in doing that. They what's their evidence?
What's the evidence that it is pure, and it's not nice? They said number one.
A lot of allowed us to hunt with dogs are not
absolutely in the Quran. And if the dog is nudges, that means he will make whatever the dog catch. Not just as well. Whatever he bites it became that and we never heard that the prophets of Salaam said by the way, when the dog catch the bird, make sure that you wash it seven times one of them was to drop like what the chef is saying. Nobody ever said that nobody will say that. And since it is an animal and it is allowed to use for hunting, it means it is pure. That's why whatever catch will be pure for you.
Also an abuse Allah Allah Allah you it was a lamb was asked in the Hadith vihara nlk lava was Seba tell Phil here at bay in McDowell Medina for Allah Murphy boonie Murphy boonie one shot Robin what are
the prophets all sudden when he was asked?
There is certain areas where there is in the desert will be a collection of water because after the rain, but this collection of our spots were water stagnant gather. So this is the other sort of lot. Sometimes this water approached by dogs and sea bass and animals wild animals and they drink from it. Then the prophets of Salaam said it has what's ever what is inside it. And we have this water for us for hood pure for us. And he caught a pothole that means it's not magic. So if the dog will turn the water to nudge that water will not be allowed.
The prophets of Salaam was only referring to the NASA NuvaRing onto the washing the utensils.
He never mentioned anything about making it impure. He just said wash it. If If you understand from washing it, it means it became nudges. So that means the water that they approach and the desert is also became nudges. You might say but you chef, maybe this water is large number we say did the Prophet maker distinguish between large and small now, and if you familiar with deserts and vnuma sometimes area will be a lot and sometimes it'll be less isn't there's not like common thing.
Also, they said that the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam said jabril came to me last night
and jabril did not approach in the house. They didn't enter the house. Why?
Then in the BSL allow it you it was a lamb was told that inside their house was a dog.
Okay, that's why gibreel didn't enter the house.
What's the doc? It's the dog belong to Allison well, Hussein, it's a puppy, Donal and Hassan per se, that Inaba didn't let him
A number. Yeah and he she among both the animals. So
It's like a piece of furniture and the dog was hiding like couch or you know or or table whatever the is hiding underneath of it and in Ibiza some didn't notice it and this is reported by the neighborhood and the site as well.
And it's been said maybe underneath the oceti which is the bed of the prophets Allah La to do something.
we say that this dog in Ibiza solemn order them to get it out.
We know that the dog set and the dog lick and the dog sniff That's right.
If the dog was nudges, don't you think it'd be Salalah Sallam would have ordered them to wash these places?
That's right. But they never saw never did. But you might say, but there is a narration where an Obi sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, Amara Nabila Emma Can he order to spray water where it was, we say is spraying water is not washing, but he why it did not is actually a proof for us. That is not nudges, because of nudges, he will say repo la like the urine of the man and the mustard said pour water over it when the minion urinated in the floor. But that's the person should spray just water here and there where it was because again, human being feel not comfortable to be in the same place where the saliva of the dog or maybe use of the porcelain, just dead duck. But that shows you that is
really not approved that it is
also one of the evidence that the set the edited neural model that I mentioned earlier, where the dog used to come to the mustard and enter and exit and again the dogs always sniff and basically touch the ground with their nose. And that shows you that the did that and in a piece of solid didn't order the Sahaba to clean that or look after it if it's an adjust.
Also one of the evidence that the set they asked the the first group of scholars and they said
do you guys believe that the urine of the dog not just
they said what?
Yes. Do you believe that the feces of the dog not just what they would say?
What do we say? Yes obviously that's right. Type f the dog urinated in a utensil
or poop in a tense
and a plate Do you guys believe you must wash it seven times one of them with sand
they said no.
They would say that the Hadith is specifically said about licking and drinking from it.
So they said the medic he would say so which one is worse the urine and the feces or the saliva
not no doubt that the urine feces is worse. But still you don't do it seven times. And the adult didn't speak about it seven times. So that means the seven times for the saliva it's not because of the impurity it for something else Allah Subhana Allah wants us to do it for another reason. But the promises are never told us exactly what is that reason as
okay and that's their argue they said the Hadith about seven times. It's our proof to tell you that if it is Natasha, three would have been enough.
