Bulugh Al Maram – Book of Purification #4 Wudu – Session 6
Date:
Channel: Waleed Basyouni
Series: Waleed Basyouni – Bulugh Al Maram
File Size: 59.31MB
AI Generated Transcript ©
So, today we will talk about continue the Hadeeth man physical
model of the Allahu Allahu Akbar, which is speaking, describing that will be Salalah How do you it was sallam, then we reach when he said to Mr. hubiera, see he he wiped over his head.
This also came in handy to have the lightness aid or the Allah one that will master how Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam bureau see, for up better be a DBA he was a developer that in the B cell allowed himself over his head with his both hand, aka Bella bat, he will advocate he went forward, then he came back, he won't forward then came back
in another iteration, but I'd be mocha de Moura, he start with the beginning of his hair. Okay, where his forehead is, eat out a foul all the way to the back of his neck, then follow the Houma mechanically the better. I mean, then he returned it back all the way to the front had is reported by Bahati, well Muslim, one of the lab near us that he must have seen he wiped over his head, what adhara is about 18 if you donate and he put his index fingers inside his ear, well, I'm so happy. He waved his thumbs while you're in the back of his ear, okay, or the appearing part of his ear reported by a bee the old one NASA.
In one narration, okay. In sunon, Abu Dawood that he entered his hand in the water, then Mr. hodda said then he wiped his hat, okay. So, in one of the videos that
we have, that the other broad or the just I read for honey, the loudness aid, he said, he wiped over his head, so, he will he will wash his face, then he wiped over his head. When he said then or and he wiped his head. That means with the same water that he washed his face whatever left in his hand, while there was an incident, there is more detail description to Medallia hufa he put his hand inside the water, where he took water then he wiped over his head. This duration incident
shows that he used a new water to wash to to wipe over his head, the Hadith or the narration that
hunter Rahim Allah mentioned of the loudness aid, that he wiped over his head also came in another narration in Muslim.
He said why Mr. Harada will be mad in the value refurb li de la de fogli. The very fugly Eddie, he basically wipe over his head with water different than the water that remains is his hand after washing the face in a hurry before ugly, the mountain the value the familia de
la de phobal main was minesh menos la J. so mad means a new water and it is sooner. Okay? But let's say you wash your face like this. Then whatever left in your hand, you still your hand wet That's right. you wipe over your head.
And I agree that you will That is correct. And you don't need to you put your hand and you take every time it is only synthetic freshwater.
You following so it is only similar to for to take fresh water and has an industry and APA and coolum Sahaja. All of them said this is acceptable.
Also never been reported that in nebby sallallahu alayhi wa sallam Canon furuya de cabela messari that inhibition Salam will basically when he takes water he will not assume for the day and he
shake off. Very good. He will shake off the water before he wipe over his head. So when if you take a new water, it never reported that he will shake it off before he wiped over his head
and kind of neuro Murali Allahu Ania own kind of neuroma live and feel the Houma even Omar or the Allah and he never basically shook off the water from his hand. Also appa said, law and field Houma alpha said I will not shake the water off and I will keep it wet. Whatever. He put his hand in the water and he baked them what then he wiped over his
Head water that evening bass and aeration in southern Ibiza. Would you remember I told you there is many people narrated how the middle vote among them at the library,
bass among them Abu hurayrah among them Abdullah Abdullah Hammer of the house and so forth. So in one of the ahaadeeth, even ambassade, the macabre abdominal map to manifest Nevada a master hobbyhorse. So
basically, that Eben abass took a handful of water.
He put hands, he put water in his hand, then he shook it off or he basically shook it off, then he wiped over his head.
He following
Kava Kava, Kava Kava means, basically he filled his hand he filled his end with basically his pommard with water, then he let it go, then he wiped over his head. This is the only narration we have that
have led the water or shut it off or let it go from his end. And this is only narration came in Ambassador the allowance is there is any contradiction between this and what we just said earlier. Allah Rahim Allah said there is no contradiction. Why? Because
when you take fresh new water for your hand to wipe over your head, you are one of two Carlos Emma and to Bella Lila deck for her de la tuneful. You either you wet your hand, let's say the faucet is on, you just put your hand in it. Or you dip your hand in a water, let's say a container of water, you dip your hand in it, or you put your hand under the faucet or somebody's pouring the water and you make it wet, then you pull it out, then you wipe. In this case you don't shake off the water. All you did was have an abacus did and describe which is in he have a couple of 10 minute map, which is when you take a good amount of water and you had like this. So you have actually hand filling
your palms. In this case, you have to leave the water and go, you have to shake it off. Because if you didn't shake it off, what's going to be the issue?
That's going to be what? wiping or washing.
