Zakir Naik – Pathan Girl asks a Contradictory Question About Pakistani Society
AI: Summary ©
AI: Transcript ©
Assalamu alaikum, sir.
My name is Pallavi and I'm from Lucky
Marwad.
And, sir, first of all, Alhamdulillah.
And thank you so much for giving me
the opportunity to ask this question.
Sir, the place where I belong, there...
Pardon my Urdu, please.
I'm speaking Pashto.
Sir, the place where I belong, there is
a complete Islamic religious society.
There, women do not go out of their
homes unnecessarily.
Sir, there, women live in their homes and
men do not offer their prayers.
And every Friday night, the Tablighi Jama'at
or all the Dawahs, the people who go
on the path of Dawat-e-Illallah, their
statements are made every Friday night.
So, sir, they go there.
Recently, a very big Tablighi Ijtema took place
there, sir.
And in our area, all the people are
very religious.
And their social conduct is also based on
religion.
But, sir, my question here is that, according
to your wisdom, what could be the reason
that, sir, drug addiction, adultery, pedophiles, and all
these kinds of bad things have occurred there?
And, sir, there...
Okay, sir, a question came to my mind
in the middle of your statement.
I will ask that as well.
Ask one question.
Okay, sir.
And short.
Sir, what could be the reason that, why
is the society collapsing there?
And why don't our scholars call out, specifically,
the pedophiles?
Then the question is that, in their society,
where they come from, those women are very
Islamic women.
They don't go out of the house without
a reason.
I also don't go out of the house
without a reason.
And a man should also not go out
of the house without a reason.
Yes or no?
Do you go out without a reason?
Does anyone go out?
They don't go out here either, Mashallah.
Your question is that, in your society, Mashallah,
there are many Islamic relatives.
But there, pedophiles, if I heard correctly, are
very common.
Exactly, sir.
And you said that Sina is also common.
Sina, sir, is increasing now.
And specifically, pedophiles who manipulate children.
And then when those children grow up, then
again this cycle continues.
Sir, this is a very big sin that
happens there.
There is a contradiction in your question.
You say that my society is Islamic.
Then you say that it is a *.
Sir, I am saying that the same *.
Listen, sister, sister, sister.
You asked the question.
Will you please be quiet?
Your question is over.
Do you want to hear my answer or
not?
Yes, sir.
Do you want to hear or not?
Yes, sir.
So your question is over.
Yes, sir.
Now listen to my answer.
The question you asked, according to me, there
is a contradiction.
You said that my society is very Islamic.
And there is a * in my society.
There is a contradiction in both.
There cannot be a * in any Islamic
environment.
Either your first part is wrong or the
second part.
This is not possible.
He is stealing very Islamic.
This is not possible.
You will have to admit that there is
a mistake in your question.
First time or second time.
Yes or no?
Simple.
My society is very Islamic.
There is a *.
* means to commit adultery with children.
This is not possible.
Which Islamic book says this?
Which chapter or verse says *?
Which Hadith says this?
Your saying that first time or second time
is wrong.
Both are correct.
That is why there is a contradiction in
your question.
You should say that my society is very
Islamic.
Then I will admit.
Saying this is Islamic.
Women go out without permission.
And men go out without permission.
This is the problem.
What is the need?
*.
That is why before accusing anyone, think ten
times.
If you ask this in the court of
Allah, you will be trapped my sister.
You should apologize.
That your question is wrong.
Sir, my question is that there is the
same religion.
Sister, sister.
You will have to accept my question first.
If you don't accept, then my answer is
over.
Sir, my question is that the nature is
wrong.
The nature is not wrong.
The question is wrong.
You are wrong.
You are accusing your society.
First you say it is Islamic.
Then you say *.
Both are wrong.
One of the two will be right.
Or one will be wrong.
What is this?
You repeat after listening to the media.
Both cannot be right.
If both are right, then this is a
mistake in the Qur'an.
Where is it written in the Qur'an
not to do zina with children?
This is the work of the media.
Put allegations, ask questions, give anything.
It is written in the Qur'an in
Surah Al-Hujurat.
Surah no.
59.
Verse no.
6.
Whenever some information comes, you investigate it before
repeating it.
You are repeating in all the media.
There are thousands of media.
20,000, 25,000.
And you are saying that my Islamic society
is *.
And you are putting allegations on Islam.
My sister.
And you are not even apologizing.
This is what happens.
Even after making a mistake, you have to
apologize.