Waleed Basyouni – Bulugh Al Maram – Book Of Fasting 07
AI: Summary ©
The transcript is a collection of various statements and phrases used in English. They include words like fasting, continuously fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fasting, fast
AI: Summary ©
smilla Alhamdulillah wa Salatu was Salam ala rasulillah bada le he will be human. What about
last week yesterday?
Elif Rahim Allah the author of the book,
in hedge out stock mentioning the ahaadeeth that has to do with that days, which is we're not allowed to fast or it's not recommended for us to fast. Okay, so he talked about a little footnote. Before that he's talking about the obligatory fasting, that the recommending fasting days he mentioned arafa and he mentioned the 10th, the 10th of Muharram, Ashura, he talked about Monday, he talked about fasting, the three days of the month and so forth. Then he started after that talk about the days which is not allowed for you to fast or it is not recommended for you to fast
a dino Dino law or shuttle shuttle law will help the Hong Kong law the dean belong to Allah
the halaal it was a loss of this Helen and the how long it was a loss of this how long
Allah said one day you have too fast and he said one day useful within us too fast. One day I recommend to you too fast and one days it is not recommended for you to one days and you're allowed Sunday is not a lot we all belong we belong to our last panel dad and he does and ordain and order whatever he wishes and he will
and this is something to reflect upon when we study these interesting concept
days you're allowed to fast and there's not a lot of us
so we will continue with these days that are seldom talked about in regard to fasting for the sisters they can come inside the masala here if they want your guys more than welcome to come for.
Go ahead.
Hadith abou hora de la la hustle a lotta drama
690 a billy
now working
just hold the
green.
Okay.
So come closer
and more only for a Hema Allahu taala wannabe hora radi Allahu anhu annina de sol Allahu alayhi wa sallam McCall. Lotta hosue laylatul Juma? itbp min benei Layali wala taho suyama jumeau hitbtc amin bien bien.
La acuna Fie so many asumu who are hadoken provato Muslim, Abu huraira the Allahu anhu said the Messenger of Allah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam said, Do not single out the night preceding Friday from amongst the nights for prayer and do not single out Friday from amongst the days for fasting, unless it occurs during a day of fasting Which one of you normally observes reported by Muslim?
Sorry,
maybe the next one.
One who is Ron Paul, Paul Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam la semana de como como el Giamatti. illa asuma Yeoman Kabila who oh man bairrada Who woulda coulda la wine who is one Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam appall Eden philosopher Shabana Fela Tasuku la Hamza was Sankara who Achmad? narrated Abu huraira de la one. Allah's Messenger sallallahu alayhi wa sallam said, none of you should fast on Friday, unless he fasts it together with the day before it or a day after it agreed upon. Narrated Abu huraira the Allahu Allah says messenger sallallahu alayhi wa sallam said when the Manta Siobhan is halfway through
Simon LAU hamdu Lillah wa salatu salam ala rasulillah this hadith Hadith Abu huraira the Allahu and do not specify the night of Friday with a specific night prayer nor the day of Juma the day of Friday with fasting unless it is a day that you usually fast and it happened to be in on Friday that day
this hadith reported by Muslim Rahim Allah to Allah
I'm sharing this for because there is a lot of people online and some people on site also may be few benefit from it.
We all know that till Buhari will Muslims ahaadeeth are all authentic,
but this is in general, but there is certain ahaadeeth even in in Bahati and Muslim, some scholars and Hadith criticize
and the criticism to these narrations and Buhari or Muslim are more of a technical than anything else. So, that is technicality there is a problem in the technicality of it or
that objection will be not in the whole entire text, but will be part of the text is basically criticized by the scholars not the whole entire idea, but maybe some addition in the Hadith. Like for example, give you example, you will hear Hadith that didn't abhi sallallahu Sallam said that you will give in charity that you will give a lot or conceal your charity that your left hand will not know what your right hand given. You will find for example in a Muslim and eration it says that his right hand will not know what is his left hand.
in color, bullheaded al-rawi We call this Hanif makalu upside down. So the narrator got confused, and he's making the opposite this category part of what we call weak narration.