Washing your hands. That's right. If you take the water in your hand like what's my best cup of Aqaba, wood for his handful. If you take the water on you put it in your head that means washing your head. And this Allah subhanaw taala said
that you why you don't wash your head. That's why he led the water goes, is that clear? That's how Mr. Mo la have combined between these narrations. Another issue here, which is how many times you wipe over your head?
Is it one time three times two times five times what is it? A sinner is to take your hand and you go all the way to the back and you come back. So going all the way back and coming back to where you start from that consider one and the sadness to do it one time. That's the method of remember Abu hanifa Rahim Allah and the Maliki's and the Hanafi and wondering why Afro Mushaf area. And I want to say that because the famous things that Shafi It doesn't say that, that if you read the most of the books, they will not say Shafi he said one time, most of the books will refer to an image of Shafi that he believes more than one time three times lacking happy rewire hibben in a bay area and
autonomy the Rahim Allah ashara they have recently that autonomy that a Himalayan mentioned that the Shafi believe it one time, and that's one duration, at least from a Shafi also in Rome or the Allah who said that one time and even abiel party palha Ebony, Muslim Hamad bin Zayed an amendment brought him in now. Hi, and Hassan al basally Mujahid abou Thoreau, and this is one narration from appa was an aide was Salim Abdullah. I will tell you I'm saying this because this is show you there are so many scholars have from the successors. And the early generations said that you only wind over your head one time. Ben Abood obeyed, exaggerates and he said Carla Alamo, I had a nuclear crowned Miss
Allah Ross, Ella Ibrahim at me about obeyed said no one from the early generations and his Sahaba the successors ever been reported that he said you want more than one time except Ibrahim etame is a great scholar from Abilene.
But this is basically not accurate. not accurate.
Here I want to say something that sometimes you might see some of that amount to hammer home a lot would say
that it is
no one ever said that. Okay? Or it is only
no one of them with a sell off ever took that position. Okay
like what we give an example last time, which is what AdMob mobile what is 10 sharp? That's right. rinsing that we said mmm shafia mo law said no one from the setup ever basically said it's wajib That's right to burns your mouth. But this is not true. This is not true that I think Ahmad last time he said How come no one of the setup ever said that. But that's sometimes lm a make statement like this, but it's nonsense. It's an accurate statement. That's why I told you him not knowing that somebody did that doesn't mean that means nobody did that. So it makes sense. That's why for memorialist in shock, for instance, who are calling upon
every woman in Mubarak Mohammed Abdullah all this from a Seraph. They said that you must rinse your mouth and you must basically
snap the water inside your nose and you blow it out. So it's not true that it has not been ever reported that anyone took that position. So the same thing here when he said this only Ibrahim it to me said that that's not a very accurate as you will see.
Because Anasazi Allah Anwar and this is a Muslim shava Mr. howitzer, who said Athan, he went over his head three times.
And Ibrahim tamie even hasn't mentioned that he did three times but also have been hasn't mentioned that this is also say dibny jubair, the great scholar among the successors will Mesa and other scholars from the tablet in been reported that the wind over their head more than one time, that's why mmm shafia Rahim Allah said it is Sunnah to wipe over your head three times.
Okay, and that's the famous narrations for me Shafi Rahim Allah and Imam Shafi he based his opinion earn one narration for Hadith Earth man, the one we studying warmaster Hadassah, who said that one of the narration said, and he wiped over his head three times, but this narration is weak, because it's been reported by Ebony Dara Mola with a man who I'm a dude. The one who narrated this from Earth man is an unknown Narrator As in half of the job Rahim Allah said, and everybody else who narrated the story from Earth man never said that he did three times. So when you have a weak narrator narrating something contradict what the authentic the trustworthy narrator narrated what we
call this narration
law a shadow IT are our thicker my Harley for our socket. But when a VA if the week which is module unknown, narrate something contradict the others, we call this worse than shall we call it mongkol Hadeeth which is when a VA eighth week goes again to stop trustworthy, we call this rewire mukalla.
Apa been said that he wiped over his head three times. But when you look carefully, you will find that he did this with one hand.
Okay, and he never took new water every time. So you might say with one hand he did three maybe because one hand he cannot wipe over his head at one time. Okay, so that's why he did it three times just to make sure that he covered all his head not because he believed that he'd be eating it The sooner so that apart because APA is a great scholar and any him being among those who take that position will make that opinion very strong.
from a perspective pure filth perspective, it makes no sense to say to wipe over three times.
Anybody can tell me why from a fifth from a logical perspective
brothers and online
from a nun not based on had it from a logical from like, logically, it makes no sense to say three times
Okay,
the logic comes from multiple areas number one, and earlier mcaloon Ellucian almak. So the meaning in when the sherea order as to wash something, it means you have to clean it.
