Shadee Elmasry – Irans Attack on Israel NBF 329
AI: Summary ©
AI: Transcript ©
Bismillah al Rahman al Rahim Al hamdu lillah wa Salatu was Salam
ala Rasulillah early here was a biggie woman who Allah
Ladies Gentlemen, welcome to the SOFIA society nothing but facts
live stream on a bit cold
clammy a little bit.
Yeah, Wednesday afternoon, in which will begin to begin with the
dot between the Hora nostra it's very important to do this to take
advantage of any moment in which Allah Tala told us
that or through the Companions through the Sahaba through through
the prophets I seldom that dua is accepted in it. So let's begin
with that right away. Leila had a lot of medical and medical benign
andalo medical doctor Amin La ilaha illallah medical opprobrium
similar Amanda Rahimi in Ephrata, Anna Lika tam will be in the offer
Allah Coloma taka demon them bigger one at a quarter Wait a
minute metabolic DECA serata must be even when surah Allah Who knows
Rana Aziz
Cana in de la who would you how would you have dunya Well, karate
a minute macabre been what Jawad you he had a Lady Fatima to
Ensenada her mother I minister of mineral life had some collagen but
she didn't want me in Yeah, you're Latina? I'm an akuna ansata like
and I thought a 70 muddiman How about ina mineral Saudi it'll law
but how are you in an animal Assad Allah? Allah Allah Allah Allahu Al
Heyoka you later called the hosts in Atlanta Lahoma for Samoa Joe
mafia. Mandela Diaz founder who elaborate in jamoma Boehner ad him
Omar Khalifa Humala, a tuna mache made me love him Asha was yeah
Chrissy was similar to you will although I would have Domo who
Allah Allah you know the Bismillah R Rahman Rahim Allah azza wa jal
nallah Javon and Nora eita, Okasha, Mutasa, German Hashem
with 10 kilometer and another Ebola nasionale Nami atrophic Kuru
who Allah Allah de la ilaha illa who are limited by viewers that
the Hora Manuel Rahim O Allah Allah de la ilaha illa who el
Mercado could those who Salam al momento Mohammed Aziz we'll jump
right in with tech cap Subhan Allah Hi, I'm usually goon who
Aloha appleberry Almost so what hola hola SMA or Husna Serbia hola
home if it's somehow it will all do Oh ALLAH Zs will hacky
way there are civil rights army columnist malby other names will
be named when she BDJ line up this way they can reach everything.
Hassan FCB La Hawla Akbar min Sharma aka for other mineral
genuine insuman Dodona xojo Jonathan Oh taka set as
well Allah viral alumina Jericho funeral idea that he will either
be coming true to him which I do to him when I cut him when we get
at him. I'll turn out a minute or two minutes genuine and see after
the Ivy League FEMA Subhanak er I've met other machette Nick was a
sort of dynamic test center Villa I mean his main lobby it love like
the lobby I love this villa saw the inventory at the Law Center of
Cebula Illa illa Allah Muhammad Rasulullah sallallahu anyone who's
on them Allah modesty Malika Lottie Latin American phonemic
Kenefick under the labrum what how many were quadratic era for La La
Quinta de partie. Raja if you have a thermistor at nearby thermistor
is the nearby thermistor at near the record hediki near the record
hurricane hurricane hurricane. It finished recording quality data
can you throw Kobe Leyland on her laptop? Can you throw Kobe her
naked traditional cardio. This will lie Archana assuming Colima
demon Cooley has in Las Vegas Malayala Allah Martinez Advil best
issue and to share with you I've entered my feet as you have a lush
evoke Savannah no other Sofia Mona anima
yeah caffeine. Mafia Hamid Yama de define Nikolas Da Vinci de doc
fundamental hardeeville Hadid Almara the shedule JC la did
virtual environment. Guzman is conocer menos ko Bamba terminado a
cosmonaut I'll stick with either Metallica doolally Willeke rom
while ma Hey Bella, so you can take fina Machado co Ed equaliser
in I can't Allah Akbar Wa SallAllahu ala Sayidina Muhammad
Mala early he was somebody he was sending them to Slimming cathedral
anti Mubarak and P or hamdu Lillahi Rabbil Alameen overhearing
about the pneumonic Kula Halia or hamara he me in Jelacic a few
minutes for door
Allahu Allah said no Mohammed while earlier Samuelsson was upon
that number behind the commission to Allah Allah Allah and and stuff
will expand. That'll be Curbelo ISAIAH MILES ephone wa salam ala
mousseline Alhamdulillah your enemy in.
Alright, let's start off
with our reading, which we did
yesterday we intended to do this reading on Elevate, we're gonna do
that reading segments is gonna be segment number one. Segment Number
two is going to be an unboxing.
There's a new product out there that some Muslims have made.
Segment numero Ptrace. Okay.
Is that's going to be the, that's segment number one, segment two,
this unboxing segment three, we're gonna read about Iran and what
they've done and correct some errors that were made by people
who were not informed. And then segment number
two for I don't know, we might read this about Indonesia's
they're really trying to make all the masajid green. We'll take a
look at that segment number five, we'll take the QA and yes, I do
read
from the
from the chat bot or a box or whatever you call it, the chat
box.
We do read from that. I see it on my lap my iPad and I see it on
this TV screen here. And also the Instagram as well.
All right, let's pick up
there is Zubayr I'm in Nabi sallallahu alayhi wa salam,
the children of Zubayr the prophesy centum has a a uncle
mature paternal brother of his father, paternal uncle got it
Zubair, and of course,
he had sons, and the first one is Abdullah Elizabeth. Good.
He was one of the greatest Sahaba of the Levin's of it, he stood
steadfast with the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa salam, but he
has no offspring.
His mother was Attica, been to be at Michael's Rumia.
He was killed in battle during the Khilafah of Abu Bakr and he has no
offspring. Next,
we have Taha Ebenezer bear.
Good.
Ahead of Elizabeth Kinnaman of the Rafi Fitz, Yannick Quraysh, some
Benny Hashem Daraja Oh, Allahu Akbar. Guys, if you come to New
Brunswick ever, you know we're in New Brunswick, where we're one
mile from Robert Wood Johnson University Hospital, right around
there as Rutgers University right around there is a new coffee shop
called Haber. And we've been basically reading this place every
day, because also nobody goes to Starbucks anymore. They mustn't
don't go to Starbucks anymore.
I've heard even the local Starbucks here is having issues
You're kidding me.
You're the older lady who? Excuses she was a nice lady.
Because you are kidding. That lady that like she has orange hair. I
haven't seen this woman for woman for like 10 years. And we're like,
We talk all the time. She's like an older lady. She's the manager
of the store. She wasn't demanded in the beginning, she moved up,
right? And did have a new manager every few years. Finally, she
became manager. She's very, like, nice, talkative, she remembers
your name.
So I'd go in there pay my rent, which is a small cup of coffee.
That's my rent, right? And I'd sit with my laptop in the daytime
before we had the studio and stuff like that. Just to like to be
around some people. Because sometimes, like if you sit in the
masjid, you sit at home, it's like, too quiet. Right? So Subhan
Allah, I'm shocked that they gave her six months, there are six
months to fix it up. Or maybe you bring her on to Hiber so like
Muslims, right?
Yeah.
Priests like established in Australia. So he's saying we gotta
read that Mari Mari who was bashing the Prophet peace be upon
him? Yep. But he's mentioning apparently, I didn't know this
that PPD that our coverage of it. I don't know if you saw this. And
he's saying that. They went off on an extremely Islamophobic rant.
I've said this before. I don't condone it. But it's like a law of
nature.
Right? I can't condone this stuff was forbidden to do it. Obviously,
there's no doubt about that for anyone to do what they did. Right?
But it is just seems like to be a law of nature. You know, what else
is a law of nature, you go out in Newark Gore on Camden. And take
your wallet out and take the money out and say, hey, look how much
money we have. It's a law of nature, you're gonna get jacked,
and you're gonna get jumped, right?
Here's another law of nature out there. Right? I mean, this is
cause and effect happens all the time doesn't mean it's right. But
it happens all the time. Right?
Why don't you go post something on LinkedIn, anti Zionist anti
Israel, see how much your career suffers? See how far your career
goes. There are like these basic causes and effect. It's not right.
But it's pretty obvious that this is the result. Right.
And this Marie Marie, is
what he talks about other things, he's fun to listen to, I have to
admit, right? He comes with the outfits. And he talks about, you
know, when he talks about some of the social issues, he's fun to
listen to, then he turns to the Prophet peace be upon and he
unloads. Okay. And he fires away with ignorance, I might say. We
think he says he's a Syrian like Iraqi, and HE READS ARABIC.
You're, it's, that's not Arabic. I don't know what that maybe that's
a Syrian or a Syriac or whatever he's reading is not Arabic. Okay.
So I've seen him try to speak Arabic.
But what Omar is pointing to which we have to make as a segment
today, is that he was stabbed at his church. Right. And we're not
condoning that. Right. Hmm. I think they're saying it was a
Muslim.
I
don't know he, they said an article that I read that in
Sydney, I believe in Sydney, Australia, there have been
tensions between the communities because he's very outspoken. And
he always brings up the prophets name, right. So that's why they're
assuming it's nothing is confirmed yet I don't believe as of last
last night when I read it. But anyway, you could read it, and
when read it, and we'll get ready for the segment for that segment.
When we get there. We'll just read a couple more pages of this to a
veteran out of seeking the blessings of reading about the
prophets. As I said him and his family, there was another tire
administer bear.
And they say that he was
he used to be so beloved to the Prophet peace be upon him that the
prophet named his son after him.
Right.
According to Ignatian, the third child of zubaid the uncle of the
Prophet, the Prophet had a paternal uncle named as Zubayr is
omole HECM can Tatra via Agnel Harith Ibn Abdul Muttalib she
married her via son of habits on a Abdulmutallab and she was a
companion she entered Islam. And she also narrated from the
prophets of Allah who sent him some had eats afterwards.
Then there was Luba been to Zubair she was the husband, sorry, the
wife of Nick and dads. So there's a famous companion by the name of
Nick dads in an S What? And she bore him Abdullah admitted myth
dead and Kadima
Bintan Mcdot, daughter of Mcdot and she also narrated Hadith from
the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, and she narrated from her
husband things that her husband said.
And then there was
our best the Fourth Uncle, paternal uncle was ibis, of
course, the famous Ibis. And he has fun lemonade, immanent Ibis
got
fun Libnah labas. And for those of you that are Bess was
the famous companion who was with the Prophet. So I set him at
hedge. And it's a well known Hadith and chapters on hijab. And
lowering the gaze that a woman came.
And the prophets I said, that she asked questions about can I make
hajj on behalf of my father, who's very old.
And our best apparently was looking at her and he turned the
face of a bus. Because that's his cousin, younger cousin. And he has
the right to do that. Because the younger cousin is almost like,
he's the prophets like a father figure to him. On top of that,
he's your prophet is above a father figure, right? So and he's
the ruler. So he has the right to touch some that, that men and turn
his head away. So he pushed his face away from looking at her.
And so they said, that's one of the evidences that her she her
face was apparent, is that what else would be looking at that
another man's some of the opposing arguments against that? They said,
maybe he was listening to her voice? Well, you don't be turning
your head would not change that you hear her voice. So that's
arguments on the side, that maybe he was looking at her figure. And
that's far off, right.
So, so somewhat fully covered, and you're going to start, if you're
fully covered, you're you don't even really get to see much of a
figure, right, because it's just see a draped cloth. So that's why
the dominant opinion on that is that he was turning her his face
from looking at her face, not hearing her, which turning in the
face would be irrelevant. You still hear or looking at her
figure?
Which would also be relevant, because if you're covered from top
to bottom, right, your chances are most likely. And by the way, if
she was covered with something tight, okay.
Wouldn't the Prophet have had to have say something? Right. So she
wasn't wearing anything tight. Otherwise, we probably would have
said something. He's it's an obligation
they'd have taken or unless you'd like wrapped it, you know?
Yeah. You know, that for us. If a scholar does not say something,
Scholar does not say something. It doesn't mean he permits it. It
just means that he determined at this moment, it's not the right
timing to say anything.
Okay.
But for free for profit doesn't say something that mean just
permitted. The profit, as like his the law pertaining to the prophets
I send them is that there cannot be a monkey in his presence,
except he says something why? Because his silence is an approval
is for us to learn. Okay. This is why the chef here had some
leniency with the flute, particularly this is applied by
the entire team. They they hold that opinion, other chefs don't
hold this opinion. Because the prophets I seldom
came upon two instances in which the flute came up, or any wind
instruments came up and he didn't condemn it. So the first incident
was that during for the event, someone said, Let's blow a horn.
Prophet didn't say blowing is forbidden. Blowing into
instruments is forbidden.
The trumpet, yeah, yeah. That's a good point to thirdly, secondly,
well, you know, they're gonna say that the angels are at the source
of our shittier. That's what they'll say. And also, that's
after should he has no longer obligatory because it'll be end of
time. Those are the be responses to that. The second thing is that
the Prophet SAW Selim is narrated to have been writing on a on
across an area where boy was playing a flute.