One it will be enough.
Okay, seven times with water would be enough. But we never heard. We never heard that to Sherry I ever comes to tell you that you purify an adjuster with two with sand as Soil and Water
is never heard before. No matter how this Najaf says a hot vitae does. So that means there is another reason behind this order from the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam
any, there is other evidence that they have
a lot of data and I personally believe that the magic is mehtab is the strong man hub is a very strong method. And I believe also that this is more suitable to the Muslims who live in the West. Because how many times I would be asked, oh, I passed by my neighbor and he like my
Got a dog touch my clothes, okay, or my basically neighbor came came and or I wasn't at my unloads a new Muslims or someone like you know visiting neighbors or someone who's not Muslim or in the airport I have a brother who was telling me that he washed his suitcase seven times and with sand because the Customs and Border Protection dog smelled his dog or licked his suitcase and his clothes and all those things. So that I believe is here especially in the West. That is how a mash up
for many Muslims to deal with this issue of purifying the
the saliva of the.as for the dog's feces and the dog's urine and me know your AHIMA Allah said that will very happy said ijma and Muslim una Alana Dasa t bo, Lil kelbyone. Authority.
There is a consensus and agreement between all the Muslim scholars that the urine and the feces of the dog is something impure
type, how can we purify it?
If it has food in it, or water?
If it is because the person himself spilled the water. So it means also you can make this analogy and he said through the food away.
Let's say you're putting your your your food and the dark comes and
basically touch your foot.
It's your chicken about to eat it.
Okay, and came on maybe for many of you is not a very common scenario. But if you're a new Muslim,
that's very common scenario happen. If you have non Muslims who comes or you visit some people, non Muslims, you know, in their homes, huge, a very common scenario could be happy. Or maybe the food that came to you from a neighbor, who knows,
you know, if it is touched by a dog or not. So what would you do in something like that?
The Maliki said you're allowed to eat the food, obviously, because they don't believe it's nudges. But you must you must clean the plate. By the way, the Maliki who said it's pure, they still believe you have to clean seven times one of them would the sand because that's the process order, but not because of impurity. And the set
for the water because the Prophet explicitly said it will be spell so you have to spell it.
But they said for the food, no other aroma Rahim Allah said no. You can make analogy, the water the food take the same ruling of the water type.
And you heard me saying
basically, before that this is applied to this duration spill is the debate over the authenticity of
claim some American law said there is exceptions. The exception is if the dog is a seen dog. If the dog is a dog, that service dog in a dog that for hunting, the dog that the Prophet allowed us to possess. They said if that dog eat or drink from a utensils, you can use this utensil without washing it seven times.
But even hajra Rahim Allah said, that's not correct. And one of the good evidence that he mentioned four or five time ways over here if you did this from four or five different ways, but one of the good points that he mentioned that if you look at the Hadeeth and navy sauce on them, Sophie kill this lady. We're calvillo Hernan, waka, Laval, kal woofie and I had a feeling of somebody in the Hadith the person give the permission to have a dog and for a shepherd to have a dog or a hunter to have a dog and he said and ever the dog
had a dog basically
eat or drink from drink or put his mouth and
the utensils you should wash it seven times. So the person mentioned it after he mentioned the permissibility of having these kind of dogs.
like what is
said the Maliki said you're allowed because it's pure. But the majority said no, you should spill it, throw it away and wash it seven times. One of them with sand first time how we wash it. Okay, the process of them seven times the first one with sent the narration of the first one would send is the most authentic narration among all of them
the most authentic without going to details there is a lot of Hadith. any details here, but rewired Ola Honey, I have already wired the narrator generators of this rewire are the most accurate generators. Okay.
And makes perfect sense. Because if you take the narrations Can anybody tell me here? Let's say you know nothing about animal How do you know nothing about the generator, but I want to just use to come and since it's stuck the Minneapolis basalt then durations, the last one with sand doesn't work.
Because you have an urgency the first and the last. The last can't work logically. Why?
Yeah, because the sand it has to be washed. That's right. Water, water, water water then you put a sand in the end.
