Channel: Akram Nadwi
© No part of this transcript may be copied or referenced or transmitted in any way whatsoever. Transcripts are auto-generated and thus will be be inaccurate. We are working on a system to allow volunteers to edit transcripts in a controlled system.
Bismillah al Rahman al Rahim al hamdu Lillahi Rabbil alameen wa Salatu was Salam O Allah Rasool e Muhammad, wa ala alihi wa sahbihi, Medina Mahabharat.
My dear brothers and sisters in sha Allah, I'm going to teach you in these two days, the famous text and muslera o cuando su la Hadith, which is a loser to Nava Fie, toady.
By in her Allah Allah Allah wa Taala, the one who was born in the year 773 and died in the year 852
Rahim Allah Allah Allah, this is one of the standard text, which people have been studying for a long time since actually he wrote
it always had been circulation and used by the people in the madrasa in the colleges everywhere. And hamdulillah I have learnt this text, in word by word in another trauma.
And then after that, I taught it many, many times. And actually, I might run out of this one is
to I learned this actually, now I'm going to teach you in two days. But I studied this definite throughout a month in for a year, not one day. It basically while the curriculum for the whole year, a very little bit discussion and understanding. So that kind of stuck to that how much explanation was there how much thinking of discussion. And actually, I learned this with my favorite teacher whose name is Masha. So my time to many of you, more or less Shabbat is Allahu Allahu taala. To give a really great thing, God always, you know, raise good questions. In whenever I start teaching this text, I tore the text very critically, to not just to explain the text basically, or so, you know,
to put my criticism I have the text and explanations that I'm comparing with other writers in the field of the Hadith. So I do this all the time, because sometimes when people complain that we have come to you to learn, you know, Islamic teaching in a good song after people do something like this,
but my professional is not to criticize, you know, he, as people think, because I really respected very much he's one of the most respected you know, extra you know, document among the last people he was the best person on this committee touch your body on Buhari is until now the best country in forever did not have to equal to that today not that I don't respect him of his knowledge respected and his great man actually after him, there have been nobody in the field of the data with the same knowledge until now, we never have anybody before the dirt you can find many many people, but he is the last man in the field. So certainly, you know, when we criticize it not because we know
respected, respected, they are we love Him, we respect him and actually his his great favor upon this discovery of atterberry
So, you know, some students asked me that if I can write down my comments that were helpful to that I wrote down you know, this last few days and inshallah and good publishers as well. So, you know, it will come more wider circulation, you know, our people in our, you know, students that the Hadith and you know, they can also read it at the comment, you know, so you know, that how knowledge actually you know, is developed to people, you know, two sides people learn from each other. So inshallah to be there, though I wrote what I wrote actually very concise, it also needs documentary so that why you could not just don't rely on that meaning it will I'm going to spend two don't think
that you know, you've got already notes anyway, don't worry, you know, don't think to write the best thing really, whatever you learn from your teacher, keep writing don't rely on these notes, the guy cannot write everything. I only wrote the major points, but there are many many details which I did not write down it's been some time I just mentioned the depth that I have discussed this in length in my country as a Muslim. So you don't have that you did not publish it anyway. So I just refer to my own commentary, which is not published to certainly when I'm teaching I will explain some of those points inshallah in much more detail.
So one thing you know before starting writing the very important write down everything this actually what we sing in our universe, Angela when we used to study we used to write down everything the teacher says because there's nothing to record there are no mobile phone, if you miss what teacher said, You miss not knowledge base, nothing was there. If you don't write on the classroom, you basically miss everything. So we used to take notes of everything, then after that coming to the room or to our own room and then used to you know, write it again nicely and you know, in more detail
so that how to help her and those notes like that I prepared in another trauma in India, a hunger there many of you know for Buhari for every book, there was, you know, after so much improved, that the students have kept borrowing from me after I finished I become a teacher.
And now I don't have them because in all we have in circulation, the trauma to I don't know who has got this, those notes.
So I'm trying to say that you know, you should write down right it's very, very important that how the analysis survived don't think that you're going to record we know our mobile phone, it will help you then you never go to listen. Because how long to listen to today's recording, you know, revising them again Again, it's not easy. The best thing is right down
is my I didn't have the American nurse that once I was sitting with Arthur uberaba,
the great expert of the Hadith and the fifth and Mufti of maka, maka, Rama. So, somebody in his module is in his presence narrator howdy
to Arthur said to his son booktuber, who are writing down disease so early, ATI is to not have a dilemma but the latter on Homer. He is a tavai He is the bestest teacher, his teacher
I never met in my life, any one better than other
to be the teacher
is 23 now but a lot a lot. Bigger man of America, leader of people in Makkah Luca Rama, somebody in his presence in the Reza Hadith is still he asked his his son to write it down.
marinara, Camelot Allah is also
an expert on the Hadith.
He said a millennia to be the oil. la mejor elimu Rama malam Jacques to be Lam your del elimu Halima those who don't write the knowledge, their knowledge and never considered as a knowledge to writing important manlam Jacques de la mirada even more Who are you
soufiane fell in arrears for our manasu yBnL Mohammed and he narrates Swami lambda high. And if you know in the Hadees account some people the most sound listener in the whole world is Sophie on authority. From Ibrahim from monster even watermill from Dr. nahi. from Alabama.
To this I'm talking about the best is not in the world. So the unfolding the recipe
for our monsoon even more taboo. He said I said to him on Sunday moving I will jod thumb Mojave Santa Monica.
When asylum Ileana Ross howdy Sam Harris v you narrate his or her This is more complete than you just think really will have the best amount of the Kufa in the knowledge in the piety in the Hadith in the film is the Imam is is to not Mansoor said to him, I said to my teacher, that there are other teacher in Kufa, Salim interval Giada who the holidays are more complete than you.
You know, it is really just kind of synchronicity How can somebody could be more complete and how this deliver him nahi you know, how can we do when I said to him, he would have no he said in NASA the man can Yakubu The reason kosala we used to write down everything see,
by writing sight solving even became better than you will have
more complete otherwise no doubt in the virtue in the piety in the fear of Allah in the faith in the Hadith and every single thing I ever have to hide the man. But when it comes to you know complete heavy, there even the stillness of
the silence is more complete than he will have. Luckily.
