Bukhari 112 The Group Prayer Hadith 711 716
Channel: Taimiyyah Zubair
Series: Taimiyyah Zubair - Bukhari
File Size: 11.28MB
Assalamu alaykum warahmatullahi wabarakatuhu
karimabad feroza Billahi min ash shaytani r rajim Bismillah al Rahman al Rahim. Leah cidery. Were silly Emery melissani of Coco Lee probenecid nerima.
inshallah, today, we will do a web search to jinora.
And the last Bab that we covered was about the Imam shortening the prayer due to the crime of a child. So if the Imam when he begins the prayer, he begins with the intention of, you know, prolonging the PM, but then he hears a child crying, because of that reason, what should he do? shorten the prayer? Why is the child performing the Salah, his mother is right, and people are listening to him. And anyone who hears the crying of a child will be disturbed, right disturbed, not that his prayer is being affected that also, but also everybody gets concerned and worried that why is the child crying. So in order to help people retain their who sure in salah and to help the
mother, and to help the child, what is necessary that the Imam should shorten the prayer. Now, remember that there is one difference that needs to be understood. One kind of a child is He who was perfectly fine when the mother started the prayer, right. And then something happened, and the mother and the baby started crying. So when the Imam will hear that the child is crying, and he's not crying, just a little bit of crying a lot or crying again and again, after every few minutes, then what should the Imam do? shorten the prayer. But then there's another child who was crying even before this law started.
Right? So that means, you know, he needed something, even before the Celeste started. So should the Imam shorten the prayer because of him, he will give the benefit of the doubt that the mother is praying, right? And if she's praying, then of course, he will shorten the prayer. But if, you know like many times it happens that women are towards the back attending to their children. And if it's not the women, then you know, it's the younger girls or whoever is with them attending to the children, then in that case, should the Imam shorten the period like for example, in Ramadan, throwaway prayer is going on. Okay. And at the back, there's going to be women, and obviously,
they're going to be children also. Now, if the Ma'am, here's a crying of the children, and because of that, he begins to shorten the prayer, then what will happen,
people will never be able to finish their throwaway prayers, right. So in that case, he will have to lengthen the prayer just because that is what the people came to do. And the mother, she should understand at this point, and either she will break her prayer, or she will
decide not to pray the next unit, the next set of prayers. And as a result, the child will also be attended to and the congregation will not be affected. Now there is another question, can the mother break her prayer? Meaning if she sees if she hears that her child is crying continuously? Can she break the prayer? She can?
Exactly it depends. If you know with a movement or two, she's able to comfort the child, then she doesn't need to break the prayer. But if let's say the child is repeatedly crying, because he got injured or something like that.
So in that case, what can she do?
The thing is that if she has to take a step or two away, to hold the baby, to comfort the baby, she can do that. But if she has to, let's say she breaks the prayer, she holds a child and the child needs wants to be nursed. Or the child needs to be changed. Or the child needs to be taken out of that place in order to be comforted. Now she can't be away for a good 510 minutes and then come back and join the prayer. And in that process, she's been walking, she's been talking, she's been looking here and there, then obviously her prayer has broken completely. Right?
You see if it's a step or two, a little bit, then that's different. But if it's a lot, then obviously the prayer has been broken and then she can rejoin the jamara. Right. That's fine. That's fine. Then what I understand is, that's fine. But if you have to go outside the masjid, and look for the child and ask people where the child is, and definitely this law has been broken, right? But if it's just the end of the road or something, then that's fine.
All right. That's it. So let them a mccalman Eros Allah when a person performs his prayer, meaning behind an Imam, and then Summa Ummah, Coleman, then he leads a must mean he becomes Imam he leads who common and other people. So a person performs solar behind any man. And then he goes somewhere else and he leads other people in prayer. The First Solar being his fault.
The second solid being his novel. So he performed his fault asthma.
And he performed his nephal as Mmm. Is that permissible, had done so they might have not have been would have been normanni Allah had done a Hamad Museveni and a UVA and unremitting adding on jevin Kala kanima iden. He said that no ultra low or no you Salima and abuse on the log are the username. He used to perform the sada with the Prophet sallallahu Sallam so Mayor de como who, then he would go to these people, for you suddenly be him. And then he would pray with them, meaning he would lead them in this manner. And we learned earlier what happened once he started reciting Baccarat. And one of the people he left the prayer and the prophet SAW a lot of sound got very upset with my little
doula who I know. Now, there's two things over here. Firstly, is it permissible for a person to perform his Salah two times, no.
