Shadee Elmasry – NBF 86 Abu Hasan AlAsh’ari
AI: Summary ©
AI: Transcript ©
Do
you want the sidebar with video or yes sidebar right oh no the video
split screen put the video on
who's there?
Come in
Come on in
alright ready we ready to go
come on and I'm gonna sit
sitteth
but not what's happening you're doing good
today ever hasn't necessarily
yeah
all right we ready to go
I'm not gonna be speaking
lower the temperature for us. You're gonna have to maybe aim it
here while we're we're here, put it put the temperature on 63 Then
when we leave, but in fact up to 69
We're on. Oh, I don't know we're on this whole time some lot of man
that I even said on Monday come everyone did not realize we were
on this whole time today. We were a bit late today but that's okay.
Because we have today a really critical session on I would have
suddenly today. Alleged shoddy ceramic Jevon Bucha Begam Harris
for okie logging in from Jersey City or maybe from
j&j, New Brunswick. Who knows I just given everyone's personal
information out to everybody here. I'm so good. It could be
unresisted in your business trip. I didn't give away his address.
Yeah, we came late today, but there was a reason for that. But
today we have an amazing session. And we're going to wait. Okay
we're going to wait. I mean, we're going to you know this channel big
cat Namibia is amazing. Then the stuff that they Wow. That they
come out with. It's crazy. They just showed how a cheetah or a
Jaguar or a panther or something just eats the intestines
of an animal while simultaneously pushing out the excrement. Right
like squeezing it into its mouth but squeezing out the excrement.
Multitask it's multitasking with its mouth Bismillah R Rahman r
Rahim Al hamdu lillah wa Salatu was Salam ala Rasulillah who are
early he also be women. Well, okay. Today, let's go straight to
the sidebar and bring our topic of Satan. I would have sent an ash ID
which you can get. Okay.
This book from Mecca books stuck calm. You don't have to put the
thing up Mecca books.com. And go to put in the coupon code Safina.
And you can get these biographies. This is a wonderful book. All
right. Today's topic,
being stories of the odia. Now you might say well, this isn't one of
the zodiac. This is one of the scholars. Well, you have to
understand something.
Willa, cut them out and to so Wolf, they have an overlap, but
they're not one thing. Okay. And overlap is different from one. So
the the issue of karamat an issue of Elia the issue of vicar
antisocial if they have a major overlap, but it's not the only
thing. There's nothing greater than clarifying the truth and
delivering it to people. Mm hmm. Dad says this, what's the proof of
this? Proof being is that every messenger, the who are the
greatest of prophets, the messengers, every messengers
function
is to clarify the truth
and spread it to people. Okay. The truth of Islam is at any given
era, the most important truth is that which is threatened, so that
if people are threatening your life, then what's more important
at that time
I'm self defense
or have Sakura. Of course, you can't compare. There's just
because we make a comparison doesn't mean we're belittling
something. So there may be a moment in time where the one who
knows how to fight is the most important person. And the greatest
act of worship to Allah is to fight. If you watch medic, he
clicks podcast with me yesterday on his YouTube channel, we talked
half the time to so if somehow we got into the topic of self
defense,
if there may be a time where that's needed.
There may be a time as we talked about in the biography of who was
it
all might have nabbed it as these were the omegas were spending so
much money that the Wilaya the right, the path of Allah at that
time was good.
Okay.
In the time of Malik and lathe have been sad.
Where have you been gonna be tells us there was a calamity there was
a
the fitna at that time oh, by the way, I mean, it's in that little
red corner on the top left, you have to expand it.
The file that you're looking for a think, oh, no, sorry about that.
Forget that.
There is a time of magic and native insert and whatever Miranda
says the confusion was, what Hadith do we apply? There seem to
be contradictory narrations, the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa
sallam never contradicted himself
but transmissions may make it appear that he countered that
they're the transmissions may contradict you see the difference
they're not Hadith does not always reflect the prophet had these can
be weak Hadith it could be cut out out of context, Hadith could be
something that is abrogated later on so your you want a companion
may have heard a report from the messenger sighs son Allah when he
was later on the Prophet abrogated that hadith, okay, or adjusted it
or made a change to the situation. And he didn't hear that why?
Because he got sent off somewhere. So later on, scholars are looking
at this. And it was narrated without saying when he heard it
from the messenger. Scott's got to figure this thing, these things
out. Okay.
So today, we're going to talk about
the use of intellect when it comes to our understanding of Aikido.
Because there are intellectual bullies out there in the world,
and there are people who misuse intellect.
And now, what are we not going to do? We're not going to get into
the nitty gritties of what the more Tesla said, because that's
irrelevant. What we're looking at is the broad stroked attitudes of
the Tesla. Okay, the broad strokes, attitude of the enemies
of the Morteza.
Okay, who are the henna Villa and scholars of Hadith? Who are upon
the hook?
And then why that wasn't sufficient.
Okay, so someone says, oh, well, how could you say, a hadith not
sufficient? Because it's not just about having a Quran and Hadith.
It's how you use it. It's your utilization of it. Good. So why is
it that I will, Hasson actually came with a middle path and what
was that middle path? And then we're actually going to learn how
is it relevant for us today? How are these principles relevant to
us today? In the same way, that if there is a time where we have a
physical enemy, we have to learn how to fight that enemy. With what
if we have a physical enemy? The solution is not to go worship
Allah, the solution is to learn how to use how to put together an
army like Salahuddin or UB like NewTek Dena zyk. How was new to
Dena zinc in which I did an Habib Ahmad bin Hamad is different from
Habib Ahmed have been heavy. I remember how to be vulnerable,
haven't seen these were kings. Okay. These were kings, and they
were locked up and Abdel Noridian is Genki, Salahuddin a UB
these were kings. And they were hooked up
to a doll.
And the question is then, so how do they attain their wilayah by
fighting? So
everyone has an Ashley came out in a time where the MOI Tesla. They
were an intellectual group and they excelled in the use of
mantra. So what is the use of Mantap it's how to properly use
your intellect. There is a proper way to throw a punch. There's a
proper way to speak. You can't say NFL Badal
right because fee is hard for jar you have to say and Phil Beatty
there's landfill loca okay landfill Luca and as Allah
referred to the Quran as being an Arabic language Imam and had that
says net went out who the biller him in the Latin if you look
right, we seek refuge in making grammatical mistakes. Why? Because
Allah says We reveal this Quran in a pure Arabic tongue. Okay, Billy
Sen and Oribi and Mubin. Therefore, there is a potential
of existence of Lisanne are a bit later Moby Moby means clear a
clear Arabic tongue. So there may be a time where we can there may
be examples of an unclear Arabic tongue messing up the grammar all
the local dialects of today the dialects of the show and the
Egyptians the suit the Sudanese, the West Africans, the Iraq these
ladies. It's Arabic that's butchered. Okay, now who cares if
you're selling tomatoes? But if you're actually speaking about
Quran and Hadith your Arabic has to be right. Okay. So there is a
clear way to speak, there's a clear way to throw a punch,
there's a clear way to recite the Quran we call that Tajweed there
is likewise a clear way to use your intellect every scholar
agrees to the importance of well suited.
well suited fifth is how to properly think and draw
conclusions
from the Quran and the Sunnah.
That is a sub branch of Mantra. Mantra is how to use your
intellect in general, yet for solid focus how to use your
intellect in specific. So the general is the source. So everyone
who believes in also live IP, by default must recognize the
validity of Munduk 100 Where do you want to go?
Then you open up okay, but don't walk around because it's
distracting. Okay.
You understand? So, how to use your intellect the MATA Xena were
a people who rose up in the Islamic circles of Iraq by
refuting the literal lists
which we which came out of the cottage.
The always have two camps in Islam. You have the literalist.
And you have the rationalists. And as soon as in the middle, okay,
what do the literalist do?
They refuse to answer pertinent questions, and the challenges of
theologians, philosophers, they refuse to answer those questions.
So I'm gonna thinking guy, let's say, hypothetically, and I have a
question.
Let's just take an example that happens here all the time. You go
into into a college class, and I went into my first philosophy
class on the board right away the lady, she tries to deconstruct
your belief in God, she puts up Can God lift a rock that create a
rock that he cannot lift? Okay.
And she had it up on the screen, back in the day, there was an
overhead project. Right? She said, This is a clear answer, if he
can't, if he can lift it, if you can't create it, then he can't
lift it. If you can't create it, then he's not all powerful, right?
So in each way, he's not powerful. So there's no such thing as an all
powerful God. And then she takes it off, then she says, Oh, my name
is such and such. And this is philosophy one on one, right? So
the first thing she wants to do is deconstruct that. Now, let me make
something very clear here. Nobody derives. The truth is not derived
solely from the intellect. The main truths of life aren't derived
solely from intellect. And human beings in general, are not
rational. They're not we're not driven every day by intellect, but
intellect, but just these arguments, philosophical
arguments, and logic can protect you from the doubts that people
throw into your hearts. And we need this more than ever today, as
we're gonna get into trans ideology. And I'm just gonna give
you one example of, of the logical, basically chess moves
that are used by trans ideologues and how you could set them aside
because once you get these ideas,
all right, you're attacked by one of these ideas. You're unsettled
on the inside.
You can say all you want, I don't believe it. But unless you have an
answer, you're unsettled. On the inside, having an answer, it
settles you, showing you why this is why this was a trick. Right? It
settles, you calms you on the insights. Why? Because it said
animal killer is a
is a
it's a medicine. It's not the way to Allah, but it's a medicine to
protect you. In the same way, like shooting an arrow, shooting a gun.
This is not necessarily a way to Allah, unless you're protecting
someone else's body, then you can be a martyr for the cause. So they
never want to answer this question. Let's say I'm an
intellectual guy, and I hear that question, Can God build a rock
create a rock that he can't lift? I'm bothered by that. I'll tell
you what the literalists do. That what the litoris do is fine for
themselves dangerous for the OMA with the literacy. This is
nonsense. It's COVID I'm not even discussing it. You can die upon
that and you have no problem with Allah subhanaw taala but you can't
be our leader. You have to answer these questions.
