Earn On-Going Rewards Now
Introduction To The Science Of Hadeeth Part 12
Channel: Jamal Zarabozo
Series: Jamal Zarabozo - Introduction To The Science Of Hadeeth
File Size: 20.05MB
Episode Transcript ©
Transcripts are auto-generated and thus will be be inaccurate and at times crude. We are considering building a system to allow volunteers to edit transcripts in a controlled system. No part of this transcript may be copied or referenced or transmitted in any way whatsoever.
Sorry for coming late.
This is the 12th. Class.
What did we leave out? Yes.
Actually, I have
an entire lecture just about sideboarding a Muslim but because we're running kind of late,
I mean, getting kind of behind the class, we will not do it someday in the masculine as a general lecture, maybe I'll give it
we're talking about the
what is the level of the different headings for this?
And we said, What What if a headache is not worth it, then it comes under these two categories.
And we'll put the earlier Kini or Emily premium Murray.
And it is a basically they are stating that there is definitive confirmed knowledge, which no Muslim should doubt.
And we also said that when it comes down with the word head, if you don't have to go through those five conditions that we mentioned
remember those, don't you?
nothing is correct. Okay.
Actually, it's not an
But then we said the other had either had we talked about another Buhari and Muslim, many of the Harris or and meeting them with what we discussed all that we came to this point, this is their fourth.
was the second one.
Most of these
basically, there's very little difference between these two.
Except for when they say a brewery, they mean and it is something that every Muslim should know doesn't need any investigation.
Just clear to everyone.
Now, the way they usually define these terms is
it usually means that in one of the length of the chain, or one of the several cuts, there's only one narrative.
Great means one of the double card, there's only one narrative.
So for example, from the prototype and
then we have our
because of demand.
so if we take this headache, and we study, for example, who narrated this hadith and each of the tablecloth, or each of the generation, we find, for example, only once the hobby narrated for devayne 12
to the domain and so forth. Usually this, this is the way it is.
So for example, once the hobby knew it, and he narrated to four people,
those four narrated and so forth.
Hey, this is very this, this is not as odd.
Because in one of the summer clubs, there's only one there.
It could, it could be the opposite, but it's very strange. Very strange, because really,
in this case,
yeah, it could be the case.
Free to have it in one survey What that means is this one survey he heard it from three so happy to have any Batman it's not coming you do this the other way okay
by class like the name of
the period of Harvard and the one thing at the time which the last holiday
domain has two categories major
minor major domain are those who missed many other
minor those missed a few
so the cemetery are those people who met the domain
and so on. Okay
but he couldn't be could three o'clock be within 110
yeah for example
as everyone he takes from the Sahaba he took mostly from the mostly before this time
right so we're talking about the people not the date necessarily Who are the people in the chain because as I mentioned, the headers we discussed earlier today has to Sahaba and the chain right Mohammed bin jubair and his father
so both of those are from the same
visit 100 from the other one. In other words, if it's something like this
if it's something like once the hobby passes on to another hobby and then two three,
then we still say this is only one in the first
they have to hear it independently of each other for it to be more than one
paper from the same token generic information
determine the last habitat This is the stuff that I said will not go over but you'll find it in the text.
I gave you the face.
The most the most famous example of a very Paris is what
okay with this man
who narrated from Mama
narrated from other than Abraham and the high from our and then you haven stayed open
with Alcoa two in a hurry to hear him say to
me is the last
it is because of armor is the only hobby that we know who narrates it
and the only one who never had any grace and exchange from honoris causa from him Abraham and
so the first three links does vary because of the first series from yeah havenstein of cotton we have 700 chains for this heading.
So it went from one
to one to one I made it very famous
very mature, these are all types of I had had you
know, you don't have to
worry by definition it's
by definition, it's either going to be very busy so
now that you have it like this, you study to apply the five conditions doesn't meet the five conditions.
And this hadith is scientism said before audience, I must
reading about this Yes, you have to study it.
And if you say what what that means is this automatically So hey, it was like the Quran? Well, if you say it's either variable or as it means you have to study, it could be weak, it could be strong.
