Ahmad Kutty – Is it permissible to migrate from a Muslim country to a nonMuslim country
AI: Summary ©
The transcript discusses the history and implications of the Hadith, which is a situation where Muslims try to engage with Muslims in safe locations, leading to the loss of their freedom of action. The importance of practicing Islam to avoid oppressed and persecuted is emphasized, as it is required to avoid seduction and trial. The sharia law is not applicable in India, and the situation where all non- Muslim countries are free to prayer and pray is seen as obligatory. The sharia law is not applicable in Europe, Canada, and North America, and the situation where every non- Muslim country in Europe, Canada, and North America is now a structural structural problem.
AI: Summary ©
The question is, need some explanation? I need some
explanation on the Hadith where it is said that migration from a
Muslim country,
Islamic country or Muslim majority country to a non Muslim country is
prohibited. Can a Muslim from a non Muslim country bracket India
migrate to another non Muslim country? That Canada?
I think, brother who has asked this question is referring to the
Hadith to a hadith, which
is reported on the authority of God, Ruben Abdullah, rally Allah
Allah, and it is recorded by Muslim and a few others, that the
best narration
in caramelly, we say is Rasulullah sallallahu wasallam send an
expedition to her thumb. And,
you know, they were fighting Islam and Muslims. And when Muslims were
trying to engage them, some of them rush to make sujood you know,
in order to defend themselves to give an impression, they are
Muslims. So, but Muslims thought they were simply pretending. And
so they, you know, engage them in battle and kill some of them. And
then Prophet sallallahu wasallam asked them to give half of the
conversation, you know, the blood money do because of the doubt
involved? And then he declared, I am innocent of every Muslim who
recite chooses to stay in the middle of the Mushrikeen in the
midst of the mystery Cain, and when question why is replied,
because, you know, the their fire do not resemble they're not you
cannot distinguish one from the other.
This Hadees has been taken by some groups, and they run with it, even
though it is specifically referring to a situation of
warfare between Muslims and non Muslims, especially the pagan
Arabs, who declare war against Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi
salam, the Prophet salallahu Alaihe Salam was
not allowed to practice Islam in Makkah.
And because they were persecuted,
although he preserved He was patient for some time. So the
situation get from bad to worse, finally allows one out Allah
allowed Muslims to migrate to Medina. And when the prophets are
allowed us and them, you know left to babka. He said, You are the
dearest place to my heart, and you are the best place that one can
recite on the face of the earth. If not, for my people are not
forcing me to go out, I will not have left it. So the concept here
is Rasulullah sallallahu Sallam and the Sahaba left for forced to
leave Baca, where they were born and brought up. And then after
possessions and properties there, because of fitna, they were facing
this test in their religion. And it was hard for them to hold
firmly to the religion. So you know the situation this is the way
every companion every sahabi, every one of the authentic
Imams, and the eminent scholars have interpreted this situation
that Muslims are allowed
to live in any place they want, because our Lord Allah will abide
by the law. The word belongs to allows one over Tala and the
creation, the humankind are the servants of Allah. So leave it
wherever you feel safe and secure. And you can practice your
religion. And this is what you know if you read all of this
verses in the Quran, where Allah subhanaw taala asked the question,
first of all, you know, under the in Africa, for whom Monica, the
angels when the season the soul of those who were oppressed, you
know, and yet and because of being oppressed, they could not practice
the religion. So the angels will ask, and I'm talking normal law he
was Yeah. They said we were
Salafi and we were oppressed, we had no choice. So the question is,
wasn't the earth of Allah you know, washed and why'd you put on
migrated? Of course, this was specifically referring to the
situation in Makkah, where Muslims were oppressed and persecuted.
They were prevented from practicing the religion. So those
who have can afford to live Mecca, to Medina to Rasulullah Salallahu
Salam, where one could practice religion freely, and if you didn't
do that, having had the ability to move, you are allowed him you are,
you are a grave sinner. And this does not apply to anyone who is
living choosing to live in a place
where he is completely safe and secure in regards to his life, in
regardless position is owner and religion and he can establish the
rituals the symbols of Islam, without any fear of anyone in the
inner interfering with his practice. So if that is the case,
he is free to live wherever he wants. Omar moving
internationally, Alana was asked the question, are we supposed to
oblige to bake Hegira? No.
I shall allow no replied. No more Hijra after mocha has been fallen
as been conquered by Muslims. We know they were asked to leave
Makkah, if irregular be dini. Rasulullah sallallahu wasallam a
person was living or fleeing with his religion to rasool Allah Islam
to be free to practice religion, commanding on this beautiful
Hadith, Hydra, alas calorie, the who is known as the Ameerul
movement in full Hadith. In fact, wholebody says,
I shall Allah wanna terraces that Hegira is only prescribed because
of how fitna when there is a fear of sedition and trial tests in
case of being forced out of our religion, pressure put against
call being caused to leave a religion. So we're who como yo do
Roma, I love to hear the rule, rewards with Allah. So where there
is a reason you are persecuted in practicing your religion, then you
must leave as long as you find a safer place. But if that is not
the case, Lam tangible later I will know I know he'll he German
No, it's not obligatory for him to make a gyro Omen Omen some I'm
Carl Marwadi. Therefore my word he says, is Kira yulara. Dean if he
buried him rather Cofer. If he says he goes on to say my
worldview the political theories of Islam and Greece color a shaft
of a Sufi school and author of many works. If a believer a Muslim
can practice his religion in the country where majority are non
Muslims by the fact that he's able to practice his religion freely.
