One of the most sound books in the world
Channel: Akram Nadwi
File Size: 75.28MB
so one of the change has been
that we go to start with an aka Dima Hey Muslim.
So in this way we also learn something about because Muslim, I returned we also introduction of Sahih Bukhari and also the methodology of yamahai Muslim both to the left from activity that mambu said, very often when people learn the methodology I found Bukhari Muslim, they learn through the books, a lot of heavy you know, you read most of the current books like that, that where you will learn what what is the methodology of Amhara Muslim, but we don't look directly from them. So this an effort to learn directly from a Muslim what he wants to teach what exactly his book is, and from that also, we can love or at least find out somehow that what about Buhari mythology is in Sharla.
So these two books Sahih Bukhari and Muslim
they're very well you know, they are the most sound books of Islam
and how the sciences they have developed a very well actually in the first and second century of aphasia. By the time I Buhari Muslim, they became on their height.
So, you know, in terms of the narrator's their biographies and all those to say, you know, these cars they have done so much work that no nation ever has done. So, in about a few that the company has and then diabelli and then people after them, and are studying properly that you know, how accurate is their relations, and things like that. And on the basis of data, they were able to judge who is more authentic, who is less authentic, who is weak and who is not, you know, who the strong narrator all these things, and then comparing between the narrations of the of all these people, so it took a lot of time, while hamdulillah they were able to buy that time to do all those things as
clearly as possible.
motif of Mega Moolah was written very early to by that time the science was destroyed, it was a stain on my rahula mainly to basically produce a book which was the best book up to that time. But as I mentioned science in the science have kept you know developing more and more until Imam Bukhari and Muslim these people come
when they wrote these two books, very quickly, it became very clear that these two books are the best books on how the basic electro electrical motor written very quickly people realize that the Bestival it did not It did not take any century or any period of time to understand what everybody knew. When a molecular motor it became very clear during his lifetime, that mothae is the best book of his evolution. And that way, people from all over the world you know, from his fan from, from perasaan, from from Iraq from everywhere, they start coming to learn more from Mali, to et during the lifetime what Malik Mata became famous and what I became so important, it now
became important and famous during his lifetime. It did not take any central to understanding our multi Mama.
He went in when he was alive and people are his contemporaries. They accepted they admitted that the fact is to advance
a deadly Masha Allah who actually is among the fastest prusa Malik he made very clear that you know that there's no book more sound than the the mortar.
So when Bukhari and Muslim were written down, people who were in the field, they could see with their eyes, where these books are coming from what the narrator's are how they have a selector, most of that you know, laquon Bukhari Muslim when they select a hadith This is not just their work, you know, in the classroom doors is to us you to discuss in every subject every chapter, what are the best Hadees to most of this is already accepted and known to the people to when Bihari Muslim did produce their worker, people already think they know they're in this chapter, these are the best studies and they could see that what they have done is actually a guide to Norse accepted by all the
people. So this theory that Buhari becomes so important after one century or this century, it is not right. You know, many people don't the word hypothesis, some people actually they're looking for a particular reference is somebody used the word elect more sound or something like that. To then they think it does the first time Bihari hasn't accepted either bistable this is not true. If you read the inner history of that early period, you can see Luckily, I soon as I turned down, people accepted people like a massage, all the glue the feel of the Hadith, even among humble people like that they accepted that this is amazing.
Work and they accepted this actually, you know, they could have some you know, some some mistake they can find it, but the cushy among all the books which existed, they are the best people have seen. So a few books became very early I the main books of Islam.
And the reference for that former Iraqi currency you have the video is actually contemporary and destruction Buhari. He keeps referring to cyber Hari.
So that, you know, that's very clear. And also you can see him have the heart in a Razzie who is sent up over hottie murase he keeps referring to these people. So, they are effort and what they have done was accepted for a very beginning. why I'm saying this, because you can see really, the one of the word orientis is very distinct, very, it is so different, there there is always to find actually, exactly, you know, certain phrase, which can make clear that these are the best book, but if you read the history of the lots of the Hadees at that time, you can see that not no work at that time existed, which can be compared with people have no no doubt about that further, if
it took ages to include in the Marja amongst six books that accuracy because there's so many Versa equality limiter on More importantly, myself even the majority of these people in Maya died in year 273.
But in a tuna crudo serrania Marja among the six books, it took many many centuries
because for many people that are was much more important in the merger to some people that I was equating the merger to there could be some problem to accept in the merger Arsenal
to the Krasnodar me among the main books of Islam. It took you know a lot of time but it never has been disputed among the people to recognize a Buhari Muslim you know as early as possible at any center after after they have written since they have been written down. Everybody's coming to love them. people admire them they accept them a waiver people talk any word what are the main books of Islam? The first name come to their mind is Bukhari Muslim. These two names are the foster dad became very very clearly very established.
I'll just mention you know what his story and that will tell you you know, that how from very early people accepted these books
nasaka has written
an enormous he has written terrible kamaal that abou iE seyyed ignores the man ignore second
was an Abu Ali Saeed ignores the man in the second it well known here it looks like
he was expelled Angela Hartfield, and about Daddy, Nas Isla missler. Later he settled in Egypt, originally from Belgrade, but certainly in Egypt, he died in there 350 53.
But this thing, you know, he became a teacher very early. So one day all the people, a group of the people of the Hadith, they came to him and said to him in nella portafill Hadith, or the cateura Elena, there are so many writers of Hadith you can see really that by that time there are hundreds of them written not only one two, hundreds of the books are there for our masani Mahajan even more sadhana, SONA, hundreds of the book are written to people of the holidays came to him and decided there are so many books, plenty
in the beautiful Hadith Hadith or the castrato Halina follow that Dinesh Allah in Napa Cerro la minha.
We want to chef Musa the teacher if he can tell us what are the main books in the debt we can find ourself
first, he became quite what the harder is it for us Raja are abohar reason. And then he took out from his house for parts of the book
for Nevada are about the heart I love about and he put them in in order one the second, the third one, the fourth one. And he said her the he our duty Salaam. These are the foundations of Islam. These books are foundations of Islam.
petard, Bihari wakita, muslimeen wakita without wakita wanna say?
The first time you got photobooks
to Iran you can see him I'm gonna say he has died. You know, illness 803 under three.
It Mr. Khan is saying this thing. Just basically the second is among the
two he's a second generation and by
The time you know, even before the reference our fingers I'm telling you just to see Mr. Vanessa who died just under three. You know just few years later. You know when people called for books office alarm examiner says book one of them.
an Imam Nephi himself actually accepted Buhari to work. There Buhari is the best in this matter. So you can see Buhari being the top in the list that never has been disputed.
