Abdur Rahman ibn Yusuf Mangera – Q&A Why do some scholars appear in videos
AI: Summary ©
AI: Transcript ©
I am aware that taking pictures isn't allowed in Islam, but I have
seen a lot of Mathieson Mahnaz pictures on their profiles in
social networking site, I just like to know is permissible for
them and not for the general public. Now, there's two, there's
many opinions about this. And one opinion is that digital pictures
are okay. Because they're not real pictures, they're kind of
temporary pixelation coming together, etc. So based on that,
that's probably what those Molana or those Imams or those scholars
are, are going with. That's why they do that.
Those who consider that that is not permissible as well, then they
will avoid that. So whichever opinion you want to follow, for
good reasons, then that's what you'd need to follow. But if this
is if this question is coming from a woman, then another issue that
you have is that to display your face in front of men, that becomes
problematic, which is a different issue, right? So there's a man's
issue. And there's a woman's issue about this, about this thing, and
you have to be careful, even on social, you know, closed social
sites, where it's password, etc.
Especially Facebook, I would never trust them, because they always
have these loopholes through which you know, you can see pictures,
etc. And a husband has to be just sitting there by his wife, and
she's checking her Facebook that and then not every wife on your
group, or not every woman in your group is going to be very
particular that she's going to shield you away from everybody
else, you have to remember that as well.
But anyway, the principle is what I mentioned is a difference of
opinion about this, right about about digital pictures. And that's
why I follow the opinion after I came back from the US in USA, I
didn't when I came back from the US, I believe in Digital
Photography, for Beyonce, and for our purposes, and that's why we
have some some Academy and that's why we do that, because that is
what people are looking for. They're not gonna listen to audio,
there's very few people that are gonna listen to audio. And there's
a lot of stuff out there that is incorrectly done on the video. So
we're just trying to provide what we consider to be, you know,
something beneficial and shallow on video. And that's why Mufti
Rafi Osmani, one of the great the Mufti of them of Pakistan, on one
video, he says, that I have a fear that Allah subhanahu wa taala is
actually going to question us that you had this great means to
propagate your religion and you still refuse to do so using it.
Right? Because people are going to probably watch more video lectures
than they are going to read a book. Right in general in general
speaking, however, this doesn't mean that you then abuse that
system and then you know, you just so I try to avoid as much as
possible just general pitches and stuff like that. But when it comes
to videos, you know, I do that as well. But again, there's two
different there are two opinions on this. Bla