The conversation covers various versions and their significance of the Prophet sallamps, including the history of the Sunita series, the book "naughts a", and the importance of the Prophet system in various conspiracy theories. They also discuss the pros and cons of different versions of Islam, including one embarrassing and another a problem. The speakers emphasize the need for acceptance and acknowledgment for the negative consequences of the system, particularly in context to the profit system on women's health.
00:00:20 -->
00:00:59
Bismillah Rahim al hamdu Lillahi Rabbil alameen wa salatu salam ala Sayyidina. Muhammad Anwar Ali
was a big marine about today's topic is one of the most difficult topics, and I have been postponing
it for a long time. But then I realized that there's no point delaying it, you have to obviously,
deal with the facts, and then you know, discuss it in a academic manner. And, well, the fact of the
matter is, I would rather not have to discuss this topic and all of the allegations and all of the
stories and whatnot. But we're living in a climate and a time and a place where our profit system is
attacked by so many different sources by so many different people. And they bring forth all types of
00:00:59 -->
00:01:02
calumnies all types of issues. And
00:01:03 -->
00:01:18
I'd rather you hear it from me. And we discussed it in analytical detail the way that we talked
about the Satanic Verses, if you remember, we talked about it in a lot of detail. We mentioned
different reports. And then we came forth with a conclusion. And we explained, if you remember,
there were three different versions out there.
00:01:19 -->
00:02:01
Then we explained which one who said what and why each group said that. And similarly, the in this
case, the story of Xena been to judge is also a very contested and a very controversial and a very
sensitive story. And in some ways that is even more sensitive than the story of the Satanic Verses,
because it deals with what is considered to be a love story. by many of the non Muslims, it is
considered to be a story of issues and a story of muhabba. And so obviously, it becomes much more
sensitive. And it's a very awkward discussion to take place. And this is really an issue that many
of the later scholars, in fact, completely turned away from it and did not even mention it in their
00:02:01 -->
00:02:42
books. And we only find this in the earliest books, the versions that we're going to mention. And as
I said, had we been living in a different time and place in a very Islamic environment. There's no
need to go into all of these versions, but I would rather we talk about it in a confined
environment, so that when you're exposed to it outside by an Islamophobic person, by an anti Islamic
website by sources that are not so sympathetic, at least you will know the correct version, or at
least you know, what are semi plausible interpretations? And then we talked about it shall Allahu
taala in a more academic manner. Now, who is the nibin to judge and when did she marry the prophet
00:02:42 -->
00:03:28
SAW Selim and what is so controversial about the marriage? Well, Xena was not born Zeynep Xena was
born bhatura Xena was born Bala and she was from the tribe of the Bernabeu hoceima so she is not new
Hashem she is Cora Shiva. No Cosima is of the chorus tribes. She's over the bundle hoceima but her
mother was omega Binti abdon mo Polly. So the I'm of the process of the la vida, he was saying that
her mother is the sister of Abdullah. Right. And so from her mother's side, she becomes a first
cousin of our Prophet Muhammad sallallahu alayhi wa sallam. And she was around a decade or a decade
and a half younger than the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wasallam, probably more than a decade and a
00:03:28 -->
00:04:07
half younger than the Prophet so so again, as with all these birth dates, who keeps track of the
birthdays of those times? We don't know exactly how old she was when she married the process. But
most books say she was around 35 years old when she married the profits of the la vida. He was
selling them now. She had been previously married in Mecca, and she became divorced and she migrated
with her brother. She migrated with her brother and she had been divorced. So she is now available
for marriage. She migrated with her brother to Medina. And the Prophet says Adam sent a proposal on
behalf of his quote unquote, son, Zaid, because at that time, they was still his son, you understand
00:04:07 -->
00:04:48
what I'm saying? His Son, meaning the adopted son and his he was called they've been hammered up
until this point in time. So he sent a proposal on behalf of date that I want you to marry Zaid, and
she said, I am the widow of the chorus. I'm the most illegible Bachelorette of the kurush. And you
want me to marry date? So you can sense from the beginning. She's not too happy with date, that she
felt Zaid was not to her caliber that it's not going to work out and it is human nature that the
woman wants a man she can respect and look up to. And this is human nature. It is ingrained in the
fitrah. Right, and that is why I'm in a bit of a modern issue here. But somehow lo and a husband or
00:04:48 -->
00:04:59
when a man proposes to a woman he finds out the woman is, let's say earning more money than him or
has more degrees than what happens the man feels intimidated. No, no, I can't. It's not going to
work out whether it's right or wrong is besides the point
00:05:00 -->
00:05:41
Talking about human nature is human nature that it the woman wants somebody she can look up to and
respect. And the man wants someone that he has well field, okay, I am the man of the household,
right? I am the person who has the authority. So Xena felt that they this beneath her that he is not
a real prodigy. He is not someone that is worthy of Me. And so from the beginning she kind of said
it's not appropriate, but the prophets Islam insisted, and according to one interpretation, suta
that Isaiah verse 33 was revealed. Because of this as soon as a verse 33 Allah subhana wa tada says
in this verse will mark on any movement in one minute in either kado la hora, Zulu Amman, and you
00:05:42 -->
00:06:22
will hear two men under him as soon as ever 36 excuse me, that it is not appropriate for any man or
woman, once Alon is messenger have decreed something that they then follow their own opinion about
this issue. And we find in the earliest books of Tafseer, that there is an interpretation, this
verse was revealed because of Xena. When she and her brother said we're not going to get married to
date. Her brother as well says eight is not worthy for our family. And Allah then revealed that once
the messenger has made a choice, you cannot have another choice in this regard. And so when the ayah
was revealed, the both of them said we are content with Zaid and Xena is well known that eventually
00:06:22 -->
00:06:48
when she did marry the Prophet salallahu it who was setting them that she was really the only
competition that our Isha had in terms of muhabba in terms of love that the process of them had
issues only main competition was ative and the wives of the process and were divided into two camps,
the camp of Xena and the camp of Arusha, right, that you had a number of women that were in the camp
of Ayesha, the number one on the camp of Xena, and
00:06:49 -->
00:07:02
the long story of sort of getting big will never be limited to how to remember halala hula or
profit. Why do you make how long what Allah has made Helen? One interpretation was that this was
revealed because the process of them overstayed in the house of Xena.
00:07:03 -->
00:07:43
And he became so jealous that she and helps her concocted that story that when he enters in you
asked him what is that bad smell coming? And he stood and this is the honey that he was eating the
type of honey from the neighbor's house. And so the both of them said there's some bad smell coming
from you. So he said, Well, I am not going to ever eat a Zeno's house again, and then Allah revealed
in the Quran. Yeah, you in the bulimic? Hello Lola tepidarium OData is watching. That's one
interpretation that Buhari has in his side, the point being that Xena as Arusha herself says, and
this hadith is a Muslim. She was the only one who competed with me in status in the eyes of the
00:07:43 -->
00:08:25
prophet SAW sort of, she was the only lady who was a genuine competition for me, meaning while I was
alive, remember I had deja was another competition that was she's not in front of her. Zeynep is the
only one that is in front of her and therefore, after Isha, perhaps Xena was the most beloved but
obviously when he and Xena are both there, they don't know this, and the both of them are competing
for one another in this regard. Despite this jealousy, he has a lot of praise for Xena. And Isha
says we already mentioned in the story of the slander, that when the profitsystem asked Xena What
did you think of Arusha? Zane upset Yasuda I will only speak the truth. I know nothing but good of
00:08:25 -->
00:09:06
her. And Zane and Arusha herself said that xenophobes piety saved her from saying anything, whereas
her sister, and that was how men have been to judge this is in a vintage rush Hammond had been
rejected was one of those who spread the rumors, right. And her sister wanted to defend Xena not
defend but cause problems between Irish and the process and I'm out of a love for Xena, but Zeynep
herself. She has had her tequila prevented her. She had the opportunity to backstab but she did it
protocol prevented her and she didn't say anything. And Arusha herself says in another Hadeeth in
another incident when she spoke about Xena after the death Hosanna Ayesha herself said, I have never
00:09:06 -->
00:09:50
seen any woman more righteous in religion than her and more fearful of Allah. And more truthful in
her speech, and more caring for her relatives, and more generous with her charity, and more
energizing in her efforts to come closer to Allah subhanho wa Taala except that she had a temper
that would come quickly and then go away. This is a very beautiful Hadith where he praises enough in
an entire paragraph that it is a Muslim, an entire paragraph. She says I've never seen a more
religious lady than her. Imagine the wife of the process. I'm saying this about Xena and Xena was so
warm to a woman. She was one who regularly fasted and prayed and she was well known amongst the
00:09:50 -->
00:09:59
wives of the process and for being the most generous of all of his wives. She was called the mother
of the orphans and the mother of the poor. And in the famous Hadith
00:10:00 -->
00:10:35
When the wives were discussing, who will be the first wife to pass away after the prophet SAW Selim,
so the process name came out and he saw them all arguing and debating, he said, the one amongst you
that has the longest hand will be the first to meet me. And so for the next few years after the
death of the process, and they will all line up against a wall, and they would measure their hands,
they would have the hand put in who has the longest hand, eventually Xena was the first to die. They
understood what the process of them said, by the longest hand, the one who spends the most, the one
who spends the most because she was the one who would spend the most and so they realized what the
00:10:35 -->
00:11:15
prophet sallallahu Sallam meant, when did the process and marry Xena lots of reports. But in sha
Allah insha Allah the strongest opinion is that it took place in the beginning of little cards of
the fifth year of the hedgerow, the quarter of the fifth year of the Hydra. And we know this for
multiple reasons. Most importantly, the verses of hijab were revealed on the night of the wedding of
Zenith and the prophet SAW Selim, the verses of hijab came down before the wedding of Xena but the
process of there was no hijab. So women did not wear hijab, they did not cover themselves, the way
that the shediac required them to cover because there was no God revealed at that time. So when was
00:11:15 -->
00:11:27
the shady out of a job revealed the night of the wedding of Xena and the profits of the low sell
them that was when I actually a job came down. And we know in other reports that the hijab came down
in the corridor of the 15th of the hedgerow.