And the Prophet was reciting something. So he covered his ears.
And they took from that, that an Abdullah bin Ahmed was with him.
It took from that that he was silent about it, and he was
covered his ears because he was reciting something. So they took
his silence to but coverage to mean discouragement. Because it's,
it's neither did he say nothing fully. He took an action, he
covered his ears. Some said he covered his ears because he was
reciting something other said no. To the silence and covering the
ears is indicative of discouragement. The chef as they
know, he's he only covered his ears because he was reciting so
it's permitted
So hence, a sawI, I believe has a statement narrates a statement
from the Medicus, which is not the dominant opinion of
discouragement, but they do teach that in Egypt. My teacher Sheikh
Mohammed should be teaches that opinion of wind instruments
discouraged. stringed instruments forbidden and percussion
instruments permitted. Absolutely. Not just in weddings and not just
for men or women, right for men or women, in weddings and outside of
weddings. So that is like your most lenient opinion that you'll
find in the book. And you can find that in how she did Sookie.
Yeah, and they give that photo. They give that photo, but it's not
the Moazzam matured federal in the Maliki school, the mature is all
forbidden, except for the drum by women in weddings. Right. So
but point being on that is that the argument against this is that
it's not known the order of,
of these narrations. So these narrations on the flute, but then
the order on the prohibition of all instruments
like it could have come after. So that's one of the arguments
against the the wind instrument permissibility. Right. And as
ultimately, at the end of the day, when all is said and done in
practice, in practice, the there's a general full acceptance of the
open ended drum,
the duff the open ended drum, and that's it at all times.
McLaughlin, but not in misogyny. So it's not what
but I mean, what luck I'm by men or women, weddings or non
weddings, but not massage. So the only exception is not to do it in
the masjid. And
that's when you travel across the ocean. You see, like what's
actually in practice? That seems to be that's accepted. But flute
but when no string Definitely no. Right?
Or Egyptian.
So let's now go to next. The sons of our bestest fuddled, that's one
number one second one to the famous, of course, I'm loving
Ibis.
He's Rabbani you had the hill OMA, he is the scholar he is the
manifester of this ummah. He is the one who the Prophet prayed
for. And he was born what he dubbed Allah couple Elijah be
filthy sin. He was born for Shabaab. And he was born three
years before the Hijra.
Okay, and he was
a prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam passed away and he's 14
years old. How does he have so many Hadith somebody else
yesterday? answer to that is that
the scholars, the young companions did not narrate only what they
heard from the Prophet Seisen. They narrated
what they also took from companions. So they would go to
companion so what did the Bible say about this? And this was
before the time that you had to name who you took your knowledge
from. So they would go to him and say, what did the prophets say
about this, what the prophets say about that?
And they would attend their sessions and talk to them, then
they would narrate it from the Prophet peace be upon him without
saying, I took it from Sahabi Soto because there was no need, there
was no concept of lying about the prophet at that time. Nobody lied
about the Prophet. But one way that you can tell is that they
would not say I heard the Prophet say, right, so they would say the
Prophet said,
and that's one of the ways you can tell that he took it from a
companion, okay.
Metalogix Allahu Anhu. But he moved to thrive.
In the year 82, of the Hijra. In the days of Abdullah bin Zubair,
there's a baby caliphate. And he moves to talk because in Mecca,
Allah subhanaw taala says, When my unit fee bill had an OB don't even
know that whoever even in and he and he made Tafseer of that, that
if you intend
or you have a bad intent, just the intention, the thought to do
something wrong. You get sins in Mecca. So he's he held that the
bad intention in Mecca, counts against you because of that verse.
So he said this is too much so he left so we will move to dive.
Good. And this year was the man was 1868
What kind of new Zubayr kraja hoomin Maccha. Were met Oh of new
otter bison. He says something different years has it been
disobeyed removed him from Mecca? I don't I never knew about that.
Never heard that. I heard that he left because of the weightiness of
that verse. Whoever intends a sin
volume
Got in Mecca. He said all sins are. So if you intend to sin in
Mecca, it counts against you. He said that well out about Sabina
Santa when he was 74 he was removed from or he died when he
was 74 years old.
While Salah Ali Mohammed, Hannah via his cousin,
or would be maybe nephew,
his cousin's son, Mohammed bin Hanafi, a son of Amara will have
prayed the Janaza prayer on him.
Right
and he's one of those who saw Gibreel in the human form speaking
to the Prophet saizen
Allahumma fapy who fit Dini you are limited with the Prophet
prayed for Abdullah bin ibis, oh Allah teach him the religion, make
him knowledgeable in the religion and make him understand
interpretation.
And in another Hadith, oh Allah bless him and spread from him
other words a lineage and make him from the righteous servants. Okay,
so it's many, many, many people are from the lineage of Ibis. It's
one of the lineages that exists of added baits, and they're not. They
have special rules for them. But we've mentioned many times before,
if there is no Islamic State, taking care of little bait,
financially, they're poor.
They're impoverished, then they take from this liquor, then it's
just intended as a gift.
And his mother was omole fuddle Lu, Baba Bentyl Harith, Al Elia,
when will father sister of Maimunah. And for this reason that
had been our best Abdullah and best was able to sleep over the
prophets house. Why because the wife of the Prophet was Maimunah
Maimunah being the wife of the Prophet, business business, his
maternal aunt, his collar, so therefore he can be with her
without hijab. So he would sleep over house of the Prophet size and
we learn a lot about the prophets routine in tahajjud. And in that
hadith says the prophet would sleep in the initial part of the
night, then get up rub his face, use the miswak firstly, clean his
mouth recite then the last 10 ideas of Adam Braun.
Okay, then make will do and then pray to short articles and then
pray long because after that,
and then there is Obaidullah evident I best put them in an
ibis, Abdul Rahman Abdullah Abbas MALBA Jibon labas OMA Habib
Scintilla best to Mohammed Nila best catheterization lab basil
heard them love buzz. So by will miss her. Well, I mean, I was
Sophie Webb Ben who had I'm in the business. Oh, and that's it. Stop,
stop right there. Sofia. didn't allow bus. Okay. And he just has
short.
There's not much comment on the rest of those
children. Okay.
Rest of those children.
All right, next subject is
John foreigner. I don't know if this is a real name or not? Or if
this is just a internet name. Who says
he said disagree completely. All right. disagree completely with
our take on the Iranian attack Iran's attack on
Israel. And he says basically summary of what he's saying. Just
because they're Sunni, you say that the attack is weak and
meaningless. Not Shia. Right? Just because I'm Sunni. Just because
their ship. I have a question then. Why is it that I would
defend the right to attack?
Right. And why is it that I have said so many numerous times to so
often out of like, it's a shame.
The only factions that have anything have done anything
outside of the Palestinians?
It's obviously Hamas is a Sunni organization. All the Palestinians
are Sudanese Right? Or Christians.
Okay.
But the resistance is Sunni. Outside of the Palestinians.
I have said repeatedly What a shame. The only people that have
anything are the sheer right? And I'm not gonna even gonna do a
psychology on it because there could be a psychology, the
theology and the psychology could be is that their doctrine is based
on a David and Goliath mentality constantly. The the, it's
constantly that we're have to face off against the bigger forces.
It could be an it could not be. I'm sure there's times where she
weren't like that, right. It's irrelevant. Point being is that
don't come on to this
to the to the page, make a comment, which you're not informed
about. Right? When I said on the same day, I told you I'm totally
with them on this attack. In fact, they were very measured. They
could have done it the next day.
But I do still stand by the fact that concept that this is not an
actual seriously damaging attack. Someone said they lost 2 billion
Israel lost $2 billion is really not the case. Can someone look
that up? and verify that? Maybe that would be damaged? I mean, $2
billion, is pretty decent amount of money. Right? But what's my
proof of that? My art of the support of my argument is you
don't tell your enemy. I'm coming in 72 days, hours, right? It says
here that 99% or 90%, here of the drone attacks.
all over the news. were shot down.
I'm gonna say point by that. Why do you think they were shot down?
Because they were prepared? Because you gave them three days.
So I stick by the fact that it was a symbolic shelling.
And I can't leave out. We can't leave out
some nations who are absolute when ethics I must be I don't know what
else to say.
Helped Israel knock these down.
Some nations that are attributed to us, right.
Okay.
All right.
In other words, as soon as
there's nothing to say about them,
the whole lot of them is done to say. So if the brother is saying,
Oh, he's spected some praise. We've said it many times the shame
on a sunnah outside of the Palestinians for either either
being bought and sold, like people like bought and sold, they're
handcuffed. They can't really say anything. They have too much to
lose, which is not good. And then there are absolute utter
cheerleaders of Israel lovers of his Zionists.
Right? And I and I'll tell you why I'm not gonna even just name these
countries because
I have too many
established people in those countries. They told me Listen,
you name the country word associated with you. They're gonna
come knocking on doors, but you know who I mean? You all should
know who I mean. There's Jordan Mizel just said, Jordan who went
and helped them
knock down these missiles. Let's read this.
Ad May a dean English
said that?
Well, while the the missile and drone attacks were largely
thwarted and cause little damage, according to
journalists here, Faris tun Yos,
character Bochenek bunch of journals, they all say the same
thing. There's very little physical damage. But unmad Dean
says
is your loss hundreds of million dollars possibly up to $1.3
billion.
That's decent. That's decent. That's good. But let's just look
at this. Hezbollah Shia. Iran. Shia, Yemenis Houthis, Shia.
There's a theme here. Right? On this thing, they got it right.
I mean, the Houthis. The Cold War world have it for a week or so.
Right?
Other than Yemen's attack on Israel, and Israel bounce ships,
which has cost the occupation billions of dollars, what does it
cost the occupation? No, no. One night of attempting to repel the
retaliatory Iranian attack on Israel cost the occupation at
least $1.3 billion.
Okay, this comes in a dish in addition to Israel, dropping
billions of dollars worth of munitions on besieged Gaza,
killing 10s of 1000s of Palestinians in little over a
year. Okay, is there an article on this? Or is it just a picture
here? Yeah. So the
the bulk of it,
that part of the financial element of things is damaged the physical
part. No, I stand by that wasn't a serious physical attack.
Let's see what he said. He said what you said. Thank you.
The physical part of it is nothing. Right? The financial
part? Yes, symbolic part. Yes, maybe.
But it has nothing to do that. They're sure I'm here admitting.
They have 100%. Right. And they showed a lot of they were very
measured in how they did this. When your embassy gets attacked,
in the same day, you could launch a missile right?
and no one will
you know will say anything to you.
Okay.
Here it says the Iranian threat and met the aerial and
technological superiority of the IDF. Yes, there's the IDF is
superior when they're informed three days in advance, because
Hamas did the same thing.
Right. And it wasn't so superior on that day.
Let's read Sammy Hamdi.
The second one, Iran has no intention of escalating beyond the
drones. It sent crawling to Israel, meaning with forewarning,
you know, you're coming. Okay. Iran only wants to save face and
has no intentions of escalating further. Okay. Biden and Israel
know this. Netanyahu does not fear Iran causing a regional war he
fears Iran trying to avoid one.
Good. So on that.
I stand by that take on in terms of the the shelling the nature of
the shelling the nature of the drone strikes? The 72 hour
warning? It was symbolic, right? It has nothing to do with them
being Shia. Right. It
just has nothing to do with Theology at all. The three groups
that at least politically their position is correct. On this
issue. Are the three share groups, Hezbollah? Houthis, Iran, at least
politically, right. Turkey is now the R mo one of our most beloved
of Sunni nations. They talk a good talk and that's it. Why? Because
we read earlier that there is neutralization they share a
similar enemy.
In Europe, with Israel, there is a nation I can't remember where that
article is. I wish I had that article. Where is they? They just
they they put out there that Turkey and Israel actually share a
mutual enemy that the trying to neutralize can't remember who it
is. But
and as a result of that Turkey and Israel have great relations. Hey,
can you look that up? Turkey Israel relations before the war.
That's why when this thing happened, right, and Erdogan, of
course, he's who he is, with his politics and his Islamic approach
to things, was almost handcuffed. All he could do is talk a good
talk. Right? And we own it. That's it. That's all it is. And is that
good or bad? No, it's blameworthy to talk and not act as
blameworthy. There's no doubt about that.
And then it goes, it's like it's like Erdogan and then a big drop.
The Egyptian people talk to good talk. And they say the government
allowed the people to talk a good talk. The government itself
silence
by and large.
Take another drop go another down another cliff.
And then you have the lovers of Zionist okay, I would say I would
put Jordan with Egypt when those just completely silent. And then
you're going to put the Gulf states and Jordan maybe even be
between because they help them they helped them gunned down these
these drones okay, why can't you just say hey, it's not my my fight
you can't because you don't even have your own free willpower.
You're bought and sold you're told what to do. That's it
a shame and an embarrassment and can you open this again because I
want to read his saving Yeah
Okay, let's see. This article is from
Jewish news syndicate Jin's?
