Shadee Elmasry – Do Madhabs Contradict Hadith NBF 297
AI: Summary ©
AI: Transcript ©
Bismillah al Rahman al Rahim Al hamdu lillah wa Salatu was Salam
ala Rasulillah while he was happy woman Well welcome everybody to
the Safina society nothing but facts live stream on a snowy.
What is it Tuesday, snowy Tuesday here in the great state of New
Jersey, where we are in the LA Casina soup kitchen building third
floor is where our studio is for nothing but facts. And we're a
mile down from the Robert Wood Johnson University and Medical
Center and Rutgers University. It's it's snowing here and we're
gonna get some more ice snow cold wind. Today probably most likely
canceling all of our evening classes today. Most likely we're
canceling them all today. But let's let's start with
a quick question. What happens when a meth head brewer link seems
to be the exact opposite of a hadith? In other words, I'm a
regular guy. I read a hadith it says
123. The ruling says the exact opposite. The ruling from a
certain school of thought says the exact opposite. What do we do?
Why is that the case? Now let's ask a question could it possibly
be that the Imam knew the ruling and said you know what I'm gonna
go exact opposite of the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa salam now we
know that that's not possible, right?
He wouldn't be an imam acceptable in the community, deemed righteous
etc. If you see, okay, the prophet is going this way. You know what,
I'm gonna go the opposite way. So we know that's not the case.
Right? All right. Could it possibly be that the Imam didn't
know the Hadith? Right? In which case, we should ask the question.
How did you get qualified as an imam? If you didn't know these
Hadith? If it was something so obvious that here we are, you know
much later, it's so obvious to us, then your Imam it should be in
question. Not only are you Mamet. Well, what about all your
followers? Were they just being stubborn? Were all your followers
just saying, you know what our Imam didn't know. But we're going
to cover it up.
And we're going to not admit that. And we're just going to dig our
heels in and contradict the Prophet peace be upon him. Is that
the other option? That's also you wouldn't have a righteous
forebears if death was the case. Our predecessors would not have
been righteous people, then if that's the case, the form the
foundations of the meth hubs, is not one Imam. It's many, many
Imams. It's one Imam and dozens upon dozens of students and
hundreds upon every generation of students. So for us to imagine now
that they dug their heels in to contradict the prophet to support
their Imam who was ignorant. That also causes actually ends up being
an analysis that's a warrant very hard to prove, but be
it kills the whole
history of Islam, like our history of our scholarship was some
stubborn people, if that's the case, ignorant people who dug
their heels in so most likely, the answer is and we can find this in
the literature, the debate literature, scholars have debates
with one another. And there are books that are known as Al
Mottola, which are very long books in which debates take place in
which there these debates
are cited even a book like quotes to be cites the debates he cites
with the back and forth the Shafi essay this the Hanafi said that
thematic he said this chances are the Imam had a stronger evidence.
Okay, a stronger Hadith.
So you may have come upon Hadith Yes, you did come upon a hadith
but you didn't come upon all the Hadith. There's strong Hadith out
there that you don't not aware of. So it's funny that oh my gosh, the
Imam didn't know about the Hadith. Also, look in the mirror, maybe
you also didn't know about some evidences. Right? Why? It seems to
be egotistical for us to come this far down in Islamic history and
say, boom, he didn't know the Hadith. Maybe also you don't know
a lot of things about the evidences that they used. Okay. So
that's one thing. Secondly, could be a Quranic verse and certain
Hadith, and certain scholars differ on whether
certain head deets can provide exceptions to Quranic verses or
not. Alright, let me give you a simple example. The magic is in
the in the Hanafi is, did not hold that a solitary Hadith can provide
an exception
to a Quranic verse. Quranic verses what to watch.
It's more authoritative than one single narration
that does that lacks context and explanation. So what they did for
example, on Joomla when Joomla when eight falls on Joomla what's
the ruling there? The ruling there for the Hanafi is in the magic is
is that you must pray Joomla the Chef Ava, and I don't know about
the Hannah Hannah Bella. But the chef Eva Imam Shafi, he took a
different approach than his previous two teachers. He said No,
even if we have one single narration, we will use that as an
exception for the Quran. So there is a narration in which the
Prophet salallahu alayhi wa sallam told some people that if aid is on
a drummer, they don't have to come back
for Jomo pray the hood in their homes. So what did Abu Hanifa and
Malik say about that hadith, they say we didn't see any of the
previous generations practicing that. So we don't deny that it
happens. But we don't know the context wasn't an exception. Was
there a specific thing was it abrogated later on? We don't know.
So we don't deny that the Hadith took place. But we don't have
enough information around it.
Okay, to make a ruling by it, and the companions, and the tab ain,
and the Tibet Tibetan, none of their leaders practiced it. They
all prayed drama on aid. As a result of that, we accept it as a
hadith, but we can't use it as evidence, we're going to use the
action of the companions and the tab ain as a greater evidence.
Now, the actions of the companions is that not the Sunnah, when a
whole generation of companions is doing something, is that not the
teaching of the Prophet peace be upon him? Okay. So so that's the
first understanding is that there was another evidence that's
stronger than that. Okay, what's next? It could have been
abrogated. We already alluded to that it could have been abrogated.
So when the Companions see when an imam sees that, there is isolated
Hadith one narration to do X, but we find none of the companions or
the second generation doing X, then what do they assume? They
assume maybe it was abrogated is why is it that the action is
different, of the most noble of generations. And this narration,
so they so it's not to say that the narration is rejected, is to
say there is not enough information around it. And there
is contradictory information to it. In other words, the actions of
the next two generations is contradictory to it. So as a
result of that, we're just going to suspend it, and we're not going
to act upon it, we're going to act upon what stronger yet, I'm going
to assume possibly was abrogated. Another possibility is was an
exception. So for example, the raising of the hands, even the
clasping of the hands to take an as an example. Medic himself,
cites the Hadith of the clasping of the hands. But his method is to
put the hands down in the prayer. So we need to know like, Hey,
don't drive me crazy. Here we follow in the prophet the hadith
is right there. Why are you ruling the opposite? The answer is, is
that oftentimes, a hadith is deemed to be an exception to the
rule, not the rule itself. Okay. And what's an example of that in
other narrations,
they state that the Sahaba were praying long Noah fell, and the
prophets and their hands were getting numb. And so the prophets
I sent him said, clasp your hands, as an exception as a Roxa. When
you're printing long prayers, to clasp your hands so that your
hands don't get numb, the blood is down to their hands. So it's the
idea that a narration is accepted, but it's known to be an exception
versus the rule. Right? And that's why a method ruling may seem to be
quite opposite. So you'll see mentions that the mimetic has
dozens of Hadith that he puts in them what up that he doesn't rule
by because he's basically putting them in them what saying, I know
these are exceptions. These are not the rule. Okay. Another famous
hadith is at bay Yanni. Bill here, email me it's a very funny example
that a man came to him a medic. And he said medic.
When can two people who buy and sell something make a deal?
Retract?
He says they can't, as soon as they make the deal, it's done.
Okay? He says but Maddock you yourself.
cite the Hadith in the Morata that two people, they can retract their
deal that they made. Okay, as long as they're still sitting together.
Right? He says, I cited that hadith, so that an ignorant person
like you doesn't come and tell me one day that there is such a
hadith. I knew that hadith, but I have a stronger evidence from it.
There's a stronger evidence to that
and so on.
Again, you have any situations where the Imam may know Hadith and
cite it himself, but he's citing it to make people know, I know it,
and I have a stronger evidence for it than it.
Okay, so what's another example?
How about that the narrator may act differently from what he
narrated.
What happens when that occurs? narrator says one thing, he says
the Prophet said do this, but he doesn't do it. So clearly, he
viewed it as a minor fothergilla. Or maybe an exception in the
famous example of Abdullah bin Omar, who narrates the hadith of
raising the hands before the court and after the core. So maybe he
was saying the prophets I seldom did it once or twice. But as an
exception, not the rule, because he himself was narrated that he
didn't do it. He narrated that anybody didn't do it. Okay.
We have other examples of this. bigger issues. How about saving it
and the cut and the coverage? Did not the Prophet sallallahu alayhi
wa sallam say, if I was alive when the colada just came out, I would
kill them all. who narrates that hadith? Say Nadi? Who was alive
ruling when the Jaredites came out, said no. Did he kill them
all? No, he didn't kill them all. So what did you do? Just ignore
the prophets Hadith.
Or he understood it in a context. Okay. That it with conditions
maybe? All right, yes, he would do that. If there were conditions,
the condition being that there wouldn't be greater harm than
good, right? Common sense as that. So say that it knew that hadith,
the prophesy centum said if the who are the pharaohs rights, the
rebels, they think they're more pious than everybody else and they
rebel against the authority. Okay, those are the high wattage rebels.
And they have a political and religious element to them. And the
Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam said, if I was alive, I
would kill all of them. Yeah, they're the rebels. They're gonna
cause problems in the OMA. So say 90 narrates the Hadith and say
nadi is ruling when the Clara giants emerge as the prophet
prophesied.
But he killed them. He said they can go and live in their mosques
in their villages and pray in their Missmiss agit, as long as
they leave us alone the moment they start killing us then we
fight them. So the problem so Sade Nayeli understood the conditions,
the preconditions before the implementation of the prophets,
Hadith.
And of course, he did in certain period of time, the Battle of no
one did fight them.
Okay, he did fight them. But before that, and after that he let
them live. So he understood the conditions. So again, the another
reason is that, yes, there may be a hadith and a ruling in a method,
but the Hadith has understood conditions around. Why are we
saying all this is because the best way for you students of
knowledge brand new students are not this whole livestream. The
purpose of this livestream is to introduce Muslims to the path of
knowledge and piety and worship. The best way to go about this is
to study the four Imams choose who you believe is most worthy of
following. That's the he had the scholarly effort of the common
person, and then follow that person. Because we don't have
time, we don't have the time of day to study every single issue
and get to the bottom every single issue, but we can study the Imams
and their methodologies. And then it becomes a function after that.
So this is the Imam and the methodology that I believe is most
worthy of following. And then after that, I going to follow him
and I could study his evidences as much as I can. But now, me my
life, my family, my community, my household, my masjid, we have a
policy. This is the book. And it's all predictable after that. And
trust me when you go to communities who adopt a non method
methodology. By the way, that is a methodology. You don't see learned
people, you see confused people. You see people ping ponging of
opinions all over all over the place. Okay? No, by the way, when
someone says, I just follow the Hadith, and that's it, that's a
methodology. You have adopted a methodology. So it's not like you
are not following a method that is a method. Now let's ask this
question.