Foul his fault, and it will only be once. So now if a person has performed his fault, he's performed his OSHA. But here comes another person and says I missed my job. Mark, can you please pray with me? Can you please lead me that in that case, can he pray with them? Yes, but not with the intention of repeating his shell. But the intention of performing knuffel. Okay, now, there's another concern now. Is it permissible for the man to pray knuffel while those who are praying behind him are performing their fault.
You understand the question?
Mm is performing nephal and the people behind him are performing their fault. Is that permissible? There is a difference? I mean, there's a difference of opinion amongst the scholars. Some scholars didn't allow it. Okay. They said no. Why? Because they said that the state of the Imam should be more complete than the state of the people. How is it possible that the man is performing knuffel and the people behind him behind him are praying their fault? So they said it is not permissible. Now what about this idea of murottal? The long run? Isn't it so evident. He used to perform Salah behind the Prophet sallallahu Sallam and then he used to go lead the people in prayer again, we
cannot imagine that he would perform his select two times, he will only perform it once, that once by the prophets that allows him and then secondly, what was that novel? So they responded to this hadith by saying that the Prophet sallallahu Sallam was not aware of this incident. But this is incorrect. This is a false assumption. How is it possible that the prophets of Allah would not be aware of this, Sharia was being revealed? And if this was incorrect, the prophets of Allah would have been informed. And the fact is that the Prophet sallallahu Sallam did know what's the evidence that he knew
exactly what I didn't know and who he recited so little Baka and Salah, the Prophet sallallahu Sallam found out what was happening. Obviously, he must have noticed him in sada behind him, and then he is going in leading people elsewhere. And remember, the Prophet sallallahu Sallam was also upset with my eyes of the law and also the fact is that the Prophet sallallahu Sallam was fully aware that this was going on and he did not stop him, nor did he tell him that he should not pray with him. No, he let him carry on, okay. Now, remember that, from this, we learned that anything that happened at the time of the Prophet sallallahu sallam, okay, and he actually felt that the
companions performed, we will take that as a herder.
Meaning that is an evidence for us, meaning it is also permissible for us, we will take it as a proof. Now, for example, something is mentioned in the Quran. Is that an evidence? Yes, something is mentioned clearly in the Hadith. Is that an evidence? Yes. Now an action that the companions performed at the time of the prophets on the line is Allah. Can we take that as evidence? Yes, we can. Why? Because if it was right, the Prophet sallallahu Sallam approved of it silent approval, and if it was wrong, then the Prophet sallallahu Sallam corrected them, where he was revealed concerning that issue and the people were corrected. Like, for example, that incident where one of the
companions he was leading people in prayer while he was drunk.
And he made a mistake in his recitation at that time, alcohol was not completely forbidden. This was early on in Medina. So what happened? I add were revealed that lacked acabo salado Anto suka. So you see a mistake that was being made, it was corrected immediately. In the month of Ramadan, clear guidance was not given initially with regards to sleep and eating and intimacy. So what happened the companions Ali mala who and Nicole Dr. Luna and fusa come they will do Fianna with themselves right. And what happened the measure was coming
Alright, so a mistake that was being made, what happened, it was clarified later on. So, basically, initially the ruling was that if a person slept, okay, in the nighttime, then his next fast began. So if he woke up in the middle of the night, even before so who he was not sure if he was supposed to eat if he was allowed to eat and drink, and had relations with his spouse or not such clear guidance was not given at that time. But the people just they kept it as a secret they were doing Fianna with themselves, they didn't go and confirm what the prophet sallallahu said that they were allowed to do that or not. So, what happened last panel data revealed the clarifying the matter. So,
likewise, over here, we will understand that if more of the lower and who was doing this, then it was permissible.