Iran is attacked attack on Israel yesterday demonstrated one thing
did demonstrate one thing is not just America that protects Israel,
but also the Arab states going when I 15. You won't call him what
you want to call him. Of course, I can say that because I'm not
there. Otherwise, I'd be in jail. My family would be in jail. And I
hope that none of my friends get in trouble for when I say these
things. I mean, it's
they all know it to
Jordan, they're, they're good with their citizens.
There are some other states semi Hamdi can't go ever to the
Emirates can never probably got to order even.
It's not just America that protects Israel. So the Arab
states, okay.
I would have to specifically say the Sunni Arab states since these
brothers they want everyone to be fair. Here I'm telling you how it
is. And I've said it so much before what a shame though the
only people sticking off is the only ones who got it right on this
is the sheer states
Iran seems to have reached Tel Aviv directly, despite not just
the Iron Dome but also the air
Up till
quite a statement in this regard. Iran attack is an offer of de
escalation in which everyone wins.
Iran wins plaudits for attacking Israel directly while other Muslim
leaders just appease Israel as it commits genocide. Okay, correct.
Biden shows his strength and successfully rappelling Jones
drones. Good.
And Israel gets to say that they are Iron Dome worked
by added that
I think he's 100 grand, right? That is a de escalation when you
when your response is, is is is just like that drones crawling to
Israel, when that is your response. You're announcing to the
world, we're done. Basically, we don't want to fight
you.
It's like when you are when you're having a severe argument with
somebody, and then they come back with with their response of well,
all right, well, you know, I disagree. Okay, that means he
wants to de escalate the whole thing. He wants to end right
there. Or he says, Okay, well, listen, maybe you have some
points. But I don't like the way you said it. Once. It turns from
the content of what you said to the way you said it. There's no
more discussion. Right at that point.
Not Saudi not not UAE, not Qatar, not Kuwait,
will be eager to allow the US to use their territory in any attack
against Iran.
Even if Iran's loud slow telegraphed attack on Israel turns
out to be a show, which it did to her but but the financial thing is
real, right? I mean, did they meet us is gonna pay for it anyway.
Right.
Teheran would not hold back in actually punishing its neighbors
via malicious
if a war broke out
between Iran and Zionists, I'm rooting for Iran.
Simply
because we have brains, our brains separate between categories of
things. Simple as that.
Did not the Companions then HAC support the
did they not support the Christians over the pagans? Right.
So I would support
Iran
in the Mongol time, were allied with anyone who, yeah, because
everyone was being plowed down. Yep.
Let's now read this next article here.
This is by the Janus written by some different Jewish Jewish.
Yesterday we read from Haaretz. Now it's the Jewish news
syndicate.
And this is only 20 hours ago, in an effort to improve bilateral
relations. After years of tumultuous fluctuations. Turkish
President Recep Tayyip Erdogan agreed to meet with Benjamin
Netanyahu for the first time on the sidelines of the 78th UN
General Assembly headquarters in New York in September 2023.
This article was one
okay, it's
he's he's talking about before the war but this article was was
released yesterday. 2017 This was from the 16th there cordial
relationship will be short lived just a few weeks weeks later,
October 7, timeservice invaded Israel, etc. Kidnapping killing
1200 and kidnapping 240. The massacre marked yet another
turning point for Israel Turkish relations as Erdogan backed Hamas.
Unlike many of its NATO, NATO allies and the European Union
Turkey does not consider him as a terrorist organization. And host
members of the group and hosts members of the group on its on its
territory. Daniel Pipes i This guy's Daniel Pipes is trash.
He has no credibility. President of the Middle East forum. Yeah,
noted that since 2003, looking at Turkey's foreign relations as a
whole Erdogan has engaged in highly erratic, contentious
policies with every important foreign government with the
possible exception of Azerbaijan, Azerbaijan. I actually believe in
that you got to keep people on their toes. You can't be
predictable. You have to keep them on their toes. No problem with
that if what he's saying is true. He says there's so many examples.
Jns went to Daniel Pipes for the for the for the reference. So,
there are so many examples. He points to Iran, Iraq, Syria,
Egypt, Libya, blah, blah, blah.
He even have tormented relations with his own puppet government in
North Cyprus. Okay.
So what is the Israel Turkey relationship? The relationship
between Jerusalem and Ankara has been more
Ready to buy significant ebbs and flows? Why is he saying Jerusalem
not Tel Aviv is is it now official that that's the capital?
Yeah
marred by significant ebbs and flows in the last 14 years.
Relations between the former allies deteriorated in 2010 after
Israeli naval commandos came under attack and killed 10 Turks. In
2013. At the end of the of then US President Obama's visit to Israel,
and just minutes before he departed from Tel Aviv to Jordan,
Jordan on Air Force One he brokered a phone call
at the airport between Netanyahu and Erdogan, during which they
agreed to re establish relations.
However, this attempt was started in 2014 by renewed airstrikes
against Hamas, Operation Protective Edge. It wasn't until
2016 following Israeli compensation to the families that
those killed on the Marmara. The diplomatic ties were reinstated,
and they exchanged ambassadors. This piece again was short lived.
In 2019, Israel forced was forced to suppress Hamas instigated
the Hamas instigated great march of return and it has it during
which Palestinians attack the border fence.
And that reignited tensions between Turkey and Israel.
Hertzog then visited Turkey in March of 2022, and subsequent
visits by both foreign ministers helped thaw relations, which
ultimately led to the Aragon Netanyahu meeting in New York last
September, a month before October. The meeting took place against the
backdrop of UNHCR his efforts to resolve disputes with Arab nations
like Egypt, UAE and Saudi concern coinciding with a broader global
alignment with Israel in the wake of the Abraham Accords, Ankara saw
the revival of diplomatic relations with Israel, not just as
a matter of bilateral interest, but also as a strategic move to
enhance its standing in Washington.
Erdogan has sought to mend ties with many former adversaries,
right? Even mended ties with Saudi Okay.
Seeing it as a means to also both bolstered struggling Turkish
economy. One major driver has been the potential economic gain.
Alright, that's a paragraph on that. However, October with
October 7 elections looming, he backtracked stiffened his
position, right and in so that he could win back cities like Ankara
and Istanbul, which he lost in the 2019 elections, but on March 31,
Turkey's opposition Islamist opposition won a stunning victory
across several cities.
Trying to save face he doubled down on criticism of Israel.
Erdogan offered condolences in a phone call to Hamas leader Ismail
Haniya who lost three sons. And so they don't mention that the nation
that they have ties with Israel will definitely be held
accountable for the law
before the law for the crimes against humanity committed Okay,
the honeymoon is officially over now between Turkey and Jerusalem,
Israel say experts in the region okay, it was a honeymoon they say
different you know these Institute's you know these
Institute's they're always very suspicious. Right anything with
the more generic the name the more suspicious is like Institute for
the New American Century or American Institute for whatever
right American Think Tank whatever you think tank the more generic
the name the more suspicious is after October 7, Erdogan adopted a
pro Palestinian stance and a pro Hamas attitude he legitimize the
group. Alright since then we had very bitter discourse against
Israel in Turkey.
Due to Islamist parties and their demands to cut relations with
Israel, facing disloyalty with his own party his solution was to
neutralize the bargaining chip of the opposing parties by
implementing trade limitations with Israel.
Last week, Turkey restricted exports of a wide range of
products Israel. All right, so he's taking some actions but not
the critical actions, which is use of force and who knows, we
weren't. We're not in the region. We don't know if he has the
capability to do that. But he's, there's something that's why you
got you put Turkey there's a line of, there's a line here, right
above that line.
You're gonna put
the nations that are explicitly with their policies, taking some
action
against the Zionist occupation.
Under that line, you're gonna put those who stay silent completely.
Then you put another line
those who are supportive, right, and that's where you're gonna get
your, all your MBAs and busy MBAs and all the
All those, Jordan,
where would you put Malaysia and Indonesia? I would say that
there's so far it's not expected from them anything but words like
not and it's not expected of them to
you know what is a 24 hour missiles coming right
almost so spread out that they would just but what about the
economic power? There's not united that's what No. Erdogan they're
saying is sacrificing the economic interests of the people have
turkey in order to support Hamas.
Okay, so
he's the elected leader so they clearly like his policies and
therefore, yeah, there are what's wrong with making the sacrifice?
Make a sacrifice? What's wrong with them?
Over the years Turkey tripled it. Okay. This is what we're looking
for. Over the years trade Turkey trip tripled its exports to
Israel, from 2.3 billion to seven bill. billion
fifth largest supplier of goods
to Israel and seventh largest customer.
All right, you blame me for having a Wix website? These guys $2.5
billion a year. Okay. 2.2% of Israel's income
from sale from international sales to Turkey. Okay, so Turkish
Israeli relations had been like this. Once again, Turkish Turkey
Israel relations became the scapegoat of Turkish domestic
posts. Of course, people there, they're gonna say, no, he's just
using Israel to bolster up power. How do you know maybe actually
believes in it? Do I think he actually believes it to not just
using it as a chip?
While there are no direct flights between Tel Aviv and Istanbul no
proper tourism between the two countries and bilateral trade has
been reduced. Relations between two countries remain cold.
Okay, on paper.
He noted however, that if a new a new Gaza flotilla from Turkey
arrives off Israel's coast as expected, this will further strain
relations.
Okay. Today, the Turks look at Netanyahu as committing genocide,
it'll be difficult to do it for them to do a u turn. In politics,
everything can change. But in the short term Israel In Israel, we
need a new government to turn a new page with his with Turkey.
Okay. So based upon this, really, they got to put Turkey above the
line, right? You got to put them above the line, they're not at the
level of the sheath, three sheary and entities in their response.
But
it's something then under that line, you're gonna put your Egypt
countries like just say completely silent on everything. And then
under that the line, another line, those who are actually
cheerleading and supporting and helping, and they are Zionists.
They love them. And they'd have no problem with what's happening.
Okay. No problem with what's happening. We have an unboxing
here segment number three
a new gifts or product I should say.
Okay, look at this.
And they said hey, could you I said send me a copy, send me one
of them. And I'll show everyone your product here.
All right, so this is a
new company called CDI agile. It's name of the company
and you put your laptop in here, obviously, it closes with magnets,
there's a magnetic bar and two magnets down here.
And then you have a strap.
Okay, and you have some, some pockets in here to put your stuff
and there's writing everywhere here. Okay, so there's little
messages everywhere here. The bag itself that it came in had a
leather message says and model mom and a hub. A person's Hadith of
the Prophet a person is with whom whomever they love, meaning on the
day of judgment.
And it says it here to model moment.
And then it has another message inside what's
that says a person will be with those whom he loves. So they say
it three times. So that gets in your head. It's written three
times here. Now let's see if there's an outside pocket. There
is an outside pocket, little outside pocket and what website is
CDI Did you could look at it. This is their website.
This They call this the kins up
portable laptop bag
oh the box was from them to you know that's that sandal that
sandals storage box that we put our Odin that was from them too
yeah and you can go to the website called see data.co
Alright and you can get this for 200 bucks but you can't anymore
because it's sold out so maybe later they're also the producers
of those sandal wall art wouldn't cut out okay they also produce a
scarf they also that has many colors the bag this bag only comes
in this brown color. Okay, what other products do they have? Let's
see all their products then Seattle duck co
wrote a nice website here gives you that vibe you know the new
Instagram companies that are very artistic and mission driven and
everything so they have they have scarves they have the laptop bag.
Okay, let's look at let's click on leather goods. No, it's only this
one. Okay, then scarves latas winter scarves very simple though
not a lot of ornate scars just regular color scarves that come in
cream. It comes in red, it comes in black for different colors. All
right.
Then the decor accessories. People love accessories is the box. Okay,
it's a sandal it's a box with a sandal on it. Now people may be
asking what is the big deal with the sandal the sandal? There is a
description of how the Prophet sandal looked. And so that's used
as a symbol basically
you know when that started because it seems like it's become much
more prevalent Yeah, I don't know to be honest with you. I really
don't know but this is the shape of the Prophet sandal. Okay, so
what does it symbolize it symbolizes being in the footsteps
of the Prophet that's why he put the sandal there you're in the
footsteps of Satan
that's a concept
let's read this
Indonesia
what's the deal with what are these?
What I'm not saying and trying to do in Indonesia let's see if
that's interesting. Alright, this was sent to me by Anis
what can green Islam achieve in the world's largest Muslim
country? If you're into this stuff if you're into climate change if
you're into climate
you know environmentalism this is the article for you this was
written by sweetly we N
sheets travelled to Indonesia from the New York Times and published
this today.
Just faithful gathered in an imposing modernist building
1000s of men and skullcaps women and veils so exotic sitting
shoulder to shoulder she's shocked right
there leader took his to his perch and delivered a stark warning. Our
fatal shortcomings as human beings have been that we treat the earth
just as an objects. This is the grand Imam nosode Dean Omar, the
greedier we are toward nature, the sooner doomsday will arrive.
Then he prescribed the cure, I'm gonna have to correct that I mean,
an epidemic is coming whether we like it or not, you'd be the best
towards nature in the world. So So Dan was coming, right? It's coming
with sins or with good deeds. That's the difference. Right? Many
people ask if if the person hadn't, let's say been reckless in
their car. Let's say someone was reckless in their car and then had
a severe accident.
