Shadee Elmasry – 9 Bid’a Hasan & Tajribi Knowledge
AI: Summary ©
AI: Transcript ©
My next question is also somewhat of an old school, but it relates
to practices
element to gdb.
Is that accepted or not as a source? I know you even remember
that even Taymiyah had a comment on this. He said, sometimes when
you want your DUA to be Mooster job, you go to one of the old
masajid that's no longer used, and you give life to it, you print it,
have admitted gdb 10 gdb means experiential. From the experience
is the ad dead of vicar. This is a something that comes up a lot, and
I want to know the hand up somebody's approach to it. For
example, husband alone emo kid, it's well known that it's spread
around amongst the many machines that 450 is its number of Salah
Allah Rasool L for Mara phillium 1000 in a day, is its number.
Okay, and this is not no one saying that this is NetFlow or Ned
mandu or anything, but it's to gdb knowledge just like someone says,
you know 15 setups in the morning 15 At night, okay, it's just
experience and things like this run five miles a day is becomes a
weird for many people in the fitness world. Could you comment
on the role of tragedy be knowledge? This has to do with
food? Yes. Angry. Previous question also had to do with food.
I hope when the listeners
when they when they listen to these things.
I hope that they do not rush into ringing this quote from this
Hanbury Shea who rejected something in particular, we are
talking about food, we also love them.
Do they reject these ideas? Do they accept them? Can Can this be
something that doesn't contradict with the humbling phone? This was?
This somehow was the question
I haven't handled. And this is mentioned in the books of faith. I
used to believe that if you write Psalm eight of the Quran, in a
glass
of water, and give it to the pregnant woman or give it to the
sick person, this would help. Where is this in the Sunnah. If
you bring me a hadith, if you bring me that this was done by
some of
the companions,
you will I will give you other examples, from Muhammad himself
from other from other people, at the time of admission from our
high Nebula, who
showed us that you sort of dumb as * can never be contradictory
with such things, if you tried something, and it resulted in
another thing.
And your Aki that is that Allah subhanaw taala is the real DOER of
things.
I should I shouldn't fear for you, I should feel for the one who
believes that things have the power almost kind of delegated the
power in them to act accordingly.
And they might believe in such things this this is this is the
interesting, but for for me and for anyone who believes that the
last panel data is the doer of things. And you know that this is
the Sunnah of Allah Allah that the unbelievers have doesn't reject
such things.
In the end, you might find that Hamdani or to rejecting something
in particular
but this doesn't mean that they reject the Constitution. Now and I
have many examples in my mind, but
will take a lot of time, but at least this example is enough.
Which means in that case that there is something known as an if
we can, we can rename this to gdb
experiential
practice is it a type of Buddha has an event is there such a
thing? Because it sounds very much similar we're gonna get the same
results what Imam Muhammad did for example, recite the ads or write
them in water right the dissolve the ink and water or something
like this. What else is that besides what we would call better
Hassan
it's just that this is an issue of terminology can Yes, it's been a
hassle. Now I agree. Do the Anabela have something called be
that Hassan do the HANA Villa that Hannah Bella and we are talking
about a term in the embodiments term according to those people who
call themselves an avid now this this is a teacup or fie Stila
No, we do not have something like that linguistically. Yes, it's a
bit of a hassle. It's better and it has Yes. Then how many of us
have Elpida is either disliked or haram prohibited?
This
term is a term
which means that there has been a husband. Yes, linguistically. Yes,
we agree and
then what would they call such an action such as whatever the Tamia
said about going to the or the massages that are out of use or
Imam Ahmed's use of the verses for pregnancy? What would we what
would they call that?
By it, they will give it a ruling they will say this is permissible
or this is Sunnah, sunnah, they will call it sunnah. They are not,
they are not restricted. In that case, they do not call it sunnah,
if it has been done by the prophets, I send them only you
know, they call it sooner, even if it hasn't been done by the
prophets on the laurels. Now, and they have they have setup and they
have
this was the strongest example Ahmed himself writing the aid. And
it's and you know, you know, what, what makes it really strong that
they mentioned this example, in particular, in the books of faith.
And you open a book of fiction, you see this
other things
from Damien,
about
and this is not material, but this is not even whatever that the
origin of added everything, but look at this knowledge. The dad
knows his
visitors.
He knows them. He knows how they are, he knows about them.
This is not only the law, the composition embodiment of this is
what you read
from a Potamia. And even if you write my dad, they said the same
things and he said more, just enough to remember everything that
they said. He said even more than this.
This is not even
in in direct way. This is weaker than that. And yet they do not
mind saying such things. As they say you should. And I have many,
many more examples, but the strongest was one of the amygdala
who did not