And it's so many people know in each of the double costs, this is no any no way they could have any forge this head either come together to make this any
or all of them have made the same mistake in North America know to mean by many, many people in each table cause many problems. Like for example, men can devalue the dominant, something like 82 Sahaba narrated that
well as he
as I said, there's no any actual formal definition of a minimum number, just that so many people never raise it.
And there's no doubt about the fact that they did not gonna get together to fabricate it. And there's no doubt that they couldn't could have made the same mistake all of them. Therefore, and it raises to what the comment what that means to me his definition of mutawatir is somewhat unique includes many heads which other allameh will not consider what what
he raises the question if it's sometimes by the by the person who narrates it some people like him American mm Sharpie and scores
scores and had he narrated like this he considered
this is by the way, an example of a headache, which is very, and also most of the
most of it is a term.
Actually, you'll just find it among the
among the Hanafi they are the only ones who use this term
was the Hanafi representative here um the rillette
Oh cannon is for sure.
The head of Easter Muslim.
What they mean by that term is is the heaviest which was less than most motivated,
but became very famous, they will not like the study
they would call this Harris Harris most of it. So in the head of it, most of it has this as a special ranking, just considered stronger than it is everybody
does the heaviest, which is originally either labeled as is. And then after some of the during the first three generations, it became most well known. Like
I said, this is an example of
isn't it but it
the only ones who use this term. The only ones
Yes, they would call this Mr.
Especially if it became famous within the first three generations.
the other hand if he stressed the first three generations
because the both of them said the best generation of mine than the one after it then the one after
Okay, so they say that these are the best generations and, and the end the amount of lying in this kind of thing is not like it was in later years. Okay. So for me basically the talk actually about Hadith, which during the first three generations, even though sort of very became very famous. So that has a special ranking in there also.
The next one is that is
the only difference between Aziz and Marie. In the case of a very Western said in one of the double class, there's only one Narrator And the case of ideas and one of the total costs, there's only two there is no words for example to Sahabi narrated from the process of them after that maybe 10 to vein and 22 to the end. But in one of the federal courts, only two people are
driving in every
Well, my tour
is three in one of the double clutch just three in one of the double quotes like for example three, the hobby
will force the hobby and and just treat the brain.
Well in general they consider anything after that.
As is in one of the double costs, it is hovered domain activity is only to people who narrated this heading
ending with what it is that needs to
I'm saying but at least I'm just trying to get to that point that at least two is not the proper way to say it.
So usually when they define it this way, then they say of this poor in every double costs, we call them to us.
And either way, most of them had nothing. Explain it, although it is not.
Probably not exactly
Three and one of the double costs and just one of them
Yeah, yeah, we're not talking about rejected narrators get we're talking about acceptable narratives. And each of the other words the three liars or four liars and each generation narrated doesn't make it
it is, you mean please three.
And these three have to study them to see if they meet the conditions that we mentioned earlier today, but they can be they can be they can be the healthiest, which is very it can be a hero by which a disease can be solved by
simple mesh for sure is not likely, but could be
bad condition, the chain has to be unbroken. Every scenario has to be either scenario has to be loved. There can be no shadows, and no ela. You can guess what those two.
It's very unlikely because you have three, at least three people on every one of the chain, every one of the telcos supporting each other.
Most of the difference of opinion whether it is Firebase, we're talking about how nice is this category as he's
this, but to me, you know, you can
have your own.
For example, the head is in the mail. Mmm, yes, we only have it authentically from one Sahabi. This is just before you can we discuss
on what is the oldest, The Hobbit? The Hobbit who narrated this that we have it authentically from him? Now some people will argue that that is not very because the dog narrated it, actually during hotbar in front of many of the Sahaba. And none of them. Yeah. And he rejected it or Sydney This is not right. But from that point of view, it's still considered.
Okay, now these three categories are
now we still have to come
back to the question.
What is the level of El Nino? Not the Midwest that had it but have I had
to make you
do you think that they are of this level?
get the first by the way, the first people who to question I had had these were the mock diseases.
And those people who are questioning them today they're actually following them.
And the thinking for sure.
Is there are people who
want to rely on
this thinking originated from them.
