Shadee Elmasry – Did the the Salaf have Madhabs Ep. 3 Debunking Madhab Myths
![Shadee Elmasry](https://artwork.muslimcentral.com/shadee-elmasry-150x150.jpg)
AI: Summary ©
AI: Transcript ©
med hubs were the concept of med hubs the concept of following
someone when you don't know an answer, and there's a lot of
discussion around this. But one of the major statements that relate
to this is from all of the above. And so I'll let him clipped up
when it comes to one inheritance question said, I'm ashamed from
Allah subhanaw taala to go against Abu Bakar.
In other words, there was a question in inheritance, the
inheritance of courses.
But there are details there are exceptions that are not in the
Quran. In one of those, we're not gonna get into that specific but
in one of those, every bucket had an opinion and Ahmad, how are
they different, but almost said here,
I'm ashamed in front of Allah to defer to go against Hubble bucket.
When I boubakeur passed away, and Obama became the Khalifa almost
said, I will go I will go by the book of Allah, and the son of his
messenger peace to be honored, but I will not restrict myself that
will go. So while Abubaker was alive, yet, he was a funny funny
follow them afterwards. He didn't consider himself obligated to
stick with the opinions of
the Prophet peace be upon him himself, said why as a judge? And
he said, why? And he said, Why will we rule by he said the book
of Allah. And if it's not at the book of Allah than the son of his
refer, ESP water, and if it's not there, he said, then by my
opinion, so therefore the Prophet in this hadith is confirming that
opinion exists in Sharia, yet, opinion becomes part of Sharia.
The opinion of course, based upon principles, a third one are all
made up of Dobson I'm Marvin Yasin and Abdullah and Miss ode to the
people of Kufa in Iraq. And he said, Falco, the one who Mao
didn't we
take from them and follow them? In other words, oh, people have
Gouveia? You don't know. You don't have knowledge? I'm sending you a
modern Yes. And I'm sending you a relevant message. These are your
events. The whole city was commanded to follow them. I was a
method yet, why would I follow them? If they're pointing me to
something upon which there's no difference? They're answering your
question that may not be directly in the Quran.
But why don't offer him a job simply say, learn the Quran from
the law. And so far, it didn't take them as it said.
Everyone was said Ashati
on any matter of discussion, would not make an opinion, but would
first ask what it said that he said.
If it had an opinion, do you follow that a bit, and he loved
him. So
they had been service
if he had an opinion,
and then he felt that will be been kept by the different a bit he
left his own opinion followed a living camp. So what are these?
Why did Zaven tablets follow Ali? Why didn't ever Musa Sid follow
him up?
They saw that this person knows most in the Quran. This person
knows most in judgment this person knows most in financial matters.
Yet all the prophets of Allah who it was some of them said
a frog Lucozade walk doc Molly, the best in matters of judgment,
like in court is the best in knowledge
of inheritance law is a so the prophet is recognizing expertise.
He's the expertise of this automatic lookup dog was
approached by obey of uncap the companion and he said to him, I've
always said why don't you use me as a governor? He said someone
with the knowledge of the Quran like you can never leave Medina
and all whatever helped us to say bits and MACOM they said Vidya,
but he was traveling one time at a question came up.
What did he say? He said, What a terrible place. A place that
doesn't have
any said Lola I knew yonder had a calmer now the words there are
questions that he could not answer and he's home.
And who did he follow? I leave it every thought. Even though he's at
a higher level. He's the Khalifa and said he's not the Khalifa. But
he recognized it knows things that I don't know. So the Sahaba
themselves, they were 120,000 Upon the death of the prophets of Allah
what He was said that not all of them are scholars. In fact, in the
finitude says you can count them. Look, these are the people that we
would today call muftis yet, what we're doing yours we looked at
everything in common sense. We looked at the meaning of what a
method is the definition why methods exist. We looked at
Quranic verses. Now we're looking at the sahaba. This in the Thomas
Abba, there were seven tonight
People will give rulings who give judgments said there are many
teachers teachers have the basics. But to give a fatwah to give a
religious Berdych ton of matter, that had not come up in the time
of the prophets, Allah. So there were only seven or nine. That's
it, and you can count them on your hands, and different Sahaba
followed different ones. Let's look at the second and third
generation. Even before the format dubs existed, there were two.
And they weren't based on people. They're based on locations, and no
Muslim says all these people were innovators. The first division of
matters of opinion were the people of Kuva. And the people of McCann,
muddy, we call them Edward, Edward Hadid, where as you're right, the
people who followed who had more knowledge in Hadith, more access
to Hadith and they followed that versus the people who would really
do a lot of thinking and analogy
and those are the people you don't see any Muslim saying all the
entire second and third generation were all deviant because they
followed by those Mali the the whole OMA was really in two
different methods as well. Hadith. Alright, and in the south in the
Hejaz andalo Right in Herat,