Will if they weren't reckless, would they still have had the
accident? The answer is the state that they were that they're in now
they would have still been in that state but with a different path.
Maybe a praiseworthy path, maybe an innocent path, maybe you would
have suffered the same injury saving somebody, maybe you would
have suffered the same injury while being fully victim or you
suffer the same injury while being blameworthy. Speeding, you're not
wearing your seatbelt texting while driving. So the result we
say will be the same. But the path would be different. If someone
wasn't texting and driving, would they still be alive? It's a
question. Right? Many people think about
injuries. The Time of death is the time of death. But the path you
took to it could have been different. Right? You could have
died in a praiseworthy manner. That's that's where you're
blameworthy. But the end result is end result.
Time place location.
This is all set.
How? Yeah, and and and everything and how the state in which you got
there. That's where your deeds take place in or have an impact.
Are you getting there and dying?
In a blameworthy state as fully a victim
or as
in a blame, were in a praiseworthy state, okay? Certainly there's the
same thing, the concept of the saying,
When is tribulation comes, if you reject the tribulation, and you
hate the tribulation, and you're fighting it, and you're maybe even
committing sins, then you will suffer while getting sins written
against you and being blameworthy. But the same tribulation is not
going to change, it's going to come down upon you, but you have
sub, you treat it right. You will suffer and you will be rewarded.
Right? That's so the suffering, the state, the tribulation, the
end result, the death, the accident, the bad thing, the
result is going to is written, right, it's there for you is not
going to have changed. But how you got there and the state in which
you're in? Are you praised or blamed? Are you victim? Or are you
guilty? That's what could have changed. And that makes a big,
that's a big difference. It's a huge difference. Someone who,
let's say has a terrible accident.
Okay, terrible accident and is the cause of death of other people
because of texting while driving. How do you live with that? In
contrast, somebody who, for example, his his car hit someone
that caused great damage, and he suffered,
you know, the same exact suffering.
But he was totally innocent. Right?
It's a big difference.
All right, so the mm, he then prescribed the cure laid out by
their faith, which guides almost a quarter of humanity, like fasting
during Ramadan is every Muslims fought a dying or personal
obligation
to be a guardian of the earth.
Just like giving Zika his congregation should give Waqf a
kind of religious donation to renewable energy.
Okay, then not not like Zika then one rung down, which is the
difference between the obligation and the recommendation, right.
I'm just highlighting these little details, but the point is well
taken, like daily prayers, planting trees should be a habit.
The environment is a central theme in Mr. nosode, Dean's Mosque,
which is the Istiqlal Mosque in Jakarta, Indonesian, Indonesia,
who has tried to lead by example. They're the they are ahead of the
curve. And so many things, these Indonesians, they're ahead of the
curve and like everything, there's one name one thing they're not
ahead of the curve and nothing. They just don't have the longest
history in Islam. That's it. It's not their fault.
Maybe that's why they're ahead of the curve. It's like fresh, they
still have the energy. They still have the love. You go and type
anything to search anything in YouTube.
Indonesians are everywhere, right? Especially in the arts. They love
the arts. Love countries that have to contend with what their nations
have done. Yeah, and they're just grabbing on to that that's exactly
why they're shorter history in Islam is probably why they're at
the cutting edge because every other country is is satisfied with
their past. Right.
Like nationalists, like they keep grabbing on to like their past
history and stuff. But it's like what what about now? Exactly.
Yeah, yeah.
So dismayed by the trash selling the river that the mosques sits
on, he ordered a cleanup, shocked by astronomical utility bills. He
REIT retrofitted Southeast Asia's largest mosque with solar panels.
It's amazing. Slow flow faucets. Oh, I'm a big fan of slowfall
fathers. I would do that if I had a mustard. Like there is never a
need in a masjid for your water to be white. You know, when they turn
the water on so much. It's white. You don't need that. You don't
need that.
And he introduced a water recycling system. Okay.
So it won first place. Right?
helped make it the first place of Bordeaux is the first place of
worship to win a green building accolade from the World Bank.
Okay.
And there's a picture of the masjid there is Stickel al mosque.
Maybe you could pull that up for us for any pictures or the grand
admits a huge message. He says he's simply putting in the Prophet
Muhammad is instructions to care about nature. Okay. He's not
alone. In a country of more than 200 million people.
The majority of the Muslims and trying to kindle environmental
awakening through Islam. Top clergy have issued fatuous or Enix
non binding rulings on how to read to rein in climate change.
Neighborhood activists are beseeching friends, family, and
neighbors that the environmentalism is better
In the Quran as the country with the largest number of Muslim
people in the world you have set a good example. While other Muslim
nations also have strains of this green Islam movement Indonesia
could be a guide for the rest of the world I heard that in
in
Cambridge sure hub that I came rods Masjid is very much folk
built on this basis. It what do they do when they give out water
and if taught, because it really bugs me how much plastic is not
that?
How much of a difference is make but it just bugs me see how much
plastic bottles there seems to be no solution to plastic bottles,
right? There's no solution to that.
As we drink. Yeah, plastic lid here.
Everything's plastic.
Cameras, bunch of plastic so plastic, the world's biggest
exporter of coal. It is one of the top global emitters of greenhouse
gases
1000s of hectares of hectares of its rainforests have been cleared
to produce palm oil, or dig for minerals. Wildfires, and flooding
have become more intense. Some people say what is the point? When
just driving your car you produce more wastes, right? Just taking a
flight once a year you're contributing towards the question
is I think in these things, is you just do what you can do. That's
it.
Right? Some may have heard this from people who don't subscribe to
environmental questions where they say okay, well, Allah subhanaw
taala can create more he can produce more you can eliminate the
waste. It's our sins and it's our other actions that are preventing
us from actually getting more and more and that the environmental
issues really shouldn't be something we're focusing on we
should focus on ourselves and everything will fall into place. I
think that the prophets I seldom said if you're at the ocean making
we do don't waste water.
Waste is terrible. harm
is bad, right? If prophesy Salam was was sitting down and he had
his job Bong which is like a like a cape almost. And then a kitten
took a nap on the edge of the cape and the prophesies settled him cut
the cape
which one of us will cut a garment so that a kid could take an appt
which she does all day anyway. And kittens if you know kittens they
take 10 naps a day right 10 minute nap here five minute nap they're
right there they just nap they never sleep hours on hours they
just nap so kitten was taking a nap on the Prophet size seven
garments and he cut it
okay
so if the prophesy sell them kitten the kitten, what is the
kitten do back for us? Probably nothing but get the mice and get
some bugs? Maybe? So what is the sky do for us?
Right? What kind of function does the sky have for us? How about
trees? What are the function of trees for us? What is the function
of the seas for us? So and it's not just this function? It's
actually the clinical Allah it's deserved something. So therefore
I believe personally that you're not allowed to pollute more than
you need. If you have a need and you need you know, for what can
you do you have a need. But I think that this they're on the
right track with this right
now what I don't what what the argument that Allah can always
create more is this fear of, of use of overpopulating the earth?
That's where you should use it, right? No, the prophesy son said,
populate the earth. Allah will supply provide more and more
supplies. But keep in mind, that all belief also comes with Zika.
If people paid there's just the Muslims, just the elites of the
Muslims
paid there's
probably I would say nations, multiple nations, hunger issues
will be solved.
multiple nations, many, many nations hunger issues would be
if some of the top
people in manufacturing world had a little bit of Taqwa.
Then a lot of wastes would probably be you know, those are
the big users, right? Not us with our plastic bottle capital or
whatever, right.
It's vast reserves of nickel which is used in electric car batteries
or a pathway to a cleaner future but processing nickel requires
burning fossil fuels. The President elects has campaigned to
expand production of biofuels that could lead to more deforestation
with the capital Jakarta sinking into the sea.
ie the departing President Widodo is building a new capital that is
built as a green Metropolis powered by renewable energy. But
to do this, he has cleared forests. That's not a crime to
clear forests. And if you need the space, you need the space the the
human is, takes priority.
So not everything in the environmental agenda is something
that's going to be in line with our with our beliefs. Some clerics
see environmental lism as peripheral peripheral to religion.
And surveys suggest that there's widespread belief amongst
Indonesia that climate change is not caused by human activity.
Of course it is, but educating 200 million Muslims the proponents of
the green Islam movement say can drive the change. People will not
listen to laws, they don't care.
They listened to religious leaders because they say you can escape
worldly laws but you cannot escape God
The fence was
Masha Allah Who do we have here?
To go to Monica Jean the Skyway brothers. You got the picture I
don't need to read more right I lost we get the picture. Right.
I'm with him.
I liked the idea.
long article here in the New York Times it continues on
I'm gonna say this and I'm a man by Article Oh, he comes
to love from data loom.
Data Dotto loom Ohio. Which city Toledo?
Dayton, Ohio. Where's your third wheel? From yesterday? And a
sticker. He lives in South Jersey. Oh, he was just there for
yesterday.
Yesterday, we went out how many guys were we at the end of the
day.
38 brothers to a new restaurant called cartoon little eat party
for us that we had 38 Brothers a
lot of antique kafirs we had this year, a lot of ethic efforts. And,
and then we went out to celebrate a little bit.
We ate there at smoked
smoked meats, basically. So
smoked meats, we ate until mclubbe. Time recited a little bit
of the butter right in the middle of the restaurant. Right.
He was so pumped. He is the owner. It's a brand new restaurant. So
the owner was pumped to see all these people, right?
All right, in Cambridge, they give water from glass jars into plastic
cups. But at least the jars are reusable. So it seems that they
don't go around
using these plastic bottles.
Okay, we're on our last segment, which is q&a. So
you can you can read for me the anything that comes out of
Instagram. What's the ruling on the bodies of all men? It's a bit
a group but theology is in theology of innovation. Meaning
what is the difference in innovation, a sect and a school of
thought.
Right. sects and school of thought. sects differ on thoughts,
a text on explicit texts, that you become a sect if you do that.
Your deed you're not doing it right. You want to be Muslim?
Fine, good for you. But you're not doing it right. You have to do it
correctly.
You have to do it correctly. Certain mistakes are inexcusable.
What's inexcusable, the party deviating from a explicit text? No
interpretation is possible. You deviate from that and then no as
put a line there. So you you're within the circle of Muslims. But
we have to you know that you're you're having inexcusable error
in your theology. So what does that do that what it does is makes
us stay away from that person. And it renders your good deeds
invalid. Okay, renders all your good deeds invalid. I got a
contract with a landlord as an example, and says I have to pay
him $1,000 A month. Okay.
All right. And if I want to mow the lawn, that's extra from me, I
don't have to mow the lawn. But if I want to. So what do I do? I go
and I say, You know what my interpretation of the 1000 is that
if I can pay 1000, so I'm going to pay $900 of rent every month. But
what I will do because I'm a florist, I'm going to make a
beautiful garden. Not only am I going to cut the grass, I'm going
to make a beautiful garden. So a person passes by the house and
says, Wow, what a what a great tenant. This guy is, right? What
an amazing garden. He's done for you. And he doesn't have to do
that, right?
Yeah, but what you don't see is his ripping me off.
$100
was a month? He's not paying me $100 a month. Yeah, but I
interpreted the 1000 to mean if I can pay 1005 801 Day one month 900
The next month, you know, what's the big deal? 100 bucks. So what
would you say about such a tenant? Someone says, hey, I want to I
want to bring your tenant can I take him he wants to work for me.
He wants to be my accountant. He wants to lease from me. You have
to say, No, this guy doesn't pay up, right?
And then what if the tenant then says this is my interpretation,
though certain things don't have interpretations, right. $1,000 a
month is not up for interpretation. So that is a
difference between a sect and a school of thought, what is the
school of thought that school of thought is in any line of our
religious texts that is susceptible to multiple
understandings, we call them interpretations. All those as long
as the rules of interpretations are observed. They're accepted,
what are the rules of interpretation? The rules of
interpretation is very simply, the interpretation can not contradict
a the language and be the explicit texts. Right? I'll give you an
example of an interpretation that's utterly wack and was given
here in a mosque in New Jersey, which is just insane.
Uh, khateeb
said, the Prophet peace be upon him, told his uncle, I will tell
him, c'est la ilaha illAllah. So I can intercede for you on the Day
of Judgment.
The khateeb then says this teaches us and shows us the all that a
person needs is that Allah Illallah regardless of what his
religion is, he doesn't need Muhammad Rasul Allah.
He had a basic rule of interpretation is that an
interpretive statement? Cannot the interpretation is invalid the
moment it contradicts, and explicit text? Right? Why don't
you then eat in Ramadan? Because Allah says Kulu worship Allah to
eat and drink but not to access? So Ramadan comes in we're all
fasting and this person drinks says Do not steal Quran right?
Call to worship Allah to sinful because eat and drink with but
don't go to access Allah says in the Quran, so why don't I go eat
in Ramadan because an interpretation must not contradict
explicit text. And a cannot contradict language either. Right?
For example, failure Brebner B Homura hymnology will be hidden.
