Channel: Waleed Basyouni
Bulugh Al Maram Series presented by Sh Waleed Basyouni at the Clear Lake Islamic Center
This lecture was presented on May 03, 2017.
© No part of this transcript may be copied or referenced or transmitted in any way whatsoever. Transcripts are auto-generated and thus will be be inaccurate. We are working on a system to allow volunteers to edit transcripts in a controlled system.
How do you shadow the alarm?
How did the Java added
salam alaikum everybody
are you guys doing?
Um the law sisters? You can come in if you guys want to join us
inside the prayer
smilla we're going to be reading a hadith the 24 Hadith. Amato, inheritor
alimony for him. Oh la Giada
niharika toda la Hakata havanna Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam send them or be meaner. Well who? out I hit it. Well, Laura boo ha sido Allah KTV Hello Joe medulla tirmidhi you are Saha
narrated American college are rhodiola on Allah's Messenger sallallahu alayhi wa sallam delivered a football religious talk to us at Mina wall mounted on his camel and its saliva was pouring on my shoulders reported by asthma then a telemovie and a ladder graded it so he sound
now smilla hamdulillah salat wa salam ala rasulillah
anybody remember what was the last Hadith is about
Berry to Sabbath another
what was the last Hadith is about
basically silver to the cup to the profits or salons when his club crack
and he filled it up
the donkeys I taught this when I was in Toronto, you remember? Okay, so the last hand It was about the perturbation of eating the donkeys meet. And we said because of Rahim Allah consider it nudges regice rich and he considered something is unlawful because it is nudges according to some of them, and we talked about this last time.
the other Hadith that came after, it's about an abuse of alcohol. He was a lamb's camel, and it is your ABA, it is basically saliva
touching this man's hand. So what this has this has it has to do with izannah to adjust. First of all the Hadith reported by Ahmad openhearted out of the allow an American Khadija
who will be happy
actually means from the south end millionen to SD and he is headed for Abu sufian
Abu sufian center sent him to the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam in the incident.
Today via when or even before in fact, the mecca when Abu sufian sent someone to the Prophet Assam to talk to him, he sent a model of inheritor and
he doesn't have many of the Hadith and to be Salalah UID or sudden them reported from him. This Hadith did niharika very famous that he said I was with the prophets Allah suddenly in Mina during HUD when the process of delivering his huduma to us while mounted on his camel, and its saliva was pouring on my shoulder. As you heard the losses reported by ashmit and intermediate and intermediate considering considerate authentic. Howdy.
Maybe it is authentic by looking at the different narrations and joining them together. Heather hannity oconus ohana didomi
Maria de ba ba, ba ba, ba, ba ba ba ba ba because that is not the chain of narration that mentioned by Amanda telemedia Oshima, Hola. And it's someone who's considered weak, even though he's a very famous Adams color. His name is sharp I've been How
have you ever heard this name before? sharp event? How shall
Majority of Rocky Mohamad law considered him weak but an amendment to the media Rahim Allah consider his Hadith acceptable and he will categorize this hadith as authentic
he said that a Hema hola Khalid Mohammed when he said Mohammed said he means that Buhari and Mohammed bin Ismail Bukhari he said Allah Mohammed
Shah Hassan Hadith, this hadith is Hassan and the word has said of Hadith. Here it means it is acceptable if it is combined by other narrator by by itself is not Hassani acceptable according to the earlier Hadith well wa Hadith in limited media Rahim Allah, He said that an amendment Buhari consider him strong. And he said tirmidhi were in the medical lemma fee happening.
He said the only one criticize him his own. Well, cadra and
the given hour narrated from him but through not directly. So it means Eben Allen left him to regenerate directly from him. For other reason, then what, then him being trustworthy narrator sometimes, will not narrate directly from a man.
Not because they don't trust his narration, not because they don't trust his memory for other reasons. Like what?
Can you imagine why he wouldn't narrate this from him directly.
Even though he might not have a problem with his memory.
Maybe because his manners. What do you mean by manners?
Maybe there is something known about this man, that if I read directly from him, it will make him famous.
Yeah, and he wouldn't have had it from someone might not associate with
it. Maybe it's not worth that title.
He doesn't want the students to go to him. He doesn't want to make him famous. So he will not read directly from him.
So what is that share of Niihau, which I've had that lead some of the amount of him a lot to avoid him.
Female but the metal among Muslims Muslim llamada Kershaw on NASA cu.
