Islamic Perspective on Roe v. Wade

Yasir Qadhi


Channel: Yasir Qadhi

File Size: 21.02MB

Share Page


WARNING!!! AI generated text may display inaccurate or offensive information that doesn’t represent Muslim Central's views. Therefore, no part of this transcript may be copied or referenced or transmitted in any way whatsoever.

AI Generated Summary ©

The second wave feminism movement began in the 80s and focused on men and women, not just against women's rights. The movement's claims were wrong, but the majority of dissent was on the defense of their claims. The Supreme Court overturned Roe vs. Wade, stating that the government had no effect on any ban on abortion, and the movement's claims were wrong. The discussion on privacy and privacy issues, including rape and incest, is a problem that is widely discussed among conservative groups, and parents are urged to preach the truth and speak out against evil.

AI Generated Transcript ©

00:00:00--> 00:00:40

Spil Alhamdulillah wa salatu salam ala Rasulillah, who either early he was so happy women are humbled by this last week. I've been bombarded with so many questions, especially of our youth. I've had a number of conversations with them about the overturning of Roe vs. Wade. And even today in my office hours, I had dinner with some youth as well with so many questions. So I thought it would be useful to share some Islamic perspectives on this regard, so that inshallah Tada we can benefit and begin a broader discussion obviously, only so much can be done in a short hot era. For those of you who are not aware, Roe vs. Wade is one of the most landmark and historic Supreme Court rulings in

00:00:40--> 00:01:24

this country. It was passed in 1973. So basically 50 years ago, 49 years ago, and it is considered to be the culmination of the second wave of feminism. So I need to now take a step back and explain what is second wave feminism. So feminism is a movement as you're aware, these days, they consider to have four stages. The first stage, which began at the turn of the century, was the fight for women to have the political fight for women to have the right to vote, and the right to own property, by and large that was finished and successful by World War One. So across all America, European countries, Western countries, women won this right. World War One World War two kind of

00:01:24--> 00:02:04

halted the feminist movement, post world war two second wave feminism began, second wave feminism began challenging gender roles. And the notion that men and women should have the same opportunities and the same playing field should be leveled. Up until World War One and two, women's roles was very different career wise, education wise, look at any black and white movie, look at any historical record in the past women were, let's say nurses and men were so there was this gender role that was understood. World War One World War Two because of obviously the socio economic factors, men are going towards, things are changing. So second wave feminism begins second wave feminism, women are

00:02:04--> 00:02:47

arguing that, why should there be any difference, we can do the same thing as men. And so education wise, a lot of people don't know this, that up until the late 60s, early 70s. Most universities were gender segregated, Harvard and Yale only began admitting women 1970 Unbelievable. This is a generation where many of you might have been studying in college. This is when these universities began admitting 1970, not 18 1970. So second wave feminism, they wanted a level playing field men and women should be the same in this regard. And intimacy wise as well. How can men get to have fun and women cannot get to have the same type of you know, sexual intimacy. So you had a part of this

00:02:47--> 00:03:28

was the revolution, the, you know, the hippie movement and the notion of sexual freedom, if you're aware of, you know, that movement as well, in this timeframe. One of the rights they wanted therefore, because the problem comes Okay, education wise, both can study in the same class, what not, but when it comes to intimacy, when it comes to intercourse, one of the genders gets burdened the way the other but gender doesn't correct. One of the genders is left with something that is not wanted, and the other gender gets to walk away scot free, right. So in this second wave feminism, they began demanding the right for not just abortion, but also contraception. Again, many of us

00:03:28--> 00:04:12

don't know this, up until this point in time, it was very difficult for a woman or a man to get contraception. It was only in the 1960s that the government opened this door because they understood or that whatever the reason was, they thought it would lead to immorality, which obviously it will they thought, well, let's keep a control on this. So in the 60s and 70s, contraception became widely available before this point in time, you needed a doctor's prescription, believe it or not, it was very embarrassing, and you a woman had to go, there was very awkward. And women also began demanding the right of, of what abortion why? Because freedom now, no baggage left, whatever happens, okay,

00:04:12--> 00:04:52

now it's fair because before this point in time, if the man does something and leaves, who's gonna get you know, quote, unquote, stuck with the child. So the rights of abortion became a hallmark of the second wave feminism so much so it was considered and it is considered to be the victory of second wave feminism. This is the culmination of women's rights of the second wave. And third wave begins after Roe vs. Wade in the late 70s, early 80s. And that's a different wave where women are demanding representation. Wherever there's men, there should also be women and women are demanding equal pay. And again, I'm just speaking factually over here. As for my own views, and whatnot, I've