You're gonna keep it with you have to watch the sun. So it makes no sense. That's why
that that duration of first is the most authentic narration very obvious. Okay. So they said the sand in the beginning because when you when you clean to the sand, it will take all the saliva and whatever from the dog attached to this utensil. It will wash it away, then the water comes to clean it afterwards. How you do that? Do you put the sand then you pour the water or you mix the sand with water outside and make it like muddy and you wash it it doesn't matter. Both ways can be done. You put a sand then you put water in or you put water a little bit then you put the sand on the top of it so you can use it both Okay.
Coming to this coming. Also,
ella moroccanoil I said that there is one narration and say Muslim Thurman who nabbit Torah wife Pharaoh who say Amina tabet Torah
what is that and make the eighth with St.
Ne this concept this narrations and Eman with Rama law said the only one the only one who took this narrations and apply it literally was the hustle and bustle.
Hustle was no one else among the Sahaba that debate in that debate in the origination ever reported that he took that position. But to show Kenya Rahim Allah said it doesn't matter. Because the Hadith is explosive, the narration is clear, and the eighth one should be he should be dusted or with sand and show kind of hemolysis and that's By the way, one opinion from an Imam Malik one donation from an Madurai Mahalo to Ana. And it is not true that there is nobody have done this before.
He said the mathematic also one narration from him that you do the eighth one with sand and
I've been hard on him Allah have mentioned that as well.
As for the eighth of Imam Shafi, he said I don't know if this authentic narration or not so sure can he said Alabama Shafi didn't know but we know it's authentic. It's Muslim. Okay. And
very happy said this narrations basically narrated by Abu hurayrah and Abu hurayrah is
the most reliable companion so show Kenny said we never heard that methodology before. Because Abdullah loved him often the one who said the eighth is another companion are trustworthy as well. You know, you can make that so he completely didn't agree with them. Anyway, a show county of Santa Clara humane law, they both goes with it has another basally and the law here is the said that the eighth should apply as well. So you can do the first or the eight. So that means you do seven and the eighth one is sent. But I don't agree with that. Because what it's
seems to be the meaning of the eight as at the moment No, come online other said it means you do six. Okay? And after you do the six, the seventh one, the seventh one, you put the sand, then you wash it with water.
Water. So that's what it means. So it's not eight, as if you consider this the putting the sand as it's one, but actually it's the water that comes next we'll make it the seven.
Anyway, the majority of the law like shafia and Madigan said you must do this seven times. Abu hanifa said no, three times is enough. Anything beyond three Edison
three washing You didn't even miss end. One if it doesn't believe in this and doesn't believe in the seven as must why this is the Hadith is just encouraging us but there's not must. They've How do you know that that is encouraging us? You might say the question was right. You might say how hanifa will come to this. The Hadith explicit
hanifa Rahim Allah based on narrations from Abu hurayrah. Abu hurayrah. Remember the one who read the hadith of seven times? Abu huraira the Allahu Allah said
he himself said that when the dog eat or drink from your utensil, you only wash it three times. Carlos, Sara Sara,
but to be honest with you this narration from ovaherero the alarm on which is dharapani and others also been narrated in another way exactly like the hardest seven times one of them would send
and then duration of three is weak. So you have one week duration said three and one authentic duration from him saying seven. They even if we say yeah about hanifa. Let's agree that about about Herrera's regeneration of three is authentic. Malik and shovin. Mohammed said in this case, we don't leave what the prophets of Salaam said for what the companions understood.
alebrije Halle Abbey Mara, MB Ma.
There is a debate, a long debate and also when the Sahaba narrator Hadith, and he has an opinion about it. Should we take his opinion over the text? Or we take the text over his opinion?
I saw him in Colombia.
And now they have the strong opinion that it depends. Either Canada or us fairly broad to be marala. If what he narrated is explicit, you take what he narrated over his opinion. We're in kanima Raja mubychem Tamil fillet brought to Bhima radi Allahu Allah Manasa rewi if he would, if what he narrated was ambiguous, something not clear. So he is opinion should be taking and should be the text should be understood. Because here you have the understanding of the narrator and the understanding of someone comes 100 years later, I will take the understanding of OSI because he was there witnessing the incident. That makes sense. And that's how allow Adam and this Misato soul.