Anybody knows what that word means? NASA cu,
Anyone can guess wild? Yes.
I don't think anybody will be able to get it. nessa Kuya and yamo, who've been NASDAQ
and NASDAQ, it means the falling star, nessa Kuya Annie, as of the short term would the star who do you shoot with the star?
The shale team.
So it's a very strong word of saying that this person is not worthy, or the shale thing and also steal the word and add to it so it's not line. So when he said there's a cool robot named Zack Yeah, and they are considering him very bad. So it's a very strong word. They're saying that is not worth it. But look
Eman Muslim Rahim. Allah, he said, they said naza ku they said that he's worth to be shot with the star. Okay, so they it shows that he's not really taking that position. Because allama Rahim Allah debated overshadowed nowship, some of them have very negative view of him. And some of them have very positive view from
those who have very negative view of him, accused him with things allow them like for example, they the most famous I don't have ever heard that the most famous things
that the story that he stole, he took from vital man courier
commerce via Legion mafia man pouch. He was in charge of the Muslim Treasury for the care for the city where he lived in Alabama. And basically he's in charge of the Treasury. And he said that he was found stealing from the money
and he took a pouch
This is well identified from the Attractor Factor the harriton fee had arrived. It has some servers
bah bah bah Sharon Dena who Bihari Putin. familia Manuel Cora.
They said in the poetry, if shop, can sell his own religion, his own honesty and trustworthiness for few Durham's few pieces of Silver's, who's among the among the hafod among who knows the Quran can be saved. Why because Shahab was known to be a great candidate for an OSHA, OSHA Corrado Khurana, a been a bass sabarimala.
He read the whole entire Qur'an would have been about seven times baccara Al Quran, Allah Omar and he read the Quran with Omar.
So he's a well known Yanni Mujahideen been
about four times harder seven times.
So that means that this is a very high caliber. So for them to say that when he said who can be saved after you at that happy Rahim, Allah said, this story, the chain of narration for this story that is not of this story is when Tata is not complete, there is weakness in it. But it might have maybe Tappan Allah, Allah Allah, because it's very famous, and he repented from it. Or maybe he took that pouch of money,
because he have a justification for it. Who knows, because as we know, those who are in charge of the Treasury, they have power over the money. So maybe he took it with honesty and justification. We asked a lot to forgive him. That what he said, as a comment on the story.
But there is another story of him.
That yahia upon said that about the human soul said
that I traveled with him once sharp, New Hampshire.
And he took something from me from my belonging sarafa IBT. He took something belongs to me, and he took it.
And he said, I can't say anything about this. I don't know what to say about this kind of imaginary malcode Avada.
Anyway, what it looks like that these either claim from people who are in the same level as him, but many of them are not considered these stories or stories, no proof for it.
we consider him trustworthy.
And you see him a whole lot did not consider him someone who should be left completely.
Allegedly no near any of authenticating
people who are not very strong, he said the sticker.
And in Maine was a great scholar of heavy Thiessen theft, trustworthy
and I like what Abou arogya Hola Hola. And many other like in nessa even this is very strict. They said Lavazza be
Yeah. And he is acceptable.
Whenever he needed to head it is acceptable. That's why they're happy Rahim Allah mentioned what jacoba sofiane said even people claim things about him and have been around criticize him but he is still
and they have a comment on. Yeah, province of Dan's
statement. He said
no doubt that this person is that the truthful side of where we're at him and has knowledge and will try to be hematology and you can accept his narration. But what I his Hadith cannot by itself reach to be authentic. It needs someone to back it up. And no doubt that this Hadith, the snad this hadith has a lot of backup, okay.
Especially sometimes he will narrated it in any as a statement from him that this has happened to the process and sometimes he will give that is the name of the habit of the line.
I just added this because sometimes I like an hour studying of kuttabul or murghab, sometimes to give you a little bit of how Allah speak about the Hadith and I saw a need and the debate about a region. So you kind of get a little bit of glimpse of animate Hadith, not only the physical body, but also an assignee at region and so forth.
what this had, he says, he said, hamana, he gives us hope. And this is the hope but a nice demeanor.
Hajin nebby sallallahu alayhi wa alayhi wa sallam, according to some scholars, he said, This is the hopa that he give when he was about to sacrifice to teach people how to sacrifice. Other people said no, maybe this whole debate took place in Mena, winning maybe somewhat addressing the companion just giving them a general talk. There is no proof for that. Why in the village of Santa mounded his camel, anybody can guess? Why never saw him give the speech while he's on the top of his camel
Because he doesn't have anything already, he can stand up on on the floor on the ground.