As I will have him sit down in principle, he said, We don't read
their books. We don't utter their arguments. But if they utter it,
we have to answer them good because they will unsettle the
hearts of many people. That's why I said some people got upset with
me. Those who shut down admin Kalam, in their countries, these
questions can spread and nobody knows the answer.
So you got a guy's coming to fight you with a gun.
And all you have is a spear. Because the Sahaba had spears.
Right?
And you say fight, rely on Allah go fight and rely on low wages.
It's just a habit. And that's not the method of the sahaba. That's
the specific of this habit, the method of the Sahaba was to adapt
to the situation. So if he's fighting with a gun, and he could
shoot me from 50 yards back, and I can only shoot him from half a
yard. Kill him from half a yard. I need a gun. So you have lands
where they shut down Edelman Kyla
and I'm telling you have testimonials of people who said
what grew up in these schools? And students ask simple questions like
that. Out of curiosity, like one out of 100 is actually curious and
he's an intellectual. Like, you know, like guys like Kadima day,
and as the thinking think about that, right? Their heart will not
settle until they get an answer. Right? That's, that's, that's the
way I wasn't in college to like, I'm totally, I know, this is
nonsense, but I need to know how it's nonsense.
To give you just the answer, that is the idea that, first of all,
lift ability is not a quality of rocks, a rock must have a weight,
the weight must have a limit. That's number one. So there is no
such thing as an unlivable rock. Number two, there's a It's not
premise there that God lifts. Right?
Why did you assume that premises stuck in a premise there, and I'm
going to tell you how the trans ideologues, they're sneaking in
words and premises all the time. And then they're shifting to
appeal to emotion. Got this stuff. It's not all karamat and fuzzy
wuzzy.
Not say Fuzzy Wuzzy. That's not the right way to put it. But the
stuff that we love, but this stuff is important.
This is not a hard softener, this is a like the wilayah of I will
have Shadley and why we're putting in stories of odia is not because
his heart softener, it's a heart protector. And the heart protector
is more important than the heart software, you won't have a heart
to protect, to soften.
You will be poisoned and dead, if you allow these ideas to to come
in. Okay, so there's no such thing as an unlivable rock. And what the
question is actually saying, is the definition of God as being all
powerful? Can that God be not God? Can God be not all powerful? So
there's some basic rules of how to speak and how to think is that the
first thing you have to do is to define the term that you use, and
the rest of the proposition must be in accord with that definition.
And that's the meaning of Mr. Hill, Auckland. Right? Or
whatever. Yeah, the terminology we wanted was to hate Auckland.
Interjet is right.
To paradise, so that the idea of the paradox that is a
philosophical term, it's a term of mugdock It's not a term you find
in Quran and Hadith. But just because it's the term isn't there
doesn't mean the reality is not there. Because the Quran mentions
the same concept. Right? Well, okay, m and n divided by 257,
zero. If this book was from other than Allah, you would find it much
contradiction. So what is Allah saying here? The truth has no
contradictions. Therefore, that's the law of non contradiction right
there. So just because the term didn't exist, does not mean the
reality doesn't exist the same way. Did the Sahaba have soul or
soul? In fact, what is also referred? What's the methodology
of knowing halal and haram? That's a quick summary. The layman's
term.
The Sahaba had a methodology every one of them had a methodology what
was the methodology go ask the prophets of Allah when he was
done. That was the methodology. Ask if Quran was revealed about
this that's the methodology did they call it also to know right?
Did when new convert come in here and say,
did a new convert when a new convert came? Did this Hobbit say
our also is to ask the Prophet first and then or to ask if Quran
was revealed? Or to wait until Quran is revealed or to wait until
the Prophet that's the lawsuit. Right? But that's not they never
called it the word also that they all understood. That's what we do
here. Okay. That's why when a man when a Sahabi came to Ahmedabad,
kata Rhodiola dadan
and he said, I need you to roll between me and my friend. He said,
Okay. Judge said fine, he said
Did you first asked the Prophet? He said, Yes.
You asked the Prophet, but why you can hear them. Right? Said the
other men said, the defendant said, we also asked him a book
sonship almost said, So you asked the messenger of allah sallallahu
Newson
and then you ask the workers to dip. And then you're in my home
now asking me,
the man said, Yes. Why?
He points to the plaintiff. And he said, Because he didn't agree with
the ruling or their judgment.
Okay, so you want my judgment? So the plaintiff says yes, we want
your judgment set. Okay. So excuse me one second. He goes in the room
they're waiting what's he doing? And then all they hear is
I'm gonna comes out shining sharpened sword. Here's my
judgment, picks up his welds him from the hair, slits his neck.
The defendant ran for his life.
To the Prophet,
said Mr. of Allah, Ahmed, just killed that man that I was arguing
gets in court,
almost came out, cleaning shop, cleaning out the sword, the blood
from his sacred geometry, what did you just do? They said, a
messenger of Allah, the man's hypocrite.
What happened? He said, You he came to you. He didn't like your
ruling.
He came to
a buck. And then he came to me. Any man who does not like the
ruling of the Messenger of Allah must be nothing other than a
hypocrite? How could you believe he's the prophet, and you don't
like his ruling? Right?
The Prophet read silent.
Then the Prophet afterwards, he told me that this is forbidden.
Now. You can't do that again.
You judge him to be a hypocrite but he actually committed no
capital crime.
The Quran then comes down saying yes, the prophet rule is the rule.
Now you can't just go killing people because you know, they're
hypocrite or you assume they're a hypocrite. But Omar was right.
Okay.
Follow up because we know in a hot day, you had chemo coffee machines
or a bainham. By Allah, they're not true believers until they make
you the judge. They don't like your judgment. They're not true
believers. So the Prophet set the rule. But Allah confirmed Omar was
right, he was a hypocrite. Okay. So what is that will soon the
methodology that man, he made a big mistake and methodology. Okay,
so let's get let's get to like how was said no, I will have to share
that he. Like, what? Hasn't sad? See how many beautiful people are
able to Hudson right? Say an ally.
I will have some sad, I would have to share it. Okay. You should just
name your son, Edward Hudson, even there's no Hudson, right?
Maybe I'll do that next. So he comes he's a descendant of the
Yemeni scholar and judge and wise man that the Prophet used as a
judge of a buckler used as a judge say normally used him as a judge
say North magnesium as judge said And it used him as a judge. And
that is Abu Musa and Ashari. He is his descendant.
Now he's dead. He dies.
I will have son Ben is made it's made dies. Who does his mom
remarried. O'Boyle job bae. share as much as you know. So he grows
up getting private tutelage getting everything from the it's
almost like no, we don't we don't we don't can make comparison
between a Muslim and a Catholic. That's haram. Right? Because the
Muslims, not like a Catholic. The Morteza are Muqdadiyah but they're
Muslims. Right? They're moved out here.
They're heretics, but they're muscles nonetheless. So we still
don't make a comparison between the governor but you notice how
Satan a Musa alayhis salam.
He rose up in the house of Pharaoh.
I would have to lash out he was raised in the house of the Tesla,
the leader of the Moto Z, one of the great scholars of the Moto Z,
except that Edward Alger Bay was not a great debater. So he used to
use his son, Edward Hudson as a debater. So he would like on the
on the way home on the way back talking about everything like like
you got kids come come to with to their parents, with their parents
to the masjid. Let's say they're driving. They're the ESCO. So
what's the what's the class about today? You tell them a little bit.
And then on the way back home? Oh, that was a good thing. But I have
a question. A follow up question. So your kids, if they're
interested in the dean, they get so much special attention and more
knowledge than if they were you know, than a regular person.
That's how he grew up. Every nitty gritty detail about them or
designee doc
And he grew up with by the age of 40, though he realized there's a
problem here. Okay, there's a problem here.
This is my Tesla, although they started up
to respond to the philosophers.
right to defend the Sunnah.
As we, as we said, we must answer questions
that come up,
they're not actually going after the truth. And remember this as a
theme, hasn't actually realized, they're not actually going after
the truth. They've become another sort of this group of
philosophers, they have their own set of terminology, their own set
of values. And they are today very similar, you know, to slamming
studies departments, and I'm just making as a very general broad
when a general statement, okay, means that there are many, many
exceptions to it. So no one in Islamic Studies, or an academic
academia should take offense to this, because they also will agree
that Islamic studies departments, a lot of these academic
departments, they're not a search for the truth.
It's a lot of things. But one thing that it's not is a search
for the truth. If you go into an interview at Yale, or Harvard, or
someone, oh, okay, what's your interest in Islamic studies here,
I want to know the truth about Allah and His Prophet, and I want
to spread it to the people, you want to get the job, right. So I
think we can all agree on that which is, which means it's a
general observation, which means there are a lot of good people out
there who are in those departments that it doesn't apply to them.
Number two, is that the second point is spreading it to the
people. So he realized these more Tesla, are, are people who
it's like a select group. Now, they have their own language, they
have their own values and what they do anything in the Quran or
Hadith that goes against their philosophy. They reject it
altogether.
He began being unsettled by this until he saw he spent
a lot of time at home by himself, just like his future successor,
Abraham was any good. He spent a lot of time home by himself was
resigning debates and just being sort of depressed. And as it was
that he said, there are different types of depressions. There are
types of depressions that Allah brings upon a Muslim a movement in
order to bring something out of him, right, to bring something of
the truth out of him. That's a type of, I don't want to say
sacred depression, but it is a divinely ordained depression upon
somebody, and usually doesn't last long. And it's not because of his
body or his circumstances. It's something that Allah brought upon
Him to show to take him to a new VISTA.
So in that depression,
he saw the prophets of Allah when he was the messenger sallallahu
alayhi wa salam gave him his medicine. He said yeah, but he
doesn't take my Hadith
there are two people two groups and it Hadith
the people they take Hadith full stop. That's it. As we said, you
can die upon the Anima Sana, but you can't leave the community.