When we talk about Imams not knowing the Hadith, is it
possible? Yes, we I think we mentioned this, it is possible,
but usually, it emerges in debates that they did they were aware of a
hadith and they still chose a different evidence, what the
Hadith that you imagined to be the only Hadith on the issue is
probably not so most likely, what you're projecting upon the Imam
ignorance is probably also going to rebound back to you ignorance.
You don't know his evidences. Okay. Number two is that we
actually can hold
that Imam didn't know something. And when we do hold that, we
usually hold it because one of his close followers, okay, or he
himself admits it.
All right.
That's how that's how we do know that. All right. And for example,
Abdul Rahman Al Qassam is one of human medics greatest students. He
is one of those who says that.
In some cases, if medic knew this, he would rule like this. So when
someone who studied with medic for decades, says he didn't know this
hadith, then we can accept that that we can accept, right? Because
there's a reason to accept that. But just not seeing him act upon
that hadith or rule by that hadith or cite that hadith for us to then
say he didn't know it. It's there's not there's not much to
support that claim of ignorance, it's very hard to claim a
negative. All right, do we have any questions on this subject
before we move on? And I hope that the brothers, you know, can clip
this, and, you know, maybe even add it to the madhhab series. I
know, it doesn't have the nice New York background, and we were
at the Empire State Building.
Couple we were at the embassy, we say again, there's a couple of
comments. All right, read us the comments until I load up. So one
brother is asking what month have you followship, Maliki
mathematicae? Someone to Sheffy? That's not gonna give you another
question. So that makes complete sense. My one question is with
regard to the actions when they contradict a hadith for example,
how did we know the actions of all the sahaba? Isn't this from
Hadith? or was there some other recording record keeping
happening? Of the actions? The Ahmed of Medina, for example?
Yeah, that's the question. Okay. So it says that.
How do we know the actions of all the sahaba? We know it's we know
the action of some Sahaba, but usually their students, and you
see from the companions to the Imams, there's a chain of
transmission, right. So through that we know that chain of
transmission, we know the action of the sahabi. Right, through that
we know the actions of the sub.
So for example, we know that Abdullah bin Ahmad did not know
how to sit to water, look, you know, the waterworks sitting in
the prayer. It's that you sit on your left
thigh, your left ankle is under your right shin and your right
foot, toes are bent. That's called the Tawadros Mejlis. In the prayer
itself, so I mean, sorry. And so
we know from his students that he didn't sit like that he didn't
know how to select that his legs didn't allow that. So we know
things about the the Companions like this. We know what say that
Isha used to do in many cases, because she had many students and
she would talk about these things.
Another question, we have
Salam Alikum. Let's say if there is a conflict between Hadith and
Imam, Abu Hanifa, how do we reconcile? Is there any book
available by Imam Abu Hanifa? Well, we just talked about this
for the last 10 minutes. What happens when a hadith is what you
should word it correctly, it seems to conflict with the ruling of a
meth hub that the whole
method literature, especially of later days, is meant to reconcile
all these things. Okay, how's this question?
Abu Hanifa didn't have access to Bukhari and Muslim. That's why he
didn't know many things. Well, the answer to that is that your
assumption about boycotting Muslim is incorrect. Your assumption that
boycotting Muslim is like the be all and end all of Hadith. Okay,
and that Islam has just taken from those two sources that is
incorrect. Bukhari and Muslim you have to understand something, they
had legal opinions, mostly from Shafi environments, okay. They
then went to the Hadith to find the supports of those legal
opinions. Okay. So she Bukhari and Muslim are not neutral collectors
of Hadith. You have to understand this. They didn't say okay, I'm
going to be completely neutral. Let me just go for it look for how
do you know they had their opinions already. Then they went
and they found the most sound Hadith.
Number two, they did not intend to gather an encyclopedia of Hadith.
So they just gathered Hadith that you that would suffice you right
to to live your life. Number three Hadith existed and was being
transmitted all throughout the OMA before Bukhari and Muslim and
without them, do you think that we wouldn't have an Islamic heritage
of Hadith even if Bukhari Muslim didn't live with all
are great respect to them Subhan Allah, Oh, Hadith always existed
and they were not the first book like The Islamic OMA had no Hadith
and all of a sudden boom 300 years later, Bukhari Muslim come up. So
how it works. Hadith was all over the place documented in notebooks
and private books,
scrolls, private books,
and other publications before the many, many, many Muslim Ed's
dozens upon dozens of books of Hadith before Bukhari and Muslim.
Okay, so this is one of those types of a
I want to say myths, but close to that. Make sure if
it was this big misconception with regards to the grading of Hadith
as well, like, Okay, this hadith is dive today. And remember,
Hanifa clearly is following this hadith. And then this hadith is,
right. This is a big misconception because as you mentioned a lot
when it comes to rewired as time passes, right, it gets harder for
us to really discern whether or not it's authentic. So it might be
that it was soft yet remember honey first time, but then it got
weak eventually, because the chain got weaker, there is no one final
say.
On chains for example.
There can be difference of opinion on chains. There can be to give an
example. The famous Hadith, in which the prophets forbade animals
with canines, and birds with claws, birds with talents, the
prophet forbade eating animals with canines and birds with
talents. This is a great example for two reasons. Number one, Malik
himself deemed the first half to be from the Prophet. The second
half to be an analogy from the narrator.
Then some other students assumed the whole thing was from the
prophets of Allah he was sudden. So here you have a sound Hadith
medic, only Diems the first half of it sounds the second half to be
in Raj Indrajit means the narrator makes a comment. And accidentally,
a student deems that to be part of the Hadith. Okay.
And that's number one. Number two, when the Prophet forbade it, did
He mean haram or mcru? Malik said he means mcru
right because food is only forbidden in the Quran, according
to the mimetic so that's two examples there, one the nature of
the prohibition and number two the nature of the Hadith.
So,
what is the best way to learn this as key upon the best way for a
layman to understand this, you key upon will not be a layman in terms
of studying the Imams and their methodologies. The way you do
this, keep studying the biographies of the 40 minutes,
read the biographies of the 40 minutes, watch videos of the
biographies of the 40 minutes because in our methodology, you
are not a layman in determining who to follow. Okay, you must use
your effort, you must use your intellect
you must use what you know about Islam that doesn't need
interpretation. To assess who is most worthy of knowledge.
Remember, all knowledge is two categories, that which does not
require effort to understand. And that which does require effort to
understand. If we only had knowledge that does not require
effort, we'd have no need for scholarship. And if we only had
knowledge that does require effort to understand, then nobody could
attain any knowledge. So we have two layers of knowledge.
Okay, I thought oh, do you another he the first layer of knowledge is
that which all people can understand with no effort. The
second layer of knowledge is that which can only be understood
through effort. Okay. And hence we use the stepping stones. We use
that first layer of knowledge to see who is most worthy of
following. So you must become learned. And you must trust your
judgment and make a judgment you must make a judgment on who is
most worthy of following no different than when you choose a
mechanic. When you choose a real estate agent. When you choose a
dentist, when you choose an oncologist May Allah protect you
from cancer may us when you choose a doctor of any kind, when you
choose the university to go to when you choose a law school, when
you pick a lawyer, we make these judgments all the time. I'm making
a judgment on a world that I'm not aware of, but I have enough
knowledge, enough intelligence to assess who is most worthy in that
world.
You understand how that works. So this is this what all the scholars
have said in the past that every single one of us must use his
intellect to assess
the method that we're going to follow and learn our religion on
because you're going to spend the next 1020 3040 5080 years of your
life studying
these mega this this meth hub and perfecting it and learning the
evidences and becoming first
I'm in your religion such and I'm telling you this is extremely
useful because calamities come and go and when you're when you have
knowledge of your religion, you're like a fortress calamity comes in
it goes and you didn't shake up okay
yeah for interesting thoughts when someone holds Makati to be from
the self as opposed to Abu Hanifa when Abu Hanifa lived far earlier
than him
and has far shorter chains than him.
Also like one huge thing in the sort of the meta is with regards
to the emotional Hadith, right the mahadiscom they completely
disregard this. Which one the merciful Hadith? Yes, this is huge
in the hungry mother motorcycle Alright, let's introduce this to
you write this down. If you're a new student of knowledge
listening, what is a motorcycle Hadith? The word motorcycle means
that it means sent you sent it up. So what does it mean? You sent it
up? It means someone from the second generation
does not say to companion but he cites the Prophet directly. Okay,
he sends the Hadith right up to the Prophet salallahu alayhi wa
sallam, he does not say the companion. So what's our opinion
about this? What did the scholars say about this? Well, number one,
the scholars are of two different opinions on it. Mannequin, Abu
Hanifa say that when a senior
Tebay a senior from the second generation that means he spent a
lot of time with the companions.
And he cites the Prophet directly. He only does so because the hadith
is so obviously true that it doesn't need to be cited. Okay.
Like in a PhD or something, when you cite a fact, like World War
Two happened at this date to this date? Do you need to cite that you
need to go to I'd be funny to see a footnote for that right? Because
it's such an obvious fact or President JFK president from this
date to this date. Okay, well, you don't need a site that we know
that has effect. So they hold that those Murase
are Hadith
but if they were not seeing your tabbies if they came later on that
no, we won't consider their their Murase the plural is Marasi and
the singular is Morisset. Remember the whole nother affects life and
try to introduce
regular Muslims to the world of knowledge the world of knowledge
is what will make our Eman powerful strong unshakable in the
later
Shafi and amateur been humbled do not hold the same opinion about
the medicine. So as a result you end up the Hanafi Malik is
utilizing a whole different set of a hadith.
Abdullah
as a says, In Islam, the scholars of fit came first then Hadith and
Arpita. That's correct. And that's why the opposite of scholars
ended up essentially being the methods choosing a different
nakida Imams of Akita to follow.
Can I take is it permissible to take the opinion of him which
deadhead that is outside the four schools? Like, can I take an
opinion of say dice or say in a lathe of inside? The reason that
you cannot is has to do with transmission? Okay.