Muslim are still being next to it that never had been disputed. Then after that, it took a little while to include these two other books or without an essay to these four books. You can see our earliest reference with regard either for books is this one for the first one we got during the lifetime of hambo hardy Muslim but first time where Muslims started talking about it in a manner books main source of Islam to the first time in six weeks about foldables to win the mindset for books first one is Sahih Bukhari there's a mostly no dispute, then it comes up without an aside to these four books.
Then after a while,
they also included sonar three MIDI in our book also became part of the cavada slab Foundation, five books very quickly, our earliest reference we don't know, but we have seen that in our selfie who lived 100 years. So he was born in 400 something
and Danny 576
in his lifetime he but he started writing and teaching he used to emphasize our importance after me and he is the first in reference we found I did a movie being part after these important words Islam. First time we found clear reference in the writings of our Salafi
it could be read before that but the first time clear reference to now for from for books we can begin to find books.
And he wrote in the mocha DOMA he wrote
Padma sunanda he said one Makita
for four who are hired to record to be the Hamsa allottee in his waterpocket Dima to produce it soon enough or without indebted Mahatma he writes for a Makita
for who are hiding kotoba Hamza, and Lottie Fatah
merfolk, the high profile hadith
of Nova anata Buddha, what
he is saying, the people who are like Hollywood among the folk aha and is perhaps the hardest meaning at least there must be face teachers, if he's born in 470, something like that. The meaning is at least his teachers will be before him the meaning in the middle of fourth century or a beginning of the fifth century, basically to learn a primitive part of those books which are considered either foundations of Islam. Timothy also became part of that in the early two, he says five books
and then he also said one must
40,000 low Seton philosopher,
wahaca matar to aha to Kota Villa Hamza, unlucky takala, or a mouse shirt.
In a colostomy, the aneesa or a mouse sharpener, Harvey, east and west everywhere they agree to this agreement must have come in after a long time.
To more likely by the end of the third century, or a fourth century of beginning of the fifth pyramid, he also became part of this team. We've got five books now. I'll go to the homsar.
As much as
a Makita for how to be the Hamsa allottee
melfa her for her father, hobbies ANOVA her Allah kabuli her well,
then I will have bass a hammock in the evening Muhammad
died in the 521.
Bass or Hammad methodic in the Mohammed authority, died and 521
Allah Hafiz he is
at RAF, Allah to Allah hum sutra used to be like index. If you want to know your heart, this very sound to the you to write the first sentence of the beginning of a hadith and they will tell where you can find it, too. He wrote a raffle. So he thought the currency must be
By that, by that period already known to the people these five books
and there has me comes in five when he died in a 584 and he wrote his book shadow till I battle cancer, which everybody knows. And then after that everybody groups all the five books in it no NaVi and masala
and everybody agreed def these fives are five books are the soul of Islam.
That little bit later we don't exactly people started saying
to go to Cuba, Sita Sula, Sita that a word came a little bit after in during the sixth century after literally after that, which is the sixth book that had been disputed. The five books have been agreed upon Buhari Muslim Abood out to the Medina say this far five books I've never read from you can see from the beginning from the middle of first century are in the fourth century of being a fifth century, at least four books from the middle of fourth fourth century. But fifth one, maybe a little later, to five books haven't ever read. Buhari, mousseline abou doubt, the remit the NSA.
Then, in the seventh century, people started saying six books.
The sixth book has been disputed.
Seventh beginner says maybe sixth as well, but it is 70 where people can't find indication that we're charging
700 630/607 century
so people in Morocco in a western part of the world, our maybe a spoon de McCool, Murata, to when there's a sixth book, they have these five books and mortar,
the Buhari Muslim or Buddha Philomena say no,
to all this, there's six books, people in the East they started saying, even a mother but the mother was not so strong to some people used to change to Darwin sooner daarmee also don't even imagine that remain until Allah Hafiz will further unlock the sea. He wrote his book shuru to a medicine and that when he inclusa even a mother so to debt equity, how is because six to if you really want to know six? Yeah, it took a while for the people to start saying Allah, Allah su sitter. But if I Buhari and Muslim Atkinson, during the lifetime of Bukhari Muslim these two books became the most important books of Islam. anybody who'd in the field of the Hadith, they could see really that you
know, we had been discussing Saha this sound had in the classroom. These are the books which actually have gotten to know even people like him, you know, the teachers they could see. And during the lifetime of these people it no they're basically in our scholarship, and this practice was well established among the people. It is not true that Buhari became important in one city late or something no Buhari was important during the lifetime in a 200 blind person who consistently magnetically if you see the book Sahih Bukhari and compared with anything in that time, nobody can actually even even think really anything near to say Buhari is such a such a killer. Yes, such a
horrible saves a Muslim and among Muslim, Lee became potent because of his book. Other words, the only time a Muslim Muslim law buhari, buhari if did not rise, say Buhari, this still he's a big man, because, you know, his knowledge and expertise, his lack of a lack of Mahatma Razi abou Razi. These two people did not write any Seibu but they are well known ml expert of the Hadees. They know the same buhari, buhari his expertise was well known among the people like Mahatma Razi. But when he wrote a book, no doubt, he became more important Muslim was not so well recognized.
Though Levy's and Muslim became important during his lifetime it's because he wrote this book that book make clear to the people that he is also expert a same way I remember Hari and Marathi and Gujarati book make his book made him important. So no doubt
and one thing I claimed inshallah, in the process, you know, collecting all information, you know, to make very clear that Bukhari Muslim sidebar and say Muslim day became foundations of Islam and most solid book not after one century during that lifetime ifunbox Mambo hottie Muslim, the references went are Kotani actually in write critic nerd because you know, because a dark attorney became potent dark kutani doing this because it already important
that the reason
actually taking these two books are right at the top one reason why he why he's chosen these two books, really, if there are many other books equipped with him, why Dr. Putney had to start with these two books. Dr. Putney wrote his book.
He could have written that up on his offer, NASA is will offer something here. So acceptance is very important. But why does he have to choose, you know, these two books for a marriage? You can see me reflected on hockey. Why Hakeem had to write Mr. Callahan. Why not something else, it means when there's two lists are ready this is established and in an harco sepilok there are many indication that people already have been accepted these two books that he wants to
clarify, he wants to say that people are without death. So, he had this is what is he bokhara Muslim.
I was in a better more so he said he had this. So it is not true, really that you know, Bukhari and Muslim became important because of the writing of dharapani al Hakim no dark kutani and harking will lead in what are these two books because these two books already had been important and that's why after these two books, when people write what they call Mustafa, Mustafa is basically means that an expert of the Hadith who expert who can write his own
but he knows really he can't produce a work like Buhari,
they know the Carter produce a work like as a Muslim. Even if they make all effort, they can do something like that, to the new IDs started, okay. We accept these as best book. But listen, we can bring we can actually, you know, take an array the same habit with our own is not the most dahari means you take the Hadith Sahih Bukhari but you bring that Hadith throw your own, to why people started starting in from the first century. We know this, in writing Mustafa Raja Sabha
of Ravana, who's a stronger Muslim, he writes Mustafa smiley, he know he's so early, he must have wide these two books and
why people don't justify anything else. If there are any book in Islam equal to Bukhari Muslim, when people write why they don't write Mr. Harun on any other book.