Okay, you're gonna lead them to to, to go into a
rock fight you using rocks and the other guys using a rocket
launcher, right? These guys got a gun, you got to spear because all
they had to Spears okay, you die. But don't be our leader. You go
and die. But you're not PMP or leader? Because you have to answer
this question. The other group is these elite academics who have
absorbed certain values. Okay, they've absorbed certain values.
And they use their own terminology that nobody understands. All
right.
And they don't actually submit to the to the Quran and Hadith
anymore. So he starts now buying all the books of Hadith, and
poring over the books of Hadith, studying Hadith, until like,
another two weeks went by, he had just read so much Hadith. And he's
absorbing every single Hadith and submitting to it.
And saying, and coming to the conclusion, the Quran, and the
Hadith, the revelation is the only source of actual metaphysical
truth. Everything else is a rational speculation. Good.
He then
has another dream.
And he takes he took all his books.
And he all put all his Qalam books on the side, all his philosophy
books on the side.
He had actually seen that that dream twice the first one, he
thought it must be false because a lot of idiots, they're not
consistent with each other. And as we said, we can say that because a
hadith is not a reflection of the Prophet. It's a narration about
the Prophet. I can narrate something about you have you can
go narrate something about you
Okay, they conflict. Have you used his effort, I use my effort, but
they don't actually.
But we didn't narrate the full story about you. There's no
inconsistency in you. It's our narrations that
were not consistent.
So he then sees the second dream of the prophets of Allah
Williamson, where
he says now that he's going to be solely a person of Hadith. And
he's gonna go back to Adam, Adam and humble, who's the imam or
Hadith, but the humble is had not produced anyone like him since and
he's just gonna follow him. He has a neck next vision of the Prophet
sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, in which the Prophet says, Yeah, but
hasn't. I said, take my Hadith. I never said leave Kalam.
Right.
I said, take my Hadith, but I never said leave off that ability
to show logically, that this religion is the truth, that there
has no inconsistencies and that the heresies are inconsistent in
within themselves that is the purpose of Kalam what is the so
there are narrations of the 14th Memes against Kalam against marked
as any column,
that column, not this column.
Because the when the four Imams existed, the column that existed
at the time was the philosophizing of the month desolates.
This column is using rational principles to show that this
religion is not inconsistent with itself has no internal
inconsistency is is that not a Quranic mandate? What kind of an
integrated ledger up here at 11 kathira. If it was from other than
Allah, they would see much a contradiction. So therefore it
becomes a discipline in religion to show there's no contradiction
here.
Number two,
that it there's there's no contradiction within itself.
There's no contradiction between it and between intellect. Why is
that also, a discipline of religion does not the Quran say F
an attempt to learn to not use your intellect is not this
religion only comes down and is legally binding upon someone with
a sound intellect. Therefore, we have to know how to use the
intellect, rules of intellect, and this religion is the intellect not
a creation of Allah.
There cannot be a verse of Quran that nature and observation that
contradicts the observed worlds. Why because Allah has the revealer
of the book, and he's the creator of the world, the intellect also
is a divine creation, which Allah commanded us to use, therefore,
this religion and this book cannot, it is, it is not possible
for it to contradict with with the fundamental rules of the
intellect. And there are fundamental rules of intellect
that are very simple that no two people would disagree about.
Very simply, that if you use a word you have to define it cannot
use a floating word.
If we're going to talk, we have to agree on what the word means. You
have to give a definition that is manna jam at minimum, that
collects all of its meanings and excludes all of its not meanings.
And then you have to the rest of your sentence, the rest of your
proposition cannot go and contradict that meaning.
That's the rule of identity and non contradiction. And then you
have an excluded middle and we have other rules that that are
like ipso facto means that if a, then negative A if A is, if we've
established a, then we have excluded negative a. Okay, so
we've established that Ahmed is upstairs.
We've established also that admin is not downstairs. Okay? That's a
lot. These are the three basic rules of logic, if all you know is
these three, but you apply them properly, you cut through all this
trans ideology, nonsense and a lot of other nonsense, okay. So, I
will have some actually after seeing this, he becomes so
energized that he goes straight out to the mosque of bussola,
where they are the gym, the main mosque, and right before the hook
but of Juma. He elbows through everybody. He goes up the steps by
himself of the member and the analysis. I am everyone has an
SRE. If you know me, you know me. And if you don't know me, then my
name is Edward Hudson. And so I would have an SRE. I used to be
the proponent, a proponent of the motto as much as the doctrine and
I announced now that I absolve myself from that, and I have
adopted the way of the scholars of Hadith and the Sunnah of the
Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam and will spend the rest of
my time
disproving the matassini doctrine in defense of the Sunnah.
He then proceeds to start
I
am one will announce time for questions, not time for questions
right now. And I'm just kidding, why they can steal them from
Bangladesh, or to Bangladesh. She's been posting that for a long
time now. So when it comes to them to Bangladesh, and all and to
Bangladesh, as long as Bangladesh still exists, because you know
that soon enough, it's going to be flooded. We ask a lot off here for
all those people who are going to eventually become refugees. Okay.
And of course, we have useless Khadija countries who are going to
host the World Cups and spent billions on the World Cup, but
they're not going to do anything for these people.
We're going to now move to what does he do afterwards? He, he now
starts going to the circles, because this is a clique. Now,
this is like a clique. And like, it's like, it's as if he's going
to academic conferences. And we would say why don't go to those
conferences, it's all corruption. And they're, they're going to
poison your mind, he but he would say, I have to go. Because I know
their doctrine, they're not going to come to me, I have to go and
show them their errors
and their mistakes.
And he starts going there. And he starts developing a following.
They follow him to these conferences. And they have belts,
right? They have gatherings, and they have belts, and he usually
lets them speak first. And then he speaks and undoes their points one
by one, cuts them up. Let me read you a quote here. That was a
really nice quote. I love this quote, because I really feel this
way.
And by the way, if you guys and you guys are studying knowledge
right in the mat, always keep in mind that our purpose is to seek
the truth, to act upon it and to spread it. There's no other
purpose. If you're if anyone develops any other purpose. It's
usually because they lose focus. They get into nitty gritty
details. And they start competing against each other, to lob against
to lob scholars against scholars. It's just people get caught up,
human beings get caught up, they get caught up, they come back down
to earth.
A way to bring us back down to earth is doing the soup kitchen.
Doing the classes like today I was taught middle schoolers, right?
You can't get caught up if you got to teach middle schoolers, right?
Because you're gonna have to bring yourself down to their level.
Everyone has an SRT, when he was asked, Why us?
Why speak about the deen in this in this rationalistic and
intellectual manner.
He said did not the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam said
speak to people at the level of their intellects. That means
downwards and upwards. That means if I'm speaking to middle
schoolers, I got to speak with like basic words that they all
know. But if I'm speaking intellectuals, I have to speak
with that with those terms, provided that I'm not going
against the doctrines of the truth. Okay, nor using
methodologies that are not allowed. To repeat the purposes of
Kalam is to show there is no internal contradiction in the
religion in the Quran, or the Hadith. That's a Quranic mandate.
Number two,
to show that there is no contradiction between
the revelation and the and intellect. What does that mean?
Does that mean we deny miracles? No, the miracle is not a
contradiction.
It is possible for Allah subhanaw taala to cause a human being to
rise up to the heavens and come down without use of rocket ship or
anything. That's a marriage. Good. It's possible for Allah subhanaw
taala to do things that we haven't seen before. But what we say is
not a proposition that is acceptable. is the contradiction.
Okay? And when many people say impossible for Allah, this, this
phrase impossible for a lot. Don't say it any more. Things People
think it means you're limiting Allah, we're not limiting Allah.
Allah has the power over all things provided that the thing is
a thing. And the thing that contradicts itself is not a thing.
Okay? So if I say, if you ask me, Can God create a square with five
sides? I say to you, your proposition is invalid. The
sentence you said itself is invalid. I'm not even going to
answer it. Okay, well, my answer is your proposition is invalid.
Why is it invalid? Because you just negated Allah Tada can take a
square give it five sides. It won't be a square anymore. It'll
be a pennant. What is it called? The Pentagon? Right?
So a lot of these people they come in and there's two two camps the
philosophers want to put give you doubt and Allah. Oh, he can't
create a square with five sides. There's no such thing. The
proposition is invalid. There's another group of people that say
yes, we must believe that Allah can do it. You have full sorry to
say this. Yes, you're a great believer and inshallah you'll die
upon the man but you're full. No offense to you. Okay. Because
you've you taken the bait. If please put out a little piece of
fish. Oh, let's see, yes, Allah can create that the proposition
itself is invalid.
The proposition is nonsense. Can Allah create a Djibouti goop at
If the group doesn't exist, there's no such word. Right? And
usually, yes, he can, if he can, what you don't even know what
you're saying. It's not a word. It's just a jumble up of letters
that I just made up on the spot. And you just take the bait because
you think that's the fervor of faith. And at the time of Edward
Hesson, the Hanna Barbera
their honor, as Arab said, they're on our heads, which means their
lofty believers, they had not produced anyone close to Sydney,
Imam Muhammad, if it hadn't been, they would say, We will not
discuss it period full stop. Some of them went to another extreme
and said, Yes, whatever it is, yes, because he's called that
adequately shape.
Whereas what they're falling into is propositions that don't even
exist. Invalid propositions and I would have said, when I said he's
shaking his head, he said the entail you will lose all the
intellectuals, anyone with a brain, you will lose them in
Islam. This is unacceptable. Okay, so a beautiful quote here.
As God maintained, that the ultimate source of faith and the
key to metaphysical and unseen realities is the revelation period
and the teaching of the prophets of Allah what He said and full
stop no discussion, rather than human reasons, speculation, and
metaphysics,
a Greek metaphysics, at the same time, he differed with the rigid
dogmatism
of the conformist who thought it prudent to a remain silent, about
issues raised by opposing sect. Just because the messenger never
employed that terminology.
