Bulugh Al Maram Series presented by Sh Waleed Basyouni at the Clear Lake Islamic Center
This lecture was presented on Feb 1, 2017.
Waleed Basyouni – Bulugh Al Maram EP02
AI: Summary ©
The speakers discuss various versions of the phrase "water is pure" and its impossible proof. They also touch on the history of water being used in various ways, including washing, washing, and making coffee. The speakers emphasize the importance of avoiding leaving behind one's clothing and the need for proper cleaning. They also discuss the use of "immediate" in relation to impurities and how it can affect one's health. The segment concludes with a discussion of the sport of bouncing water, which was initially restricted to men but is now popular among women.
AI: Summary ©
Don't have my coffee
123123
okay
smilla
Rahim Allah The Book of purification, chapter one water
narrated Abu huraira or the Allahu Allah His Messenger sallallahu alayhi wa sallam said, regarding the sea its water is purifying, and it's dead animals are lawful to eat, a larva and even a ba ba reported it. Version version is of the latter. Even kazama and tirmidhi graded it's a he Malika sherfane reported it
narrated the second Hadith narrated Abu Sara Del Oro the Allah and Allah messenger sallallahu Sallam said, water is pure and nothing can make it impure, reported by a thalassa and graded it so he narrated abou mama Alba Healy Ravi Allahu Allah His Messenger sallallahu alayhi wa sallam
said, water cannot be rendered impure by anything except something which changes its smell, taste and color. Even Marja reported it and I've heard him described it as wife week and Albania three reported waters pure unless any impure thing is added, which changes its smell, taste and color. Say that again. We'll be happy I'll be happy reported water is pure unless any impure thing is added, which changes its smell taste and color. No that's that's not what he said. Okay, so the translation the translation is
very happy Rahim. Allah narration says Alma oppa whoa Illa Illa into Yahoo. Our Moo hoo hoo. So instead of and you see or Yeah, so water the correct translation is water is pure unless any impure thing is added, which changes its smell or taste or color. Yeah, because the the first narration says, It's taste, smell, and color, the second duration or and there is a big difference between and and or That's right.
The fourth Hadith narrated by the love and aroma of the Allahumma Allah's Messenger sallallahu alayhi wa sallam said, if there's enough water to fill two pots, it carries no impurity. Another version has it. Another version states. It does not
Become unclean. Alberto reported it will cause aima even been
graded it so here Zack Ilaha Bismillah Alhamdulillah wa salatu salam ala rasulillah Allah Allah He was a happy woman voila for that
first of all sisters if you want to come up here to the masala you're more than welcome
here
Eman have been hijacked by him Allah to Allah mentioned this for that Hadith and the first one we made a commentary on it last time, just very quickly when the prophets are solemn answer those who are travelling and ships. And they said Yasuda law, when we are when we have when we travel, we have limited amount of water. If we use it for all, you know, we'll run out of freshwater. So can we use the water of the sea? And the prophets are solemn? Told them? Yes, it is. Water is purifying, and it's dead animal are lawful. And we said that a Sahaba of the Allahu anhu Moldovan didn't have a problem with understanding that the water of the sea is pure. But the issue was, was that water good
to purify you? When we say purify Hina Manor own and shake up here? What do we mean by that? Ah, man up top here. Can anyone tell me when you say purify something, what that means, in that sense, and? And the water when you say the water purified?
You come from something not unlawful to something lawful. That's very general. Can you be very specific? Yes.
So removing two things, what are they purifying is removing. That's right. What we remove?
Very good. So Mohammed was saying the first one which is absolutely correct. You know, alhadeff and Akbar Anil had asked us a lot I had about I wanted to understand this word in Arabic, sorry, and you have to add it to your vocabularies, and had us It means a state that you are in which it does not allow you to pray.
You're not allowed to pray? What are the state that you're in and you're not allowed to pray? The Salawat?
If you break your elbow, that's right. Or do you have
Chenab like quid dream or * or for a woman?