And those who say it or following the thinking of their
own I had
a specific head heavy that some of them
had hedis in general, to say we only submit to us if
you're we only accept an update that we only accept moved to weatherhead yet we don't accept that.
this is Andy from a master's in this idea
while they say that mostly because they were philosophers
so but the reason is because they're philosophers and
their argument is that Johnny says something
well listen no data many times in the Quran criticize those people who follow what has been
the problem then can have many meanings in the Arabic language
is an English
but in Arabic language can have many, many meanings, okay. One of them
is going the opposite way. One of them is something that has no basis whatsoever
and no proof for
no reason to follow it.
No basis whatsoever. That is what the Quran is criticizing people for
me to follow things that they have no reason to follow. no basis for no revelation from Allah subhanaw taala no guidance concerning
the other extreme
there's one convenient thing
for certain things something known for sure.
so any button can mean your key
that's something else.
because they did from the end, they are taking London's meanings if any, they are what they're what they're doing is they're saying in the Quran tells us not to follow them. This heritors only so therefore, we should not follow them.
You know what they are making it biased. They're just taking one meaning of the word but
another type of Lenore in between those is a brand which is
of the oven.
But this kind of been?
Okay. There's something we are not certain about. But the preponderance of the evidence or the majority of the evidence tells us that it's true. In other words in in the courts here, United States Courts, if you're on the jury,
if the preponderance of the evidence shows that the person is guilty, you must vote for him to be guilty. Okay. And also in if the preponderance of the evidence shows something you have to act according to that evidence.
so much of the things, many things you'll find are lovely, but they are this type of them.
And the the preponderance of the evidence shows that to be correct. So it's obligatory on the Muslims to follow this type of hunt.
relative to other evidence against
for example when we say a headache
when we stay ahead is to say we're saying that it meets those five conditions meaning we are certain to a large extent
we're certain and to a large extent that this Hadees has been properly preserved from the provinces
so what we're saying when we say that I need to say we're saying that it meets this category
This is why it is obligatory on the Muslims to breathe in and follow any Hadith which is graded by the LMS
said, I wasn't planning on getting into this but
somehow we get into that clear
and I'm saying that if this is the highest meets at least this criteria
at least the Muslims to believe in it
maybe have you have some
okay. This raise it from this level
And it will come in
added by external or supporting evidence, the headache is raised from this level
to a stronger level.
Okay. Example of those headaches.
Oh, the Hadith in Sahih al Bukhari and Sahih Muslim.
We'll discuss them in more detail in a few minutes, but
not every head is this is considered So hey, by the cameras and this this much. Okay.
Yeah, if we have supporting evidence, it's raised. Like for example, the had eaten sales before is a Muslim.
A Muslim as I mentioned the other day in the mosque
and they were just taking from the top level or the best Teddy's available.
So the overhead is
given us the law.
Out of out of all of the reasons the head poker is a Muslim 210
have been criticised.
210 have been criticized, we'll get to them in a few minutes.
210 days out of is about 5000 or between six almost 6000 coming
to an attempt. I mean, Chris mentioned what kind of criticism they meant. But the scholars have had it like a minister asked to be on the safe side.
to be on the safe side they say that beside these few that have been criticized, there is a
heaviness in all the areas in Sahih Bukhari and Sahih Muslim artha Hey.
So as Allah Hadith is one of those external evidence in JAMA, Yanni all the scholars agree that these headings are the type of external evidence that raises the head, or the level of those headed from being one, Roger to being
No, except for these 200 kanheri e v. 210. Stay in this category. All the other edits are agreed upon. And when the other scientists agree upon something it's obligatory on the non scientists or non specialists
are an anomaly now
what's the difference between this one
and then the opinion Rory and the opinion of what's the difference between
I tell you that it's not accepted for any Muslim to reject either one of them
but what's the difference between them
Miss Harris that is ma Lola they are
every Muslim any there's no excuse for any Muslim to not love to know this body
okay and not worry and he needs some knowledge some investigation. In other words the scholars know this for sure.
Okay that's the difference between me appearing every one and nothing and normally this is everyone but with respect to this part
Bini they are both the same. So there was no especially non specialist in Hades has the right to say that these headings are not authentic because there's
this external evidence that raises it from being a writer to being an opinion lover.