00:11:28 -->
00:12:10
We also know for a fact that the marriage took place before the slander of Russia, because Ayesha
mentions Zaynab, protecting her tongue during the slander so definitely before the slander and
therefore to say it occurred in the little corner of the fifth year of the hilldrup inshallah it
fits in perfectly. We also know before we get to the the controversial stuff, we also know that
Zainab walima was the most luxurious walima out of all of the wives of the Prophet system, that this
has mentioned in all the books of Hadith that the best walima that the process team gave for any of
his wives. Was that for Xena, and they asked us what was the walima he said, meat and bread until
00:12:10 -->
00:12:49
all the people were filled meat and bread, which is basically what our with him is that you I told
you many times they had no rice, the process of never ate rice in his life. Rice only came to the
Sahaba when they conquered the Persian and the Roman Empire. So the process never ate rice. So what
was the luxury bread? The staple starch was the bread and then meat. And so he he had all the meat
and all the bread which is to this day, this is what he meant Africa is right. And that was only for
Xena. For most of the otherwise they were they did not have the capacity to sacrifice an animal. It
was just whatever other food was available. But for Xena, he invited everyone he sent NSF pneumonic
00:12:50 -->
00:13:28
to, he gave a whole list as the wires go call aboubaker and Armando northman. And it gave a whole
long list. Then he said go to the people of the sofa. Then he said go to the masjid. Then he said go
into pathway that he said anybody whom you meet, call him. And so everybody came and they ate from a
small dish and and it says that I thought the dish would take care of two or three, but will lie
over 70 people ate from the dish and when they all finish it was still the same amount as it had in
the beginning. And therefore the story of the marriage of Xena is something well known. And the way
I'm going to discuss the the the story is actually do it in this matter will first discuss the verse
00:13:28 -->
00:13:47
in the Quran. Then we'll look at the books of Hadith. Then we'll look at the books of Sierra. Then
we'll look at the books of Tafseer. And we'll go in chronological order. Okay, we'll look at the
Koran What does the Quran have to say? Then we'll look at the books of the six books of Hadith. And
then we'll look at the books of sila. And then we'll look at the books of Tafseer.
00:13:48 -->
00:14:31
And as for the verse in the Quran, the primary verse, in fact, the only verse that explicitly
mentioned this is suitable as a verse 37 sunat that Isaiah verse 37. And what does the law say? And
this is right after as apt 36 which is according to the majority opinion also regarding Zainab, that
who no believing man or woman should ever have a say once alone is Mr. gem decided to do something.
The majority interpretation this also relates to Xena, Xena has marriage to date. Now verse 37. Now
you need to memorize this verse or at least the translation. What is the holy Linda he Anam Allahu
alayhi wa rahmatullahi and remember when you said to the one whom Allah has blessed with Islam, and
00:14:31 -->
00:14:59
the one you have blessed by freeing him and adopting him, what is the order of the anomala while he
will and I'm totally I'm sick alakazoo jack, keep your wife what tequila and fear Allah. So the
process is telling Zaid, keep your wife do not divorce her and fear Allah. What to what what took
Fifi Neff seeker mon la humo de and you hate it
00:15:00 -->
00:15:48
your self in your heart, that which Allah would make clear to the people. So the process is telling
Zaid, keep her fear Allah do not divorce her. But as you said this to Zaid, there was something in
your heart that you were hiding that which you are hiding, Allah would make it known to the people.
What Tasha, not why did you hide it? You were fearful of the people you didn't want the people to
speak while Allahu Dasha. But Allah has the ultimate right that he should be feared. He shouldn't
have been scared of the people. And this is an ATAR This is a minor rebuke about a for profit system
that why were you scared of the people you should have been scared of me not scared of the people.
00:15:49 -->
00:16:36
phylum, although they do mean high water law. Now, pause here completely irrelevant to this story
will not completely irrelevant, but it is not directly relevant to the marriage. The only Sahabi
ever mentioned by name is a right here in this verse ever. No Sahabi has the honor that Allah
mentioned him by his name in the Koran other than zero. And this is the biggest blessing that Allah
has given zaytoven Hadith, right? That Allah mentions him by his name, Allah, Allah say you don't
even Abu Bakar comes a distant second compared to this, that a lot of references him with the direct
pronoun, and a lot of calls him saw him, which is still good, but you can't compare to the hate.
00:16:36 -->
00:16:47
Right? And it is narrated that when the Prophet says Adam died, one of the Sahaba remarked, had Zaid
been alive, we would never have chosen aboubaker over him
00:16:48 -->
00:17:23
that it was an obvious choice if they'd had been alive, that we would have chosen z to be the next
or the first halifa. Right. So sades macom, unfortunately, is not known amongst many of the Muslims
because he died in the eighth year of the digital right. He died as we'll talk about in a very
actually very shortly, maybe two three weeks is going to come to incident of the death of eight. So
they died. It was a huge tragedy. The processor was crying he was visibly grief struck. And because
of this, most of us we don't understand the macom of Zaid who is eight and what is the mcommerce it
Allah mentions him by name in the Quran. So when they finished off and I'm apologize to them and
00:17:23 -->
00:18:10
Juan Pablo what Allah who is an Arabic expression, which basically means divorce took place there's
no need to go into linguistics is a deep meaning which no need to get into Wednesday divorced her
let's just translate it like this called all Lazzara who has other meanings, but the implication
Wednesday divorced her father Mercado, Zuma waterland Zola Janaka ha, we married you we married her
to you, though watch NACA. Once they divorce has finalized, we marry her to you so that there is no
hemorrhage there is no problem for any believer to marry the wives of their adopted sons underneath
him once they have divorced them. And of course, this is when we understand one of the wisdoms
00:18:10 -->
00:18:51
behind this that nobody denies that quote unquote adoption is not the same as a biological son. And
a quote unquote adopted son is never going to take the status of a real son. So the real son's wife
becomes a mom. But the adopted sons wife does not become a murderer, the biological sons wife, and
the biological daughters husband becomes the mother and for the parents, right? But not somebody
that you have raised as an orphan, and he's not your biological son or daughter that doesn't become
a model. So Allah thanks so that should there should be no problem after this, that anyone wants to
marry an ex wife of the adopted son or an ex husband of the adopted daughter. Now one of them wants
00:18:51 -->
00:19:23
to marry that is something that is allowed, what kind of Allahumma flula and the last command will
be done. Now the next verses are very beautiful, and they're very relevant. I'm not going to go into
them into detail. I want you to read them. The next page and a half is all about praising the
Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, the next page and a half that Allah says in the Quran, McKenna
Mohammedan Abba had emetogenic Malacca Rasulullah who will hurt me and Naveen Mohammed is not the
father and the Mohammed's name is mentioned and Allah only mentions his name four times in the Koran
and him his name is mentioned Makana Mohammed
00:19:25 -->
00:20:00
Mohammed Salim is not the father of any of your men. Rather, he is the hot women have been heroes
Rasulullah inhotim and Ambien. And then Allah says, Allah is the one who sends his Salat upon you
and eventually in the same surah next page, Allah says in the law how America to use aluna the nebby
Yeah, he will let the new soul do it. He was selling them with a slimmer Allahumma salli wa sallam
Asad Mohammed. So the whole page and a half is a praise for the prophet SAW. Right? Therefore, this
ayah is in the context actually comes at the beginning of an entire passage that the Prophet
00:20:00 -->
00:20:27
Sessoms. macom is praised. And Allah says mark and Island Navy him and hydrogen FEMA follow the law.