Yeah, and this is a summary of a long debate between Alan
can you use so detergent and instead of scent?
Some aroma said no, the sand is mentioned in the Hadith. So it should be the one only use. And that will be the shaft? Yeah, the hanabi law and then has him by the way in the old days they used to have. So it's not true that they don't they do have soap, and they don't have the
Oh chemical is not the point. The point is, the point is, do they have other methods of cleaning? Other than the scent? The answer is yes. They have soap and they can use it.
But did the Prophet Solomon give them the permission to use soap is known as ash Nan, for example, where the person or the woman after the finish of whistle when they make the also to use it as a noun or men
to clean themselves. He didn't say that to use it for utensils. So soap was not an option. That's why Shafilea and the Hanoverian hasn't said no other scholars, which is one opinion among the shaft here, and this is the famous position of the Hanna Barbera. They said anything will be acceptable sand or nonsense
what I go with personally, which is an opinion that some Sharpie and some humble he says it we said, if the sand is not available, or the sand is not easy to, to reach or to have in this case you can use soap you can use whatever you want
but what if he touched your clothes?
With a dog look your clothes? Would that makes you
the majority who said it's impure? They will said yes, you have to wash the clothes seven times with the scent. Okay, and among them showing us showing it male or female level data
and also show
some great colors like an fatawa legend a diamond area, they said seven times the first one with scent. And
yeah, but the washer doesn't have a scent.
No, but the personal homestead scent. So, so that's how
you take a sand, and you put it here. And you do like if you do like this.
That's that's the opinion of those colors is if you do like this. Okay. So that's the opinion of those scholars. But there's other opinion also among what I learned that it says this is does not apply to clothes.
And that's what I choose also, why? Because the process of them said fee now Heidecker
in the basically in the utensil, I don't believe it's nudges at all. So yeah, I for me, it's not an issue at all. But for those who believe it's nudges, even if I believe it's not just it should not apply to the claws, because in the visa Salam was very specific, speaking about what utensils and in Debbie's Hassan said that so it should not apply to other things. Also, because what the brother trying to mention, if we say seven times with sand, FEMA Shaka Allah does that make things difficult? and Sherry I will not comes to put people on difficulties so that's why I would say that it is not
any need for seven times the What about the urine and the feces it just to clean it doesn't need to be seven times I don't even know how to come along the Chevy almost agree on that.
Can we make analogy to the pigs?
If the pigs eat from a utensil?
Do you wash it seven times with sand?
That's summertime. I said that like a lot? A whole lot. But no, he was a great champion scholar said the strong opinion that only one time with no scent. Like any other agenda, because the Hadith is specific in the dogs and should be limited to the dog.
So these are some of the issues that I thought it will be beneficial to share with you about the dog solid Sorry, it's
it's kind of late but I hope this was beneficial. That you understand all the ruling of the that related to the dogs and the the issue of Naja sonbhadra of the dog.
Okay, the summary the summary is that what I believe is that the dogs if they drink or eat from a utensils that this utensil must be basically whatever and it to be thrown away and it must be washed seven times the first one with sand
and if there is no sand, you can use
detergent or so whatever is methods that you can clean with chemical spray chemical or whatever
whatever will clean it so that's number one. Number two, if that apply to the doesn't apply to the clothes that you wear only to the utensils you know that you drink from or eat from uses for food. We also we say
nothing. Okay? Because I believe it's it's not nudges us why also we say that the dogs
the seven times the first one should be with the seven
Okay, but if you make it the second or the third, it doesn't matter because just the subnet to do this one time, and it must be seven is not less than seven
pigs doesn't take the same ruling, you can add the sandwich with water and wash it or you can put water then you put the sand on the top of it, it doesn't really make a difference in this case.
That's the summary of what was
very good if a person has will and the dog touch you
see here, some of them have said that dogs is the saliva of the dog nudges. Some people said not nudges.
Both of them, both of them will tell you your robot is perfect.