But when you wipe over something is not meant for cleaning. That's right. When you wipe over your socks, you're meant to clean your socks.
Right? When you wipe over the bandage the Jabir, it meant to clean it, when you wipe over the amount that you mean to clean it now, so the cleaning part which is has to do with what with the washing, when, in fact, it means to the whole thing to do it perfect. That's why that's why the most of the ahaadeeth is speak about the repetition three times has to do with what with the hands and the feet as I said last time, because it's most it's an area you need to clean it very well. And it's a big areas where you might miss something. But if the hair The point is, is wiping so it's not about really cleaning the air. So that's why three feeding a three times makes no sense because in lay
selmak sod mineral mess that makes sense to you guys.
Sharma but also this set out chaos.
And now analogy. Look at everything we've been ordered to wipe over, none of it ever. You do three times, like the Sox or the huff or algebra era, the basically to wipe over that
any band aid or you can cast your hand or anything like that you don't wipe over three times as a mama Torben. So that's why we say we don't do it three times, even in Tam when we don't do it three times. Because Lisa, oxygen mask and to mimic mass wiping. So that's from a physical perspective.
Okay, make basically perfect sense. Also, one of the things that maybe support that idea that you don't repeat what I'm do live now I'm from the US or the allow answered.
And the Hadith we have a tear, we have part of it, that a man came to the process along with the problem show him how to make war. So it basically the process, he said, show me how to make with also the problem perform the law in front of him. Then he said he washed his hand three times he washed his face three times, he washes her arms is three times then warmaster hubiera. See he he wiped over his head. And he basically he used his fingers inside his ears, and he basically why but the hurry that I just mentioned earlier, then he washed his feet three times. So every time he said three times except what?
Why being over the head. That's right. He didn't mention it three times. Then in Ibiza Salam said hi Kevin.
He said this is how the world should be feminine zyada Allah hada alna us
our volume, our volume our eisah This is how the law is whoever add to it or
basically take from it something add to it or take something from it have done wrong, and basically vollum transgress so that means in the visa Sallam said once so if you add, you have transgressed because you add something not from the Sunnah of the Prophet sallallahu sallam. I just want to mention something that this hadith is a problematic
anybody knows what's the problem and this heady? There is a problem in the Hadith that the texts that I just read.
I will not say send anybody will increase or decrease.
I will not pass that means or decrease type question. Can you wash your hand two times? Yes. Came in the sooner that he did it once. Yes.
So how come he said oh nacoss Assa? That's why Rena Mara Hema Houma la like in half of in hajj on the Cindy in Baton Jimmy lo fi Hashi at a he said that. This rewire this additions I will not bus in NEMA here shahzada wrong the call him one min our hammer Ravi will let the ohana ma'am Ivana Rahim Allah Who am in Wareham Valhalla
and this is an addition that have been added
added to the Hadith and it is wrong. There is no owl notice there is no or decrease. Our LMR said no even if nothing else is authentic decrease or he took out basically he reduced the sin he meant out an Assad one minute Abba Jani. He basically didn't wash one of the parts of the bodies or uncas Marina Napa Sophie it's mammal will vote Yeah. And he didn't complete his end. He didn't complete his face. He didn't complete wiping over his head. That was not us means. But many of them talked about how weak this edition Narcos is basically, not as of means decrease or to call something from it. How you wipe over your head.
And a magnet Abdal bottle, which is a great scholar and Hadith. He has a very beautiful book could call him the streetcar. He's a malicous colors, but he is enciclopedia he lived in it and debtors are him a whole lot.
And he cares about all the opinions of the tea's aware of from
a shaft a
value to him. But you have to be careful when people like this from an underdose they're not very experts in the opinions of Iraq. The opinions of Iraq and Iraq will include the Hannah Bella and the INF so sometimes you have to review what the claim because they might be missing the opinion or not having a full knowledge of the opinion of Iraq in general.
Anyway,
so I've done about about him a whole lot on edge Marula. All agreed and among mlms have anyone who is over his head be mocha dim in Omaha in our south safer homes, is it anyone who lives over his head in general, it is sufficient, he starts from here from the beginning from his forehead, he starts from the back or to start from the middle by the way remember he does integration when he asked how they will look in the head he said like this.