He may be excused for rejecting those edits because he's not a specialist and heavy and he doesn't realize the position they have as opposed to just someone says there's no prayer five times a day just kept ruminating because there's something I think everyone knows, but this is something else and he requires some knowledge some some study
which is a Muslim, there are only excuses their ignorance
and if they do not realize what this editor
and if you study for example,
the these days and how all Bukhari and Muslim en el Buhari is that you know, 100,000 Hadith which are authentic, and yet in his head Buhari, he only included about 4000 handy.
And he was just taking the cream of the crop.
the cream of the crop
is divided into two types, the type and the thing.
talking about the book, except for these heavy switches that we'll discuss. None of them are urban, Mr. Booth.
None of them
came because of this crime.
Labor Buhari, we're not talking about his own he had
virtual Buhari, he took his collection, to academic Hanban to add even the machine to azura.
And have them look at them had had him had them look at his collection. And they accepted all of the 363 was not clear whether he took those heads out or not. But anyway, the point is that it's not just a hurry things authentic but also you have those other elements. similar words in the case of Mr. Muslim, he took his book club azura, one of the experts in edit or defects that we mentioned earlier, and any headache that was that I had the slightest
doubt he took it out. If I was there, I mentioned anything about any anything just took it out because you wanted the collection to be the strongest Yeah, heavy. If you look in
the Muslim, you'll find a hadith that Mr. Muslim recorded and then someone asked him what about the Hadith is overrated? Isn't it also authentic? Why Muslim as Remy said, yes, it is authentic In my opinion, but I'm only including those Hadith in which there is a jamaa or the Lama agreed upon authentic
has always talked about saying Muslims say, hey, Buhari, we're not talking about independent Allah making it
we're actually talking about what the scholars have had at this time agreed upon as authentic.
You know, is there a section in the 6010
that belongs to them?
Oh, yes, yes. Earlier today, we mentioned that many of these hobbies are also met with
them with whatever they go into this category.
even listening to someone
says any questions about this.
This is getting into some little bits important.
We'll get to them. We'll discuss them in more detail before discussing the books of Hadith.
Before discussing the books of say ideas, let's just mention two other terms.
One is the hay
and the other one is hay
with the new students along
with what is it that he doesn't want to say bye?
what do we mean by these two terms?
Before going through, are you asking my question? Are you
the title of the section? The section is there's two terms you want to define.
One is the height. The other one is
easy. The engineer
Okay, what's a literary
doesn't meet the five conditions
does not meet all the five condition Okay, there's a headache which is a little bit less than a by itself.
But due to a supporting evidence
We raise it to the level of
insight Muslim you'll find both
example of Hadith which is a lady
an example of Hadith which is same as it is
the province that says if we were not to be a hardship upon my alma, I would always infuse the miswak before we start up.
The one of the narrator's his name was Muhammad.
But one of the narrator's name is Mohammed Ahmed, he is he is
obviously is going to be on the right
but he is a little bit the only when it comes to poverty
is a little bit not from the top
but he is not the only one who never is there how many other people in there is the same and they support each other and were raised and headed to this level called side
chains yes supporting Mohammed bin. So therefore we raised it to the halal at
have a clear, said you'll find both signs and signs.
And so I didn't even see it. I didn't know
the first one the first person to collect a book of just authentic it was mmm Buhari
What does what does the name of his of his book
something before this
the first the first words there's not there's not a book of regents the first the first word in the definition
I mean in the title implies that this book contains Heidi's on every aspect of the
paragraph six Section E 248
talking about the first person to collect collection of heritage just authenticated
and his name was Muslim so he must determine
what the laws
are so like lay
more he a me or me One morning
I don't remember which actually it's written right here but anyway, we had
from the from the title of the book
what do we get
Gemma means discovers highly concerning every aspect of the deep human
things about human glioma
the two rows together
What does the Muslim mean?
Is it goes back to the
Muslim has it means two things
means two things I'm giving up on your focus means this is not
to say something is most not in this terminology is another terminology we'll get to later. This terminology Muslim means it says Murphy's Law and it has an unbroken chain. But does this mean
that you're raising your hand
means it goes any trace back to the process and
trace back to the process
with an unbroken chain
to not be
a dogma definition a Muslim
No No, that doesn't that's not for me.
Okay as I said, Hey goes with this.
And I was hoping to get question while the tape
what what that means is narrated by many people in each of the
muslin we're talking about one chain this unbroken and it goes all the way back to the processes.
