Shadee Elmasry – False Claim! That Ibn Mas’ud Prohibited Dhikr Gatherings
AI: Summary ©
AI: Transcript ©
The last point of opposition for Incorta if you say
fucka, the new kala animus Odin. It has been narrated from Eminem
so again no kala fell Lamesa my fellow on the authority of
autonomous ODE and now Hora Coleman that he saw a group of
people, you hallelujah bureau of assaults.
Making to heal to heel is La ilaha illallah saying Leila hella
burapha is so different Masjid with with raising their voices in
the mosque while raising beautify soti by raising the with the
raised voices in the masjid for Carla, Morocco in Moby today, Moby
Teddy. I mean, I don't see that you are anything except innovators
had a Harada home mineral mask JD until he expelled them from the
Masjid. Well to have a thorough and ABMS Odin, do Ella bandhasana.
A member cities as I say, this report from eponymous ODE requires
clarification regarding its Ned
woman, Raja home Minella a matter of fall FICO to be him. Right and
who from the great scholars, the whole father of Hadith Imams of
Hadith, right? Who narrated this in their books
while attack theory through booty. Okay, Let's hypothetically say
that it sounds hypothetical that this narration is sent for home or
audible I had eaten kefir a fair bit and Medaka Dima, it opposes
for whom wild it is in opposition Bill ahaadeeth Will Kathira right
to the many a hadith, a thermometer and with the Kadima
the Affer mentioned and confirmed a hadith a saboteur confirmed and
with Academy the aforementioned yeah what did he have 23 Hadees
well I am Oka dama Allah here in the toddled well here being the
prophetic Hadith, the Hadith that are metaphor that are attributed
to the prophets Allah Allah, Allah, Allah, maka dama. take
precedent, I lay he over the motif, the statement of the sahabi
and the Tao when there is a contradiction, so when there's a
contradiction, when you have two opposing things that can't be
reconciled, okay? Can't be restricted or qualified. So in
that sense, the metaphor, the Hadith, the especially when there
are so many, okay, when there are many not like one and one such
that we have to reconcile between the two many metaphor, a hadith,
prophet from the prophets of the word metaphor, meaning the Hadith,
the speaker is the prophets of Allah. Listen, and this is one mo
Cuf. Okay, Mo Oof. Meaning it's the statement of as a hobby.
That's just one point. On top of that, wait a second, who narrated
this hadith? Wait, how do we even know that it's actually that
Eminem is owed said so and in fact, a member SUTI will continue
to tell us there is actually no way he said so he says here so
Mara Ito may actually incur that he can have numerous owed he said
then I've seen what would force us to negate that even wrestled ever
said this at all. Okay, the exact translation would be in addition,
I saw something which shows that the above was never the position
of animus Oh, to begin with. All right. So what does he say?
Girl, Imam Ahmed, the Imam Muhammad says Abraham Bennett. By
the way, man, man's name is Muhammad ibn Muhammad had been
humble, humble is his grandfather is just he's became famous as
because humble was famous. So he's became active and he's actually I
met him in Mohammed bin
V. kitab. His Zote in his book as Imam Muhammad has a beautiful book
called Zeus asceticism had death inna you see here it says that
noon lf that's short hand for had definite Hussain who knew Mohammed
had death en el mismo de I met him Nisha Pippin, and eBay Elan, Carla
Okay, that's the chain her hola those are Lavinia is Omona who
claim and Abdullah that Abdullah Massoud can a yen here and a vicar
that he used to prohibit vicar merger less to Abdullah he
Methodism Allah the Quran Allah haffi I've never set in a medalist
with Abdullah except that here made vicar in it. Okay, so this
man this hobby who is not as a hobby by the prophet, but he's a
companion we can say like a companion of economists or he's
saying he had heard the
Rumor at that time, he heard the rumor, right?
And he's negating it. So here you have someone who sat with him and
MSOs who had heard the rumor that some people claim that even Ms.
Aude prohibited people from doing Vica he's telling you, but who's
gonna know better than someone who lived with a venomous owed? We're
not here trying to guess and speculated maybe this maybe that
no, he lived with him.
Ever what? How old Latinas Omona and Abdullah Canadian and victory
magia less to Abdullah my Judaism to Allah the Quran Allah V Avi
except that he remembered hola in it.