00:04:52--> 00:05:00

given a whole about gender and Islam and we firmly believe that genders do have meaning and genders do have a role. Let's give it an A hold the right and I'm being factual

00:05:00--> 00:05:27

Hear. So third wave feminism, that fourth wave feminism were interested in second wave. So Roe versus Wade was passed at the culmination of the second wave feminist movement, and it was viewed to be the biggest victory for feminism. 49 years remains unchallenged. It was passed by a vote of seven to two, what is Roe versus Wade? It is the court's ruling that the government's the constitution of this country

00:05:28--> 00:06:09

guarantees the right of woman to have an abortion. So the federal government along with the guarantee of no police can, you know, take your property without a warrant? They cannot, sir, all of this guarantee freedom of speech. So this, the Roe versus Wade said, of the guarantees of the Constitution is that a woman has the right for abortion, what that court case did, because it's Federal Supreme Court, all 50 states of the country have to allow it because that's assuming Supreme Court and government funding is now applicable because this is Supreme Court. As you're all aware, America is a conglomerate of states states and and federal, they always have an awkward relationship

00:06:09--> 00:06:54

together. But when the federal government and the Federal Court, the Supreme Court passed it, all states have to come on board. And so it becomes a constitutional right. As we're aware, many people challenged this. And last week, by a vote of six to four, the Supreme Court overturned Roe versus Wade. Now what does it mean to overturn Roe vs. Wade? A lot of people don't understand this, right? Their argument does not ban abortion. A lot of people missed the point. Their argument is actually very simple and straightforward. It's very simple. Their argument is the founding fathers of this country, and the Constitution they drafted has nothing to do with abortion. They didn't imagine the

00:06:54--> 00:07:40

Founding Fathers about abortion. And it is a mistake to link abortion to the Constitution. This is all they're saying. They are dealing King, the constitutional guarantee. And they are saying the government based on the Constitution has no right to get involved. Hence, it goes back to what now the states, a lot of people are misunderstanding that this ruling is banning abortion. No. It's literally withdrawing federal support agreed. But it has no effect on any ban. But effectively, obviously, immediately, as you know, 15 states whatever they went into ban locally in their states, but the government, the federal government is not getting involved. They're saying that it was a

00:07:40--> 00:08:21

mistake. By the way. Roe versus Wade Wade was passed, I think seven to two, the two dissenting, the two dissenting Supreme Court justices. That's exactly what they argued. That's exactly what they said. Whatever your position might be. It's not a part of the Constitution. You're reading it in those two dissenting voices now becomes the majority, six out of four and they're saying the same thing. Okay. Now, this is the history of Roe versus Wade. Now, a lot of Muslims immediately get bogged down in the field of abortions. As for the sake of terminating pregnancies, I've given a whole hour q&a with Dr. Hatem al Hajj, one of the senior scholars of North America and a medical

00:08:21--> 00:08:59

doctor, one of the few people who's combined knowledge of medicine and a PhD in Islamic faith. I have an interview with him here in epic masjid, during COVID. We had a zoom interview, you can listen to that. And it's a very detailed lecture, the fifth of of terminating pregnancies, you can listen to that. And in a nutshell, there's no question I have to summarize all of this. There's no question the default and our Shetty is that Allah blesses you with the child, you take it as a gift. The default is the preservation of life. And exceptions are exceptions. And our position is definitely not as strict as some evangelicals and Catholics, but it is definitely not as open or

00:08:59--> 00:09:42

liberal as the left is as well. We celebrate life and we affirm that Allah blesses. So we're supposed to maintain that life. But there are exceptions. And definitely in the first, you know, a month or so perhaps there's a few more lakhs that he's given, but never, never is aborting or getting rid of a pregnancy allowed because of an inconvenience because of monetary factors, because of the standard reasons that are given here. medical issues, no doubt, yes. And that can be even maybe in the second trimester medical issues, issues of you know, problems, no doubt. So the Sharia has a more nuanced view. You can listen to it in the lecture over there. And we need to be practical

00:09:42--> 00:09:59

here. Now. Forget the Roe vs. Wade, the reality in this country. For the last 10 years, roughly roughly 1 million fetuses were being aborted roughly sometimes more, sometimes less 1 million for the last 10 years. Now whenever