All right. And likewise, we find out about another incident, which is that some of the companions they used to do meaning in their sexual intercourse, they wouldn't ejaculate inside their spouse rather outside as this was a means of a way of contraception. And the prophets of Allison did not stop that, right. The Quran was being revealed at that time. So based on this, the scholars have allowed different means of contraception today as well based on this evidence, right. So muraleedharan who if he performed for that in this manner? He was performing knuffel and the people behind him are performing their Phalke then is that permissible for ourselves? Yes, it is
permissible. So the Roger opinion the preferred opinion is that it is permissible for the Imam to lead while he is performing knuffel and the people behind him are performing their job. So if let's say in the month of Ramadan, a person goes in the masjid Salah Arusha is overthrown he has begun he missed his Isha. Now the Imam is performing his nipple can
join with the Nia alpha Yes, he can there is absolutely no problem with that. Now, remember that there that this can take four forms. One is that everyone is performing the full the Imam and
that's obviously permissible. Secondly, everyone is performing felt the amendments performing for the people behind him are performing folk that is also absolutely permissible. The third case is that Imam is performing forth and the people behind him are performing knuffel that is also permissible And the fourth is that the man was performing knuffle but the people behind him are performing fun that is also permissible to all these four ways are permissible
All right, you have the option
No, no, no, no, you performed your Salah Okay, then you go somewhere and the people over there performing their first ngema. Now you say okay, I have to wait for them. So what is going on? I might as well join them. So when you join them, will you Will you join them with the intention of performing further again? No. Your fault is done. Now when you will join them? That will be what you will
know your previous for Do you can't say okay, I will make that into nothing. You can't do that. Okay, because the intention is before the action.
Okay. All right.
That man Esma and NASA duck below Imam man Asmara, the one who makes to hear and NASA the people. What does he make the people hear the real email the duckbill of the Imam Who is this person? He's called the macabre or the mobile.
What's his job? That when the man says Allahu Akbar, or he says semi or lovely man Hermida, then his job is to repeat those statements. Why? So that the people can hear what the Imam said.
So he's called mocha bit, the one who does that V. or mobile is the one who's conveying that we'll have the email
address and we'll set the tone color at the center of the light, color header, image and Ibrahim and guess what, on our shutter. There'll be a lot more on how Khalid lemma marionville sallallahu alayhi wa sallam Morocco who led the McAfee attack will be left alone. You know what we sold it for color Morrow clean for use only in Nevada clean water safe and we have read this hadith multiple times before so I'm not going to translate it here
in Yokohama comica Yep, Keifa la de la karate Kala Maru Ababa Korean for use only for ultimate le hufa Kala filati Robbie it in the kindness over who uses another clean value Sunday for Salah hora Genovese Allahu alayhi wa sallam you had a veiner Delaney any undue delay here hope to be the delay. For them narrow Abu Bakr in the habit a huddle for a Chateau LA and suddenly, Fattah ahora Abu Bakr radi Allahu anhu we'll call it an abuse of Allahu alayhi wa sallam a Lamb who Abu Bakr in yusmeiro nessa took me
Are Homer hobbiton and Amish? So in this case, what do we see that when the Prophet sallallahu Sallam he came out because he was unwell, he sat down and he was leading the people in prayer, and Abu Bakar Aguila and who he stood next to him, and what was he doing basically repeating the duckweed of the Prophet sallallahu Sallam Why? So that people could hear him? Now why was there a need of repeating the technique? Because remember, the Prophet sallallahu Sallam was unwell if he had to come to the masjid, or taking the support of two men, how is it possible for him to raise his voice? So his voice was varied because he was unwell. And as a result, the people in the back rows
would not have been able to hear him. So this is a reason why he would say the COVID Abubakar Apollo and he would repeat the takbeer. And the people would follow Abubakar, and this is how it should be. Whenever there is a macabre in the middle, even though you hear the Imam, you will not follow the email until after the appeal of the McAfee. You understand, because email, then look up there, then.
But if it's like the Imam, he says duck B. And there are some people who can hear him, they are moving behind him. While the macabre is still saying that it doesn't seem like a united congregation that unity is missing. So what is the procedure? First the email, then look up there. And then the rest of the people. Also this, these shows to us that, that saying that out loud, is larger, in the sense that when a person is leading others in prayer as the Imam, then he must raise his voice when he's saying that that could be why? Because the people have to follow him. And how can they follow him without hearing that the crease, right? So if he is capable of raising his voice, he must do
that. And if there's a reason because of which he's not able to raise his voice in the duckweed, then what should be done, and we'll cover or mobilock should be appointed. Right.
