Shadee Elmasry – Not EVERY Biddah is Misguidance
AI: Summary ©
AI: Transcript ©
كل بدعة ضلالة Every innovation is a misguidance.
Ibn Hajar is saying here, the wording of
it would indicate that every single innovation is
an innovation.
However, what's meant by it is that which
is innovated without any evidence.
Suyuti says the exact same thing.
He said this is specific.
The language is كل but not every mention
of the word every is actually every but
it's most, could be most.
So he says this hadith, this every new
thing is a blameworthy innovation, is specific to
which ones, that which does not have a
basis in the religion.
That act which is established on the foundations
of the religion, but the companions had never
done it and the set of had never
done it, but it's on the basis in
the foundations and the purposes of the religion,
is not blameworthy and is not sinful.