Yes, there's an authentic book. But yeah, it is intention. And it was just you just taking the Hadith that passed on to him.
But this is the first person who has the intention to go to the head is by his tender weakened and authenticated. And to make a collection of just authentic hadith from his
forehead, as I said, goes with this
very important point.
And is saying that all of the Muslim Hadees are ahead in this collection.
All of the Muslim Harris are saying this collection
because not only but definitely
now he's saying that all of the Muslims in this collection meets the conditions for study.
Any habit which is traced back to the provinces, will be called Murphy's Law.
Okay, we'll discuss that when we discuss the metaphor and yet in general, but there's something for example, if the Sahaba said, if one of the study said that
on the Day of Judgment such and such will happen,
obviously, this information cannot be from this head.
And this is not something you can make use to head above. So on those areas that you cannot make it to the head of the Sahaba said something, then the ruling are we consider that statement as being from the process.
So they say the outcome of that statement is that it is modified or it is from the public.
Wishing to see that's quite often you'll see that
what does this mean?
Okay, Danny? Isn't he's already telling us right there, this
gig. Now. Now, there's many times you'll read, and I've seen it many times,
especially in newspapers and magazines nowadays and books.
Sometimes when they talk about a specific heavy, they say, one of the criticisms they have, as they say this heaviness is not as was not included by a Muslim.
Incorrect, because this was not their intention to include all the headaches, which were so high.
And you were making a type of sublease becomes because I'm sure in most cases, the one who wrote it knows that it doesn't mean anything. But he thinks no one who reads it would be
added because sometimes we're talking about people who have PhDs and sometimes even in hygiene, and they make sense
doesn't mean that
is just a special collection
is not correct.
Gemma means that this is a collection of headings. That includes sorry about all the aspects of the deed as opposed to for example, a pseudonym.
Assuming in general applies to collections of holidays that are already
Gemma just means that it includes headaches about Eman about this. About Menaka. About
You nanny if Mark doesn't mean not in with respect to subjects. But with respect to the offending calories that are out.
There was this many authenticated that he did not include in this book.
He regarding the same? Yeah, it could be regarding the same Yeah, getting the same topics. And he didn't use it. This was probably
not probably. And he says that what I've left out of this book is much more than what I've included
of authenticating that he wanted a book that would be readable.
the number of Hades inside Makati
without any taking out the repetition. Because as I mentioned earlier today I think
Buhari was sloppy.
And what are the methods in his book of hiding is that he would
put the sometimes any project will be talking about some aspects of setup,
for example, how to make local and
there might be one Hadith that describes the whole salon. But in that chapter, you'll just take part of that Hadith, which is related to otoko. And he'll put it there.
And then when it comes to the sedge death, how to make this, he will take the part of that headed with a disassembler and put it there.
When it comes to what to say in the hope you'll take this part of the Hadith and put it there. So actually using the same Hadees in three different places, or more. So there's lots of repetition, you'll find the same Hadith
or different parts of the headings in many different places in the book in the book. So without repetition without repetition. There are approximately 4000 heads in the head body.
Okay, now remember this point, and we'll discuss it. Well, why don't we discuss it now?
We'll discuss it we'll discuss it in a few minutes.
Remember, remember this, remember, these two terms
must never pay is a very important with respect to
the second person
anything wrong with us?
We thought with a long time ago anyway,
that's why they're Muslim. Now.
The second one, to make a collection of the Hadith was al Bukhari student.
What's the name of Mr. Muslim? His book
was not as deep as
could just call a janitor for
the collection. And even Yeah, he did not put even the chapter titles.
He just janitor just had it from the beginning to the end. There's no chapter titles, no division, nothing
order, but without any chapter. If you pick up any collection of the homeless nowadays, you'll see chapter titles.
both chapter titles were added by later scores. In particular, no, we
know we went through the Hey Buhari is a Muslim and added chapter titles every so often.
made his own
the number of
No, doesn't mean but he just didn't put it in the title.
You mentioned in the introduction, and also, as I said, and he tells us a lot about it. So you'll also find hidden from him saying that he did not collect. He did not include all the edits that were saved but only those edits were agreed upon by the score.