So just because you see it in a book does not mean that that's the
sound perfect transmission. One of the things about methods is that
it's an HD head. It's a photo essentially, but we need to know
that that photo actually was what in which the handyman said
so that's why we don't do that. But chances are you could look at
in the meth lab and see if that opinion is there. Can you please
go over the issue of innovation? I heard that Imam Shafi said there
is a good innovation, ugly innovation and others say that
every innovation is a misguidance This is from soldier of Allah. So
the answer to that is that innovation, we
chef I did say this and he Where did he say this in El Biohub? His
biography of a Shafi a mammal by Huxley was one of the last Hadith
transmitters. Okay. There's a last Hadith transmitters and he
clarified a lot of things that Chef a never clarified. And he
wrote his biography and he answered a lot of questions about
a chef A. So people say, if there was ever a imam who had to thank
one of His followers, it will be chef A to be hooky. So Bay hooky
does cite that Imam is Chef, his definition of innovation is that
which contradicts the Sunnah of the Prophet sallallahu alayhi
wasallam not that which is simply not in the Sunnah of the Prophet
sallallahu sunnah. That doesn't mean that that's the only opinion.
I mean, that may be the opinion that a lot of people follow. But
there is another opinion that anything in worship that did not
exist in the time of the Prophet sallallahu Sallam isn't
innovation, and is a blameworthy innovation, but it's not the
innovation that puts you outside of medicine, it'd be innovation of
something that is discouraged for you to do, maybe even invalid,
maybe even forbidden, or just rejected, but not the innovation
that puts you outside of that Asuna like you're a Shia, you
know, or something like that. It simply is that that's just an
action that
we you shouldn't do that they condemn for you to do. All right.
And so you have to understand that those are the two opinions of what
an innovation is. And innovations usually come about. The question
comes about, on things like vicar in a group or 10 hour pm or
Leyland a group, things like that. So for example, the Sahaba the
Prophet never just did an attic F in the middle of the year. So only
in Ramadan. They never did group
pm and late group to hedge it never happened in the time of the
Prophet salallahu Salam. So but a chef a He permits those things, he
allows those things. Malick does not okay. Now when he when he says
doesn't allow it, it means that you don't do it. It's an invalid
prayer doesn't mean that if you were to do it, that you'd be
outside of Edison. So you have to understand that when we say
innovation in that regard, innovation in acts of worship is
lesser of an issue than innovation in doctrine, which would put could
put a person outside of it what does it mean to be outside of
Edison nor Gemma it means you're not practicing Islam properly. And
the but you're not
out of Islam altogether. You're contradicting something very core
and clear in the religion. So what's the result of that? The
result of that is your good deeds are not that are not accepted
until you fix your beliefs. Who said this the convenience said
this, The Quran says this. Have you thoughts Amazon, their deeds
are not accepted until they correct the religion
or their ethnicity Maliki the amalickiah have been the
staunchest machetes in history.
If someone cites a hadith as whatsoever, and it contradicts
what you have learned as part of a method, what should they do?
For example, the hadith of rough Alia Dane as much water
I don't know if it's considered whatsoever. But just because a
hadith is spread far and wide does not necessitate that the
implication of the hadith is, is clear.
You have to understand there's two parts of every narration, the
there's the distribution, the transmission of the narration, and
there's the implication of the narration. Okay.
So the district the transmission and the distribution can be far
and wide. Yes, everyone knows it. But the implication may not be
good implication meaning what ruling is derived from it, because
if there still can be contradictory evidence, there
still can be questions about it. You understand? So just being far
and spread and wide does not necessitate that. It's the final
word. You understand?
Are we ready to move on to some tafsir? No.
Mohammed s says
fantastic drip of restream learned or genetic? The
the lingo of this new generation
Alright, let's let's get well Can I pray behind an innovator? The
answer is that is if it's an innovator,
an innovator of Aqeedah then praying behind him is sinful but
the prayer would be valid. If it's praying behind somebody who is a
complete, we must say unfortunately xindi
xindy Because outside of Islam completely, but he says he's a
Muslim, right? Then that Salah is invalid completely, such as prayer
behind a Qadiani or something. Okay, here's the question.
This question says I was going to ask what the ruling is, with
waiting for a couple of days before the burial.
All right. The snow prevented us, for example of the burial. The
cemetery is reluctant to allow burial tomorrow because of the wet
grounds. Can we wait until Thursday? Even if they agree the
answer is yes, you can wait if there's a reason to wait.
If there's a reason to wait such as, like the nature of the ground,
the mud, etcetera, then that waiting is you won't be held
sinful for that.
Alright, let's
let's read one more question, Adam. Enzo says,
What is haram to imagine?
Okay.
What is haram to imagine and is playing music in your head among
it? What is haram to imagine is that which is haram to do simple
as that. Right? It's, it would be we would say mcru.
And if you persist upon it, it could enter into the haram. So
anything that is haram to do,
is haram is mcru to fantasize about and persisting upon
fantasizing about it can become sinful. So It's haram to, for
example, gamble, go to a casino, and spend all night in the casino,
you know, like these James Bond movies.
Okay, so it's, it will be discouraged for you to fantasize
about doing that. And if you persist upon fantasizing in that,
then you could enter into sinfulness. Why? Because what you
think about a lot, eventually you would want to do it. So that's why
we should monitor our thoughts. Where are the questions being
asked Instagram? I see your questions are there you can ask
them, you can also ask them on YouTube to Okay.
Let's turn to tafsir now
are the bodies outside of medicine?
Yes. Otherwise they wouldn't need to be called the bodies. Right.
But their doctrine does. They do have things in their doctrine that
are insulting to say that Hussein,
hypnotic, and they have other things. But there's such a small
group that a lot of people don't really study them.
I want to point you to something hey, right. Almost, can you do
something for me? Can you look up the Rosetta nebula while I read
this? And by the time you find it, it'll be time for us to look it
up.
Okay.
What does Allah mean when he says Coolio? Men who are fisherton
Every day Allah subhanho wa Taala is amongst or in an a
business having an affair, okay? What it means is that
the creation that he has already willed, He is commanding it to
manifest. Okay.
That's what it means. We'll move on UB dia, wala EBITA dia, it does
not mean Allah is deciding, okay, let's do this. Let's do that. No,
all matters have been decided, but rather Coolio man who officia and
meaning he commands manifest
this matter that has already been created and willed.
Manifest.
Okay, so it is not that he is creating something from
from nothing in the sense of at this very moment in time so that
on Wednesday, he's going to create Wednesday on Tuesday, and then on
Wednesday, he's going to create Thursday. No, all has been willed,
but he commands it to manifest.
folder. Huhtala is aluminum for Samoa to an old alma Annaeus
Allahu Memphis similarity or Rama or Memphis or the risks.
They ask Him those who are in the heavens and those who are in the
earth. It means those who are in the Heavens asking for mercy. And
those who are in the earth asking for sustenance, we're always in
need of energy and sustenance. God have not best wobble sada Hello
Samoa tes Aluna Hu l Mo Farah. Those in the heavens ask His
forgiveness. What is a loon Horus and those in the heavens do not
ask for risk. Because once you're outside of this abode, there is no
fear for sustenance anymore.
All just Aluna who was Allahumma is Aluna Houma Jimmy and those in
the earth need to ask for everything forgiveness.
Mercy sustenance but once you're in the heavens, remember the
heavens is not paradise paradise is different. The heavens are
abodes above us and they do not seek risk. They do not worry about
eating and drinking and sleeping okay they've been Jude age says
tests alone Mala Inca to risk Valley Island art. But the angels
even are worried about the sustenance for people
for Cana Tilly Miss Ella tourney Jamie and Melissa, what are the
odds? So even the peep the angels in the heavens are seeking help
praying for help for those in the earth.
In the middle mela it Getty Melech and low Earth orbit ojo. There's a
hadith course we are reading here.
A jam out.
That little caught up to me.
A German camel Quran
ABI Abdullah Mohammed Ahmed Al Ansari are called to be great
scholar of Cordoba. What does he say here there is a Hadith there
is an angel. He has four faces.
One face is the face of a human being. And he asked Allah
sustenance for the human being, he prays for help for human beings,
and another one like a lion. And he seeks the sea praise constantly
for sustenance for the for the carnivores, a syba and another one
with the face of a bull. And he is always praying for the herbivores
and another one with the face of an eagle.
And he's always seeking support for the Eagles for the birds. What
God have not thought and know very strange Hadith, right?
Very strange Hadith. We wouldn't want to see such a creature of
beasts.
Any strange narration I should say. And he doesn't cite anything.
He doesn't cite it. He's just basically saying that there's a
hadith like that. He's not making any conclusion that this is sound
or not sound he didn't say
what kind of northa in the home set Allahu Allahu wa ala a bed?
Okay, yes Aloha Memphis similar to an audit they asked him strength
the righteous of the people of the heavens and the earth. They asked
for strength and worship.
Coolio man who officiated.
Got
I would go to dat narrates from the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa
salam min chutney, he and yo Farah Themba
from him for what is the shuttin the, the the what is the affairs
of this this verse is talking about what is important in the
heavens, the forgiveness of so and so. The relief of a tribulation
from so and so. Okay, the elevation of a people from
humiliated from disgraced or from lowly to strong
and downgrading of people from glorious to abased.
And from Ibn Ahmad that the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa
sallam said Coolio Minho, officia and yo filled with them by wax if
acaba ug Bucha the year and to answer prayers, in addition to the
other things mentioned, to answer prayers, these are the spiritual
affairs that is the greatest concern Wilkie lemon chutney he I
know you're here when you meet and also who is to live, who's to be
born who is to die. Okay, who is to be respected and honored, who
is disrespected and dishonored right, who is to gain wealth and
who is to lose wealth
Okay, so that's the shetan that is those are the important affairs
and the important matters.
Written
called Kelby Shan, who soup and maca Dear Ellen ma Pete l Kelby
says it's all destiny to arrive at its destination
lokala on revenue Mamoon Coolio Madhavi Shadman chutney and you
need to hire
while you're Kara Phil or hamesha its birth and its death. Okay,
Coolio Minho, Fisher and fillet.
Every day Allah subhanho wa Taala is manifesting a destiny for
somebody that has already been written for him pre eternity in
his knowledge.
Wakasa Annelle Calama Jeff Bhima Hua and en la Monica Yama. So how
do we understand this?