So Masuda said quilter libera Hema saw the movement of a thermo Hadeeth aminika in NASA the Malecon young,
North American so a man a time in Kufa in bussola. There are a few people that amazing one of those to the amount of time you know greater value. You know, very few people like him, and then his son is more than me is not the way but you know, he's also great man. Actually Northumberland Solomon, both son and father There are so pious that in in the night, they used to move from one or more skill Buster to the other mosque praying to each mosque and witnessing that they have they met that they used to spend time in the prayer their dinner train one mosque, they used to move from one a mosque to other mosque all the night that helped us to have been and also they are great people with
The more the merrier. When he was a student, he said cassava Elijah Avi, his dear friend bussola, but his father Sulaiman sent him to Kufa to Lara Hadi. He said when Ivan Kufa there my father wrote a letter to me, advising you what to do in Kufa to watermill said kata by Elijah Abbey over hon Kufa, my father wrote a letter to me when I was in Kufa, our initial terrorists of rock Toby Aleman. Don't waste your money in food, food and eating and drinking rather than
And that was due by the papers. My father wrote to me, they want to spend your money somewhere else, buy the paper, work to be the ailment, or write down the knowledge for indle Amala, yet Habu while they are in the Mahabharata, because the money will finish anyway, if you don't buy the paper, you will buy something else money will finish, but the knowledge will remain to buy the paper. So, you can write out a doubt, if you see such a great advice from a such great man to his own son, you know, and nobody can be more sensitive advice, then advising his own son to either advising his son by by the paper write down
this how they used to do, the second take so easy, not only is writing they used to learn by heart, mind, what very sharp, less very of the world way people have got so many concerns, really, that knowledge is a secondary thing. So many were in the life, you know, mobile phones, the TV and newspaper Sunday, you know, so many business in the life, so many discussion argument, the knowledge nowhere there. So we don't learn anything.
But the P those people they used to consulted and analysis is or even used to go to the market, he used to put cotton in his ear. So no voice can come in his ear. He can't learn anything from the shopkeepers and from the people in the understood every only thing he can learn with the you know the words or the Hadith.
The discovery, certainly big man, you know, Malik said once, so hurry narrated to us 30 hajis how many 32 I said to Sorry, I memorized from door 30 only 15
tokens repeat to me 15 other 15 to I can memorize them either.
So he said to him, Malik Malik, I never asked my teachers to repeat the heartbeat. Repeating the heartbeat is more heavy than moving the mountain. People don't want to repeat the same again again. When the teacher was asking them, they don't do this.
Then it was his Sham in automatic. He shall have to medicate one of the Omega califa in a very powerful mind. If you know the philosopher came to maga de la Toronto from omega then remain in his family for a while. Did a marijuana campaign in the field he has a for ammonia, but he could not get properly. His son other medic marijuana became halifa after medical marijuana has got four sons. All of them became califa worried the middle mother Malik, Sula, jersey and heisha all four become Felisa to their stories official, a Shah even though the medic asked sorry,
that my my son said Do they want to learn Howdy, can you declare some hobbies and then they can write down from your memory console you do not carry the books or in memory to carry the dictates of hobbies. So they can write down
so he said yes, then he called the writer those who can write a scribe so somebody came to zaharie dictate to them 400 Hadees how many 400
then so he came to the foot of the Hadith and he said yeah, I know Anton yasawa Javi Oh overhead is where are you? Because you know did not like to teach it some sub kings and oppressor and not teach it you know other muscles to Jory wanted to teach the same as also to other muscles they call them for film for HUD data home but
they narrated from the memory all those 400 these two other people
after one a month
a sham wanted to tell a story to his said to the Holy Rosary in Kitab tada data writing in which we wrote your 400 is their last we love the book
is already said La Liga did no harm for the arvika TV.
Okay, ask someone to write again for amila ha la there is no hurry again dictate all those 400 this for his memory all those for nothing forgetting filma arbella shamoun bill kita with a one firma Dara huerfano va Hayden
then hey Sean compared these new writing with the old one I'm sorry, no singular word about missing missing. The thing really don't look the memory. The Zohar he narrated 400 days and after a one a month he Repeat the same for under her this not from the book or from the memory and the people compare and they did not find any single mistake from Allah Dora. Her fun was hidden
jarier in Ramat raazi in the red from lira even a milk some other baby Molina died in there. 133 from Kufa baby
Man, a mother teachers are louder and so God big big money mom
to Jerry in arrears for a marinara even a milk some of what? He said, ma coffee masa Amelie Shea one, fantasy two. It never happened, that something fell down in my ears. And I forgot it. It never happened. Whatever I heard, it got deep in my mind. I know that it never happened that I have forgotten it. Ma waka fi masamichi Shea one, fantasy two, nothing happened. Nothing came to nothing fell down in my ear, which I forgot it never happened.
My hubby who narrates the story, he's dead. he commits all of the heavy you heard the world law he the hateful. This is the memory. This what memory means? law. If a woman Doris Akita one, Margaret in our data, what are the film Mahabharata la thermadata Sahaba fellow film and I see a lot.
Not a lot of those people who memorize the one book many many times and then they come to the teacher and ask them can you listen that that you know they present to them from their memory? Then they mix touched cart reel to their teacher mix. Then they come back again read and memorize. Then what happened? They forget all it or most of it. That what happened over time? People repeat nothing in the mind.
Her mother has had the rails that Henrique No Oh, by the way, sorry, narrated to him from I was Isaiah,
who was his scribe, our Secretary of marijuana. And marijuana was governor of Medina
who is a nurse that one day Marwan called abou Herrera della la Toronto, the great companion, he called him up.
And he asked his ta asking him, his hobbies, one after the other. And Matawan had appointed somebody behind the curtain to write down everything, whatever hoorah said write down all those hobbies. Well, I did a sunny Hala fossa de mer marijuana married me to sit behind behind the bed behind or behind the throne somewhere where a Buddha cannot see me. Were unacceptable. And I am writing until I wrote all these are these
Hata is the holy the RB for aka hijaab Vijay is Alou on GitHub, after one year, again, Marwan cola Herrera and made me to sit behind the curtain and kept asking him the same Hadith from the same order. asking Allah for masa wala Napa nabasa wala Padma Wada
he did not add anything that an increase Did not you know, miss anything, did not make anything you know, changing the order. Ever. Same order. Mo the heavyset haka folly Yep.
This how the memory should be
michelada nurse that I will walk away with our Buddha. He came to his farm. People ask him nereda Hadith. He said I don't have my notebooks. I came from Baghdad to serve for my family business. I don't have my books with me. How can I teach you? I don't have my books. I just compare a big family gift for a family business. You know, it is not a book massive mistake say we are sending his books ramboda we have got his books compared those Hadees that he wrote he interviewed
and they found somebody who can take all the muscle Sarah who doubt to bow to his forehand in 17 hours. Two people came then to compare the his dictation our his book compared fucka Tony fee says that they are hardy they found me that I did mistakes in 600 how many only six minahasa lotto ha ha ha come after this theory mistakes were not mine. He wrote in my teachers to I just you know said what I have learned in the last two or
three were my mistakes 30,000 or this one literary mistakes are actually more than that. Is that somebody in the rear say that in his or somebody said is Hakuna sakurako that Amina shabby said I never wrote down any of these things. I learned everything from memory never wrote down mercato soudha Fie bear that. I never wrote a black thing in the white music. I never wrote in here. This
is hard said to the person. Are you surprised? He said yeah, you know if somebody does not write and you can know they will be by heart. I'm sorry, sir by is a hardened diversity. You're talking to someone who know the 70,000 Hadees IDF is reading from the book.
73rd not 30,000 70,000 This is a fifth reading from a book
People mentioned to a Buhari this matter. Go Horace, are you surprised?
Perhaps in this world there is somebody who knows his 200,000 holidays, I this is waiting for the book, meaning himself.
