Waleed Basyouni – Tafseer of Surah Al Kahf 20
AI: Summary ©
The conversation is about
AI: Summary ©
Amina Shea upon your Raji
she had to call us on our team on all the wonderful
to see him
to
lean onto the oil omega por una shanaka
leadin Azzam to further
study Bula whom, wah
wah moody moon and
while me
masala rifa Wanaka. nappy poo and even seeming Colima.
What.
Tadashi
God
I did not make them witness to the creation of the heavens and earth nor to their own creation. I do not take as my supporters those who lead others astray. On the day God will say call on those who claimed were my partners, they will call them but they will not answer we shall set a deadly goal between them. The evildoers will see the fire and will realize that they are about to fall into it, they will find no escape from it. In this plan, we have presented every kind of illustration for people but man is more contentious than any other feature
smilla hamdu Lillah wa salatu salam ala rasulillah Aria sabio Manuela Hobart
as you might remember, last week, we were talking about the verse where Allah subhana wa tada told us the story of the creation of Adam and his Salaam and the story of Adam and it bleeds on the ship on and we talked about the difference between the sin of the item the sin of the shade lawn, we talked about how human being ended up ending up taking a shape on as partner, as well as a friend, as someone that they turn to, instead of Allah subhanho data every time they disobey Allah azza wa jal
then Allah Subhana Donna after he mentioned, the creation of Adam and the story of the beginning of humanity, Adam is not the universe. So, Adam, Lisa, who and Adam, there is other things also been created before either, which is heavens and earth, and a loss of Hana data as he told us a little bit about the history of his creation. We only know a little bit about the things that the Lord created. We don't even know everything that alive made everything a lot more data created. So here is saying Mashhad to help us somehow
you did not witness you're not there witnessing nor helped Allah subhana wa tada when he created what the heavens and the earth and remember these verses are lost when addressing Who?
Primarily the disbelievers that don't those who don't believe in Allah Spano, dada, the disbelievers. They have other deities that they worship that they depend on That's right, that they love the trust they they seek help from it. So lots of Hana data saying that I have not made any one of you know your deities, nor the gods that you believe in know the gods that you claim as partner with me. None of you all have witnessed the creations of the heaven than Earth.
And that's why there is another karate Raja Buddha he said, Mashhad, to whom la Mashhad now whom
we have not made them witness the creation of the heavens and the earth. And aroma rahimullah said them referring to some set a shared bond and his followers, the disbelievers Some said the angels Some said the people of Mecca and what it seems to be that all the creation of everyone can be included in that. And that shows you that no one ever held Allah subhanaw taala and planning and making the heavens and the earth has come out of you know, that's what shows you what
The last part Allah is the only one who created the heavens and the earth and universe. He didn't need any help, nor he didn't need anyone to help him in planning, excusing, making, you have the perfect knowledge, the perfect power and ability to make that this universe. So, if this is the case, that shows you that those you are worshipping besides Allah Subhana data, do not have the power do not have the abilities that made them gods
and Allah subhanaw taala in many verses in the Quran on he makes this case very clear.
For instance, in Surah, Csaba Allah subhanaw taala said verse 23, poder only leadin as I'm going to
call upon those who you claim as partner other than Allah, Lam licona myth, Kannada rotting fish
or
they do not own the dome process, namely Khun mythical Adama they do not own even as much as the raw what is the Dora the smallest thing in LMS says like the size of the head of an ENT, the smallest things they do not own it. Everything that's been created by Allah owned by Allah.
Tell me one thing that you own
your deeds, what else one thing that you own, your stores, what else you own
your soul? What is your own, whatever you want, and your life, clothes, all this the reality that it is owned by Allah, not by you. He's the one who made it happen to you. And to prove that he can take it away from you anytime.
He can destroy it in any time can take it away from even your own soul. You don't have a control over it. He give it to you and he can take it so that means you don't run me on it.
So I lost kind of data saying that everything in this universe is owned by Allah subhana wa Tada. And also other than Allah, nyan lacuna, mithuna. Dora, they do not own anything in this universe. Why man? I
mean, sure.
Well, I'm I mean,
nor the own, nor they have Shoraka partnership with a law because you might not own it solely, but your partner with Allah and me and Allah together on this know, the prophet, Allah says, none of these days is none of these gods that people pray to other than Allah on anything, nor they have a partnership with the last one girl in any level, in any shape in any form, what man whom, in whom member here, and Allah doesn't need any one of them then to help him to run the universe. So Allah here, didn't negate how many things three in this verse, that they don't own anything. They do not have a partnership. They don't have the ability to help or to support or the Allah no need for them.