They should throw their veils over their chest. Okay. The J was was
here. So someone says, while you're driven to become Rahim,
Allah Gu will be hidden. So no, no, no, it means put the veil down
this way. So it goes over my pant pockets. No, not acceptable. This
is the language doesn't accept that the job at that time was
here, not down here. Or we all have breast pockets now to write.
So let me just put the veil like this, and let it just go down on
the sides like that. No, that's not acceptable. So it has to be
acceptable in the language. And it has to be acceptable in in the
text cannot contradict an explicit text that is a big difference
between a sect and a school of thought.
Now, what happens if we have
an interpretive text Vani Delaila. The interpretation
does not contradict explicit text, but does contradicts either
language or in Joomla
Joomla. There's a consensus of the companions of the first three
generations or something that this is what it means it's
interpretive, but this is what it means. What do we say about that?
If we say that opinion is an egregious error, that is in itself
a Bidda. In itself is innovation in itself is wrong. In itself.
It's sinful to act upon that. But we don't remove you from Edison.
Because he didn't go against explicit text. Right? On this
matter. We say he's a great scholar, but we circle that point
here. This is wrong. Don't study from him this issue, because he's
wrong on that. We refute him on that. As a brother, that's the
reputation of done as brother. That means I can invite you for
dinner chitchat with you have a great time with you. My kid can
marry your kid, right? We can be best friends even but I have to
refute you on this issue. I don't have to stay away from you.
On such a mess right.
Now you have to stay away from just like you stay away from
someone with COVID But you don't have to stay away from someone
with a broken arm right after son somebody shun but stay away from
right. It doesn't mean I had been. We don't pray for them. We we we
hope that they're if they do something good as I just mentioned
about Iran, we can imagine we can we can say that.
They will allow to enter Mecca
they can pray in our massages. We don't go to their massage but they
can come as suddenly as a regular attend memo just attending the
mosque to pray.
When they die, we will bury it bury them in the Muslim graveyard.
No problem. Right. There's probably some difference of
opinion on whether they're slaughters are halal for us or
not. Right? Are the witnessing of the New Moon is hello for us or
not? That's probably discussion on that. So the Edit Bidda have this
there is a distance between them but not an excommunication.
That's a difference. They're excommunicated from the Sunnah. In
other words, they're not part of Sunni tradition and they're doing
it too long as you can only inexcusable error.
As opposed to the apostate all relations are cutting the
apostate.
All relations are cut that is the someone who announces he's not a
Muslim or he goes against the explicit text, which is from the
essential definition of Islam. When someone becomes Muslim when
they hear the word Islam certain things are well known, no
discussion about it. Muhammad is the last prophet there's five
prayers a day alcohol is haram pork is haram. Right? These gent
generalities that the whole world knows. That is literally the
definition of Islam. So someone who goes against those also would
be an apostate and basically isn't. So that's the difference.
It's why it's important to know these things because so we know
how to act. We know when you know how to deal with each other.
Or these groups. Any questions on
how do we even get into that the bodies of Oman? Yeah, so that's
turquoises question on the bodies of Oman. Okay.
Eight beyond says I thought the story of cutting the Juba was
attributed to Sayed Ahmed Al Rifai and not the Prophet salallahu
alayhi wa salam Allah Allah my heard it from the Prophet peace be
upon him and it may be one of those things that you have heard
when you're a kid and may have very weak bases but you know those
a hadith that settle in your head and there's never an occasion to
question it but I guess now we can question it can one of your
brothers
employ your six year program to see if that hadith Hara is
correct? Right? Or has the the cat that was on the shawl of the
prophets I send them or the job of the prophet and he cut the job
you heard that story heard it mentioned you know certain things
that you hear it all the time and some things you do them but they
you won't find them in any text you know, like what? How many
times have you prayed with a drummer and then everyone insists
on praying the Sunnah in a different spot
I still haven't seen that in a single text right? Except the
general statement of all material that we should separate between
father and son. But what does that separate in what way in my
intention or what anyway some of those things they settle in your
mind and you don't necessarily know if it's right or wrong
Gee, because magic is ruled by that
is given by multiple companies, but that specific wording
became so popular that I have taken a look it up for me.
If you have your phone and you have how many years of Dr. Lim did
you do? Oh, Mashallah. So you also finished what six years you said?
Mashallah, amazing.
What's the Maliki school of thought? On the six days of show
well, says lathe Newton. No, it's any six days of the year. It
doesn't have to be six days or so on. It's any six days of the year.
Ah, H Audrey says if we follow the prophets guidance, and did and
consumed everything in balance and remove greed, we'd be preserving
the environment. Yeah.
Right.
Good.
Okay, let's go to questions here. Charge Ollie, pick me some
UK Glasgow area next year. Glasgow now this year? Well, this year
it's it's it's Australia. It's Melbourne this year.
And
please advise where to study in Jordan? Well, you need to contact
us at info at Safina cited dot O R G, and we'll connect you to shake
Murad. Awesome man who's there now?
Yeah, it's chickens out some kind of expression. Or is it a lewd
expression?
No, chicken. No chickens out.
Chicken, Chick Chicken.
Chicken.
Yeah, someone said chickens out. I said
Oh, is that what it was?
Oh, I see I says, Okay, I thought maybe there's has some other
meaning. Okay. Because someone commented and said how could you
say that there's not right for you to say I'm like
responded I'm like wait a second
I was that what it was all about?
Wait a second, they have to be killed
right in because they're an invading army killing kids they
have have to be fought in by Shinya so if you have to be fought
you have to be called many other things. What about friends? That's
true.
That's what it's about. Oh, okay, dodgy shame
judging
where's a good place to study Arabic in Cairo?
Is Federal Institute still in business?
Yeah.
Truth speaker says is paying taxes we know are punishing Israeli
bombs to murder Muslims MOBA in Malachy fit can be avoided by
Hijra while Hijaz, oh, Hijra to a better environment is always
recommended. Always recommended, unless you would be doing some
harm like what for example, let's say for example, you have an
elderly father that needs care. And he cannot go to Hijra to the
place that you want to go to because there's no medical care
for him there, then you can't you have to stay with your father,
right to take care of your dad or your mom. So that's an example
where it would be sinful to abandon them.
Okay, it would be sinful for you to abandon them, Hijra to a better
niche, a better country, a country where things are done in a better
way is always always recommended.
When we talk about taxes, though, we have to keep in mind that we
never pay the taxes like willingly This is forced upon us, right?
Essentially, they have a gun to your head, if you think about it,
because they can put you in jail, right? They can end they could
they could
it reaches that point, right? tax fraud, tax evasion and all that.
Chances are they don't go after little accounts, but they only go
after big accounts, but it is essentially something where you
can go to Joe. So it is something that is
forced upon you. So don't ever pay it like you're not paying it
willingly. And if when they when you do, write the check for them
or whatever.
The ultimate do say make the intention that it's going to what
is valid, the highway system,
et cetera.
Alright, Kellyanne says you said I can come to New Jersey from New
York. I'll be there Friday 10th of May.
We don't stream Friday, but try to come for Joomla. Now again, email
in fosse if he decided.org Or go to our Telegram, go to the Safina
site or go to shedule mastery telegram. So there you could talk
and the admin will take care of you. He'll make sure that you when
you call when you text someone to pick you up or take an Uber to the
New Brunswick Islamic center.
Come to the New Brunswick Chase train station. literally two
minutes from the Masjid. Boom, boom, you're on Livingston Ave.
You go down three miles on Livingston Avenue.
And you'll be at mbyc and there we could pray Jamar then we go out to
lunch again after that. Right. And then we probably will have that
night we will have
may 10. I'm going to Teaneck. Actually, I'm going to give a talk
in Teaneck. And Dr. Mateen. Can.
Khan is scheduled to talk about his trip to Palestine.
How much can you shorten the beard in the Maliki school? According to
Sheikh McGuinty, we asked asked this question and he said that the
ruling on that is a bruise as long as it's bad is as long as you
could see it. And it's what the people of the Muslims would refer
to as a beard. For example, that's a beard right? That the Maliki
school is pretty much doesn't have the the one hard and fast rule
except that it boots back into corner Berryessa is something that
is apparent on the face. And it's one of the things that is a sunnah
and is one of the things that's a fixture of beauty for a man and
it's one of the things that separates the men from a woman
right. So he has
So I have something that is known as a beard, right? What the people
call a beard at that time, and the beard should should not be
excessively long beyond the fist length based upon an aroma.
And in the medical school, they forbid, shaving the moustache, as
opposed to the Shafi and Hanafi schools that allow that, because
ematic took by the hadith of shorten the length of the
mustache, and that none of the Sahaba or tebing or any of the
Sheoak of Matic ever shaved their mustache off, so he actually
deemed that forbidden because nobody had had done that. And
that's a prohibition by its yet. There are different types when we
say the word prohibited, you have to understand the basis are we
saying prohibited? Be Nossal Quran katri absolutely forbidden by the
Quran or forbidden by the estimation of a scholar that this
is forbidden it's forbidden Mr punished yet, right. So therefore,
the Hanafi is of a total different opposite view than that. The Shafi
has have opposite view than they permit that and they have no limit
on the length of the beard. Maddox said no the shave the mustache is
forbidden if you want to read this go to the photo was shot Henry
salah. He has a beautiful section at the end on the fitrah and the
attributes of the fitna, which there's the beard there's the
clipping of nails, removing hair from the body, certain parts of
sunnah certain parts is permitted certain parts is forbidden, okay?
The beard is flooded in the Maliki school, it's an obligation has to
have something that the pious Muslims of that day call a beard.
Okay, and it has to be a parent.
And
it should not pass more than a fist length. Why no one was more
knowledgeable than the Sunnah than abnormal. No one was outside of
sooner than abnormal. And he used to grab from the beard from his
beard and cut. So the fist length basically like four fingers worth
maybe five fingers worth however you would calculate a fist length
without,
to shut down and, you know, like by the inch, we don't have that
concept. But the beard is for beauty. And it's for separation
between male and female, and it's just one of the profits to on top
of that. So it's top booty, and a schmuck hooded man. At the same
time, it's known why we have a beard, but it's also just an act
of worship. Right?
And that's all something I want to write a short a pistol on and
publish it for the internet from the photo we on every cell on all
the matters related to hygiene men's hygiene. Or I should say
grooming because this is grooming, right? men's grooming.
Right?
How should we view Gandhi? We should view Gandhi that we need to
do an episode. Who is the rom the
who is the person who who has taken Gandhi as his like research
and refutations of lambda think it's chicken Assad? Right? Our
sickness our
GM D is a MCDA on multiple counts, He is charged with multiple counts
of right?
I don't even know if he's, I think he surpassed Bedava two, or he's
clever enough not to surpass it. But let me ask you this. If a
hadith if there are many, many, very, very, very weak Hadith
doesn't make it has an meaning. The meaning is hasn't in our in
the in the epistemology of transmission, a narration could be
weak a second, one week, a third one week, a fourth different chain
week, a 50 different chain week. But when I have 678 week chains,
it gives me a meaning that sounds
I want to talk to a theologian about this when somebody brings
50 Bidda in his theology
50 bit, probably more. Right? At some point, we have to ask a
question like, What is the ruling of this person? will it just be a
normal data? Or is this going to even put you outside the fold of
Islam? But vom de he's like the sweet talker type of academic with
intellectual tone of voice and the way he talks and the way he
dresses and all that but at the same time,
the degree in which he's off
having read his translations of his fatawa
No, not even fatawa they're just like
it's it's basically he studied the liberal mold of things. It's so
predictable on anything, I can tell you what he's gonna say. It's
the liberal mold of things. It's the modernist mold the liberal
mold, put that together.
And that's his religion. Right? So
my Tesla,
I don't know if it's that many, to be honest with you.
I don't know. Did you find that hadith by the way? Yeah.
Let's see. Did you find anything on the cat one?
Yeah.
Oh, nothing early on. Nothing close in the Sierra there anything
to be honest with you, that's a bit of a relief the brothers
saying that he found nothing in his research by the way finding
nothing
is not necessarily grounds for Fetzer, however
I mean, this is not if that's what either right this is much smaller
matter, but he says So far he's found nothing
on the prophesy said I'm having cut the edge of his job. You know,
I actually more relieved by that.
Any homeowner that has cats and the cats sit on something that's
going to be ruined, and takes a nap there has been feeling guilty,
right for years, because that hadith that that if it's a false
Hadith, or if it's a misunderstood Hadith that people misunderstood
it as a hadith it's become more to do with being a nurse and no
Hadith or Lazenby Hadith, right? It's spread amongst people as a
hadith but it's not Hadith we should actually look that up and
clarify because every cat owner that I know has the same issue the
cat sleeping on the bed I get allergies What do I do? Right?
I feel guilty removing the cat right so maybe we don't have to
feel guilty anymore
yeah
okay, so we got it Well, let's look that up in sha Allah just to
make double triple check right
oh, we need that we need to look at that.