There is never any difficulty in anything that Allah has decreed for his prophet, there should be no
difficulty. And this is what Allah has decreed. So this is the Quran. What do we learn from the
Quran, we learn that the Prophet system told us they do not do force her, but he hid something in
his heart out of a fear of the people.
00:20:28 -->
00:20:39
And that which he hid his heart Allah would tell the people or Allah would indicate what it was.
This is what we learned primarily and we also learned that Allah married Zane up to the process of
directly.
00:20:40 -->
00:21:07
The watch took place, Allah azza wa jal revealed it in the Quran, the * contract we recited to
this day, this is the nikka contract, the * contract between Xena but the process of them it is
in the Quran, so totaliser and we were excited to this date. So, let us look at the books of Hadith,
the books of Hadith in Bukhari and Nativity, unnecessarily. Malik said that they came to the Prophet
salallahu alaihe salam complaining about zeyneb.
00:21:08 -->
00:21:39
But the prophet of Islam kept on saying to him, keep your wife don't divorce her, I'm sick, it was a
joke. And I said, if the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wasallam were to have hidden anything from the
Ye, he would have hidden this verse, this highly visible hottie. If you would have kept any ayah to
himself, he would have kept this is. So this is the Hadith in Bukhari. Notice, this version of
Bahati does not give us any details. Honestly, it only says,
00:21:41 -->
00:22:00
Zaid came to the process of him complaining and the process and said, keep your wife that's all it
says. What was he complaining? Why did the process Some say keep your wife what was he hiding? It's
not mentioned. So Bukhari and Muslim don't have anything explicit about the reason what Allah is
referencing that the process of them hid.
00:22:01 -->
00:22:45
We have other reports as well that don't quite mention this the reason or what the process of was
hiding, but to give other details that are interesting, but they're not quite relevant to our story
of them is insoluble hottie unece reports that diversity of hijab were revealed regarding Zeynep
that was when Allah revealed a job. The night of Zeno's marriage, Allah revealed nothing that I
attend a job. That was when I attend, hijab came down. And and I said, Xena would boast to the other
wives, the woman Illa, whom in focus of a semi what Allah has married me from above the seven
heavens, and another version, she would say to the other wives. As for you, your father's and your
00:22:45 -->
00:23:25
brother is married you off to the Prophet system. As for me, Allah marry me off to the Prophet
system from above the seven heavens. Okay, so what is to be expected as Dana is happy, she's proud,
she's boasting to the otherwise which is all isn't highlighted. We expected between co wives, she is
saying, I have this honor that none of you have that Allah married me off directly from above the
seven heavens in activity. We learned that our Isha says the same thing that is reported from us
that our issue says, If the Prophet system were to have hidden any idea from the Quran, he would
have hidden this ayah from Iran, which means this ayah is painful,
00:23:26 -->
00:23:38
which means this ayah is painful. And the Prophet system is being criticized in a way he has never
been criticized. And if he were to have hid something, he would have hid this ayah.
00:23:39 -->
00:23:52
So this ayah is telling us something that is awkward for the processor to tell, but because he is
honest, and he is solid, I mean, because he is Rasulullah sysm, he will reveal everything that Allah
has said.
00:23:53 -->
00:24:11
And there's only one Hadeeth in the Muslim Achmed that gives us some indication. And as is to be
expected, there is a controversy over its authenticity. This is how we're all going to get into the
whole issue of authenticity in the Muslim
00:24:13 -->
00:24:22
world from immaculate teacher who is married from hammarby been saved from fabric from Anna's that
the profitsystem came to the house of zedi benhadad.
00:24:23 -->
00:24:55
So he saw zeds wife, Zainab, in the house. Now, Mama, the shareholder, Mr. Mohammed says, I do not
know whether Anna's said the next statement or whether it was interpolated by my teacher Hamad. So
Hammad is the teacher of the teacher of environment. So the teacher says, I don't remember this
phrase, did it come from others? Or did it come from my own teacher? I don't remember where did it
come from? What was that phrase? So something entered his heart.
00:24:56 -->
00:24:59
Something entered the heart of the prophets list.
00:25:00 -->
00:25:20
firewalker vehicles be something came to the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam. So they came
complaining to her about him. But the prophet system said hold on to your wife and fear Allah, I'm
sick it kazuchika with tequila. And it was that when a law revealed sort of Eliza or at least this
verse of sulit Eliza
00:25:21 -->
00:25:26
and we also find in the books of Sierra and also in some books of editors such as soon and
unnecessary
00:25:28 -->
00:26:13
other details that are not relevant to the story that we're interested in but the relevant to the
the overall surrounding details and that is when they read Xena finished the Prophet system said to
date go to Zane up and mentioned my name to her. So pause here now, eventually they does end up
divorcing Zane up. Okay? The process of never told him to he eventually does it anyway, he divorces
Dana. And the profitsystem then tells eight go to the cleanup and mentioned my name does she if she
wants to marry me or not, in the version of inside the process of them said Tuesday, I don't trust
anyone more than you. So go to sign up on my behalf. And this is before hijab has been revealed. And
00:26:13 -->
00:26:27
so even though the divorce has been finalized, they can go and visit Xena because there is no hijab
as of yet. There is no segregation and whatnot that has not yet been revealed. And so Zaid goes to
Cena and he finds her
00:26:29 -->
00:26:44
getting the barley ready. So during the the middle, what is it called the grinding mill and just
basically cleaning the barley. And they says, When I saw her, I felt shyness that the Prophet system
had mentioned her name.
00:26:45 -->
00:27:27
So I turned around so that I don't see her. And I spoke to her with my back to her that Zaid is now
feeling a sense of higher that the process of has mentioned Xena, and he's interested. So I feel
awkward even though they had been married for at least three, three years, at least three years it
had been married. But now that the processor has mentioned her now he turns his back and he speaks
to her facing the wall and his back is to Xena and he says Oh, Zainab, the prophet system has
mentioned you and He has sent me to you, meaning Are you interested or not. And so Zayn have said, I
will not respond until I seek a loss assistance meaning prayers to heart. I will not respond until I
00:27:27 -->
00:27:38
seek Allah's assistance. And Zainab stood up to pray in her area of prayer which she had in the in
the house. And at that point in time, Allah revealed the verse of
00:27:40 -->
00:28:24
the witch Naka, and the profitsystem was sitting with our issue at this time, and he became the Bush
era, which means he closed his eyes and they could see that the water was coming down. And so he
then recited this verse, and he sent a messenger to Xena that this is the verse that has been
revealed. And he says, When I heard this verse, then there is a beautiful Arabic expression, which
has no English equivalent, but she basically said, I became struck with jealousy from every angle.
from every angle, I became struck with jealousy, because of what I knew of her beauty. And worse
than this, because of the manner in which there's a watch took place. And that is the Quran coming
00:28:24 -->
00:29:08
down. Right? And so when the reverse came down, so the Quran has been revealed, and this is of
course after the aid of zeta right after the aid of Zaid Zaid goes back and says design of the
processes interested, Zainab stands up to push harder, and basically even before she finishes her is
the harder is responded to by the Quran. The Quran comes down, and therefore, the prophets are
seldom entered into the house of Xena without any other marriage contract without any other
witnesses because it's in the Koran and the world is a witness without any worry being necessary
because Allah said so what Janaka and this was the only marriage in the history of the world
00:29:08 -->
00:29:39
basically, that was legitimize directly by Allah subhana wa Taala without the need of any other
method any witnesses any other Nick got nothing. Then he got his there in the Quran, zo wedge Naka
and the story, Allah says that which Naka, we married you to her house, who is going to now needs to
be a witness who needs to be the way that's it, end of story. Okay, so we're beginning to see some
of the problems or issues arising. Now let's look at the books of zero. We turn first and foremost
to evidence and
00:29:41 -->
00:29:57
even as half is something you should know about. We haven't really mentioned this before. But
unfortunately, one of the biggest criticisms against evidence hoc is that he, for the most part,
really ignored the wives of the processes and their stories.