He said you start from the middle and you go to the front and to the to the to the end. So there is any it doesn't matter really and I think wasn't recommended him a whole lot. He doesn't mean by doing this or saying this is to make this is what the Sundance certainly as as much as trying to tell you it is permissible to do it in any way you want. Okay, but they there is a debate between the scholars how they understood the narrations. So some of them said, you start mina shadowmoon, sadly and Ignacio de la Papa, they said you start from the hair that in the forehead all the way to the back of your head. Then you come back to the your forehead, you back from the back of your neck
all the way to the forehead part who had he wide. And this is supported by the narration that I said earlier, the narration of benzene, the honey that I mentioned, which is by the mapa de Moura start with the forehead all the way to the back of his puffer in the back of his neck, then or Dahomey. Then he came back very explosive. Kyla Malik had a blood mass amerit visitbritain muscle. And Emma Malik said this is the clearest narration we have in regard to this issue. Very clear, very explosive. And that's how hanifa Rahim Allah said the weibing over the head should be like this when you come back. And this is an image. This is an image of Shafi also an image and an overwhelming
number of scholars from the Tibet in and the successors and follower of the second assessor. Also.
A humaid was asked NSR the Allahu anhu used to do this. Can I use Alibaba Allah Allah?
what that means?
Can I use Alibaba? Allah Allah? Yeah, and he when he wiped over his head, okay, he used to basically put his hand underneath the hair and flip the hair, you know, like miss the hair? No.
Yeah, any somebody for example.
The only one has a long hair is Muhammad and here. So imagine, you know, he Muhammad, for example, will go like this. And if you go like this, what would happen to your hair? If you go the opposite? And you put your hand under there, it will be a mess. That's right. So no. Same thing. Imagine you go like this and you go like that, I guess for you, it's gonna be the same. It's gonna be like all over the place. Sisters will be even more problematic. That's right. So he said, No, the point is to wipe over it not to move the hair.
It's not like you put your hand inside the hair and you like, move it. It's not like massaging your head or like
Now it is wiping over so it is still the hair will stay in the same basically way. You just swipe over back and forth. Pot lions lie you wanna you wanna fish mobilia day
but also been narrated, and it hasn't been, hey, he said the opposite you start from the back and you go over to the front. And the point, those who under some scholar said that, and the base this
opinion on the narration hadn't been tomorrow was one of the people who describe the process on a mobile. She said, Can I
see through mamuka Deming, he starts with the back of his head all the way to the front. Reports of me that would
tell me the world very healthy, lacking and half have been hijacked by him a whole lot. He kitabi he'll be diethylhexyl Javier. He said that this is this narration is superb. It is the narration have so many different ways been narrated by that narrator that make us don't trust that narrator anymore. And that's why they said it's weak as well as an amount of Nadel Baba himo allow to add one of the narration she said from the middle to the front from Rachel from the front to the back. So the narration of this note of this hadith came in a different way they contradict each other that's why we said more so that that particular narrator who read that Hadith in this narration we don't
accept his statement because it's kind of he contradicting himself
how much you wipe from your head
how much you wipe from your head
as soon as to wipe most of your head this is the recommended asuna most of your head like what you heard me The problem is go all the way back then he comes back to the front so as soon and to me man must have been Abdullah boss said this is each man there is no different opinion between the skills of others that it is recommended. Okay, come on Jamal. Also the agreed all of them said the best way to do it is to go over most of your head. So most of your hair will be wiped over. I even admire all of them agree. And Alia sera la de la yoke Sato Scapa. mutata was on an F there is a basically a little bit of hair here on there. Like let's say I wipe like this, you know here there is some hair
maybe I didn't wipe over in the back maybe in the way or the way in the back here I did my finger didn't reach That's right. Maybe some in the middle in between my hand this is this little over all of them not all of them regardless what their position is. All of them said it's forgiving. He didn't need to worry about it. Because we don't want people to start like oh my god, this is like one hand here are your nose a little bit of hair missing make sure that everything is going to be a shout out after words. You know and that's not the point. The point is if there is something missing this is basically forgiving. But
they debated over
how much is obligatory upon you to do so everybody said that's the best. But some said it is the best and it is must
the best but also it's must the 2am Misha yeah and the most of your hair will be wiped over. Why the metal metal Hema Hola, and also the famous opinion over the mathematical himolla. an amendment Mussolini, who's a Shafi scholars choose that opinion and ignore Tamia and am Rahim Allah, Allah Allah Allah
Ibn taymiyyah Rahim Allah and even obey Him and said in my ad Oh, my God, they were so excited is so strong in supporting this opinion.
So you have the ultimate, you have the famous opinion of the shafia Yeah, I sorry. amalickiah and you have some henneberry as well.
And
what is their proof that it is must
watch that UI over your whole air? Basically, or your hair
pilu how many times in Ibiza solemn made
hundreds of times how many companions described his world?
Many, we just have a hadith of 22 companions reported to us how the miserable 1000s of people reported underrated how the middle though? That's right. And that's the strongest evidence even to me, you're always bringing it back into the argument. He said in all these generations, not a single time in the meantime
seldom ever said or dead or approved or give a hint that you allow to wipe some of your head and leave some.