If she has her menses, or she just deliver a baby? That's right. And she has postnatal bleeding in the fast That's right. So these are for that for three. So the first one when you don't have when you break your will vote, and you know the things that break will.
obvious. So when you break your elbow, or this is called minor header and Ocelot minor header and Akbar the major when it is out of sexual sexuality, or it is based on bleeding the woman menses or woman new fast which is the boss needle, possibly of bleeding after delivering a baby. Is that clear? So when we say ahead, if it means that stated you're in, which is you're not allowed to pray, not allowed to perform Salah? Is that clear?
So purifying, it means it takes you out from that state. Regardless, it is knowable, or regardless of hate, regardless of
Geneva, basically, to bring you back to the state which is lawful. It means it lawful for you now to pray a lot for you to pray for menses, as we know, this is after the blood stop. After the blood stop. You take a whistle, you basically use the water to purify your body by taking a shower. So you're allowed to pray. That's right. If a woman's menses stop, she cannot just pray she has to take a shower first. Is that clear? Okay, that's it. That's what purifying means. Are there is more than that.
What else that we purify?
This state that we talked about? Is it something
it does something intangible that state which is that it's intangible thing, it's a description of you. But there is something tangible? If you have it.
It will not allow you to pray.
Which is called the jossa impurity. Let somebody you are cleaning your baby's diaper. And you have the baby's poop. Okay. And he does baby is two years old. One year old he's eating. And you have the book in your hand. Can you pry?
Nope. Somebody urinated for example, and have a urine and has a close? Is that allowed for you to pray?
No, because that's basically that urine is impurity. That's right. So an adjuster, you see this impurity in this carpet, how would you remove it, one of the way to remove it is through what? Water. So when we say when the prophet SAW Selim said, purifying, he means he purify your body, from any physical impurity, and also can put you in that state, which is allowed you to pray and allowed basically, you can make a vote with it. Is that clear? Well, I believe so. And I said to you, that this understanding what led the shaft is the humble is to tell you that water is divided into three categories in impure water, which is you're not allowed to use for purification, and pure water, but
not purifying water. So it's a water that is pure in itself, but it's not enough. Or it's not, you cannot use it to purify itself with it.
And the third category, which is a water, that you it is pure in itself, and it has the power to purify you, like the water of the sea, the water of the rivers, the water of the springs, the waters of the rain, all these waters, the natural water that Allah subhanaw taala created this out of the water that have the power to purify you. And I told you some LMR a lot like an F and Maddie keys. They said, No, actually, we only have two category. pure water, which is ba heard that it has the power to purify you, I notice, we don't have three categories.
Where's the third category comes from where's the fight over
the fight over water that distill
water. But one of its qualities, one of its descriptions, it changed with something pure.
I'll give you an example. Here where these two groups cause debate.
Because when the water completely changed to new entity, the hand the Maliki will tell you the heavy will tell you. They've been telling me and I will tell you that's not any more water. This is let's say coffee. It made of water, but it's not any more water. It does consider what coffee even though my doctor could still consider it and my dietitians still consider it too hot water because it's a liquid. You know when you calculate your water over the day, you calculate that is that right?
I guess Okay, so you calculate that as part of your basically water that you consume. So here you see what i'm saying is this the hand IV and America will tell you how is this not water? That's coffee, that's juice.
I let it go I agree with them. But the problem comes with what with water that has a little bit of touch of gasoline benzene
if you put a little bit of gasoline out the gasoline smell attached to the water now the water doesn't have a smell now the smell like gasoline, but it's water can you make with what with it?
Do you see where's the question comes? Let's say how much solder in his eye hop. Okay, and he goes to make weevil from a pot of water. Then he found that his worker are the word he works there. And while he's doing the pancake, some of the flour fall into the water.
The water has a little bit of flour, or a woman in the kitchen doing you know her basically pot and there is a little bit of flour. So it changed a little bit the color of it.
Are you allowed to use
This water tomiko
or not? You see, that's the question comes here, let's say,
a water, a pot of water, you put a little bit of salt.
You put a little bit of sugar on it
just a little bit, a spoon of sugar and in a water. This, this has a little bit of sugar in it.