And people say some somebody said that he smiled, he was able, he could have written his own book.
And he should have done due now the hubby comments that it is Mr. imaam is my is my laser in expertise, and he understanding that he wrote Mr. hora, but he knows that he can't win, if we're to say Buhari, that will not these people. So these two books became central for our very beginning, the people around distribute writing, you know, Mustafa down that mustard rock occult side in the book, you know, anyone has to write good criticism, you know, not to the nerdy book, he knows these are important work, they are the one where he needs to work something.
The reason I was spending so much time because, you know, there is some misunderstanding and misunderstanding has been, you know, been growing for you know, for a long time. And many people, you know, they they also add to that, I don't understand why 100 feet will have to wait in between, that people have no idea really, that in addition to the mother, you can not make
any work near to it is this impossible as somebody who's blind, even a blind person, nobody can think about that. But I don't understand why it started with my teacher Amala Rashid normani he the first person who insisted that most sound book in Islam after Quran is without atara Abu hanifa Rama love that and I discussed with him and with the new argument fasting really the never hybrid proven that this book ever had written down by a different I wrote an article and I've written a second article to refute the second earthquake some misunderstood the stimulus a new question to I'm dealing with that, that no single proof read has had it been Abu hanifa the work that should be the
first to work on a few people have read it. But the most important was arthritis or Muhammad and the six books what you know vertical Well,
if I will hanifa writes him says something that should be the most important work in any mother, like molecule have the most important work in water for every molecule in Shafi might have the most important thing Mushaf his own writing at risala whatever he wrote, that's the most important thing in our hanifa writes himself something that should be the most important work of the month. People should read, nobody knows that we're actually not part of the Ohio River River. We don't have any continuous is another summer of these books. Nothing does not exist. And there's so many plants in that. Nothing to do with and then making accusing Abdi Buhari must involve many, many things that
I've seen really what people because in order to
prove that, you know, clever is so important. The water could say Bukhari Muslim
This is not writing anyone who could cite these two books really did resign themselves because the books are known amazingly enough, so great. So that's one thing you know inshallah, in this class I will emphasize a dead white chocolate mocha drops a Muslim to make very clear what a Muslim sister what what exactly is doing and what has been misunderstood by many many people
so before starting as a Muslim just shooting
just you know, some little introduction, or we are mostly Muslim Allah tala. And then we start the mocha demo.
Truth really easy. These books daughter needed mocha demo, because when you mentioned when you said these names, you can't just say that introduction because it was heinous. It was understood by the experts of the hottest dose to when he said this or this hi to people like I was Razia hottie were lousy. They exactly know what you mean. To that well known that why Buhari did not make effort to Rademacher Dima because his name
is very clear what he means but later on we could don't under people are not in the field today don't understand what it means. But those when he wrote this thing was already known that not available in our Muslim also did not want to write a mocha dama Muslim was written mocha Dima because in his time a beta is something new started nice Allah He wanted to refute that for refuting of that new with a new idea in Islam. He wrote this mocha dama to the A manifested
refutation of something that why he was basically like mobilized to like look at them otherwise the books themselves the name is very clear what they're doing.
In our Muslim Moroccan Allah tala, his name is Abdullah escudier who said a name is a Muslim in a judge in the Muslim if the word even Akasha is can see it is not it does not allow people to just we did a few generation you can see the name is none already. He's Muslim father and grandfather Muslim Muslim evil hijab in the Muslim under the fourth generation ignore the talk did not Arabic name and it didn't even occur shall sit all Central Asia noon. Akashi passare does not mean he's a firm believer, Pasha, Waylon they used to having a will are more a lot, you know, just affiliation to your tribe.
And nice aboudi because from Nisha, a from well known family, good family he was born in more likely in the year 206 because we don't know exactly some people said 200 for some people who make less than people, but there are more indication that he was born in the year 206
if a true then he is a 10 year younger than Buhari because he was born with 194
so it's easy it no doubt well if we can understand that Muslim will miss many many shoe club ohare because by the time Muslim is started learning many of some features Buhari would have died but Buhari may anything you can see that if Buhari start learning he will start in here before Muslim a both start learning in the same age that in every single table harelbeke tinea Shinya to to Muslim and that exactly happened a little bit problem also have a
10 year gap and the second thing both are two different Bukhari the more active
Muslim Rama Allah tala who is a little bit lazy. So that laziness affected in it getting highest and he could have got something very higher but discipline happened Bahari from very beginning they actually met his his circumstance that helped him to become to be remain active.
See our Muslim Rama Allah tala first time when I start hearing the Hadees it was the year 218 282 you can see you know is a 12 year old or something like that, to Buhari will start earlier than Bokhari what basically what whenever 10 year old or 11 year old he is to discuss in the classroom. So you can see Buhari in that matter Buhari Oliver you can see more more active
it's an early start learning from the people like yahaya even a yahaya attorney who died India 226 Yeah, me. Me Me.
Dima Muslim got him you had the mean to the people who narrate a Mata for a Malik. Few of them are Kalia one is yahaya even Abdullah ibaka. In the risk motor family one of the more motor the motor is called rewired to yahia ibuka to his yahaya ignore dilla ignoble girl from Egypt. He's also
Secondly a year in the year a lady al Maliki al andalusi. His Mata became more famous, but people in the East did not know it to that no narration from
any of these books
do now when you say what that what everybody understanding more tougher yahaya even a lady but that was not known to people who had a Muslim did not did not have any access to that mortar to Indian books there are no narration of her data Mata from yahaya India lady Korean Spanish and until
the third one who is important
in nourishing water with malaria etc. yada yada yada Mimi Muslim was lucky that he got on a motor forum this year here to Hadith Amata in in Muslims mostly from yahaya India Tommy
then Muslim went far high in the year
220 220 he left
across a 10 year gap to mojari lift goes for India 210 on the Muslim list in 220
if boo Salim actually has done same with Buhari,
you know to be with God blame him anything but didn't hyper really he came he came with he went far high in 220. And he heard more from Carnegie Carnegie was the eldest chef Muslim ever can meet to at least he should have learned our motto for him when he left India Tamimi. his motto would have been very high and one of the important narration is Sahih Muslim.
But what happens is he came very quickly to his house, he left Makkah and come back to his home.