00:29:58 -->
00:29:59
There's no separate section.
00:30:00 -->
00:30:44
The xojo of the Profit System, there's hardly anything just tidbits here and there, he doesn't have
a separate section dedicated to the wives of the Prophet system. And therefore, there's not anything
narrated and all of urbanist talk about the meaning of these verses about what the prophets of
Salaam hid in his heart, nothing is mentioned it's nothing neither this nor that. So we don't have
any luck with even his half. And it's not just presented, it's for most of the whys of the process,
and we really don't have much coming from a business Hawk. Even sad is the next authority of the
seal. And inside dice 230 digital and inside gives us a very detailed version, which I will call
00:30:44 -->
00:31:23
version a and there's only two versions version a version B. Okay? And version A is the problematic
version. Version A is the version that has caused a lot of criticism. And it is found in a lot of
detail in many many books. You are hearing it for the first time now from inside but as we will see
it's actually mentioned in many books. What is it been sighs version? Remember, this is version
eight. Inside says And when did he die to 30? Hey, Joe, we're going to do this chronologically.
We're going to see who said what, at what era because this shows things as well inside said the
Profit System and I'm quoting directly from him inside stuff aquatera have translated the process of
00:31:23 -->
00:31:41
went to visit Zaid but he was not home. And Zane up came to answer his knock. And this would be for
a job so there's not a problem. So she came wearing her regular address, meaning she's not wearing
anything extra because it's not her job. That's what she would have been wearing anyway.
00:31:42 -->
00:32:29
And said, He is not here or messenger of Allah, but come on in meaning the process of is visiting
How can you like not say anything? Come on in, but he turned away and he muttered, and the only
thing that she could hear was Subhana Allah and Allah subhana wa subtlely Falco loob Subhana Allah
Allah, Allah subhana wa sobre Falco and was the one who changes the hearts, the hearts are changing.
Zaid comes back, this is from inside. And Zainab tells him the process of visited he said Why didn't
you invite him in? She said I did. He said What did he say? zeyneb said I don't know but all I could
hear was Subhana Allah had Allah Subhana Masada de Falco loop. So zayde understood that perhaps the
00:32:29 -->
00:32:32
Profit System was inclined towards her.
00:32:33 -->
00:33:18
They understood that perhaps the process Zeno didn't understand. They understood by Subhana Masada
from Kuru, that perhaps the process was inclined towards her. And he went through the process of an
offer to divorce Xena, but the Prophet system said, I'm sick alakazoo Joker with tequila, which is
in the hold on, keep your wife and fear Allah. But after this incident, all that was remaining in
David's heart left, and he kept on insisting to the process of that he wanted to divorce, saying
that she had a sharp tongue saying that she kept putting him down and saying this thing that so they
never really got along with Xena. And so, they did not want to persist in the marriage. And he kept
00:33:18 -->
00:33:35
on asking the process of divorce and the process and kept on saying mc colloca xojo COVID tequila
eventually he divorces her meaning the process of never told him to do this, but he just could not
bear Zane up anymore, her tongue her sharpness whatever, he divorced her. And
00:33:37 -->
00:34:16
then when the processor was sitting without issue, the why he came upon him and he recited so little
aza. Okay, so this is insides version. And this is version a and this is the version that is
problematic. We understand why it is problematic. I don't need to explain, obviously, why it is
problematic. It's understood why it's problematic, right? The emotions that are felt this is what is
problematic, right that Dana is now married to Zaid and as the reversion very explicitly says that
he inclined towards her and he said Subhana light Allah subhana wa solderable kulu Now, this is what
we find in inside. Let us now look to the books of Tafseer. And we find the books of the scene will
00:34:16 -->
00:34:53
obviously concentrate on this first obviously because it's in the Quran. So every single book of
Tafseer ever written in the history of Islam has a version of events correct. You understand this
point? Because it's directly in the Quran. Right? And today, all of today from nine o'clock in the
morning I have been in my library looking up literally 4050 books about this and that this is
shallow. This research is new and novel and it is thoroughly done a shallow Tada. And I went over
dozens of the facets that I'm summarizing what we went through what I went over today. One of the
earliest stuff CDs in existence is that of more artistic, so a much more cartoonish romance. Here is
00:34:53 -->
00:34:59
the earliest of seed in print. More cognitivists with a man died 150 hedgerow. No buddy
00:35:00 -->
00:35:38
earlier than him we have that has written that to you. Now, Mahathir bin Sulaiman. He's actually not
a scholar, he's a storyteller. And he's not considered to be academically reliable. He's simply a
source is simply a person who just talks about stories. He's not reliable, so we don't turn to his
Tafseer. for reliability, we just turn to it to get a glimpse of what people were saying in 150. Ah,
that's really what we turn it to. We don't turn to it for reliable, if you will. And so demand is
not an academic scholar. He is a storyteller Of course, sauce. Right? And so we just turned to him
to see what people were saying not for academic opinions, more cartons of cereal mentions version a
00:35:38 -->
00:36:18
in quite a lot of vivid detail, more details that are found other places, but it is mentioned in
version eight. Right now, if more cartoon was the only person who mentioned version a, we would sell
hamdulillah he's the only person and the story. But he's not the only person we just had even said,
Now we have more cartoons. Now we turn to the next famous Tafseer and that is the absolute poverty
of poverty died 310 and that poverty is the most orthodox the most authentic, the Encyclopedia of
tissues. This is the bastion of Sunita, all of us come from poverty or poverty is the polymath is
the historian is the Sierra expert. He is the Mufasa This is authority in Mohammed material poverty,
00:36:19 -->
00:36:58
die 310 Hitler, October it mentions version a as basically the only version. It's the standard
version. And he mentions reports from Qatada and from Ibn Zayd and from other authorities that
explicitly mentioned version a and basically support this version. He goes back with his is not to
attack the who's kata kata is the student we've been abuzz, and cortada is the main Mufasa of the
tablet room. And cortada died 103 100 so Qatada says, What the profitsystem hid in his heart was the
desire that they divorce her.
00:36:59 -->
00:37:28
He wanted to divorce but he didn't say it. This is what he hid. And he mentioned from Urban's aid as
well, who's another scholar from the top your own similar reports, and this is the standard
understanding of poverty and authority is what poverty is, he is a one of the in fact frankly, he is
the greatest scholar of Tafseer of the early centuries, nobody is greater than of poverty. going
next in order to have seen another tip co written by a Persian Hanafi scholar by the name of summer
Conde
00:37:29 -->
00:38:02
who died 375 and he wrote a book called battle loom, and he basically mentioned the same version a
and the next version of cffc. Who died for 27, the same version. And then we have non Sunita sees a
machete in his car shop, the same story as a machete dies 538. We have found a dino Razi, who is a
famous Chinese scholar, and he has his serial COVID A Razzie die 610. He has all of this. So we have
all of these mufa soon mentioning version a as if it is the standard one. Okay, what is version B,
then let's get to version B.
00:38:03 -->
00:38:18
version B is not actually a specific incident. It's an interpretation. It's not a story. Version A
is a story. version B is no story is simply an interpretation of the verse. And what is this
interpretation? And where is the first book that mentions it? Well,
00:38:19 -->
00:38:52
the first printed book that I could find that mentions this is Albay happies della Nobu, and they
happily died 458 Digital, and then they have the and I'm not saying that it doesn't exist before
they happen. I'm saying in my limited library. This is all that I could come across and also online.