Not only that, he said, even my father, he said, What are tiempo? shefa to endo Illa lemon Eleonora, they don't even intercede.
If this is the case, if these deities of these things that you pray to other than a lot you turn to other than a law, they don't own. They don't have a partnership. They cannot help and even they cannot intercede for you Why do you pray to them? Why would you turn to them?
And the last panel data here in this verse, He said one unforeseen and I did not make them witness how themselves they've been created. They were not there with the last one the data have created Adam at his center. And here again, he's speaking to the humans. Then he said the last panel data after that, well now couldn't do more mobile Lee now
yes or no. And I will not take a mobile lien.
I will not take a mobile lien. Any
mobile lien means the people who miss leaders, as helpers, Allah Allah will not take a mobile lien which is the shape bar and his followers as helpers. So a lot telling the Godfather there is no point for you to go astray or to follow the shape bonds path because a shaped bond and his followers is never someone that Allah subhana wa tada will turn to
Or who need us helpers. Alba? Yeah, and IANA as an emetic. Rahim Allah set. So this verse is meant to confront the disbelievers, and to make them realize that their deities will not help them in any shape in any form.
And
how can we make this relate to us today?
There is nobody worship idols among us, but around us there is a lot of people still worship idols.
Oh my god, just look around. There's a lot of people still turned to an idols, and they worship.
And they believe in it, there is a lot of people who worship humans. There is a lot of people who worship other than Allah Subhana data, this photo of Shirky still exists. And this kind of argument is very strong argument.
That's why I remember him Allah, when they said, Yeah, and he talks about, for example, those who worship Jesus other than Allah subhanaw taala beside Allah, and believe Jesus is God.
The same question, we raised the teak did he own anything in this universe? Did he create anything in the universe? Does he have any Ark partnership in the universe? If he did not, he's not the God. The God is the one who created him and created the universe, the God is the Creator is the owner, not any other, not any one of his creations. And Allah Subhana data is in no need of partners. He doesn't need a son.
He doesn't need to forgive, to make to have a son. He doesn't need to make things to have a helper or aid. So this verse can be used even in our days, when we deal with
any form of shelter that exists today. Add to this
this also verse can be very good, something to reflect upon in our life as a Muslims. because it'd be Masuda the alarm does this a lot. He looked at the verses that speak about the kuffaar. And he applied to the Muslims.
And a lot of people said, Oh, this is the cure, there's not a clear in it. We're not saying that the person is cafard, but it Massoud was trying to say, Do not adopt the quality of the machine. That's why when Allah said, we're not an immediate machine, mushrikeen I'm not among the machine again. Now that doesn't mean any I'm not going to worship other than Allah. No, I'm not in then we should, again in the worship, and I'm not like and we should again in their attitude, and their qualities and their be the way they behave. That's what it means. So you're not allowed to be like the machine and the disbelievers in any shape or any form. So here we say that one of the things that we should
say to ourselves, that anything that today, people take as a way of life, as a guidance for them to survive in this dunya keep to yourself and say whoever came up with that guide, guidance, whoever got come up with that law to organize your personal life, claiming that it is better than what our last panel data have given us in this beautiful book. Remember that those people did not witness the creation of the heavens and their they did not even witness their own creation.
To know what is good for you to know what is really going to heal you what is really going to protect you.
Remember that Allah Subhana Allah to Allah will not take on Moodle, Lena Buddha, Allah will not take the misleader helper, Allah will not take the misleader helper to help guide humanity.
When it comes to the relationship with Allah subhanho wa Taala then Allah subhana wa tada here again, as I said earlier, this one of the thing about moving from one place to another from one time to another, so here he talks about I have not made the mootness the creation the beginning. Then the next verse, he said, Why oma or Luna
el Medina tomb, Fado home Verna Mr. Jean moolah, whom watch
movies
and remember the day when Allah Subhana Allah will say call those partners
do Shoraka wherever may afford now do Shoraka. The word is call upon
the word needed
and needed for it means you call upon someone with loud voice.
Okay, the word nada and cry means you call upon someone with loud voice. So that means you're screaming either because their partners are very
Far away from them.
They can hear them or because they are very desperate so the call the want to save themselves so the screen upon these
deities and partners that they took with the last panel what it's like when you see when your problem and you see someone that you thought is going to help you hey, I need to screaming out me. So the word is very
it gives you that
feeling it lets you hear them screaming upon them and the day of judgment or in the Hellfire
or in the hellfire. That question you might say how people will wow what will happen with the people who will have partners with a lot but those partners are not bad things.