00:10:00--> 00:10:45

Roe versus Wade comes up and abortion, you always find generally in the left wing media, a very emotional story of a lady struggling with a problem or a rape or an incest and wasn't able to be aborted. Actually, if you look at the statistics, now the problem comes statistics, the government did not and does not compile statistics on why abortion occurs. This is private entities, and some states they monitor why. So I did a quick survey today and I'm giving a general numbers I'm not claiming these are exact, but I did enough to know and show this, it's confident to say rough ideas. Generally speaking, abortions that are due to rape and incest are less than 0.5%. Generally

00:10:45--> 00:11:14

speaking, abortions due to rape and incest less than 0.5%. That's one out of 200 less than that. Abortion due to medical issues very broadly defined very broadly. Because when you say medical, what do you mean is the mother's life in danger? Is the child going to be born with abnormality, that's a whole big spectrum, roughly five to 8%, depending on what survey looked at five to 8%, the default of abortions, unmarried

00:11:15--> 00:11:57

mothers who did not want to have a child for financial or it was inconvenient, or they didn't have a partner with them in some surveys and statistics, up to 85% of abortions is because of this statistic. So when you read one of these sad stories and whatnot, this is the point 5%. Let's not forget the default, the default. It's inconvenient, of an action that should not have occurred, you get what I'm talking about, right? It's the byproduct of something that should not have happened, and you're like, Oh, now what do I do? And then they go for the abortion. So let's be very clear that those people that are bringing up those exceptional scenarios, we don't base your Commissioner

00:11:57--> 00:12:40

you on exceptional, we base it on the hokum am here. Now, another point that I also want to mention when we talk about this issue of abortion, is that Subhanallah we thank Allah we thank Allah, that our *tier has come with clear cut guidelines, because honestly, it is really a difficult situation or scenario. When does life begin? Who has the right when it's early, middle late? All of these questions have a philosophical, theological, ethical nature. How would you resolve them if you didn't have revelation from Allah subhanho wa taala. As for us, I settled in Santo and Utica Sudha did man think that he will be left without a god? As for us, Allah says about Okuma, Obinna

00:12:40--> 00:12:41

acuminata, do not

00:12:42--> 00:13:20

your father's and your sons, you don't know which one of them will benefit you more when it comes to the inheritance and the fractions of inheritance. Allah says How would you decide the fractures of inheritance between your father and mother between your son and daughter? How would you decide? How would we decide anything without Sharia, our morality, our o'clock hour? Adab are halal and haram. If we were to leave this to the chaos of people voting of the fads that take place amongst people Subhan Allah one day something will be highlighted the next day it will be out on doesn't work that way. The Halal is what Allah has made halal. The Haram is what Allah has made haram and the *ty

00:13:20--> 00:14:02

outcomes and teaches us this reality. That's why Allah says that. You Halal the homopolar Ubatuba you heard him talk about the Sharia outcomes to make the pure things halal, and the filthy things haram How would you know pure and filthy unless the Sharia has come? So we need to use this conversation about the gray area of ethics, morality, politics, law to teach our communities and the broader society the blessings of having a divine revelation when Allah azza wa jal reveals in the Quran when the prophets of salaam says 40 days here 120 days there hamdulillah things clear up, we now have a clear cut understanding when is the roof blown in our foot? Haha, yes, there's a small

00:14:02--> 00:14:40

spectrum of 50 law, which is always the case, but it is relatively small spectrum, our full QA generally have a very clear idea about the fit of terminating pregnancies. We thank Allah for this because when Allah speaks, the messenger speaks, somebody will alternate, so we don't have to worry about those ethical and philosophical debates that takes place outside here. Now, another point I also wanted to mention is that too many of us especially our youngsters are caught up in the rhetoric of the left and the rhetoric of the progressives of the Democratic Party. And we have to keep this in check. We are neither Democrats nor Republicans, we are neither left nor right. Our

00:14:40--> 00:14:59

language is not the language of the current politics. It is the language of the Sharia, the language of the Quran and Sunnah. We don't base things based upon the fads of today. No, we are above this. We need to teach our children this and honestly, not just our children and our community. We need to preach to those around us.

00:15:00--> 00:15:54

The reality of why this is taking place you see, we jump to the problem to the cure, and we forget the solution. This whole debate that is taking the country by rage about the rights of abortion, abortion. Well, let's take a step back. What's happening before the abortion, such that you're thinking about an abortion, this spread of immorality and the normalization of far hisher. And the prevalence of the hookup culture, it is something that is should astonish the average mind 100 years ago, in this country, less than one out of 10 men and women engaged in premarital intercourse, the norm was, you wait, you live a dignified life and then you get married? This is just 100 years ago.