It's not a reason. You need everything to be spelled out for
you, or did not the Prophet give you certain basic general
principles? Okay. I debated a youth. He said, you negate for
Allah what Allah never negated for himself. Right? But I said, Okay,
Allah has negated these things, in general, with the simple phrase,
Allah has summit means he has no need, therefore, anything that
indicates that he has a need, and a dependency is negated? Does he
have to go and negate every single specific or he just gives you the
general laser commitment? You say, therefore, if you make an analogy
with him, it's false. Okay? If anything that he has a different
Allah had he's he's one in Himself. Therefore, any
proposition that would indicate that God is divided up in himself
is negated. So he negates in general, okay.
Then everything that falls under that generality is negated by
default does not have to give you every single thing so I told him
just gotta have a color. Is he purple? Is the pink is the rainbow
flag when the biller Wait, you didn't ever negated it? He never
negated it. Allah never negated color for himself. Are you going
to make of course we're going to negate it. Colors audit for see
you guys don't even define terms say, Oh Allah, Allah has an STD is
the same exact thing. He said, You have a lot of faith. But you will
get caught up in the field of logic. And the philosophers will
cut you up so badly, your kids will have delta in Islam. So what
is the color? You have to define it? Again? First rule of logic
define the terms. What is a color a color? What kind of creation is
it? It's the audit, to quality. A color must can only exist on
something else. There's no redness flying around. So redness
greenness purpose, it has to exist on something on a cup on a bird as
so it's a hot
and it has to exist on a material thing, something that we can touch
matter.
Therefore, if we know that Allah is not consistent of matter, then
he has no color. So we do negate color for Allah because if we
don't, then we're admitting matter for Allah because color cannot
exist without matter. Okay, so this is a very basic example,
simple use of the different defining terms. And then bringing
a principle that relates soft data. In the same way ever hustler
Shetty was saying in the same way that new legal matters come up.
Likewise, new philosophical questions come up. And it may not
be a new question. But it's new to us. Right? It's new to the OMA of
Islam. So then we have to answer it, right. I mean, isn't
transgenderism a completely new ideology? You got to answer it, we
got to answer it in many different ways. We got to have a clear cut
definition. And as I was talking to her about this one time, he
said that his shift, shift, shift,
shift, so to head shaking, Algeria, had to open the books and
go back because in his study, he was saying, We've never occurred
to us. All right. To to remember the actual definition of a man
like what is it? What is the definition of meal of a min
bucket? Right? How do we actually define what are the qualities? We
have to have an objective different definition so we had to
go back to it. It's not something that they would have to do because
the world wasn't that stupid back then.
In the world wasn't that crazy Spatola so, he then he says this
alleged he felt that this attitude would really be regarded as a
weakness for the Orthodox school and harm it. And he also
maintained that the attitude of rigid dogmatism would enable the
Montecito. Okay. And other opposing sects.
Okay to win over the youth and to the masses, okay? These people are
sheep, these people, sheep in wolf's clothing, they're speaking
a wonderful speech. They're talking a good talk. But
ultimately, what what is important is that they pull out of your
heart certain beliefs. Okay.
There's another quote that I want to bring you here. That is a
wonderful quote. He wrote Edward Hudson, all this, he wrote this,
in his book is JSON, or SSL called the animal killer.
The praise worthiness of defending doctrine using these rational
principles. That's the definition of
what else this is, there's another quote I want to give you here.
These are quotes from from his book. Yeah.
Where's that other quote?
I lost it.
All right, we pretty much covered most of the things, right. I
wanted to put this in a way that every common Muslim could
understand. Right? And I hope that we achieved that. I think that we
achieved that. Remember, number two things about some of the
biography of a scholar, it's an intellectual biography, there's
not much exciting, like new denas Enki, he goes to battle, all that
stuff. So when we talk about the biographies of scholars, their
moves in life, our intellectual moves, right.
That's the first thing. So that's, that's why it's sometimes it's not
as exciting as the biography of other people. Secondly,
we have to remember we lie is about the relevancy of defending
the truth and spreading it to the people. All right. And what he
realized is that the Morteza that these people are no longer
concerned as they started off as defending the truth is just an
ivory tower, nor do they care for spreading it to the people, if you
care about spreading it to the people, all right, and acting upon
it for yourself and spreading it to the people, then you speak in
terms that people can understand. Otherwise, what's the point, and
many academics will lie they sneer and looked down upon most of these
dots, and most of the scholars that want to speak to people on a
simple level, because all that they love is their intellectual
gymnastics. Right? That's all they love, intellectual gymnastics. So
they sneer and look down on people. But you know what, you're
going to be irrelevant because you don't benefit anybody. Number two,
if all you care about is spreading it and acting upon it yourself,
you filter out unnecessary knowledge. You don't take it in,
except if you wanted to compete with somebody, then you're wasting
your time to learn knowledge to compete and be able to say in the
gathering, you know, certain phrases, certain quotes,
citations, whatever, to impress other people. And that's a will
Allah Allah name is 99% of academia. That's just what it is,
but tell the truth, and everyone else is an exception. But if all I
want is knowledge to act upon it, and to spread it to other people
that I don't need a lot of certain things are not unnecessary for me.
And speaking with high level language is not necessary speaking
to the people that awaken on the way they can understand. And so
mimetic has a famous quote, he said, Why do you say to students
why do I see you writing down everything right? On just listen,
remember what you remember then go act upon it and Allah put a note
in your heart that note will show you what's true and what's false,
right. So, that is essentially when the chef aka came upon this
when the Maliki it came upon this they absorbed it and drank it and
they said this is the truth and they followed a luxury and from
the to the medic he have followed him with more vigor and they the
medica you cannot find a non
according to
who is amendment how do we need to join or is it Ted Ted's Deena
Sookie Ted Dean is Sookie said the Medicare or the the chief leaders
of the Russia IRA as well as the chef here but some chef are
entered into Shiism and into touch team.
And some of the SNF they entered into Alia tizzle
and I followed a woman suit and met with Edie. At the same time
period out and some other kind of woman too.
Metro DD did the same thing
to fight with the Montecito.
Metro DD stock according to
NetSuite, he says the Metro DD thought was more moderate
than an SRT. I don't know where he's what he's alluding to. But
he says the Metro media also answered more questions than the
shaido. At that time, at that time.
And therefore, they reordered things they honed in, they filled
in blanks. And they made it more comprehensive. Of course, he's
probably got to do it.
But the differences are all marginal, they're peripheral. And
they can be limited to 40 questions, some limited, it's 12
questions. So the SSID and Metro DD became the same thing,
essentially, in its essence, and only in the periphery in the
organization and some of these other things, they're different.
Okay, now, let's go to the split screen. And I want you to all hear
a clip. And I want you to, and I want to point out to you how to
basically utilize some of these very simple logical principles.
All right, I want you to use these logical principles in make sure
the audio is on in that book in that in that guy.
Alright.
In a very simple transgender ideology debate, okay, because the
the rules of Montek. Remember, no one derives their ideas from the
rules of magic, but we can simply, we can undo things that will
unsettle you and trap you. Alright, we're ready to go.
You've referred to people with a couple I think you have to hit
play is the audio on women.
Sure, many women sis women have the capacity for pregnancy, many
sis women do not have the capacity for pregnancy. They're also trans
men who are capable of pregnancy as well as non binary people who
are capable of pregnancy. So this isn't really a rights issue. It's,
we can recognize that this impacts women while also recognizing that
it impacts other groups, those things are not mutually exclusive.
Senator Holly Oh, so your view is is that the core of this, right
then is about what? So I want to recognize that your line of
questioning is transphobic. And it opens up trans people to violence
by not recognizing that, oh, you're saying that I'm opening up
people to violence by asking whether or not women are the folks
who can have pregnancies? So I'm one I want to note that one out of
five transgender persons have attempted suicide. So I think it's
important in my line of questioning, because we can't talk
about it because denying that trans people exist and pretending
not to know that they exist. I'm denying that trans people exist by
asking are you if you're are you about when are you in pregnancy,
so you believe that men can get pregnant? No, I don't.
Trans people like this thing that leads to violence is this how you
run your classroom are students allowed to quit?
Alright, let's go back to the main screen now. And I'm going to play
this and stop it at each point to show you where the logical
loopholes are. And before that, let's just do our sponsors real
quick. You can get this book from Mecca books.com.
Coupon Code Safina I highly recommend everyone should have
this on their bookshelf. And secondly, you want to support this
live stream, you go to patreon.com backslash Safina society, your
support is always appreciated. And we have some wonderful patrons
that because of their financial support, we're able to put this
program together. I have no shame in saying that we're in a
codependency operation. Yes, dependency, right, y'all I want to
depend on a lot alone I am depending on Allah alone, right?
But Allah gave us a superb and this we cannot possibly have this
stream unless the community wants it. Right? Because no one's got
the time to come in every single day and do this unless there is a
financial, there's an economy to it and a financial support to it.
So to all those out there if you want to see this continue. I have
no shame saying there is a financial dependency between the
viewers and the producers of this live stream. So support
[email protected] backslash Safina society. So we're putting this out
there. It's for free to everyone use and you want to support it.
You support it with however much you want. So now let's go over
this one one point at a time. Good.
You've referred to people with a capacity for pregnancy
would that be women?
Many women sis women have the capacity for pregnancy. Many sis
women do not have the capacity for pregnancy. All right, let's stop
right there. Right off the bat. The introduction of terms that are
not universal nor accepted. That's the first thing there. And let me
tell you, he goes along and he doesn't do a bad job but he also
maybe he's
not, I don't think he did a bad job in this, but and I don't even
know who he is some senator. But the first thing that anyone said
Kelim, or any student of logic, although you introduced a term
that I don't agree with, right, and that term will have Loas him
in her mind, it was him are necessary repercussions in her
eyes that I don't even believe in the term in the first place. Now
she's gonna argue about the repercussions. So that's the
first, the first thing is you introduce a term that I'm not I do
not agree with, right?
