Shadee Elmasry – Just because they narrate the hadith…
AI: Summary ©
AI: Transcript ©
Just because ImageReady to 30 narrates a hadith does not mean he
supports it doesn't mean he sell it Majidi to 30 his main work, he
has two main works. One is the massive history. The other one is
is Tafseer. And his style of Tafseer is he goes from fetch head
down, and he talks about every narration that was uttered that
was stated by anyone. Okay? Related to that doesn't mean he
supports it. He so he's an encyclopedic good. He's not
selecting the Hadith that he believes are correct. And you have
to know that there are three major works who do not do this or who
who do not only cite what they think is correct, and they are a
buddy, okay, and
Imam Muhammad and humble and before both of them even Malik Ibn
Anas good. In America, bananas has 60 Hadees he's citing to let you
know that he knows about these Hadith but he finds them to be
exceptional or contextualized and he doesn't apply them in his FIP
Imams duty narrate 60 of them.
Imam Ahmed his own son came to him he said Father you narrated a
hadith in the most net but your ruling is different. He said my
Muslim is not my the Hadith that I rule by.
I'm putting in the most net anything that any scholar or all
the Hadith that any reputable scholar uses in their FIP so even
if I find a stronger narration or a stronger proof or contextualize
that hadith are limited, okay? or suspend it because its context is
unknown. Okay, but someone else uses it then he includes it.
That's mmm Ramadan is mostly a debris as well. He cites many a
hadith, which he's citing them so that you know they're there.
Right? This is like scholarly honesty, right? This is proper
scholarship, so that you know that there. He learned he lists all
these then he goes at the bottom and he said and I find the strong
one or the one that makes the most that's that's most corroborated or
that fits with the texts or that has no contradictions to be x y&z
So just the fact that he met somebody cites this does not mean
that it's the kid