Why would he need to stand up on top of something
for people to see him a lifetime ad, so people can see him? Why? because it'd be so seldom said, who do any man.
copy me. That's when there is a myth off on his camera. Image, say on his camels awesome. So people can see him. Because if he's just walking with them on the car, but nobody will see him too many people. That's why he was very distinguished allow audio. It was like, Yeah, I need the saliva of that. camel.
Why would he mentioned this hadith in the chapter about ban adjusted ban? Is that an agenda? Wa hoekman? Why would he give this hadith when he talks about impurity?
So he talked previously about the donkeys that is ninjas, and the dogs are, according to him as well. So here he's talking about how that camels are not dangerous. So don't think all animals are ninjas. Okay. And anything that we we eat, anything that we eat, it is not nudges anything that you're allowed to eat certain ages. So the saliva of the camel we're allowed to eat is not
the same thing to saliva of
cows or sheep or goats or anything like that. So this is Rahim. Hello, Donna. He want to make that point. You know, the Sharia says
that anything that you eat, okay? Even if you eat it, it's your own considered nudges.
Okay, but that's the Shafi is position. But the Hannah Bella said no, the urine of the animal that you eat is not nudges.
So the urine of the cow the urine of the camel is not nudges.
They will say that the saliva and the urine is not measured. Why? So they said that the urine of the camels not just because it'd be subtle allow you it was a lamp. He said about the urine of the camels, that it is the law and it he'll TEALS that's why they'll be selasa lamb order some people to use the urine of the camels for healing.
And if it's not just an episode will not allow them to touch it and to use it and put it in their bodies.
Some people get you know, I remember somebody was telling me Oh, this is so disgusting. A
Yeah, any healing in the urine. What kind of nonsense is that?
The nonsense zoo.
The nonsense zoo. who's saying that?
Because that same person. This is someone I know.
I told him about a friend of mine
in Saudi Arabia.
Not a friend of mine.
His family is a big investor.
So there are basically sponsoring this lady who doing a research. She's a scientist. She's doing her PhD on the urine of the camel.
And give her for her search, a million dollar sponsor,
as my friend, like, I'm talking to the one who gave her the money.
So they spend a million dollars on the year and the research that she's making.
Then all sudden, after several months, she returned back the million dollars to them the check and said, Thank you.
I'm out of the deal.
Why? Because the German, a German company came and they gave her $10 million
for her search.
And there are parts of what they call the Saudi German hospital.
give her $10 million for her search. And they said we are going way more than that if you need it.
Because what she found, she found a lot of interesting, you know,
results of analyzing the urine of the camel, and how it can be used in modern medicine today.
And especially for diabetes and things of that nature. So when I said that to the person, oh, Mashallah the switch,
which is I understand, if it's just the ignorant of not knowing how the Hadith works, I understand. But sometimes it is the doubt in the heart that we believe the German company model.
And that's a sad,
if you don't understand or it feels to you that this doesn't make much sense.
You need immediately to accuse your own understanding, before you accuse the prophets of Allah. Especially if we know that the Hadith is authentic,
either had to come and Rasulullah sallallahu Sallam for whom will be he led you Ana De La Jolla, Alon. Whenever you hear how did I never saw some of them? You always think of it as the best way. That's what the end of the line said. You don't think of it the worst possible way. You always think of it the most positive possible. And if you couldn't, you accuse your own
anchor. I'm not saying cancel your anchor. No, there is like two extremes here. We're not saying don't think Don't be an analytical, non be critical. Ask but don't object, raise the question. But there is a difference between raising a question and questioning something and raising doubts and accusation there is a big difference between the two.
Say, I would like to research this more I would like to look into this more.
Just didn't go and and basically raise the doubt on the whole entire sun of Rasulullah sallallahu sallam.
That's a nonsense that's not accurate because if you know that, that's what the process of him said.
And then there is a southern lion decline in how he doesn't speak from his desire or from ignorant.
He speaks from knowledge
that comes from Allah. So you have to be me to be very careful how you respond to what you hear in the Quran and the Sunnah of the Prophet sallallahu sallam, because
you have very limited knowledge or focus only the admin area above every person of knowledge that is, someone has more knowledge than him.