Any Jesus
or somebody worship Mohammed
or someone worship
and one of the righteous people who passed away somebody worship Jin Jin Muslim.
What would happen to this date isn't the the claim them partners they will see the images but they will not see them. So they see an image of so called Jesus an image of that shrine image of that claim that is Mohammed Schrage. An image of some so called a Heidi Abby Barnum, anything that we used to worship with the last panel What are these images? So the screaming the call upon them
and see the last one that I said sure I can call upon your partner
that you claim
them partners they will not answer your call
him Allah
Allah call them partners shorrock out welcome your partners not my partners those the one that you have taken you partner up with them by worshipping them through Shoraka Oh como la de una Zamzam.
For me for the telomere study Buddha home they a lot call them partner marking them pocket the most for sure. A Shoraka our exam document that you claim
marking them and he said that the you claim Zamzam you claim it gives you indication that means or the word Zama it's something means false. It's a false hood is not true. That's why he said you call them that way and they're not further our home. phenom Mr. g Bula, aku Fado, Mr g would on the call upon them the bag them but they did not respond to them. They did not respond to them by saving them by even talking to them by making promises to them nothing
for them yesterday Buddha homebush A
and as Allah Subhana Allah says in Surah Al Baqarah la who don't want to help the one lady in the room do Neela is dodgy buena Don't be shy
those who call upon other than a lot they will never answer your call with anything except like this in la cabeza Tikka funny enough
any new offer except like someone open his hand like this and he puts his hand inside the water and try to drink
Can you dip your hand in the water then you pull it out and he tried to drink there is anything remain
that's how you are you call upon them and they will not respond to you with anything on your own carefully in
the dirt out of the caffeine is bilall in vain will not help or not benefit and this is sorta right. 14
then the last panel data set after that further album for me a study Buddha home so here the call upon them the screen the the big them they did not respond to them. Then Allah said of a john or john bainer whom mobile car he said that the last one is data and we shall put a mobile car between them.
john bainer home yeah I need between the disbelievers and their deities bainer assura car one lady in a can we are we doing a banner anyhow Mr. Buddha, those who used to worship these deities and their deities, their idols, whatever they used to worship beside Allah subhanaw taala
Or it could be a law have made a barrier or mobit up between the believers and the disbeliever at that time, so the disbeliever will be told them hey, go with your partner together and the believers you stay together and that would happen in the day of judgment and abuse Allah Allah Salim said that everybody used to worship something he will see the image of it and will follow it until these images fall in the in the Hellfire and the people will fall behind it. So that means they all will gather together.
So last panna, Cotta will make mobila which is a barrier between the disbelievers and the believers. That's one opinion the other opinion said know what jalna Bina homophobia? We made a barrier between the disbelievers and the deities that they used to worship the gods that they used to worship with Allah subhana wa tada
What does mobila it been a bass Rahim Allah to Allah, Allah answered mo Bella Malika distractions something Well, anyway, we made between them, what will bring death to them? What will destroy them? Abdullayev now I'm not going to assert a valley in the hellfire.
A very deep valley in the Hellfire, that the people, the kuffaar cannot cross it. So they see the deities in the other side and the Hellfire and they want to go to them but they can't because they see this huge deep valley in between them
and has an imbecile he said know what jalna bainham mo because we made between the mobicom Allah Allah Dawa hate animist. Hey, in the disbeliever, when they see the deities, and these gods and those who misled them, not telling them they will hate them the most at this point,
our hobby
and madness, it means we between them, that they were locked up. So the kuffaar will be locked up in a place in hellfire. And they cannot reach out to these guards and talk to them.
The point is that there will be a separation or barrier between them and their gods and their deities, then they feel that there is no way they can benefit from them at all. Then a Lost Planet Allah. So what's the fact the fact is this? And the majority mean, criminals, sinners, disbelievers hypocrites, those who truly mean what will happen, what our enemy to the moon and now
shall see the file.
And basically, when they see it, they will realize that they are going to follow
and that support the idea that they will see the deities in the Dave, the land of resurrection, they see the images and they tried to reach them they could not. And they basically ended up in the Hellfire or maybe that barrier between them inside the Hellfire of that valley. What would you remove and now that when they see it with their own eyes, in the land of resurrection, because my brothers and sisters, the Hellfire will be seen by everyone on the Day of Judgment. As our last panel data said, What Gao made me jahannam that day that Hellfire will be brought near to people our interview sallallahu sallam, it will be held by 70,000 * each row billed by 70,000 angels. Elon
Musk said these robes and tightening the Hellfire because if they do not do that, the whole fire will jump into the nine different direction and will swallow and take and pick every disbeliever from the face of the earth
or every sinner that is supposed to go to the whole fire.