Now, this also clarifies to us that the purpose of the mocha bit or the mobile is to
basically convey the creator of the Imam to the people. Does this mean that in every scholar it is necessary to have mocha know, is only when the Imams voice will not reach the people? Okay, so this means that if there is a microphone that is being used, alright, because of which everyone will be able to hear the email, then in that case appointing cukup it isn't necessary. It's not necessary at all. Is it so not at all. In fact, it will be falafel, soon,
this will be contradicting the sun opposing the Sunnah. Because the Prophet sallallahu Sallam did not always have a mock up. It was only in such situations where his voice was not able to reach the people behind him. Now, what about places like the harem? Over there also you have the microphones. But we discussed this earlier, that it's a large congregation, very large congregation. And it's possible that because of the noise of the people, you may miss out the Imams that way. So in that case, the meter the mocha is helpful, given that it's a large place with a large congregation. Yeah, I mean, technically, it's in a mixed congregation is the men who should be doing it. But if it's a
completely different section, let's say women's section is upstairs in a separate room and there's a glass window. All right, and the women can see on the first row can see what's going on. Let's say the electricity goes off or something. And the women have no idea what's going on, especially those in the second third row. So in this case, one of the women standing in the front row who can see what's going on. She can do that so that people can hear.
Mobile Email me with Timo NASA moon Raja Lu, a man yet 10 Mobile Email
he follows the Imam where Terminus and the people follow who will not moon the moon? Who is the one who was following the email. What does it mean? Mmm is leading. There is a person behind him who is following him. And the people who are behind the second person, they're following you. The second person
you see one is the backup where the mobile and here is a person who has been followed. Because there's two ways of following one is in words and the other is in actions where you've been so the longer that you send them to them Obi Wan Li them become members, that you should follow me and those who are after you should follow you. What does it mean by Mumba calm when we're accom those who are behind you. So what does it mean that each role
is to follow the road that is in front. You understand?
This is obviously in the case where the Imam can barely be heard. And the mobile live also cannot really be heard or there's a confusion. So in this case what will happen? Each tour is going to follow the one in front of it
had this an app with a with a cruiser even Carla had the Santa Margarita and an armature and Ibrahim is what they call it. Lambda sakala Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam on the Prophet sallallahu Sallam became heavily ill Jelena you know who this fanatee bananas in our and who came in order to take his permission for us on a four color model of a Birkin and you Salinas we read this hadith earlier. So again, I'm just going to read the Arabic for Coco rasulillah in the other duckling module, se when we're in the Houma, Tameka McCormack la yusmeiro ness fellow amongst the Roma fekola Moodle everclean you suddenly bidness for Kota they have SATA. I shall do the one who is saying this
to have some Polina who in Nevada clean Rajan safe we're in the home Mattei of como como la you smearing this fellow Mata Rama, Allah in the Quran, Allah and tuna Sahaba use a model of evergreen and you suddenly have a nurse for the medical facility where did the Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wasallam have a nuptse button? For karma you had a very narrow domain, what did you learn you
will have the heptad Masjid Fela massimi or Abu Bakar hisako. They have Abu Bakr lineata aha for over a year Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam for jr Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam had they're jealous and sad to be battling for Cana Abu Bakr and you certainly can imagine what kind of a pseudo life and the longer you send them you suddenly carry them. Young Teddy abubakr in this reality Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam when NASA McDonough was honored to be the queen of the Allahu anhu. This last statement, this is a relevance to us. That Abubakar Abdullah who would follow the Sunnah of the Prophet sallallahu Sallam and the people would follow the Sunnah of Abu
Bakar have a lot more one. So a person follows the meme and the rest of the people are following him. But remember over here, that the mobile or the macabre, right or the person right behind the email, he doesn't become the email. He doesn't become the second email, Mr. Mizzou, only one person All right, and the one behind him is who you can say he's just like an amplifier. Okay, a voice amplifier is someone to convey the action the words of the email to the rest of the people so that they can follow him properly.
Bab Helya hodl emammal either Shakopee colinas hollier for the event is the event required to take meaning accept, either Shaka when he's in doubt, become an S the word of people. Meaning if the people are telling the Imam something that you are making a mistake here, this is supposed to be second rocker or they're supposed to be the fourth rocker. You know, they're trying to get a message across to their saints upon Allah trying to get his attention. They're correcting him. But he Shaka
is undoubtedly like, No, I'm not making this mistake. Why are you telling me
now What should he do? Should he listen to the people? Or should he continue? What is he supposed to do?
The response is that he has to
listen to the people.