And true scientists, true scientists. They never ever said that's it, then you that there is more than they don't know than what they know. And that's a common theme between any scientists. You ask any scientist, he will always tell you that what we don't know is much bigger than what we know. No matter how much you know.
Roger manda holofil l
lm three stages manda smithton. If any man no Jai. When you reach to the top, you realize that you're ignorant.
The more knowledge you have, the more
you realize that you don't have much of knowledge.
Anyway, so that's why he brought this handy the next
one, I shall have the alarm on palatka
Also in law his alma mater, he was sending them
money to Morocco in a sauna TV danika So, while Anna unburrow in a 30 loss leafy
be rasuna forca for use on leafy orfila for Lila leopard going to
be some beautiful Freeman will be
narrated, I shared the low on Allah messenger sallallahu alayhi wa sallam used to wash the semen and then go out to prayer and that very garment, and I could still see the trace of the washing on it agreed upon and the version of Muslim I used to scrape it. The semen off the garment of Allah's Messenger sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, and then he and then he offered prayer with it. In yet another version of Muslim verily, I Ayesha used to scrape it the semen off his garment with my nails while it was dry.
this have Ethan is authentic hadith Is this your hottie one Muslim and other generation and Muslim.
This headset has a story
actually reported this headed after an incident one of her relatives was sleeping in her house.
And he had a weird dream.
So in the morning, he tried to return the cover
with the trace of the semen and
so he washed the whole thing.
And then she said to him, why did you wash it?
Remember, in the old days, the water is very limited, and it's a big deal to bring water to the house.
She said Why did you wash for? He said I had a wet dream.
So I had to wash it because it has a trace of my semen and then she said you would have needed it to do that. Would it be enough for you? Just to scrub it.
Then she knows
that she said that in a very subtle Allahu Allahu alayhi wa sallam. I used to basically scrub the semen of the garment of the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam
and he would offer pray with it. So he was she was she reiterated this hadith as a comment on this incident.
The story was narrated in other than in barrio Muslim.
What's the benefit of this story? The benefit of this story to reject the idea that in every cell allowed to sell them semen and
in every cell allowed to sell lambs. sperm is different than anyone else of human
of other humans. Because some people have said that didn't have to be salaallah xlm semen is pure, while other people semen is not part of how the husband Navy Salah lights on some of the acid because in obese Assalam semen is pure while any other humans other than the process alone is not the said that's why in a B cell Eliza Lanza urine and individual solid blood is not matches.
Some people said that and they said even the promise of solemn feast is not magic.
They said that's why it's observed by the ground otherwise it's not an individual solemn pure, a lot pure a pure him. So he's completely pure.
And that's exaggerations, no proof for it.
And this understanding is not the understanding of the law and
she did not understand that the prophets of Salaam semen are
many is only from the prophets of Salaam and
doesn't take the ruling will not apply to other than Him because she applied the same rule to the process of him seeming to that Mansi That's right. So that just mentioned that to reject that notion.
Here he used the Hadeeth has three words. The first narration said Alice wash,
but the other two generations use two different words.
And in English, the put one word for it which is scrub, to scrub it
to scrub that
the semen off scrubbing it
is one word or you can also use what other words like
scrubbed, scrape, sanding,
scrub with water, a scrape, dry
scrape. Also there is another word which is you could ticklish
duck, which is
to rub something rubbing it.
In the Arabic language, we have something called Falak. And something is called hack.
And in English he put the same translation, scrape, but in Arabic and heck, Wilfork is a different, what's the different alforque when you bring a piece of garment altogether and you start basically rubbing it together.
So Bill traffic, like you bring like this, and you bring it the whole thing and you put it like this and you start cleaning it dry or with water, it doesn't matter. You bring the whole thing or you start cleaning it. But I'll have one team in Jatin wahida be doing a gentleman hacking Arabic language is to scrape which is basically you see where's that here and you start cleaning that part without bringing the rest of the clothes together or the garment well that's
why I'm saying this because this headin shows you a little bit of a different approach of how she dealt with it. Especially when it is dry. In one place, she will just scrape it and take it off with her nails or the allow on how Allah
will talk about the ruling in a little bit.
As many sperm or semen
Hadid speaks about a semen
that for men and for a woman
the semen of the men is made of a combination of
two things together. Liquid
and whether it is that hairnet admin UI, and would you call it
the sperm with a discharge come from or liquid come from the broodstock you mix them together, that's became that simple. You mix these two together and basically
the meat and that what's the semen of that men?