But here it is so obvious the heading is so long had his job but are they alone and about seven people in the DB in the shade of Allah Allah. So one of the generation in the Muslim for example, happened this. This is technical, it's obvious, it's known, you cannot say the whole entire Hadith is weak and just this luffa or an addition. Okay, and addition and the heading that, for example, that our last panel with Allah created the heavens and the earth and what's in the heavens and earth in seven days, and instead of six, so added the seventh, that edition the seventh something to criticize, or you will find a hadith where the narrator will cite through Medina Fattah de la.
So he will say the one who came closer to Allah closer is Allah, this edition The one who came closer is Allah is criticized and this is weak.
Because no one ever add this to the nourish. So you will find that it is very long but one statement or one paragraph or maybe one word it would be criticized also sometimes the debate over technicality and this is a good example this heavy even though it's a Muslim woman Her name is Mohammed bin Syrian and ebihara are the Allah and Mohammed urban city in said Abu hurayrah said the Prophet said okay that's fine it'd been city in met his narration Viola acceptable.
But when we start examining this narration, you will find that all even Siri in most of them and Syrian students narrated that even Siri in her said a Buddha said
not Abu hurayrah
and we know that even Syrian did not hear anything from appdata
so it looks like someone from a different city and or his students students mix it up and put up over and above data because no one had been sitting didn't MIT
so it means that there is someone between urban Syrian and Abu hurayrah We call this hadith mersa. How did this honey is based on copper there is a pie there is basically not correct. There is weakness and that's why an amendment data company Rahim Allah, met with the tuber criticize Muslims.
narrating this hadith and he said Muslim saying that it is through O'Hara, but the reality is no, it is from a bit dark that
he never actually heard this little girl.
And they said that the Hadith goes to Abu Dhabi that doesn't go to be heard or the Allahu anhu are out of LA. And then ration of ABA, ABA da da. It is known Abdullah Zamp reported nabeshima reported the nessa reported Ahmed reported we were very aware of it.
That's why many of the scholars of Hadith is headed like a B hat immobilize the abuser da da da Kotani Rahim Allah have basically picked on him a Muslim in this specific narration and they said no, here you say like Shia is that means the Hadith is weak? No, the text the actual meaning of the Hadith is correct. How come you just said there is space between or there is, you know, had been said he'd never heard from da da Yes, but if you look at the meaning of the Hadith goes along with the next study that he read, which is a little Buhari or Muslim
goes in the same light so the concept the ruling is exactly is confirmed by other narration so we consider the other one is like shanghaied is another narration to support that's why Muslim put it in his sleep. He didn't put it because nothing because he believed that this tax has a based and authentic backup for it by him allow data which is headed or be heard or the ally. Also it means maybe that also been sitting really heard from Avaya on the alignment not solely to be limited to EBIT da da da da Alon so here that's why you will find gentlemen in a group of scholars 100 Hadeeth have authenticated this hadith like even Hadith Muslim and Avi hurayrah had been hit ban
and in battle hacking an eBay healthy and others
the second hand each individual solemn said in the same concept do not fast Friday by itself unless you fast one day before it or one day after
the previous one do not specify Friday with fasting here the other half of them have a Muslim make it more clear you add one day to before or after
which the ruling in regard to fasting Friday. I want to fast Friday.
We say if Friday happen to be a day
like let's say out of
and you're not traveling Can you fast it Yes. Because you did not fast Friday because it's Friday because it was out of order actually Ashura? Okay, let's say you're in the habit of in the habit of fasting one day and breakfast one day fast one day and breakfast one day so Friday happened to be one of the day that you're going to fast we see no, break your fast two days. No, you still can trust Friday because that's basically a regular habit. But what if you know what, tomorrow Friday? Allahu Akbar we pray Friday the best Salah Juma the best salon the weakest Friday tomorrow prayer. So let me fast as well.
Guys, in Friday isn't the end of the day that is a time what is acceptable. So when you fast upon breaking your fast isn't acceptable. Why don't we do two in one we fast Friday, so we get the two
we have the virtue of the end of the day of Joomla and we have the virtue of being about to break your fast. So you put these two together, I get more reward than logic.
Two guys, don't you think this is a good point.
So in Ibiza, Salim said do not specify Friday with fasting. This logic is cancelled by Muhammad Sallallahu sallam.