There are also trans men who are capable of pregnancy. So I don't
believe in that, right? I don't have that category. Everyone to me
is a man or a woman. Right? So you're introducing a term? Why did
Aristotle say he wins every debate? Says, because I'm the one
who defines all the terms.
Well, it's non binary people who are capable was a binary non
binary, because I'm not accepting that everyone to me is on a
binary. Okay, so that's the first rule of we're using some of the
basic rules of how to think so that when you hear this as a
Muslim, you don't shake get shaken up, right? Because they're like,
like you they get trapped you and stuff, right? No, that move,
you're out of bounds. You just stepped out of bounds? How are you
winning all the time? Because you get to step out of bounds and I
don't, right? You get to go around the chairs and around the basket,
right? And then you get to go out of bounds. And I don't so that's
so that's the first thing. So this isn't really a women's rights
issue. It's we should recognize that this impacts women while also
recognizing that it impacts other groups. Those things are not
mutually exclusive. Senator Holly. Oh, so your view is is that the
core of this, this right then is about what? So I want to recognize
that your line of questioning is transphobic. Okay. Now, where does
she shift? She now shifts
to an attack.
To be honest with you, she's in control this dialogue, right? She
she brings in terms that she wants, she shifts the discussion,
right. And now she's on the attack. She attacks him with what
another term, these liberals want to they want to beat you in a
debate as
what's his face, said, Dave Chappelle when they want to beat
you. And he said it very well. And guess what well said say no,
Yusuf, right. These are just as smart, some maybe more
sentimental, Obeah Minnesotan, right, say no. You said you all
just worship, you make up words. And you worship these words.
That's it. Dave Chappelle made the same observation when they want to
beat you out in the debate. They just make up a word. You're
transphobic? Because I don't recognize that either. Right?
Because I don't recognize your term. Okay.
He didn't call that out either. He didn't call the shift. So she made
up one term first. She uses she if you brought in a term, she she
shifted to an attack. She's a law professor. That's why she's she
knows what she's doing. She shifted to an attack that puts him
on a different you're transphobic.
And then she brings up another term, which is transphobia. Okay,
now let's see what else she says By the way, give us it's too cold.
Now.
Your Patreon support is so good that I'm too cold. Now, I went
from being too hot now to code. 67 is good. And it opens up trans
people to violence by appeal to emotion. Fourth issue.
It opens up people to violence. Oh, wow.
So you get in your head, trans people getting hit with bats and
stuff. You opened up people to violence.
Right? So you're not only you're transphobic, a term and an attack,
you're now opening up to the violence. So it's an appeal to
emotion. Now, you're the violent one, right? And we're the victims.
That's called an appeal to emotion. appeal to emotion is
good. When you're trying to do something, it's fine. When you're,
it's neutral. In some cases, it's good. In other cases, it's good if
I'm doing an appeal to emotion about what's in Jahannam or what's
in paradise so that you could do your duties, that's fine. That's a
good appeal to emotion. There's a neutral appeal to emotion, how
happier you're going to be if you drive around in this beautiful
Jaguar, and I'm a Jaguar salesman, right? It's neutral, just using it
to sell a car. It's hard to do here, when you use appeal to
emotion to muddy up the truth. That's where it's out of balance.
Recognizing now you've seen that I'm opening up people to violence
by
so my he answers it fine. But my problem is I would not even step
into this arena. She invented her own arena of discourse in which
your words open up to people to violence. I'm not even recognizing
the existence of urea. It's an invalid arena. But he goes into
it. Right and it's easy to for us to stop and pause and re see he's
in the middle of it right so whether or not when
I know that my pregnancy so I'm wondering, Okay, what else is he
doing here? So he actually makes a point he says that wait, I'm
asking you a question.
And you're saying that's violence. So what is fifth thing shut down
discussion. The fifth thing that she's doing here, she's this is
the anatomy of a football play, right? You ever seen the anatomy
of a play the play, you watched it on TV, it was three seconds, hike
the balls out of his hands, the guys tackled in three seconds. But
then they go on ESPN. And they you bring Peyton Manning. And he's
going to divide up this and he's going to talk for 15 minutes about
those three seconds. That's what we're doing here. But you all have
to learn. Okay, you got to see. And I do this so much, just like
these football quarterbacks, when they see it plays like, Wow, what
a play. All I saw is a bunch of guys moving across and the ball, I
don't even know where the ball went. Because the cameras not
always spent right up. It's not always zoomed out. But the quarter
that the analysts who know football, they're like, that was a
work of art, right? And I have no clue who said, but when we're
cutting this up, you can see now all the things she's doing in this
little clip,
as a law professor, that all of them are out of bounds. They're
all against the rules of logic.
She's applying her own metaphysical worldview, that trans
people exist. She's now making assumptions. Words are violence.
Good. And she's now also
basically making an accusation. Right, that's she's going on the
offensive and accusing him of this stuff, and appealing to emotion
that they're the victims and he's the aggressor. This is all stuff
that you could see in this little clip, but most people I guarantee
you will see it will get frustrated by it, and will feel
handcuffed and upset and they will just get frustrated. But you don't
get frustrated when you see what she's doing. Right. When you see
the play. Like if you ever get beaten by the same team over and
over and over. And there's a set play that they keep doing. You get
frustrated. Unless you sit back let's rewind this play. What are
they doing this guy he's going around?
Right, he's going around another player, therefore, his defenseman
is missing him. His defenseman can't see him for a split second
because he can't see him for a split second, he loses him. That's
why he's open. The other guy gets it passes to wide open. So you get
frustrated, but unless you slow it down and took pick it apart, you
can't argue against it. And note that one out of five transgender
people to emotion, attempted suicide. Okay, attempted suicide
snuck premise because of you. They want maybe they've attempted
suicide before at 10 Other reasons. Maybe they maybe they're
attempted suicide because of an illness. Maybe that's also the
reason they want to be transgender. Right? So the snug
premise, that's number six, I mean, she's prolific, right? It's
a snug premise that all these people are committing suicide
attempts, because of conservative words, because of anti that's not
premise. So I think it's important to my line of questioning because
we can't talk about it because shutting down discussion trans
people exist and pretending not to know that they exist. Trans people
exist by are you if you're sorry about when
we go? Yeah, I'm telling you, it trans people, okay, they their
existence is one thing for me to recognize that they deserve
certain rights and that they're victims. And that I'm the cause an
anti trans ideology is the cause. That's a whole nother set of
things. Good. For you. Alright, pregnancies, do you believe that?
Men can get pregnant? No, I don't think.
So. What?
Now that's like a complete gap on her part. Like, that's a complete
gap on her part, right, though men cannot get pregnant. What is the
definition of a men? Him and her they don't agree on the
definitions. So this is not it's pointless. Right. So but it's a
gaffe on her part to basically saying
that, if you deny that men can get pregnant, then you deny that trans
people exist. So because her definition of a man is not my
definition of a man. And that's where this whole thing falls
apart. And unfortunately, this is happening at like, the highest
level of society. This is a Senate hearing. Okay. And then it becomes
a little tick tock thing. And by the way, yeah.
By the way, piercings have shaved head and half knot and colored
hair, and tattoos, we muscles, we don't do any of these things,
because this has become like the symbol of these types of liberals.
Right? It's the symbol you when you see someone with purple hair,
blue hair, piercings everywhere, Half shaven, Half shaven head and
half long.
Some crystals and some paganism hanging from their necks.
tattoos everywhere. Like we've heard, we know the rules on
tattoos and piercings and tattoos, piercings, there's some room
wiggle room right we'll have the righteous Desi world have no
problem with piercings in the nose, Arabs may not have that
Africans may have many piercings in the ears. Right? So piercings
can be discussed. But in light of the existence of these folks,
anything that looks like these folks would be, you know, either
between Mikado and haram, because we have to separate ourselves from
how they look. Right? So
because they've taken like, big purple hair isn't their thing now,
right? And half shaven, and half. So basically, if you look like the
US, the captain of the US Soccer Team, you got issues. All right.
So that's basically
a little bit of a
applied
an application of the premise of what Edmund Kadem is about, is, is
abusing using the basic rules of intellect to show that our
religion has no inconsistencies, it does not conflict with our
intellect. And that heresies are full of inconsistencies. So you
can not show the seat, you feel very different about a clip like
this, after you've dissected what she's actually doing with her
words. Okay.
All right, let's stop here and go for question and answer. Everyone
can now put their question and answer on Instagram On Facebook on
YouTube. Okay.
Yes. So how do you change from like an argument from being like,
when they do emotional appeal? How do you change the playing field to
turn it back to an intellectual? Like? That's a very good question.
Really good question. It seems like everybody does it. Like even
Jordan Peterson will use the video. Sort of like, he's trying
to appeal to Muslims and say, like, show us that, like, anybody
that rejects perennialism? Or, yeah, like that has like, like,
why don't we deselect that tomorrow? next livestream? I
didn't see it, but
if someone uses the appeal to emotion,
okay. How do you get around that I actually wrote a paper for this,
but I couldn't for the Islamic.
You know, I respect them. Because they know that this is a field
that we have in Australia. And they asked me to present it. And
what's the group called? I can't remember if they're mainly like
kind of Villa. Basically, it's a Federal Council. And they asked
me, I couldn't present it, because COVID hit but they they present.
Someone presented it for me. And it's the idea that if someone uses
emotion, you cannot respond with logic. Okay? You can only respond
with another emotion. Right? You can only shift it to humor. Right?
If you shift it to humor, you kill it. Right? So someone says, oh,
you hit me.
You hurt me.
Say, you're lucky. That's all I did. Right? I wanted to do a lot
worse, but it's illegal, right? So you could flip it, but you can
only flip it to another emotion. Because now they've taken the this
discussion from logic, which is logos to pathos, emotion from
logic to emotion. You now have to play in the field of emotion as
shake Newark Keller used to always put it very simply, what is Calum?