And he's not like me, you can see from his books he knows that is by heart. I'm just telling you some of these things. But I want to make it very clear to you science of Hadith is not that you've sent in front of the computer and try something that Google and you get an answer in, they would have just read, you know, that he knows that he could have made a group of the dis 24 you know, topic expert of the RDC in Saudi Arabia, and including my room as well.
So there was somebody quoting Hades from a narrator from the book to I just read a question that does not attack this I can tell you the this basically was the coating that I drew when I saw
that when I was young boy, I used to come with mice. My father asked what do I say a lot. And I was young boy, I used to intake to the house. And literally forever. One day I became adult, I will allow my become adult to I call from the behind the curtain. Oh man woman in Omaha believers, what makes a Muslim obligatory, my usual Muslim.
Now she knows that this boy until yesterday was coming into my house and now suddenly he has he taught me from the cartel. She knows what she said, Allah Allah, the higher loca, minute person, you have done that as well. It means you became adult. There, she answered the question. So what happened? These people are, they're quoting the Hadees and they wrote the name Abdul Malik in US word for Allah.
To I wrote my comment I said, Can you check please it Abdul Malik Nevada Adorama. Allah said, they wrote in there, look at the I Sharmila this matava this print version, our Abdulmalik this all over America circle Can you check this then they kept checking until they found the orange yellow one
too Then the second mistake is very, very old. It many many people always have been doing the bright automatic muscle w Harper era Do you think really that you know you get computer you get the knowledge, how many mistakes are there people have no idea really this knowledge is not by your computer, it is really your meaning it there are no machine in the world, which can be substitute for the human mind. human mind is amazing. A unique you never can make a machine which can take the place of human mind. Machine cannot do this. Whatever you spend money whatever you do, how directly a machine can be helpful to you. But machine cannot take your place. If you rely on the machine, you
will really do sometimes silly mistakes. And those who don't realize the machine, they will know this thing. So that keep in mind Don't think that you know you have got everything your library not like your knowledge is what is with you in your mind that I used to say that your knowledge the one which goes with you in the bathroom. In America, ma Harlem aka Alabama. Your knowledge is the one which in touch with you in the bathroom. Tell me what goes in the bathroom, your library, your computer, your mind, to what you take in the bathroom that what your knowledge is. If you cannot take your knowledge to the bathroom, it's not your money.
So this is in the future. I wanted to make one thing also is it asked question. In all deck we have been studying the hardest, you know, people's biographies so much. One thing what makes them a really amazing question. out of it, they ask questions discuss debate, asked question in revising, memorizing learning. That was this really should be there. Somehow it is missing really from our learning circuit. People don't ask question. I'll tell you two things. What are your sources for answers first, Alou Hara Vickery in quantum law, if you don't know then ask those who knew simple matter first or who had a theory in quantum law.
The professor Lacan said in math she found
the cure of ignorance he asked the question if you don't know then asked her this to karate.
So Risa the great amount actually among the nobody more knowledgeable than sorry
sorry, said Lily elimite has you know, tough to her Allah masala nada has got many many treasures will ask the question then you open it when a Teacher Teacher He teaches something we don't notice everything but when you ask a question that he says many more things that he did not teach you to ask the question actually make the teacher to open all the treasures for you to he said Little wailing because you know that the hula Allah masala nada has got treasures, which are opened by asking the question
Ibrahim this acid to me
The family of origin that have been
in operation many, many people, like you know, Alka Siddiq from birth time in his time
to his, you know, two people after a medical one is one who's over, but it's over at the people from whom is also the mother of the process the army know, I'm an extra busara to form bonds or are among the, you know, companions who are xiaohua among them to computer friends.
And solid middle class both are from busara from same same family to you don't find like that in any family, two people from the same family. They're from I shall wash Southern in the US and drop me off at night in the birth family that remained for a very long time. As our sons Dennis grandsons, all of the big people in the Hadith in the niskanen one of them with even heat in the south.
Even I was acid, I said to my father sat in Ibrahim
Bhima fakuma sorry, how's the hurry excelled? So much has already left you behind? Do you see why he asked me like that because
saw the layers of saying that you are from the same family. But what happened there so he excelled and he left you behind and you did not do this either well as Laurie did,
Melissa Minsu The reason is because he used to come to the classroom, in the front sitting different not in the two fasting zone he used to sit in the front of the classroom. First thing is to do what it means not from the behind already in the front for that is to do Wallah up the middle is a shop in Lhasa Allah when the teacher has gone then what he will do is it will not need the classroom. Then he will go to every gentleman the classroom and discuss with him every young man Wanaka Hernan Illa Salah who, then every car, everybody who's old little like 4050 year old he will go to the car and ask him
well fatten ilus sarlo are no 18 is a teenager, but sorry, we'll ask him teenagers
then he will not miss the women what will happen to my dad? I mean, do you answer? Follow up charbon illa Salah who didn't even come to the house of Medina and didn't ask every young man
walk in Lhasa and a very old man wanna fatten and every teenager when I use on a very old women, he asked in Lhasa, Wanaka Latin and middle aged women, Latino 4050 what you have ADA, Rob Bertie, the hija until sorry, will make effort to meet those young girls who are kept in the houses before the marriage. Two people are not allowed to see them God will make it hard to see them as we'll discuss with them. The thing that the House of reason, now people get fatter, you cannot talk with the women. And now sorry, the mom of the mouse teacher of honey for teacher America. He not only in medicine, in the women who are Jews of color, he even goes to Roberto Hara battle Muse inside the
house, they used to make another you know, hiding room where the girls are kept to people will come to the house they can't see them. Sorry, used to go there, behind the curtains, and with those girls and discuss with them about this matter. This The reason how sorry, Excel, everybody, that it will tell you really how much knowledge what in DOS time among the men and women both, that somebody who is really on the level of sorry, he feels the need to learn from everybody. And that was the ordinary Saudis for so many women, because he learned from them to read something among his teachers, or many, many women and that not related to him, you know, not that they are from his
family or that his aunt, your dad, he's mad. No, they are different from different types, no relation between them, but he kept learning from them.
Another thing really is before starting with that, when you learn from your teacher, it's not really you learn a book, that uplift people have been you know, in many, many traditions, people keep doing this mistakes that are collected when I taught this one said to somebody, you know, came on my question that we come to learn from you know, whatever, and you got outside the book to pick up wrong either you think you're coming to learn the book? No Really what to take from your teacher that you need to know understand, you take from your teacher, the attitude of mind, that what you need to learn this to really teach attitude of mind, how to think, how to understand that what to do
really, Mr. President Muhammad did not learn how to follow what they learned from hanifa the attitude of the mind, how Abu hanifa the mind works, how we raise question how we think
That what actually have been our discipline in the past and that actually now kept it in major industries of West in Oxford, Oxford and Cambridge in the books that is towards consult there, it though the books are available in the market, any mystical, but why these industries are so different? Tell me really do they have access to some books which other users cannot have it the same books, the reason is the teachers who teach them that focus on in retransmitting, this articulate the mind they make effort to teach people this attitude of mind that what they love that what they call itself otherwise the curriculum is stale, anybody can teach the same thing.