It's so what is the ruling in regard to fasting Friday what if somebody
and ematic Rahim Allah and Abu hanifa Rahim Allah said it is permissible to fast Friday by itself.
Why? This said because it will miss Rudra the Allah Allah said
Allah Mara Ito Rasul Allah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam use the Roman Juma. It's very rare that I see the Prophet sallallahu Sallam not fasting on Friday.
So an Imam, Abu hanifa most of his knowledge
Most of his fatawa and his position comes from Minnesota they allow and he is a student of the School of Minnesota. So he has this ratio to Minnesota he based his argue on it.
The second opinion they said no,
it is dislike too fast Friday and to specify Friday with fasting. That's the position for mega Rahim Allah and remember Shafi and it was half an hour and they said the Hadith is very clear on the Buhari Muslim he said do not fast Friday by itself unless you add a day to it or day after it
and headed down another one that you heard earlier.
Also do a ribbon to hateth and this hurry decision Buhari and abuse will allow it seldom told her do not fast Friday by itself unless you add one day to it before or after.
Also and this is an essay Muslim holiday jewelry or the allow unfillable hottie sorry for Bahati not Muslim
so if this is the case, they said it's clear in Ibiza Salim said don't and this is for alcara why dislike why not how long this it's not haram because the prophets of Salaam said you fasted and the day after. So it means only by itself is mcru That's why you are allowed to festivals we add one thing or dated or if it comes as a day of other fasting like what I said earlier out of our circle the third opinion I think you can guess by now they said it's forbidden
and they said the profits or some of them said do not and that's very explicit from the processor level which it means how long lie so men a very clear prohibition from the present do not fast Friday by itself do not specify Friday with fasting and that's the position have been hesitant Rahim Allah and also the HANA beta one ratio from the HANA beta and the choice of scheffel Islam had been Tamia Rahim Allah to Allah they said the Hadith is explosive. what it looks like to me it is highly dislike to fast Friday by itself. Yeah and you caracara hasha D that did that. It is very highly dislike to do so.
Among the evidence that even Tamia used to say it's how long he said Friday is a day for eat
it's eat the eat every week we have eat okay. And there is an aeration honey that in Nabi sallallahu alayhi wa sallam said that the day of Friday is eat
there is debate over the process on said that are not as authentic. But Omar said that he said I know it revealed in a data feed which is Friday
he was referring to a verse in the Quran so Friday known to be eat and fasting the day of read is not allowed. So that's one of the position that the hen ability but it's not very good argument actually. Why because it's an aid but it's different than the eagle football on either of
us right? Can anybody tell me what's the difference between Friday as I eat under eight footer on either
give me a clear differences between them
last Friday type had you
know the the eat itself it's it's not the same eat
not the same prayer.
He said to read so you cannot make them
54 eight That's right, as very good point. also read the filter select and read for either filter for
some do it house that's enough. But Juma is divine upon every Muslim male residents are capable seen by
him I said why the reason Islam told us not to specify Friday with fasting because Nabi sallallahu Sallam want us to be strong to do other kinds of worship during Juma come to the mustard early stay focus on the hotbar listen to the hot leave. It's like I can tell you the difference between me when I go hot button Ramadan and outside Ramadan and Ramadan. Everybody's like
so out of it, at least outside drama man I get a little bit of excitement you know from people. But then I'm Yvonne people completely off.
Anyway,
Eben Massoud on the lava and generation which is reported back to the MIDI, how Allah understood.
Any episode meant lm acid
Very rare to find the process of not fasting on Friday in Indonesia supplement his regular fast a Friday comes he will not break his fast just specifically for Friday, he will continue fast his regular days. So for example, if he fasting six days enroll 10 days when Friday he will continue fast. You will not break it just because it's Friday. That's what Massoud meant that's how American law said that's what also in Ibiza so that may be fasted Friday sometimes just to show us is not held on too fast friday
so we understand because he did it he want to tell you it's not forbidden and just dislike so sometimes it don't do that and when he do it so Allah send them just to show that it is not haram it just not recommended. Okay, ordinary Salah Sallam said do this, but then we will not do it himself. Why? To tell you that when he said do it, I don't mean it is must just recommend it. That's why the problem left it. So that's something we understand when we look at the practice of a Navy SEAL allowed you it was said
what we learn from this hadith number one, that if you have a regular habit of fasting, you basically you do it even if it's Friday, Friday, it is a form of eat from the Muslims, similar to the eat from certain aspects. Also it is not from the sinner at all to specify the night of Friday with any type of worship, like the amylase or Salah or specific prayer or anything like that. The only thing in the night of Friday that is ordained for us is to read social care.