He did not continue journey that is not horrible, horrible, horrible, horrible to have to tell. He continued learning he continued traveling to he got all the big big shoe Muslim did not do this Muslim one far high in 220 10 year after Buhari, but he got back very quickly he really had had this for a few people one of these Carnaby somehow does not even you know properly and second pass 100 reuse of units and see people like that and quickly came home
then he nearly after 10 years, again ghosts are rarely
affected nearly around when is it 230 or maybe a little bit before that. See, by that time Bahar is a well established person
the Muslim became very late it Muslim had continued you know traveling after two when he left for height 220 then no doubt really who would have been in the highs and and all those things that he got all the big books, but that in he came quickly to his home and that is
this is what it must look our Muslim is a really amazing book. But one of the things that anybody can see very clearly you know, which really is not appropriate to a book like that. That is another Muslim the nozzle it is not even abou doubt is hardening Muslim in this matter is not you know not high bar is not very tough in this matter. Very very tough. But not Muslim.
Then he came back still he could have got some people he got some great people. One of them is Ali Evo Jada Joe Hurry, Ali, even will Judd as Joe hurry Olive Jana Joe he lived very long life to this good Muslim was lucky to get him an alum Jada Jo he's also a high teacher for Buhari as well. To Muslim came and he got alum jalaja Hurry and many many Hadith and ungenerous Hadith very highly from short one from people like that.
But the problem is our Ninja olimpija Joe Hurry, he was not good enough either.
And a Muslim is more strict about al Qaeda than Buhari.
He was accused of
some problem one of them is that olimpija Joe hurry used to sometime criticized Sahaba companions. So visiting Muslim did not like what happens when Muslim later on wrote his book. So he then he best did not include any Hadith. In his book,
Muslim accepted to make his book lower by doing that accept to include Ali in Malaysia did his book.
If you include him then he had it as a Muslim that no single Hadith where a Muslim narrator said directly from soufiane and shaba. The no single Hadith a Muslim has taken Elisa then he couldn't read Hadith directly from Chava. Directly mojari has got so many Buhari asunder family injured in every chapter Buhari has got Buhari did not reject Muslim rejected him to that middle Muslim book lower for a reason
A Muslim is more restricted in this matter.
Then after that Michelle traveled to Iraq Harriman and Egypt in all these places.
People divide a no bajas teachers in five classes, top one those who narrate her this from top
to do that the people who made boycott javita Buhari filati between Buhari and the professor, three people to the top people in Bihar is Sahih Bukhari abroad who narrate Hadith from the Abilene, like McKeen Ibrahim and people like him
that second generation of teachers are those people who met are and maybe did not know read from them on Earth, but very strongly to be still very, very high.
These two classes Muslim never met them, Muslim does not have any of them, the two classes are bucarest teachers Muslim and non Muslim non Muslim even end up without and these people they missed them
then because God is the middle you know middle teachers
they are the highest people for Muslim and abou doubt and people like to among them are people like both Eva and
Tommy these people today are the third examination for third glasspar Buhari and the first five Muslim
and then what is four to five Buhari that became second foreign Muslim and why the fifth that contemporary a Buhari that became the third generation third class of Muslim teachers in this matter Muslim is the lower than Buhari he that he is is not is not high in a Muslim that no Hadith with his philosophy, all the Hadees you know, just a robotic Musa between him and the prophets Allah highest is not for people.
The Buhari has got wanted to have this verb between him and the power source and the other
so that inshallah when you can see
okay, I'll continue something return but if you have to ask the rubric.
Okay, if you have questions.
we're gonna get who you mentioned that a sign of a books acceptance as it were it being taught within the middle of the month of Imam Malik and rusada numancia. And
then we have books around shelf a we have books in the hundreds of books around Mohammed, for example, are not generally taught in the hannity schools, which are the books that have 100 for example, you Muhammad Muhammad, Muhammad Yunus and Shivani they're not generally taught in Hanafi schools. So why do you see the sign of it except the sign of a book being taught generally as a sign of being accepted within the mother or from the original sources within the mother? Does that make sense? Yeah, but you know that that is very late thing in the beginning, Mr. mahama books were taught the popular you know, at least until third of third or fourth and even actually up to but you
know, these people they used to do the books, his books are popular people used to do later are welcome back at UCLA and they know they got hedaya but also know that they can just you know, they read these books but before that, those are the books will have to wait for you to read all the busaba Mohammed until he Sarasi comes and includes them in his mob suit, the big book with a part of that, but it still it will know to see like author for that give saying you know referring to Buddha Muhammad Allah Allah muscala Muhammad he keeps referring to Allah tala they were there but you know now 100 females are no doubt really like our mother mother in decline hyper so much now even don't
read you know, books or Salah co those people. I feel even without hardly anybody reads the book that in matassa T the highest book is hedaya It is so late.
Because people just want to know something in a concise or something like that which can fit in, you know, in their understanding.
Yeah, but you know, but in early suggestion to doubt it that way. The hard coated wire wire wire wire will sit for the spirit, everybody's to read.
But then we'll shuffle book as well. Later on in the book also not only in the beginning of the event, but not later on. Later, we will start just reading books of Novi and rafaelian people like that.
Two questions. First session when Mr. Muslim rahamallah side recite reading or learning from me I have in your head to me, where was this that he started his militia put in I suppose.
From his own calm, yeah, yeah. And secondly, Chef, what was the Do we know roughly what the nature of the criticisms of olive and Jonathan Joe had he was of the Sahaba What was it that because obviously I'm missing? Yeah. You know that
Last few things you know he abused like one other thing is olimpija
that we use to compare among the Sahaba to use Jabu Casa de Omar. Osama bin Laden was in Florida
I live in Georgia Georgia does not like a distinct he's against a no this respect of mana or this heater. He said someone who even does not know how to divorce and it's not always that he said just a child who does not know how to divorce comparing between Sahaba company with aboukir Omar, this house will do
the similar things he also said about other companies, some of time who deny somebody does not deny. Some people say like Jamia, somebody knows that there are actually very serious accusation against olimpija jewelry. Jewelry was a pious person, no doubt in the pious person. He's very accurate. Memory is very strong. Good narrations are very good. Because Bahar in this case is what he does it he looks for the people who academically they are sound if the narrations are sound, even if the Buddha Buhari does not mind it and take it from them. Muslim does the same thing but Muslim also test incarceration more about without a duty without more severe and allegedly bedava mostly Muslim
to Muslim trapped him do not do not
associate Is it possible that your mom Hydra himolla actually felt that his tactic was that Jodi's my wife was not what people are projecting often I this was not corrected what Jodi's saying, maybe whose beauty of it is that possible or actually it's not Buhari has taken her this evil people are worse than God. I don't think we'll defend his position very clear. He will not narrate from someone who's a liar who will accuse in memory of if somebody's academically very strong an array sound Hades, then with I will not stop him he will narrate her this and there's so many people are Buddha, people a Buddha in Buhari or more than a Muslim.