But why cannot copy industry of Oxford? Tell me the reason is because you are thinking University of Oxford means really these books are these writing, it does not mean it means the human being there, it means those teachers, those tradition, a tradition is to basically this attitude of mind that, why nobody can be likable, honey, honey fun letter from those people who taught him the attitude of mind, the train his mind, that made him to think that what you actually should take from a teacher, this thinking, this attitude, that how to make question How to invent I read the same thing, why this question cannot come to mind why my teacher couldn't raise this question. When I was doing
this? I did not have this question. When I'm going to teach this book,
you will see, I will read many questions, it could be possible that they never come to your mind. Then think really wide hyperlink that I read, I read the same text, but I don't read the same question mitogen that what you need to look at? Then your mind will find the answer. If you learn from me what I'm saying, but you don't read my mind. You're not going to learn much. You need you need to make effort to learn my mind that how my mind working if criminal run sometime. But you need to learn that why? why these questions come? Why teacher emphasize on something which many people don't emphasize why this is so important? Is it clear to everybody to this one thing you need to
learn this take this attitude of the mind that what body become excellent, that's what the Muslim is excellent, inadequate, they have access to some knowledge which other people don't have the same knowledge in the same class everybody come, but some people are exposed to people or not, because some people take books, some people take something else.
So this is one thing, you know, focus on that inshallah.
One thing it Also, I'd like to emphasize before starting real easy, this analogy that we are going to be teaching we have not really, you know, the people who are expert at this knowledge, they have got two amazing qualities, to amazing quality. One quality is the
fear of Allah, pious people for a fasting, in remembrance of Allah, fear of the Day of Judgment, the people of Allah, they don't feel anything else that were Second thing, you know, about the technology with accuracy, and the transmitted accuracy, understanding and thinking, the daughter miss anything, that when these two things come really the knowledge because it's amazing, then you can take knowledge from that person that Allah adopted, that what actually makes soufiane photoscan 30. That what makes Abu hanifa hanifa that what makes a Malik no as of yanaka and right in Assad and her mother said Buhari and Muslim all these people combination, these two things that over and above
that what you need train, this is something you cannot inherit
it had not that you know you studied in Durban, you get that over and over and Dr. Song something you need to make effort to get it.
You cannot inherit from a school from a madrasa from your father from nobody it is you have had to develop. Nobody else if you develop more than your teacher, you Excel or your teacher, simple matter. These two things are qualities they have read by you for yourself. Nobody can do it. You have to do nobody else men have to do for themselves and women apart from the nobody else can.
In the asuna Hadeeth book,
Mr. Hart book, whatever you're going to learn, try to understand what they really are that what if mine is very clear, it's very easy to discuss. There are two things really one of the hardest and what is also the hardest what I immediately had this meaning that TCS or the professor larussa whatever he said, Whatever he did, in all those things are heavy. Heavy Hadith is a divine, what is it for you to know that from from Allah, I cannot I cannot say I cannot make her this. You know, this is not made by anybody here actually is revelation. It comes from Allah to my to the Prophet Muhammad. Allah has this divine nobody can make her do her this but authenticating the holidays, to
save her This is sound or not sound, it to the human knowledge, it is not divine. The human experience when is
This is not divine, it's not a revelation, it is basically human action human experience human work the process of certain things, it is science basically in order to say aha This is in Asahi it is science
means meaning it it is something which can we explain to the people to when I said to you this or this sorry, it is not a secret not a mystery, I can explain to you what is you can learn it and I can explain to you and then you can teach your students
to to say her This is not a mystery, it is not a secret it is not a Sufi knowledge was so, few people say to only go from just to just to to not like that, it is basically something open for anybody even Muslims, non Muslims they want to learn they can come along anybody can learn basically purely human knowledge anybody can learn you know can come
when you learn this one look for the single thing really why these things are important to learn about how this or why they made these rules their human being like me, what may cause them to discuss these points, when you think like that, you will learn more really that why that warrior question really for Apple when you study the definition of sahadi then you should question really every part of the definition why they made this condition what made them to do things like that what and then similarly is a really complete definition or I can add something more than that oh I can beside them that definition that they are making with not proper is actually misses many things
that house should learn at all where the Lord really what the present what the teach you learn to you know what the T the next question should be why the teacher like that.
Then next question should be is that something is really the mist which I can add, I can learn from my own society and I can add to them
this will actually increase your knowledge and very often it will make you to have full trust in these people then you can think really it is really so amazing. What they do really we are unable to do identity. I remember really once I taught that this whole text no flicker in indoor Institute in Oxford
and when I came to one of the professor who was presenting me he said in the history of a retail Institute it the first time a Muslim is teaching also had this it never happened
in seven weeks because they are not not most of them that was the first thing I said to them into learning that what we believe in Hades in Divine
but we don't believe that these are divine
but what I'm asking you people first and directly what we have what we have developed a lot of promise then after that if you can teach us that you can prove it we have no problem we can learn from you but first try to understand what it is
so then we can very happy so no love definitely no doubt we are not agree against anybody to meet a human knowledge in a non Muslim Okay, if you can make contributions we don't mind but first not really what we have done so far you've never done what you have done and then you keep criticizing is not right to first try to understand what we have done and no not really it is really amazing thing what muscles have done. But we Moses, you know don't don't understand them.
Okay, now understand the starting the text.
Okay, Bismillah R Rahman you know, the thing really? Have you got these notes or not these you got the notes. Okay, that's good to either mentioned in these notes, though, there are points which about which side it also has
been but I did not refer every single point that i i don't agree with because it is too much. Right now under company under a book like that. It's too many. But while I teaching, I will keep them to those points.
So Bismillah R Rahman r Rahim was Allah Allah says Dinamo Ramadan, were early he was a hobbyist person, let's say Allah, or rockler to rohilla to whom you people try to
do to travel or refer are the one to one people come and play with Dr. shefali, salaam, Allahu Allah Shahabuddin to she have the title in the letter centuries, you know, after the fourth centuries after that, a tradition has become any sort of developer that very often big people, O'Meara, Maru Holika and also all ama, they have the tightest with deal the what the election, so Dean, Shahabuddin Salahuddin many many Dean so that you can see him head on he has got title up Shahabuddin. And some high junk somehow generally, is somebody named Ahmed. His title which has to do
if the name is Muhammad, Titan shamsudeen. Somebody stuttering easily easily can actually work out not always like that, but generally is that how they do
Other people have named their title Shahabuddin people with the name Muhammad, the title be shamsudeen or something like that is God our Father is punia ohana who Allah given him or her mother in law scholar
he's not only from Egypt it from us alone. But if every move Asha hero given to somebody in the family, you know, we've got title to he got in Ohio, I shall tell you this man really came from nowhere. He's not a man in his family in science of how this has been some time you find actually, somebody is big, big because his father or great grandfather, somebody has been very big in harassment and he actually is the one from nowhere. And let's just admit a person from nowhere no background really of family that scholarship nothing really, it just seems. And then after that, also family do not keep the tradition very highly anyway, to his unique in the whole family. So in
his mercy of Allah subhanaw taala being a chef are you for Salah if you would 30 meaning it when he when he wrote down? The students are copying he is still alive? to deliver the safest laugh he would that he may Allah make him to live longer to see do I not irrational faster Hello, daddy. What are the other Muslim Amina min Baraka t to this is sir, by the student. Now coming What in hailakandi? said the hamdulillah he lady lamb yes Allah Allah man. pudieron Hi, john, a human Semyon basura
the one of the problem has been in Islam really easy since then for one soft cannon and especially is actually our motto at school, you know, in JAMA, they have developed this idea, there are some some attributes of Allah, they are eternal. other attributes, they are not like that, to aimag them actually people make seem
you know what they say that they are seven or higher element
to the da
da da da virada summer basler and Alcala and FC moto do people make eight high art udara ilam iraida some bizarre color and color
and other attributes of Allah they make Davi to these eight of seven they accept as they are and other than this influence actually even because so deep that when they praise Allah, they bring those two they can see interest in this The 100 is basically in a reflection of, you know, Ashley school offer about attributes of Allah subhanaw taala
why shadow light? I don't know.