I will say this again the night of Friday mean Thursday night.
You are recommended to read circle Caf as well as the day of Friday. So either you read it the night before Friday or you read it in the mornings you read after a show on Thursday, or after Thursday or you read it after federal or after any before tomorrow or any after tomorrow or until you have until us or until November according to some
next Halley's
people's say Juma Mubarak either yeah Nia Allah bless this tomorrow. That's why
we're in who I don't know Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam upon Eden philosopher Shabana falletto Sumo, Rahul Hamza was tenkara who
narrated above what are the Allahu Allah His Messenger sallallahu alayhi wa sallam said when the month of Shabbat is halfway through do not fast reported by enhancer and Ahmed considered it monka
this headed when Chad ban became in the middle you should not trust as you heard earlier, reported by Hamza Buddha would
tell me the Oneness it will be magic what I met
and this hadith Lima Rahim Allah to Allah criticize it and he said it is mooncup Why? Because this narrations the whole entire Hadees goes around a man by the name of Allah Allah bin Abdullah Hey man, he inherited that his father said that. And Lima Rahim Allah said, This is the worst thing ever Allah Allah ever narrated in his life, okay. And he rejected this, while others color accepted it like it took immediate like Abu
Taha we have an uphill battle about him a whole lot of inhibin have been hesitant. They said it is correct and it's authentic. But Raja been heavily in it and said, there is greater scholar than them more knowledgeable of integral Hadeeth like ashmit was euro one s ROM or gwazi. All of them said this hadith is weak and is not acceptable. And because of this problem of Allah.
Rama Rama Lima Muslim Rahim Allah even though he narrated a hadith Allah Abdur Rahman and Abby, he narrated all of them except this one, he did not put it in as Muslim. And even Muslim abandoned this Hadith, specifically, even though he knows about it, but he never put it in his book. And that shows you that a Muslim doesn't consider it as something that meets his condition as authentic.
Anyway,
some even said Rahim Mahalo to Allah. If chabanne became fit
The 15th of chabanne do not fast they've been hasn't said if this had this this heavy means yeah and you do not fast the 16th
pile even toss of a shadow ban fell out assume and Isla de banda do not fast the 16th of shabba that's what it is have been hasm Rahim Allah said other said no in Abu Salah la Sallam said after the 15th of Sham ban, don't start fasting just because you want to be in the safe side. Hey, I'm going to fast after the 15th just to make sure that I'm not gonna miss any day from Oban. This is not correct. Many of the amount of human would love to Allah do not consider this hadith is authentic. And that's why they said you can fast after Shabbat as much as you want. Some said no, it is not recommended because of this Hadith, but I don't know anybody who said it's forbidden or how
long?
In the 15th of Sham band. There is a very famous prayer at called Salatu was Salam elfia the 1000 Salah, which is basically the pray 100 tracker in each rocker, the Red Bull Allah had 10 times the total is 1000 repetition of Portola.
Okay, so the Scarlet a Salatu elfi it's very famous practice and ritual people do this is innovation in religion. There is nothing in related to the middle of Shabbat as a ritual or a virtue for any specific worship act of worship during that
night.
Go ahead next.
One is some eventi postwhen radi Allahu taala and another Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam call that assume uyama sub the famous story there Aleikum for inlandia Jetta how to come in the arena Arena
in abettin, Lee arena, Baton Rouge ashada Ratan folium, Doha Allahu Hamza William bow folium Doe, Rahul Hansa regional support, under whom operate worldwide Ankara who Malik makalah Abu Dawood, who
narrated a summer Binti bussola the Allahu taala on her Allah's Messenger sallallahu alayhi wa sallam said, Do not fast on a Saturday, except what has been made obligatory on you. And if one of you can get nothing but a grape skin or a twig from a tree, he should chew it reported by the Hamza and his narrators are reliable, but it is narrated with irreconcilable contradictions in the chain. Malik rejected it in Abu Dawood said it is monsoon or abrogated,
or reconsider bullish
narrated
early considerable contradiction, contradictions.