All these narrations, all these narrations, basically supporting one or narrating to us and reporting one thing that you wipe most of his head all the way to the back and come back to the front of his head.
Okay,
so that's their biggest
proof. Also this
or is it the bat that is consistent and helpful? Whoo. You did a Shea.
You sell bow
is anything it called? You do part of it in your hand, do part of the hand and you don't need to do the whole thing. You wash part of your face, but you didn't see why the head is different.
This if you have to treat them all the same. If I guys, Okay, good, good.
Also, they said the Tinder be Salalah is and then
when you hand the Imam,
the turbo, he wiped over what the whole entire What?
Terrible.
He wiped over the whole entire turban. He didn't wipe part of it. So that way, because it's a replacement for the head here. So that shows you even when there is a turban on, he went over the whole thing
to me
the second opinion
or the other opinion,
which is the opinion of the vast majority of them. This is why being over the whole entire head is sin.
But it's not must
is not must
be said even if you weren't part of your head. It's enough part of your head will be enough but you don't need to do the whole and then they debate it among themselves how much you have to wipe over your head
would be enough. Abu hanifa Rahim Allah came with something very specific. He said 25% over brown rice.
And in another he said metadata Assad s and the Hanafi said as much as three fingers. They've been hesitant Rahim Allah said they
have been hesitant became very aggressive against this and he said there is no proof for that he made this up but he did it have been handsome as long.
an Imam Abu hanifa Rahim Allah and the Hanafi who said that they have proof what the proof, they looked at what has been reported from a setup. And the found there have multiple proof number one, the set that in ob sallallahu alayhi wa sallam. When he had his turban on, he pushed it back and he wiped over nasiha trrc
that part of the head that is here in the front of his hair, then he wiped over the rest of the what of the turban
you following guys? So that part is that that's like almost one fourth of that.
Okay.
And or three fingers like this.
Okay, put them the word that's about it. So they said that's what basically we came up with this. Also the son that have been O'Meara De La Hoya and Messer have been a fool here.
What's enough for is basically do we call this banks also for men? The banks, okay, so the banks are the the hair and the basically on your forehead. He wiped over this, that's it
and add a shadow on her. When she was asked about woman she said you only wipe over the banks or the front of your hair. And that will be sufficient.
Ivan, this has been reported that even Omar did that as he said, he said that selama hadn't been acquired said that.
He may
also you have great scholars among the successor said that like not like who are hustling and bustling, and Mr. Michel brought him shabby and imaginable him in a hurry. masana for
me, layth had been sacked. This is his position and amendment alza and this is his position and amount of normobaric This is his position and Imam is happening or Hawaii. This is his position and I said this is also
Rahim Allah and an Imam Malik
and an Imam Abu hanifa Mr. Abu hanifa more have decided what exactly is basically restricted with
basically force of the head or that
amount.
NARRATION power one narration from medic mature thematic, the famous but one narration from 101 narration from Malik
Shafi iya the said we don't have to wipe over the whole thing. But this is not even the banks or the forehead, the part that the front of your hair
lomasa Sha, one single hair
it's enough
to ban one single hair or couple of errors that pop up and
that's never been reported. Any one of the staff said the single or two single or two here, but that position we see even if it's a little bit, that's a position I've been hesitant. A Burberry, Alabama we use a sharpie, implement munder Urban Decay cul de Ashoka and he also he was so strong in supporting that idea.
And what is their proof?
And both groups, both groups they said that in Ibiza Salam wiped over his forehead, like the hair in the front of his head. Then he went over the map.
Okay.
This Hadith that the Navy says or wipe over the hair, then the Imam who had eaten Maria I've been sure it's a very famous hairy little movie
that she pushed back in a moment. Then he wiped over the forehead or the head in the front. Then the rest of the email.
Okay.
I'm sorry, I
hadn't had this narration in particular, only the T pushed back and he wiped over the hair and
head Raja Hamza, the son of a movie.
Okay.
But everybody else
Okay, everybody else who read this hadith. Never ever said that in Ibiza Salam pushed back the turban and wiped over the head. And the term everybody said he only wiped over what the turban
you guys follow him?
No other way.
Okay, so everybody else as hobbled moving around the students Masaru, cabeza savara in Burma, all wound right in this hadith. They never mentioned that he ever pushed back and wipe the hair and the turban. Everybody said why over the turban? What is Alec we call this an enemy Hadith. What
shall
even though a blue movie era, Hamza is a trustworthy, but because even though he's trustworthy, he goes against large number of other narrators narrated in a different way we leave his narration because we have four or five people who so well known who are much much better than him and narrations, more narrations they have delivered to us and we know them very well. They did something different than him. In this case, we live we live his narration
and because of this the Hanafi Rahim Allah not all of them took that position. Not all of them agree that is only part is enough. Some of them joined that Manik and ultimate and they said you have to have over the whole head.