That place has become virtually like $1 Islam for likoma to fiat
Alfa Romeo relative in ha So staying there is better than
leaving that place. Because from his stay there, many other people
may be guided to accept Islam. And we have so many other Hadith from
Rasul Allah Himself Salah Julio Salam, which establishes this
beyond a shade of doubt. You know today according to your AUSA tub,
Ronnie as well as we burn, for they came to Rasulullah sallallahu
Assam man called Houdek and he told him here in the Himalayas or
Munna Unno Mala Mahajan. halacha. They are saying to me that if you
don't make Ijarah you are you perish for Cairo Rasulullah
sallallahu Sallam the Messenger of Allah told him your foot ache
after Miss salah, establish Salah artistica and offers the cat Why
would you sue and shun evil was convened merrily home you could
choose to live wherever you're comfortable from the land of
your own people. And in another Hadith, the Prophet sallallahu
Sallam told in Arabi In our counter Salah wa treatise Zakka
for under Mohammed urine we will have Rama if you are too free to
establish Salah and give the Zika then you are a true muhajir even
though you did not leave your place while you motorable have
Rama even if you die in the land of your mama, which was totally
out of
For at that time when the Prophet spoke, so that is why Imam Shafi
Rowley, Allah will know says the great Imam will look to Rasul
Allah Allah an affordable Hijra Allama nataka in nama who alarm on
foot in R and D. It is very clear from the Sunnah of the Prophet
sallahu wa salam, that the obligation to make Hijra is only
on those who have been persecuted, who have been pre rendered who
have been coerced against practicing the religion. So this
is the eminent scholars and the fatwa of all of these colors that
are recognized by Muslims. So, of course, they can quote fatwas
after fatwas of prominent people. The short reply is that Muslims
have followed this. And because of thanks to this, Muslims went to
Indonesia, no soldier when they recited them in the non Muslim
population, their vast majority of them, Hindus, the majority
converted to Islam, because of the Muslims going in the setting down.
In China, millions of people converted to Islam, because of the
merchants and the traders, and the Sufi scholars and saints who went
there. The same thing with many, many countries. I come from South
India, where Muslim Arab traders came, and the Sufi sheiks, and
household member members of the Prophet's family came and settled
down and intermarry with the local population. So the majority in my
part of malaba are Muslim or Hamdulillah, we have a very
thriving Islamic community, they're establishing all of the
rituals of Islam. Of course, the Sharia law is not applicable
there, because it is still non Muslim country, India is majority
non Muslim. So it's a secular country. Now, if you look at
anywhere in the world, in Europe, and Canada and North America, we
have an institutional so this is a situation where all our everyone
is free to prayer, there is freedom of conscience, it's a
multicultural, pluralistic society. So the situation where
some scholars said, you know, the binary, you know, division of the
wall, into Dar Al Islam, and our hub does not hold. And that's why
Marvel himself was forced to change the definition. I myself
presented this case in the court here in Ontario. Based on this,
they released that man, who were accused of being a terrorist,
because the, the, the, you know, the prosecuting side was citing an
Islamophobic expert on Islam, who said, according to Islam, there is
only God or Harbin dar or Islam, I caught it. Moreover, the hijab and
others know the situation has changed. Now, even as the judge
who is a Christian, I told you how you are free to practice and
preach your religion as a Christian, I am free, I have been
doing it in this country for over 40 years, I said to him, and of
course, they were convinced that Islam does not teach us, you know,
to leave a place where we are free, actually, by staying here
and practicing Islam, and showing the beauty of Islam through our
words and actions and behavior, Inshallah, people will be
attracted to Islam. And this is what the Muslim wisdom has a prac
learn Muslims have learned from the wisdom. And of course, there
were some exceptions in some cases, and that is only
contextualize a specific situation. So now the world is
different. Pluralism and multiculturalism is an it's a
principle followed by many of these countries, so there is no
need for us. And finally, I want to make a point, there was a study
made, they distinguish the Israel criteria of specifically being
Islamic, especially the social justice, and they cited four or
five principal values. And they studied all of them country's
Muslim and non Muslim. And you know, all of the Muslim countries
failed, because there is no justice, there is no
accountability, and there is persecution.
So, the number one
country that paths are of the tests of the valid Islamic
criteria, number one was New Zealand
and the Muslim country even even Malaysia came, you know, Gruder,
but it came very, very further further away in the lowest but
other Muslim countries. No other Muslim country passed any of those
tests. Because there is no accountability. There is no
justice. So how can you say that
Have you from Canada should migrate to a Muslim so called
Muslim country where you are check, you have no freedom. You
cannot feel safe, whether you will live tomorrow, your family will be
safe. How many of these great scholars are in jail, and many of
them have disappeared from the face of Europe. So let us stand
the last one Ottawa, we are here in Canada, we enjoy the rights
here and read that constitution of Canada. I have done it on the
member. And I said this document should be in every Muslim country.
I wish they practice it because this enshrines the social ethics
of the Sharia, the soul of the Sharia, the way we should run this
country, we have lost one author helps us to understand and let us
not get carried away by the extremists who are trying to
implement their agenda by preaching that something which
they did not learn. It is, you know, people with a demagogue
political demagogues who is not trained in Islamic sources, who
are giving this kind of fatwa, Allah subhanaw taala help us avoid
having to rely on tangling the last one Ocula every Muslim in
Canada should tanglers Monica, we are in this country enjoying the
rights which I cannot enjoy in my own birth country, even India. Of
course, India is much better in many ways from other Muslim
countries. But yet I don't have this. I don't have this kind of
freedom anywhere else in the world. We have lost one out there
help us to appreciate what we have, then we can of course, I am
not saying we are perfect here. And it is our duty to stand up for
the truth and justice as mandated by the Canadian Constitution and
Charter of Rights. We should fight for our rights, of course in in
the legal way in the way that is approved by Islam, the wisdom wise
preaching and Inshallah, by writing and speaking inshallah.
Hakuna holy hada Mustafa Rula