When the pen the ink of the pen of destiny has dried, right? So how
do we understand this again? It is to say that it is already destined
but Allah subhanaw taala is commanding it to manifest at this
time
versus that time, et cetera center for hola como a US Soccer learn
we will free ourselves for you owe him being what does that mean does
Allah busy he has to free himself No, it means that we will devote
all of our attention to you that means nothing will slip by not a
single Adam's weight of good or bad will slip by. That's what it
means. Good. Because you someone's busy you feel like I could slip
one past him. No. Oh Allah says Cena for a warlock calm. Are you a
thug? We are completely devoted you you're gonna get our undivided
attention. Does Allah need to do this? No, it means this is what's
a Shabbat in one sense in that respect.
It means nothing was slipped by every single atoms weight of good
or bad we'll be recognizing and judged.
Santa fro Hola, como yo, Sokoine Oh, incent Jin. Now here's an
amazing thing said of us is this as as if you Oh Jin and humans if
you're able to pass by the outer edge of the heavens and the earth
then do so the amorphous city in earlier on. They deemed this to be
that oh humans, if you imagine that you could flee from the
the grounds of the Judgement Day. Then go he's basically saying you
can't
later amorphous city and clearly state that this is literal.
It is about actually human beings leaving going into space.
Modern Warfare suiting. And that's why they say tough see, it is one
of the subjects that never ends, it never ends. And here we have
essentially space travel in the Quran. Alright, oh Jin and humans
if you're able to penetrate the outer edge of the heavens in the
earth. So the question of human beings penetrating the inner part
of the heavens and the earth is assumed, right? is saying, if
you're able to penetrate the outer edge, then go ahead. You will not
be able to do it without power. salt on here means knowledge,
wealth and willpower, salt on knowledge, wealth and willpower.
But then it's saying that if you ever reached the outer edge of the
heavens, which we don't even know where it is, by the way, right?
You notice that we don't know where it is. We just see black. We
have no clue. Where's the outer edge? Where's the rim? Okay.
Does anyone? Have you ever looked that up? Like what is the rim of
the universe? God, we have no clue.
But he's saying that. If you ever reach that rim, you'll be
confronted with no harass and swallow them and not flares of
fire and copper. And you have no one to help you.
For that's untested and you will not succeed. So what will you not
succeed? Didn't say it won't succeed go in space, you will not
to succeed, penetrating the outer rim of the universe of of space,
what we what we know to be space, we haven't even reached that outer
rim. So it's amazing that the verse is saying referring to the
Outer Rim, not to just outer space. Okay, UK, DOD is similar to
the edge.
And of course the old tifosi they don't address this at all. They
address it as
like Toby. Toby is if you think that you're going to run away from
us on the Day of Judgment. Okay, you're gonna fail. That's how the
classical tifosi read that.
Okay, and here we are seeing exactly
space travel mentioned here in the Quran.
Okay,
now let's read the tafsir here.
Center for Woolacombe with Takala new Carlu ferrata Mina, surely
Afro Furukawa Farakka and Waterford roba.
I free myself for you. Okay, the meaning Sunak sudo limo Jazza team
one will have Subotic calm we will direct
We will intend to judge you and reward you and punish you get
every single little thing that you won't get anything bias as sorted
themselves or
Mikhailova rotten Hira, yada,
yada, yada. Even an atom's weight of good and bad you're going to be
judged but you will see it, you're gonna see it. In other words, it's
not going to pass by if you see a small can in the road and you
throw it in the garbage on the Day of Judgment, you're gonna see that
if you throw it there, and imagine it's not a big deal.
Or you throw a banana peel there and someone could slip on that
banana peel and you think to yourself, well, what are the
chances forget let me just throw it you're gonna see that on the
Day of Judgment, okay. Nothing will pass you by.
Okay
center for Hola, como, como loosen Coolen? Illa Marwadi No, there
were no promise will go unfulfilled.
No Promise of Allah will go unfulfilled.
Say yo fragola Come alarm alarmists recited it say you
fragola Calm or you
say Afro hula calm. recites Hamza and Kisei.
Now yeah Masha Allah jindee Will ins o Jin and humans
will first city and say about this.
Call it the hack either Kenna Yeoman, yo Malkia Matty Amana lo
sama sama dunya Photoshop Crockett, be earlier feta Coonan
Mala a koala have Fatiha had to have motorhome loaded up. fenzi
Luna Ellen ology favor atonal, all human fear that the human beings
and the jinn will all be resurrected on a flat plane of
Earth of land, then the sky will open up and it will pour down with
angels and the angels will surround them like soldiers and
then they will initiate the judgment.
And then another
sky will open up and more angels will come down and more angels
will come down until seven layers of angels come down surround the
human beings and make them stand in rows organizing the human
beings managing the chaos of the human beings.
Thomas Rashidi says Can these lives be viewed afterwards? Yes.
On Safina society's YouTube channel, make sure you like and
subscribe and hit the notification bell.
Okay, so angels come down and the chaos of human beings just being
by themselves comes to an end they organize the human beings and they
put them by generation. All right, first generation second all the
way in order. And you stand with your Imam you're resurrected with
your Amen. Who did you follow? You followed Hitler alright go stand
with Hitler. Who was your Imam who did you love in this world and who
did you follow in this world? Get you stick with them? You're going
to be with them on the Day of Judgment in rows like this until
your names are called no one moved no one talk
if I let us know Illa Ahimsa they organize the human beings in rows
like this. And no human being is
has any
ability to speak no one will speak let us know Allah Hamsa you will
not hear except like hemps just like a sniffle there or a sneeze
there or something like Ahimsa just like when you're in Salah and
everyone's quiet for Salah to load or something and you don't hear
anything
except little things here and there.
Okay, go to father how they kunafa dunya wa ala Mazda carbonyl
Mubarak Mucuna Phil after Awana the hockey a lot
in his sets out to him and to horrible middle moat so the hawk
let's look look at the early interpretations of the scholars
who never imagined that space travel was possible What did they
say? They said if you imagine that you could flee from death
it's been our best says is it's awesome and Talamo math is similar
to math and all DeFalco even our bass says this is saying the the
more if you can learn about the heavens and the earth and go try
to learn about it. Okay, well in Tala mu Illa de sol Dawn, you will
not learn anything about them in general except what Sultan which
means what proof you need proof. So it's like almost pointing to
epistemology or you need proof you need to learn how to determine
facts
let them produce the 11 Sultan letter. Hello gentlemen Soltani.
rakura tra calm
it's also said
you will not go without Sultan In other words, no matter how far you
go human being you will not exit my my realm you're always in God's
realm. It's as if you leave the earth have you left God's realm?
No, but Dad this is Latin for dunya Illa be Moluccan well I say
hola como will Latin for dunya Illa Illa Sultan right
your sorrow Allah commercial Walden, a willow Corrado Marisa
Aleikum, Casa de manera, Waka qumola, blue mana, Mina new fouth,
if you try to leave this earth you will be met with fire. Now the
words
schwa them and not flares and copper. Okay, if you try to flee
the abode of the afterlife, in other words, so again, some of
them are still many of the narrations are still related to
that the otter didn't matter the word or the masher means the abode
in which the judgment is taking place.
All right now
I want to point you to the next item
for either in Chicago this summer for Ken Atwater the 10 cadion This
is where
do you guys think Shaadi is a grifter blocked this fool or no
grifter? I've been on the same I've been doing literally like the
same thing my whole life literally for methods Sid update about
my whole life been doing the same thing.
Not into fools these days. Let's go to
Rosetta nebula. This is so amazing to read this
it's so amazing to read this
throw up a picture for us. Copy and paste a picture one of those
red ones
the red one Yeah, that one. Perfect. This is as a shortcut
this summer will for Canada to water the 10 Canadian.
If the heavens bursts forth or are split
cut, then it will appear like an oily red rose.
Alright, they say this that they interpreted is on the Day of
Judgment.
But look at what we have here in our world today. Put on a black
background to skip that yellow.
In our world today, there is something called the Rosetta
nebula
which is
when does this happen
the Rosetta Nebula
is a cluster and nebula that die that lie at a distance of 5000
ladies from the earth and measure roughly 130 light years in
diameter. These are phenomenon out in space.
The radiation from young stars excites the atoms in the nebula
causing them to emit radiation themselves producing the emission
that we see the mass of the nebula is estimated to be around 10,000
solar masses.
Okay, give us give us some English here. Okay
the Rosetta Nebula is a satellite
cluster. It is a star forming region, star forming region near a
molecular cloud.
Give us English here please.
Give us give it to us for beginners.
All right, maybe the BBC can help. Look at how gorgeous this is.
If the heavens split,
look at this.
When the heavens split than they are like an oily red rose.
And this is what we're reading here. About this is called this
picture here is called the Rosetta Nebula
or Rosette Nebula. It's a huge star forming region spanning 100
light years across and it is 5000 light years away. It can be seen
in the mono SAROS constellation.
Okay, so what is it?
It lives up to
It's nickname. It's circular shape deep, dark centers. Give it a
floral appearance.
How amazing is this?
And you're gonna tell us that the prophets of Allah when he was
salam.
This is something clearly
he could not have seen in his time.
So this star is probably 4 million years old. It's a cluster and they
emit streams of charged particles known as stellar winds, carving
out gas and dust at the nebulas center
giving it the rosette nickname
because it
because of its floral structure
it's carving cosmic gases in stellar winds right have caused it
to view this rose shape or to be viewed with this rose shape.
Alright, it looks like it's a rose because it's like moving in
circles like this. The surrounding gas that forms a ring around the
dark center is glowing right because it is being blasted by
radiation from nearby nearby stars
BBC sky at night magazine right
selected this image etc etc.
Amazing. So this is the Rosette Nebula that we see here. Something
very similar described in the Quran. When the heavens are split
asunder, right open for then chakra to sum up. If the heavens
open up,
then it's for either chakra to Soma, or for Ken at water the cat
the hen, it looks like a flower, an oily flower.
And is that not what we're seeing right here. The Rosette Nebula is
a stunning Astro photography target for your camera and your
telescope. The colorful hydrogen gas and embedded open star cluster
make this winter Deep Sky target one that is not to be overlooked
it's also known as the skull nebula some people call it the
skull nebula it's impressive object competes for your attention
alongside Orion come over the years I've photographed the
Rosette Nebula many times using various camera types in this post
food sharing some Okay, and he's not really talking much about the
construction of it just saying what it is. Okay, let's go to
galactic Hunter and see what he says
the Rosette Nebula is one of the largest most beautiful and most
popular targets for
stargazers.
Their gases expand so much that they seem to interact. In other
words, one covering the other, like the petals of a rose, one is
covering the other.
Okay.