But the tide how far the holding back, pull it back. Then almost panatela who said when they see the how far they know that they will fall in it. Why? Why they know that they will fall on the helpline. They know that they belong to the Hellfire because they found out that the deities that they worshipped are false. They found out that there is a day of treatment. They found out that there is a resurrection they found out that the believers are calm and so the the understand that go for the dead, the the sin that they have made as Allah Subhana Allah says in the Quran, also their books, even before they take the books they realize that as Allah subhanaw taala said, buried in Santa Ana
and FC basura
The other day, you know exactly what you deserve.
What made you do unharmed,
and they will not find no way for escape from the alpha.
And no way to escape after the internet and before they entered, they found no way because there is only two places to go to enjoy judgment, Jenna or not, there is no there is no option with Go Go back to the dunya there is no option to go back to the word reliable. It's either you go to the Hellfire or you go to Paradise. So that's why I lost, they have no place to go no place to escape, or maybe after the enter the Hellfire and the experiences they know that they can get out because in the
Masada it will be they will be locked inside the hellfire.
Then our last panel data set after that, what happened so rough nafi had an enemy method. And indeed We have put forth every kind of example, illustrations in this book.
So why Allah Subhana Allah will give many different kinds of illustrations, many different examples, how the 10 we're what the serif why because people are, people are different. So sometimes the Koran speak to your mind, sometimes speak to your heart, sometimes speak to you, putting fear, sometimes putting hope, sometimes reminding you of the blessings of Allah sometimes speak about things that is very materialistic, something you can touch some time to your soul, something very spiritual. So, every piece every person is different, and it will give you the worldly benefits, the hereafter the benefits for you in the hereafter. So all these different things that are unexplained to you, and I
basically approach you with it may it may create you or create inside you a sense of excitement agenda. He didn't tell us about one thing in general.
Any for example, can you imagine? One day I was teaching about the agenda and somebody was asking me, Chef, why any of us want to speak about food in general and I don't like food.
It is not like something excited me in there is food in general. Who cares for food?
I said maybe you don't other people do.
Okay, you don't like food, other people like food. for them. This is a big deal. Other I respect.
I respect for it. I like good food. I like good fruit. You know, somebody else speak about clothing and jewelry. Somebody else may be attracted the concept of that they will have you know, servants, you know there'll be young they will be healthy. There is many things. So Allah Subhana Allah mentioned many things in the Quran examples. Why because he wants to touch everybody's heart. And everybody has his own taste while a console of nappy has. It's reminding me of the verse when the last panel data said
to Sleaford Ria,
Allah said about the wind, that there are not one type of wind for some from the north, some from the south, some comes cold, some comes
warm, these different type of wind that comes is the reason for making this earth full of life.
An f that when why because if the wind doesn't move, or to move on in one direction, you will not have this
environment that you have today.
But these changes that allow us to make it in the air is the cause for rain the cause for the movement of the clouds and and basically the seasons to have it and so forth.
The same thing with these different examples of the law given the Quran, while dorabella home method and hayati dounia Audra hamata, La Jolla rajala in these examples, different examples of Allah given the Quran, these analogies, these things that make you think about the nature of your creation and the nature of a Lost Planet, Allah and his rights upon us, lead to guidance.
And then a last panel data set after that, even though with all these different examples and illustrations that allow
have given to us to guide us in the Quran. He said what Canon insano Akashi in Jeddah human being is basically a man is ever more
he is how competent you need,
he is the most
argumented creation, or he loves to argue.
So, because of your nature as a human being that you love to argue, you love to think you love to analyze, you love to questions, things. So a lot give you so many examples to choose from so many different ways. So you no matter how much if you start thinking and using really your logic and your article, and you start thinking about it, analyze it, you will arrive to the conclusion, which is that Allah Subhana Allah is your Lord, and the one that you should submit yourself to. And his religion is the best Sherry and the best guidance for you to follow.
And remember Rahim Allah said, Is this a praising or not?
When he said and the human being the most argument, creatures
that a praising or, or criticism.
Is that a good about seminar method? Actually it was said that this verse in particular referring to the kuffar who keep arguing with the prophets on Sunday, and particularly said it, it's related to a number of ninhydrin when you start to argue about the Quran, will be even harder.
And what it seems to me that this verse not only related to this individuals, but to show the nature of the human being, because human being liked to argue, they just like to give up quickly. And w Salatu. Salam, his beloved daughter, Fatima, came to him, came to his house, but he wasn't there. She was there. And she said, I want to talk to my father.