With that consider water. It's thought it's pure, but does it have the power to purify you from the
having normal, you will see the shaft fittings, and you will see the ham bellies will tell you know,
that's pure, pure water. But not the hood does not have the power to remove your state of header switches that that state of preventing you from Salah, but you will find the Maliki's you will find the HANA fees, you'll find them in Tamia and a large number skaar said no, you're allowed because that's the water that still even if that smell, but didn't really change it completely. That's a very temporary, very small, very minor very minute here. Whereas basically,
the enough comes in the debate comes between the scholars.
I just thought maybe this need to explain from last week more and I hope this is will clarify. I do believe that that classification of the water to three category make for me.
It's a strong argument. And I feel more comfortable towards that direction.
Because the Hadith and Nevis of Solomon he said,
he went he said, a horrible man who that means in nevison described the water with something more than just it's being
it's being pure. It has the power to purify. When there is a solemn said about the land, cover directly. Or do misty then what ahora this land, the made for me and my oma, behold, for the nations before us, this land was only pure.
But for us, it's pure and has the power to purify. That's why you make it instead of football instead of horses. That's right when you do
the second Hadith which is headed by Allah and which is one of the most important Hadith that Allah mentioned regard to understanding the concept of water, which it says that Alma OTA hora en la luna de su who shade the water is pure, and nothing can make it impure. Abu Saeed anybody knows his name? His very famous with Scania, Abu Saeed.
Yeah, this is title. I will say this name is sad. Not many people remember that. His name is sad, sad. His father is Malik and hoodie comes from Mohammed Chava comes from
Hydra Okay, which is a neighbor, a neighborhood or a group in unsought. He was among the scholars of the Sahaba of the alarm on him, and he used to give
not all the companions or scholars, or not all the scholars of the companions, give fetters.
Pay attention. Not all the companions are scholars, or not all the scholars among the companions you've tuned later kulu Sahaba Allah Ma, Elisa Kula Matt Sahaba ft. She was when a few people have that melody to give fatwah he lived Rahim Allah, Allah and
sit down with him and he in a center. He died in the age of 86. So he lived a long life. And for him there is about 84 Hadith in Bukhari were Muslim so he among those who narrated many a hadith
this hadith where the prophets of Salaam said water is pure and nothing can make it impure. There is also a story behind the came to the prophets of Salaam this hadith known as Hadith, Baba,
Baba, if you ever heard this name,
the companion said Yasser Allah, can we make a lot from that? Well, the will of Allah.
Okay, can we make from the well, you might say why would they ask about this? Okay, the water of the sea we understand. Because it's smell different. Its tastes different. But what about the water of the the well, which should be a question No, that is a reason listen. So they said Yasser Allah He a bit a little too low coffee had
Hale blue and Latin word whom will kill up
this will where a lot of impure things and or thrown inside it or goes inside it and hear the mentioned here than here which is basically the the pads of the woman during their menses they used to put pads to stop the blood so this pads the take it and throw it and also that did dogs or cats or animals or the waist any the thing which is disgusted things the waste, it's like a dumpster. Okay, so here you might say Sure. Do we are we hearing this correct?
Are they throwing this impure things inside the well? No
no, don't ever think that the companion would ever do that as a puppy Rahim Allah
said
yeah, and he he said how can he wouldn't think of the disgusting Kaffir at that time we'll do that the one who doesn't know how long how long we'll do that. So how can you think of the best of the oma the Sahaba will go through the blood the Naja the impurity inside the will know what happened is how the water goes to the well. You know, when there is rain, the rain runs through basically.
Huh?
So, the rain goes all the way to the to this well, from the hills in the way of that rain, when the water comes there is dumpsters an area where the dump the stuff so sometimes when the rain comes, will wash with it or take with it some of these impure things or maybe the animal on the way it will carry it and dump it in that well. So this is sort of like that very possible. Okay, so if this has happened, or do we allowed to make a vote from it?
If that's happening, sometimes we notice that impure things inside the world ended up in the well because the rain bring it in or it's Washington
brought by the flood, the water flooding or whatever. Inside the well. So the prophets of Salaam told them this answer, which is beautiful answer he said, water is pure, nothing can make it what impure ly energy suhu shape.