So essentially, really, that's really the there's not much else
to say about it, except that that's one of the most amazing,
one of the more amazing and direct
verses in the Quran that has, you know, something that we're seeing
right in front of us here. Right. And it's something that
we really couldn't
we know that the Prophet wouldn't have seen that in his time.
So Bishop, for calling me a grifter has been suspended for
timeout for 86,000 seconds. Why does it say 86,000 seconds, don't
just say five minutes or whatever that is.
That's a good day.
Here's what
you know, the funny thing is that anyone who knows me have been
saying and teaching the same thing for
20 years.
So this is amazing for candidates. What does it think again?
Right, and when you read these Tafseer, because they don't see
what we see. So they're trying to explain it in some other way. And
they're saying that this will occur on the Day of Judgment,
right? What could possibly be true to All right, it doesn't have to
be one or the other. But it's just How gorgeous is this picture that
we're looking at on the screen right here?
Amazing.
Amazing.
All right. That's it for the tafsir reading today. We will
let's go to
q&a.
Could it be for the Shaka to Semak? Could it be space time
splitting? Okay.
In Chicago to summer, once the skies open up when there's a split
in the sky of some sort, it's pretty broad that
if I made a mistake in Tisha hood, do I have to repeat myself? No,
you do not. If you skipped the Tisha hood accidentally,
you need to pray sujood a cell what is to do the cells to
prostrations of forgetfulness. If you accidentally skipped in the
second aka you got up and you did not set for to show hood, you
continue praying.
provided it was accidental, forgetfulness, then you make two
prostrations before you salaam out of the prayer. And then you do
Tisha hood again, and then you Salam out of the prayer. Okay, how
can I be a scholar if I have a busy life? It's very easy
actually.
You take courses, you know, can you keep that stone rosette there?
I like it.
There
it's very easy. You study
systematically every day, 510 minutes, 20 minutes, 15 minutes,
maybe videos
okay.
Yeah,
maybe videos of some sort. But systematically and you study
Tajweed first,
systematically number two, you study off data second. Number
three, you study your father dying. Third. Okay.
Some may say for dine before athlete.
But point is that you should study on a schedule, whether it's daily,
every day, or every three times a week four times a week, even if
it's only 15 minutes a day. Okay.
Is there a hadith about not recording Hadith? Good question.
The answer is yes. In the beginning of the of the time of
the Prophet sallallahu Sunnah the messenger peace be upon him said
he did not allow the companions to write down his Hadith so that the
Quran could be firm with them first. After the Quran was firm,
and they know the difference between the prophets words in the
Quran, then he said, Write my Hadith. Then he permitted that and
he encouraged
is doe devotee a deviant No, he's not a deviant, but his method was
died up. his manhood was an extreme was not practical. He said
that there is no analogy.
And everything is exactly as it is. So that method is has died
out. No one practices
that we trust in Birmingham.
They have Maliki there
all right. What do we do full time where our full time activities
between ArcView Safina societies online classes are Q dot o RG.
They're nothing but facts livestream and our physical msgid
as NBC dot o RG.
Here in New Brunswick, this is what we do full time, day and
night.
How do you address atheists that mock that we need revelation to
know what is good and wrong, as well as being motivated by reward?
While we say very simply, you could mock whatever you want. That
doesn't make your point. Truth of the matter is that morality is
completely relative.
Until the Creator tells us about it, there is no absolutes in
morality is no absolutes. There is nothing that would justify any
moral ethical claims, except the Creator. Right? So yes, some
morals we can know by gut instinct. But we can't enforce it
upon others. If because your gut instinct, oh my gosh, how could
you torture a little pet puppy? Because your gut instinct your
sensitivity says that's bad. But is that how is that a rule of law?
Right. So human beings do need what is above them in authority.
To tell them I made you I have the legal authority to tell you.
This is right and this is wrong. Secondly, motivation by reward.
Who isn't motivated by reward?
Who isn't motivated by fear, reward and then good.
And we don't say that that's the only motivation. So that's one of
the mistakes they make. They said that's the only motivation now
that is one of the greatest motivations is to avoid the bad
out of fear to do the good
For the sake of reward, these are some of the greatest motivations
and not the only motivation. Eventually somebody could reach
the point that they want to do something good because the love of
Allah.
So if they're saying that,
if they're mocking this, then we say them, okay? Oh atheist, show
me how many drug dealers have has atheism reformed?
How many bad people?
If you can even define bad, how many bad people has an atheist
philosophy reformed into becoming a good person?
Reform. It goes from fear, to desire to love. And what is so
lowly about desire? What's lowly about desire? What's lowly about
fear, there's nothing lowly about that.
A man is constantly committing fornication.
Pleasure, but this pleasure is harmful to other people spreading
disease,
what is going to move him other than fear? Right?
What's going to stop him other than fear?
NASA sometimes digitally adds color to their space images.
Possibly.
I still like to image though
what knowledge is considered forbidden learning black magic.
forbidden knowledge.
There is something called white magic to white magic does not mean
it's Hallett. It just means it's not covered.
Or it's means that they try to use it to help people and this is
forbidden to
is all forbidden. But it may not be covered. So the format hubs
they divide magic into two types, depending on what you do, in order
to do this magic. If you utter words of cover, then it's covered.
If you don't, and you're just uttering different incantations,
from some crazy book that you found,
and you get a gin to try to whisper to somebody to love you.
That kind of world, then it's sinful. You get lashes for that.
But it's not good for
us. And you can see in the books of Chef A's and medicals and
honeybees, they have this
good.
Negative is Takata means obstacles. Positive is Takata. Me
Homina Riaz, your question
when you praise Takata and
you continue to pray staccato, you should just wait to see if there
are going to be obstacles or ease. If there is ease, that's a good
sign. Keep moving forward. If there are obstacles, that's a bad
sign, that means you did not choose correctly. Make another
decision now. Okay.
But
that doesn't mean that any little obstacle means that we shouldn't
try. No.
You can keep pushing forth.
When we say obstacle, we mean an obstacle that renders it
absolutely impossible. Like should I propose to this woman right now?
Yes or no? Let me praise Takata. Okay, I'm going to do it, right.
Because it's Takata does not mean is Takata means I have a decision
I made the let me let me rephrase that. I plan to propose to this
woman right now. Let me praise Takata
and that way, Allah will send me a sign that I made the right
decision or the wrong decision. All right, call the woman.
Salam aleikum. I'm ready to propose to your daughter. Oh,
she's already married. Okay. Hello. So now it's impossible for
me to propose to her now she's already married.
So when it becomes impossible,
that's when it is a sign that I made the wrong decision.
Now, if he says, Okay, you can propose but she's away now and
she'll be back in two months. That's fine. Right? That's just an
obstacle. Or yes, you can propose but she doesn't. She doesn't want
to talk to you right now. You don't have to convince her that's
not an obstacle that makes me stop. So the obstacle of istikhara
that is a sign that I made the wrong decision is when the matter
is completely impossible now not just has a hardship
is even reached bidet in which they had a good reference to learn
about positions in other med hubs. Yes, it's one of the best books
ever produced is excellent in fifth just his philosophy was just
like a side hobby of his you can ignore.
What do you think about Hanafy?
No, I'm not going to end
For those questions
a father disliked when his son kept a beard and disliked him
sitting with scholars, this father is also consistent obstacle for
his marriage with a girl.
That's not good, in a sense in the shittier, the Father, if a if a
son can live on his own,
he works and he can live on his own a father can not prohibit the
son from doing certain things, which are his right, which are
eating, working, earning money.
Getting married,
Father cannot forbid these things. By Sharia, he can advise, but he
cannot forbid, once a boy has now works on his own. He earns his own
money, he's a man now, the father cannot say don't eat, don't go to
work, don't get married, can not do that.
It's no secret, a book a good book on our feet at one of the best.
I've tried to place my right foot in the bed position during the
sitting portion of the prayer, I'm not able to do it. Is it a
requirement? No, it's not a requirement. The prayer consists
of requirements confer confirmed sunna's And then virtuous actions.
Every physical element of the prayer except for a few.
Like how to move the finger how to hold the hands, whether to raise
the hands, how to sit down, how far to turn the neck and slamming
out. These are considered the virtues of the prayer. What
physical movements are obligations is what the Prophet mentioned is
an obligation standing perfectly still for at least a moment.
Standing fully upright.
When you stand up, when you sit back up, from sitting from sujood
to sitting, your spine has to come fully backup that these two things
are called to Nina and attadale to Nina is to be fully still for at
least a moment.
And attadale Is that your spine is is fully back. So when you get up
from Roku, you don't get up. This much only you have to get up all
the way.
It's called anti debt.
Why did the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam said I am not a
reader when God asked him to recite the first two times
Akari the word cloudy refers to can be handled the meaning of
reading and reciting like reading a book and reciting
our Java is a fifth madhhab No, there is no such thing. There is
no chain of transmission with a reliable information about what
say Najafi the subject said and didn't say. So that's why we don't
hold it as a fifth myth him.
What Tafseer were you reading from previously? Close to these tafsir?
Gemma?
I can Can I take ArcView essential classes without knowing Arabic?
Yes, you can argue essentially you can take without knowing Arabic.
Are there any ruling on men shaking women's hands? Yes, there
is a ruling which is for prohibition.
It's probably been prohibited to touch a woman that is not from
your family.
Meaning the madam, the women that you are not allowed to marry.
Okay, or your wife.
The word Muharram is plural for Muharram which means that type of
that woman that you cannot marry or for the woman demand that you
cannot marry.
That's your daughter, your aunt, your grandma, your mom Of course.
The if a woman breastfed you before the age of two, the sister
the daughter of a woman who breastfed you okay, what is the
breastfeeding before the age of two? Even one gulp of another
woman's milk if you consume that you are her son it by
breastfeeding milks on the colon. Her daughters are like your
sisters exactly. You cannot marry them.
They're like your sisters and everything except inheritance law.
Your nieces same thing there Muharram.
And then of course your wife is not a Muharram that's his OCE
so your xojo and your Muhammad him. Those are the women you can
touch after that that rink. A man is Allah to touch such any woman
like that? No, there's a situation that happens where
is a necessity or some kind of a hot fudge? And it happens you make
us defer.
What should I do if I accidentally recite Durood? Sharif darood
meaning Salah on the messenger Allahumma salli ala Sayyidina
Muhammad ISAPI Salam
during the second raka after Tisha hood, nothing don't do that. Now.