that was an Allah Allah says now Muhammad in under the other Salah nassetta fatten bashira Juana de la vida Ali Muhammad, wa sahbihi wa seldom at the Sleeman kathira Ahmad, find natesan eva da Heidi, by the cathode multifeed pardini. Well, Hadith books are written about the stellar heart of the Hadith, there are many, many,
despite the heart of the word, it's like a define for you. So you can see very clearly this fella basically either that when people agree after 10 tradition, you know our discipline on a meaning of the word, which is not common, but they just in their discipline their car, in the restaurant, to like for example, in the novel, you read it, you know, many other people have not I will say marfo
to tell the meaning, but people have heard it also smartphone, it the same meaning no different meaning marfo in inaho has another meaning when you say barabas and Amara is that is not for buffoon, the Hardy center, I think, Murphy the heydays of he actually had this other person or supporters who listen
to you can say same words, but two different disciplines, two different meanings. So that what is the law means really, two people have logic they're only solahart people have either only solahart people or the fact that they have their own Easter people have you know, every discipline, people who don't know this that are hard, sometimes they can be can be confusing, you will think it is actually high the dictionary meaning if they don't use a dictionary meaning they use for something like you know, like if you when you study in the industry or see if you study physics, or you know math or something like that, you can see the same English words, but different meanings, because
they are developed their own terminologies and they use them to it will become easier for everybody.
If people have the hardest they have got so there is a heart
in this heart What is telling me you still really does something used by the military discipline. That's what he means, when he read in the novel marfo
to this and you know what it means that it is a word which is used by by law grammar.
They use what refer and Murphy all the time, not when when Sue. When you read Logie, you actually find all the time they use the word, they use the word PR, they will work the law, the law, the law after the law is me so many, so many words they keep using. So you should know what they mean. If you don't know what the meaning is, you will misunderstand, it will not help you to simple matter.
Same thing we should expect really, in this Knowledge Center we should fit the solar cell. But that is not the case.
In a solar factory, you will learn many many terminologies which had not been used by FOCA
it has been borrowed from somewhere else. How can we muster hot official data from sources from servers?
in doubt, Mr. hottap heavy you will read many meanings to the heart they say to Mr. llahi. At actually the name of the book is admission here anyway. Loser to Nava fito de nous battle Faker. fie masahito
Allah, Allah teach music is something used by Allah third period, the Hadith.
But this is not the case. He will find in this book and I'll point that anywhere and I'll measure some of those points in my notes. There are many things that they mentioned the musala which never has been used by people have had the Buhari Muslim or Buddha Medina saved a merger before that.
I didn't madine or the expert of this thing never use those technologies to then question will be how can they come with it It never has been used by those pool how it has become where they come from. There's a problem they borrow the words from somewhere else which had nothing to do that is
in unnecessary you are burdening the people when you teach
this, it should be one letus which are concerned to like now, I find this materially that in most accurate and accurate people are appeared as they don't discuss entitled really they discuss their own terminologies. Simple matter. Palomar Kala ino is filled her Rafa rabina Rafa nasbite, Jr. Ordered much more sorry for verbal sorry, you know, whatever they have the disk, there are nothing to do with the hobbyists or nothing, they don't borrow money, they just discuss their own terminology. They are more accurate, more consistent than anybody else. But this is not the case in the hobby, that what we should expect to you should be like, this is not the case. It is one thing.
I will keep recycling in here as Kalani very heavily under criticism and not only against him actually against even people other than him because he's not only doing this, there are many people doing the same thing. Today actually introduce into sort of this many of those terms, which have nothing to do with her this, nothing to do that. But that is unnecessary introduce.
Okay, now he's going to mention who are the first people
okay to now think? No, maybe it is helpful to go through this. The, you know, the criticism that I made in our guest the book is basically you can say four things. In summary, I've decided not to check out Mr. Miller in four points in some summary. The first one is that he has followed or not the manager Alamosa 3 million monthly unicorny fitori What does he feel ANOVA p katagiri milma model. The first micro SIM is in the winning mahasamadhi Rahim Allah tala, he defines certain terms or when he makes classification, classifies it many many things that he follows the way people have logic,
not the karate. So, this one person basically is influenced by the methodology of the people of logic in definition and also in classification of the knowledge first, first major commit. Second one is that he had introduced a Thani and other philosophy A year later, Allah Batalla de Mistura ha ha D
had introduced in the book, some of those things which have no relation to the terms of people of Hades another.
The third point is
that he has
defined some terminology
in a way, which is not not, you know, different from what people have heard is really not the same thing. Meaning defined differently from the peep from them. So that's very misleading to you read a definition, which is not actually people don't have their definition. The fourth one is, he actually had also assumed assumption, you know, he assumed at a certain age
No rulings about certain terms in
your raga min tuna yet yellow heavy but the Li automated there are no evidence or no method, no example. So these are the four, you know comments, which I've summarized now the details were coming.
So one of the things that I have criticized him is basically after these two pages
you know, what you read here at persone focus de la Hadi did not come into his farming outlet him and his son naffaa Allah Allah, the Abu Mohammed or Rama who mosey fakie Tabitha Mossad de Philip Mohammed Al fastly
Abu Mohammed Rama, Rama Hormuz he died in the year 360 360 you can see Buhari died in the year 256
Muslim died in the year 261 This man is nearly 100 year after these big people
don't fit under 60 he wrote his book or the Mohammed Death to the fasten by now Ravi Wallah Why are you
here he is among the first people microsystem here actually is that in Alaska Ronnie, since he's writing this book for the students, he should actually start from something earlier. Other people will think really why it took so much such a long time to have their own terminology does not happen. People that know how they're so early, you know, the first major work of the Nazi Kitab was written down in the second century you know, 200 years before so just think it didn't really amazing the major science you know, so Sula written 200 years after after now,
it does look very
rightly a noticing those people he should start from something earlier, too that I mentioned here actually is it that Karna young Bella who and you hear Ala Moana Saba who memento had data on masala Hata helfen kalila Shafi shuffle easy a few rissalah tea were mostly female Kadima tea, what do you want me to really feel either Li You know, people like that, and also many others, I mentioned that some beginners these to our sub discusses to the artisan taboos, you should actually mention their names to people can take back the history even earlier. You know, jmeter many, many points actually love Shall we discuss so nicely in a rusada you should actually mentioned that.
