Shadee Elmasry – Group Dhikr in the Hanbali School, Hatem Alhaj
![Shadee Elmasry](https://artwork.muslimcentral.com/shadee-elmasry-150x150.jpg)
AI: Summary ©
AI: Transcript ©
In the humbly framework is to so have a personal practice or does
it have any communal element to it,
as its developed, the Mejlis of vicar has become one of the main
focal points of
the practice of to Soloff for many communities and its benefits are
sort of visible you see people who would not regularly do a certain
of God and vicar
by themselves, but when presented with a group then then maybe some
socialization afterwards and some food have come to easily practice
it, leading them in their homes to slowly do this themselves.
Is there any precedent for this in the humbly school
effectively to me, others talk about metathesis
approvingly,
as like, touch via in unison or Casa Ed and of God and those in
use in unison in unison, as is the the issue here and people can
agree or disagree over this, but madalas to sit down together and
make thick if you add in unison, that is when
this agreement starts, yeah. But but there, you know, honestly,
speaking,
I do not believe that this is better. Personally, you know, this
is a fapy disagreement, of course, yeah. Wow, how could the
disagreement and that is where we have to draw the line. This is not
you know, happened button. This is not it's not even with our son, it
is just the flippy disagreement.
And different people from different Mesabi backgrounds, they
may have different thoughts about this. I personally don't believe
that this is I believe in the superiority of that horrible
Rebecca Donahoe, Fiona German authority, but whether we are
so is that the the sort of the individual the person of the
individual
one
or you know, Jeremiah, My Allah azza wa jal
this is all together and this with Allah subhanaw taala I believe
that this is superior, but I believe that there when people
come together and set together this is established from the
Sahaba no one can argue about this, that to have motherless Vic.
The only thing is that in unison, like if we all make Vectren we all
remind each other of Allah and we may make this meat Hunter lead and
so on.
If you add any unison, then we can disagree and we can say that okay,
this is a valid fapy disagreement. I believe it's not a problem. I
personally believe it's not a problem if you believe it is.
Okay, it's about if you disagree and