And here when the Prophet sallallahu Sallam said she had the neck, your fecr and nafi this is indifferent. While the process of making an allegation nothing can nothing can make it impure. It means it doesn't matter what kind of impurity because the impurity is to level
major and minor. Minor like the urine. Major like the feces, like the blood of the menses. That's a major impurity. Okay, so
it may be so Salim said nothing no matter what type major, like the blood of the pig.
Versus I just did animal regular animal a bird. But here, a pigs that's a major impurity. But still in Ibiza, some of them said nothing. So no matter whatever that Naja is, it will not make that water impure. But you cannot take this hadith without the two other Hadith that we heard, which is the prophets or subtler mentioning, that when he mentioned the sea or the ocean, then later on you're going to see the prophets are solemn is speaking about that the water will not be impure unless one of the three things change. Here we say the process of Solomon he said that pure nothing will make it impure. Yes, as long as this water is huge in quantity.
So if the water is huge in the quantity of it, that nothing can make it impure, like if somebody did
threw a pig's blood in the ocean would that make it impure? No matter what do you do in the ocean or in the river or in that well, which is filled with water under water, keep coming to it. Okay, so nothing well make it impure. Also an abuse Allah Allahu Allahu alayhi wa sallam.
here telling us that the water is a hood is purifying and remove the state of ahead of us a lot of the major and about you
To tell you that before so I don't need to repeat it every time you can make a vote you can Mickelson with it and also removing that impurity that the physical impurity which is an asset like urine like the blood of
the blood of any pigs or animals or the blood of even human according to some scholar that impurity that can be removed by water
here Mr. Human law said something worth paying attention to
will can only be removed vote can be only achieved only through water and if you don't have it, you're excused to use what
the sent
no other you can't make a vote with coffee you can make with it with juice. That's right. can make a lot of anything with things like that. They but what about impurity helina jazza can you remove it with something other than water?
The answer is yes.
Anything would remove because an adjuster is a physical entity that physical entity disappeared there is no more images
that's right the state of not having although that's not a tangible thing
any if I look at sama I don't know if he has or not.
No embarrassing Okay. Can you tell I can't tell because it's not something physical. That's right. But impurity something physical you can see you can see it. So here I am. I said as long as this physical impurity removed helaas it doesn't meet water for instance, somebody
let's say you have
a basically an impurity in your carpet. The Sun comes and hit that carpet. You come next day completely disappeared.
Touch it no smell nothing is chumps Jeff perfetta dried it out completely.
Is that spot clean? Absolutely. I put heat or bring heater on I completely make it disappear through heat system Virginia. Okay, like dryer, you put it on? you let it go? They
Okay, just let me finish the point. I'll answer your question. Also, let's say you bring that
chemical, use chemicals to remove the impurity. Like in the carpet so many times in the carpet, you don't put water
spray, you spray certain chemicals on it, and you brush it and it's clean.
Would that be sufficient? Yes. So any methods you use? it's acceptable. It doesn't matter has water not asked for a service question. If the sewer water been purified and recycle, it became permissible to use or not Yes, because basically they bring it back to its original state that the way Allah subhanaw taala created it
here there is more restriction going to come to this hadith through the following one the prophets are Salam certain the other Hadith Alma which is headed to mama,
mama, his name is so they they've been agilon and Baddeley Kabila back in a
second if he muscle, Rahim, Allah what are the Allies he lived in Egypt. Then he moved to Syria to a sham and he died in a sham 81 hijiri or been said 86 injury and he was Ackerman MathML Sahaba fibula Disha he is the last companions died in the land of a sham. mafia had been a sham here means Palestine. Jordan, Syria Lebanon.
So the Ackermann mud masala hula Disha Are they alive?
And he narrated mini Hadid that's why when he lived long, so had a lot of students. Anyway, this head these were the prophets of Salaam said the water cannot be a Dunder impure by anything except something which changes its smell, taste
And color or on another narration, taste and smell or taste or color. So it doesn't need to have three of them even one of them will be sufficient change it to completely something different or than a jassa will then the smell of then adjust the color of the jaza the taste of that adjustment will be recognized on the water. Okay, so in this case, this will make the water what not any more pure.