Okay, he has to listen to the people he has to do what they're telling him because he is one person and there are many. He could make a mistake. Right? And the rest of the people. I mean there's quite a few of them have different I have to let him know Muslim Mata and melachim, the NSN and a Yoruba be to me with us so Danny, and Mohammed nee syrena and Avi hora and the Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam. That one day the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam in sort of a minute entertaining. He finished the prayer. After two. He ended the prayer after two meaning after to Dakar. He led the people into Dhaka and then he ended the prayer for Carla who Julia Dini, Julia Dane wrote the Lahore
and this was his name. He said, a cassata Salah Salatu has a solid been shortened unnecesary Rasulullah sallallahu wasallam or did you forget on messenger of Allah, what happened? For Kala Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam? prophets are a lot of things that are Sacagawea day. He asked the rest of the people that is really the truth for meaning has he spoken the truth? Did I actually make that mistake for colonists sooner? So that people said Yes, you did perform only to Raka for comma Rasulullah
sallallahu alayhi wa sallam for Salah isn't a tiny ofany. Then he prayed to other tulika that he had left out thermacell Lemma. Then he said the Salah, so macabre sajida, misasa God, and then he did the quieren did such that the same as his previous search, though we're a little longer meaning the size. So, now what do we see over here many things first of all,
the Prophet sallallahu sallam, he, when he was asked by the name,
he didn't just accept,
what did he do? He confirmed from who the rest of the people.
So does this mean that the man must also do this, he must seek conflict confirmation before accepting the correction of an of one individual.
Not in every situation. This will only be in the situation where the Imam is sure that he did not make a mistake.
And the other person is also determined that no you did make a mistake. Then you consult a third party, that what happened? You understand? So for example, the Imam is leading the people in prayer he's reciting. And a person behind him corrects him by the memes. He says he's very, very sure he read it correctly. But then what happens? Another person he says Subhana Allah, or he didn't hear subpanel from one person, but he heard three or four soprano.
Okay? Now there's three or four people telling him that he's made a mistake. And that case what is he going to do? He has to listen, he has to listen. He will recited the way he has been corrected. Okay, you will correct himself over there. You understand? Now this can happen during this time can also happen after the sun during the summer, like the example I gave you. And after this what I like it happened over here that the Prophet sallallahu Sallam finished a prayer to the car, the only thing is asking him, there is even a bit of back and forth. And then the prophet SAW this and then accepted what the people were telling you. So is it clear? The man can hear he heard at least three
or four voices saying soprano law. Okay. He knows he made a mistake. Or for example, someone says to Panama, he stops and then he's thinking, What's going on? I didn't make that mistake. And while he's still thinking, another person says so Panama. Alright, so in that case, he got the confirmation. Now he has to accept. So what do we understand when the man is corrected? If he's also doubtful about himself that he might have made a mistake? What should he do? accept what he's been taught. But if he's sure he didn't make a mistake, then he should seek confirmation, or he should wait for the confirmation. And when he gets the confirmation that he did make a mistake, then he will again
accept. Now one more question is Ola ness you see over here, Holly hodel email is a shockable. colinas How many people are an S? Is it one person is a two people more How many?
Two or more okay, but even if it's one person, okay? Even if it's one person correcting the email, then he will accept he has to accept Okay, not just two or three, but even one person and remember that the reason why the Prophet sallallahu Sallam asked the rest of the people was not because he was not accepting the earlier day, but because he was not sure he was fair about the fact that he didn't make a mistake. He was doubting Dooley again. So this is the reason why he asked the rest of the people
had definitely led
inside the people around him and Abby salata and Avi hurayrah Takara sondland abuso de la who really will send them a letter on a car thing. At one occasion the prophets of Ultron performs a look to the car for PETA, so it was said so later garthen you have performed total car for some narrow Kartini. So then he performed to Morocco. So masala Mata Masada says the thing and then he said this lm and then did to such this meaning such the so now over here you see the prophets on a lot is only accepted without seeking any confirmation from anyone. In the first instance, what happened? He asked the rest of the people is Lydia Dane being truthful. And over here we see nothing like that he
just accepted. So it shows that even if one person corrects us, we will accept it. And if we are sure we didn't make a mistake, in that case, seek confirmation. Now, remember that a person may be corrected, or he may realize his mistake through two ways through the coal of people or through the action of people. And both are valid out of people. It's clear. Like for example, the man was making a mistake in the recitation and
He is corrected by the words upon low or someone he recites the idea correctly. A person is performing the Salah, and the one who is not praying this watching him. He says, Yeah, this is your second record. Okay? Or, you know, he's getting up and he's like, No, no, this is your fourth record, someone else tells him called. Okay. So he will accept
Ferrell through action? Can he be corrected? Or can he seek the confirmation? Yes How? By, for example, a person begins his Salah, and there is another person who will begin to swallow at the same time.