I want to talk to my father about something. What do you want to do? I need to talk to him.
She said he's not here. But I will let him know when he comes back. So in the be Salalah, you It was said that
he came late. So he went to his daughter's after night, the night after Asia. And she was already went to bed with her husband.
So in obese Allison, actually let me zasada Mati, did he he went there before
he was told and rafter so you don't approach people. So maybe so someone said he will go to her in the morning and see what you want. But before he went to the mustard, see how much he loves his daughter. Before he went to the hospital for fudger prayer. He went where to his daughter's house to talk to her you might say shift, but isn't that also lights not fragile yet. But generally someone expected them to make it clear.
To be praying in the night. That's the expected. So you found them sleep.
So when the process of them came to them, she got shy.
And she covered herself. Because as you assume that in the old days during the process of time, they don't have that concept that we have called pajamas. You only have one set of clothes. Most likely people when they go to bed, they are naked. They don't have clothes on, they take their clothes off and they discover themselves and that's how they sleep. So she felt shy her and her husband next to each other. Yes kind of shy. And she covered us I never
told her that.
If you went abroad you She told him that she was looking for a servant
than in the US alone. She's I heard that you got some money. And I would like you to get me a servant than in Ibiza Salaam palm, pilot mcenery Mohammed wouldn't be fit that Mohammed
eruptive netta who Hardiman were on the sofa.
Sarah wouldn't be right for Mohammed to give his daughter, a servant. While we have poor people live in a sofa. The poor people who live in the back of the mustard wouldn't happen.
If I have extra money, I'll give it to those poor people.
But I can tell you something better than
serving that when you go to your bed. You say panela 33 times the relative three times allow
About 34 times for both of you.
Then individual Sam said, don't you stand Didn't you pray before before you find out?
Then Adam navitat the middle the Alliance said, Yasser Allah.
We are human,
our soul, not in our hand. It's in the hands of Allah. Whenever he gives it back to us on we sleep, we wake up. And if we didn't bring it back to us, we don't wake up.
Yeah, and I'm not It's not my fault that didn't wake up for prayer.
Then in Nevis, he did like this.
He had to stay.
And he left walking angry. Saying mccannon in Santa Fe in Jeddah.
Human Being love to argue
in the face of Salaam is not accusing you of anything. They want to encourage you when he said you don't press upon a line, I'm praying the night Subhana light the word and maybe someone who used it is not like auspices of Allah for everything. Now, he said when he said some how to lie that means something made him angry, something not correct. So he said Subhana Allah, you don't pray in the night. So the province of Santa Monty was trying to encourage you to show you that this is nothing not not the best thing what's expected from Alibaba and follow them to Mohammed demetria Malaya and the praying the night. That's what expecting from them is not saying this for you to start arguing,
oh, you know, I overslept, and the soul and the hand of Allah, you don't do that with Rasulullah zasada. You don't do that with the Sharia. You don't do that to someone who giving you advice with someone who wants Good for you.
So and the Beatles are seldom used this verse
in relation to this incident. So that means this verse is not only related to the kuffar and even if it was sent down in regard to the incident of the kuffaar, we can use this verse in any incident that it fits the meaning.
Anyway, no matter human law said that in San, he is the most argument creation. Even he argued way more than the angels and don't argument.
Then you have more arguments, then he argue more than the shale theme, and the gin.
Some of them said that and some said no, they've been actually said it is possible for a human to argue more than the gin I believe so.
I believe human being arguably more than the gin.
gin are so weak compared to humans.
And the point is that human beings, they argue a lot the question and a lot.
And I think that's because they are the most intellect creations more than animals more than they speak. So that's why I like give them quality made them have this ability to argue to question things. And I believe that this description is not negative and not positive. What determine your argumentation it is positive or negative. It is how you are you and what you argue for. And what's there to lead you to.
If that makes sense.
last panel to Allah here said
Wanaka disorder often he had an N in in seeming Colima.
Anybody knows another verse very similar to the sound the same.
There is another verse of the Quran almost identical to this to the beginning part, which is and indeed we have put for every kind of example in the Oran
for mankind.
Anybody knows
and certainly saw the sutra before
Allah says in the Quran, what are the sorrow of Nan in Sep hadn't any mean Colima?
Indeed, we have put for,
for human being, for a human being.
In this call on every illustration.