What ashara Delica philomathean was it Mr. Snyder written his book on a madman about his teachers what he read with them? They are he has pointed out to this this point there he mentioned a little bit not in detail when it writes biography of his teacher, elbow rowhani but I'm at the newsy where he said para la almohad different facet. This book I read to my teacher, and principal how bollocky tabin suneetha aluma de Fiala one first the book written in rival one, wine acana yuja de Pablo, who was old enough to move further, I mean, for me, was akin to her the ajumma omaggio Miyagi Delica fisherman, before that, there have been many many books that they have something here in Delhi, but
this is more comprehensive, that what he he said to my thinking really easy that that should be mentioned in this book, too, because otherwise what happens is, many people read nobody did the only book they read Russell Hades originally made their mind faster to start a run then never come to their mind to know really, what Mr. Shafi had done, what Muslim did what Timothy have written. So nice discussion, you can learn so much from him is one thing. Second thing actually, he said Larkin who learn just
but he did not comprehend. Rama Mozi is Booker he did not write everything. He write something let me start with this again really is a mistake by myself. Funny. I don't agree with that. Paul told our family this is not right. Leanna Rama Hormuz He loves you and lift kita who filled the moose para hidden Hi, Bob Mustapha, this first learner What is his objective? There you tell about him. He never saw them. He said I'm writing a book on Mr. Latta, this then you can criticize him Okay, you're writing on that but you cannot comprehend it. But he never said this. In
the first level, Ravi will why he will leave us to write our one point. What a difference between the people who narrate Hades and the people who received the Hadees what's different between these two people? The one risk and then hope preserves. What difference between them in that what is right? In that point, if you look really one Li You know the list after the titles are subject to discuss, comprehensive he did not miss anything on his topic. His top basic subject is on the Fossella better, right why you
In that matter the book is complete. Nothing missing. You don't read really what his purpose of the book is now comparing his book with your own book and you see comprehensive now right? He never claimed to write
in your content writer, Mr. Hardy, he won't leave it rissalah on his more point on the first binder Ravi worldwide and in the macadam I mentioned for this for this point, and then after that he gives example for that,
then I committed for kita
gandolfi Moto E, the book is complete in subject matter, nothing missing. We're in Niger and a lot in Allah, Amina de la Jackie de la Latina Danica,
important, you know, Naveen are in discussion you can see Tyler the heavy yo kita mahad within a fast battle. Ma wa sallahu Nikita how nice it is.
Because the hobbit not looking at the book
is rooted in a kind of subject he's a master I mean, how good it is book. And then he said in a cell Ophelia nasality when it when you take knowledge from the computer that will do actually not only that I've still really some people they read the book. And when they write his name, they put Fatah they because Salafi, he had not selfie, you know it This word is not in Arabic anyway, this word is Persian word. This word is a selfie. What what? selfie selfie? combination of two words said military on it lip love. You know love is the lip in English, meaning it was assessed on its ancestor. He's the one with Qatar to become like three lips. Two people call him the man of the
three lifts and Celebi in Persian became Salafi to his name is Salafi means the one whose ancestral head three lips is a collector very very the door do dismiss stick to it is a big big man of his hobby very big man very famous in his time many many books is one other person who is not a very one of the highest in the world in many meetings you find his name Indian Lee in many many collects all the time keep coming but the problem is people don't know to some people read his name. I selfie big people actually somebody who has written a book big famous name and he can put Hanukkah selfie. So you think you got the title selfie so early in Islam theories call this a selfie? No, it'll just
sell a few to nothing to do something selfie.
The selfie? You know, he used to call Elia God your father kokumo he used to always give this book in his sleep got that how they used to because they used to make big they always putting their Jani FIBA ohmori in America Jenga maybe to hit that how I used to do it everybody so this competitor is not I did not like
now it's coming to another thing
there is a one hakima block the line nicer Budi Harkin died in the air for under five lakh in the hood and while I'm your hockey mutanda four and five he wrote the book ma refer to Illuminati in holliston invest to comment on that one Islam you have the N one Islam you're a lamb you have the Miss did not refine it, meaning it did not edit properly to the tune or to improve it Lamoureux did not put in the right order.
You read this book and you become your mind really, you know, this is not this is not the case. This is actually the case exactly opposite of that the book is very much refined and the book be the properly order and have written here if you like really, I put all the you know disk chapters of the book in order in the book, you can see how nicely done and how all the order is so nicely done.
Then to figure out how to have such a bigger man he can do this mistake why he said lacking
in this question then has big man the problem is because the word means order to their mind in order of the later people. When logic because deep in the mind, you have got a certain idea of what order means. You are not looking at the order from the angle of those early people what what order to them really what are the most important to discuss first. The very nice actually order if you really and maybe I said to order that why America but
poor pulled to
my camera some time will be harsh reason is because mistake is that I may come across like that a cattle mistake or two ma baldness.
How far is this word from being true? Rama, Rama hirakata and how cool is to be mistake to a to a mistake on my
Yeah pathoma told Melissa Mahabharata
final kita kita hockin vine Idina, the book in front of us.
Whoa, I mean Asana COVID hockey. It is actually one of the best book of hockey will ever die. And very amazing.
Santa Ana drama It is very nicely. However keytab in a car million film or two in this subject in this is the most profitable work in the field, right it's very well defined. Well morata Boone arvato team nice nicely order. While then I commented what occurs
in the center it removes data in the desk has become corrupted because of the logic and philosophy from yesterday for anastasiou na alum Madhava who word does not fit in there? test. The dog did not like it. While this Sedona saw her for a while. What was cool he was having that same story every year. In the novel in the surf in the fifth in those every year. The order of the photos is basically different. Look at the photos by calama loogy.
not heard this but at least is a man who knows the history he knows how to order. He's not influenced by this new area. He actually when he when he writes about this book of hockey, what he said work at Oliver Nassif your alumina Hadeeth walk through woman for Julio Allah He was I met him Abdullah Al Hakim, what are the foofy Hama Shu Ratan Verhoeven la de has ever who will ahaha You see, he is the one who refined it he says
is that what you know? set by Alterna Khaldoon less than the sun what Aquino Raja Mojave rhetorically Oh
la la Liberace hodel Jerry mean to people should not actually criticize me that why I'm referring to in regard to my my reasoning here so people should not accuse me unnecessarily
okay now coming
after I'm not going to read everything detail otherwise because so much time what allow anonymous bihani for America taboo Mustafa region farmina Allah kitabi Mustafa, Mustafa Mustafa, Rajan Abkhazia and I'm talking about Hamas for honey came on he wrote Mustafa
Mustafa basically means that some time if somebody writes a book to you, right, you take the same book, but you bring your own is an odd is to laugh at Apple. People wrote a mustache on sahadi like a smiley, to say hello, Bahari, but a smiley bring the same. This is not some comments as well. People wrote in massagin answer a Muslim who does not bring his own musala he brought his book of happy but he bring out those stories and how this forum is only set out to become like his order book. But actually the order and every information is originally from Al Hakim.
And he left many people found that those who come
by still after the book is very very important.