This heavy head is
related to not fasting on Saturday, it's very strong headed that the problem is that if you couldn't find anything to break your fast word, you could take a root of a tree and you suck it. Or you take a basically is called a shadow
branch.
Grape peeling?
Yeah, great peeling No. It means basically, that you peel the branch, what to cover the branch, you take that basically cover over the branch, and you suck the water out of it. Or you take the route out and you suck the water out of it just to break your fast. And so today, if you can find anything to break your password, you go to the desert and you do that just to make sure that you're not fasting. That's how the process aligned emphasis according to this lead on the importance of not fasting on Saturday, unless it's a day which is obligatory to fast start up a whole lot.
Like yesterday.
So this has been reported by a Buddha would when he was telling me the word imagine what he meant. I met Dr. Maha baho to add some
authentic like and hack him or him a whole lot upon it's not it's not authentic. But as you heard my buddy what's my buddy mean? motoric it's mean
when things is not stable,
okay. It means instability, when there is contradiction that you cannot reconcile between them.
What's the problem with this heavy the Bruce had started the problem with it from the beginning generator of the hidey hole neuroaid this hadith. We just heard him saying a sama bin to boost. But this hadith was narrated that a sama bin to Bush said her brother said
her brother, I'm delighted, is a famous companion.
Okay. Another time it was narrated was enhanced. I'm delighted. nubus her brother said, my father said, The Prophet said, so it is now the grandfather of Assam. Also, I'm delighted Nivison said my enset The Prophet said, harlot. Once the Hadith came, that Abdullah was said that
his aunt, her paternal aunt, not maternal
Amazon, and one he said my sister of some
and once he said, my sister, Asher nopsema, the other sister,
and once he said my mother,
and when he said, I heard that he said, the prophet wife said,
so how many we have now? Did you see how many house mixed up this is? That's why no matter how Allah said, we cannot accept this narration. Whoever in the successors among the successor or the follow the successors get so confused. Is it a Somalian to Bissell is her brother, her uncle, her father, her grandfather, her other sister, her aunt or uncle? He gets sick. When that narrator is so confused like this. What do we do with the Hadith?
We said we don't need it. We exit it's weak. So in a matter of Hadith, he would reject this hadith. That's why the Missouri Rahim Mahalo to Allah said liath but I'm not going to take this narration. That's what Emma Malik Rahim Allah when he was told about this hadith Kala the end Yanni hapa mapset Caribbean Li Lima, Malik said this is Kevin. Kevin, you guys familiar with the word Qaeda in Arabic language in the people who will hijas when they see Qaeda by means of pop? That's why I show when she said about Omar Kadam she means mistake. A lot of people share some raffia they use this and said oh she said he's a liar on how can you trust a lie? That's not true. The logo on it he just the
way that he just speaks when they said Caribbean
mistake that's a very common way of speaking anyway.
And remember, I was I have no upon any memory but how we have been Tamia akima Hola, mini Ruda Matt. Hazard as well here said it's, it is weak narration. And even if we say it is not weak, it is not
a Buddha Woodson, it is Mansu abrogated.
And also, it looks like he leans toward that as well, that it is also abrogated.
So that it's not his week. The text itself is strange. The text of the head is strange. Why? Because in the bizarre sanlam in the Hadith in Bukhari and Muslim we just heard, don't fast fry the embassy fast one day too before or one day. What's after Friday, Saturday, so how he say here you fast Saturday. On this hand it is bahaya Muslim.
So that text contradict very authentic hadith that shows the permissibility of fasting Saturday. Also, many other narration that tend to be sal Allahu Allahu Allahu wa sallam fasted Saturday masala said in Derbyshire Salim used to fast in a regular base on Saturday.
And oma cinemas, narration is more authentic than this one.
The Hadith is more authentic than this one. So the text contradict other texts, more authentic and more clear. Also add to this when the prophets of Salaam says unless you go and you dig a tree and you suck. Why?
