Yasir Qadhi – Ask Shaykh YQ – Episode 17 – What Are The Conditions To Make an Animal Halal

			In a nutshell in a nutshell people are confused why is there extra love and why do the scholars
differ Can we eat this ebihara non sibi headset for me on
		

			almost
		

			any gala region in the region no thing he him
		

			there are a number of conditions to make an animal Hello some of them are unanimously agreed upon of
those that are unanimously agreed upon number one that the animal itself be helpful. If you have a
pig you can never make it Hillel the animal be halal. So cow chicken. This is hella number one.
Number two, that the one who slaughter is must have the need to slaughter This is unanimous. If an
animal is killed accidentally. It is never going to be valid. It must have the Nia to slaughter.
This is unanimous. Number three, the religion of the one slaughtering the animal by unanimous
consensus, the slaughtering the slaughter of an atheist or agnostic or Hindu or Buddhist is not
		

			allowed. It is the slaughter of who the Muslim and the believing Jew and Christian allocate out
water amulet in order to get Abba Hello, welcome. And there is the foreseen who is a helicopter. But
for now that is Jay let us just say that the believing Christian and Jew is a helicopter. This is by
the text of the Quran. So Muslim Christian Jew, they must be if you're an agnostic and atheist, the
Hindu that slaughter is not allowed. Even if they say in the name of God, it would not be allowed
this is unanimous there is no data. So these are so far three unanimous for pretty much unanimous
one or two very few scholars they went against this but this is pretty much all formats have to have
		

			this the fourth condition and that is the blood must be cut in the proper manner that it gushes out.
When you slaughter the animal, the blood must gush out from the juggler from any vein in the neck.
And this is based on the Hadith that a man came to the process and said O Messenger of a law.
Sometimes we are in the desert and we don't have our knives. What can we eat? How can we slaughter
the animal like a rabbit or something? And sometimes we don't have a knife. What can we do? The
profitsystem said Hadith in Bukhari and Muslim called Luma and Hara dumb was Akira small La La for
kulu. Anything that causes the blood to gush out, in other words, you cannot take an animal and
		

			smack, smack smack or with a builder that is made that that is how long you cannot take an animal
and electrocuted to death. You cannot take an animal and trap it in a fox type of trapping until it
starved to that it would be out all by unanimous consensus through the AMA is not allowed. The
animal must be slaughtered by a Muslim Christian or Jew in a manner that causes the blood to gush
out because we want the blood to exit the body as much as possible. Okay, so therefore, if in this
case you have a rabbit, they would have taken a sharp rock, let's say right, and they would have
then managed to slaughter it such that the blood is gushing out. And the and the Hadith is the name
		

			of allez Mencia. So all of this is unanimous, there is no est j, where is the end of the big
controversy it is in the fifth and final condition, and that is mentioning the name of a law as you
slaughter the animal. This is the controversy between the three of them a dime, the ham bellies, the
mother keys and the henna fees. You can say the varieties as well but three of them are die. They
are strict on the Bismillah and they say in order for the animal to be halal. You must mention the
name of a law when you slaughter and the evidence is from the Quran and Sunnah. Allah says in the
Quran for kurumi Madhu Kira, small La La eat over that which Allah His name has been mentioned. And
		

			Allah says in the Quran, while Kuru Muslim youth carisma la la do not eat over that which Allah His
name has not been mentioned. And Allah says in the Quran, for kuruma I'm second la COVID, Kuru small
La La regarding the animals that are the Falcons and the hunting animals eat what they have caught
for you and mentioned the name of a law when you send them out. So there are so many that mentioned
mentioning the name of Allah and the Hadees. I just quoted you right now, when the man says I don't
have a knife, what did the process Some say? All that causes the blood to gush out or the second
condition.
		

			And you mentioned the name of a law over it. Okay. And even Tamia has a treatise on this an entire
treaties, on the necessity the would you have mentioned the name of Allah over the animal and he
says the evidences for saying that the test smear the Bismillah is obligatory or more numerous than
the obligation for reciting Fatiha in the Salah.
		

			And he mentioned
		

			The most explicit, he says, is the Hadeeth inside a body that a man said O Messenger of Allah,
sometimes I send my hunting animal to catch the prey. By the time I get to the prey, I find other
animals as well. And I don't know which one killed my animal. My hunting animal which one killed the
prey? Excuse me, my hunting animal or the wild animals. Do you understand the scenario? Guys? You
understand the scenario, right? I get to the deer. I get to the whatever rabbit I'm hunting. And I
don't know there's a whole bunch of stuff. My animal is there, the trained animal and the untrained
animals, the wild animals are there and I don't know which one killed it. Our Prophet system said
		

			this hadith in Bukhari and Muslim fella
		

			for in some Mita Allah Kelvin, welcome to semi lol Kelvin. He'd been telling me it says this is the
most explicit Hadith. That doesn't mean his watch it, do not eat of that meats, because you said
Bismillah over your animal. And you did not say Bismillah over the other animal. This Hadith is very
explicit. Now. The shaft pretty much is the exception. And they say and they have their evidences,
but in a nutshell they say all of these evidences merely indicate that it is sooner and not wajib
jagat that's their position. Okay. The Shafi madhhab says that saying Bismillah is recommended it is
not worship. Hence, if a Christian or Jew with Nia to slaughter slaughters the animal and causes the
		

			blood to gush out, even if they don't say Bismillah. The Shafi method says what?
		