The only difference will be those who believe the saliva of the dog is not just telling you you can go pray straight. Those who believe it's not just will tell you you have to wash your the area where the dog touch you seven times. One of them was sent those who believe that like the Shafi and the HANA. Well, some of the HANA not all of them.
And I believe it's pure, it's not legit. I will walk I wouldn't have proud. Do you remember guys? We had here a sister,
woman prayed with us. She had a thin dog.
She came to the master prayer does Asia. This woman been looking for a master she wants to intermix it for a whole year.
All of a sudden Houston turned her down. So the interfaith call me said this lady. She wants to ensure the whole year tried to intermix she lives on the other side of town.
And she really wanted to experience being in a must.
But every master I reached out to they said cannot walk with a dog. And she said she doesn't feel comfortable to leave the dog outside the area or anything like that.
So he said, Would you like would you mind to accommodate her?
I said, Yeah, she can come and she came and we put like a sheet just for everybody to feel comfortable. Because in the massage, you don't deal with my madhhab only we deal with majority of people, we have to respect people's as well. So we put like a sheet in the back and the doc games even the dog didn't touch because these are very well trained. And she entered the muster. And when I talked to her, she's like legally blind. Like she had tears in her eyes when she told me how this is the most beautiful experience she ever had in her life. When she hurts a lot.
And she stayed antiship radiation, she stayed Asia. And she hurts. She attended Asia prayer as well. Everybody loves you sir. I'm setting until I said I never felt so relaxed and peaceful. like this before.
And I said the only it's a sad when we have this phobia from dogs, that mustard used to come in and out and they don't have a problem with that. So I hope this gives you a little bit of idea about what's what the dogs are or the ruling on because sometimes you have to deal with it in your business and your you know, in your neighbors. And so
but just last point before the doctor leaves these saying it is allowed to it's not notice. It doesn't give the permission to possess a dog for no valid reason. Acting alcohol possessing a dog is a different rule.
You're not allowed to have a dog unless there is a valid reason for it. Like your security, your habit for seeing dog. It's a service dog. So in Islam, that really matters a lot. I agreed that just having the dog not there is no consensus. Also I want to mention that on the show Kenya Rahim Allah said that from the Hadith, of Hassan Hussein, it shows you that the process Allah allowed
the dog in Allah He didn't object to have that dog in there. And he said some a lot of that but the vast vast majority of the scholars said you cannot have dogs and loss for a service dog.
So Lola salon a Vina Mohammed
now, the Angela will not enter a house with a dog. Hmm.
There is a debate over what kind of angels will not enter. And what exactly this hadith means. What exactly the angels will not enter is the angel of Rama.
Is this the angel and what that means will not enter it.
But that's why we say is not allowed to have that. And then yonko swimmin, actually, he could lay on clear upon erotica.
And aroma said even though what if I didn't make a good deeds that equal to
the size of the mountain, they said it takes from the past.
It's up the past.
So if you don't have a valid reason for it, like I had a dog for a while, and I took it because of security, for security reasons. And when I don't, I didn't need it. I just let the dog go.
And if I feel like I needed for security reasons, I will have it if I don't have enough, I don't have the need for it, a lot of go. And that's how it should be.
Also, if you're a hunter, if you are a
shepherd, if you are a police officer, or
know, the black.is not yet on the process, I've said the black dog with two dots above his eyes.
So the Hadith is very specific on explain and shape on it doesn't mean here. It necessarily it means even if there's a block, it doesn't mean chiffon. It means it is a gin. It could means it is Jani in Medina, these were the most aggressive dogs, because nobody speak about what he has in his city. Also, for me, it could means could means shaytan is also a way in Arabic language when we talk about a smart doc
that's why we bother rely upon who are shavon often Hadeeth
Yeah, and he very smart very fast.
not necessarily to be any always the
the connecting block to bat. That's that's just not also correct. And unfortunately, this is something you might find some of the SRA have that instant connection between the two. And that's not correct. Or the gin and the champagne has to be blocked. That's not it's not necessarily to be the case. The only reason gin comes in black, because black is a strength measurement or
that why they said the black part of your eyes this though it says the black part of your eyes that's where you see. But I said that I came home a lot these guys because they are Arabs, because there is other people don't have black eyes. So the analogy wouldn't work.