If you don't want to fast Saturday,
do you have to do all this interest in your intention? I'm not fasting done you're not fasting? Why you have to go dig a tree and to eat it and even makes no sense.
It doesn't really make much sense because you can just break your fast bite the intention.
The
that's why Luna Mara human
I do not have a problem with fasting Saturday
it is became in modern days an issue because Chicana Schiphol Albania Rahim Allah tada one of my teachers and great scholars of Islam in modern days shall Bonnie authenticate this generation authentic of the city and he became very even strict about it
that he said if out of come Saturday you're not allowed to fast out of
because you cannot fast the day after
which is eight you're not allowed to fast if you can endlessly fast one day before he said but Saturday is not allowed at all. He said it's forbidden and heroin
and I don't know anyone before shall ban he says that
all respect and love for Chef America mama but I do anyone in Ahmed Mohammed Salah Salam said what he said about this
and no doubt is a great scholar but everybody will Kapha Bill Maher in Oberlin Antara and to add that
a noble people the one that you can count their mistakes can you count my mistakes? You can't there's too many of them
if you can count your mistakes You're a good man good man.
But the problem is our mistakes are there's too many of them Michelle among those so you can count their mistakes. Very few.
Next
one Omi Selamat er the Allahu taala under Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam. Actor Americana Xsara acciara Makana yasumoto minella yam yo mo subbed for yo mala had Makana Yahoo in Houma yo Meriden Lil mushrikeen Well, Anna Marie do an O halifa home of Raja Honda EU wasa ha ha
ha ha de la
narrated on Santa Maria de la wine ha Allah messenger sallallahu alayhi wa sallam used to fast mostly on Saturday and Sunday and he used to say there are festivals for the polytheist and I want to add contrary to them reported by unnecessary and emphysema graded stuffy and this is his wording.
Yes this head is also
considered by Lima pond as an acceptable and mephala Rahim Allah and others
and also shall albani authenticated which is interesting, as well.
This Hadith misalignment of the olana shows clearly that fasting Saturday will be acceptable. The
mme Shafi Rahim Allah Shafi and the hen Abdullah said fasting Saturday by itself is dislike
they still consider this even if it's weak Hadith, the Hannibal especially they still go with the weak Hadith with preferred over the opinion said it's McCrone but it's not how long
Some said No Actually it is recommended to faster day
because honey masala Marathi Allahu Allah wa
and the correct opinion is the third one which is the opinion of the magmatic Rahim Allah and in the moment Jose and the chosen between me and him they'll pay him also supported that and I assume other
in his comment on that be dealt with and others and have been handled as well that it is permissible you are allowed to fast Saturday if you want and you just like any other day the only one who said it's How long shall Albania Rahim Allah Allah and I can't think of any scholar support him on that opinion. Next.
Oh, the hadith of Salah. He said there are celebrating this as eat so the eat and drink and eat. So I want to do the opposite by not eating and drinking them that day.
Can we say that this logic is still fine because today, Saturday and Sunday. It's a celebration for the Christian and Jews and you would like to be different than them? Yes.
Why NaVi hora de radi Allahu Donna, and then nebia sallallahu alayhi wa sallam the thing we look at when we find a hadith like this, we look at the AMA the setup the practice of the Sahaba.
I'm not aware that there is a common practice between the Seraph on regardless they didn't understand that they want themselves also to faster
dense under. Yes. Why? nabee hora de radi Allahu taala and the nebia sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, Naha, and Somi Yomi arafa bR of Valhalla Hamza vida tirmidhi for Sahaba Jose Mata al Hakim was tenkara Hanako he narrated Abu hooray rhodiola who run the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam prohibited fasting on the day of alpha at arafa reported by Al Hamza except at the middie even Hosea in a hacking authenticated it and an old lady considered it monken rejected
Yes, and also had been has him and and no and then one day he and it albani all of them considered weak Hadeeth because how shall pay and that's why
okay and others surprised by some people who authenticated this hadith and they said cow can it be authenticated? Because this man How should we apply it is not from Alba heart is Narrator As of hacking claimed, and he is actually a weak NARRATOR But anyway, this lead to the issue of fasting the date of alpha for those who are on had What's the reason we learned before fasting out of a for non Hajaj some people staying and not doing Hajj is highly recommended. But what about someone in out of itself?