By the way, which is found in both sides Buhari is a Muslim is called one
it means explicitly that the Buhari and Muslim agreed upon but
implicitly it implies the whole ima agreed upon. Because, as I mentioned earlier, the ultimate grip on it with a body with Muslim one therefore
the whole room I have to follow their
For the major reason, because they're both walked up
and gave me the other hand
doesn't mean that those
are the questions that they have to put on.
But those reasons did not.
say there's about 4000 Hadith in Sahih Bukhari Sahih. Muslim there's also
Yeah, do you have the guts?
Also, and it was around 5000.
Between them, there's about something like 2500 500 heads which are
common between them.
That's why some people say, hey, Muslim is the most suffrage
that is not correct. Now, for me, there's 2500 headings here. Once you find them Muslim, you multiply them and Buhari
does not mean that ohare does not consider them authentic.
Not don't get that impression.
What he needs his own
way. And the other, the other. He added and he said
that he did not start with he did not start with alcohol his book and say let's work with that. Now he just made his own collection from his own show, that he in fact is not happy. By the way it's a Muslim from Muslim Arab Buhari. I know.
They wish to get an
he made an independent collection of Hadith which he felt at the top level of the hair is so important for the people to know and
also for his students, when Buhari has the problem with the bully
should anyone who's went to study with a buddy he should leave me in my Muslim to COVID books took a deficit Here you go.
Bali says this about the Buhari because he believes that there Buhari believes that the Quran is created, what is enough what what is it and he will twist it
he was thrown out of his city
or even made
to take his
dog and he noted again, these are the numbers of headaches inside body without repetition.
The number of Muslim Muslim this little reputation
This is common between
5000 here total and indicated area 25.
Now the scholars of the West
and like Spain for example, have to be
other scholars of that nature. They consider a Muslim to be superior to say what
was most of the scholar says ahead Buhari is superior to him.
And we can give
studying the two books
I'll get to those. As I said most of the scholars they say
is the period the same?
We'll discuss the reasons why the head body is.
Number one, animal body and Muslim, they did not mean to use many of the same narrators. But they did not always use the same narrative.
They use many of the same narratives. But if you find someone in the room, it doesn't mean necessarily it would be.
Right. Okay, so of those
people that you're only finding,
refine, find in 30 narrators
for 30 narrators you'll find them in body but not.
Out of these 430 80
I've had some discussion about
some discussion, discussion.
With a hand you can find 628 he
And sometimes by the way, I have included them on purpose in his haste to show that the statements about them are unfounded.
And remember, for example, we said, if someone has shaved, for example, because from this year, someone may reject them just because this year, so Buhari might include him to show that he has stepped up and he is acceptable and what they're thinking about them is not correct. They did that many times.
Okay, out of these 620 160 narratives, or 25%,
There's been some discussion about it.
So from this statistic, we see that the narrator's in general, are safer and hearty than they are. But there's some bias here.
And that bias is that after he did his work Muslim,
and he when when everybody included some people, because there was some question about them to show that they are authentic Muslim came along and did the same thing. But for more people. And in other words, the people that beyond those Corey mentioned, he did it on purpose, the same head if you will find this inside Buhari with the top the best chain, you'll find it in a Muslim with a weaker chain, having one of these narratives to show that that narrator is in fact authentic. So there's some bias here. I mean, it was somewhat intentional, in other words, an enormous part
has very little discussion about the
with your loved one.
you will find it in the book.
I cannot tell you can be found I cannot tell you out of hand, but you will find it in the book called gentlemen.
Young men are jealous.
And there's also another difference here that makes this stronger than that, that most of these narratives were there's no question about it. There are so many of them are actually our own teachers that he knew very well. That he started with a new them. And he knew they're authenticated and they knew they cared.
Yeah, of course, I'm sorry.
Out of these
Well, that was not the case. necessarily with Mr. Muslim with respect to these 160. So therefore also the certainty with respect to our body.
Also, now remember some of these again, how are we because Buhari or Muslim came after
Bahati if you remember our ranking of the narrator of Godzilla, except one there it is.
Only built from the first class.
First that narrative in the principal part of his book,
not sure which principle should be
we benefit from
principalities or powers. That's how you remember, the Delta has other meanings.