It's exactly the same the only difference in salted is raw
He said for humans started with human will occurred sort of naturally NASS
were put forth for human beings, all kinds of illustrations in this call on so the human came first and came later. But in sort of the cat it's the opposite woollacott sort of nafi hadn't any Lena.
illustrate in the Koran for the human, he put the Quran first, then the human comes next and aroma him Allah said, it is for a reason. Because in certain is tsra Allah Subhana Allah was challenging humans below his stem as an insult Jin Anna yet to be Mythili hadn't Quran so Allah was talking to human that's why it started with them. And he said we have for humans for you. We have brought all kinds of examples. But in so little calf, the suit is talking about the Quran, not that humans, the beginning of the surah is all talking about Al Quran. That's why you start with the Quran in this verse, even though they are very identical. And that will be an actual Rahim Allah said, as I have
seen, and Allah subhanaw taala knows best for those who cares for the the verses the very similar to each other. But there is maybe one or two differences and sometimes very unique why this comes first and comes later. And that's one thing that I've been assured by him a lot care for and his stuff. So anyway, I want to a little bit making a comment on the concept of algebra.
algebra or arguing, arguing? It is it's a big subject and argue Even it is became
a science and art, okay, that people learn and you take a class in debates and
general
generally speaking, arguing, arguing is something discouraging Sharia.
Any when you look at the text, the word jeden argumentation is not something good.
Alibaba Hari Rahim Allah said, there is no better there is no Kufa there is no power there is no banana. There is no Zenda. Okay, came except out of argumentation.
All caused by argument.
So, that's number one. Number two,
agenda. As I said, any two people start arguing with each others in the religion, the end up claiming things in the religion which is not from it. By math. taraka illa. Allah
Hamad bin is a he said that something very similar to that.
Also, Allah Subhana Allah says in the Quran, furnish who have the Mim lukey Roby For ye Nabina, whom Allah Tao Atal Baba, we made them enemy to each other's talk about the children of Israel. And this is sort of the verse 14, Ibrahim in the I said, how Allah turned the children of Israel to fight one another, to hate one another by making them argue with one another.
That's why shediac mainly taken very negative argumentation because it leads to hating each others. And I can tell you that is not a single book almost specially from our traditional books that talk about Islamic creed, unless they have a chapter about the burn reputation and warning from argumentation
are sort of semana de la Kai has a full chapter about that. A Sherry and is a jury and Ivana hakuba Alibaba, German abandoned Elmo probably Kitab al Bukhari alphapay
Daddy aswani de kitabi and he'll jeffie Bian Sunni daddy me and many books of Hadith and Aki, the talk about that. Let's see that and then we continued
along
along
shadow one
Hey,
hey
if you look at the Orion and the student of the processor lab you'll find many versus many ahaadeeth, forbidding and warning us from engaging in any kind of argumentation.
alladhina mujer de Luna de la mujer unison * in
Cabo maakten de la de La Nina Manu. katha Anika ma wanna ad could be Muhtar, Kent bearing
and Sora Trafford verse 35. Look at sort of the short of verse 35 as well. Look at so Blaffer again verse four and verse 56. All of these verses talking about that the kuffaar are the one who like to argue and the argue for the sake of defeating the * and supporting the falsehood
and abuse a lot SLM said, Yeah Isha. If you see those who argue in the Koran and argue about the religion, they are the one alarm mentioned in the Quran shall be aware of them. Without ecola Nina Simone will have a handle on this the one people obey Him say this the one of their heart doubts
and abuse Allah Allah is a lamp when he found that the Sahaba argue over when is laylatul Carter is he was so angry that the extent his face can animate the Philip Kotler development. Man, he became like a perma pro got his face became so read
that and nobody saw them said, Are you been created for that purpose to argue with each other? Is that what I ordered you to be that you argue with each others everyone use a verse against the other. And he was so angry that even Omar said, I never in my life wished that I missed one of the prophets of Salaam gathering except this gathering. I wish that I wasn't with the crowd. I wish I wasn't with the person that time. He was very angry. And he said the most hated person and the first time he didn't say and this also Buhari Muslim, the most hated person to Allah Allah The one who like to argue over everything and very aggressive in their argument when they argue with others
and also incident Abbe de la Mira over puranic of welgedacht over Quranic of those who argue over the Koran and, and and and basically with no knowledge with the no great intention. This is a form of cover. Yeah, and it is the attitude of the kuffar the actions and the way of the
abdomen, Maddy said, I remember all the scholars that I met in my life, they advised us not to argue
the same thing with me Xena at the rockin lol fugly Mina, you have zero nominal gender, as a matter of fact, when he said the different the fundamentals of the Sunnah, the foundation of the sydnor. He said or, and he mentioned following the Companion of the process of them leaving the innovations. Then he said third one and you leave argumentation, you don't argue with albida and don't argue in general. Number five.