Yeah, I've been saying that on saadian and even Hassan and he said it's forbidden it's a sin. Okay, and this is gonna be so solemn forbid that it means forbidden,
it is recommended for the person to fast the day of alpha urine had not been had. And by the way, this opinion, adapted by some of the companions like I shall be allowed, and also the zubayr. And this happened on our hallway, and they said that Heidi spoke about the virtue of alpha fasting alpha did not say for Hajj of non Hajj, its general the third opinion which is the position of the former die, the Shafi the Hanafi the Maliki the Hanbury, and it is the vast majority of the earliest colors from the Sahaba and the tambourine that we know of that fasting the day of alpha for the person who's not in hajj highly recommended for those unhedged it is basically highly dislike
and it is highly recommended for the judge not too fast. Why? Because there is other ahaadeeth more authentic than this one had his own family or the Allahu anhu. At the day four out of four people were debating is the price on fasting or not because every year he fast the day of arafah when he's in Medina, but when he making Hajj people start saying is he fasting that if out of or not? Yes, no, yes, no tomorrow, oma Salah witnessing so we'll follow the alarm and witnessing that. So she sent the price up she went to cut the debate. Shouldn't a cup of milk, cow's milk to the profit she said the profit during the milk.
He is not fasting. If you're rejected, it means he's fasting. So in the B cell A lie Selim was in his camel on the top of his camel. She passed the milk the prompt took the milk and he drank the milk
Hello, no no debate. The person is not fasting that they said the sinner is not too fast and that they felt a bit like the process alum called Hulu anumana seeker can do what I do. And inhibition did not fast the day of out of Arnie's fasting when he is doing Hajj. salatu salam and this by the way, in the Bukhari Muslim Muslim, the story of Omar Favaro the Allahu wa Alba.
Somebody the man like Shafilea him on line one opinion and then hop Baba Shafi choose this the said and this is also artha and atod said we differentiate in hajj between someone capable of fasting and someone fasting will make them weak cannot pray and make them and move from one place to another.
If he is weak no it's best not to fast if he's strong enough it's recommended for him to fast but again I don't think this opinion is very strong because in the B cell allow it is stronger than anyone else. And he himself didn't fast some allow it you it was the next
one up below 11 Norma radi Allahu Allah and Houma all Kala Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam last fall Mammon sama, Muto Hakuna la nonformal Abed that's why man sama, Ubud takuna la Vallee Muslim in Ibiza to be loved in Lhasa mala after, narrated up to live in omalo the long line Houma Allah's Messenger sallallahu alayhi wa sallam said
He who observes perpetual fasting has not fasted, agreed upon. Muslim reported it from Abu Qatada with the wording he has not fasted nor broken his fast
Can anyone explain what this hadith means to me?
What this means?
He said he did not fast the one who continuously fast we assume Coolio everyday you've asked
for forever like this. He said he didn't he's not fasting
by law son is not fasting
and another version is not a fasting not a non fasting
naughty word. Yeah and you fast but there is no reward for your fast so he said la sama Wallah. After Yanni he did not break his does not break his fast to enjoying food. No, he is fasting and enjoying the world. And he lost both. He lost the world. And he lost what
the food, the ability to eat and to drink. So he lost both. That's what it means. laughs perasaan Yanni La Jolla, Sam, Wollaston Tabitha,
he's a losery and in another word, the person he lost both he didn't get this nor he got that. So remember a human last.
Last time I'm on Simon Abbott had Hubbert on his to do app it's a statement from the prophets of Salaam telling us that the person who does such thing yeah and you will not get the idea of that fasting. And some said it means maybe the Prophet min dragon is that person that Allah do not accept from them
any Do not let their fast to be accepted to be a correct fasting
and this headed as you heard in Bahati wa Muslim in the other nation that he said he didn't fast nor he break his fast it because he didn't enjoy the food nor he finds what that means continuous fast, some adult
Why? Because there are certain days in the year it's forbidden for you to fast. So, like eat not allowed to fast and if you fast you have committed sin. So, is this what the processor meant?
And Rama Rama mama debated over the
ALU
subset.
If you continuously fast, continuously fast, but you avoid the days which is fasting and it is not allowed. It's fine.
Any in another word