Qur’anic Evidences
Munir Ahmed – Islam, Music & Singing – Part 2
AI: Summary ©
The use of salt in musical instruments, including musical instruments like shakedown, is discussed, along with the importance of language in pastime and political settings. The use of "will" and "will" in relation to actions and words is also emphasized, as it is used to avoid confusion and confusion. The importance of language awareness and "has" in bringing up issues is also discussed, along with the use of "naughtier" and "naughtier" in relation to the message. The use of music in various political settings, including wedding proceedings, and political events is also emphasized.
AI: Summary ©
Unless you go, oh devil, Satan only please go and try and be fooled him gradually as you wish. Go and use yourself. Now the word salt is used using a salt, what is the salt of shape, some of them shape one shape.
Almost all of them have made mention of
musical instruments. And this is a great thing to
try and control them use whatever you have at your disposal, those who know me and those who worship me, they will never follow you.
So,
with the greatest respect and love of demand, I always very popular. I like many of these things as well don't agree with everything he says, of course, we're right to do that.
Notice in this area, he says something I hope you pick to be said almost all the more serene. Now he said, make mention of thinking about musical instruments in regards to this as the voice of sitcom.
So
clearly, the obvious one is talking is left with the idea that this means musical singing, according to almost a serene.
That's what I would get from what he's saying that right.
But it's not true.
I'll show you why it's not true.
This is there's about five as we're going to analyze and this is the first one
where last law says as he said, a Saturday beautifully beautiful recitation. What steps this man is that out? I mean, be some peek?
behind the camera jamika Wash,
wash at home feel am well you are.
So what steps is insight? agitate them if says excite them? Yeah. As much as you're able to manage the data minimum, those who are able to excite an insight, be something with your voice.
So if I looked at a number of diversity
and if we go first, for example, to the fear of God coming he says be something he says was so Tohoku la da de la Seattle LA. is so this is the voice of Shekhar is all that. Yeah, well santoku la is every person who calls to disobedience to Allah is installed.
And he says quote to be clean B was fatigue and he said batteries was wasa
because that comes in the Quran has led us to be sudo in this is one who whispers in the hearts of human beings.
And, and he mentioned about to be the Buddha he didn't abis although this report is weak, by the way as I thought they said elvina will masamune singing and music and flutes. markazi What does he say? be something da Oh ella anoxia Tao who Allah Masha Allah is calling is calling to disobedience to Allah.
He says what kill it is said however alakina singing and play and level and amusement if you said because no has his opinion.
Ma'am tamari
well before I could get mantapa he says
Sam is going to be remembered he says sotto colada in Diana Shatila says all
Who call to disobedience to Allah is the song is the voice of Satan?
That's what it means. And it normally goes further he says he has nobody has a right the alarm Yeah. So when Delica something do not sound, nobody has a right to specify a particular sound rock particular voice excluding other voices. Nobody can specify that becomes a general use of the words. So,
as long as I'm Ashley elka sharp, he said he will be salty, he be the IE ela, ela, ela Sham, there must be says that he sold his voice is all calling to do all that which is evil.
So that's about four or five I've given you so far. None of them are saying what to say.
But what's the deal? This is Mansukhani, who mentioned earlier is famous stuff seen from over 200 years ago, but something Dion lahoma Nazi Attila besotted with your wife meaning calling them to that which is the disobedience to Allah, on calling to disobedience. Allah is the salt of shake on walkie It is said
when they say what killed the morpha city, the same other service, but I want this opinion. That's what they say. Well, I'll give our Masami It is said that it is singing and fluids but his opinion is all that calling to disagree a muscle alpha and beta wing, be something yada
yada if
you're calling to all that, which is corrupt shape, I'm saying that's your voice.
Another week, but something
he mentions that a lot Qatada the cabbie he said, been to iE illamasqua Tila you're calling to disobedience to Allah. That is the opinion of Katana which is actually authenticated.
And in the abass says similar Kula de la casa de la huaming. john doe a balise. And that's what we mentioned, although it's week two in the past, but this is Bobby's opinion on that, which is a calling to disobey a lot from Shakedown. He believes his army that is assaulting
him now soon. More recently in the last century was so useless Allah, Allah qalam caffeine, Allah was swept up on WhatsApp, fino wholesomeness, the salt is used for all kinds of pork.
Now surely saying in this case, he's talking about the West was out of shape bomb.
The Chateau de from Egypt basaltic, the West Swati.