So my job Adam
Abubakar body, he died in the 463 He is the my really no route, hottie body came, then the science of how these include not actually in development, but in writing, whatever what you know, not compiled properly, he put everything in the writing every single branch of this discipline he put into writing before that things were scattered everywhere. they existed, were scattered. He is the man who put them all night them in every single topic record of traveling the hobby, he wrote a book
you know, dictating hobbies, every single point that you can mention about hobbies. You can find hottie had a book on that. He wrote a book on every topic of the Hadith of the Hadees
for son never feel alone in other a wire kita Bursa Mulkey fire, Eduardo Sula, Dc roadbook Alka fire, very famous printed. Then he wrote a book about the minors of learning and teaching her this and that is a journal that we share was actually the book is printed with the name of john Leon after Ravi was someone
that I applaud the book actually some part of it. Some people
walk on the moon misophonia, Hadith, Illa, Robinson, efia, Kitab and Radha, every single branch of the Hadith he wrote a book sakana cannot ALLAH hafiz Abu Bakr, Al Baghdadi koloman and Safa alima unelma Hadith in another capacity,
Allah ko to be anybody whose fear he will add
We acknowledge that mohabbatein they depend on the books of hottie verbal body and he's a true that no doubt about that really every buddy depends on his book
so much about the matassa T for a sudden the harder it may be. The other thing is now we've had this money because he wants to mention in every generation even in this one is not related but I do not recycle every single points. Then he said for Jamal Peterman Latif and some mouth his mouth he will I will have Allah Allah my energy juicer and somehow just answer Mao mala yes almohad defied Yahoo myanna de houttuynia 583 he wrote is more juicy is here ma so almohad data jello stinks. Which mahad this is not allowed to not know it, he must know it. To my teacher, Buddha used to say the boss has been known Maya solimo had this idea Hello, what ma this should not know that nothing really in the
book was what they should know. You know how these are fabricated many problems interpreting it should not be mentioned in this whole thing. The only reason has lies in mentioning Okay, you want to fill the gap. Have nothing to do with that nobody's interested in learning that you don't get any knowledge or that they don't want my teacher has written a book name should be my sl almohad this
is something you can afford not to me. If you don't know it, nothing will happen to you.
While methodic Matheson de politische taharah verbose laferrari wakasa faha erangel half alpha p that you Dean abubakr osmanthus sada Adra
Adorama ashara zuhdi that I think will there have been many many until this might cut this mine is a turning point in the history of a sort of a D in musala. Either off the table that you can see turning points or hockey, hockey with one turning point. The next one is hottie body. Then the third one is this man musala who died in their season 43 zero they must be he was from you know
of Kurdistan Shara zoo, and then he came in Syria and settled there in the West and he taught there for Jama lama boulia that there is a hadith below mother Salah shall fija Kitab Masha moto Sasha is the major center for this in in Damascus and I came there are other books on that as well. Very very big he was he was there for her the raffle you know what I'm allowed to say? And by the end he refined this fund meaning it he took everything from all those books, books off the table daddy and it's an all nighter properly this book now.
It put it there.
There is a further hurdle um, yeah.
Although the more the ultimate Nassim because he dictated in long period because when he started the dictation of the book, it started on a Friday 17th of Ramadan 630
we started and he kept doing this until I finished on a Friday last day of the year 634 to basically it took him three years, four months and 13 days
you can see if somebody dictates that you know so long to their country but still really I don't think it is so fair to say that no not very good. Not really you can see that Turkey is dead. They taught it to I don't think you know it is so fair to say like that very well. What better sunny for the hotter even for Raka for Gemma Asha Tata mapa ma ma ma la homina. Very nakaba first time aFy kitabi mata Farah fury now in his book, whatever is cutter somewhere else, all we come together
for the Harada aka Fernando la dat why everybody base it tough to read this book. We're sorry, Desiree fala yassa comm now let me let Mr. McNally on one more argument. So how many people have written about that you cannot you know, our share of photography was mentioned in the demand for author there are 33 books written around mocha risala 33 books that after that everybody basically just depends on mocha masala everybody. Now we can summarize it anybody cuz basically the dependency on mocha musala. That that way in a green field at least I'll tell you after reading this,
Mr. Miller, then after that, you should read Nakamura salah and you will see the right compare I will consider that how knowledge there. Then after that you read books available Daddy, then come to the book of Madiba told him The Hobbit and other books, then you will know something. Additionally, if you just rely on this book, you basically will have misunderstanding and many many problems of your knowledge. This book is just an introduction
just beginning to you know, don't take lightly what is something more common anyway this What happened then somebody off is a student of Eros banani He is zurka she or somebody else maybe he asked him to summarize Salah. So, then he summarized it in this few pages of Navy news bottle flicker, free Mustafa some people read the water flicker, this mistake is not a secret word flicker gymnastic rotten
immune is a selection of thoughts and ideas is selected from many many thoughts and ideas and you can see outline number two speaker fee must try
to figure the figure you cannot run to figure two if not figure two that should correctly the other I got like this. will this happen for another period Denali? Do you go to Harlem and you should not say no particular you should say
no now the same to tie for the broker to stop it here.
And certainly a literal with fast dog we have to discuss something more detail Kadena main at this point, if you learn from me nicely to install, what happened militarily is up to you then you can do yourself too. I'm not going to teach every point in such a detail, but some points I will emphasize because they will be helped with the help they help you to understand the signs inshallah. Now if you have any question about what I've been saying, please ask
questions. Yeah, favorite question.
To ask question, I mentioned this he has already well, he will discuss outdoor shy because now if you ask that you can do you understand a teacher? Even if question is very silly. No question is silly. Because it is going to help you to knowledge that anything can help you not silly, people can laugh, that is good. Actually, you get rewarded. You you learn and then you get people to laugh at the very mechanism to become hyper, you get the word for that, that don't worry, people laugh as your question. Nothing happened.
I was just wondering that we see in his terminology of Hadeeth, for example, Aziz and so on and so forth, that he uses it differently to previous scholars.
Was that new from that era? Or is that something that he invented? You know, is it something he invented? or? Yeah, exactly. When I will come to all his plans after you know, motiva Matura zz, or the three I'm going to precise anyway. So to the commercial that what the what the problem is.
Now I can show
you know, you mentioned like the, the strong memory of the magazine of the past and many of the scholars, we don't probably find this to be the case today. What kind of advice do you have for students to increase their memory you know, people ask the Buhari, how people can have good memory with a pencil he said if you can assert, you know, in the past when you did not have enough time in all these to the navigator and you to travel, how do you narrowed your concern your concern if you don't know you will miss to you go once a second time, then you know, by heart now really, all those places where I've been traveling before the TomTom, now I know them by heart. But after this, I
start relying, I don't know anything. Every time I have to rely on that. Basically, what happened to was uh, you know, if you can assert if you miss you miss knowledge, then you will think the boy has cancer. penicillin is very, very important, no doubt, really, and not have too much worry. Too much worries in the life. There's a problem, make your worries the life as small as possible. And then after that, devote, and Atkinson think, really, if I don't let all sort of have this, how can I know anything, then no. concern, think and study and go deeper, and how it's possible that these people can teach and I can even not know it will help. And a few people have been actually I've seen among
my teachers, those who did this deliberately. No one asked my teacher he said once in the classroom, that any of you read any first part of any project was in Urdu, Arabic or Persian. I will complete the whole the whole was under 50 students in the classroom with the study and he was right. Whatever we read, he knew by heart
what's the one of my classmates in he knew so much we'll do poetry once is when we once we asked him how much you know about in the lover. What love mentioned in property, how many for divorce, you know? And then it started really not stopping going on one after the other and metaphors, but you can some people know distance so much. It's another meaningless concern if you can, you can
show just a question.
