Shadee Elmasry – Who Evaluates Islamic Law Ep. 8 Debunking Madhab Myths
AI: Summary ©
The transcript describes a ruling from the Andersen School of Medical Sciences that states that a doctor who believes in the method of medicine should not be killed. The ruling is not recited as Quran and is directly inspired by the message of Jesus. The ruling also includes a discussion about the levels of each culture and the importance of the doctor's method in the medical field.
AI: Summary ©
Okay, first of all, the Messenger of some Malawi it was Saddam does
not do his Jihad and he doesn't give a penance he gives you the
state of the ruling of Allah subhanaw taala. Because to say
it's, it's Jihad indicates that he doesn't know. And he's trying to
find out using his mind, the messenger sallallahu alayhi wa
salam, everything, may or may on the planet, however, he doesn't
utter a word in Huila here, except it's actually white. So the
prophets, saying is not another. It's not an HT yet. It's the deen.
It's a ruling. It's from Allah directly. Why you need to know
they say it's a revelation that is not recited as Quran.
It's directly inspired in the sense as truth from Allah, God as
Quran, this hadith could see added Neverwet. Now, the ALMA, from the
Sahaba, not all of them were on a map, all of them were upright, or
dual, which means they can transmit Hadith, but not all of
them, gave rulings and give Fidella. Okay, that's number two.
Number three, the Sahaba then taught the next generation. And
every generation, every culture, every discipline has a way or a
means to signal to the rest of society that this person knows
what they're doing. And the way for example, Abdullah bin Omar
said, Abdullah bin Omar when he became old, and he became very
busy with a bed and worship, and not so much involved in the
discussions of the day and war. As many people when they get old,
this happens to them. They're not so in tune with what's happening
in the world anymore. Good. He used to go to his student site and
his students say to minimal say you and he used to send students
to him. He used to say go to site, no longer answer questions. He
forget sometimes as what happens to elders, right. So he used to
send people suicide and say, That's a sign and an indicator
that he authorized to say them and so that's how today we have a
degree with a diploma, and it's signed off. And it indicates the
signature of the president indicates that 20 or 30 other
professors at some point signed off on a different facet of your
education than the university emblem indicates that back in the
day, it was more individualistic. One person will say even today,
it's individual. Today as someone who gives a fatwa and ism which
dead is in which dead only in New matters, there is no wish to hide
what they call them, which died Mcluckie may now be our discussion
may now be what are the levels of each jihad, the scholars tell us
in the book. So also, at the end, that the levels of HD head are as
follows In which date and look, look, what lapwings up salute?
Which dad is someone who goes directly to the primary sources
and he gives you the answer. That's what I'm which had mclubbe
is directly to the prime minister that gives you an is there can be
m which stayed in a certain field guy if you look in the books of
Kabbalah or or judgment in court, there could be someone who only
judges on certain matters, like financial matters, marriage and
divorce, things like that. So you can't have much debt only in those
fields. Next level down you have them which tended within the
school of thought. So the parameters have been set down by
the the meme. And within that using those parameters, he gives
routes, using those parameters. Next level down is to GIA which is
he doesn't give his own ruling within the parameters but he could
judge which is the best ruling most accurate within those in most
of the schools. There's no need for that. And they don't. What the
math hubs have today is something called an woodshed for nasbla.
nasbla is something that come came down meaning something new that
came into our lives that we didn't know about, or that the previous
the elders and the previous generations never saw before. So
in this respect, most Mufti is today there within their method,
what is in which to head in new matters do he goes back and he
finds an analogous case. And he sees how, and which died within
the month have ruled on that case. So we have a long history of
affetto from the from the time of the first in which to ADMM all the
way till now there how many federal hasn't been given millions
upon hundreds of 1000s and millions, right? So they look for
something similar to that. And they make analogy of that, and
they give the fatwa so that becomes the ruling on this new
matter in the medical method. Good. Someone once said The medic,
he met up on Bitcoin and they laughed and said, You tell him he
outed him. Bitcoin when when medic is when this because they imagine
that a med had is only the founder speaking it's not the founder lays
down the parameters, and then afterwards cut many 50s in which
to heads within those parameters give rulings so a founder of the
school of thought the essence of it is he
establishes the methodology. Well, we call Saul. He establishes the
methodology. And sometimes he didn't explicitly establish it,
but you could tell that that was his methodology is Shafi is the
one who came and said, Actually, methodology is far more important
than the actual rules. That's why it's called the father of bustled.
Mo honey was called the father of FIP. Because he's the first one to
say we need to chapterwise Chapter zation. Okay, of the legal
rulings, and then medic, you could read very clearly in his words,
what his method was, and then later on, the scholars say that
very, very obviously, this is his methodology. So there are also in
FIP, according to the Medicus also wouldn't have felt according to
the Hanafi school, a super likewise Shafi and somebody