			It's okay.
		

			And the Hanafi and hanbali and Maliki say it's not okay. Not good.
		

			So what do we do in the end? And by the way, there are other issues that are raised as well and and
it complicates it, and of them in the land that we live in? How do we know if the slaughter is
Christian or Jew or atheist? And that's another question mark. And another question that is raised
is the issue of stunning. Now, to be very precise,
		

			stunning the animal
		

			itself is mcru.
		

			If the animal dies as a result of the stunning the animal is how long, but if the animal is alive,
after the stunning and the slaughter occurs, then technically the animal is Helen. But and this is
the big butts. What percentage of animals die between the stunning and the slaughter.
		

			Scientific surveys differ greatly. Some say two 3%. And I have read some they say 20 30%. If it's to
3%, we can ignore if it's 20 30%, we cannot ignore. So there are uncertainties that are added that
even according to the sharper image hub should allow them to be very cautious, because we have all
of these issues. On top of this. To make matters even worse, in the last five or six years, the
modern abbatoirs the modern slaughterhouses have pioneered a new technique to cut the animal to
minimize the blood spurting out. They don't care about the blood, they care about the dirt and the
filth ended up. And what they have done is they cut horizontally and not vertically.
		

			And that minimizes the gushing of the blood. So this is yet another big question mark, in my humble
opinion, and I respect all of them at the hip. The evidences for the destiny are very explicit. And
as even taymiyah said, this hadith don't eat he made it how long don't eat, you said Bismillah over
your animal. You did not say Bismillah over the other animal. This is a case of 5050 we don't know
which dog or which Falcon kill the animal. How about the case of 100% You know, there was no
Bismillah given right. So in my humble opinion, I am a humbly or a hanafy in this method or Maliki
and so I am a strict person. But at the same time My dear brothers and sisters, the Shafi method is
		

			a legitimate method. So if you might meet a fellow Shafi he's not an evil Muslim, you know, you can
pray behind them. Your namaz is valid Don't worry okay. You may visit him in his house in return his
salon no problem. Okay. I mean, yeah, it's don't make Islam difficult. This is a legitimate method.
We respect the method. And we respectfully disagree. Now, some other points before we conclude the
issue of GMOs, a lot of people ask genetically modified whatnot. Generally speaking, our film
councils have said that by enlarge, this does not make the meat out on the issue of mistreating the
animal unethical treatment of animals. The animal is not fed properly or the animal is put in cages
		

			with the animal
		

			Doesn't have green pasture or whatnot, you know. So all of this the abusive animals and there are
many videos that we have seen cruel farmers beating animals and throwing, you know, the chicken and
whatnot just absolutely out um, and very, very, very bad practices. So there has been a movement to
say this meters, how long and technically speaking, we say the farmers that mistreat and abuse the
animals are sinful in the eyes of Allah and they will be punished if Allah does not forgive them.
They have to repent for that. But the farmer mistreating the animal does not make the animal how
long for us if it is slaughtered properly. Now, whether we choose to boycott on an ethical farm or
		

			not, that's a totally separate issue. And I'm not advocating either way, but I'm being technical. If
a farmer is mean to the chickens, but he slaughters the chicken properly, that chicken is healthier
for us. Now Should we buy from the farmer or not? That is an ethical issue fixes that animal is
halal. Ethics might say, why should we support that farmer and let's support the better farmer. So
let's not conflate the two. The technically the meat is halal, but where do you want to find it
ethically sourced or whatnot? That is up to you and that the other issue comes you have to be
practical. Those types of farms are triple the price of the regular ones. We cannot make something
		

			wajib upon the oma that is unreasonable for them but me personally as a personal human being in my
own capacity, I try to find ethical and humane farms, but it's not how wrong to to go to those ones.
		

			The other issue that comes is kosher, halal or not. And I have written an academic paper which is
published and you can find it online as well it is called is kosher. halal. biosecurity is an
academic paper that was presented at an academic conference, and I concluded that kosher meat is
halal. In fact, kosher meat is exactly the meat that Allah says in the Quran will tombola dinner
altogether. But Hello Lacan, the term of the anti Kitab is helpful for you. I can include it in my
paper, that is a reference to kosher not to McDonald's.
		