I mean, you don't have to do anything. You don't have to make
repentance or anything, nothing, you get the good deed of doing it
not for Hunter fights.
So just so Chad you
are naturally
I've heard legends about my grandfather seven generations
controlling and using Jen for transportation and stuff like
that. Was that Helen, in interaction with Jin?
We're just talking theory don't ask me about I don't know anything
about this stuff but I do know the theory, the law, interaction with
gymnasts hada is what you do with the interaction. If you use it to
abuse other people to take an advantage have an advantage over
other people, then this is forbidden, but merely interacting
with a jinn is not haram. So many of the scholars right read it. You
see in their books that they taught the jinn. The Prophet
himself taught the jinn. And he brought Abdullah bin Masood to
watch if it was bad. Why would he bring him to watch? You think
maybe you think Abdullah Masood learned a thing or two right on
how to educate the jinn. So the mere interaction with Jin is not
forbidden. Okay. It's what you do in the interaction that could be
forbidden right
is beat boxing haram
beat boxing like
with your hand like this and stuff. There's nothing haram about
them.
Right? Who beatboxes though these days?
Yeah, I saw an online federal phone asila that acknowledged the
Joffrey Shia as a fifth Mehtab of Satanism.
It doesn't matter if they give that Fetzer or not it's not. It's
not recognized. They have this there's no Senate for it.
What is hypnotism? Is it halal or haram?
I really can't tell you much about hypnotism. I don't know much about
it. But we could just follow the general principle. If you're
harming people,
that is forbidden. If you're taking advantage of them, then
it's forbidden.
If it's merely techniques of persuasion,
as persuasive techniques as hotter Hello, every every marketer, every
businessman, every salesman uses these techniques. You're using
them for an acceptable end such as to sell a product, that's how to,
you're using it to misguide somebody to harm themselves and
buy something that's a waste of waste of their money, then that's
forbidden. Okay, selling people something that you know is a waste
of their money is forbidden.
So that's how you would judge it. Myself. IBM says according to the
reliance of the traveler during jihad, it is permissible to kill
old men 40 up and monks, isn't that a war crime and immoral since
they're not combatants, it's only allowed if they are combatants, if
they enter the realm of combat, so a monk sitting in his temple,
worshiping God, doing whatever he wants to do, or being just being
an old man by himself, no problem. The moment he picks up a sword, he
has transferred himself from the legal category of noncombatant to
a combatant, then you can fight him and kill him.
Same thing with a woman or child. If a child comes at you throwing a
grenade, you can kill them. What are you going to do? Right? He's
about to throw a grenade at your whole group. You have to shoot him
down first. If a woman comes Throw, throw grenade at your whole
group, you have to do this, right? It's not something that
it's just simply that are they combatants or not? That's it.
Guys, whether the man is old, young, male, female, doesn't
matter.
Thoughts on remote viewing basically seeing something miles
away through meditation.
I'd love to do that. She could teach me how to do it. Yeah, I
guess it's up there with
astral projection, right? Listen, I mean,
if I can learn to do that, I wouldn't have to take so many
vacations. Save my money. I would have to fly on a miserable United
airline flight just to go see the sightseeing. I will just astral
project and call it a day.
Good
why are people falling fit, for example, Abu Hanifa when it comes
to up to you, they follow my two liter SDSA the HANA fees. When the
AKI the debates came, they emerged right. They emerged after Abu
Hanifa
and they needed two answers to these questions.
The Imam Abu Matsuda 3d
formed his Aki EDA
With the question in mind, what would Abu Hanifa say about these
new issues?
So the metadata is what it is the Hanafi Arpita? Because he answered
the question, what would ever Hanifa say, based on the
principles we know
when it comes to this new issue?
Same thing with the Medicare and the Shafia. Medicaid in the Shafia
when they when the new issues came about and they said what would our
should have said, based on his methodology, what we know about
him, and they concluded that the sad Arcade is correct. The sad
Arcade is answers to questions that did not exist earlier on.
Okay.
My mother, like
Mitch said in our method, when he mentioned his like his man had she
says in filth Hanafy and he said anokhi, the Hanafi Yeah, even the
maturity maturity, the Akita sometimes called Handfield kid.
Can you pitch why you chose the medic? In other words, most
deserving fallen because the AMA Verna Medina is very hard
to say that it's, it's incorrect. What is the Ahmed is basically two
things. Number one, it's the public
displays of worship that spread in the society, such as the event,
how to pray, how to recite Fatiha out loud. In other words, do you
say Bismillah R Rahman Rahim are not? What does a woman wear?
Like why do we need textual evidence for that? Did not the
Sahaba have wives didn't know how to have daughters? Right?
Did it the Sahabas a choose Santa wives for their daughter for their
sons. So what were they? What was their standard? Right? Like we
don't do we need textual evidence for this. It's right there in
front of it. They were living Islam. So that's the one thing the
second thing
is that Ahmed al Medina refers to
the ht head, the fatwa
that the major scholars of Medina of the second and third generation
agreed upon, right, the leaders of that society when there was a new
matter, they came to a conclusion on that. And in specific, there
were 12 great leaders and these 12 of the 12, there were seven even
more senior to them, which were the Council of Ahmedabad Abdel
Aziz, he considered them the seventh great scholars of Medina.
So when they came upon a conclusion, and they agreed upon
something, that's the second meaning of Ahmed al in Medina. And
as a result of that, we can also look back like so they came to a
conclusion, we can read back their methodology, so we can assess
their methodology from the conclusion. And that's why
it's almost it's very, very strong method to follow. And that's why
even called the Ayyad says obligate, it's obligatory to
follow this method, because nobody has an argument against this.
So that's the idea. Of course the Shafi does Abu Hanifa does, but
he's saying that he believes that there's nothing stronger than
that. And that's why every Maliki falls American myth because the
Ahmed is that powerful. It's like, here you have the prophets, I send
them live his kids, his grandkids, his Sahaba, the Sahaba and their
kids and grandkids. How could they get things wrong?
Wish you'd have begged him he's gonna teach you how to dine.
Yes, keep teaching spread knowledge.
ArcView doesn't have a course on how to pray. I mean, how did you
record sujood? It's very useful for my convert friends, yes, we
put that on YouTube. Go to Safina site a YouTube playlist, how to
pray. Ahmed is gonna get you the playlist right now.
What is the ruling on people who do not believe in Hadith and only
follow Quran not Muslim.
If I forget to recite a sutra after oh, by the way novels, and
that means there is indeed
is indeed is indeed someone who says he's a Muslim, but his belief
system puts him outside of Islam. Why because you would end up
having to negate
that which is known in religion by necessity, such as Salah cm, many
how to do Hajj, how to do other things requires Hadith. So when
you negate Hadith, you, in fact, are not doing those things that
are known in religion by necessity. So you end up
not only you're not doing them, you don't believe that you have to
do them.
And that's why we say
that that person will be outside of Islam they will be as deep as
indeed for someone who's in fact outside of Islam while saying he's
a Muslim.
I
don't like to go around saying someone's a catheter, someone's a
Muslim, but we just need to know the category of these beliefs.
If I forgot to recite a sutra, after al Fatiha, do I do sudo de
sel or repeat that aka you do sudo de sel, because the SUTA after
Fatiha is a pseudonym or akkada
you don't repeat your prayer. You don't exit your prayer. You
continue praying this if you forgot, and then you make sudo to
sell before so then
can I take it over? We learned?
No. How do we reconcile working toward what you want, and making
staccato with
while considering the wisdom, of Immanuel thought saying don't try
to break down the barriers of clutter.
He didn't say don't try to break down the barriers of cutter he
just says you won't. So to leave that aside, don't even worry about
that has nothing to do with our course of action, our course of
action and our prayer has come from the Prophet Seisen Quran and
Hadith this April Yeah, mellow, take action. Make decisions, think
and take action, improve yourself better yourself, advance yourself
and praise to God.
If you have made a wrong decision, that is true, then you will see
that your course of action becomes impossible. Then you find another
course of action. That's it. But we're in a people of movement,
nonstop movement.
Do you have the same octet as Shiva Serato sheet I believe so?
Are there Hadith that contradict the Quran? Maybe on an external
apparent contradiction, but it can be understood in a different way
or in a in a correct way in which there is no contradiction but by
by theory, the prophet will never contradict the Quran Of course
not. Right. But you you're saying Could the wording of a hadith seem
to contradict the Quran? Yes. All right. I'll give you an example.
The Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam said none of you will enter
Paradise by your actions. Allah then says in the Quran, enter
Paradise by what you used to do.
With the hula Jana Bhima Quinton Tamarin prophesy some said linea
Hello Jana.
I hadn't be Amelie.
Ill and yet of a Medina lo barometer.
No one enters Paradise by his action except
led halogen family. India taka meadow Lobi rahmati. unless ALLAH
covers him with his mercy. They said had Santiago Sula, even you
must have Allah He said, even me. So how is it the Quran says Enter
Paradise by your action because of what you used to do. But the
prophesy assumes that no one answers paradise except by the
mercy of God, not by his action. The answer to that is, no one is
worthy of Paradise, except that ALLAH has mercy upon him.
And his degree in Paradise is by his actions, you see the
difference? So it seems to be that they're contradictory, but they're
actually not. Because one has to do with entering yes or no. The
other is what level so you're enter seventh heaven because your
actions were very good. Enter the fifth heaven because your actions
were good, and to the first heaven because your actions were lesser
than the other ones. So the rank of Paradise is by your actions,
but entering or not entering is by mercy. Divine Mercy. That's it. So
that's the answer to that question.
Now, another understanding of it is that you don't enter except by
Divine Mercy, but it's your action that earns you the mercy.
See how that worked. You don't enter except by Divine Mercy, but
it's your action that earned you the Divine Mercy. That's another
way to look at it.
Can one be in sad while following Hanafy and Maliki
in fit? Yes, you can. Nobody's there, no one's obligated to
learn the
kalam Animal Kingdom no one's obligated to learn Animal Kingdom
however you are forbidden from saying that this is an innovation
you would be contradicting your for the forefathers of the hunter
fees in the Americas if you say all this is an innovation
then then don't take their fifth either if there are Peter was so
off
is Salawat during sujood allowed yes it is allowed. So what's on
the prophets I said
it is is it okay to make specific dua for specific things.
It is permitted, but it is better to to have a general element to
it. Or to is to say or something similar to this. Oh Allah give me
this job or something better than right. Oh Allah give me this
husband or someone like him.