On today's format How will you be teaching because um for those of us who might be struggling with how you what we've had up to now will you be like section by section going to your notes well as we go through know how to figure or because I've seen you've sectioned off according to the chapters of North Dakota so we'll be talking about North Myrtle second and then go into your notes or will you be going there when you go what happens you know I'm teaching a guy to order the book to you know go to what happens you get so reading from his inadequacies you know that you have summer for me and I spend those points which are important to love
and also then in my notes where I've commented I returned data but you know, my notes are parents are not on everything. But whatever comments are there I explained them in detail so people can understand, but I'll make effort to finish into this to some to the pension You know, there's so much in this book not everything that I disagree you know, basically 70 80% more than that the same thing that I agree with no problem that anyway so that I'll go some of them are very easy to understand. I I'll teach them quickly some of them the new explanation or example
if possible is a time that I'll do I'll fold out of the book not my own notes. No, I cannot No, sorry about that. Anyway, notes are right to the book.
So could you just repeat the books that we should study after this So you mentioned that first after this we should study maka developments? What do you think and the books that we should study after we complete this text the books that you should read after this one yeah, I said mission you know after this issue
of Abu Salah that are why what I did in the Thrall of Mata IV study this book and then after that the major text of the studies were mocha Dima even Salah
then after that, they don't teach it after that you have to learn from your own effort. So I I studied myself reading many books about it. I also studied alcohol if I'm lucky fire then I also study North Road hockey in the military and we learnt in madrassa
idol after MIDI animoca devout Muslim
and so many possibilities are rissalah. So, these are the things that But anyway, if you want to follow the right way the psalmist says to after this one, you should go to mocha devil Salah. Then go to the Buddha especially as the fire like a fire you important then I just love that Ravi what I was saying then after that read book a fucking ma refer to Omaha D and then after that Nakajima mousseline an idol after with the wrestler Shafi
and then basically after that read warriors McCarthy movie and then you would see how they've used another problem in our times people read one book off the record, and they become sort of ignored. So it's not a not a real, it's not not serious, nobody would come
by reading this text and it was not proper anyway, it is using the text detector introduction to the first thing that you come in the field.
We Okay, this online question as well. Okay. What are the what are some sources of Mostel ahat which are not from people of the science or of Hadith conasauga
what are some sources of mustard? mustard lahat which are not from people of the science of Hadith?
What are the source of what sorts of
what are some of
Maybe I got one question I didn't understand properly.
Okay, so what are some source sources of Mr. lahat of Hadith which are not from people the science of Hades
when I teach it when I come to those points which are not from the picture I'll mention that discuss you know thing really in the knowledge is that don't say anything unless you had the lead even though I'm not going to teach you something wrong. It could be a misunderstanding mistake can happen but this very bad knowledge the record side on is such a big man without any argument to this very, very bad really this not not allowed. No, but nobody will take it serious athletes is it unfair to my own knowledge? So it's not a time deciding for no reason. You know, I'm not good. I don't have any left to criticize anyway. inadvertently, I bought to criticize people. It basically to please
you cut them my way to teach people in the with honesty and fairness as much as possible.
You love really bought way too shallow to come?
It's not like I'm sure
one question I had was if if Muhammad was prone to mistakes in his nose, so, what is the what makes it so good in because he is he not only when people write books, they totally spend time and effort on every single book in the same way that a trough I buy many people. Do you read Biharis? Sahih Bukhari, then you write in, in the bookshop or in mcdouble, every enabled name, you see, like Bukhari
Sahih Bukhari Sahih Bukhari
and Buhari are not the same in that mean to to be like that, no, they are not written in a in such a thinking that mistake the problem again Buhari is in his main work, but
he missed he spent his time all his knowledge in the federal body a diverse he must have done very quickly. He did not write one book.
Do you know many of those to the right so quickly anyway. And it could be also that he is convinced for some reason because that time this how the thing about led to he maybe can use it in the best way. But the federal bar is really a federal body the work where he spent time when he finished the work. He knows that he had done something big. He made a huge party. He spent a lot of money yeah, the walima for federal bar, there was big walima invited all the judges all of my scholars big feast a celebration. He knows that he is amazing. But he's not like that. He's fertile bar is amazing, no doubt. Until now, it is only work really best in the field. nothing compared to that nothing is
equal to that
startling shake. So in terms of the time period between these books and like,
and in terms of like the people who did the ritual, like the hobby and mizzi how are they connected in any way?
In the hobby the teacher or the teachers have lost money. In the last 97 of the major teacher is Allah Buddha, Allah Buddha Han abuse ha era, he Tanase on the body, the blind man he was actually behind. But his big big man he is is to attack him on the hobby.
Similarly, even as my head learn many things from Abu Dhabi, another horizon of the hobby to basically the one generation guy between both of them. Yeah, actually let us know that if Allah can make him like have the hobby in the in the radar, so you can see how the hobby was big in his mind. But certainly I don't think anybody equal to the hub in this matter. The Eros canal is better than anybody else in Cambodia say Buhari, but when it comes to the result, the heavy the tough man, then if we don't really have anybody after the Hubby, who is equal to him, and his father rajala the six books the best person is missing. Even has nothing to do nowhere near to music to misery and the
hobby the two top people in
the region that nobody equal to them. They are the best people. You had a question?
Just one more.
Shaq I had two clarification questions one about the document that is presented. Is this your commentary or your criticism of the actual book or have an existing commentary?
That this this document we're looking at? Is this your notes or your criticism Microsoft is offered this book, which I'm teaching, okay, of the actual book or the commentary on the book? both together anyway, he originally wrote in the water shaker then he wrote commentary and another
Okay, too. I'm teaching both of these words together anyway. Right okay. Second very small anyway, just not detail. You can say commentaries mostly basically on the commentary in my comments are on the commentary, but also maybe on on between the horror book basically concerning commentaries on the dollar. Okay. And just another question you might come to this later on, but you made a comment on the style hazard Hadith and masala had a solid filter and you you made a comment. You said something negative about a metalhead, authorial Hadith that they've come from somewhere that is not really your I Michelle
mode, but in our pseudo pseudo Hadith, there are certain terminologies that they discuss, there are nothing to do with that field. They have been borrowed from somewhere else. They are more actually connector related to Alcala. motek eliminar The one who just could discuss this matter. It is their motto, nothing to do with the sort of Hades but we these plots so much influence
By the Golan they included them also in their books for some reason for some connection, not a you know, without any connection, but it not necessary. It's an unnecessary
thing to add to that I'm going to criticize