Anyway, and the principal had it and he would use second class narrator
things like what it means nowadays, but go down to the next category. So they're only a top level
as supporting evidence.
The difference between this
rally this first class, we're talking about those people who are like in American Liberty, and in the great schools.
These are people rarely made mistakes, but they just not did not get the same as the problem.
Even Muslim, on the other hand,
would use both of these classes for his principal.
And he would use this class for supporting evidence.
For sure, it was unintentional.
And they didn't put the head
down, he could use that out, maybe not on every head is put here.
But there's no need to do.
Now, one of the problems, there's this code nowadays, like an advantage Whoo, hoo, sometimes, and he goes to some of these edits, and he
criticism of the Hadees.
And it was respectful party and Muslim it is not as simple because as I said, these are areas that were well known amongst the tourists at that time.
And even Muslim, sometimes you would even required a weaker heading a weaker chain.
Even though he knows a stronger chain, it would require the weaker chain, especially if the weaker chain is early or shorter.
realize they like to get the shortest chain possible, be closer to a resource.
So one time I was gonna
criticize one of the heads and say I'm Muslim.
And one of our students heard this and he went to him, I'm Muslim.
And ask them, Why do you have this headiest through this chain, it's not a very strong chain. He said, I have this idea through this chain only because it is obvious the shorter. And because this hadith is so well known among LLM, that there's no reason to include the better chain.
So the only one we're talking about is timeless. And we're actually talking about ideas that are well known amongst the realm of the time as being authentic.
In other words, no longer chain.
He did not include this dollar chain in the same book because it was so well known, that included the shorter chain, even though it was weaker.
So someone comes along today and comes as a Muslim. And he looked at it as though I think this narrator is good, but weak and therefore this chain is weak and I don't accept this chain. And you can do that with the other books like a widower and others which do not claim to be authentic, authentic, which not seems to be agreed upon by Obama. But you cannot do that with a Muslim because you're forgetting the circumstances behind the book.
The people who believe that
this might be people from Spain.
In general, there's not many scores from Tunisia.
superior upper and upper
another another reason
if you remember this earlier
with respect to Milan headin
in order to show that you know
something but the other example I gave is just because we wanted to put the shorter chain and if they prefer it to
space but they consider Johnny you're closer to the system
and if they love to get the shortest change possible like some some hideous alcohol he has just two
or three narratives between him and the promises they love this type of Harry
the minimum the second
the Golden Chain well there's the short version and the long
with respect to Martin Harris also there's a little bit difference between a party and
y'all know it's mine and heavy thoughts
and to the power one it's a headache in which someone one of the narrator's uses the word
Okay, we discussed it earlier today was the problem was
not possible Okay. Now for if you have x
x and y
x narrating from y, both of them are
Yeah, the both of them are not consistently
in the international
highway sign, not with the least
x and y are stuck up.
It is sufficient for him was
alipore the preponderance,
preponderance of evidence.
Okay. In other words, if they both lived at the same time, and they have the possibility of meeting each other, Mr. Muslim would consider this to be an unbroken chain
next class or the one next class,
sometimes they're committing to at least
like the word
like with respect to all Buhari, he has to prove
or confirm that the narrator has met
the narrator is actually in the
game has to prove that the narrator is actually in addition to that
this was given given given
putting condition which is robots fitted in
Now, the point
point that you should keep in mind this is not
alcohol his definition of Asahi
for headaches. According to Lima Bukhari, it does not have to meet this condition
to prove that there isn't but for at least to be concluded in his book, jam, he has a it has to meet this condition.
The difference between the zoo and it is headed towards silca. Here according to him ohare was to be more careful to be stricter in his geography, he did not include them unless they met this condition.
Some people get confused on this point. Yes, some people what's the difference between or a Muslim there'll be this point and they'll say that's the difference. Now there's many differences and this one is actually a slight difference.
In the case of Muslim, as long as he has evidence to show that they live the same time they could have possibly met their boss that they do not commit at least the sufficient for him to accept this as an unbroken chain, the case of Al Bukhari he has to have proof that they actually met.
And it's just an extra condition, not for an alcoholic mind for it to be so high but to include it in the gym. So how can you ensure that
is the word of the
nanny is known by us here many years ago.
