Shadee Elmasry – Do All Disbelievers Go To Hell in Islam

Do all disbelievers go to *? To me, they have different reasons

for believing what they believe. And sending them eternally to

hellfire doesn't seem very merciful. a more specific

question, why does it will tell you to go to jahannam? Even if you

have the profits so much All right, let's let's take this one

step at a time here, do all these levers go to help Allah told us

that those who have heard the message and rejected what is the

message, essentially just the identity that they're that God

sent a messenger name is Muhammad with a message with a book and the

religion is called Islam, just that basic. Now it's up to them,

it's up to them to just like when you say to somebody, there's

there's a fire downstairs, I don't need to go and go into more

details. Now it's up, it's on you, my liabilities God, now that may

not be the best tower, but it is sufficient then you also they must

be informed. There's punishment and reward in the next life.

There's resurrection. Okay, so that essential message of Islam

that you're responsible inside of God, God set created you made you

sent you a messenger sent you a book, and that there is

resurrection and punishment and reward. Because we can fathom that

someone says, Hey, God created us and send us a message in a

Muhammad if I'm someone who doesn't know about that Islam

talks about an afterlife, I don't have a motivation yet. So the fact

that I'm going to be judged is extremely important. And that's

part of the message of Islam that we given down so that by itself,

you've given the message now it's upon them now to research it and

to look at it because also you can't get subjective in this. You

can't get subjective say, Okay, well, first of all, you have to be

really nice. You got to be really smiling, your appearance has to

match the culture of that person is too much, right? Oh, you just

give the message those who have not received any message at all,

or received a distorted message, distorted message like the Nation

of Islam, it's called Islam, they call Allah and they call their

Prophet Mohammed. But it's a completely different identity,

Elijah Muhammad, obviously different identity, Allah they

even have some kind of, they say he manifested in the form of a man

and came down to the earth in the form of a man. So it's a whole

different religion, even if it's the names are the same. If someone

has received a distorted message or no message at all, then they

don't go to hellfire. They go to Paris, and that is by the Quranic

statement will not condemn while the Vienna Hatena, bathra Sula, we

are not punished until we send a messenger and that is what look,

if it dunya will occur, not just in the dunya, it's in the dunya.

And in there, and as for the Hadith, that there'll be

resurrected, and they will be tested with a test from Allah on

the Day of Judgment is an had Hadith that the ultimate say that

if we choose one or the two, we're going to choose the verse of Quran

because the Quran also tells us that this is the abode of testing,

not the other life. The afterlife is not the abode of testing. This

is the abode of testing. What do the scholars do when there is such

a seeming apparent contradiction, they simply suspend it. They don't

say that it's a false Hadith, but they say we don't know what the

prophet meant. We don't know if there was more to it that the

prophets I send them said that we don't know. So that's the first

question. So not all disbelievers go through but the disbeliever has

received the message. Yeah, so Allah tells us he's he's on a path

to hellfire. We say this person died a death that is earning

hellfire. He earns it what Allah does with them. That's his

business. But that's what he's earned. And that's the threat.

That is what Allah is threatening, so that I've seen the classical

interpretation for this, which means he knows what I just said,

he knows that, all right, but it doesn't logically appeal to me. So

what would logically appeal to you? How about this? What What if

we said you about you stand at the gates of heaven and *, and you

decide, would you like that? Now most people don't make a lot of

people, you have to have two answers, either. Yes, I would. or

No, Allah is the more merciful than me. If you say yes, I would

love that. And I would put everyone in Paradise because I

based on what knowledge right, based on what right, so the the

idea of I don't like something, how do you even know that heaven

and * exists in the first place? Right? It's from Allah. And

Allah tells you he's the most merciful and he's the most

knowledgeable to so why are you worried? Why are you worrying

yourself with this issue? You don't even believe in heaven and

*, except because Allah told us about this Heaven and * is not

something you're going to think about, or do some kind of

demonstrative experiment to discover that it exists like

electricity, right? You only believe in it because Allah

subhanaw taala informed us about it. Well, Allah also informed us

that he knows best, he has wise purposes, and he's the most

compassionate now when you say that I will tell them or some non

believer who thinks that he genuinely doesn't believe in Islam

and generally believes in Catholicism for example, or else

it will help the Prophet peace be upon him so much and you in your

conception think that that's not merciful that they would go to

hellfire. Let's look at what you actually know. What do you

actually know? You only know what the person told you. You only know

the outward of what Ebeltoft did even let's leave out outside

because that's a there's awkward, even if it's weak but let's say

there's so so leave that up. You only know what the person the

outward of the person or you can actually make a judgement just on

the out external the person and you don't know what

actually moved in his heart. So you should if you're fair actually

disqualify yourself as a judge lack of knowledge. I don't know

enough. That's really what you should say, I really don't know

enough. I don't know about people to make a judgment on them in

terms of heaven and * in the sense of like, why do they earn

that? Why did they deserve that? All that we could say is that we

hold Allah to be most knowledgeable, Most Merciful. And

this is what he's told us. It's not anyone's decision that NATO

who has to go to heaven and * this what Allah told us that he's

going to do and he's threatened these people, if you get this

message and you don't believe I will put you in *. Okay, so the

summary of it is really this above your paygrade. And you should

disqualify. I understand that you have feelings towards these

people, but you don't have enough knowledge. You don't know about

them. You don't know what they do behind closed doors, you don't

know what goes on in their hearts. So that's the answer to that query

in that question.