Shadee Elmasry – Gives His View On Istighatha
![Shadee Elmasry](https://artwork.muslimcentral.com/shadee-elmasry-150x150.jpg)
AI: Summary ©
AI: Transcript ©
I
play this video of Sheikh Hamza al Bukhari honest of author because I
actually hold this opinion myself to
contain him and
so he said that it's not going to be we're not going to hold it to
be sure but from the standpoint of FIP he talks about people who
permitted it he's now going to talk about people who forbid just
have author
instead of
Hollywood use
he doesn't the person doesn't believe that the person that is
being asked has any impact he's just a sub so that's why it's
removed from Chuck guy he's merely asking out of a need not out of
draw of iboga same way I asked Ryan actually I wouldn't ask you
anything because probably gonna get destroyed
just Just kidding. I they all
go move my car please. Right All right. Can you please go
get water for the plants? I'm asking you not out of a bed right
I'm asking you for a need
listener
while he's telling us currently under what in Canada who does read
Luca we saw here Well, I can know who you will hear more man and
fantasy then he haven't said either. That's what I believe in.
How well is that you him? Oh man infested you can easily imagine it
to be something fastened easily you can imagine it to be something
that's close to draw that's close to ship that's far from Islam. You
can easily imagine that
you're lacking your human manual says it was a man a
man enough outdoor mineral Willie you him desire luckily sermon
on us, yes mount.
And that's life I'm on it's not my jersey majaz ockley sub Luca life
I'm gonna get a regular person. By the way, the people who do it and
the people who are hearing it and witnessing it, they don't know all
these
technicalities of update of theta and majaz and all that.
So you will hear me well, first, he may imagine it's now more on
Fit bla be taken no.
Alpha
Manhattan agenda soldier
soldier in our weekly Mad Men Hey in this Jackie Theon lo sejak.
Marga Murata inhaca is difficulty levels that can get across so the
answer is soldier adeleye. A little bit other Mala nostalgia is
her Qudra Luba and also replied to the Lord, He's saying to has
rules. And example, one example of.is That your dot becomes a
poem. He says one or twice Rhyming is no problem but constant Rhyming
is showing that you're you have power in language, whereas da
you're supposed to show that you're miskeen so there are rules
into a bluff that can
handle alien cave Anta turbo FF second Lotus Virbhadra. Kilauea.
And don't be Turkey's serger Bob Anwar sajama ma Maroon? Maroon
Vika Rihanna. Minha and naptime and in each
one of them garlic is staying away from something that may appear if
I carry her on your Pula, insulin Allahumma inni. Luka behalf
Mohammed
had a module under man was called Tito soldiers were called to jamaa
hero
Hanifa Minato Sufi rewire called you crawl and yes and Allah Behati
I've deniability, he says here that if you tow us soon,
okay, even a minute for your him and Lily lab. Because it gives an
A
one can imagine that it gives an appearance that Allah owes
something to one of the slaves of Allah to say be happy so and so as
if Allah owes them something.
And he can have you also have a honey for your well known either.
Mohammed Salah
Allah Allah,
Allah, Allah, Allah, you're cleaning your home as every
Muslim, as if as if Allah has to give when you say that be happy
Nebby from the Gambia. Bihac means by the right of as if any act has
rights over Allah. Nobody does. Right. So that's why he said it.
You can technically give it an excuse. Technically you can
justify it by language and by theology, but
it can ease
be misunderstood. So by setting the video we should forbid this to
close off any possible misunderstanding. So I will
be happy for now. Let's
look at what happened to him. And when I saw him when he bought hola
Yo
let's now start
lagging by the ball from a visitor witness for Him and either hug the
minor Allah Azza wa Jalla will happen. So it's same thing he's
gonna basically say it's too confusing.