I downloaded some books today as well. I could not come across the book that is printed that has
this exact version before I'll be happy, but it is referenced before by healthy but not with this
explicitness so what is this version B? version B is the following.
00:38:54 -->
00:38:56
I release a new album, who's Allison?
00:38:59 -->
00:39:00
Who is Alexandra Aberdeen?
00:39:02 -->
00:39:03
Hussein's
00:39:05 -->
00:39:06
saying, son,
00:39:07 -->
00:39:13
I've been in it for St. Sun. Ali's Aberdeen asks one of his students one of his peers.
00:39:14 -->
00:39:20
What does hassanal basally say about this verse? Were to Fifi nuptse como la como de
00:39:22 -->
00:39:32
What does hesson albasini say about this verse? Were to faith enough say como la moody. So this
narrator says, I told him what Hudson says about the verse
00:39:34 -->
00:39:48
and from other reports, we find out that's version a he is saying, I told him this is what Hudson
says. Version a. It is no Aberdeen said no, not version a no. rather
00:39:49 -->
00:39:57
a loss subhanho wa Taala had informed the prophet SAW Selim that Xena would become his wife
00:39:59 -->
00:39:59
now
00:40:00 -->
00:40:42
That's version B. That's all version B's. Now pause here. This changes the whole dynamics, version
a, what was he hiding in his heart? His inclination for Xena clear. This is what he's hiding. He
wants to legitimately marry Xena. So he has an inclination towards her. So he wants to divorce but
he's not gonna say it. Why is he not gonna say it? Because the people are gonna say that Oh, he did.
He caused the to divorce and then he married the divorcee. Right? So this is version a, version B
says the following, that Allah had told the Prophet system that Xena will become your wife.
00:40:44 -->
00:40:48
So they now comes to him and Zaid says I want to marry Xena.
00:40:49 -->
00:40:55
And the Prophet says Allah knows that eventually, Zainab will be his wife.
00:40:56 -->
00:41:10
Knowing this, he tells eight don't divorce her. Why? Because he was scared. What was he scared of?
that the people will say he married the wife of his adopted son.
00:41:11 -->
00:41:13
Which is a Java No, no.
00:41:14 -->
00:41:39
Okay, you change the whole dynamics have been changed here. Okay, every single phrase has a
different linkage now. Okay. What did he hide in version a? His inclination? In version B, what did
he hide the fact that he knew that he would eventually marry Xena? Okay, version a, what was he
scared of? that people will spread rumors. version B. What was he scared of?
00:41:40 -->
00:41:41
What was he scared of?
00:41:48 -->
00:41:52
The the daily practice of marrying your
00:41:53 -->
00:42:31
adopted son was a very evil thing for them. So people say oh my god, he married the adopted his and
his adopted sons ex wife. Right? This is what he was scared of that this was a criticism. That was a
gigantic criticism. Okay, now, these are the version A's and the version B's. So version B
chronologically, it does seem to appear after version a. Now if you look at some early tough seers,
interestingly some early to see as mentioned both versions together. And most important amongst
them, we have even altea in his halmahera wedges and even Althea died
00:42:33 -->
00:43:05
500 and don't quote me to 540 or so 540 something without Leah died, if an idea mentions all the
version a in its entirety, and then he follows it up by mentioning version B. And then he leaves it
at that these are the two versions that are found this and that Alibaba we and Alibaba is a very
famous scholar of fct, he has a famous book called monomyth, Tansy and about who he died 516 Alba,
who he mentioned the same version a in great detail. And he actually quotes even Abbas even Ibis is
saying that what the processor hid, was a love for
00:43:06 -->
00:43:36
what to feed enough sick. What he hid was a love for Xena. But either he mentioned as saying that
what the processor hid was a hope that they would divorce her. But then he brings in version B. This
is a backhoe he, he brings in version B. And he quotes all of from Alabama hurricanes in Aberdeen.
And then he says, and I quote from above UI, and this second interpretation, version B, is more
befitting and more appropriate for them are part of the profits.
00:43:37 -->
00:43:43
So the first author to say version a seems to be problematic. Is that a bumblebee?
00:43:44 -->
00:43:50
In my reading, I haven't found anybody who even found version a problematic, poverty quotes it
nonscientific, nothing, no big deal.
00:43:51 -->
00:43:56
Even sad quote, all of these other authors are quoting it, Alibaba 516 says,
00:43:57 -->
00:44:06
some have said that version B is better, because it is more appropriate to the status of a profit.
00:44:07 -->
00:44:35
Now notice here by the way, why did he choose version beovision? a, not because of it's not not
because of quantity of people not be simply because in content, it makes more sense that the Prophet
should do version B and not version a, okay. This is the reason he prefers version B over version A,
then and then his very interesting he says, even if the first story version a is correct.
00:44:36 -->
00:44:47
The other interpretation, which is that he hid for her a love and a desire to marry her, is actually
not something that tarnishes the reputation of a prophet.
00:44:48 -->
00:44:58
So, Bravo, he says, I think version B is better, because that would make our life easier. But even
if you insist on version a
00:45:00 -->
00:45:22
Not the end of the story. Why? Because he says, it's not actually something that tarnishes the
reputation of a profit for a servant is not criticized for a desire that comes to the heart as long
as he does not intend any evil, because love and inclination is not something that is in the control
of men.
00:45:24 -->
00:45:33
And this is Alibaba from 516. Right at the turn of the fifth century, the turn of the sixth century.
At Baba, we're saying, I like version B, because
00:45:34 -->
00:46:08
it's easier for us to swallow. But even if we insist on version a, it's not a big deal, because it's
only an inclination of the heart. So we find here a shift now that version B seems to be getting a
little bit of traction. And then as we go on and on version B seems to take more and more role until
version a is actually ignored, and completely set aside and then castigated and then criticized and
then, as we will see, even more bizarre things are said about it. The next FC is of no Josie is
Zelma CW Josie died 597.
00:46:10 -->
00:46:50
A Nebula Josie says there are four opinions about what the profitsystem hid for opinions. Number
one, his love for Xena narrated by Ibis number two, a promise from a law that he would eventually
marry her as narrated by Xena IBT in this version a and version B. What is three and four? It's
actually version a as well. Number three, I wish that zayde would divorce her and this is what
cortada and mgh and MacArthur said, number four, the intention that if they divorced her, he would
marry her. And this is what has been reported from urban z. In other words, if you look at it, these
four opinions, he mentions, one, two, sorry, one, three, and four are all version a.
00:46:51 -->
00:47:33
one, three, and four are all version a, and then only two is version B. Right? So he says, This is
what has been married, what did he hide, a love for her hoping that they would divorce? Well, that's
the same thing. Or if they divorced our marriage, again, it's the same thing, right? version two is
only mentioned once and that is that Allah had told her he would marry Xena. And he then says, Some
scholars have said that it is not possible that the Prophet system was inclined towards her and one
today to divorce her this isn't who is speaking out ignore Josie, you must have heard the name of
Josie, the famous scholar, very famous scholar of seed and Hadith and film is very famous scholar of
00:47:34 -->
00:48:14
the Hannah Bella his of the humbling method. And he's well known for his most famous book is LBC
police and also he wrote suffer to suffer and they have actually both been translated to or to do on
some of them even to English very famous scholar. So even though Josie says some scholars have said
that it is not possible that the Prophet system was inclined towards her and he wanted to divorce
her, even though this is what is commonly found in the books of Tafseer. So he admits Look, this is
the predominant interpretation. But this story has been found problematic. Rather, these scholars
have said that he was criticized in this incident for concealing the fact that eventually she would
00:48:14 -->
00:48:57
become his wife. And that it is also said that he felt out of a concern for her that if they would
divorce her, he would marry her to fulfill the ties of kinship since she was his cousin. In other
words, even though Josie removes the love factor completely removes the inclination factor. And he
says he wanted to marry her to take care of her because she's his cousin. But he doesn't actually
quote an authority. He simply says, This is better really, for he is a modified version B basically.
Right? Same goes with a quote today. And the famous underneath is called quote to be in 671 that he
mentioned version a in a very explicit detail, then he follows it up with version B. And then he
00:48:57 -->
00:49:04
says our scholars have said that this is the better interpretation of the verse, and it is this
interpretation that the critical researchers have approved.