Now, what happens after the second record? He's not sure was this my first record my second record?
Okay, and it may happen with anybody. And it happens. Now, he says, he looks at the person standing next to him, that he's getting up from such though.
He's standing up. I started the Salah with him. He's praying to the car, I'm praying to the car. He's going into his second. So this has to be my first and I have to go to my second also. You understand? So is this permissible? It is permissible. Clear, not clear?
No, no, I'm not talking about email over here in general, in general, that where a person is performing his sorta he feels he's making a mistake. Now he wants to make sure. What does he do, he notices the other person standing next to him. And he says, Oh, he's standing up. So okay. Now, this can also happen behind the Imam, how in the women's section, where you cannot see the man after the second knockout when people are getting up. Now, one sister, she gets up and she thinks it's the fourth record the second record, so she doesn't say for the show. Basically, she's planning to get up, but then she sees everybody sitting.
So in that case, she has been corrected, and she has to accept that correction, and she has to sit down. Okay, so one may be corrected through code, and also through fairy. But the main thing over here is that as email or asthma, if you realize your mistake, by the word of someone or by the action of someone, what is necessary, accepted hollyhock Yes, he should accept it.
Before we move on to the next step, one more thing you see, in the first incident, what happened that the prophet SAW a lot of sudden he made a mistake in the solder, he ended the prayer. And then people spoke to him and he spoke to them. And then what happened?
He completed the remaining to the car, he didn't perform all four cars. What did he do? Just to even though it was conversation in the middle, and there must have been some kind of movement also. Right? So what does it show?
That if you talk after, after ending the prayer, meaning you believe that you've completed your prayer, and you even spoke after that, but somebody tells you know, you made a mistake, you don't consider your prayer to be invalid. It's not invalid, even though you spoke, all you need to do is just complete it. And you end it with what such as a
bad either Becca emammal fanatee when the Imam cries in the prayer, if the Imam is crying in the prayer, will that corrupt his prayer? Or will that corrupt the prayer of the people standing behind him?
This was a matter of discussion. And the scholars have given different opinions concerning the sunset, that if the Imam cries in the Salah, such crying that is loud, then his file is invalid.
Why? Because if a person laughs a little bit, a little bit, not giggle, but like a smile, and just that does not invalidate the prayer. But if he laughs out loud, does that break the prayer? Yes. If a person talks out loud in sauna, of course, that will break the prayer. So this said, crying out loud is very similar to
laughing out loud, and talking.
So in other words, if a person is wailing, such that he's sobbing and his wailing can be heard by everybody, then that will nullify his prayer, whether he's the man or the moon, but others said that, no, it will not nullify the prayer. Why? Because there are many evidences that show that it is permissible for a person to cry. And when a person is crying at times, it gets uncontrollable. And he's not able to control the the sound. So so that will not invalidate the prayer. Now, what about the resemblance between crying out loud and laughing out loud? Is there any difference between the two or are they very similar? They're similar with regards to sound.
But they're completely different when it comes to solar. If a person is left
what does it show?
Nancy recited to, they have forgotten their prayer. They're very, very distracted from the prayer to the point that they're laughing out loud, but if a person is crying and Sunnah, what is that a sign off that he is immersed in the prayer. Right? So you cannot resemble the crying with the laughing or the crying with the talking
hallucinogen. And also you have the cry, right to such those mentioned and along with that crying is mentioned in the Quran. So that shows the crime insert is permissible, it will not invalidate the prayer, even if it is loud, over corner of the library, shadowdance America, he said, I heard Nishiyama, then a sheet of metal on who was an athlete is Sophie and I was in the last row. I was in the effort of a fourth of the rows at the end of the rows. And I heard him crying. I heard that the machines have remodeled our New Yorker, all while he was reciting in Nima Escobar, they were hosting at the VA, he was reciting this ayah from Surah Yusuf he was the email I imagine all the way in the
front and he's crying and the person all the way at the back can hear him crying. So what does that show that are modeled in our and who wept in Florida and his weeping was such that it was also loud that people could hear it. And the question is, what is in the sheet and the sheet is a shoulder
to cry heart sobbing and this crying is obviously with some kind of sound
doesn't mean that a person is screaming. But naturally what will happen there will be some kind of sound. It is also said that in the ages the sound, okay? of crying. You know, like for example, when you hear children when you hear babies crying, and when they cry, you know that sound in the throat? sobbing right and when they're crying,
yes, there's a sight and you can hear that cry coming out from from deep, right.