It makes very clear that Buhari is not so concerned about me that I later people become more concerned
shaves off and
we've got we know we know that Mr. Muslim because he discussed the book with your teachers
during their time. And then you mentioned from where it is it North man of second who died in 353 mentioning that is one of the core of Islam, but between the death of her and Muslim so I think Muslim dies in 266 or something between that period Do we have any any reference to the book itself being taught or revered? in those maybe 100 years almost as in between they pass away and the quotation from above already? Yeah. Because you have so much in relation to Buhari during his time. There are many, many narrations from Buhari many, many important innovations. But from those people asked innovation, but the book itself I mean, we have the book Sahih Bukhari being narrated from
Boko Haram as it is as it is Yes, it is. Not only probably many people that have many, many more rewired and different doors many pages of many many more rewire prefer the unpadded world people are coming to the east of Iraq from to to Baghdad to the places the first major to the left actually Buhari you can see that this is important because so import for the people from very early people became famous for this part. Even after say Buhari we don't find any book has so much respect I'd say Buhari
any Republic any biography anywhere that the first thing anybody but compare is it it will compare to say Buhari
and the second year you mentioned to me the referencing Buhari a lot of the time in Timothy he references Buhari himself as an he asked Buhari something from what he said x y and Zed. Does he does he referenced his Sahih as a book or is it Booker T cell Jama is about to enter Jama to meet a German German at least it will known yeah it he just said Jeremy tomorrow. He said that you know these are This Is Buhari which version with more right he said like you have this African suitors later on about it is Assa to Buhari did not make it my day he said but Buhari in Algeria has mentioned otherwise.
He can see him after he made the model Jama he referred he knows this this is a book Not Just me narration from Buhari so I the book. Well, no ill will won't do the lifetime.
you said that Mr. Muslim felt the need to write them a demo because of some bidda that had arisen. So what was that without people saying that
narrator's had to meet or pleonasm that was a dead or other problem cuz people have the Hadith. They never heard this condition to them actually Hadith if there's somebody Nerys from his contemporary, whether use unknown Allah or any akubra are the same like my mother or someone listen to whether you say hi Donna says he Allah say whoa now,
it all collected that word there has been all the time. This is the first time that you know some people come this and no one and cod are not very clear. And we cannot accept unless they prove that they have met or they have heard from each other that this bill never has been if you start that one that minimum how this sound how this will be drafted because you know not necessarily we have proof for every single thing that he felt needed to refute there. But unfortunately, what is refuting it later people they make that sound opinion what are we doing this time? That becomes a sound opinion. And people think that Muslim is wrong? What Muslim says about They say he might under control? Yeah,
what Muslim has been telling me shall come when I've been but this is the reason he wrote
about alternate the normal symbol of Allah in winstar teaching to explain the holidays in that time. Most of the coming and learning from him.
All the big people like
even Mahatma Robinette hottie from him, so just imagine
to call him when he was a Muslim is a cause of ohata Marathi senior to Muslim abou hottie Marathi equal same way I Bukhari but Abu hottie Maharaja nurse Hadees from for a Muslim and the mu syedna Haruna halfhill aha Medina selama mo Jose mahoosuc Emmanuel ame Lima two people like him then naritasan identity a big big people in our machi nada and Abu Hamza Michel de Alba said in in Muhammad in the CRT but I know the quality of what I want is for anyone who is a Muslim, he knows from he
and a blockbuster right. Even activity he mounted it in in JAMA Timothy had narrated one Hadith for Muslim.
So you can see the ultimate who died in the year 279. He wrote the book before that is can see he narrates in his journal. He headed for a Muslim
and that is in our song ba ma v. Asahi Hillel Siobhan, Leah Ramadan. To there he said had that Muslim Buddha judge Allah had that yahaya the HUD data Nabu, Mojave, and Mohammed Medina and Avi Sara Mata on Avi hora de la vida para su lies a La Silla. Aha su haidara Shabbat, the Ramadan. It is there.
In our Muslim, Allah tala was a rich man. He has a business trade. So it was easy for him to have enough money to he can survive that he did not need to earn money to assemble Hari Bukhari and Muslim they were lucky that they have business so the money keeps coming to them. So they spent so much time outside it
to this help them you know far for the scholarship. I think most of these people come from Central Asia. The rich people
do it in Islam so there have been poor poor people and they have been begging I'm like mama hombre Allah tala Imam Malik Omar Shafi to these will not receive my Maliki Masha Johan, but they are not rich people to you know that Miss Korea know these people prove that whether you're rich whether you're poor, if you really you know, devoting ourselves to something you can you can accept, you know richness of poverty cannot be stuffing under hard luck llama honey ma hanifa layth in the side, Buhari Muslim, they are rich people, but still is he managed to reach whether they're rich or poor. They continue to do their work. They are Muslim has gotten a property and business and
in 1000 A shabu
The reason they say he was he died Is that the one their Muslim hijab was teaching. And somebody asked him about a hadith which Muslim did not know.
He came to his house and he lit the lamp in the night to look find that had this in all his books. And he said in and he was in his room for the libraries in the library. And then he said to the family, nobody should enter into the room because they're busy just working looking for the holidays. They said we have got a basket full of debts.
Take that one you keep eating and researching, too. They gave him that
and he was so busy looking for the holidays. He didn't realize how much he ate. He kept eating
It becomes too much. And that was basically his death. Because if it had harmed him Sahaba they said he in the hoomin hamata he died because of too much eating other dates.
He didn't realize this, and he died in the 261 ophira.
He was less than 60 year old 50 something when he died very, not very long life said Buhari was not involved when we ordered him, but long not long life.
He did not leave any sun, but they are very likely he's descended from his daughter's side.
What the must have disputed the fact that also should be known very clearly. Because you can see that there have been this tradition to write a book of Tabata every month Takata Shafilea Takata Hanafi McCotter ohana Villa de molokhia. A very, very, very keen to include a very prominent person in their own Taka to make everybody Shafi Buhari will be Shafi imag Shafi people Muslim also because a Shafi so this is not writerly. These people don't have distinct
the truth really is if you look in these books, behind Abu Dhabi, clearly they are independent instead but without a book make very clear that he that most dead is either mustard either honey fine Moloch and Shafi he doesn't say buhari, buhari does not follow anybody
to Buhari and a Buddha among these six people Buhari Muslim without in Vienna cinema among this Kandahar without the
Muslim man naszej and tyranny the enemy Maja they are not mustard like data, but they follow the madaba Maha
meaning a default well sound has defaulted the hardest read the daughter started sound Hadith, then they follow their own mouths among those who are circuits they prefer one or the other for any reason that they do they don't follow anybody particularly this is not the way they are not a no just follow up one one particular person to the generally what in understood in the in the School of the Hadith there what they follow. Is it clear to mousseline to remove the NASA maija they are on the Mahabharata, people of Hadith which means where Hadith Casa de follow the Hadith and where there are no Hadith answer more details, sometimes they use their own understanding, and sometimes from
their own teachers or somebody who's primarily from the in the field of the Hadith, they will follow that, but they don't follow any particular image like Abu hanifa or Mali or Shafi they don't follow like that.