00:49:06 -->
00:49:30
So we notice here that in the first three, four centuries, it's only version A that is predominant.
version B is found. In the fourth fifth centuries version A and B are both mentioned. But then some
people began to say version B is better let's just ignore version a. Then in the sixth seventh
eighth centuries, version a is basically never mentioned anymore. And the best example for this is
even
00:49:32 -->
00:49:59
after him even hedger. Even Katia died 774 even Hydra died 852. So we see now an evolution taking
place. And what happens is the later scholars for example, even kathira says, and even hairdressers,
the basically the exact same thing when they talk about this verse, they say some of the earlier
books have reports that we would rather not mention, literally, we would rather not mention them.
Some of the earliest books of the theater have reports
00:50:00 -->
00:50:41
We want to just cross them out. not that important hats off to says, We don't want to waste our time
talking about them, they are just not authentic. Not even mentioning what it is. Not it's not even a
mention is simply only version B as mentioned. And there's no mention at all the version a, in fact,
we don't want to mention it. So even had you never mentioned it. Even Kathy does not have anything,
he simply says, We will not mention anything of this, we're just going to cross it out. And then
what happened as a result of this was that later scholars, they actually began to say that these
other versions are fabrications. And many modern scholars who are not experts in Tafseer, or Hadith,
00:50:41 -->
00:51:08
but they're famous amongst the masses, they want even more bizarre, and they said that this version
A is a fabrication by evil orientalists that have corrupted our books. And I've introduced it, you
know, to bring down upon the character of the Prophet sallallahu sallam, and frankly, you know, that
type of conspiracy theories and whatnot, we simply have to reject interesting left, I actually found
Eben Pagan, and we don't know who he is,
00:51:10 -->
00:51:20
in his book adapt with Dawa, which is a really interesting book, by the way, just a footnote here,
adopt what the what somebody wrote in Nakayama letter.
00:51:21 -->
00:51:40
And the letter is ambiguous that he's suffering from a problem. And he doesn't mention what is the
problem, and the whole adult with the word, which means the disease and the cure for the disease.
That's what it means adapt. What the What is the disease? The what is the cure for the disease? What
is this problem? It's actually
00:51:42 -->
00:51:42
the problem is,
00:51:44 -->
00:52:27
okay, and because of how many problems arise in this world, right? Most of the problems of this
world go back to Okay, so this young man writes him a letter that I'm suffering from, as I mentioned
the problem but it's understood, he's completely arshak with a virtue. Okay? And he is saying, I
don't know what to do when I need help and this and that. So even though Kalyan writes a beautiful
book, adult widower, beautiful, it's worth its weight in school and gold. And it's all about how to
cure the problems of of basically a ship in this regard. And he has entire chapters dedicated to
martial arts about a goal. And he has a whole chapter about the dangers of fish.
00:52:28 -->
00:52:28
Okay.
00:52:29 -->
00:52:31
Some of you guys need to read these chapters.
00:52:34 -->
00:52:36
Hockey, hockey, hockey.
00:52:39 -->
00:52:48
You want to start about there's much that can be said, but I will keep that side hidden. Don't
worry. There's a beautiful line of poetry. Hello, as you open the one out of me. There's a beautiful
line of poetry.
00:52:51 -->
00:52:52
What is it begin?
00:52:54 -->
00:52:56
At Armani, Wash, wash. Puna.
00:52:57 -->
00:53:29
The gossip mongers have accused me of loving her. The gossip mongers have accused me of loving her.
And I say to them, that is a sin I will never repent from that humbleness to men who are tubal.
Okay, so much can be said about Ashkan mashu. Here we have no problem writing a book that would go
up he has it. He has a chapter called the dangers of vanish after this right at the end of the book.
He has the permissibility of certain types of issues.
00:53:30 -->
00:53:38
Now not all issues head on, obviously. Right. So marriage is good. So marriage because Hello,
marriage is necessary for a happy married life. Is that not the case?
00:53:39 -->
00:54:09
What you guys didn't think of marriage integration. Hola. Hola. Hola. Hola, Priscilla villa. When I
mentioned marriage, you laugh when I mentioned HQ. Imagination goes elsewhere. I hope your wives are
not sitting here. Okay. Mr. nakaya mentions certain types of issues are good. They're Hello. They're
encouraged. Correct. Right. And he mentions stories from the seller from the Sahaba of Helen. Okay.
And of what he mentions is the story
00:54:11 -->
00:54:12
very interesting.
00:54:13 -->
00:54:29
him mentions a sanitized version a, that the Prophet system saw Xena and then they divorced her and
then Allah married Zane up to the Prophet system. Okay, so it's interesting that even OPM seems to
find no problem
00:54:30 -->
00:54:40
with this version of events. Now. Let's summarize some of the pros and cons of version a and version
B. That summarize some of the pros and cons. Version a.
00:54:42 -->
00:54:43
In terms of
00:54:44 -->
00:54:49
the text of the Quran, Wi Fi fi NFC como la humo de
00:54:50 -->
00:54:59
in terms of concealment, it makes more logical sense. That what the profitsystem is hiding is not a
sin, but it's something embarrassing.
00:55:00 -->
00:55:49
Notice is not a sin. Allah did not say you have to seek refuge, you made a mistake. There's no,
there is no them that the process of them did. But the context of the verse seems to suggest it's
something embarrassing, but it's not sinful. And hence the reports from Anis an issue and others and
has an adversity if the profits are some word to have concealed and if he would have concealed this,
it makes sense version a correct. Version a makes sense in that regard in terms of the sheer
quantity of early authorities, in terms of authority, and inside and all of these others Qatada and
what not even a bus. It does seem to have been the standard interpretation of early early Islam.
00:55:50 -->
00:56:26
Now, some have said, Oh, some of these reports are weakness not. And this is true, some of them are.
But firstly, even if one or two art, the sheer quantity of all different variations found in all
different books, really, it's not that difficult to say the gist of the story could be deemed to be
authentic. Secondly, the same is not the go back to Katahdin, even Abbas and ebensburg and whatnot
in a poverty associate, for example, these are the same, it's not the poverty users throughout his
whole life. So if you want it to be that picky, then you have rejected basically 80% of poverty.
00:56:27 -->
00:56:34
So this is something to keep into account. Also, there is another point that is raised. version B
says that,
00:56:35 -->
00:56:37
what was it the processor was hiding? Who could remind me
00:56:39 -->
00:56:45
that he was informed that he would eventually marry Xena, okay? If he knows he will eventually marry
Xena.
00:56:47 -->
00:57:30
Why delay it? I mean, if you know it's going to happen, and you believe Allah has told you is going
to happen. It doesn't make sense that you're just gonna say, keep your wife, you know, you're not
going to deny her the correct I mean, if Allah has decreed it, you know, it's not going to be you
cannot get out of it, none of us is going to say this. So it doesn't make any logical sense that if
the process isn't new, that eventually is going to Mary's enough, that he just delays the delays and
delays it. To what extent to what point in fact, if we look at the seal of the process of that type
of courage and bravery, he had it all the time, on the story of the incident of Israeli marriage,
00:57:30 -->
00:58:12
the next morning, he wakes up, and he knows he has to tell the people, right, we talked about that
story. And he told them despite whatever the the the reality might be, right? So the fact of the
matter is version a, the process of them is embarrassed about a human emotion. version B, it's as if
he is trying to deny a loss other stuff at all, I think about it. Think about the difference.
Version a is actually acceptable, human emotion, you're embarrassed, version B, you're trying to
outwit other, or some of this or something like delay further. And that's not who's gonna say that
it's not going to be possible. So that's the pros of version a, what's the corner version? What's
00:58:12 -->
00:58:16
the negative version? A obviously one thing and that is?
00:58:21 -->
00:58:32
So the the well, then we can say the one thing is, what is the what is the real problem about
version a here?
00:58:33 -->
00:58:40
It creates a stigma of our profit system, and his inclinations, this is the real problem. Okay?
00:58:46 -->
00:58:48
Why is that problematic?