So how are we being the arrival of a CLT right so how are we in CLT
they were both amazing students but he studied more with him and
100 is you was older
All right the hadith of shuttered a homily
and in
in
in
now that
we have see where medic got it from them maybe Maddie got it from
us this
or use this hadith as it is it's just that this was the nurse
and then
because you know that is to Lel is on of that half her life not
praying is on hide being 15 days. Yeah. Yeah, that's an
instance of anachronism. But the Hadith what is the wording of the
hadith of Nakazato oxen Woody, what's the rest of it? And Menaka
saw to Auckland Fisher Fisher head. What am I not so Dean, look
that up and you should find something there. We'll get back to
you at this
so that's the answer to all the random
alright.
I understand that the Quran is the word of God and uncreated. Is the
Arabic language not create it? Says Ma.
Okay, so this question came up a long time ago. And three groups
formed out of this one group said we're not answering this question
the Word of God is uncreated. That's it no discussion. This
group was called the Hausa.
Yeah, how should we write what is it?
The group that said word of Allah uncreated, we're not even going to
discuss it.
No, no, it's the How shall we I think,
next group Mata Zilla said, therefore the Word of God is
created because Arabic is created right. In the middle came the sad
scholars who said hold on a second. The Word of Allah Tala
branches into two types.
The first word is his word. Amongst them is his word within
himself,
is called his al Kalam and Nipsey his speech within himself before
the creation of anything
before the creation of Arabic before the creation of anything
and that Kalam Neff see is without meat without order, without
beginning and end without parts without
language.
It's without any attribute of a creative think it's his speech
within himself and has no attributes of creative thing.
That's what we say is the word of Allah subhanho wa Taala that is
Kalam. Nuptse
Then there is Kalam lofty. Now what about how do we utter such a
word that Allah Tala puts that Kalam enough see in a language yes
the language is created. However, it is what what is greater the
kalam Nuptse or the graded language of course it could have
enough see. So therefore, we attribute the Quran as 100% Araki
and it is the word of Allah subhanaw taala and mer baina do
Fatah that was the Kitab Allah Kalam Allah no muy bien a
different they must have kala moola said is just saying what is
between the two binds of the most half of the written as the word of
Allah and
while a Sally I had an oscillator key cusp, saying of the mozzarella
me and also none nobody has any
can attribute any or take any credit in the
construction of this word. So we don't say like, there's no no
created being has any say or is attributes any credit to them for
this word is purely the word of Allah but we understand as Kalam
Nuptse and Kalam lovely.
And the kalam lofty we say is the it is the word of Allah.
When I said Lee, I had NPRC TV cast.
Okay, so that's how we separate it.
So that's a really good
hunk is saying here you are, you don't trust the Hadith and even
your scholars. When we look at Hadith and say, this is sound,
this is not sound. That's why we trust Hadith because we have
investigation. That's exactly why we trust Hadith. So you think like
trust hadith is okay, anything that they said about the Prophet?
Let's just believe it? No, because there's a rigorous
checking, and examination and interrogation of narrations.
That's why it leads to the trust. Right? Yeah. So we the fact that
we have fabricated Hadith,
no, outsider came and said, By the way, we studied your chains and
fabricated and we're the ones who made who declared them as
fabricated. The Muslims, Carson was declared them as weak, right?
It's just like the old Atlantic Monthly article, way back in the
year, like 1999 came out and said, Revelation, the Quran is not what
we thought it to be. And we've discovered different variants. And
all the evidence is from works written by Muslims, right? We're
the ones who documented this. Our scholars are the ones who
documented this. So we know exactly that there are variants,
we know that there are recitations that are no longer recited
anymore. Okay, because they don't have chains. And that clearly, if
we know that, then when you discover a must have like that in
Yemen, right? That's because that's what happened, they
discovered a must have in Yemen, that was one of the variants which
we don't recite anymore. There's no Senate.
And they're, like, shocked. They're like, this is the Quran of
the Muslims is not what they thought it to be. No, we already
know about these things. We just didn't have that copy. That copy
was discovered. But the concepts and those words probably are in
the deficit as variants, right.
Let's say hypothetically, hypothetically, say, Oh, wow, we
didn't know Okay, here's another Quran. Hypothetically, and this is
not the way we would analyze this at all.
But bring me the most different variant to the most half that is
on the shelves of all the mosques today in the world. Huff's an
awesome
what is what teaching will differ? How will my life differ? If I
followed that myself?
Colonial Memphis Castlefield Memphis, there's a verse that says
the mountain will be like Calayan element push, like just scattered
wool pieces of wool, you know, like wool is right?
Another one says Castlefield monkfish a synonym for wool.
How does that affect anything? Just by meaning if we were to,
like this was a gentleman for the sake of argument.
For the sake of argument, just leave me let me accept your saying
that the Quran is totally different. All right. I'm gonna
build my dispute and my Aki and my FIP based on that Masaf nothing's
gonna change. Absolutely zero liquid change, right? Zero optina
would change.
Hilarious.
You have to leave.
A beyond says the story is in CR LM and novella attributed to
SHEIKH AHMED AL Rifai, good research. I would trust that the
heavy 100% trusted the heavy on that.
Take care of him slump 100% I would say
receive the hubby over. And I think we should publicize that
right?
Free Muslims of guilts
cats will be sleeping a lot less after that is revelation. Get up
I have a cat that that can push through doors now. Pushes, pushes,
pushes, pushes pushes. And I'm telling you this cat has got
strong right pushes and can open doors by and ruin the door. Like
they keep pushing all day. We'll keep pushing.
Yeah.
While making up for the fourth fasts, can we combine Nia of
nanofiller suna fasts and show well and Monday of Shawwal and
Monday and Thursday? That's Yes, yes, because
the six days of Shaohua do not need a special intention. Their
intention is nothing. Mondays, every Neff fast, does not need its
own intention and can be combined.
What's the sooner more accurate or fast? So fast is our shoulder? i
Sorry.
You'll modify. So in the market, the fast of Yamato, which is the
ninth of the ledger in the Maliki school, that's the pseudonym aka
it requires its own special intention of cm you'll modify,
right? Every other fast Monday, Thursday, six days of the six days
of show automatic effects any six days of the year. But if you don't
show well, there's no problem with that. But Malik didn't like that
you do them on the second like right away, because people would
then think that this is something we should do right away. So he
likes it to be spread out
or not fixed. But in any event, if you did it is valid and accepted
from you. All of these no F and fast do not have to have their own
specific intention. Right.
nephila can be fast at any day of the year you can pass on Friday by
itself and Medicare Saturday by itself the only thing that would
be mcru for you to do. It would not even invalidate the fest is
say, You know what? The venue sort of didn't have the Sabbath. I'm
going to fast just the way they fasted. They must have fasted and
Benny slow you like that. So I'm gonna fast Saturdays now. First of
all, that's my crew because you're trying to imitate other religions
but or previous nations. And on top of that wouldn't even be the
issue because fasting is not their thing on the seventh. They eat on
the seventh, they just don't work on the seventh. They don't use
technology on the seventh that would be something totally
different. So even your attempt of Bidda would not even be right. If
you're going to do betta consult me do it properly, right? So that
we can condemn you properly. Right? So
in medic effects, he confessed any day it's all nephila.
It's all nothing except the amount of us on the market.
And of course, you cannot fast anything on eight and eight. And
fisheries one day, is the first of Ramadan. Adel for this.
It's the 10th 11th 12th 13th of the hedger get, we don't fast on
those days. Right.
You got sins for fasten that to swallow you get you get sins for
fasting one day after having fest 30 days, right? Because it's
obedience. Right? You have to obey. Right? There's certain
things went the timing of when you do it is correct, is good. And the
other timing, think about this if your son sends you a joke,
right? He said he texts you a joke while my son loves me. I'm gonna
look, he's sending me a joke as text. Right? Now if I tell him
I had a very, very bad day. And so and so died and I'm preparing for
the janazah and he sends me a joke on that day.
It's something's wrong with you, right? So see the same thing but
on different days. Why? Because this is about obedience. It's not
about you achieving some state on your own.
All right. So that's So what's another example of this in Maliki
FIP differs from Hanafi phip
in that the autowatch tip that Allah tip, the rakaats before and
after the footage, prayers, all of them are nifiga
okay. And there's no limit on the number or special number. So for
example, we know and Hanafi fiqh is for before though and for after
the odd right or to have to after they're affordable for the two
after that. So in medically fit the nefler the TANF will before
Salah is waiting for the imam or to improve your Salah. In other
words, my mind is busy. I can't just pray the hood right away.
I'll pray nephila until my mind settles down. Right then I'll pray
Door any number 2468 Doesn't matter
after NAFTA same thing that's the NAFTA after the same thing as many
as you want or as list leases you want including market. Right it's
NAFTA
NAFTA so Scheffer is nothing. The shefa is you could do Neff
intention of nephila intention of is Takara. Right? Any nephila
right can be done there for the two the one is pseudonym aka The
one is a sunnah that requires its own intention so you can't open
Salah halfway through. Let me make this Switzer class call it a day,
right? No, can't do that. You have to intend it.
To hear to the message it does not need to be intended. Right you go
you pray. My mind is to rock us is Takara you go you pray tonight
because it was Takara as it Oh, what about to Hades and mustard.
Hello. So you did it. Right. The other one that does require a
special intention is the to duck as before which why? Because the
Prophet talked about its reward. And therefore it's if Tucker
Alinea it needs a Nia, the NIA of Buffy but will fetch okay. And
that Nia is
that prohibits or fetch it's called the Aviva because the
Prophet didn't name it. But he talked about its great reward or
other Lufia Well, I can let me use a mere. If the prophet named a
prayer it's a pseudonym, aka, if the prophet promoted a prayer
which is only one he talks about, it's your word. It's called the
Aviva. And if the prophet did it, but never named it or talked about
your words enough.
That's how we treat it. All I have to I'm going to take a two second
break. Can you read for us?
The Marie Marie situation let's take a break. Come back and we'll
wrap up in a couple more questions
Yep, pull up some Marimar
see if this is working. Alright.
So as you guys know Daksha you mentioned that Mario Mario Manuel
he's that bishop that we refuted once on our podcast. We also you
know uploaded a video of the reputation which got a lot of
views as well over 60k I think um, so he's recently apparently
stabbed in Australia by what they're claiming is a Muslim,
Muslim brother. So inshallah let's see what the news is
okay, so the Guardian
Hello Adam, how trustworthy this is but
symbolic shadows so it's in crowds clashed with police after Bishop
allegedly stabbed during Mass in Sydney
are hundreds of people clashed with police that actually let me
see if this is the right one if this is the right article
might be something else actually.
The bigger Sydney church to having what we know so far.
Church that signature 700 alleged
that a bunch of articles on this
see
teenagers
can look for the solution. Sydney church serving
legit
okay, this is the one I think. Yeah. Okay.
Sunni church stabbing an alleged attack on a firebrand preacher
reignited tensions.
So at around 7pm on Monday night, a teenager wearing a black hoodie
walked out to a bishop conducting the service and an Orthodox Church
in Western Sydney, took out a knife and allegedly stabbed him
repeatedly between that moment and 12:34am and police issued a
statement saying they had concluded their operation the
suburb quickly descended into violent bedlam.
And intervening five and a half hours hundreds of people came to
the streets around the church and a riot ensued in which two police
officers were hospitalized with serious injuries. So I'm assuming
that
it's interesting actually was something like people that were
sticking up for the bishop.
I'm not sure why the police were hospitalized though. A paramedics
are trapped inside the church for more than three hours in some
cases under direct threat from the crowd in emergency counsel have
some sorry if you guys can hear me.
So
maybe
so paramedics are trapped inside the church for more than three
hours and some came under direct threat from
In the crowd, and emergency Counsel of religious leaders was
called by the state's premier with a group calling for calm and unity
and bystanders were left terrified. Okay, so the alleged
attack on Bishop Mario Mario Manuel came at a powder keg moment
in Sydney still reeling from a horrific mass stabbing attack at a
shopping center in Bondi Junction in the series is two days before
yes, there's a bunch of extra information as it gets to the good
stuff.
Let's see.
Okay, so it says that the church is controversial, but beloved
bishop has a huge social media following and the service is being
live streamed on the church's popular YouTube channel. Okay, so
this is actually online, that's fine like the the stabbing. I
wonder if they took it down, but which meant many people saw
horrific video of the alleged attack in real time or shared
almost immediately.
So the bishop and another clergyman were injured. Both were
taken to hospital and we're recovering well.
New South Wales Police said they were lucky to be alive.
The alleged attacker pinned him to the ground while
our sorry members of the congregation runs the rushed the
alleged attacker and pinned him to the ground while they waited for
police to arrive. The alleged attacker severed his own fingers
and the attacks fall now just having he's probably okay, so this
is the part where there's the main stuff we want to get to
which says
that in a video shared in a private in private WhatsApp groups
and seen by Guardian Australia, okay, in a video shared in private
WhatsApp groups, okay.
And seen by Gordon Israel, the teenager held on the ground with a
church by a group of men calls out in Arabic. Okay, he was an Arab,
he was only an Arabic if he didn't get himself involved in my
religion. If he hadn't spoken about my prophet, I wouldn't have
come here. If he just spoke about his own religion, I wouldn't have
come so. So now apparently say, Muslim youth
teenager, I'm assuming is around 15 years old.
