Shadee Elmasry – Valid But Sinful Fast
![Shadee Elmasry](https://artwork.muslimcentral.com/shadee-elmasry-150x150.jpg)
AI: Summary ©
The speaker discusses the concept of sinful behavior, including fasting and sexual activities. They explain that sinful behavior is a result of one's actions and does not necessarily mean they will be rewarded. The concept of valid behavior is related to gaining or maintaining a status, but it is not a substitute for reward.
AI: Transcript ©
valid but sinful has to be in one act. Let's take for example, the
month of fasting. I fasts my month Ramadan, I did not eat, drink or
have sexual * or emit any sexual fluid for the day. So
it's valid, but the whole day I spent it watching illicit movies,
cursing, yelling. So my behavior in the fast is sinful, but the
fast overall is valid. Valid does not mean you'll be rewarded for
just means your body fulfilled what you were asked. That's the
meaning of valid but sinful