Good
smiley says today's questions are wild.
What is the book recommendation for masala * Hadith
once you stick up a link for masala Hadith I'm not familiar
with the actual titles in English
for masala Hadith
but what's in English though?
Were Hadith passed with attention to every word, or by the meaning
yes with attention to every word.
What is the Sunni position on the bash?
I don't want to come in on different whole different group
and then kick a can of worms or a hornet's nest.
Will you be doing a chef a intensive program?
Allah knows best we just did the Hanafi one. But I don't know if
we'll do a Sheffy one.
I don't see why we shouldn't.
Is pollution effects or for a thing to be haram? Like plastic
causes pollution? Yes, if you know that there's damage then
we're forbidden from doing such damage to the environment to the
world.
My family including me suffering greatly in our personal lives. I
can try to convince them to come to therapy. Would it better for me
to find a Muslim family counselor? I believe so. It doesn't
necessarily mean that a non Muslim can help you. In worldly matters,
a non Muslim can help in worldly matters. Even like communication
and things like that. It's always better to have the worldview of
of,
of a Muslim.
Question I saw shift a nice Atmos video about how the Prophet
sallallahu alayhi wa sallam did not get scared on his first ye.
What are your views on that? No, I didn't see it. But clearly the
Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa salam came down, ran down the mountain
came to the house and he said that to say does Khadija is a million
is a million so we just describe it as is we don't have to say what
the emotion was. Just describe it as as this is what the narration
said and that's it.
Good.
Good next question.
What are the extra virtuous acts or Sooners that we can do
throughout prayer
you can
recite it's virtuous to to be selective about their sutra that
you recite as opposed to reciting the very short soon as all the
time showing no effort. It's virtuous to make a long dua
Institute it's virtuous to make a long dua before salaam it is
virtuous to make dua for your parents
before Salaam and there are a special dua Against The Dead jet
and the fitness of the end of time and the fitness of the grave. Jay
before said I'm you should look up that door. Those are all things
that are virtuous in the Scylla.
I heard someone from the Olia was given the power of couldn't is
this possible? No, it's not like that. It's that there was
answered. That's it simple as that. Okay, when someone is so
obedient to Allah all the time, it is as if Allah reveals his will to
him in his heart. So he comes to desire it, he prays for it, and
he's given it to him. That's the understanding of mudgeeraba Dawa.
Because how is it that something is happening because I may do out
for it, because of what he may do out for it, when we know that it
only happened because Allah will write. The answer to that is that
for certain hearts that are so submissive to Allah and obedient
to Him,
He will manifest to them in his own way
to desire something, and they will only desire what He wills to
exist. So they will then pray for it and then it will come to exist.
That's how we understand. We Jabba Dawa.
Okay. Something doesn't happen because someone prayed for it.
Something happened because Allah willed it. But Allah reveals his
will in his own way. When we say reveal we don't meaning a book in
a law.
Good.
Meaning that he stimulates in that will lead to desire something and
when that will eat desire something is because Allah desires
it.
And he prays for it and it happens and that is the understanding of
Elmo, Jabba Dawa Philo E. l Padalka.
Okay.
So praise nameless convey Akun means Be and it is so we don't
have it's not that just a beat and it is no it's they pray for
something and it happens.
All their prayers are answered those
special types of people who are extremely pious and obedient to
God, that Allah subhana wa Tada answers all their prayers, even
sometimes before they make a DUA, they have a concern in their heart
on Allah fulfilled for them
are people who are living on usurped lands After being warned
to evacuated millet legitimate military targets? You'd need the
judges of the land of that area to determine that.
Got a lot of questions there. A lot of extra things surrounding
that. So whoever the judges are of that country, though, determine
that. How should you approach when you get into something
questionable from your shake? For example, he doesn't have a beard
but as Maliki
well
why didn't you assess all these things before taking him as a
chef? Because that's a pretty big thing. Obviously, he didn't,
you know, suddenly discover, oh, I realize after five years that he
doesn't have a beard? Wouldn't you have assessed all those things
before him?
Secondly, let me give you a rule of thumb. There are there are
objective sciences in this religion, Hadith, fill out the
things where what the chef is saying, I can look at it in the
book.
Those things, even if the chef has bad deeds,
as long as we know his knowledge of sound, you could take that
knowledge. Now what you don't want to take from someone who has bad
deeds and his in pious and shows lack of piety is spiritual
guidance. So when am I need to revive my heart? I won't go to
him.
So that's where we separate between the objective knowledge of
Sharia is, if he has it, and we can see his knowledge of sound and
it's corroborated in the books and the other shoe corroborate him,
then we take from his knowledge, even if he's sinful, okay? But
and of course, that sinfulness has a degree, right? There's a limit
of course, but
when it comes to spiritual guidance, such as I want to revive
my Iman and my heart that no I'm not going to take from somebody
who, who is like this I'm going to take from somebody who, who
clearly shows that he does a lot of acts of piety. Okay, who just
got suspended or
saying that you're scared to call up?
Zales but you live in the US? So it's understandable every single
stream like what besides Venus society what have you seen Zinus
and Judaism and titling their videos scientism against Israel
have you seen our Twitter account? Have you seen look at all the
likes look at all streams Yeah, we have the Israel flag after we got
banned. Yeah. Title we've been talking about XyO and we've been
tweeting about them forever
what is the ruling on permanent hair removal by laser for men on
the back chest and stomach permitted it is permitted to
remove that however the hour cannot be uncovered Of course he
said back stomach no problem but
there's no out of there okay, so no problem there but just you
cannot cover this is not a valid excuse to uncover you're outta to
another person you're out of being you're loaded with another your
private parts but for the back for the chest for the stomach.
hair can be removed there no problem
could you please do a video or series of video the pro
introductory comparative analysis of the difference in sort of the
four methods in Java we can if one is about to miss Allah can one
pray without will do never
know you can make Tamarindo
some about to miss Salah regardless of the reason I could
be sinful for that or I could not be sinful. But I'm about to miss
this Allah I see that a man walking to give the event right
now.
There is no way I'm gonna get one record in. If I go make me do what
I do I make to him.
Yeah, I go get a rock, make tambem wipe touched the tap the rock, tap
my hands, tap my face or rub my hands on my face. Allahu Akbar,
pray with the shortest I can pray and achieve perform one raka
before he calls them.
Now, if and this was valid, but if I had delayed the prayer out of
laziness, I'm sinful. But this was valid.
And if I had an excuse that I'm not sinful and this was valid,
make sense?
Safina society checkout page is not working properly for ArcView
essentials. Ooh, that's not good. Can you tell a man
I'm taking yourself a fit course. It was mentioned in class that a
female
slaves our data is the same as the power of a man from the navel to
the knee.
Okay.
I don't know about that. I can't answer that question
because I'm not a Shafi and I don't have experience with slaves
I don't know about that Mrs. Brother in him or sister lamb
that
isn't an insult to get therapy let Why not was an insult it's not an
insult to get therapy. Nothing wrong with it.
What is ultimately a clean, clean, clean clean area clean? says Mr.
Ajay Excellent question.
certainty. I'm certain about something it has three levels
certainty based upon knowledge.
certainty based upon witnessing and certainly based on experience
a mammal has said he says if a trustworthy person CNN
some people don't trust them, Weather Channel Weather Channel
comes and tells you there is a forest fire
in such a location now Weather Channel this trustworthy, right?
So we now have certainty that there is a forest fire in such an
location
but now somebody comes from the forest fire and said I saw it who
is stronger in their certainty the one who heard it from weather
channel.com Or the one who saw it.
Of course the one who saw it right now a third person comes in with a
burn mark and a bandage. And he said I was there. I was in the
forest and I got burned. Now who is even greater of certainty? The
one who was who touched it
and was in it the one who saw it or the one who heard about it from
weather channel.com Of course the one who heard who was there okay
so that is how to do clean than I need to clean then l Millia clean
that's the answer is that all right oh world prize on Instagram
has some of that to say what are they saying there I'm sorry I'm
the new is this one if you're medically fit mainly I if I'm
giving you a off the cuff ruling it's medically fit
our app does living Alia that can change reality look No no changing
reality they are just very pious, knowledgeable practicing Muslims
that the whole community relies upon whether they realize it or
not. That their emem is okay is very strong.
And the command they they're holding down the fort essential
that's the but in very simplest terms
that's what the dead are when one of them dies another one replaces
them. Can we pray for non believing family members? The
answer is yes. provided their life once they die then no. We don't
make dua for a person who died outside of Islam. Why? Because
they don't want those prayers.
Okay.
Can someone shot change hide his or her method? Yes. It's not like
a religion. Yeah, you can change them with them. But it should not
just be
for no reason. Right? For whimsical reasons. Even if it is
still valid, your worship is still valid but your way of doing things
is not good. Just whimsical. pneus. KENNETH Leachman says hold
on the How to Pray video is on ArcView so okay good. So it is on
ArcView
good
cap Muslim says how should we introduce the schools of law to
new Muslims
in the right time when they start asking questions and they need to
understand that the text of the religion some of it is explicit
and some of it needs interpretation
and by the way, we have a wonderful method playlist that the
brothers made for us so you can
you can watch that why don't you put the link okay
good
so it looks like Garfield got suspended here with Yuki
I don't know why he got suspended but he's out
no, we don't have an official list of rules. I think our rules are
basically
you gotta respect the religion
cannot say anything bad about the Prophet salallahu Salam much less
about about Allah about the Quran and you can't spam Why did them
what what's after the end of the Medicare go against the views of
Ibn Abdullah bar and Ibn rushed and others when it comes to clubs
I don't think they went against them. I think even Abdullah button
Hypno roasts are the ones who went against the majority.
That's why
Okay.
Kept Muslim says in earlier NBF. You mentioned the sheikh who was
wali he knows he is a Willie and the whole community recognize him
as well. He can you explain this one more time? Yes. We said that
Imam in no way an imam. It was
a drainie. They spoke about Wilaya. And they talked that the
willie can no he's a well, it is possible. What's the proof of
that? They said that the Sahaba are is a greater rank than a
Willie. And they knew that they were Sahaba and they were from an
agenda, such as Abu Bakar was told directly or from antigen Billa
libera. The Prophet said, I hear your footsteps in paradise. Many,
many, many Sahaba were told directly that they're people of
paradise. So it is possible that a Willie he knows his body he could
know he's lived through a vision through a dream. Is this knowledge
the same? No, the levels of certainty are different. Okay, so
we have to understand that to know something does not necessitate to
know it at the same level of certainty. As a verse of Quran or
Hadith, you have to understand that
a claim is not always the same, the claim so and so is a Willie of
Allah. Yes, it's my assessment. He's the woody. My assessment of
this dream means that he's already okay. So it could be within the
realm of speculation, right, but it's nonetheless a claim and a
belief.