Yeah, I'm not sure if we can hopefully, the video is online
somewhere we can maybe look at it. Because apparently was livestream.
So people saw this in real time.
So I'm do I am curious about this video stuff. We actually did a
review, as I mentioned, this bishop, we refuted him directly on
the stream. And then there's a video as well on our channel,
which which has over 50,000 views. So around 60,000, approximately,
where we refuted him because he basically just was spouting some
nonsense some very non intellectual remarks about the
prophets of Allah I
think he was he was basically saying like, Oh, you know
that Jesus, you know is Ali Isola Salam is going to come to judge on
the planet only God can judge or something. And that was his like,
bonehead Napoli or something, you know, his proof that Jesus is like
God, and then we were saying like, that makes zero sense. Like you're
saying just to give someone judges that makes them God, like, okay,
by that definition, by that reasoning by that, you know, that
principle then that means that any judge normally would we would deem
them as God right now, the biller
so it made zero sense, and we address that. So this is what Just
some background as to, you know, this bishop, we addressed him
before. So Emanuel has previously Chris has Yeah, so Emanuel has
Bishop the bishop has previously criticized Islam and the Prophet
Muhammad. So it was, it was heavy in sermons shared widely online,
Emanuel has 154,000 followers on Instagram and more than 25 million
views. So his videos on Tiktok
and then just moving, skipping ahead, it was declared to be a
terrorist incident that was religiously motivated.
And just people that feel the street around the church. People
move to come to the church within five minutes. The boys were
nervous on edge they heard so many rumors and we're here to see what
happens is people in the community jumping in to protect the church
goers I guess
we have always there are a lot of old ones between these communities
you said we've always said this is one of the church members who
saying this. We've always felt always felt something would
happen.
What else?
very outspoken, very controversial, said father Daniel
of Abu Calabria. What is it?
What is it?
Okay, apparently, okay, so apparently the his family is like
the attackers family is. He's in hiding as well.
Okay, so someone is also mentioned in here. I mean, this is in the
article. I guess this is referring to the the bishop. He's very far
right. ultra conservative in some of those views. His views on same
* relationships are very outspoken. His views on Islam are
very outspoken and I understand that might have contributed to
this. He's a huge Trump supporter. He's anti Vax. He preaches that
COVID is a conspiracy. You see now
What's gonna happen is all of these far right conservatives in
the US are just going to grab on to this for wheat far right is our
enemy. Yeah, absolutely. And like I mentioned this before these
guys, you know, it's very hypocritical, you know, they're
talking about, you know, liberals and trying to refute liberals, but
they're shooting themselves in the foot because they're as liberal as
anyone else. Right? Their entire approach is liberal, like who's
the default rates? Like these people like, you know, what's his
name like Ben Shapiro and
other guy? What do you mean by that liberal? Like their entire
their epistemology and the way that they look at things? Oh,
yeah, look at religion the way I look at so they're not submitted
to any they're very liberal. And they're philosophically they're
very liberal. Yeah, the far right to us. They're, they're open
enemies with their stance on Palestine, and now they've taken
it to their stance on Islam in general, there is maybe a middle
group within that, that I think is most receptive to our message, I
would actually have to say, is the middle groups within both sides,
right, because there's been a
resurgence, or a surge in people on the left, accepting Islam.
Yeah. Before that, we were all thinking it's going to be people
on the right. Right. But ultimately, it may be a little bit
of both. And the far right, the hard, right, whatever you want to
call it. There's so pro Israel, that there is as anti Islam, like
with the same strength? And he was he's an example of that. Right.
But so did they say it was religiously motivated or not?
They're saying it was Yeah. Because so what happened was, as
we just read is The teenager and like, this is we can check this
deep, like, look into this deeper, but it's saying that apparently,
while he was attacking the, the, the bishop, he yelled in Arabic,
if he didn't get himself involved in my religion, if he hadn't
spoken about my profit, I wouldn't have come here. If he just spoke
about his own religion, I wouldn't have come. Like, I mean, we can
verify this, but a lot of them I mean, well, as I've said earlier,
I don't condone this stuff. Yeah, for sure.
But we've lived long enough to know certain things have
consequences. Why are we shocked?
I cannot go around in a place where people are violent.
And count my money at the ATM.
Right? Or go Withdraw $3,000 at the little kiosk $500 Even at the
little kiosk in these little stop little quickie Mart's and expect
nothing to happen.
I can't go
talking again Zionists in my professional platform, LinkedIn or
whatever. And expect no consequences. Okay?
Certain words, you cannot say if somebody was saying the N word,
and then someone came up, beat the daylights out of him. Is NBC going
to go out and have sympathy for this guy?
If someone went on a racist rant,
and used every slur in the book, and someone got up and said, I'm
fed up with this
and beat the lights out of this guy.
I think the left would cheer it on. Right?
Yeah, it's a crime. actions have concert. I'm not saying he deserve
this. But I'm saying that's the consequence. All the time when
people talk about the Prophet. I've said it before. We have some
very
unwell people in the OMA who will take things to an extreme.
And here's an example of it. So again, it's not it's not
I was even thinking, you know,
if the Elia were amongst us, let's say living in that town would
would veteran schewe, would they visit him in the hospital? Right?
We hear stories of this all the time, enemy of Islam and then
something bad happens. He visits him in the hospital, right? Allah
knows best. I don't know. Maybe, maybe there's some wisdom in that
maybe not to show the clock of a Muslim. We have a clock we have
these things. But at the same time, I'm not saying this as a
moral stance, I'm saying as a common sensical stance. Like
Haven't you not seen this over and over repeated?
Right common sensical you don't do this common sense. I'm going to
limit myself on what I said about MBZ I don't want to be
arrested next time. I'm on the way to hombre right. I'm gonna limit
it I have my own opinions but I'm not stupid either. Their stupidity
to just go out there and try to be courageous and that you end up
banned from hogenom rubberband who knows what else not only that the
people associated with you
Yeah,
yeah.
And the communities are destroyed. So
yeah.
Let me answer a question here from hunk. Oh seven. If you believe the
10 commandments, the Torah is from God. Why does the Sharia go
against them? First of all, I don't think the Sharia orders us
to go against any of the 10 commandments.
If he's saying that, why did Muhammad go against them? No, I
don't know what he's talking about. But let me just give you a
general principle. We believe these books were from God. But
they were a abrogated, and be not preserved. I want to answer
another Christian real that I saw recently, because Christian Dawa.
It's on the rise by the way, Christians, you know, they're
promoting their stuff is on the rise.
He said that Muslims, is the word of God per per preserved, you're
not a Muslim will say yes, almost some shouldn't say us. And Muslims
should say the Quran is preserved. The Quran is one book of the Word
of God, the Word of God came in the Torah. The Word of God came in
the zebu came in the injured came in many books we don't have the
word of God is spoken to us on the Day of Judgment. When Allah
speaks, he was not taught the Word of Allah right. But Word of God as
law to mankind has come in many different books. The Word of God
is not.
Absolutely is not
preserved. Yeah, the Quran is preserved. That's our belief. The
Bible is the Word of Allah. The Torah was the word of Allah Torah,
in Jesus Abu were the word of Allah, not preserved by Allah
Himself. They were made to be preserved BMS Dr. Phil Dolman
kids, Abdullah, you were made humans, priests, rabbis, you were
made to preserve it. And you couldn't as no human beings, human
beings can't preserve it for that many years on their own. Right,
it's going to be corrupted and it was corrupted and lost much of it.
Get.
On top of that the word of Allah, the religion of God, the law
itself can be abrogated
certain laws, they're never abrogated tend to be the laws of
the heart, like envy, hatred, those things tend to be always the
same o'clock character tends to be always the same, like love for
your brother, what you love for yourself that's probably in every
religion, right? That's that's not abrogated. The laws may be
abrogated, who you can marry when you can marry them what you can
eat when you can eat it,
how to pray how to fast, that may be abrogated. abrogated means
changed, because humans change times change. The beliefs will
never be abrogated. The idea that there's one God that there are
angels that there's Heaven and *, that will never be abrogated
every single book of God that's why the prophesy centum said Oh,
US messengers and prophets are akin to brothers of the same
father and different mothers, meaning the the theology never
changes the theology and the general O'clock O'clock means like
the character of a people, people's character sharing, right,
versus envy versus greed versus all those things that never
changes. The laws will change. Okay, just as laws in any nation
change as time goes on.
You could keep a goat in 1924 You can keep it in 2024 Things like
that. Right life changed to farming rural areas became urban
areas. Likewise the world changed you have one world now
right we never had one world before accepting the time of Noah
from the flood to now we have no we've never had one world we have
one world essentially right now. Okay.
All right. Here's another question that's
very common question Where is it? I just saw it
is the Evanna of Ashati lashari?
I have to check with all of my say but in general they say no, that
the burner is not a sound trend to soundly transmitted from machete
and it contradicts all his previous works. So I'll check with
the ultimate say about that. But l Evanna. Is a book generally
dismissed as I would have said in Ashley's work good
because it has been it is the complete opposite of what he wrote
earlier.
Ryan even a thought is correct. In Islam, the principle of optina or
beliefs creed of the nations don't change but the laws change. Yeah,
because human beings on this earth week
change therefore we need
updated laws. In contrast, the heavens never changed what's in
the heavens is always going to be the same. So the the beliefs about
God and afterlife and angels never changes but the laws of how we
interact like Moses was able to marry two sisters we're not
allowed to in Adams time you married your sister but you didn't
marry your twin today we cannot mother twin or sister
What do you know about the bunnies that are in an hombre were they
allowed to drink? You know that?
No, no if the previous nieces were had rasa we're allowed to drink
alcohol or not. I don't know that.
The Christians they weren't allowed. Christians were not
allowed.
What's the difference between weak Hadith and authentic hadith? This
is by Shamir
Shem, Shamir there sound Hadith has five conditions. These five
conditions are determined by reason. And there are some texts
of Quran and Hadith that would point to it. So shut on Lachlan,
shot on by text. And by common sense, the first thing is that it
does auto Senate, which means the whole the chain is complete. The
chain of transmission is complete, meaning that from the incident
until me the listener or when it was written down in the book.
The chain is complete of people. There's no absence there's no
link, absent link like free. I'll give you an example.
The Masjid is on fire. Who told you? Suleiman was Salamander? No.
He wasn't there. So who told him?
He deload?
Or let's say, who told him?
We don't know.
That's the correct example. We don't know who told him. Okay. We
don't know who told him.
So there's a missing link there. Right. But so Who is Sulayman?
Quoting? So a man is quoting Musa.
But did he meet Musa? No, he never met him. He's quoting someone he
never met. Nah, we're not accepting this. Right? We're not
accepting this is not acceptable. So that's number one. matassa Sana
do all right next is Allah Della. I dalla means uprightness. In the
Summary. We would basically say asked the question, would this
person be an upright witness in court?
Or were they known for public sinning?
Okay. Publicly, did they commit sins in public so we won't accept
their testimony? For anything, let alone Hadith. Okay, so I Diala is
that there is no accurate data is something you have automatically
and you could lose it by your public misbehavior. Skipping
prayers, eating in Ramadan when you're not allowed to things like
that, basically, or other things, much less than that sometimes.
Number three, but is he accurate? And how do we know if he's
accurate?
Do we go ask his wife? When you ask him for five things in the
market? Does he come back with all five? Or did he forget one now
that's not how we do it. dopt is determined by we look at all his
narrations
and we compare them to his colleagues.
When medic would sit when any scholar is hot cabinet, a hallway
all these all Emma would sit to give Hadith to further session of
Hadith. You're not the only student there. Right? You're one
of 200 students you're one of 30 students you're one of 50 students
and the shift that scholar will have certain known students
throughout his life All right, well then you come and say
something and attributed to the shake
the trends the shake said such and such where they're gonna go to
your colleagues. You're again you're not the only student.
If you now consistently are different in the narration, we
have to downgrade you there's something up something's up here.
Your duct is off you're you're never get it right. You
consistently misquote leave something out. Add something out
of order. It's never exactly as the ship said.
Yes, you're a loyal attendee or a loyal student. You're You're we
don't have any doubts about your behavior. But your memory is not
good. You're it's always something different, right? That you're
dumped you downgraded. So that's number three. Number four and five
are for big exceptions. They're negative negative meaning we just
we want the absence of these two things. What is the opposite what
do we need? We need the absence of should move should do with me.
means you quoted properly. But
a senior student said the opposite. Or you quoted a hadith
the hadith is sound in every way. But of Senior Companion quoted the
opposite something totally different. So we just put a
question mark on it. And we don't rule. But
let's say we all of us were five guys in the room. We have a chef,
we have one teacher, all of us. Let's say I'm the oldest of you.
And it You're the youngest. Right? It goes. And he's an upright
narrative from the teacher. And he narrates a story from the teacher
that the teacher has visited South Africa.
And I say, the teacher never visited South Africa. That's
schueth. So you're upright and honest, and your behaviors good.