For a woman, they have the same liquid, but without the sperm
that call that basically that the men have.
So that liquid for the woman in Nabi sallallahu Sallam said in men, it's thick, and it is white. For a woman, he said, it is colored like a yellowish colored and not a clear color, but has a yellowish in it and it is not thing
which is that witness or the discharges, that comes from some woman or a woman they have this when they reach the climax and woman are very different than this. Some of them have, they basically this charges can be strong, and some of them can be way lesser, some of them cannot even feel it and some of them can feel it strong, coming out of her body. But there is a major difference between the men and woman, that the men they shoot it out in a good large of quantity, young life, but women do not come to dufka do not comes in the same manner. The sperm comes from the men, but both share the fact that they come when they reach the climax when it reached an orgasm. That's when basically we have
this discharge comes and this charge when it comes as in Nabi sallallahu Sallam said or mount will model it rocky upon us from head to toe masala niharika Muslim and Matt are virtually vile, even abbiati It's a thick white for the men and it is
yellowish and not thick when it comes to woman
and and know your Rahim Allah, Allah. He said that the sperm of men has three qualities
Comes with orgasm, reaching high climax, it comes strong out of the body. And number three has a smell, strong smell. He said as for the woman have to
it has a smell into it. And it comes with joy when when when the woman reached the climax or reach an orgasm, but it doesn't come in the same nature of the sperm of the men, which it comes a strong out of the body. So that's when you look at it asked for this is many, that is something else to call and maybe I don't have ever heard of that word. And many people said protostar discharge, but added many what's in it. And many it is an A type of discharge that comes when the person thinking about intimacy
or about intimate and these are discharges that comes prior to basically the sperm coming out. And maybe that's what you know, because some I was reading
unique character and learn a little bit about this I'll tell you why. That's parallel you know when a person urinate, that urine is an acid.
So, the body will produce this this chart to clear any trace of acid in the
men's genital because if any acid remain there, which is not supposed to be but if there is any acid remainder will kill all your sperm.
But unless you have to add I make this discharge come first. So it will clear the way 100% it's obviously it's clear, but this is extra
to make sure there is nothing well harm your sperm when it comes out. Anyway, so that discharge that comes comes sometimes out of thinking even if it does not follow the by sexual activity or followed by that semen
and that does not comes strong. Okay, does not comes when a person reach climax or reach earner orgasm. No, it comes just because of thoughts. Okay. And it is in knowing that it's in woman way more than men. Usually woman experienced that this witness way more than men.
There is another word. I want you to be also familiar with it called a lady. She have many, many wedding Wednesday, and Wednesday. It is also a discharge thick. This chart comes after urine.
Okay, and it's white, and it's color. When a person finished urinating urinating, that's this charge comes out.
What's the rule in regard to these three?
When if you find it, it means you have to have a shower.
If it comes out of intimacy or with dream, men or woman doesn't make a difference.
As for elementary, which comes out of thoughts, sexual thoughts, only break your window and you make over and in there be sallallahu alayhi wa sallam he said to add to the long run. He didn't say directly to Addy Addy. Married to whom?
To father an ad he said control Raja muda I used to have maybe Allah is discharged a lot which comes in sexual thought. But because I am his son in law, I can say this to the process of that it's embarrassing.
I asked his dad
to ask Leo as
an official allow them about this liquid
come to the risk free college Sharia
for adolescent a Jaffa
Maha de sac and many more who did not have
from the side by side? Who is the one who asked the question men
sidewalk I like to
sleep in amongst. It just doesn't make much sense in English like I asked Who is the one who asked the question.
The students thought I'm asking about the liquid. And because Sal can be means a person who asked the question and sat means liquid in the same time but in context, obviously you can tell. And going back to the Hadith said the prophets of Salaam said fee who you should make over from it. Phil Bahati will Muslim. Also an amount of him I'm allowed to Allah said that when this comes you
so that's required to law gnosis and Wedi which is basically comes right after urine, obviously after makeover because he just urinated doesn't comes later on just right after all,
as many as we can to learn is pure buyer. What is the niches
and many style is pure as you're gonna learn right now. And maybe nudges is impure. That's why I live Navy pilot when he asked me not to ask the prophets of Salaam, what the prophet said he said it will send that Caraco
wash your genital and wash your testicles
That's why I also
want to see it and make Google commander.