About a 10th of us here have given you
do I even say well, he just said
they mentioned it, some of them. That's not the opinion majority. I say actually, that it is the worst was outside. And if you can look at the verse, well, actually, I laid him behind the cover actually, and
attack them with your capillary and your infantry.
We don't see countering infantry of shaitan attacking is doing this is in a metaphoric sense. Yeah. In other words, all those who are the supporters of Shakedown, all those who are calling to Roman ban, they'll be trying to pull us in that direction. And when you're talking about say Tom Shakedown sold his voice, you don't hear music and singing in your head which is telling you checked on speaking now
is what the Quran gives itself. What also says what a man young seven tamina shavon. Ynez best To be
honest, NASA, NASA is incitement again, a different word using the same thing. And if an incitement comes to you, ministry gone from Shakedown as a as an incitement as a NASA, which is what's worse. So this salt is the same as NASA, and the same as what's worse. What do you say, I will be living with a shape
that I want to be like you said, because you feel inside that you're being pulled in a direction to shut down doesn't come with horns and try them in front of you. Does he wear his military as a branch describing so it's using in a metaphoric sense and Shetlands voice as nearly all of us today are saying is any calling any calling to discipline Allah subhanaw taala is a sample sample cannot be limited to
however, can you include that
Yes, because it's any calling. So if a song is lewd and calling to Haram, calling me to like calling me to take drugs calling me to have affairs that would be included in some type of shape on true or false,
then you can include it. But just per se saying any scene of music is a sort of Shakedown not true that's not what the call is saying. So this evidence is not about music and singing.
Second
Law says
so
well I mean, I'm CMA yesterday law well Huggy feely up LA, de la Vega Ed, wire tequila ha hula hula ecollar whom
he
will have
left will
remember the word
Malachy comes from level musical instruments level means amusement. Yeah, includes relaxation includes wasting time left Well howdy here is
discourse just passing the time love will Huggies love. It means it can mean
any kind of talk, that you're passing the time when we socialize. When we socialize with each other. We don't just sit and talk about Quran and pour it is doing with each other as families or friends. Doing that is not well Hadees
that is lovely. It is past time we just checking with each other.
Now,
here, you have to understand what follows. Look what it says Leo villa. That key in this verse is new bill and
it's how it's being used the issue, not lovable. Huggies is the problem. What is it saying? to deviate from the path of the law?
being a human without knowledge, well yeah, that is that was a word. And and that person who's using this,
these words to deviates people from the path of Allah. They take the path of Allah as a jest and a mockery. What kind of people are those
disbelievers a monastics?
Yeah.
So the key is this bar to deviate other people from the path of Allah and making a mockery out of the path of Allah yet taking it also means mockery of severely left of the path of Allah, Allah, Allah whom Allah has such a severe punishment
for such people will be a shameful punishment. For what for using level hubbies No, Leoville and sebelah Follow me
the verse has to be understood fully you don't just technical words up I'm trying to come to a conclusion versus saying something now.
Sunset again language any language
because it's using the word Hadees here has to be to do with words. Some tried to say it is drums and flutes is impossible doesn't fit with Arabic language but la will Hadith just love on its own you may get away with but not la well honey, because this is Leslie pastime talk it is talk
it can fit with singing.
It can fit with singing, but it is not limited to singing because it has to be taken in a general open meaning Montgomery said the same thing. What is for those who said it is when I said you cannot specify. You cannot specify the arm general meaning of the words of the Koran from the comment of anybody else except Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi Salaam, if the Messenger of Allah specified This means specifically singing then we take that specification otherwise we're not allowed to specify we must take the general meaning.
Now in level if the father is who's great classical scholar of language in his dictionary now explain the words macassar lava he says a level good let's say shuttleq and say
everything which keeps you busy from other things.
It's basically low as I described it to you that started describe it there. Now, La Bella Hadid, some people have got this idea that all law is haram.
And to describe this law, well, Hadith therefore just as singing or music
is also wrong, because in order to understand therefore the language is here and make that haraam in order to understand it, you have to see what suffering a Hobbesian rasulillah some life as well. Yes, language generally comes in a pastime or negative sense. We mentioned the idea from the beginning.
Level Anima, hyah. To Allah, Allah who know surely that a life of this world is play and amusement. Does that mean a plan amusement is not allowed in Islam?
You could run away with the idea. And if you're going to say this langwell Hadith here is the problem that is haram. And it is music and singing, you've got big problems, because you're going to make Muslims there's no player and there's no amusement left in their life at all.