So he says that's his opinion, prohibition because it will lead
to confusion. And that's the opinion that I follow. And I like
to very much de Yes, Abu Hanifa said he does not like someone to
say be happy so and so be out there Mohammed. Why did he say
that? Because even though if you contextually explain it and
theologically and linguistically explain it, but it can appear to
others that you are saying that Allah owes any of the Creation
anything and he doesn't owe anybody anything. So even more so
than that. Yeah, Goethe Yeah. Abdul Kalam Jelani. Yeah, so and
so yeah, I'm going to devalue, all of that can easily be mistaken as
a kind of dua to somebody and that's what we see all over
online. I don't like anything that cannot be proven, clear cut with
one or two verses of Quran or Hadith.
And this one definitely doesn't have that you don't see the set of
doing that. So that we could sell here's medic doing it. You don't
see anyone doing this. Right. So I like comes in Buckley's opinion on
this and that's what I follow. Okay, because I don't want to be
stuck having to defend something I can't defend just because
everyone's doing it. My doing that
and it's not worth it is not part of every Islamic life. Now saved
Muhammad Daniel has a great point the Hadith of the blind man. Yes,
Hadith man of no knife. That is the Hadith that you stick to and
do that dua. Okay, keep that
nobody can just you know what that hadith is?
That is the Hadith that has is to Gotha bin Nabi sallallahu alayhi
wa sallam in it, Hadith mandible Haneef, no discussion of the man
had been Haneef everybody, if you want to do this, read this hadith
and stop there.
Here we say there's the cutter This is katri evidence right here.
And Nara Jhulan. Body run. dari Rahl bacillary, at 10 Nebia Salah
Hudson, a man who was blind came to the prophets lesson for God,
Allah Allah Lee called to Allah for me, make dua for me. And you
are funny that he killed he was my blindness for color, instead of
courage to laka occur to laka if you wish I can delay this for you
will kill you. I can delay that prayer for you means you'll be
patient with the blindness I'll make a special draw for you on the
Day of Judgment. There'll be better for you when should sit
down to look and if you wish, I pray for you. The man said Oh Joe,
pray for me.
I'd rather the prayer.
For Amara who and yet for your sin for your sinner will do. He
commanded him to make wudu and make and make an excellent rule
and pray Toorak us and recite the following to Allah home in the US.
Oh Allah asked you what, what Jehovah like And I turned to you,
through your prophet be Mohammed through Muhammad, the prophet of
Mercy Nabil Rama, yah, Mohammed in the Catawba Jaya to Big O
Muhammad, I have turned through you to my Lord through you because
by you, I have turned to my Lord. Oh, in other words, what am I
bringing to my Lord? You gotta bring good deeds to Allah to Allah
and if you want you don't have to be answered, what's my good deed?
The profit what does that mean the profit belief in the profit
following the profit loving the Prophet sallallahu sadhana
so there's something a gap here I turn to Allah with the Prophet
with what what the prophet with Amen in the Prophet belief in the
profit all that all those good things. So a jet to beaker ala
rugby fee Hagerty with my need heavy they talk about that you may
fulfill this need Allah Masha feralpi Oh Allah make him suffer
for me an intercessor for me. Where's this hadith narrated?
Timothy Gibbon, a manager at Hakim. Bacardi study, most not
even a double Ronnie.
And guess who else cites it? It's a mia himself in the Tila suit.
But I don't know what he commented on. He just recorded it I guess.
He tries to weaken it.
Go Well, if I'm going to say who else sites indica theater sites,
and he authenticated the hadith is recorded and authenticated by
several
dollars. All right Ibni manager Agnes. E. Al Hakim al bye happy al
Monday.
It's not much awaited has to be from the top. But we can say it's
most of the field may have come down from one or two but it's
spread far and wide and authenticated by many many.
Bukhari narrates it and hysterical Kabir right in his history.
narrates it we don't know if does he comment on those Hadith or he
just narrates we don't know. We'll name it Ben Hosea
Imam Muhammad at Tirmidhi
so this is what we would consider clear and air tight evidence.
And if we go by that hadith, right, then
no one can stop you. You will like it don't like it. That's the
Hadith homopolymer al Islam Almohad the Thien SE and