00:58:49 -->
00:58:57
It's actually not problematic at all, because he's clearing up any air, any problem was completely
sending the very ex husband
00:59:06 -->
00:59:52
will talk about this in the pros and cons of version B, A, version B. Okay, the real con right now a
version a is obviously the problematization of the inclinations of the Prophet system, many of us
and that's what the majority of the later scholars have found problematic, as about who he
explicitly says, is not appropriate for the most common Nebraska. Right? This is the standard
feeling that most latest callers have had and that's perfectly legitimate. Okay, version B. Those
who support version B. They have some solid evidences as well. of them. One of you mentioned, it's
not as if you had never seen Cena before. Zeno's his cousin has grown up with her.
00:59:54 -->
01:00:00
It's not as if all of a sudden he's senior for the first time. So they would say version
01:00:00 -->
01:00:26
He does not make sense that instantaneously an inclination begins, after all, the verses of hijab
were not revealed until after the marriage by unanimous consensus. So there is no hijab before this
point in time. Also, as you yourself said, he, in fact proposed to her on behalf of Zaid, and if he
had been interested, he would have proposed directly to her from day one.
01:00:27 -->
01:00:35
And Alberto, he mentioned an interesting point here as well. This is a really deep point here. So
think about this. Above all, we says,
01:00:36 -->
01:00:46
Allah says in the Quran, Fifi Neff Sica Mullah, whom will be de you hit in your heart, that which
Allah would make open
01:00:47 -->
01:00:50
Ababa we says, What did Allah make open?
01:00:52 -->
01:00:55
The wedge NACA, which is in the Quran,
01:00:57 -->
01:00:58
we married you to her.
01:00:59 -->
01:01:04
So, version B is supported by the text of the Quran.
01:01:05 -->
01:01:23
In that what did Allah say? Allah did not explicitly say you were inclined towards her, correct it's
not in the Quran. Well, if enough Sega malaco movie do you hit in your heart that which Allah would
make open Ababa we says, What did Allah make open?
01:01:24 -->
01:01:29
The fact that zeyneb has married you, xo watch Naka.
01:01:30 -->
01:01:46
And so he says this shows us that version B is more Well, of course, version a version B, I am
saying this, you understand, he simply says this is the Why is more more weight than the other
rewire. Now, which version is correct, and the end of the day, it will lie Allah knows best. And
01:01:47 -->
01:02:34
I agree with ababu his final analysis, the final analysis, which is even if version eight is
correct, it doesn't mean any sin was committed. A man is not accountable for emotions as long as he
does not act upon them. And the story does not have any sin in it at all. And that is why even in
the Quran, there is no command to repent, or that he has done a mistake. Rather, you were
embarrassed at something and it was more appropriate that you should have feared Allah subhanho wa
Taala. So both versions are there, whoever wishes and what I do not agree to is this claim by
especially later people in our times that version A is a fabrication that the non Muslims and are
01:02:34 -->
01:03:14
the evil heretics have put into our books. This is honestly, you know, it doesn't behoove us It
sounds. You know, we love conspiracy theories. This is a problem with the Muslim Ummah, we love
conspiracy theories, blame it on this and blame it on that and no, version A is a part of our
tradition is clearly mentioned by most if not all of the early scholars, this is the reality, right?
version B is also referenced, it's there. Eventually version B becomes the standard. Okay? Now
whoever says version a, let him follow about who I am and others. And that's not a problem. That
Okay, what happened in and of itself is not sinful. And our profits are the law. Why do you send
01:03:14 -->
01:03:30
them now this really goes back to how we view our processes that do Is there any problem in viewing
him as a normal man with normal inclinations? In fact, there are plenty of references in the Sierra
that clearly indicate this.
01:03:31 -->
01:03:45
And of them is the marriage with Julia, if you remember Julia, great that when Julia came to ask for
her people, she said as soon as I saw her, I hated her.
01:03:47 -->
01:04:24
Cuz I knew what the Profit System was, you know, this hadith is authentic reported, and all the
books have you know, they, I hated her because I knew the process would see it or what I see. And he
would think exactly what I'm thinking. Right? And that's exactly what happened there when Julia
came. And Julia said, I am the son of I'm the daughter of the chieftain I am the bit of food and
food and I am I am I am, she's arguing to free her people. So the process of said, Why don't I free
you and marry you? And in fact, two people were freed at that marriage, we will talk about this
right? Right. But what did I say? That I knew the processor would see in her what I saw in her.
01:04:25 -->
01:04:34
And in my humble opinion, I think a prophet that is human is a prophet that I can actually relate to
and look up to.
01:04:36 -->
01:05:00
Whereas when you make the Prophet into this semi mystical figure, who is above humanity, so
parallel, what is wrong with a prophet that has normal male inclinations, but can control them? That
is perfection. That is perfection, that he never wants a little I set him did anything wrong,
despite having the same inclination as me and you have to me that is the role model. When you
01:05:00 -->
01:05:18
Take the profit into an angel that does not have any inclination, then where is the role model for
us? You see what I'm saying here, right? And even in this version, if you were to say version eight,
which the majority of early scholars said, honestly, what is there that is problematic? It is
possible that
01:05:20 -->
01:05:56
inclinations come later on in life, it is possible, but what did the processes when he turned away,
and he said, Subhana, Allah Subhana, Allah, Allah subhana wa kaliber Kuru and he kept it. And that
is exactly what you're supposed to do, right? It's exactly what you're supposed to do. And it so
happened that they'd never liked in the first and it was vice versa. And now this is an excuse for
is a palace and hamdulillah it's presented as a burden off, he doesn't want such a wife, because she
was harsh to him. She did have a sharp tongue, she did consider herself to be you know, not
appropriate for z from day one. So Zaid says perfect opportunity. Yes, well, let me divorce let me
01:05:56 -->
01:06:03
divorce let me divorce her and the process of is embarrassed and what took the funeral siccola Home
of the keeper I'm sick it because
01:06:04 -->
01:06:42
until finally his aid cannot take it anymore without the process of telling him he still divorces
her. Once it is done. Now she is a free lady without any husband. Why not? Why should the Why should
not the process and marry her so he sends the marriage the proposal and then Zeynep herself doesn't
just jump for joy. Sanam said Let me press too hard. Let me think. And as she is praying, Allah
reveals in the Quran was though which NACA and issue says even a bus as a hustler Bosley says, if
the process of work to have hidden any verse in the Quran, it would have been this one. It is in the
end of the day, awkward, but it's not how long is not sinful? Well, not every man is embarrassed
01:06:42 -->
01:07:22
when he might have inclinations for a woman. That is, you know, it's human nature, we're all going
to be embarrassed, but it's not how long if it is controlled. So bottom line, version a, it's there,
whoever follows it, that's fine. version B is also there, whoever follows it, that is also fine. And
just a quick side point, some scholars have tried to merge the two versions together and bring forth
another story. And whoever does this as well, inshallah, that too is fine. Unless you just conclude
with the story of Xena that Zeynep continued to live a life of piety, a life of taqwa, she was well
known for taking care of the orphans, she was called Omen Misaki the the mother of the poor, the
01:07:22 -->
01:07:24
mother of the the orphans. And
01:07:25 -->
01:07:36
we already mentioned that the processor said that the first one to that will be the one with the
longest hand. So when the the processor then passed away, and Romo began sending
01:07:37 -->
01:07:39
our thought and our thought was,
01:07:40 -->
01:07:55
so let me explain to you now, rumor will work worker Norma has a different policy aboubaker would
give a stipend to everybody. in Medina, exactly equal. Everybody got the same amount of money. It's
a salary from the government for being who they are.
01:07:56 -->
01:07:59
Or Omar said, No, I'm going to make a
01:08:00 -->
01:08:13
list to criterion category abcdefg, you had a whole list of people, right? And the highest category
were the wives of the process of them. And then the earliest converts,
01:08:14 -->
01:08:37
and then the middle converts and then the late converts and then the conquest of Makkah converts
which are the last category for Tameka, right, that was the last category. So the number one
category or the whys of the process from they get the biggest amount and that amount was 12,000
Durham's, that is a fortune 12,000 Durham's would be sent annually and
01:08:38 -->
01:09:20
Xena was given this 12,000 and it was poured in front of her cold coins all the way up. And she kept
on saying the holder aku Sevilla Subhana Allah Allah Aleem, you know, may Allah protect us from
Fitton and she kept on looking at this money. And as the money is in front of her, she gave this
much to her servants that go to the household so and so then she gave this much go to the house or
so and so and she kept on doing this until Not a single penny was left the whole 12,000 imagine
12,000 coins, one by one by one by one. She did not go to sleep until she had nothing left. Omar
heard of this. And she said and he said what a lady This is and he visited her house, knocked on the
01:09:20 -->
01:09:25
door and said I heard what you did to the money. Here is another 1000 for you.