And you're narrating something that the senior the older person,
I've been with the shade for 20 years, even though it's set for
two years.
Right? That's the problem there. So what do we do with his
narration? We put a question mark on it, circle that hadith, and we
just don't use it. We don't say he's a liar. We don't say his duct
is wrong. So that's called shoot when a
sound Hadith contradicts a higher authority, and olders higher
meaning by age and time spent with the chef or with the Prophet if
it's the convenience.
Number five, the absence of a hidden error, a very subtle error,
which call it Allah that affects the veracity of the Hadith. What
does that mean? That means even the best expert one day could
slip. And that will only be known by the experts. And we even have
like a slip up from emetic by flipping a name. Or he cited this
these scholars are citing chains, and had deeds all day long,
especially in the early days when the chain has only three four
names, it's easy to remember. So he may be doing it so much, maybe
who knows a slip up he cites one chain with the opposite Hadith, or
he cites Abdullah bin bass instead of Abdullah bin Omar or he cites
Soloman had been dealt with and it's actually that would have been
Solomon. Those little slip up from the expert and who can cite that
only another expert, only another expert can say he made a mistake.
Those five conditions make us Hadith sounds and part of our law.
Such a hadith can can we accept it as law and we can act upon it? We
can not always we do because a sound hadith is one piece of
evidence there can be other pieces of evidence. There could be
analysis of the Hadith, like what once on Hadith, opposites, Hadith.
How do we make sense of this? The Prophet were gold during the
Prophet forbade to gold.
Very simply, there's a timeline. Right? There's a timeline here.
Yes, the Prophet were gold sound Hadith, but it's abrogated. After
the Prophet wore gold, he forbade gold and never wore it again. So
there's a timeline here. That's not all two dimensional. So a
hadith may be 100% Sounds however,
we don't act upon it. What's another one? It's 100% sounds but
the mean but but it lacks any contextualization so we don't know
how to act upon it.
So it's Matata but the data we don't know how to act upon it.
Right. So had in its nature
or even have all multiple hot dogs saying in general, I wish the
prophets I said them lived more so he could tell us more of the Ribba
in in bartering. So we don't know a lot about the bartering.
So those are examples of that.
Now the example where
let's say even medic for example.
The Prophet peace be upon him for bade in a hadith forbade eating
animals with canines.
But the Quran says nothing is forbidden except what is in the
Revelation the Quran. Okay.
So let's Alaina color add you to FEMA Oh hiya la FEMA Oh ala
Muhammad Illa Allah Timon Illa. So therefore the ozone in the Quran
Surah Al Anam says there is nothing forbidden except what is
revealed to me in x, y, z. Only in the Quran. So therefore Maddox is
okay, well, then the Prophet forbade animals with fangs with
canines. In other words, meat eaters, because it's not just the
canines, by the way, squirrel has canines. Squirrel has sharp teeth.
It's not just that it's meat eaters. Malik said he forbade it,
meaning discouragement,
not for prohibition. It's a big difference, right big difference
between discouragement and so you can have a sound Hadith but it's
not acted upon, or it's acted upon different
Utley discouragement is different from boyhood vision, right? So on
and so forth.
Cara? Yeah.
So that's it. That's a good question on Hadith and that's a
short answer on the nature of the sound. Hadith. Okay. And so that
also, again, keep in mind the Christians, we need to respond to
everything they say,
you know, I like to respond, it actually makes us stronger and
knowledge. When you have a response, and it removes doubts
from people's hearts. It's like a double bind. They're saying, Hold
on, don't you say God's word is preserved? Yes, it is.
God's word is preserved. That's that's the error right there. It's
not God's we don't say all God's word is preserved. The Quran
amongst all God's word is preserved. Other books that God
revealed may be altered or lost, not preserved. That's the the
mistake there. Okay.
And then because they say is, doesn't the Quran, say the Torah
and the Bible is God's word. Yes. Right. Therefore, that's God's
word. And the Quran contradicts God's word, therefore, it can't be
God's word.
Get this knot out of your head, right? The Quran is preserved. The
previous books are not preserved and every revelation abrogates
what's before them? What is the end affirms what's before them?
What does it mean that it affirms and abrogates it affirms the
Akita, and any alter the Creed, the beliefs, but any different
law. The newer revelation takes precedent. So I don't know about
the, the Sabbath, that what actually was revealed about the
Sabbath. But let's say hypothetically, the Torah says you
may not pluck fruit,
or
pluck fruit on the Sabbath.
Then Jesus comes any plucks through and gives it to the poor
Jesus's behavior abrogates the Torah there, meaning he offers a
new exception, the abrogates it, that's what abrogation means.
We're changing the law, every new of I mean, I hate to make these
worldly analogies, but just to make it make sense. Every new
Supreme Court comes and changes the law, the previous Supreme
Court, they had Roe versus Wade. Now they just overturned it. Which
one are we going to follow the old one or the new one. If you now
make a law as a state, I make a law based on the old ruling of the
Supreme Court, you're gonna get shot down. You must make law based
on the latest ruling of the court. Same thing humans are changing.
God is giving rulings and God is giving commands and prohibitions.
You follow the latest ones? The Christian
polemics
is 101.
Any new Muslim, any new student of knowledge first year student of
knowledge can answer Christian polemics. They're extremely easy
to answer. Atheist polemics are harder to answer, right. Christian
polemics are easier to answer.
Problem is that the Christians, and this is where they're gonna
get all in the comment section. They get if a cost cuts it out
clips, which is good. I told him to clip everything, whatever
anything he wants to clip, but
they're emotional, right? They're emotional, and they believe stuff
that I'm like, what? Because I guarantee you some of them have
taken stuff from Muslims, you know what they say? They say the Bible.
And the crucifixion of Christ and the resurrection of Christ from
the dead is the most authenticated fact in human history.
Historically verifiable. What are you smoking? What are they giving
you in the church? Don't they give you cracker and wine? You drank
the whole bottle, you are drunk. You're not in your right mind when
you say this stuff. How are you saying this stuff? Your own
scholars tell you this thing was written by strangers that compiled
up to right Strangers. Strangers wrote this stuff up. And we have
no clue who they are. And you're coming and saying this stuff, the
most often verifiable, and this is Charlie Kirk.
Most verifiable others to amongst them.
Yeah, he's on a rampage now going. He's doing the
who was the first person to do this? That crazy Greek gay dude.
Okay, there's a crazy Greek gay dude, who was the first person to
go light fires on college campuses? And it was crazy.
No, no, he's like, flaming homosexual.
Right. And blond Beach, bleached blonde hair. He's British. And
around 2016 was lighting these campuses on fire, right by saying
the most controversial outrageous things, * off all the
students and all these liberal woke students will be having
outrages. And that's how he built up his himself. And now everyone
does it. Then Ben Shapiro did it as a debate.
her, right? He just a straight debate with these students and
shutting them down in terms of you know their woke arguments. Then
now Candace is doing it and now what's his face? Charlie Kirk is
doing it now. Right? And he but he promotes Christianity too. And
this he's like a preacher to
and he says the most verifiable most authenticated is Zelda got it
right Milo, Stephanopoulos or whatever his name is. Remember
that Milo nut job?
Yeah, that crazy guy. So
yeah. And he disappeared completely when he promoted when
he said he was supportive of
child *. He was like supportive of *. They
canceled them completely. But point being is that Charlie Kirk
is doing this and he's said some things is like, this is the most
historically verifiable fact.
Man you need to read. You need to take a couple of courses.
Couple more questions, by the way today
is the soup kitchen.
Right? Soup Kitchen today.
We usually hit 100. weather like today we'll hit 100 People will
come in.
Can some will be matched with ag and Maliki. Now I don't believe
that there's a problem with that. Right? What's the there's only a
few differences between the two. Beyonds eight says most of them
are intertwined with the schools of Aikido madaket Shafi or Sid
humbly or Ethany. Hana fees are meant to add but somehow the fees
are Ashley's so it's an exception I guess I don't I don't
necessarily see what would be the issue of someone of the to someone
being a medically but also holding on to DJ positions
will ever come to Chiclets Roz mustard? Yes, I would love to love
to I did last year. Yeah, last year. And chickens rod has massive
hangouts after the gatherings. You're upstairs. tables have guys
trays of food and hang out all night until the master closes.
That's what we did last time.
As far as sheet Yeah.
If he's allowed it and I don't know if he's allowed it, because
you know, they say he's not allowed in.
How is a lay man supposed to take lectures from an online Ireland,
the old the say you should sit with them physically and avoid
online search of Hadith. It's not just online search of Hadith. It's
reading Hadith not knowing the dough of it, or the rules of when
to apply them. That's all it is. If you know the rules of when to
apply a hadith and you studied that, then you may read Hadith,
right? No problem with that. But
what what is always better is to live with people, because then you
see how they they act, how they apply the knowledge, right?
Likewise, we follow med hubs of living scholars, so that if we
were to go into one of our books, and I was to read, let's say in a
Maliki book, a line of law
I may have conjure up an understanding of that, that may be
wrong. So I have to contact a living scholar, and make sure that
I understood it right.
Or I have to contact a living scholar to make sure that this
book is reliable, because not every book in the method was
reliable.
For a couple of reasons. Number one, some scholars had a lot of
mistakes. Number two, the transmission of the book may not
be reliable. Number three, the transmission of the book is
reliable. The scholar when he cites others, it's reliable.
But when he gives his own facts, why it's not reliable. So you have
to know these things. Thirdly, fourthly, or thirdly, whatever
we're on.
If there's ever let's say two people disagree on the meaning of
a text in a book,
how do we arbitrate that?
If you don't have methods, living methods, you just argue all day,
and you try to get a gank and you try to get a gank. But if we have
a living method, let me ask you guys this question. Let's say you
read a book, a line from
Hanafi, FIP and a text and you say, Okay, this means this and you
read a line and said, No, no, it means that how do you guys
arbitrate it? Naturally? How do you arbitrate it?
Thank you, you just you just call your shoe, right? So okay, would
you do you do you submit that shift so and so understands the
book better than me and you? Yes, for sure. Would you submit to his
ruling on what it means? Yes, for sure. Then you contact him, he's
alive. That's the value of the living meth hubs.
Why file methods? Why we're not Alberni?
At Benny understand something takes his understanding from a
hadith or from a classification of a hadith. He doesn't ask his
conclusion and that's it. Right? We say hello. Put your brakes on
here. We disagree with you on this. Okay, we have a reference
point, let's say we can even get forced see you, right? If you say
that hadith mean, the text means a, and you say no, no, the ruling
on the text means B.
We take it to force you if to say A and to say B, then we know that
our method has two different opinions than to say we shake
hands to him that we both can give it to him by that opinion. Right?
Because our elders said so.
Or if all four said one thing than the other has to submit that he's
wrong. Simple as that. Right? He can't be stubborn.
Or and if it's like a majority.
We don't get fit to honor minority opinion. But if you did, maybe
it's acceptable because you have a living elder who gives federal
about that. Right? And there is a there's a saying and there's a
line in the booklet here that says whoever cites Ireland. Right? He
follows on him and he cites him. But Mortarion Ireland was
acceptable was accepted whatsoever, then you won't be
punished by law on that day of judgment for that.
And again, we just say that this is not correct. But we are not
punishable either.
That's why we have living schools of thought where the scholars are
alive. If we differ,
we push it up to a higher court here in America, they kick it up
to a higher court. Right, kick it up to a higher court. And then and
that's why we submit that to those elders they know understand the
law better. They're not making up law. But we submit to the reality
the common sensical reality they study for 50 years, they've been
teaching more than we've been studying. Right? They produce more
movies
than years that we've been studying.
So that is the methodology of resolving elf
vaping doesn't make you a facet if you vape in public. Well, it's a
kind of fear may give you a
What does they say about that? mcru 10 z here it's already me.
Marry me, what are the other automat say is same ruling as
smoking?
What is smoking in 110? Z McLauchlan Z
I'm gonna tell you for the sake of muscle, ah, yes, a very bad
festival. Because it's bad for your health. So you know that
festival can sometimes be given like that, too. That is muscle.
Right? So the idea because it's Oh, it says my crew. Okay, the
next thing is weed. Right? There's a clip actually of a scholar
saying smoking hot
vaping mcru We
maybe
it's I think he's he's making fun of somebody. Right? He's like
making fun of somebody. But people took the clip as like that's what
he said. That's not right. So in any event, we know that there's
harms to all these things so therefore
you shouldn't must avoid and by the way, you can talk as if said
did that here in non legal language with with them don't do
it.
So he's going to understand okay, hold on. But you actually didn't
say how you just you gave the awkward you give a safe statement
because neither are you judging on Allah's law right with what's not
in it, but you're also not and listen misleading the person so
that's why
all these puffing and smoking cancel it all. Cancel it all good.
All right, we gotta go which is awesome located and everyone
Subhanak Allahumma we'll be having Deke shadow. Isla illa Anta in a
software corner to a courthouse in Santa Fe, because L Alladhina.
Manu, what AMILO sila had what was so bad Huck. What's a while so the
sub was said what a coma Rahmatullah?
Job
know a lot
Oh
god