This heady if you heard of an agile Rahim Allah said it's weak
because this has been reported by a man by the name of
Dean Rushdie in a bit sad and he is weak is not a strong Narrator As an image, Rahim Allah mentioned that and the amendment when he mentioned that I consider him weak missoura also consider him weak and he'd been classified as mongkol Hadeeth baby hatom overthrow carried by NSI is a very weak generator.
Not only that the other generation of obey helpfully has another man his name or as a man is by the name of bhakti have been worried about the creative not worried.
And he is Moodle is shaded lease and his also the relation is not accepted. So this edition and lists its taste its color. Its smell change. This edition
is not from the Prophet sallallahu Sallam in any form of any authentic hadith. Lem yes with our initial Salam caught Allah The Joomla Illa mozzarella no tamo Arya, but the Muslim Ummah, the Muslim scholars and jurist across the board all the Medina agreed on that condition.
How the zyada lizardmen kurama levy so Salim Lakin. mean Iijima infopark Allah, Allah all agreed that these are three descriptions and condition or must
and I agree that it is the meaning is correct, but we don't say that this is statement from the prophets of Psalms and through any authentic hadith
so here Allah matter him allowed to Allah said that Alma if the ninjetta the impurity if it approach if it's approached the water The water will not be impure unless a change happened to the water
pay attention with me Sorry, it's a little bit complicated
either what are the Tina Jessa lol Ma, if the impurity approach the water
Okay, here are
divided into two groups.
Lula said if this water
large quantity, large quantity, that Nigeria this impurity when it approached the water, it will not make this water impure unless as a change one of these three descriptions clear clear other group of Roma said no. If the quantity of water is a small any any impurity approach it it makes the water not acceptable impure even if nothing change in it
and both have their evidence. But for those who are interested to to see how the Muslim scholars think deeper ultimate differentiate between then adjuster approaching the water and the water approaching then adjuster
there's big different
say that it can anyone here figured it out in his own or her own
intimate differentiate between the Natasha the impurity approaching the water and the water approaching the impurity.
And let's be specific, let's say a small amount of water.
We heard some groups going on said if the impurity approach a small amount of water, it will not make that water what it will make that water impure even if nothing change in it. But they said not the other way around. If the water approach the impurity,
it will not make the water impure
why
Now the said let's assume this pot of water. Okay? You come and you put NASA and you put urine in it, you put a pig's blood, let's discuss the
Okay, you put a pig's blood here would that make that bottle?
Not just Yes. impure. But they said, If you make if you have a spot of a blood of the pig, then you take this bottle of water or near soap and your clothes, then you go outside, then you do like this, then you start pouring the water on that blood
with the water, purify the blood or not the clothes or not. Yes, when the water touched the blood touched the blood, would that make it impure? would make the water impure No, because they said if this is the case, that means every water gonna touch is going to be impure on the following water be impure. That means we'll never be able to purify anything.
That's why the differentiate between the impurity approaching the water and the water approaching the impurity.
Why are you giving me so much headache? I give you this headache? Because many people say Shall
I go to the bathroom and I have the douche on the water I basically put turn on the water and clean myself. And sometimes I see is this water? You know, some you know and maybe my
thigh or my behind or my you know, or even in the floor with that water became nervous. We say now because it's something approaching not then adjust approaching the world.
See from that we can learn many things. Not only that question, I have a dirty cloth cloth full of Natasha, I put it in the
washing machine.
But the water approach then adjust that not the other way around.
Is that clear?
Exactly. So here that the Washington the water comes and rinse it so that water is pure
after that, and that place became pure. Nobody said after you wash dirty clothes of many schools in your in your in your washing machine. You know what you're not allowed to touch it? Or if it's going to be in edges. Nobody says that.
Is that clear? So here, this is something an interesting mama have mentioned.
And Emma Malik Rahim Allah said, let's make this simple. Let's make this simple. Let's say that the water will never be nudges unless one of the three qualities change and that's what even taymiyah supported him with.
But the Hanafi the Shafi Maliki complicated it
they said no, the Hanafi the Maliki the Shafi said the water must be a large quantity.
If it's small quantity will not be acceptable.