Let's see what happens here. level we need to understand before we move on,
as someone has said, that level itself, this amusement in past times has different levels. That is that which is watching that level, which is Mr. hub, recommending that level, which is MOBA, that level, which is my room, that level, which is how, how do we differentiate, for example,
the promises to them say
if you have for example, in a battle, and this is more relevant in the past time,
and the vocabulary or the arches or some distance away from the leader, the commander
is going to tell the trumpets to blow so they know that he wants them to fail.
All right, all the drum roll? Yeah.
If we say instruments, now, an entire instance, the playing of the trumpets of a drum roll is actually watching because otherwise you may lose a backup because you can't communicate in our mobile phones and all this business to communicate with each other.
So that you see is actually absolutely necessary. Yeah, it can become wajib in those situations.
So if you're going to put instruments
on the level, right, then this is a situation where they are absolutely required. Now we have a situation also that it is reported in authentic hadith in Bukhari and Hakeem are very lucky that from icfo movie not 11 ISIS and now has suffered in rotten Illa Rajan without
de Sala Yeah, he said to Matt, kinda Malcolm level,
find
your people
always ask them say, I said, gave away in marriage, a woman. But she was like the one he By the way,
a woman being a wedding. I said, Well, what we need and this has nothing to do this number we're going through right now. But anyway, she gave only one already married to one of the unsolved is a man called me unsolved and prophesized and said, Oh,
did you not send me any level with her?
What was the level?
music and singing? use the word level is asking her Didn't you bother sending any lowing and singing and music with her for the wedding? Because he says, No, I'm sorry. You're GMO Humala who because surely the answer they love, love the love music and singing.
Why would the public saw some encouraging loan if it is haram from this?
It can't be because he wouldn't be saying love on here. If it if you will try to make it around from this area. You cannot understand this area without taking that into context or even Buhari and Hakeem which promises an encouraging level in another happy to publicize them which is in the same which is a sound beneath and he says firstly Mr. Daniel Halliwell, haraam, adieu do for something nica
the difference between haram and halal
haram and holla the meaning the difference between
sexual relationship which is haram and sexual relations, which is Hallo nica is the drums and the singing.
This is authentic
This is authentic and majority men
generative certainly accepting for the singing somehow problems and try limited to the to the to the Duff, the drums. But Duff is massive musical instrument, isn't it but these are some actually encouraging it again, this fits with the other ideas that I saw this mentioned to you they did not take any music and singing.
Because they sound like this. Yeah. So hear the difference.
So keeping that in mind this you see therefore level where level is most the hub singing and music is recommended here by the prophet SAW. So he's encouraging, isn't it? He's not just saying, Yeah, I saw what's going on. He's actually saying Did you not and the difference between harar blessing Hello is the playing of the instruments on the singing.
So here in this area,
the issue is not the level
the issue is what's being useful.
Some said a report about another level the hardest, which is not authentic report, but many use it but that was nothing in the hive without a leader Mr. Kane, he used to buy singing girls and musical instruments and make them play to deviate the believers from their seriousness and Islam and the teachings a masala sort of be preoccupied with this.
Although this story is not true, when you can see, you can see even if it's weak, the meaning is that in other words, what is the purpose of the singing girls? Whereas you got singing here and instruments for married? With a promise or some recommending?
Here the singing of an instrument is being used for an even purpose llyod learn Sevilla. Yes. So it's not the thing that's the problem is what you're using it for. That's what the Quranic verses say. So all laughable Hadees
that can meet again, as I said, in the end, I'm probably said again, that it is general use of speech, it cannot be limited, if that speech is used to call to call to matsya Tilak or disobedience to Allah. All of that will come under this category. For general application, the key Leoville answer we love you guys, to me, we have takita musawah. I'm taking religion as a mockery in the hasm use this argue as this shortcoming added added as the others, but even the husband uses this argument.
He doesn't like it as some others in like it
says
no, even Hassan is wrong. He's saying the thing itself language is wrong.
He's saying if you follow the hazards argument
then
drinking alcohol use that word would only be harmed if it meant he dropped
his argument correct? No.
I'll tell you why.
Because actually, if you look at some of
his armor came with the list and I'll show you the
saying
I mean it doesn't do that.
Hammer became haram not from inverse like this.