At the moment, Baba Rahim Allah summarize it by saying all of them agree that arguing
is not a good quality and arguing over a law's attributes
arguing over the nature of a law is something is forbidden.
This is one side.
And the other side of course answers what Geraldine whom miletti isin and sort of did not argue with them in the best manner.
DeLuca Deltona, Tena
koe, me, we give a Brahim the ability to argue very well
and sorted and am 83 and SoTL bacala 258. He gives us that beautiful debate between Abraham and the king in the mood. He said, If Allah bring the sun from the west from the east, you bring it from the west.
That's an argument. That's right. He argued with his father. He argued his people, they look at these idols, the one the big ones on who, who destroyed them, and sort of the MBR verse 63.
What about the ruleset? Didn't he argue around back and forth?
bolon I mean upon,
it will only be you know who's going to be mean, look at sort of Shara
pannonian oho Khadija dantana fact 30 Donna. No, you argue with us.
And you argue a lot with us and sort of tooth. Verse 2032.
Did in the process of them told us that Adam and Moosa debated one another.
That's arguing.
That's right. And nebia sallallahu wasallam he argue with the Jews, and so he'll Bahati.
And that's something that he mentioned is saying, and showing that arguing with other people is acceptable.
And navies are seldom said jarhead will mushrikeen with your tongue, how would you turn by replying to them arguing with them?
didn't argue with each others. Didn't alcohol debate one another? The Muslim jurist did him in a bass argue the melodic didn't allow and argue with the
defendant. Era hammer home law made a big debate between him and one of the criteria. And Mr. Michel Shafi Rahim Allah debated have so far
in a beautiful debate, and even Ahmed Rahim Allah He argue with the Shu bohart the doubts of the Jamia
When will we do with all this?
Said Mara to a hidden la harijan in the academy, Jamia and Kenny, I have not seen a young man who argue with people who are more experienced than him and was that person became so smart.
So, what do we do?
If nillkin Rahim Allah brought some of this evidence and more. And he said look at this, this is like two oceans of evidence facing one another, like two big waves crashing each other.
In order for you to understand how to to basically understand this, you will know that
I will just give you the summary of it. Arguing is based on two things.
intention and the way you argue
with sila when Ian because we always argue with each others and pay attention to this. So if this is two things, that means Alkis MANOVA yet means you have four scenarios, that's right.
So, here,
we say that arguing either for truth,
you argue for the truth,
by the truth.
Learn how to build up. So, then intention is correct. And the way you are you is correct it for for truth
or you are you for something invalid something falsehood, using a falsehood arguing or argumentation
using a falsehood,
arguing
agency phenomenon
and to judge a bill Botha Lille battle.
So you're arguing with falsehood for falses you argue with truth for the truth, the truth
The third, can anybody think of the third scenario?
You argue with the truth for the falsehood,
or you argue with false hood for the truth. Make sense?
Makes sense. To Jad This will help will help build Babel Babel will help
build Babel and how you argue with truth for the truth. You argue with falsehood for the falsehood. You argue with falsehood for the truth. You argue for? Would you argue with truth for the false?
Give you break it down? First one, you argue for the truth with the truth. This one? I have a question for you guys. Before I go farther from these four, which one you think a Sherry appraise? And which one should I criticize?
Praise Number Number one, and the other three are something criticize something not good? That's right. That's right. You agree? I agree with you, but I will say not 100%. I will say even number one, number one is not fully praised, believe it or not.
Number one, you argue for the truth with the truth. Allah said with the condition. Is that kind of Muslim Raja, if there is a greater benefit?
Ha, they said yes. Like what? learning?
I argue with my share, because I want to learn, I will do the devil out of the desert, or take the other position just to know how to answer this. That's what one of the guys is praised.
Another scenario, which is acceptable, you argue with the truth for the truth, when you argue,
when the judge argue with that criminal, when the judge, let's say, somebody came in front of the judge, he was accused, that this person is said, a statement that take him out of Islam. The judge has to back and forth with that person asking him, why did he say that tried to convince him to repent? Like, what didn't I bastard with the karate, or when you debate someone, basically, before you apply the judgment, so and he did this before he fought alcoholic disease, debated and debated the country before I'm gonna resist excuted that man, he wants to give him a fair chance, a trial.