The guy's playing chess, you can't play checkers and beat him at
chess. You can't play beat someone who's playing chess by playing
checkers. So whatever game your opponent is playing, you can only
defeat them in that game. The scholars of Hadith they were
against the Hannah Bella were against it would have been sad,
because they said you're playing their game. He said the only way
to feed them is that their game? As I gave the example, the
Europeans don't come to us with guns. And we come with spears and
say the Sahaba had spears and swords and horses, he comes with a
tank and a machine gun. You better have a tank and a machine gun or
else you're not going to have a country right?
So same thing if he comes with you with pathos with emotion, you come
with emotion. If he comes with a, an argument, you have to come with
an argument you say and social media has made all of us have to
be debaters if not a debater than at least I would want people to
see what the guys doing. Okay. And I say this because in the past,
you didn't have to do this.
In the past, a Muslim can live his entire life and never be debated
in his Deen. I can guarantee you most of our grandparents, no one
ever tried to debate them in their Deen. Right? So they have to do
this. That's why this stuff is unnecessary for them. Okay, it's
useless for them.
The same way for us? Well, I bet you some of your grandparents had
to wait grain to pay the cat on grain. Do you know how to weigh
grain
I don't even know what a grain looks like, well, I don't even
know what it looks like. I think I know what a wheat stock is because
it's on the Wheaties box. Right? But what is the wheat stock? Like?
What do you even do? Right? Do we even know? have no clue. But our
grandparents I guarantee you one of your grandparents, one of our
grandparents had to study and learn how to pays a cat on green.
And what did they do? They put it into 10 baskets and one basket for
Zika How do you do this? What What's the measurement? I can tell
you the measurement. Like five Elsa What is it Wesak
I don't know what it What's up is right it's like the limit of when
do you have to pay to cut on grains like five also, but all I
know is words. I don't know what it was it looks like is it this
much this much? Who knows is a roomful So certain things in
certain areas they don't need certain areas. We do need them.
Even Dr. Hanselman hatch. Alright.
Dr. Hadden, masha Allah, He is one of the I will tell you honestly,
he's one of the best scholars we have in the country. He told me
with his own mouth, and I think he said it in the podcast. We are in
dire need for learning this argumentation. Not to argue but to
show Muslims how to come out of these traps that these people put
us in. They try to put you in and you just get frustrated and you
hate on them.
Well, we hit on them for fun anyway. But at least we know the
arguments. Alright, let's go start fire.
Today, we have to keep it on the topic of I would hazard a Shetty
on the basic rules of logic, the purpose of of color, and its
application in this world.
What is asking people for med that?
Med that does not when you ask people for we're not going to go
too deep into anything outside of the topic. But when you ask for
method
that the assumption there is not that the one you're asking is the
creator of the method. He may be the means of method. Right? So if
I say method, Dr. Rasulillah. Does that does that mean that I believe
that the prophet is the creator of method? No. Does it mean it could
mean that he's the creator of method, or it could mean that he's
the means by which I gain Allah's method. Therefore it's permissible
to say that by language and what's the proof of that the Quran itself
utilizes when when I call for something, it does not necessitate
that they that that person is the source of the think he could be
the means of the thing. The verses aren't at the top of my head right
now. I'm going to get those verses to be able to repeat them later
on. But there are clear verses in the Quran that indicate that when
I asked for something or when I do something good, does not ALLAH
SubhanA wits artists say say Nisa is a creator. What taco loco may
not clean K at a bite. But some philosophy, fair Kunal Baden
Baden, Allah, Bethany,
you will create from mud, so is he really created or he's the means
of the creation, Allah is the real creator, but he's the means. And
Allah uses the word risk. And he applies it to people you will give
risk to other people are you the creator of that is or the means of
the risk. So we when we say medit, we are saying he is the means of
method, not He's the source of method method for anybody. I can
get method I can get method by going to my mom and making her
left. If you go and do that, you're gonna get method from
Allah, I can go to a book of scholarship and read essay, all
right, metadata a mammal has any, what does that mean? That this
knowledge is a source of method for me meant that is anything
good, anything sustenance, that is spiritual in nature, unseen
sustenance, okay. Or physical sustenance does not mean I believe
he's the source of metod. Good. It means he's the means of mitad and
it means that my studying it or my being in his company, or my
thinking about him, reading his biography, or whatever I've got,
is a means of a thought from Allah subhanho wa taala. That's all it
means. And therefore, there is no issue and so you get
what I do to control anger is so far the prophets I seldom gave
that much is too far.
All right, how are we doing on the Insta?
Metric ladies and Ashley's? We covered that very subtle
differences, essentially no major differences. Skip over the three
main rules of months if
you're going to give our VR question for today, can you turn
this young lady's mic on please? This young lady by the ways of a
hum so just in case anyone thinks that got some funny business going
on here? Make sure the mic is close to your mouth. So
when think about Munchak logic is the same word
As speech, so let's take it from speech, the moment someone utters
a word in a dialogue with you, that word must have a definition.
Defining a term, define it and the definition must be jam Enter, it
must include everything that it is an exclude everything that is not
good.
Number two, the rest of your proposition cannot contradict
that term or any term in the proposition. All right.
That's what they call the law of non contradiction versus law of
identity law of non contradiction, then then the conclusion
necessitates that the opposite of that thing is not true. So
whatever truth we come up with, the opposite of that cannot be
true. That's the law of the excluded middle. So if I say be
careful, this tea this cup, this tea is hot.
Does that that necessitates this tea is not hot, and not cold?
Right in necessitates that the opposite is false.
If I say be careful, this this tea is hot.
You any common sensical understanding that it's not cold,
if she's pregnant,
therefore, who her womb is not empty, right? She's dead. She must
not be alive. The Op, if I affirm one truth, its opposite cannot be
true. Which is what we say in our update, if you affirm for Allah
subhanaw taala that, for example, all of his creation is with
wisdom. Therefore the proposition or any proposition that would
indicate CIFA, foolishness in the creation is a false proposition.
So don't ask if Allah can do it. Because the moment you said the
word Allah, you precluded or assumed that all of his actions
are wise. So don't ask me can he do an unwise action? Because by
saying the word Allah you assume that all of his actions are wise,
if you asked me, Can you then do an unwise action? You're basically
negating that said that the word that you uttered, you uttered it
you said the word Allah, okay. So, the, in Islam in the Sharia, by
the Quran by the Hadith, Allah subhanaw taala, all his actions
are wise. He's Hakeem.
He creates nothing with no wisdom, wisdom is a great purpose. So
don't ask the question, Can you do something unwise, right?
The same with that debate of will Allah to lie? Same thing, no
concept. Because when you say Allah is truth, right? That's the
word Allah means everything that he can. So the proposition, or the
question, can that not be the case for Allah is invalid. So be
careful. Don't say the word don't say the phrase impossible for
Allah rather say the proposition is invalid. That's the more
correct statement. Good. Nowhere in the books of that shout and
say, Allah who lay up,
never says that lay lay still Thea la Yom kinako. It's impossible
that what they say is Mr. Hale, Allah Allah, which means this
proposition is invalid when you say the word Allah, because by
saying the word Allah, you assume certain things. So therefore he
asked me if those assumptions can be undone. Good. Next question.
Do we choose a meth lab of our country? Or can we choose after
interest? I believe you should study, study the Imams study the
aka and we're here as activists of knowledge. That's what we are
activists of now. This is the real activism of knowledge, there's
activism and advocating for the oppressed for the poor. We tried
to do a little bit for the poor. Right? We don't have much activism
for the oppressed. Right? Like, it's not something that we really
have here. We should in the future, right? But we have
activism for the poor.
Every Wednesday, and hopefully next week, next year. 2023. But
it'll be Wednesday and maybe Saturday. Good.
But
this is activism, it's spring people to learn the kadaga the
issues and to study them.
And we have a mahute here and hamdulillah now, okay, a school
where people are really studying deep into the books that go into
the details, the motto what we want them to the details that we
won't go here, or in the masjid, we want them to go into those
details. You never you when you read these books Subhanallah them
deep into the seed of something you come out with something that
you never imagined before. Amazing.
Sometimes people say why do Muslims hate the West instead of
saying I don't hate the West, I reconfigure the argument and say,
I hate injustice. And I love justice. I don't go down there.
trap any thoughts? This is from the woods. Where have you been yet
from the woods from the woods had been around for age
Just but haven't seen him for like a couple of months.
What from the is out in the woods?
What from the woods just did it's called the the high ground
maneuver.
High Ground maneuver is when they pull you down into the nitty
gritty of specifics, you pull back up into generalities.
It's called the high ground maneuver
on how to debate Yeah,
I'm gonna make I'm going to rewrite the thing in simple,
simple, just simple principles, because the one book that I have,
there's, of course, Islamic books on how to debate, but I like the
simpler ones. Okay.
Because, but the one that I have was written by a nasty atheist. So
I want to just really reconfigure some he just bought terms. That's
all. Like, what is a high ground maneuver? That's a high ground
maneuver, right?
A high ground, by the way, husbands and wives, they should
not do this stuff with each other. So let's hold on, huh? No, it's
really bad husbands and wives can not do this. Right? It's a good
tool, but it's also like, I mean,
it's no different than a bat or a gun or a knife. Right? And it's
good or bad. Right? You do it with husband and wife. It's you're
gonna have a terrible someone's gonna be upset. Right? And
they come home. Yeah. How do you shut yourself off? Yeah. And
like certain things like gas lighting, gas lighting is
basically the idea of
treating the reality differently. Right? Like, the wife says, could
you not be sarcastic when you're talking to me? And then of course
you are sarcastic? Right? But you say, sarcasm a stuff for Allah?
How could this ever happen? I was caring about you. Right? And it's
like, complete BS salesmen con man tactics, right. But that's how
some people's marriages have to go. So gosh, this stuff is like
it's bad. If you use it in your marriages, Dr. Ed D.