So that means it is not just that's waiting to be auditor them to wash.
But this Naja is not. Major. It's it's minor, lighter, majestic.
That's why nebby sallallahu alayhi wa sallam. He said yeah, and you can when he said, you're sort of lucky for us like the mail. See, when we told you what I do with my clothes, my underwear. Then individual salami said, you put your hand in a cup of water like and he put the water like exam, and he just throw it on your clothes, you do need to wash because then a jassa is not major.
asked for a wedding. It snatches it exactly the same urine rules. So a lady that comes after the urinating, it just matches.
I want you to understand there is a difference between an ad, which is that liquid that white liquid that comes after we finished urinating, and some that called sellers elbowed sellers and vote when a person has no control over his urine. So he finished urinating, but later on drop of urine keep coming.
Okay, these drop of urine that comes later on even sometimes after a minute or half a minute or two minutes. What, by the way, one of the reason for people to do to get that because when they urinate, especially men, sometimes what they do, they start squeezing their genitals to make sure that everything comes out. First of all, that's not from the sun. And those some hats that you should squeeze your genital after you finish university, all these innovations. There's nothing in religion ask us to do that. As a matter of fact, that squeezing a chicken sandwich like mama said, Who can stand up, it's like, you know, when you milk the cow, the more you squeezed, the more you basically
became weak and it comes out. So you should just wait until it's finished. And that's it. But what if after a minute or two, I have some people have no control over and remember him Allah said that even though it is urine and it's not just but this forgiving because of this is considered like a form of sickness. God no calimary like someone have no control over gas. Some people there's always gas coming out of their bottom. They have no control over those people. They're not breaking the vote by this gas that's coming out of them because they can't control so they became forgiving. The same thing with that you're
so what this hadith
is for this heady memory Allah mentioned it to talk about the ruling of alimony is it nudges or not? And how can you remove it? If it's not just or not? What's the deal with it? How can you clean it?
If you look at this Hadith, and father, Hadith, the way it was narrated, the first one, he said the generations that actually used to wash them
Tell Cyril, what are
this narration that she used to wash it?
And many nudges Naga salad.
So because of this narration that used to wash it, it means legis That's why she washed it. You only wash what is natural.
But if you look to the other narration, you know that she didn't just she didn't wash it because of it is impure.
She washed it for other reasons. How do you know because in the other nation, she said, couldn't do a Haku come to Africa. I used to basically rub it off. scribe it, scraper scrape, scrape, scrape, scrape it all.
scrape it, it means is with her nails. She didn't use water.
scraping it shows you that she didn't wash it like ninjas. If it ninjas you're gonna scrape it with your nails.
Because that means it's mixed with that fabric. So if you missed the fabric, and it's not just you have to wash it. If I give you example, if there is a faeces on the garment. Can you just describe it with your nail now? On colosse No, you have to wash it. So if this many of this sperm was not just scraping it was not wouldn't be enough. Basically robbing it, it will be not enough if it's ninjas, so since he did not wash it with water, it is very clear evidence that it's what
it's what pure w might say share. It is okay to leave impurity and the close.
You don't have to clean it right away.
I said yes. But can you pray with NASA?
No, that's right. And she said in the Hadith, he used to go to the salon.
Because you can if you have an agenda in your clothes, you don't have to wash it right away. Let's say her blood in your clothes and you believe the blood is nudges. You don't need to go to war straightaway.
So just because of the stand in the fell but doesn't mean it's nudges but it means it means it's pure, but since he pray in it, it means it's pure.
Baba is clear in the huddle.
So, since she is
basically rubber and didn't wash it, it means it is
Pure and it's not something impure. And in the other ration she washed it not because it's just but because it is Mr. Duck that it is it is disgusting.
You know, can you imagine seeing the stain of the sperm or the smell of it, you know, it's not something pleasant. It's not appropriate. So she cleaned it and read American law said Like what? Like when you have for example the
the stain comes out of your nose like if somebody pokes his nose and like there's like you know the mucus, whatever, or from your throat and it's like has a green stain in your clothes or you wash it off not because it's nudges. Nobody ever said these nudges the spit and come whatever comes from your nose. Because it is disgusting. That's right. So that's why is she washed throw the flower unhappy? What are
those who said and many is the sperm is fewer.