So this is how he was crying mushiya Roman. Had this nice Marino, Colorado, Santa Monica Anderson and his seven year old daughter and Avi, are a Shatta Wale, Mina and Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wasallam Alcala de Muro de Vaca new Salinas, Arusha to call to in Arabic Grenada, coffee McCormick. Lem, you smear in SM in El buka. For more aroma, value Sally. For Kala muro, avakian falu Salinas, Carlos Arusha to they have Sutter Colella who in Nevada clean in a coffee McCormick lemon smear an SM and elbow care for more aroma for you. Salinas farfalla have satou Lacan Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam MA in the canola and tuna Sahaba use of Moodle of evergreen for you Salinas cannot
have such satola Shatta marcantonio swim in Cairo. So we have read this hadith earlier as well. But in this Hadith, what do we see that in the end of the Prophet sort of Alison's life and he was unwell repeatedly. He said, Tell Abu Bakr to lead the people in prayer. I should have done that when he said that if you will stand in your place, he will cry out a lot. And when he will cry, people won't be able to hear him. And if they cannot hear him, how can they pray behind him. So have remote lead the people in prayer. We see that our modal, Walter used to cry.
But anyway, this happened many times but the Prophet sallallahu sallam, he did not
accept that suggestion. So what do we see here? I shut the door and he said he is going to cry out loud people won't be able to hear him. But the Prophet said a lot of them didn't see any problem with that.
He didn't find any problem with the fact that the Imam is crying and the people behind him are finding it difficult to hear him.
You understand? So what does it show that if the Imam cries in Salah so much so that people are not able to hear you clearly are not able to sometimes make the words that he is reciting? Even that is okay. Exactly. It helps with the horseshoe also. And there are people who oppose it will say that the Imam should not cry in the sauna because it corrupts the prayer No, it does not corrupt the motto no one who cried avacado and who cried. Right. And the Prophet sallallahu Sallam did not see any problem with the crying off of a book. I don't know. If he allowed it to the point that he appointed a boubakeur as the email, then obviously, it is permissible. But remember that there are
two types of crying. Two types of Booker one is watercolor, meaning fake in the sense that a person is bringing it upon himself, forcing himself to cry out loud
Fake cry, right? And children are very good at doing this. And sometimes it happens that the man was told cry and make people cry. And deliberately lights will be turned off and that atmosphere will be made,
will be made, so that the man can cry loud and people can also cry out loud behind him. Now this is something that is not from the sun. The Prophet sallallahu Sallam did not cry out deliberately, forcibly, in order to make people cry. You don't have to make people cry, you should be concerned about your own prayer.
Right? Exactly. The second type of crying is natural, which comes naturally uncontrollably. And this is an evidence of colored softness of the heart. And this is something that is also encouraged. But remember that the best way for us the best example for us is that of the Prophet sallallahu. Did he cry in his Sunnah? Yes, he did. But how? How would he cry?
in Hades, which is reported in Muslim Dharma? I would, I would say, I mean, there's many, many reports. And we learned that the Prophet sallallahu sallam, when he would pray, and sometimes he would cry, the person who would be able to hear his chest buzzing, like the buzzing of a cooking Fox, you understand? Like, for example, if you are cooking some food on high heat, and you put a lid on it, right? These days with the loud exhaust and everything, all the noise around, you don't really hear the sound of the pot. But you can say like the whistling of cattle.
Cattle when you turn it on, do you hear the water bubbling inside? Do you hear? You do now the province of Madison would cry? But it wouldn't be with the loud voice.
He would saw but even but not loudly.
You understand? And why? Why is it necessary that we follow this on?
Cry with cry without making any noise? Why?
Okay in consideration for others because others might get disturbed. Okay. Why else?
It's a personal action. So keep it as private as possible. Because if other people obviously they're going to notice you crying? How is that going to affect your sincerity?