Says cuts Macedonia or they're discussing something I don't know
what that is.
J Perez says Dr. Hatem, you can feel his piety. Not only you can
feel his piety, he knows the purpose of religion, which is
drawn nearer to Allah Tala. And he always goes back to that, right.
And that's what I love about him is that you never lose purpose,
with the purpose, lose sight of the purpose of Dean to learn the
truth to act upon it to spread it to other people. If we lose sight
of that.
Well, we'll are we taking calls we're not going to take we take
calls when Ryan comes back and Sharla because he remembers how to
do that.
Okay, Google Panda is telling us about how the Chinese Muslims had
to deal with Confucianism. Very important, right? And we could
learn a lot from what those scholars did.
The idea of a square can Allah create a square with five sides,
the proposition is false. Because by when uttering square by the
when you said the word square, you precluded or excluded the
possibility of being anything other than four sides. Now you're
asking it to be five sides. So you're negating yourself the prop
put an X on the whole proposition
you already know what the definition is. It can't be
anything else. So why are you asking me for the square could be
something else? Right?
Is there a class on ArcView on this topic? No, not really, to be
honest with you, we should probably put one when you go into
month there's a lot of lesser things in Munchak but it's not
important we need to drill in the three main things because a
regular viewer like this ain't got time to for big lessons, just the
fundamentals and if I tell I'm telling you if you get these
fundamentals right, you can cut ups you can cut out 90% of the
garbage that people are putting out you right
under the under bass beats anything do you recommend to
attain clarity of intellect thought and speech the books of
Kalam as much as you can the lectures of Hamza Karmali on the
existence of God are very good
any questions on Instagram young lady?
Or make sure make sure you scroll up but not too hard because it'll
go out of the app. Yeah.
J Perez Can you talk to other contemporary Hannah Bella? Yes I
will inshallah no problem with that.
The Hannah better when they get into debating atheists, we live
with them. All of social media is a debate world.
Okay, you will be exposed to these things.
They all have to reach in and we are opening our toolbox no sudden
and use it and call it Hana. But I don't care. We don't care. Who
cares about the name sad humbly. It's the tools that matter. It's
the moon that matters, right? And they do and they use them with
atheists, but they may not use them.
Like within their own circles.
We don't have any courses on month but we will inshallah it is in the
plan to provide one
other question speaketh Okay, I'm sorry, I can wear that.
What are the differences between them met to reduce and sharees? We
talked about that a while ago the differences in metrics in our
studies, we discussed that.
The Zog do we say Allah created the laws of logic. Of course.
Allah subhanaw taala when he creates, he creates with wisdom.
The opposite of wisdom is suffer foolishness. Things that they
don't
they contradict one another's foolishness, right? So when Allah
subhana wa Tada tells us everything that's out to do and
what is
good. And when Allah says the word mu been clear, and when he says in
the Quran,
right or the a wedge, no crookedness. What does it mean?
And when he says, No, I just to fix it up and cathedra
words from other than Allah would have much contradiction. The
nature of creation itself, okay, that is must be of wisdom. And the
opposite of wisdom is that it contradicts in itself. Good. So.
So you'd notice he was very good at this, say noticing is tucked
into his works is a lot of these wisdoms. Do you have some salmon?
Speaker? I wanted to ask, like, on behalf of the
audience, like so say, like, you're studying or studying? Like,
how do you know that doubts are coming from, like, sort of closer
to the mic?
So how do you know if?
How do you know if doubts are coming from, like, sort of an
intellectual perspective or like, intellectual source, like the lack
of Kadem? And studying or doubts are coming from like a lack of
spirituality? That's a great question. How do I know if a doubt
was was is coming
from a lack of not from ignorance, or from lack of lack of piety, the
tour, the tour aligned,
the tour lens, that is the darkness of the heart will attract
false ideas.
And light inside the heart will repel false ideas, like you won't
like it. You might not know the answer to it, but you just don't.
How many parents grandparents, there's a lot of light in their
hearts, but they're not learned. So when falsehood comes in, what
do they do? They just don't like? Get this out of my house.
Oh, but you didn't answer the question. I don't care about the
incident, get it out of my house? Because he can't answer the
question he does that he talks about this, how many people have
so much * in their hearts? That's why we said you are pious
in yourself, but you can't lead us. You're gonna lead us into an
abyss as a leader, and you're gonna get sins for that. You must
answer these questions. Okay? Yes, we hate the Mongols. I don't care
if you hate them. They're killing us go to go kill them. Right?
That's what I care about. Mongols are coming to kill us all. And
you're sitting there hating on them? I don't care about hitting
on them go kill them. Right. So there has to be response? The
answer to the question is
you take it to the scholars, if it is a question of a principle, an
abstract principle, then that can be answered. If it's related to
your own state, then it's your iman. Okay, like what? There's a
question of all these logical questions that we're bringing up.
They can be answered by scholars because they're abstract, but was
was like, Is a Lie accepting my prayer? Is he going to forgive me?
That's related to you? That is be solved by your Amen. Right. That's
the difference.
And also speakers.
So my you mentioned earlier hasna. lashari, like sort of, sort of
like his path to weed. I was like, I've been like, sort of defending?
Yes. So then would it mean that every society in every age like
there's a different path to wait 100% Every society and a different
age there's a general path to life and there are special paths to
relay what is what are we specific? The general path of
relay is a bad
take knowledge act upon it, and the best you can That's how simple
it is and do a lot of remember
So Allah, but people will surpass other people
by serving the vulnerability of the OMA that exists at the
community at that time. By filling that gap, that's how they will
succeed. Right? And that's what the word relevance is important.
Okay. So we can sit here and read
chapters on inheritance. Is that not the path of Allah? Of course
it is. Right? Do we have a crisis of inheritance right now? Maybe,
maybe not. I don't think that it's a Tod issue. It may be someday.
But what do we have a crisis of doubts in the hearts of Muslims?
More, or inheritance crisis more, I would say doubts in the hearts
and listen, because of little tick tock video like that. Will could
put a lot of could sway a lot of minds. It could cement people in a
view. Right? So the intelligent one sees Where's there a problem?
Let me go there. And wait into that battle? Because there's more
value in that. Right. So that's where you as they say, they say
that in a bad everyone has is sort of can do the same a bed, but what
service can you do for the community? That that horizontal, a
bed is vertical between you and Allah but horizontal?
That's the difference. So where what you could do that I can do,
what you can do that I can't do. That's how you're gonna succeed.
Excel passed me, that's all my Excel pass you, etcetera. And to
the point that where you're doing something, I couldn't do it. Okay,
I'm trying to do something, you couldn't do it. So on and so
forth. So that's where the value of of each Muslim that's speak.
What happened? Why did you think I was holding it?
All right, next question comes.
There's a lot of questions here. What is the word Abdel and Okta?
The Abdullah and Okta are
Elia? They're the odia they're the Muslims. They're the macmini that
are like the pillars of the of the community, not just outwardly but
any men. They're the ones up keeping the community numerous
says how do we convey the idea of displeasure of Allah to a little
child? Good?
Good. Ooh, someone just put up a, you put that up?
I must be the I must be us. Just put up a
little like the YouTube poll and pull a survey. Do people find more
that they have spiritual crisis or intellectual crisis? Great
question. So how do you convey that Allah will be the, what's you
convey? Allah has created a punishment next to every bad
action.
With every bad action, there's a punishment next to me next year.
With next to that action connected to that action, just like with
every touch of the stove, there's fire, there's a pain, right? And
also Allah has Allah Tada can is displeased with certain things,
even if there was no punishment. Forget that. Yes, we need the
punishments to help us move but
lots out is not his his displeasure is the absence of
happiness, pleasure with us. Right?
The absence of his pleasure with us, we don't say that he will feel
hurt or upset. We will say
the end of the emotion, it's not the emotion itself.
It's the end of the emotions but and so but how do you say that
with to a child, right? Allah doesn't love this. Does not Allah
subhanaw taala says lay your hip and carefully lay your hip. So we
say Allah doesn't love this. And the the absence of Allah's love is
is punishment, right? Is a wrath. There are plenty of TED talks, and
YouTube videos to watch on some of the best debates.
Okay.
Okay, how can we convince littoralis of the importance of
Kadem because they won't waver from the argument. It's not from
the companions. Okay, is getting cut up by atheists from the
Companions
is getting absolutely smashed. And your next generation of youth
having doubts about Islam is that from the Companions, so you guys
go do your own thing. I stopped talking to them and trying to
convinced them you want to be hard headed, the hard headed away want
go about life, when your kids can bring in these questions and oh
seven, then you come running to me, that's what's gonna happen.
Do you didn't talk to them and talk to people at the level that
they understand, right?
They want the Sahaba and the prophets of Allah when he was set
up to level out every single specific did not they give general
rules. Law wanted to 50 left and cathedra if it was from Allah,
then Allah, they would have found much contradiction in it.
Therefore part of religion is showing there's no contradiction
in religion, right effort that's out there don't do not use your
intellect. Therefore there is a way to use intellect. If Allah
says do not use it, there must be a correct way to use it a false
way to use it. Right? So therefore seeking the correct way to use
intellect is from a better it's from the religion. Because Allah
says do not think, therefore there is a correct way of thinking
there's a wrong way of thinking. If I say listen, every
every runner I ever saw is skinny. Therefore runners are skinny.
That's causation and correlation. Because a runner, he may have been
a runner five years ago, he wasn't skinny, right? So it's not the
fact that his identity of a runner does not make him skinny. It's the
running that makes him skinny. Right? So there's causation
correlation, that's a false use of intellect if every single harsh
person that you met was Palestinian
that doesn't mean that Palestinians are by definition
harsh that's just your experience. Stop going to Paterson so much.
Right? Go somewhere else.
All right.
I didn't see Jordans Jordan Peterson messages to the muscles,
but we have to discuss it then. We got to learn Have you had a pause
a video in the middle of playing it? Yeah, I think you can do it.