01:09:26 -->
01:09:29
And what do you think she did with that? 1000
01:09:30 -->
01:09:31
all give it away.
01:09:32 -->
01:10:00
And she made a dua to Allah Oh Allah let me not see this money again next year. because money is a
fitna will love your brothers and sisters money is a fitna money is a fitna Imagine if somebody gave
you a million dollars right now what would you do with that? Right? Thank Allah that Allah is not
testing you with that type of wealth that is beyond your your control. Right? Money is a fitna and
so she said, Oh Allah, let me not see this money again. And so she passed away before her salary
came over the next year.
01:10:00 -->
01:10:38
We're right there whenever Omar decided to do it, so she passed away the next year, and she passed
away in the 20th year of the hijra, the first wife of the process to pass away. And Omar was the one
who prayed her janaza prayer for her, and all of the major Sahaba walk to Berkeley A lot of times,
and she was the first of the wives of the processes be buried. And all of the whys of the process
are buried in that same place. And the first of them Zeynep is right there. She is the first wife of
the processing to be buried in that place. And Xena was known as being so warm and cold warmer, and
someone who was as Arusha herself said, I never saw a woman, more importantly than her, this is our
01:10:38 -->
01:11:15
issue saying, right? So will law he, she deserved to be our mother of the believers, she deserved to
be the wife of the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, and whatever story you follow version a
version B, both of them are valid, there's nothing wrong with either of them. And the fact of the
matter is, when you have an evil heart, you can take the most innocent story and make it the worst
story. And when you have a pure heart, then innocent stories will remain innocent. You don't, you
know, the the the the squat the the non Muslims who want to disparage the process of them. They
don't need Zain of story, they can do it from any incident. And we have seen this enough. So those
01:11:15 -->
01:11:40
who believe in the process of them, and we are all in the shell of them, we don't have any problem,
in my opinion with either version of events, right. And those who don't believe in him will lie,
they have bigger problems to worry about than this and that version. And in the end, Xena is our
mother, she's the mother of the believers, and she deserves all of the praise that Allah subhanaw
taala has given her. And with that we conclude if there any questions about this shallow tallies.
01:12:03 -->
01:12:09
There's nothing wrong when a scholar says that I don't think this is appropriate for the macom of
the processor.
01:12:10 -->
01:12:20
As long as he bases this on legitimate concerns, and I think it is a legitimate concern, if you wish
to consider the profit system to be above human desires.
01:12:22 -->
01:12:56
This is the point here that if you want to make the process and to be some type of superhuman, and
many of the scholars did, and I have mentioned there is this tension to this day in Islam, to this
day, there is this tension, that is the prophets are more of a mystical figure, or is he an actual
Bashar, you know that in their mind of mythical calm, you know, born of human parents live, you
know, to this day, there are groups in our own home country, they believe the process of his new
lie, right? They believe he is newer from Allah subhanho wa Taala, that he's not a human, that he
doesn't eat and drink that he doesn't cast a shadow that he doesn't do this, that he doesn't do that
01:12:56 -->
01:13:30
you know this right. And that is one manifestation of that tension. And on the opposite side, you
have those who don't consider the processes to be fully a profit and they have time or they
criticize them a common number and the middle path is in Nima and Abdulahi rasuluh. I am ABD and I
am going to soon he mentioned the two things that I am both Abdullah II and I'm Rasulullah so it
depends on how you interpret it. I don't see those scholars who said it have a legitimate way but I
don't see a problem in versioning Allah knows best. Yes.
01:13:34 -->
01:13:59
Believe me, I tried my best to look up I did searches I didn't find anything that had been Tamia has
on Zenith and I'm still looking, I spent and I'm not sort of bragging or boasting I spent all of
today from the morning up until right now doing this research. And I wish I could spend more time
this is deserving of a much longer research. But I did my best to find what had been Timmy had to
say and I was not able to do that. Okay, yes.
01:14:16 -->
01:14:22
No, this is not the case. enjoyed his example is the best clear cut example
01:14:24 -->
01:14:27
that he saw God and he proposed to her right then and there.
01:14:29 -->
01:14:35
Obviously, Allah azza wa jal approved of it but not that it first came down the two month marriage
idea.
01:14:36 -->
01:14:38
Okay. Yes. Good.
01:14:55 -->
01:14:56
Manisha Yes.
01:15:12 -->
01:15:12
Yeah, so
01:15:13 -->
01:15:46
Dr. Pillai points out that insert a HAZOP. And the next page a lot clearly says that it is possible
the love that the process has in his heart will defer that to the human tissue and who knows to
really come into sharp woman, the woman is delighted women as a fellow junior high tech, right? That
whatever the process of had in his heart, there is no sin upon that. And even the process of himself
said that, Oh Allah, this is my costume that I'm doing, you know, as much as I can, but what is in
my heart? Do not hold me to account for that. And this is the reality of this. The Quran itself
explain this. Yes.
01:15:58 -->
01:16:01
I don't have any disagreement, but that that's what we're all saying.
01:16:06 -->
01:16:08
I am not to those people. So
01:16:09 -->
01:16:10
let's go ahead.
01:16:18 -->
01:16:26
So the question is, did they disobey the Profit System? So here we have when the Profit System is
acting like a shaffir,
01:16:28 -->
01:16:42
like an intercessor, then it's not something that is wired up for the person to accept. And this is
understood from the hadith of Madeira, the hadith of burrito that had a burrito burrito was a
01:16:43 -->
01:16:57
slave lady. At the time of the process and who was married to another slave slave can marry a slave.
Now burrito was freed by Ayesha burrito was freed by Asia. And
01:16:59 -->
01:17:13
when she was freed, she now has the choice to remain married or to just get rid of her husband. She
has the choice now. Okay, so buddy IRA decided to get rid of her husband.
01:17:15 -->
01:17:26
And her husband loved her again Mashallah. Her husband loved her deep love. And he began begging and
pleading with her that please take me back.
01:17:27 -->
01:17:34
We'll work it out. Don't worry, honey, we'll work it out. You know that type. And he was following
her in the streets of Medina.
01:17:36 -->
01:17:37
Crying and begging her
01:17:39 -->
01:17:45
and she doing only what a woman can do. Not even glancing at him.
01:17:47 -->
01:18:03
And so the profitsystem said to his uncle abass that Oh, Ibis. Aren't you amazed at how much
malayala was her husband's name? Malia loves buddy era, and how much buddy are hates Movil?
01:18:04 -->
01:18:16
Aren't you amazed that this marriage that was there for so long that as soon as you could get out
Hello, us. Right? And so she says to buddy, he says to belittle the process of them. Oh, buddy. Uh,
why don't you take him back?
01:18:17 -->
01:18:24
The guy is crying his eyes out. Just take him back. Have some mercy. Buddy Ross says attack Moroni
rasulillah
01:18:25 -->
01:18:29
are you commanding me to take him back somehow Look at her email
01:18:30 -->
01:18:34
or you command me that I'll take it then he said law in a nutshell here.
01:18:35 -->
01:18:38
No, I'm just tried to bring about reconciliation.
01:18:39 -->
01:18:45
So then she said with the scorn only a woman can possibly muster fella hedge attorney fee.
01:18:46 -->
01:18:52
I have no need of him. Call us. So we have over here buddy IRAs.
01:18:54 -->
01:19:15
Understanding that the Prophet system in this type of matter, she's not. He's not commanding her.
This is just shaffir this is just like trying to reconcile. Okay, so there is no issue here. That
eventually the marriage is not working out that eventually the divorce takes place. Okay. Final
question. Sisters. You have no questions in this round two.
01:19:17 -->
01:19:29
This is again shaffir. This is the same as that why don't you take him back? The same thing here.
Okay, no question from the sisters. I take it too controversial for them. Okay. Back to you have
01:19:30 -->
01:19:33
the same question. Okay. With that