			Because and here's the point when the IV Kitab follow their Shetty, the meat is hella for us when
they have abandoned their Shetty, and they don't care about what their own books say. And I proved
in that paper that once upon a time, even Christians slaughtered properly. In medieval times,
Christians mentioned the name of God, in medieval times Christian slaughtered properly, then they've
went far away from their religion, and they left their own shediac. If Christians have abandoned
their own charity, that meat is not halal for us. But if you find a Christian, who's your friend,
he's a farmer. He's a hunter, and he says, I want to give you some meat, you say, and he's a
		

			believing Christian, you say, Can you say in the name of God? And he says it, the meat is Helen.
Because why is the meter by Nikita, Helen and the meter, the Hindu is not valid. When the Christian
says in the name of God, He means the God of Abraham.
		

			He means the God of Abraham, when the Jew says, In the Name of Yahweh, and the name of God, he
doesn't say always take that back as a tetragrammaton. He said, the name of God or whatever he
mentions Shema Israel, he mentioned the blessing. When the Jewish person says that, who is their
God? What Allah who know what you know, who can why this isn't the Quran, your God, our God is the
same. This isn't the Quran, the God of the Nikita, and the God of Islam is the same. So when the Jew
says, blessings, oh, God before slaughter this animal that is that a smear right there. Now, when
the Hindu says in the name of my gods,
		

			is that ours?
		

			No, it's not. That is why the meat Valley Kitab is halal. If they follow their Sharia
		

			and they mentioned the name of God, it becomes harder. But if they bang the animal to death, is it
Allah?
		

			If they eat pork, is it halal? If they don't mention the name of Allah? Is it halal? No, that is my
opinion. And that's the opinion of the three methods they have to follow. They're shady, then it is
helpful. If they don't follow the shady, it is not highlighted. In any case to conclude, respect the
sharpspring method if you don't follow if you follow the chapter metal no problem that's why By the
way, why has this taken on a cultural connotation our our brothers our DC brothers, technically it
should not be true because it's not out of brothers is the shaft of the atoms technically the
molecules of the atoms and the embodies the atoms should not be following this photo. Unfortunately
		

			many of them do but technically they should not the humbly school and they are my teachers jacobin
buzz and entertainment and saw that he goes on and all of these humble ulama they were ultra strict
about this issue go read their fatawa they would not allow me to be eaten. That was not mentioned
the name of Allah over it. They were very strict unfortunate
		

			Many of the people they claim to follow that group and they want to follow the photos of the
shaeffer scholars they pick and choose because it's tastier that way.
		

			And I don't know why the North African brothers but in reality the Maliki method, generally speaking
does not I know there's a dissenting view, but the mainstream of the humbly and Maliki does not
allow for it. It's only the shaft fairy school. And you know what, whoever follows the shaft for a
must have hamdulillah that's your madhhab no big deal. Don't make Islam difficult. In some areas,
one method is strict another is lacks in other areas the strict method is lacks and the locksmith
have extract so if you're following a method, no big deal is remain with your mother. If you ask me,
then it seems looking at the evidences that mentioned in the name of Allah is a necessary
		

			requirement from the Koran and from the Sunnah. I forgot one Hadith sorry, one Have you ever done? A
lot of people mentioned this Hadith, however, it's in my nosa forgot to mention
		

			that Hadith is why don't you mention the name of Allah than eat? You know that Hadith Have you heard
it? You mentioned the name of Allah than eat. And this hadith is actually misunderstood. All you
need to do is look at the context of the Hadith, the Hadith in Sahih, Hadith and authentic hadith.
And the Sahaba said Yasuda law.
		

			There are a group of new Muslims Hadeeth, who didn't believe Islam, they just converted.
		

			And we do not know, or are they saying Bismillah or not?
		

			Notice this Hadeeth is in a very specific context, isn't it? What
		

			are they saying? Bismillah or not?
		

			Now, when the Muslim slaughter is what is the default? Does he say or not? He says, so if a Muslim
slaughters, we don't need to have security cameras, if it's a pious Muslim,
		

			as a Muslim, we know coming to the masjid. We don't have to spy.
		

			So the Prophet says some said, Muslim cutting the animal. If you feel doubtful, in this case, you
say Bismillah and you eat the Hadith is not about we know for a fact they don't have Bismillah
		

			that would be a separate thing. And that goes back to the Hadith of the two animals. If it's 5050 we
said we take the animal to be huddled. So this hadith is misapplied. It's only applied when a Muslim
is slaughtering and you're unsure.
		

			Do they know the rules of slaughter or not? Are they brand new Muslim or not? In this case, you say
Bismillah and you leave defer to Allah subhanho wa Taala but when you know Emelia clean that they
haven't said Bismillah and the slaughterhouses of this country do not say Bismillah unless they are
halal or kosher. Unless they are halal or kosher. They are the ones that say Bismillah and that is
not a problem to buy from there. He shall at another time I know there are many other questions
about halaal stunning and whatnot we will come to them inshallah, in round two of the great meat
debate in sha Allah tala and on the juicy note inshallah, we will continue
		

			in a feed dounia Salah
		

			Fei
		

			Li
		

			Li