And that is right understand that.
is it multimedia is measured very nicely and it actually is right. The multimedia said in fatawa volume number 20 on page number 39 he said Mr. Bahari you are both out for eema man if you mean 100 he heard one Muslim what theorem Edu one NASA yo webinar Marja Wagner Jose ma wobbu Yalla what a bizarre one Haha, for whom Allah Madhavi Allah de
ley su alladhina lava hadn't be in the Himalaya, Allah ma
they don't follow any but each particular person one mill I'm Matilda moved to Haiti now, they are not liking but they do something sometimes they do have their own opinion they prefer one or the other. They do but they are not like those people that disagree in order to understand if you read the book these books you can see very clearly that without and Buhari then state that how they do
Maha Muslim Rama has been praised by the people found very earlier mentioned even his teachers used to praise him like it's hard to Matsu who's Muslim once he was teaching our Muslim was selected the Hadith which he could teach
this hacker man so
you know I as a Muslim and then his he said, Len na da Matta Hydra ma arpan la hooded Muslim in a
Muslim is a student but it still is hard Komatsu said we will never miss a good eye as long as the land leaves you ally ally for Muslims. I love you our life. We have no good we don't miss any good. These are paid by by his own teacher.
It's hot in Morocco. You know he said about Mr. Lim are your regimen Karna how great Muslim is MTC is harden is a demon great teachers.
The rulers in the chapeau they used to prefer in a Muslim fairy mama for reading the prayer.
And and there's so many preferring the button by many colors. We don't want to spell because it indicates
read his biography especially know you read in the cell RM novella to that will give you a good understanding of of mama similar from a loudhailer
so the way is that the HA you know, after 100 humble and olive madine
then the Taka Killa statically more Parliament for Hadith is Taka Bahari to when we set out to the Buhari, meaning the Buhari
Abou hotma Razi, I was Ravi to the top people who have this field of Hades in the you know, like heavily meaning they are the one who just had this sound what not sound in all Ireland problem. They were the top people after 100 100 and even be shaved by Oliver madine and 100 million after this, these people to talk to you in Hades are Buhari, Abu Razi of Mahatma Razi then asked next
after that one, the you know, the
the people who are really in the field, the the best among them is Muslim. To after Buhari is Tabata Muslim is a tough, you know, in the field of the hobby, and after mystery, then the say, in the next follow up
the man and after that comes to people like in a manner, but these are the people, you know, in different time.
I'm a Muslim sir, expertise was known as mentioned during his lifetime in a hotma Razi, who's contemporary Muslim as well. Ladies Junior but contemporary, he has returned Ghana Muslim baton melfa fall, Muslim was reliable or he was from expert after this caught up to an ogre.
I wrote her this from him in array, right is what the rando was. So Ada or B.
people ask my father about mousseline? And my father said sodoku is a true person, adobo hottie Mirage, like teachers often Muslim, but still he said about Muslim sadu
Muhammad Allah Bashar.
all these six books I mentioned Buhari was no doubt. So they have many teachers in common. But that nine teachers who are in all these six books, nine people, not everybody knows how to one of those nine people is Muhammad even Bashar from bussola a very, very nervous howdy from him Bukhari Muslim, Abu Tao Medina, Salem, everybody knows me, Muhammad, even a Shah, who died in the year 252.
All the six people then read the Hadith from him in their books. He said Mahatma Shah said, her father dunya are about to express the Hadees in the whole world. Therefore, the teacher of these people, the teacher of Bukhari Muslim, he said the expert of the Hadees in the dunya in the world are for a bazooka or Razi Muslim in law judge
Abdullah Abdullah doremi Somerton, Mohammed izmailovo hari bokhara for people to the first one, he mentioned Abu Razi the second he mentioned Muslim in law judge. The third one is mamdani, Abdullah, Rama doremi. And the fourth one, even Buhari these four people are experts of the Hadith in dunya in the whole world.
You can see Muslim, Muslim, Muslim, Chile's youngest of all these people. All these people Muslim in the youngest one
Buhari was born, as mentioned 194 Buhari, the 10 year old and then Muslim
azula Razi are also born in the same year like Buhari is if there is something that are even more senior if a senior than these people. The among these four people Muslim, his youngest, was still in. One of the teachers said that the four of people are experts are the hottest in the world.
Abu Abdullah Mohammed Ibrahim said in Namah herget nice Abu Salah satara Jolene Nasha has produced three people.
Mohamed El Bulli, who's senior to Buhari and divert the dispute between him Buhari were Muslim in alhaja whatever Ah, He even told him
about him Dan said I asked the other half in the octagon
about Buhari a Muslim Are you whom do you see from very beginning compared comparison between Bukhari Muslim no but no third person they're asking about these two people. These two people become Muslim became important because these two people are important to when people compare the compare between these two people are in your place from the first century again in the beginning the fourth, but you know he's among the junior to Bahamas to
I'm gonna dance I asked him to okudah Bukhari Muslim,
a young alum, Chaka Khan and Mohammad Ali were Muslim.
Muhammad Ali Muhammad Ali Muhammad Ali. He didn't ask who is Maura for Carla to La Mirada? I repeat the question no. So tell me who is the more more knowledgeable about this to *a Amara, aka Allah Muhammad in Allah Allah tofi Alicia, who abroad Muhammadu Buhari Maha Buhari sometime that mistake about the narrator's of Syria, some mistakes, whether they can have a harder kotoba home for another fee, cut he looked to the books and he looked in the books to when you take for the book sometime curfew sometime you can think somebody mentioned with the cornea a bit different from his name. When you will learn from a teacher he can verify that the name of the same person but by too from the
books, too sometime he makes him personalized to people.
Further, Obama zakharova hadn't been in the community wealth growth more than our service to he is confusing. Mr. Nan Rama muslimin facula Maja Auto amila Villa Philip idle, the unknown cuttable masani while I'm jack McCarthy, our murase Muslim does not have this mistake. Reason also, because Muslim is only concerned about Musa This one is more inviting in Denali, to when you have so much knowledge to certainly is no more mistakes.