Many of the companions stated that like I should have been cited to be what are some of the ally line?
added it'd be a thought.
And among those who said it's pure from the tablet in hustle bustle, he said he didn't miss a alpha and great amount like his half normal how he would sell that would avahi Shafi remember shafia Rahim Allah and one eration from alma mater him Omar lighter than technovation chosen and also this the position chosen by many over the mountain without putting in like a metal pie em had been Tamia Sinani large number of
those who said the snatches the sperm isn't edges
will be people like who, luckily women outside and Emma Malik, Lima Malik that is to generation one generation that he said it's not nudges.
And some of the Maliki has said no shad that sweet generation, some consider, but the famous position the madikwe notes nudges. Also Abu hanifa Rahim Allah The Hanafi doesn't believe that it is pure
and the people of Kufa so you have a good split here.
And a memorable hanifa Rahim Allah has an interesting disease in its niches. But he didn't need to wash it.
Is it enough to scrub it or to rub it? Like, like I should? He goes it literally the but he's still considered nudges. Malik said no.
Remember any facility if it's wet, you have to wash it. But if it dry out, you just scrub it out. And that will be enough. But remember, Malik said, No, you have to wash it doesn't matter if it's dry or wet.
What's the evidence? One of the interesting points here I want to say or maybe share it with you some of it. What am Rahim Allah said in his book, but there are a lot. It's one of the great amazing books written by millbay Rahim Allah.
the third chapter, he mentioned a manava a debate between one family who said and many is thought and another family said it's
maybe didn't happen, or he imagined it. And he puts their evidence together. So let's show you the debate. Okay, Nikita come she Amina manava
he said Rahim Allah tala. It's a very long one so you can look it up if you want. Google.
The first one who said it's pure Carlisle many uma Hello kill Basha for Kenapa here on cateura.
Since Allah created human,
the whole race of human made of clay
and clay is pure. Also the individuals are like Adam was made from Torah, dust, and it is pure. And also us made from the sperm and that must be pure as well.
But the one who believe and many is not pure said. No, you can MIT you cannot make an analogy between sand clay and sperm. Clay is something that we use to purify ourselves.
are purify utensils with? Okay? But and many is something we purify ourself from it?
How can you make them both the same.
And he said
that basically, this, they have a very strange understanding of what alimony is, what the sperm is alpha, because they're not doctors, they don't know biology, or human beings by that time. So I thought that and many is a blood and that blood transfer through a certain process to be many. That's why also the believe the milk that woman produced the breast milk is a blood and that blood change to what I think the the thinking of like how we have the cell, the cells inside your body and the blood basic nurture them. So that's what is basically your body's start producing all this stuff. So the the look at the blood as the secret behind life. So they think this is the source of
everything. So anyway, so the set.
So since the money comes from blood, so it must the source of it is something not just which is the blood. So the money also, isn't it?
So the one who said No, that doesn't make any sense. He said, it makes no sense what you said. Why? Because something can be at one form.
That then became good. At one form, it could be niches, and it became pure.
He said look at the grape
juice. It's good and pure. But when it turned to him or wine and became medicine bad.
He said, look at the food
that you consume,
at the start something pure and good and ended up thesis nudges to spread.
And the water became urine. He said so it doesn't mean that it doesn't mean start one way it can end up the same way. So this is basically a change. And he said also look at the blood in the mother's womb, turned to a baby from blood, which is nudges, to turn to be something may not nudges which is that baby? And he said if you look at the sperm, if you say the sperm comes from blood, and since the blood is not just what it became, which is the sperm is also that means you should say that the sperm become a human. So the human must be nervous as well. If you're going to use this logic, we're going to say that this is a nobody would say that.
They said that would make no sense.
And he said as for saying
It is not just because we have to wash our body from it.
He said there is no connection between the shower and the purity or the impurity.
When you would have intercourse without ejaculation, you take a shower not?
Absolutely not because your genital is or your private parts is not just
as another reason behind that which is Allah Subhana Allah have made that shower obligatory. That's why you make Hulu
you don't make it because something new just came out of you. Do you?
Do you make a vote because something that just came out of you.
Abdullah said now sama said yes.
You go to the bathroom, but you can do three things in the bathroom. You can urinate
sama, hold on, you can urinate you can
And you can
filth, feces, passing guys is gas. And that air that comes from the Amish, is that nudges?
Nobody ever said isn't that just because of someone, every time that you release gas in your car seat, you go wash your car seat.