How would you determine large from small
the Shafi the humble use the following Hadith, which is the prophets of Salaam said either Bella Halima, latte attained merkabah, when the water can basically filled two pots, it will not be in edges,
two pots, and I'll tell you what plots here means.
The Hanafi didn't consider this heading didn't like this, Honey, what the hanafy said, they said you come to a water. If you move with your hand the water like this, you push the water and that wave reach to the end of it or make a circle. That water is small amount.
So even if a lot of if any new adjuster in impurity come to it, you're not allowed to touch it even if nothing change in it. But if the water is big enough that you move it, you make a wave your hand and that wave will not reach to the end of it. That large number. Let's say the brother was asking me the pool
the pool if you do like this in the pool, would that make the wave all the way to the end of the pool? Most likely what?
Now? Was that too difficult to say? No.
No depends on the pan. Oh no matter what. I don't think you can be very, but go to that. Go to there. Your job.
cousy
maybe the bathtub, the bathtub, you do like this. Basically the water well reached the end of it. That's right. So the consider that small amount
is that clear guys? Okay, but what of its depth they said if you make a wave with that wave go all the way down to the bottom of it or not. So that the point is to make sure that it is from the beginning to the end, babe amalickiah
they said, You know what, it doesn't matter, large or small, as long as the color, the taste, the smell of the jassa didn't change the water. The water is pure
bathtub, or pot or
ceramic pot or anything.
And I'll tell you how this is so interesting. ezeli of Mohammed Al Hassan who's a shafia scholars of Mohammed Al azali after he talked about how the Shafi and the details are not La La Murakami and I'm not gonna give you a headache with all the details, but I'll tell you what it was that he said Rahim Allah. He said after he went into this he said Rahim Allah shopee a wish a wish the to follow the Malik in this and save us from oldest edik
a wish is not convinced with with this.
He should a wish that the Shafi followed Malik and saved me from all this. Whether he
had a Jeep
you would ask myself you ask yourself so while azali just didn't follow Malik and took Malik opinion, but he is mobiledit he is imitating to a chef he doesn't feel he can go out
circle of Shafi to choose for himself which is sad yeah and he for someone to see that way anyway. So he himself wish that you if you want to know how complicated this can be among the like the shafia they said
if you have a big huge place like a pool, there is no jassa in it. Somebody put a cup somebody in the pool and urinate in the pool
okay that will not make the pool what impure because it's a huge account of amount of water and it will not change the color the taste you know or the smell of it
but the said according to them they said somebody like Mashallah you know my size go to the pool every time I jump in the pool what happened to the pool?
Am I shall wave the water was started what
getting out of the pool? That's right.
I know some people shared with me this feeling okay, so the water busy got you know, flooded out that the chef said chef, Chef, a chef, he said that water that came out
that amount that came out isn't that amount small.
Small so they said that amount that went out is impure, but the one inside is pure.
So the set if you take a pot and you take it from the swimming pool, that pot is smaller man so that water you're not allowed to use it for although but you only allowed to use that water directly from the pool
to complicate that's why and that's just the simplest example I can give you and if you look at to know him a whole lot when he went into that it's really getting things so complicated that's why it was that he said I wish that we got out of this whole confusion and we just said simple of the water remain in it is state commerce doesn't matter what because I had it before head is better. Baba is clear. The province of Southern said nothing make it impure and the Hadith of the sea and we just move on with that.
And that's why the second Howdy.
The third Howdy. It's interesting the province of Selim said if he said if the water if there is enough water to fill two pots pilat It's a big pot, okay?
It
carries no impurity. And that's how the shaft Nabila said. That's how we determine what does
Big pots from smallpox. This honey Abdullah, what do you all know Abdullah Omar born in Mecca, became Muslim in Makkah and died in Mecca are the low iron and 73 hijiri. In
this Hadees Illa debated over the authenticity of it, why? Because sometimes this had evaporated one cooler, one pop, and one time apart, don't think of the part of the cooking. It's like the ceramic pot like full as a zero key that will be lad is like the big thing that they put water in it.
And until tell you the size of it right now. Some integration said three.