And sometimes, you know, it's by the Writing's on the on the notion It is so and so present and getting this headed. Sometimes, you know, it's by the hedges terms that he is a VISTA, and he says her destiny, so and so this means you heard directly from him he got. So he has some evidence that he used.
But this is one of the ways by which and Buhari was a little bit stricter than me, I must.
we'll get to this. No, we'll get to
the process of how we'll get to what they mean by that. Okay. And the last evidence, I think it's
the last less evidence
that shows that quality is superior
to Muslim, same body spirit as a Muslim
the sum of the two.
Number at number five, this
actually is number five in the book, my book is number four, because I skipped one. So it may put four or five
be too complicated.
Now I merged it with another one. I just put it together with with no, but number four. I mentioned earlier that there's 210 IDs from psycho horrify Muslim that can be criticized
how to use only 80 may be found inside.
So with respect to those heads, which were criticized
and there are much fewer inside qualities and other evidence that party was more exacting in his collection of heavy hitters. The other 151 30 plus because also some of these, you'll find
we'll get to help.
Now those who say that I was superior, they are not really talking about well, to some extent, they are talking about things related to science of Hadith Sahih Bukhari wrote his book mostly from memory.
I Buhari wrote this book mostly from memory. So a Muslim devout Muslim, both is booked mostly from his note.
And one of the one of the differences that that led to is that Mr. Muslim was very careful in pointing out any differences in wording and narration.
Okay, and if you read a hadith and timelessly many times after that is to write the song so also narrated it, but his wording was this song, so narrated it and he said it slightly differently. So in scenario, so, a Muslim is very good at looking at
how the different scores marry the head it was stable for instance, he was doing it mostly from his memory, he did not keep the slight differences. Sometimes the slight differences are very slight. Someone said what the other one said for us fans to dilla with gentle and Muslim would notice.
not from his memory from his notes. So
that's one reason why we the one of the better aspects of famous another aspect is also he was very careful in differentiating between head dessiner and banana.
While Buhari was not always that careful, sometimes he would use even in a mix the two terms
had done enough for a Muslim means what came through
was only used if the Harris came through Santa Barbara is only used if it came through.
by when Buhari would sometimes mix the two terms
Thirdly also for a beginner for someone who's not that
what aspects of say Muslim is that he always always included the complete adage whenever he recorded he will not break it into little parts
he would always give you the entire headiest from the beginning to the end
he will not break it into little parts
while as I mentioned earlier for the reasons that
benefice benefits from the reasoning a body would
split the headache into many different parts and use it whenever applicable there's also another aspect related to a Muslim which is
beneficial aspects inside a Muslim you only find one wild
only one suspended head is
okay while in a body you will find many many many wallets hurry how many I'm glad you asked me that
1341 lines of credit
some ways Muslim can be considered superior This is why the western in other ways and he technically speaking from technical point of view, I think as we can see, let's see if this works now.
See, I hope this works.
Just going to flip around and find my look at
that area it means that one of the ends of the chain is not there missing the ends of the chain
could be the beginning could be the end could be the hole could be the hole
this chap listen to this chapter that resonates with you in both English and Arabic.
Listen to this
listen to this
However, as you know they have yet
If the profit had not started firing during the early hours of the day, he would delay it till the sun had declined.
Any comments about that?
Was this net Okay, there's no it's not.
It's just flipped to another pages somewhere.
Pick the bad boy.
For the whole
the whole it's not as missing you're missing a big
part of it.
the point is
this is very easy to open
questions. It's very easy to open or pick the wrong one.
It's very easy to open the book of Al Bukhari and find them while the cat is
and it does not take long
because there are so many wild curries.
For example, this one
That's the whole chapter Don't tell me maybe it's in the chapter the whole chapter
because the bad thing
notice that the end what did he say
and everybody obviously, this is why the Kalka?
Exactly he did not make a mockery. We know that because nobody from our radars there's not enough people to reach a body. So, there are many costs inside quality The question is how do we deal with these models?
most of them, most of them are found complete out inside body with a complete chain.
Most of them
for example, sometimes he would put us in wildland form and he for many actually for many reasons he would put a lot of fire maybe we'll get into those. But
there are 150
mile radius inside pouring which are not included. With a complete it's not anywhere inside.
When next time shall I would begin with those 160