Everybody you pass gas in your underwear, you have to wash your underwear. Nobody ever said that. So not everything that require from you to make. It's the result of an adjustment. So he said, so the Shetty I wanted us to take Listen, is not the result of that majestic result of certain actions. I'm just telling you a summary of the debate.
Then he said the one who believe it's nudges, he said, and maybe, and maybe which is, comes right before and many
talked about earlier, is nudges, isn't it? Everybody agrees to nudges. So if the beginning of it is nudges, how come the following is not nudges?
That's basically this. This is the argue of the Hanafi. And the people.
Then the one who said no, it's not nudges, he said, Who told you and many and many have the same ruling.
They don't have the same color.
They don't have the same look. They don't have the same feeling. They don't have that they don't come in the same manner.
There are different from all aspects.
And in Ibiza, Salim said about money that you wash it, and you make money from it. But and many, he didn't say you wash it, but he said you take shower from it. So he said how can you make them similar? He said, Those who said it's not No. He said to the one who's used this evidence? He said it's not correct. And he said, Who told you that? Because something comes first it means the following is going to be take the same ruling.
He said, Don't you see the milk?
comes in bainer office in with them comes between the blood of the animals and the filth of the animals comes milk.
Then he said
the one who said it's not just like the henna fees, and the mannequins said because it comes from the same place where the urine comes from.
So it must be mixed with the urine. So that's why it is
obviously medically of no pain didn't mention that because he doesn't know that. But medically in modern days, that makes no sense. Because when the many the sperm runs through the genital of the the person, the human, there is no traces of urine. Otherwise it will kill all your sperm.
So that's typically not correct, medically. But so there is no urine First of all, but they said they come from the same place. So that means they have to be nudges. We go back to that gas example, comes from the same place with the filth comes, it doesn't mean that they are nudges.
That's right. So
that throw up is nudges.
But the spec does not come both comes from your mouth. So that concept can be can come from the same place. It means taking the same rules is not is not religiously, nor it is logically make any sense.
Any different debate is so long. Those who said it's not nudges and they said it's pure. They said
Allah Subhana Allah made us out of
And it's impossible to imagine that what you were made of, is something impure.
Then the set of images, can you imagine that you say that Mohammed was made out of something nudges?
Can you imagine that Mussa was made out of something impure?
Can you imagine Isa made out of or not? Isa,
Isa wouldn't work. There's no father.
Good, you're still awake. Just make sure you're not sleeping. Ibrahim made out. Nobody would say that.
They said that makes no
sense. And it's it's it's not correct. Allah how many times in the Quran mentioned about the sperm and you made all the sperm. If the sperm is the same ruling of that filth and the urine wouldn't even be appropriate that the Koran how many times you can speak about filth and the filth and the feces and the urine, not at all. And it's not mentioned at all in this way mentioned once as a break, you're alive. But the law mentioned the sperm a something Yanni. Amazingly how he could get out of it. It doesn't fit the context of the verses doesn't fit that it's something filthy, it is something impure is something niches doesn't go with the contents of the Quran, and scribe
then also the set the Tao many times in the be sallallahu Sallam address the companions about the date the impurity of the money
if the money is impure,
didn't you think at least once, at least to give a hint,
hint or at one time, because it's a common thing to happen. People have sex people have weird dreams. So they would not know what to do with that, if it's impure inhibition would explain that since the Quran didn't. And inhibition Salam didn't mention anything.
That means it's not magic, because it is NW some would clarify this to the companion on their level I know what Allah and in the other hand, you have these narrations from the one who is the closest to the processor when it comes to this area, which is the issue of the intercourse which is his own wife, telling us that this is not something that we consider it nudges and his companion as well, like an ambassador they allow and was asked, What is the rule of the sperm or the semen, touch the clothes. He said, in Nima who can no harm when ha amid to anchor in ob with hora.
It is like that,
that whatever comes out of your mouth of the spirit comes or nose or whatever or the spirit comes out of your mouth. You just clean it up with his or her pa and you clean it up with just anything. You didn't need to wash it in another word.
Anyway, the debate is so long and he
mentioned it if you if you guys interested to know more about it, I would recommend you to read it. It's very, very interesting debate.
And with this, we conclude that the many is not nudges and basically, washing it is just for the purpose of cleaners been clean for the hygiene.
Not because it is something impure.
someone loves telenovela, and to being a mom