Also, we say in the bass Allah even let's assume it's correct that tip over forehead, any part of his hair and the mmm isn't that proof that you must wipe over the whole thing because of its color.
Have the hair is sufficient. He should have done the part of the hair and left. Why would he wipe over the man? He doesn't need to Salalah Salah if that was sufficient, okay.
But to be honest with you this also argument is not very strong, because the majority of the said
why being over the
the a mama, it doesn't mean that we have to wipe over the whole thing. You know, he didn't wipe over the whole entire imama sallallahu alayhi wa sallam. Same thing with the socks, you know why over the whole entire socks just part of it would be efficient, efficient. And if you take any one over a little bit of your socks, half of your sock wouldn't be sufficient. Sufficient nobody said you have to wipe over the whole thing.
The shafia Rahim Allah also has reported in his Muslim,
or I think in his book and
I couldn't recall it right now. But he narrated the narration where he said Hassan Nabis or Salim and he or Mr. habima and Mr. Hassan Mamata, who has a BA and an MA MA t through my master habima.
shaffir has an oration that didn't Ibiza Salam removed the Imam,
his turban and he only wipe the front of his head
following
so this is the claim that the Navy never did. That's not true.
In hedger Rahim, Allah has a Shafi Yeah, and he tried to support this narrations as much as he can squeeze it in this narration mill revised the APA and in the VSA law, Tybee APA is a little morsel. He never met the process of them so he needed someone in the middle. So that's weak. So it'd been harder for him Allah went and he got another narration insulin abida
were
basically connected all the way to the profits Alumni Center, but the problem with this generation isn't
it has a man who's named Obamacare, and Obamacare is weak.
So that would have been handled by him. Allah said, we have the rewi of APA which is more sun and we have one which is more so even if it's weak. That gives us the confidence that there is link all the way to the Prophet sallallahu Sallam so we can accept it.
Okay, but yeah, and if you want to be a technical no you have to bring an authentic narrations okay to back this up. No doubt there is a big debate and you know all these are great scholars and everybody has a point here. But the majority of them out of him alone will not take that as a clear evidence.
Also a chef ear they have very strong evidence they have very any I don't have a strong or not but it is there one of the strongest point they said I lost it in the on
one set who biru SQL, why?
over your head, I don't know how this can be translated because it's very technical in Arabic. Beautiful Oh, see come over your head. They said the bap which is over here, translate to over and backfill that a lot of the doula Allah, a temporary, Alba, one of the meaning of back here, it means part. So the said it translated why over part of your head. It's like when I say
I have to
be a dick.
I took your hand
bat, or a hug to be so bad.
I held his toe. It means I held the whole entire soap or part of the
part of your clothes part of your hand, which is your palm maybe your finger. That's right. Doesn't mean I took the whole thing. So that is the said. It means part.
Especially if it comes with a fin, a verb. You have to add that NFC, a verb that it is basically can have an impact on an mephedrone and its own by one Central Bureau OC comm versus, versus when you make when you add a callback to fail, that it cannot have a fruit by itself directly. It needs a connection in the middle we call that Farrell realmuto id you need a connection ie the letter to connect the federal road
To understand Arabic won't know what I'm talking about hopefully. Okay. They said you need it's that's why Allah subhanaw taala said while you're powerful Bill baitul attic, Colorado, we've Federal Motor,
rail motor ID tag Ella and health care for your convenience is the Mona Lisa
yeah and when you make the off you can closer to a cabin. You can be like outside in the city making throw off around the cabin and your car driving around the cabin. No. If somebody tells you, Hey, I'm making I'm in my car and making seven rounds around the cabin. You know what I'm making my helicopter making thought by helicopter? We say no. Why? Because Alyssa while you're powerful build bait and suck and you come close to the
cabin.
So when our last rep I said him, sir, we'll be able to see why.
Your head is about here, little insert. Yeah. And it means you wipe where you put your hand over to touch your hair. And you say why you can? What's the meaning of it to me, I said there is an extra meaning. Because if our last part Allah said in several sacrum, why your head like this in Arabic, you will say there is no need for water.
Because the word is Sulu cannot be done without water. But it can be done with without water.
So they've been to me as the bat here in San Lucia come to tell you that you have to have something in your hand and you have to accomplish it to stick it to your head, which is the water to wipe over. So that's a very balai very eloquent way of saying it otherwise, technically if there is no bat, it could means you just wipe over the head with your dry hand and it will be come up in Arabic language acceptable.