So that's that that debate took place with the innovators. But when there is no great benefit, actually there is risk, even if you argue with the truth for the truth. LMR Allah said you cannot argue like what
modality if it is someone who wants to go into a debate or want to argue with someone and you're not a good debater?
Even though you're going to use the correct evidence and your intention is good, but you're weak you don't know how to argue you don't know how to win a debate in this case be quiet because you might mislead others
you don't know how to answer is like this guy wasn't in yet Rice University that day. Somebody was telling him Oh, the prophet the Prophet married this number is another prophet on the medic one woman
a married nine isn't each one of them died then he met a doctor on the divorce.
That's even not a good example because he argued with the false hope because you're arguing with the weak but I mean, someone is so he doesn't know how to present themselves that is very not not right. Also any arguing even with the truth for the truth, but there is no benefit from it. And this is became very common among the fuqaha
at one point, like for example there is this whole debate over do you pray to the camera or to the foundation of the Kaaba.
Okay, so what's the point from all this debate? They said, if the cabinet decide to walk away
the habit I had earlier
and I'm quoting, said a camera designed to go visit one of the laws Willy righteous. Do you follow the camera when it's walking? Worry, stay on the camera.
I mean, that's ridiculous. That's unacceptable.
Okay. For example, they raised a question if a man for somehow
He is a man but get pregnant and get a child
and die. Does the child inherit this as a father or a narrative as a mother?
And you get all this arguing over stuff like that? That's
not acceptable.
Yeah, stuff like that. Someone asked me questions that most likely is somebody telling me share? What about me a praying and the top of Aqaba? Yeah, you didn't go to my cave. And yet in your life, you talk about if I'm the top of Aqaba how to pray, or I am in the moon or something like that.
So this is in this case, argumentation here is Mira is been recommended for enough to engage in it. The second one is to argue for the false hood with the false. And that's what the Quran mentioned right after that, what Giada Lu will tell you, they will have the argue with the full sword to defeat the truth.
And this is like the albida, the innovators the kuffaar mushrikeen. When they defend their data and their data, the third one, you argue with the truth for the falsehood.
You argue with the truth, but for the false, like those who argue to show they're to basically stretch their muscles to show that the wind debate, because they used to get gifts from governments in the old days, and the whatever and so for so those people yes, they use right evidence correct method, but their intention is corrupted. And those people they might Allah bring good through them. Because Allah bring victory to Islam through even badger. But they that's wrong. And the last one is very, very important.
It is arguing with the false hood for the truth.
And that's many of them will tell you I like that.
You have people argue with that with the Mattila. But with the false with the without Derby, the abit beta, they refuse with their with another bidder. That's absolutely not acceptable, to make up Hadith to make up
rules, and that's the door which is when it was open. A lot of bedeck came into Islam, because people thought because their intention is good. They want to refute the the disbelievers or they want to refute the atheist. So they start making up their own rules. And that's their intention is good, but it became a bit distorted in the religion. And I will end up with this very famous debater in the West here, was doing a debate in Canada. And in the debate the person who was debating him, Professor, he raised something about a patent against that person. So that person in the debate said, Oh,
I got your point. I don't think Allah knows everything before it happened.
He said, I think God only knows things before it happened. Generally, not specifically.
He came up with that. And he was able to refute that claim at that point, even though it's weak, but he maybe got out of the point. But he used falsehood
to refute that atheist, who basically tried to raise doubt about voluntary Islam. Not because he went that maybe debate or that point, it means you correct. And guess what this particular incident led that person later on, to be very far away from the sun, and he left the Center for a very long time. hamdulillah lately start coming back as a good friend of mine and I, I love this person for the sake of Allah. And I had a lot of talk with him about but he ended up in the areas far away. And that's that's very dangerous to argue for the truth with that falsehood.
Say todo Rahim, Allah has a very good example he used to say, he said that.
If you see a beautiful garden, and you want to walk through it, you can walk through to the muddy feet. Will you leave your foot footprint with your mud all over this beautiful garden? What do you do you make the garden looks ugly, it looks bad.
You know, and that's exactly the way people when they have good intention, but they do things in the wrong way. You have to have the good intention and you have to have the right course of action. May Allah subhanaw taala in Fukuoka Jaco and if this is
Then clear, you understand why in real America law generally speaking, they don't like arguing because from the four scenarios three are bad and the only one left half good and half bad.
So that means that this door should be almost closed and you should be very careful with that concept of argument any nation as of the process of them said, it starts to argue and not doing actions, Allah destroy them. And that would happen a lot in our community. We still argue a lot and we do a little
and any there is more to be said inshallah. Hopefully, in the upcoming classes, Zack will have here with Santa Monica