Okay, and some people said this hadith is muddied is confusing. Why? Because we don't know what's pot what there is many different sizes of pots. So that's why they reject and that the Hanafi that's why the NFL didn't go with that size, the NFL went with the hand moved because the concern this hadith is weak. But to be honest with you, this hadith is not mockery, and the narrations of the one and three is not authentic, this narration of two is authentic
and it is authentic and there is no contradiction between this one and the previous one. Here. If you just borrow, I can borrow your attention for five more minutes, I'm done for tonight.
This head is it says if if the water is filled two pots will not carry impurity
what this implies
the head it says if it fills two pots, it will not carries
impurity adjust what this hand is implies
about what you think
what this implies
that he said if there is amount of water that can fill two pots quality will not carry impurity cannot be impure.
Obviously, unless that color or the taste change, but that what that implies, implies, implies has a formula maharlika Have you heard of that implies what that if it is less than two pots, it means it will carry impurity.
Also that again, so if it's less than two parts, it will carry that the empiric any manner it can attain hamanaka but
if it's less than two, it will carry there
have been Tamia said no,
I don't agree with that. Why? Because
this is implied, but the previous Hadith is explicit, the water is pure, nothing will change it unless
the color the taste, this is explicit. He said if you have to text if you have an implied and you have an explicit which one you take over the other
the explicit metadata element aka sorry, well my phone
number explicit, is that correct? Yeah. And he gives you an example just to make it easy. Allah subhanaw taala said in the Quran is still fairly home. I will add a Stanford alum, Sabina Mara layer for Allah who don't, you may still fall for them. Or you don't if you make a still fought for them 70 times Allah will not forgive them. Is that can be can be sad. Okay, so 70 will not forgive them. Can we say since he said 70. So if it's 71 maybe they will be forgiven? Or 72 maybe they will be forgiven? We said no.
That's that's, that's not correct understanding why? Because Allah said in the other verse and sort of 10 Nisa, in Illuminati in a darkened us for the men and now then when after being in the bottom of the Hellfire, that is period, there is no way for the hypocrites to be saved. If they die as a hypocrite
if I don't, so here that implies doesn't work. So that's why even Tamia believe this authentic but there is no implies. But the shafia is the Hanbury said no. The implies is correct, then indeed aka indifferent or soul, no sort of
sequences, a sharp lahoma foom if there is a condition that means a condition imply for a for example, if I say
if you come at five, you get $5
that means if you come before five you don't get the $5
that implies That's right. That's right.
Hello. Yes obviously, because I put a condition
here that what led the amount of human would like to do to say that two parts pillon what the size of this according to the Hamblen the shafee it is delallo hotjar pillar these pots pots for containing water comes from hotjar hotjar woodware in the East province in Saudi Arabia today. And that is why we saved this particular one. Because that's what was known in Medina they never used any other containers. This is a form of the major of the water with it in modern language how big that is. One, the two
the one pot it will contain 270 liters
270 liters then in American language 71.3 gallons of water
so if it's two that means 142.6 gallon of water that will be a lot that's no matter what you put in adjust and it will not change it unless the water itself change. But if it's less than that amount according to the hammer and the shaft, yeah, it will be what no
sorry. The 70 is for the both the 70.3 gallon gallon it's for both will attain together 270 liters for both for the two pots. Not one so don't double that.
It's It's huge. Hola Kabira Okay, app. I go with the opinion that even Tamia Rahim Allah His opinion and Malik, it's very solid, very strong, that you know what, if the water is in a large, large or small quantity, it will not be impure unless one of its
color or smell or taste change. And among the people who said that, as if it hasn't Rahim Allah said Chateau de la Juan and Omar Abdullah Abdullah avenuesuite has lived nearly Abu hurayrah
and many other companions and from the successors. It's the position of hustle and bustle. He said at the mercy say, WW. Mujahid they've been trouble on Qasim Mohammed, the Grand Mufti of Medina. That's why most likely Malik said that, so he didn't be Laila and many other scholars have mentioned that among the deposition. So it's a very strong argument.
So with this, we'll come to the explanation of the sport or Hadith. The next one is also very interesting about you know, making widow and also in the water, you know, comes to the Can I have a lot and also from water that I urinate in it, like in pools and stuff like that. We'll talk about the show on next week, as polygon