00:15:54--> 00:16:43

Now. I just looked up the surveys. Almost 97% of men and women some said 9899 engaged in premarital in the broader society. There is no concept of it being immoral. So you guys, the broader society is jumping to the problem, and you're forgetting the cure. You're forgetting why this problem is happening. This problem is happening because you have lost all morality. You don't have a sense of what is decent and dignified and you have opened the door for fascia. So we as Muslims need to be very clear about this. It is actually a mistake to jump into the abortion debates without taking the step back and talking about a clock and morality. Hi yah, our profit system said Every religion has

00:16:43--> 00:17:24

one defining characteristic and the defining characteristic of our deen is modesty high up higher modesty. So when you open the door of fascia, and this leads us to even the ultimate source of opening the door for Pfizer, because far harsher is linked with not believing in a higher power, not believing in a day of judgment. If you believe in a higher power, this country was Christian 100 years ago, very Christian. That's why far Asia was very rare, less than one out of 10 religious levels have gone down belief in God is now considered to be antiquated. They don't believe in a hereafter what's going to happen when you don't have Iman in a higher power, society is going to go

00:17:25--> 00:18:06

as it has become so we as Muslims, we have an important role to play that role is to be beacons of preaching morality and the truth we have to tell society around us. We are Allah has delegates to be honest, where Allah is quantum HydroMet and the nurse Allah sent us that maroon had been my roofie what and how Nandan Wonka. Allah has chosen us to preach the truth and forbid against the evil. We cannot force anybody that's their business, but we have to preach the truth. We have to speak the truth. We have to live the truth and eventually the people around us as they see all of society become corrupt, and the evil becomes even more evil. And the fascia becomes even more foolish as it

00:18:06--> 00:18:49

is happening now. When we stand up and preach the truth insha Allah Who to other people with pure hearts, pure filtros will click they will understand. Yes, these people have a religion from Allah subhanho wa taala. So, conclusion here, it is a mistake to jump into the abortion debate immediately. It's a mistake, because the abortion debate is predicated from a culture of fireshot from a culture of promiscuity from a culture of complete allowance of every haram. We have to go behind this and say hold on a sec, this should not be normal. And it is not normal because we believe in Allah subhanho wa taala. So we link it even beyond this even to the basics of Eman and

00:18:49--> 00:19:31

Allah azza wa jal, and we call people worse than the sin of abortion is the sin of *can. Cofer worse than this is the sin of shooter can go for so we have to preach people about believing in Allah azza wa jal and morality and to hate and one final point, my conversations this last week, and they should not be any surprise to you was very interesting to say the least. I think there is a clear divide between most of our youth and most of our elders. In this issue, which is symptomatic of their views on religion and deen and liberalism and feminism. There is a clear divide between college and teenagers versus those that are in their 40s and 50s or maybe even late 30s. So I

00:19:31--> 00:19:59

strongly encourage all of you parents to sit down with your teenage children, not even teenagers, maybe even middle school are very well aware of what's going on and open up this conversation. What do you think about this overturning of Roe versus Wade and began talking about o'clock morality hayah belief in Allah subhana wa Tada explained to them it's a mistake to jump all the way there without working your way up with iman and Allah with believing in what has had on haram.

00:20:00--> 00:20:39

With the reality of what happens when in fact he has opened up, it is not healthy when our community is so divided where the youngsters are, pretty much many of them if you would see what's happening are aligned in one in one area, and the elders are very much disconnected from what's going on and not even communicating with them. So I strongly urge every parent to sit down with your children to have frank conversations and to bring them back to the basics. What is the basics? We believe in Allah, Allah sent down the Quran with our prophets of salaam to teach us how to live our lives, ethically and morally and when we follow that Sharia when we follow the Quran and Sunnah our lives

00:20:39--> 00:20:57

and societies around us will be pure and healthy. May Allah subhana wa Tada guide all of us to that which he loves. May Allah azza wa jal protect our children and grandchildren may Allah subhana wa Taala allow our sons and daughters to be beacons of morality and beacons of love which is akmola who played on Santa Monica Monica mucha Lucha Libre catch

00:20:58--> 00:21:15

in LA Mussolini now Alamos Lima de one meaning Mina team one quantity now look on it the more saw the pain I was for the bond the one saw the Rena was love your audio want to for sharing you know

00:21:18--> 00:21:33

what unfortunately no one was watching I think one downside BP now one downside the party was slow on me now was all in

00:21:34--> 00:21:42

one heavy Lena photo gentleman one half the award the was that good enough? Guess

00:21:43--> 00:21:47

what the guilt or? I don't know hula hoop

00:21:49--> 00:21:52

down what Eileen