So if we know the story of karma, it is inauthentic it that almost makes up top and the first verse that came for hammer was
Soraka Allah says yes sir Luna Girl hungry well Mason equal fee Eva if moon cabbie women are fueling nassima is muma bermain number 18. They asked you about about alcohol intoxicating intoxicants and gambling, say in both of them is great sin and benefit for human beings, but the sin in both of them is greater than the benefit.
The duck prohibits pharma and gambling. No did not. Even though sin is mentioned,
great sin.
Sing measure the level of ether except where it's doing what's being done with now. So Allah is reported as making a love of being Yelena being
faithful harmony Leon and Shiva in go Allah make clear for us in regards to Harmon make it so crystal clear for us in regards to this what you want from us in other words, so Next came the ayah
in
So, Lisa, after some time
yeah you Hillary dam and moolah Takara, moussaka and Tom suka.
Matta boo. Oh you believe, Do not come near to Salah when you are drunk until you know what you are saying?
This is his argument, isn't it?
So this is saying Don't come near Salah while you're drunk.
Come when you know what you are saying when you come out to your drunken state?
Did alcohol get prohibited in this verse?
No, because what's that saying? Just saying don't come drunk to Salah.
Yeah, don't use level hubbies to deviate from the path of Allah. So that is the main key column. This is a make Param common here the Chi Gong drinking sample after this true or false?
The Chi Gong majority of them until the last verse came.
Yeah, what said 30? who stay clear from it. And well how to move taboo after mentioning comma and gambling Will you not stop and almost said not in the window and we will stop we will stop now come that's the evidence. That's the beginning and it came clear. First of all, you have to stop as well stay away from it as an order prohibition. You don't get locked there. So even hazard is right. He's saying here. And marble. How do you agree with him?
He also put a title in his book. Same chapter.
Yeah, keep terribly sick that Bob kulula
is a shabalala who unbound until
by saying the same thing I didn't have to say that all level pastime battle means is waste of time bartylla rejected if it keeps you busy away from the obedience of Allah. Look what the condition is their shadow level equals a condition whereby we see a lot of karate say in the hedger from functional bodybuilding, the tertiary explanation or Mr. Buhari collection, he goes on to say a similar thing
called a big misquote 700 is translation is not correct, because it
says, even hunter says, if that thing level hobbies, whatever it is, which is deviating from the obedience to Allah is found in a text elsewhere to be Haram, then it is haram. You agree. But that doesn't make it home.
You follow me? That evidence there in front of you doesn't make law Well, hanifa. Together with what I've said about law already from the conference, the last one, you'll see many other editors
at lavaca.
Tech
and that Salam wasn't was only
only in debate is
around the Kaaba. What was their worship? Allah, what was it?
It was whistling and clapping.
And for Google azova Welcome to tech school. So if it's the best don't take it just that it doesn't say full stop, as it didn't say the previous was full stop after one minute nassima yesterday lava honey full stop.
And again, for Lu colada, so test the punishment for what you use to reject them this blue bar.
And one of the CO found doing this they punish for first they will go further rejecting the punishments for, I mean, they're rejecting they had twisted the worship around the Kaaba, which they had in jelly as well and made it into clapping and whistling.
made it into clapping, whistling, some come back and said
All right, then flopping on whistling is wrong. It's not what he's saying.
Is that what he's saying? doesn't say that. It's saying they made that worship into clapping and whistling
and they were disbelievers so if I start now worshiping Allah doing clapping and whistling around the Kaaba is wrong but clapping and whistling per se doesn't become harm because of this if
you follow me
others actually said the prophet SAW so I'm actually saying using the word
sweet or clapping for women for example in salad dressing the mom was
clapping
and for Salah the publicized slim said for the man is to give the you know mentioned that the word look man to the man yeah and clapping is only for women used in that context Some said or clapping is allowed but only for women men clap is not allowed. He said in salon you can't take out the slot now play generally.
Yeah, but others who made clapping and whistling but on this one this ayah and you see it is out of context you cannot come to that conclusion from an ayah like that and linking it therefore with music as well.
Well, Edina Elia Sedona Zoo Why not? We'll be lovely mountain roll Kiera?
Yeah, again.
Those who when they witness any kind of falsehood,
and when they go back and buy low level is like love but love, love, love is used more to do with words useless, vain talk.
Maru. kurama. And that they talk linking with zon can mean false top lying backbiting. Yeah.
That word swearing? Yeah, those believers they pass by with dignity they don't get involved in that. That's what he's talking about. What can we say from him now buzz, this zone is the the festivals of the Muslim
the Muslims their festivals, because it involves falsehood and worshipping idols and ship
Yeah.