Initial acid that Mr. Muslim has many people who are similar to him, some people are more important than the subject is equal to him. For a lot of arquata Allah vikita de la monotony Jew, whatever Muslim who wrote the book, he basically lifted everybody behind. The before the book there are many frequent to him but by this book he became equal to the stars was our ima man of jetan Ubud the OD guru who were you are two people who started her this with his name, and they keep repeating his name all the time, with Alec la eudaemonia
Muslim six parties in the Hadees in if you look at the book at Tommy's Tommy's a book is not completed, completed publish them is the book where Muslim discuss the pros in the Hadith. And if preferred, one has this over the other, if you read that, that book, it will tell you how much anonymous will help God Get out.
Get out Tommy's also helps you to understand Sahih Muslim, the when you see that Muslim as selectors or tell her this left something else, many of those things you already have discussed in this cutout Tommy's
not fully published.
There are fallible one in one of the example Hey, there are these insights in water. Buhari Muslim, they have so many restrictions. No doubt in Bukhari Muslim both you find if Harvey narrated by music by by Molly and by someone else? They will start the chapter with the hadith of Malik that what did you do in any chapter? If the Hadith from Malik and from you know from someone else? The chapter we started with? Malik sometimes they leave for a reason.
It is not easy to criticize Malik. But in one heartbeat, for example. He said where he treats his mother one How do you fit in Mata Malik had is over 183
which Muslim nurse in his time he is Muslim said so barnato are the HUD data Malecon? Anisha I mean, an AVI Avi Miss Orlando where his father and Mr. Abdullah Ahmed in Nairobi, Selena guerra, Omar,
Abdullah Amira, we prayed father binomials atop for a surah Yusuf wosu para adenopathy at an individual with a top rated surah Yusuf al surah. HUD slowly took how long it must be more than one hour. We know it to fortify your prayer.
Baby with Lana this. So then the problem here is in in Malik nereda different from his father from Abdullah
to marluxia the heisha an obeah and Abdullah Ahmed that was a Malik same water and that were Muslim has got from Malik student, Muslim sell for Hanukkah Sahaba sharmeen Hello mazarron ma they can fee harder is not fee ha Hadith, or other students have a sham. They differ from Mark in the Saudis Maliki The one who Sasha mana be here but everybody else does not say rip on a beat Not to mention other narrations. Abu Hassan Hassan aka Ronnie Abdullah Ahmed, Rocky Alicia, burning Abdullah Muhammad hottie Manisha
On a dilemma on so many measures, one after the other, that a very very narrated ad from Asia from Abdullah Ahmed, Maliki The only person who said hey Sha one an OBE
are a Muslim for how long that one me as a hobby fishermen, good
listener, I laugh a laugh in mullikin these are the few people in this Hadees all of them that differ from Malik
in this matter was lavabo mata Lu do nama Allah Malika the correct one is water, this is not water Malik said
to you can see how the computer in this one is Apple there are a few more examples I got
to this will tell you that Bali Muslim mother thinker you know, it's not like any any Mohammed he compares in nautically. In what his son What and this is very clearly from his book, The problem hyper relevant people read this book, and they teach it, they don't teach it the Muslim has it really very clear, he wants to make clear that you know, people can learn the science of Hadith more clearly for a Muslim than anybody else. But this is the book is the most clear book about the matter in how to prefer one or the other.
He named the book with either must not Asahi or the musasa Minister when the Napoli Lloyd Iris will last a lot.
And he mentioned the mocha Dima why he wrote his book and when we started with Padma I'll mention there
in our most recent book is the willow knife meaning it ademma kita, EMA data with taharah kitahara all organized, but the names of the chapters and the books are not written by the book had order but without chapter heading it all these are you know connected but if you know you can see here one chapter ends and the new chapter start but Muslim did not make any separation nothing that no it up nobody nothing is there he just from beginning to then he organized he put nicely left for Apple is somebody you know, poster or on massage together without Bismillahirrahmanirrahim
so it is still a very small difference but then you don't normally wear the suit unless you think the Muslim did not put any kita above
though the book is in order you work it out then second kitakata but the near the top of the man about a Baba taharah they don't exist. People later on they wanted to make it easier today other people they put started putting kita kita Willy market out there and in this matter people kept adding over the other two in everybody who has he's also a Muslim, they differ in the books and about Katana blog from the other people until he man nobody comes and he has many, many ticks. And now the more know his declaration, that became the most extended one after all, now we elevate who rose right a country as a Muslim, they basically take him on now is chapter nation either Muslims
one like in India people wrote commentary it our chapters are for Muslim For now, we know they follow them now, we can the most standard one
and now is Shafi
not very biased, but if certainly if he finds it that supports our Shafi mother to chapter heading will be there sometime very long chapter heading to it because like no one will see him still is shattered because of the chapter heading of Ivanova from Allah tala. And that actually is very clear from the chemistry of Norway. For apple in one other place. In nano we
discuss something in in volume number four on chapter number
In monnalisa, worked at a donor fee our karela Bob is the Dalai Lama kartu who fitted Yama,
we have mentioned in the adenomatous previous chapter de Lille of what I mentioned in the 30 ma 31. Was this heading to miss i was i was Mr. dacher. Hussein, he told me he says what Magna Carta who made the third Yamato chapter chapter heading is from no not for Muslim.
Similarly for another place, he said Wolfie obiano ma the corona avatar Gemma
it is there is a clear indication and that's why you can see keep deferring to
this either one or the problem of misunderstanding of the Sahih Muslim that now when you see a chapter heading and how this comes into a Muslim,
do you think this is the first or this in this chapter a call to Muslim? And then the chapter answer to what is the last this you think it is the last this in the in this chapter without realizing really that it's the being first heard this or last heard this depends on knowing now we would who divided about
Knowing what the made he's decided the first that that's what I did last night mostly in that a Muslim who decided this? He didn't know it. Now when you read Sai Muslim, you're reading with the eyes of Novi,
too in this chapter this hadith is the first Who said this? No, because you read that how reading because chapter headings are from an AVI That is the proper America please some people and somebody in Saudi Arabia has written a book and he wants to say that Sahih Muslim has no order. And then argumented in this chapter, this Hadees we Carissa decided that no order without realizing that this chapter headings are not for Muslim, you can't judge me
by the chapter headings. So, you know, this is one of the things inshallah I'll make it my mission. And when it comes to the macatawa this is one of the things that I'm emphasizing might actually already have done anyway, in my country as a Muslim to i divided into this whole work in a few stages to the first stage Well, you know, this is the first stage attack we are determined, what is the chapter Kitab and barbic.
To I got rid of all the chapter headings around now we and everybody else, I'll put new chapter heading, we know make a killer what is the first are these how Muslim start what Muslim has in mind, too, that is the first thing I have done the 200 that helped me a lot.