The group the hammer is and those who have been Timmy and that the other direction the other side. They were so furious against the Shafilea. And they said How come you say al badly behaved?
Even the said Seba way rejected the idea that Alba ever comes to means partial or part of
Cairo
sharena Mohammed Kitab Al Kitab
it beforehand in Sahib illuma Today I was researching it a little bit and they found that he's a very famous of scholars, he said menzerna and Alba La
la la la la foto. Whoever claimed about here it means part of your hair have come up with something not known to anyone understand Arabic and aku booty who's also a great Imam is a book called Islam and the man in Arabic Quran he said mancala had Allah Ibrahim Ibn Arabi this a person who doesn't understand Arabic very well not experts in Arabic
geniet which is one of the biggest name when it comes to Arabic language. Khan
recently has a book called cinna era on how the moon card
This is rejected to claim that it's bad the debate
doesn't know we don't know in Arabic languages that is about to be
a I want to tell you sometimes when you see this like kind of been Tamia put these and more statements like this
and a little tie em and some of the mannequins some of them put that how to win this exaggeration and like coming full force to deny that in Arabic language bap comes with debate completely like this.
I am not very comfortable with that. Because I had an older Kofi min and new hat. Many of the COO fees and scholars and Arabic lunch said about comes with debate and in the top of the class to sit that in a moment asthma urashima Houma and abroad eliel Faris and imaam ibn Malik so I have a little fee as well
and it is a it's a thing that's known in Arabic language I don't think I need to drag into this model on this because not everybody it looks like into this issue.
Also never been reported that in Ibiza Salam ever when he was over his head and the homeless haha some people do that they wipe over the neck. Okay and over their neck. It's never been reported but the
Hadith which is a little insane for the habit became a law he went on to his his neck or to the back of his neck any two words the back of Elijah, but it doesn't mean he wiped his neck okay and in Muslim definitely be shaped by just for the record in Muslim if
they didn't have a cell ally cell and wipe his head and wipe the back of his neck that can have that moon car come upon him. Rahim Allah He said this notion is makara his battle is rejected as long as
I've said also, the rules of a bald person is the same rule of a person with hair. So let's say
you have hair in the middle okay and on the sides Mashallah any free, okay, in this case, we say you still need to wipe over your head, the ball area and the hair area. Those who said you have to wipe the whole entire area or the hair, they will say the whole head has to be wiped over those who said part of it so any part the hair or the head will be in
the habit of their life and home.
Were balls or not
was in the basis of them ever ball
and Oman and had a threat they when the Sahaba shaved their heads in Milan Has it ever been reported within the visa solem are the companions made in a different way? No. So that means it takes since nobody reported something different. It takes the same role. So whatever you used to do with hair without hair is the same thing. But what about women? who say upset Rahim Allah and this is reported by Buhari mo Allah and Allah houfy Muslim, Muslim NaVi. He said that there is no difference between men and woman in the way you wipe their head, as well
as Jaco Jaco Ahjumma Allah Allah all of them agreed that women and men are same in the way they wipe their heads. He said this an intimate bisaya is
something you keep in mind. Many of those colors like urban Abdullah battle, when you say, man
he might be referring to the Maliki's
lucky no use this a lot. No, he said edge man, edge man. And after a while, you find that he recognized that the Imam Malik say something different, but I never, but he meant the lemma agreed the shafa the Shafi scholars because inside every man have you might have multiple positions.
Play is there is a different opinion. Yes. And even with Rahim Allah was asked how the woman wipe her head. And he said like this, he puts his hand in the middle. Then for Java deema. He said like this, and like this.
He starts from the middle they go to the front, so she will not basically have a mess there. You'll not miss her. I'll holla Rahim Allah said female happy I met the correct opinion miserable hanabi era MSF mapa de
la Salima Mooney, is she why only the hair bangs the front of her hair? That will be sufficient. Okay. And remember 30 Sofia only 30 said low low twosome in La la la la la la la la. The kurama Shafi Rahim Allah
Allah Allah,
Allah, Canada Dr. Menken and Tom Mr.
Lawson if a woman why one hair from her hair
why over one here it will be enough
for you
What if someone has a long hair
Your hair is long or the woman's hair is long she wiped over the whole entire hair
just what why why only the head Abdullah Victor
in the visa seller had a long hair and to shoulder it not reported that he wiped over his hair. Okay, but what's the Quran said one second what
he said why over yet.
Head he didn't say why over your hair.
He said if he said over your hair, you have to cover all the hair. But he said the head so whatever the head end, that's where you end which is basically the back of your neck here
is a clear
Okay, part one in Marathi must have any
we say that woman is allowed to wipe over her femur
over hijab.