So that's where when we see these big Imams such as Imam Minogue and
these other Imams who lead people, others lead people a couple of
hustlers Saturday. So the people believe he's overly he may believe
he's a holy Imam. And no, he says that if He's truly a Willie, that
knowledge will increase him in piety
and increase him in Taqwa.
And the whole society clearly sees he's a leader in the religion.
Right? Like does anyone doubt the Salahuddin a UB was like that?
That he clearly had a massive impact on the Ummah
How about Muhammad Fattah? Could you move the white over a little
bit so I can see the other the I just need to see the black the
Instagram Yeah, that's good. Good. There could be people who are only
Allah that nobody knows. And there could be people we assume our Lea
Allah and we assume wrong
so keep that in mind to remember when we make the claim. It does
not mean we're saying it's absolute knowledge. Not all claims
have to be absolute knowledge claims could be based upon
speculative knowledge speculation good
idea Ahmed says do Alison know hold that said no more I will
Roger Lowe John who made a mistake in it she had yes we said that he
tried to arrive at the right answer and he did it off man Qi
already answered the correct question I said that the medic is
didn't go again against Abdullah butter and even rushed there even
of the button of the roast went against the Medicus because who
came first them or other member custom
and so known
Okay
Can somebody say that shadow cutter Japan is both of them?
Yeah. By your speculation by your opinion that he is the greatest
source of guidance no problem you can believe of course greatest
source of guidance amongst all them up
not amongst the profits. So you have to understand what these the
what these words mean.
All right, let's go to next few questions and we wrap up.
If I have constant doubt about what I do for at least a day or
more, what do I do you ignore such a doubt at that point.
How do we reconcile to show you answers to us one shift says that
obstacles even those that can be overcome with time mean negative
secara and that the things should be left off versus your opinion.
Allow them to be honest with you. I don't believe that any little
tiny obstacle
is a sign that we should leave off the matter. I believe that the
obstacle that renders the matter impossible
is when we should leave off the matter. And Allah knows best. And
I think you can bring them two together. Is that continue praying
that is Takara and keep seeing if the obstacles away or more
obstacle comes in
son of Zeitgeist is spinning and he's gonna get banned, says
weatherman Qureshi
Malik's not clasping of the hand also has Hadith to back it so
don't use that excuse.
We put all those Hadith in Safina site.org/said
as a deal
okay, and let's see what all the final questions that we have. What
are the virtues of the month of Raja Bell Majora, a Toba is highly
encouraged, understood, father's highly encouraged and dredge up on
top of that. The beginning of the preparation from Robert for
Ramadan begins on a dip so if you have called up if you have
other things that you need to prepare for the month of Ramadan.
Mathematical he says the method of Madona is clearly in support a
bedroom bobbed butter was a great scholar but his fifth opinions
often leave the Masuda the method.
Right, and so is even the great if navvies Adel Kaido money. He has a
lot of Mossad, you could figure out that left the machine to the
method. Okay, so
good answer there.
What do you say to someone who says we don't need methods, we say
to them that is a method we don't need method is a method. What is a
method it's just a way of doing something. It's a methodology. So
if you're saying I don't need a methodology that actually is a
methodology. So let's see
how you went and let's see how you go about living your Islamic life.
Raising your family upon that raise a community upon that. Let's
fast forward 2530 years and then we can compare alright
is the action of companions of sunnah as long as it doesn't
contradict a hadith? It depends if it's many, many Sahaba, who acted
upon something like what like when a Khalifa rules upon something as
a judgment and all of the Sahaba accept such a judgment.
So that is EJ Mao Sahaba.
So and then you have a hadith that would seem to be the opposite of
that. There must be a way to bring the two together such as maybe the
Sahaba understood the prerequisites and the
preconditions of the Hadith, it will not be that all of the Sahaba
ignored the Hadith or didn't know a hadith okay, that will not be
the case.
Why? Because the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam
commanded us to follow the whole of Russia deen and Mandarin. And
the Prophet sallallahu sallam said Matt and Allah, he was hobby. Now,
could it be once a hobby? Yes, that one's a hobby, even to Sahaba
come to a conclusion. And that conclusion may end up being we
could say no, they're stronger evidence than that conclusion.
Yes, that's possible. But it's masked Sahaba. After a fetch,
we'll have one of the Allamah
sorry, of a ruling or a photo from a Khalifa or a policy established
by academia. Then all of the Sahaba were there witnessed it and
accepted it and nobody disputed it. We get each mass Sahaba based
upon that, okay.
Do you have to say another sort of in your prayer after fats you have
for your prayer to be valid? The answer is yes. For the first two
tacos. Okay. Yes, for the first two tacos, if you forget to recite
the sudo you do sudo to so if you intentionally do not recite a sudo
your prayers invalid
is that Imama Maliki specific not really medically specific is up
there in Mauritanians do always wear the black turban and I like
to wear the black turban because black is always cleaner than
sense. The white always gets dirty you know.
As a man physical therapist, am I allowed to make a manual therapy
session to a woman
manual therapy session.
Technically, you're actually not allowed to do that. Okay.
You're not allowed to do that.
My career and my job is that I'm a Seuss. Can I
you know, give a massage to a woman, recently a brother. I said
to him, Where are you been? You've been a long time. I haven't seen
you at Joomla his dad said he's now a massage therapist. So I was
like massage true. Exactly right. 19 year old girl says have groin
pain. You're gonna give that a massage stuff. Right?
Muhammad Islam, what is your question?
Semicolon said it's a stupid idea to say pick a method and follow it
just keeps the OMA divided. Follow evidences that's the correct
methodology.
You need to watch the videos.
John foreigner says, you mentioned in a previous video regarding
Wednesday, da Prophet made dua and it was not accepted until certain
time on Wednesday. Good. You mentioned that he came to believe
that due at that time was accepted? Does that mean the
Prophet was not already aware of the best time to make?
A good question? The answer to that question is that there was no
at that moment in time.
There was no concept that on Wednesday between Dora and acid is
an hour of acceptance.
But it's the opposite now, the Prophet was making dua, the moment
that Allah answers him that time becomes a sacred time, and that
place becomes a sacred place.
And so this hobby that was there with him Jebin Abdullah witnessed
this and understood the moment that the prophets I send them gets
an answer to his prayer that time and place becomes a sacred place.
Sacred meaning we hope that Da is answered more there and that
in the future that Allah Tada will continue to give at that time, and
in that place. That's the meaning of it. So no, at the time that the
Prophet began making that dot there was no concept that
Wednesday between Dora and ASA is a time where Allah will answer
prayers
All right, it looks like I can't see where Mohammed Islam answered.
Who is Mufti? auth man why lil mana? I have no idea.
No idea who you're talking about? Who's Mufti ottoman.
Mufti Osman Northmet Qureshi will be the Mufti trauma
okay
he's talking about Othman son of Farukh.
Or, I don't know I don't know to be honest with you.
I don't know what these been
Alright folks, looks like that's it. Here's the last question I was
saying. Can shuba heads appear if a person indulges in sin? What is
the cure to a person in a state like that?
If a person indulges his sin, his heart becomes dark and black.
If he doesn't really make Toba if he makes Toba, it becomes white
again.
But if he lives in sins, and he never makes Toba,
his heart becomes dark. And once your heart becomes dark, it's like
driving
and it's dark out. You can have an accident, right? What's gonna
happen is that shaytaan could put a doubt in your mind.
And that doubt can mess up your head and lead you to ideas that
are way off. Okay.
Well, ladies and gentlemen Joseph Campbell O'Hara Subhanak Allah
humo Byham Deke no shadow in LA Illa Illa and the software quality
with a well asked in Santa Fe across Illallah Dena Amina Amina
sada how to what was what was sub sub from Hamid Islam Sorry, there
was a comment asking you to debate somebody
you know, the only time I did that debate was really an accident when
I debated that guy in LA. I mean, he was nice to me at least but his
ideas were way off. Okay. And he was completely Australian his
ideas about the Prophet sallallahu Sallam ALLAH forgive him and guide
him and he got punished.
You know that he got punished after he debated me. And he's
he dug his heels in about this ridiculous belief that you don't
have to believe in the Prophet sighs
except in some capacity
All right. And he continued that disrespect to the property know
what his punishment was. His punishment was that zoo Yuna, la
he, it became a good idea in his mind to debate Daniel hockey.
It became a good idea in his mind to do it, and he did it. And that
was his punishment. All right. And then after that he Daniel wiped
with him the floor, and he got embarrassed and his organization
got upset and he had to resign from his organization. And now
he's a zero. May Allah guide him back to Islam to truth, and us as
well. Anybody can go astray We ask Allah to protect us from going
astray in those beliefs. those basic things belief in the
prophesy, son, we can't have a discussion on this could not be a
discussion. So may Allah Allah guide us and him. Okay. But we see
the results, not one year past he's gotten finished. Where do you
even see him anymore? Right. His organization did ask him not to be
part of it anymore.
He went off on a turkey kitchen, what got in your mind that you're
going to go and debate him and he's going to clean the floor with
you.
I'm going to be nice to you. I debated him I was very polite,
right? That was really nice to the guy. Because I'm not in the mood.
I'm not in the business of being nasty like them.
What got in your mind to go and debate uh, Daniel.
And then he just caught keeps calling you just fed and exposed
all your connections with the feds and all that nonsense. Okay.
So that but that wasn't expenses meant to be a debate. I didn't
ever intend to go to debate him I intended just to give a lecture in
his class what I thought that's what I thought it was. He I
thought he's given a lecture. You come and give a lecture about the
opposite position.
That's how it was framed to me. That's why I accepted it.
Otherwise, I never debate people. And then eventually it just went
you know why it is? Well, let's get a moderator. Let's put it on.
Online. I found myself in the debate. So Alright folks, Zach,
I'm located at Subhanak Allahu mobi. I'm Deke shadow Illa Allah
and Minister Farrakhan he will equip us in an insert another
vehicle Illa letting me know I'm going to say to her whatsoever
sobered up whatsoever also subbed was set up money comm.
Us
guys,