Yes, that is the Prophet sallallahu Sallam would cry out loud and whale in the Salah. than the people would think that we have to do the same thing as when they would exaggerate even more.
Yes, and you see, the prophet SAW a lot of sun when he would be performing his night prayer, his wife would be sleeping. Now, if he starts crying out loud at that time, obviously his wife is gonna get disturbed.
Yes, very true.
Yes, yes, that otherwise also outside of slept, there is something that is hurting us. And we become very emotional and we also cry, how do we cry with noise? No. Children do that. adults don't do that. Right as adults we should learn to kind of control our emotions, but not to the point that we suppress them, control them cry, weep, but not with you know, while making a scene.
A scene should not be made out of it. inshallah, we will conclude over here today.
Sorry, I was unwell, and I couldn't really sit for very long and prepare more. So that is all I have prepared for today.
Yes, go ahead.
You see, okay, the mccobb bit.
He doesn't have to be the person who's standing right behind the man. Because if he's right behind the Imam, it kind of defeats the purpose. Right? So he can be somewhere in the middle of the rows. Okay. But remember that a boca raton our new he was standing next to the Prophet satellite is
Why? Because this was an exceptional situation where a Boko Haram who was leading the prayer, he was the Imam. The prophets of Lawson came and joined us, Allah, Abubakar, he moved back so that the Prophet sallallahu Sallam would become the man. Right? But the Prophet sallallahu Sallam said, No carry on. But Abu Bakar refused. He said No way. I cannot be the man while you are praying. So then the prophets all of a sudden came and sat next to him. And remember that he came and sat to the left of Abu Bakar which meant that avocado and he was on his right side, which meant that the Prophet sort of all of a sudden came as a man and avocado and who was next to him, because the prophets of
alloxan was sitting and praying. Okay, Abubakar Alomar, who was standing and praying with his movements, then the people followed him basically. Because you see, if a person is sitting and praying, can you always tell
If they're going into their core and getting up, you can't tell.
So the people who are behind the pockets of Allison would they be able to tell if he was going into the core or not, they wouldn't be able to tell Abubakar Avila Warren next to the Prophet sallallahu sallam, he would be able to see that clearly. So, this is why it was necessary to have a broker standing next to the Prophet sort of answer. Okay, so, the people followed Abu Bakar in words and inactions and Abu Bakr followed who the prophets are
both are correct, yes, such disciple can be before the salon and also after both are correct.
Such as the house is when a person makes a mistake in the Salah, and then he realizes it he corrects his Salah. So a mistake was made. So in that case, he has to perform do such that at the end of the Salah, right, either before seeing the salon or right after do surgery. And what does that do basically,
it compensates, okay, like, for example, in the Hadees, we learned that, If ever a person is confused with regards to the number of records, he's not sure whether he has performed three or for Shetlands, putting that what was in his heart, then what should he do? He should perform in an extra car, if it was three that he performed. Now, with this extra the number will be complete, if he had performed for already, then this extra locker with the successor Will you know make the Salah correct for certain actions, if a person misses them, if a person makes a mistake concerning and then says this alone is not sufficient, he has to perform that entire locker. So for example, if he
misses the record completely, if he missed a certain factor completely, then his locker is not valid. So in addition to such as I hope he also has to perform the locker but there's some other actions for which says this I was not required other parts of Salah. So for example, you are reciting, okay. And instead of reciting minimum three, I add the recite to add and later on you realize now should you be performing says so at the end? No, we don't need to. Likewise he went into record and instead of saying so panel or better alim three times you said it only once. It was a mistake? Do you have to resize this out further? No, these are minor. They don't make the salad
Okay. It's not such a deficiency for which you have to repeat a car or you HAVE to do such so yeah, there is different kinds of work and right.
Any other question that you may have anything you'd like to add? Yes. Sure. I mean, remember that knuffle prayer, right? Like, for example, if a person has missed many prayers in their lifetime, and they don't even know how many.
So what's the solution to that? Remember each Lila and then try to make up? It's not going to be possible? Should you be concerned about the prayers that you have to perform now or the prayers that you've missed before? Right? So in that case, what should a person do he should just increase in his novel prayers, and inshallah those nefler prayers will add to that will compensate for that in Sharla. So when you join in us that just joined us knuffel You don't have to say it's for that.
Okay, cello will conclude here. soprano Golan will be home the ignition La ilaha illa Anta Mustapha rucola. To really a Solomonic hora de la