In Amsterdam, a lot Allah has selected this book from nearly 300,000 Hadees. I just want to finish it and we can have asked some questions anyway, because some of the things I will discuss when I started my next week, but the one thing is that people generally have been saying that between Bukhari Muslim the Mossad book Is Buhari. If you compare between Bukhari Muslim, Buhari, more sound, then than Muslim
except, Ariana Sabu
Sabu he said, that Muslim is more savvy than Bukhari and until now, everybody who could sign up wellness avoid death, you know, it got to be it's very clear and all those things, but Alhamdulillah now, through my reading and understanding, I really realized really, people are reading these two books from two different angles. What Aquinas or Buddha said that writing avoid unnecessary what he does he understand Muslims methodology he knows that in every chapter, the heavy Sahih Muslim is the Hadees which I
first heard this after that, that
he does not count mutawa if you follow Muslim methodology, they basically Muslim is more savvy than Bihari
because a Muslim not ever had this I marry her these are just matava supportive is not take them out. Remove them. What are left now compare the other one was Buhari they are more sound than Buhari. That mistake very little. Most mistakes in Muslim are a matava mostly some had been done in Muslim Animoto, but not an OSU and Muslim we actually had data for Sunni Muslim they are more sound than Bihari people who say Buhari is more sound they treat or say Muslim I seem to them they're sincere. So many had a Muslim advocate side not in Bukhari. tahari is a whole better than most of the Muslim to this is misunderstanding our Muslim methodology. If you understand Muslim methodology,
then it becomes clear that is far the sound of this Muslim is a more sound than Bihari. So this is one thing I handle a lot, a lot that I help me to understand for for my country. That Muslim is really more sound. I just know Bukhari has many many virtues, but from that angle safer Muslim more sound. If you just take those who are not motivated Karnataka, but not in condition he makes it clear in Makati. He will come
to I start with him and also one thing I the mission generally is not Buhari is higher than Muslim, but there are few is not where Muslim is higher than Buhari and especially hadith of a humble humble
Muslim has got Hadees our humble directly from number in the class. So Muslim narisawa number directly. Buhari did not come to an humble teaching. He was tough from teaching to Buhari only has time to do moussaka reviving the Hadees with a humble it is a moussaka behind the way he does not take her this amoda camera in order to include his book No, he does not do this to whenever he needs any hobbies. Number. He narrated that from someone for one number in Doha, this Muslim has become one level one degree higher than Bukhari Sahih Bukhari the no single Hadith basically, from an humble directly no similar these two advo hari does not have any Hadith from
novel hanifa he does not have any Hadees also from March
Shafi and he does not have any hobbies directly from Humber.
The only among the 40 must Buhari is actually very keen to her This is Malik ma Bukhari and Muslim both are full of the hadith of Malaga from about Allah to stop it here. And if you have any question please ask
pseudo logic which is like looking, do you know which do we know which here mom was some rahamallah studied from among 100 of them humble him Allah? versus a mumble Holly?
Yeah, that's a good question. It could be around
230 or something like that, that time and he came up with that it could be time that he can
dedicate time I think without so learn from double down on Muslim both and read directly from humble. A very, very yes in a read from someone from humble, but are without and Muslim. Then read from directly or without the more Muslim Listen, but both narrative and directly.
Hello, India. Yes, this is going back to the point about
the chapters. I still find it Buhari I mean the word that he's Muslim, the word that is produced having Buhari as a contemporary and, you know in in, in Harrisburg, you have chapters, but what was stopping him from you know, having those chapters in place for Muslim and, you know, just looking at the history now, all the confusion, you're talking about have made it public Muslim book without the chapters
you know, what stopped him from his including chapter as if it was something that was well known Buhari did it it would have probably stopped a lot of the confusion. Now, we find and
mojari actually the most hated and the highest purpose is not only sound How does he want to prove the sound how these are enough in our religion, he wants to have chapter heading on for every chapter heading Hebrews had this to make argument to see how this keeps repeating as well. His purpose is to prove that he had an another effort Muslim does not have distinguishing did not want to pro Muslims Muslim
to present to use sound heavy laden or repeating the word check is coming because his purpose is this, but this sound has this he also put them in an order to pay for policy but he did not want to basically force meaning that when he was chapter heading then you understand the how this in the light of this chapter heading there Why do you want to force an understanding Muslim does not do this Muslim just want to leave it open. And the other thing is a book of Muslim really difficult to put a heading that was that I realized now later on I realized that what what happened in Muslim Muslim is a very good in in order in order to heal start a chapter above the next above but a bit in
between those two BB there will be a hadith which will have a relation to the previous above and the next one we're going to include this one for this hour I have difficulty too big to them not basically you have to force yourself to put a chapter heading but otherwise the book does not accept that book is not written that way it is it is separate. So you can see the last half This chapter will have something which will be locked up that means that you move in from one to two other data set it up to one we move from one kitakata law so this will be a connection between the two cups. This keeps coming to it very difficult to because you know if you want to reveal that hey this is
not the last This is the bob last year the whole key
to how we're going to put a chapter that I difficulty I felt I have to explain that in the in the footnotes if you have to put chapter heading and do this to chip away at that now just because Muslims book actually is very difficult to put your head in the way he had done really amazing work it was it is inshallah complete I've done you can see how amazing the work is in many many, many many angles.
It's like to NASA was water chef is like the NASA of the sewer in this actually it was in the beginning I was confused. Then I realized but more of her identity Koran Karina Quran what Amala for he does, he said that sometime you read a canonical sir.
And then a verse a concert, you find no link between this verse and between there was said before that the reason is the versus before that they are like Joomla moderator The link is with a three or four was the default of them because the three have come to us has come to to remove some ambiguity some some color for simpler
Do you have to connect it with the Versa before that, that also I found a Muslim summer Hadeeth account for some time connection. But the next one just connected to the Versa this before that because these are just in between for some other purpose that Muslim case to really mess up. This actually has power for many Muslims unbelievable musataha number it Oracle Sahaba Abu Bakar Omar Oman it all the Sahaba sometime in the Muslim you find her data for Angela Sahabi we're actually Musa Musa from Roma, but he founded this hobby, too many people have been saying because Mr. Wagner will organize and this and that in all this profit in this problem can happen. Okay now on Humber
did not write properly. This is not really the reason is it because there he was to teach you something he believes that is her This is another foreign matava foresight he wants to remove some some misunderstanding to Hebrews another Hadees another Sahabi that actually he wants to teach something else there
is another Iran model, it is just a bring one or two Hadees from somewhere because there is something that need to be clarified that made clear. So actually, this is a mistake, I did one I once I found a hadith in Muslim until no connection to then I forced myself and I thought it must have been a mistake as if I change the order and put somewhere else. Whatever. There are no additional sessions are done. I have to look more careful. And then I'd look more carefully. And fall really has something as mine that I decide not to not to disturb the book.
And if I don't understand I can say in the footnote, I didn't understand that much better because there must be much more words which we don't understand. Very clever people there.
Okay, we can stop there. We'll stop for a break and recall come back in about 10 minutes.