And I want to say this specifically, we're in lemmya commish dude. How can the Muslim Imam uppa wha hustle bustle de la la, la la mina Rama that even if the Hema is not very tight in another word is not very difficult to
to open it
okay, yeah and it's easy to undo the Hema but she's allowed to wipe over it even if it's easy to open the Hema and to put her hand inside her hair and to wipe her Are you follow me guys? So even if that it is a lot
this if it's a lot for the woman who was allowed for men who wearing a turban to go over the question
is it allowed for someone like a mom has a Koofi
to wipe or
is it allowed for you to wipe over your like your cool feature or baseball hat
would be allowed on baseball? Why? Because even like basketball
what what uh, what about Red Sox?
Okay, well basically what do you guys think?
You keeping it on?
What's the difference between this and the turban? You told me?
You can play with it. Yeah. But what's the difference between this and the turban?
One is Rob.
Very well. his turban is a big deal to take it off and to put it on. It's not an easy task. You know, and it's long and basically to put it versus the cover you just move it and you wipe underneath it.
You know there is no machine. There is no hardship and removing but there is hardship to remove that turbo type What if you see today there is some turban today. Sold ready? pre made. Have you seen this? Digi key the buggy it has lights look like a hot you take it you put it on and put it on
like a fake turban
is not like it's already pre made. If you go to the Sham in Syria and Lebanon, it's the Silloth like this. It's already made and it just you know Palestine you have it and you just put it on.
They never had a lot of socks.
They had a socks
but the socks is a different story. There's a lot of narration related to it. Okay, but here and washing and wiping is a quite different also washing the feet versus just the head. You remove that anyway. Well I and I will tell you the truth.
I am I don't have a personal position on to this. You know because I see the point that I'm making. which is you know, if the issue to make it easy, you make it easy over everybody so even if I have a heart like this I can live over it as long as you know, basically the cover I can wipe over it. And we said now that Mr. He said even in the mcommerce dude even the camera was not so tight. You still can wipe over it. So they made it easy for a woman but maybe woman because the hijab and put it you know uncover herself in front of public place maybe that's why they didn't wipe over it is that as Michelle offered to go to cover herself to be able to do her hair you know understand but a coup
feel like this I don't feel comfortable religious as allowed. As one two even that thing that that is a mama that this looks like a goofy today I think it should be removed and you wipe over your head just to be on the safe side. That's what I am comfortable with right now.
Maybe this is something we should look into it more on
no you don't need to have a go
when you put it on, okay. You don't need to have
you know would be a good research paper. Someone research
camela a man
like look what Look what the aka did the chaos on the man because a man and why some of them easy tend to put on some easy to put the hard to put it on maybe somebody look maybe we'll find some of the opposite something we can use to search the issue of baseball art or, you know, cowboy hat somebody's wearing or whatever you know the COVID be interesting actually research paper to be made. Okay, I didn't plan to
to take that long. Actually, I was planning to reach to your feet. But I'm still on your head.
So shall la next week, we will be talking about the ear
and the feet
Charlottetown
if someone want to do a little bit of homework, next week, I'll talk to you about something very interesting.
In the Hadith, and science of Hadith,
which is required to ensure a ban or be handed
the narration of armor adventure I he said my father said my grandfather said the process of himself
if someone would like to search this and read, is this narration whenever I'm a mature believer, and is this acceptable or not acceptable?
This is a very interesting
sample.
his grandpa?
Yeah, that's part of your research. So, you know,
I'm a bit shy.
I'm Dr. Abby and today's Abdullayev nominal denials
are
what was supposedly meant in this state, you can read about it. Okay. It will give you an idea of something and the man headed how they talk about this is very interesting read, read my opponent read a map via so at least when you come to my class, you'll appreciate my philosophy and appreciate like the
the summary of that long, long, long debate, because some of these issues can be very quite long, like,
which happens to be a for example, Chef chef Ahmed Mohamed wrote about this man's biography, over 90 pages,
what the man said about this narrator is he acceptable or below 73 or 74 pages.
I if I teach in students in master program or PhD programs of master program, most likely, I would definitely consider this something that we have to study this to writing and incense of honey is one of the best thing that ever written in my opinion. And regard to tell you how to
classify a generator is a trustworthy or not.
It's a role model. And he wrote this in his commentary in a book live and see the NASS could never share the piece of history, any activity. And volume number two,
and he's one of my teachers. He's also senior in
scholars committee in Egypt, I had about had to give
him Allah, the great Alamo
is very funny.
And he used to come
and he always have two apples in his suitcase,
two apples.
And we asked him, Why two apples? He said because I have two wives. So every one of them give me an apple.
So he's to make fun of this. Yes. Which one is which? Sometimes one green and one red. One bigger than the others.
Anyway, before people get angry at us
That's a lie.