Skip the other beat zoom, all lies uncanny Bakula mariachi related any kind of lying falsehood is under zone
because some tried to say the zoo is false that is to do with singing the music.
Again, how to specify without any arrogance.
You know why they specified because they've already got in their mind hatred for singing and music. And they're trying to transplant the into the verse.
But people have real knowledge about this issue. You'll see even from that last verse, you'll find that there is no evidence absolutely in the Quran about making music haram amaku neither this was either in Arabic as he said all kinds of lies comes under this false falsity.
He says I'm not bold enough who knows Nina
to be in RBC. Sorry. As far as the statement that this is singing police against the healer. It doesn't get limited to this
same thing autoplay sound again before you can't limit it by just this statement, but this is it may be that he again like I said before that you use songs which should come falsity and lies in it then it will come under that
but not just per se being a song.
In the caffeine, it says it's schuck is to do with the festivals of the master key is to do with false witness and love who is to do with all that which is boss
walk up so Connie says I'll walk into famous Greg officer that a lot he says episomal facility Allah Amna Zoo ha ha una de la ship. The majority of them have a serene a lot of the sayings are that the zoo here false not means has the meaning of ship involvement with anything to do with ship in the ocean.
In this segment, so the man is an sankaty says the man is general, its meaning is general it means lies and falsehood
and level means all kinds of
maxia or disobedience of Allah.
Okay, here for me this is
a farming handle. Hi dee da Jabu wickard Hakuna wala taboo.
Thomas
Thomas.
Some tracks, say unconcernedly do while you amuse yourself. This is singing and music again.
But even those who said singing a music, some study environment, bass for example, Suzy he's saying, well, Amina can either sunny moon or an The Hon. No, man No. Well, I will.
When they used to hit a bomb who's talking about Muslims and disbelievers they used to sing loudly and make a clutter noise. So if you want to understand samidoun doesn't just mean because you have been using yourself that's wrong is when they're doing it is talking about the Quran affirming has a heavy hitter Jawbone I have not been amazed by this Hadith, the statement the Quran,
without the harpoon Allah de goon then you will laugh rather than weep
you love for the week does that make laughing haram by the way this list?
Because you have to make it alive as well. If you're gonna make some room around.
You understand me? And that means you have to cry all the time as well. Because the contrast of laughing is that you should be crying.
And if you cry every time you hit the ground, that's not saying that it's talking about those who are crying because of that they should be crying unless Martha's putting it in such a way without the Hakuna Matata. Boom. You're laughing and mocking Okay, actually, your your situation is should really make you cry because you're sinners and you're gonna go to * fire is not saying you should cry and said
it's not for that. So the believer standing listening to so another one on crying By the way, well, I could tell you the word from the Sahaba but the disbelievers were making mockery away so the crown was a saint of lemurs you stop crying while they're laughing is using a rhetorical sense
so you should be ashamed of yourself your sins what's in store for you should be crying when you're making mockery of it.
And again, mockery was an anthem Sammy doom. Yeah.
Which is like now bosses say, I lost.
cz in this verse. This verse goes with the other words to clarify for you all levena
we had an era
where L O V E Allah Allah toggleable a disbeliever saying don't listen to the ground, but
have a ground elevation fee from low Yeah.
Well, I love our fee. He means as he's saying either by seeing a
lot of luck come who so they overcome the recycle of the ground by making lots of noise. Yeah. So if you do that by either words or singing or anything, making a loud noise with anything, even includes music versus singing, then it comes under that category.
Yeah, not the fact that amusing and sunny do music is haram. amusement is around we get in contrast with our promises and therefore we have to look did he amuse himself?
He's messaging already. I haven't come to the army. He's already messing for wedding people that that unsought are well known. And by the way, this statement outside loving, loving, singing and, and singing and musical instruments continued for a couple of centuries. By the way, they were famous Medina and he jazz Medina and Mecca were famous during the time of the tambourine and capecitabine, from places who were there like singing the music still, after a time of a soloist was on
It was only after a couple of 100 years and some scholars who are more stricter and they had their reasons to do with culture etc, than they have but they still mentioned in the history books and lobby mentions that
even the Buddha mentions it in mobilizing the people of Medina, famous for like for loving music and singing. And then even Kodama and nobody mentioned this, which I mentioned to you earlier, from the promises to love the unstarred love.
We'll stop there, these were the chronic inshallah, we'll come back and go on to the hobbies