Anyway.
There's a little that play button at the bottom. I'm sure you can
hit pause. Yeah.
Ma'am, says you mentioned you had to relearn how to start reading
more intently. What steps did you take, the step I took was shut it
like Salah when you make Salah It is haram to eat and drink, write
and speak. I had to recreate a something like that, basically, by
when I sit down and then read intently that I made it a rule
that it not allowed to have any device in the room.
And on the table, no other item on the table. And that your butt
cannot get off that chair until you finish this chapter. So just
like we have rules of Salon, so I made those rules. So the kitchen
table has been completely empty. There's the book, there's a pad
and there's a pencil.
And there's nothing else on the table. And there's no phones in
the room. They're all off. Because if you have a phone in the corner,
it's like a mouse in the corner, you can't stop looking at it,
right? And so it has to be like in the glove compartment of the car.
That's how I have no discipline, right. But if I can do it,
everyone can do it. That's the proof. Right? I have no
discipline. But the fact that I can I've done it and I did it.
That means anyone else can do it. I'm like the hjem because I'm so
easily distracted. But if I can do it,
just because I started off like that doesn't mean I accept it for
myself. Like I hate this concept of being so dependent upon
something we're so distracted. So the first step was getting the
Flip Phone second step is there's these rules. And when discipline
is making a rule and following it for yourself. So shut it off, lock
it up. I even have a big box with a luck.
Put the devices in it, to feel that you feel that piece, right.
All the devices in the entire house are locked up in this box.
It's like we just put the genie back in the lip. Right? So I sit
there knowing that no one on the house is on a device. And you can
just talk now right even the remote control the TV
What's that?
Oh, yeah, it's got to be it's gotta be off. Yeah. I found like
leaving in the car. And then just going on go inside go home and
then just go sleep. Yeah, that's how it is. Believe it in the car.
You leave your phone somewhere and you forget where it is. Yeah.
That's true.
Yeah.
And then when you turn your phone on, you realize nothing happened.
Yeah, like the world didn't change. Right?
Exactly.
Text from your mom's Okay, good. Yeah. So
how should it come and wholesome answer? Where's Allah in English?
The question is problematic. There's it's not premise there.
The quest the premise is that Allah has a location. What's the
definition of a location? It's a physical place, right? Only
physical beings can be in physical places. Allah has no location.
Question is wrong.
Okay, Allah has no location.
But He has His knowledge. He's with us with his knowledge. Right?
He's with us with His knowledge
Muhammad has her. Why is it so hard to unlearn conditioning?
Subhan Allah, it's very true
class. Yeah, like bring up the the topics like handling student to
like how you would default this? Yeah,
I think we're still to really learn the concepts.
Later on.
I'll be fun are lame men allowed to enter into these discourses
come up to Zakka Lohana.
Lay men should be educated by all Listener
step by step before they go into battle, in the same way that you
cannot go into an UFC rink. Unless you're trained, it's illegal, you
can get yourself killed. Likewise, you can get your minds broken and
your your Imen messed up if you go into the ring with atheists, and
with these ideologues without training, but you should seek
training, because if we were in the world of the Mongols, and the
Crusaders was not every child had to learn sword fighting horse,
horseback riding, using a bow and arrow. That wasn't the case in
like, bustle of the second century, I'm sure I would have
actually did not have to learn how to kill somebody, right? Wasn't a
need. But out in Turkey, and Anatolia, the lands of air to rule
the Mongols on the east crusaders from the West, you better learn
how to fight so you're gonna be killed, right? So you have to
learn what you need, and what we need. Right now we're all going to
be exposed to this stuff. So we have to learn it, but do not go do
it yourself. Go learn from somebody. Go and there are videos
out there. There are a shout out on Metro media everywhere
Mashallah. They're growing and there's an and it should be for
the purpose of it not for the label. And it should not be for
the getting into the weeds of uselessness. It should be what is
functional, just like I showed you that trans thing and showed you
where the errors are. It's simple. It's functional, right? It's
practical.
Khadija Aasif says a couple years ago, I wanted to follow the Hannah
EBITA so I found your podcast with Sheikh Hatem. However I ended up I
found the ASHA Ira unexpectedly.
And I hope that it benefited because I personally love seeing
the dissection of this falsehood. It settles my heart to know that
it's dissected and it's thrown in the garbage
shake Hey, could we get some new duat motivation? All right, let me
tell you something. Listen to this. I will give you something
right now. By the way, young lady Do we have any anything on the
Insta?
Huh? What do you mean no?
No comments
Hold on let me give this hadith listen to this beautiful Hadith
Farsi set up when you were said that these are the messengers of
Allah Hollywood yourself. Okay.
And Morocco, call us a draconian or a salatu. was salam. A Morocco
follow the movie Her Rob in record aggrandized the Lord was tested.
Well, Mr. sujood, and as for sujood, federal fee Bhima shaitan.
Make dua in it with whatever you want. There is no limit to Allah
subhanaw taala with whatever you want
for coming on,
coming on, what does that mean?
A happy con and use that jab Allah
it is true that you will definitely be answered. That is
dua in sujood Subhan Allah from Sahih Muslim, let me read it
again. This, this beautiful, it just gives you so much hope and
Allah because the Prophet himself said Bhima Shipton with whatever
you want. Don't put your own limits. Don't make draw on your
own limits, and your own imagination that something's not
possible. Okay. All the greats of dunya and Dean,
their greatness is that they did not take action or attach
themselves to their own limits. We have limits we're so limited, but
I'm asking you, you're king of kings. You have no limits. You can
do it. How I have no clue. Right? I don't even know how I do stuff,
right? I only know I
After it's done.
So you we definitely don't know the power of Allah. But I'm going
to ask this and therefore, everyone has a frustration because
they want something they can't have. And sometimes it's
legitimate. Sometimes it's not illegitimate, and sometimes it's
neutral. Cannot be frustrated. Because I don't have a Ferrari.
That's neutral. We would say, it's dunya waste of time.
frustrated because I can't for example,
get a tattoo illegitimate. gonna fix that to get it put on your
chest. No one can see it, right.
Get it out of your system, get a henna tattoo, but that's
illegitimate, frustrated because I can't drink with my friends. It
legitimate frustration, frustrated because
I can't get married. Legitimate frustration, bring that to Allah
subhanaw taala and maybe your sins and your frustration and your
issues are all based upon this. This gaping hole in your life
that's legitimate. So take it to Allah subhanho wa Taala and
marucho off out the mafia. Rob, what am Massoud federal fee be my
shit Tom for coming on? A happy occasion and your schedule, you
will definitely get an answer Subhanallah mazing Hadith
Why do scholars say read soon as you have seen morning and evening
there's a hadith it is probably a weak Hadith. But we can act upon
it that it makes life easy. Makes the day easy sorry. makes your day
easy for your sweet reading in the morning. It makes your night easy
if you read it in the evening.
Any questions?
Make sure you scrolling unless you
have a great assistant.
If no pay him What are your thoughts regarding for and against
the ongoing health? I never got into that question. Never I've
never got into that question to be quite honest with you. Can we ask
Allah to give us miracles we can ask Allah show us your generosity.
Be generous to me. But don't say be generous to me. And you're not
being generous to Allah. How do I be generous to Allah? Give to the
poor. Give people your time. Give people your good mood. That's your
generosity to his creation. He will be generous to you.
speak into the mic.
If if a person who has her own income calls upon Allah is
absolute desperation will answer it. Yes.
J Perez says we disagree with littoralis. But it's a label being
thrown around in excess nowadays. So let's say let's so tell what
we're disagreeing with. We never attack an individual is no point.
Unless he's on total beta and Cofer then it's obligatory, to
name this person and say this person stay away from this person.
But the concept of refusing to answer a question, because the
terminology was not used by the self is an absurd concept. It's an
absurd concept. Because the Quran and the sources, they have general
principles that we apply to specifics. Okay.
And the harm, the harm, of not answering that question is visible
in front of you. Right? I'm telling you, there was a guy who
told me that his he had friends that were
many friends that he had in Saudi schools, in school in Saudi
Palestinians. And they all came back to America, because they
can't go to college. It's out of it. They grew up all their life.
Instead, he said
the bulk of them are out of Islam now. Why? Because the professor's
the teachers of the Islamic studies. They refuse to answer
most of the questions. This is just from Italy, from Italy, from
Italy, from Italy. Okay, from Iblees
and we have Mohamed Salah he was suddenly you told me it was the
the prophets religion cannot respond to the police cannot show
us the invalidity of his question. Yes, it's from Iblees. But give us
an answer. Right. Respond definitively. Yes. So that's what
we're point is here. Yes, question go.
Share the narration. Yeah, I'll email you the narration of the
Hadith and you put it up and
I'm gonna just send it to your what's
Alright, just emailed to you.
In Arabic, it's just called What's that? What's that? Just what's
what's the what's in the Insta?
All right, next question.
We're like, we're like behind on the questions here.
All right. Next question. What do you have
also but advice for protecting ourselves from the perennial list
just hang out with Safina society people.
We smashed that stuff years ago. It doesn't even exist it the
general idea exists but the actual perennial list philosophical group
they've been they don't exist anymore.
Like they exist but the irrelevant. Sure, like I've come
across like
the general belief exists the general beliefs that all religions
are good that exists.
But the but the philosophical parentless group. They're
irrelevant. They have they've, they they've had splintered.
And all that stuff happens to them. But the, the general idea of
all religions are good, all religions are equal. That itself
is an impossibility. Because the religions say opposite things. So
how are they all acceptable? That means to
is Jesus God? Or is he? Or is he a prophet? Or is he as the Jews say,
a rebel? A heretic?
It's got to be one, right? Is he a god? Or not? God? Is he profit or
nonprofit? Is he rebel? That's so just the issue of Jesus are the
same. So how can you say they're all acceptable when they're saying
opposite things?
Yeah.
Yeah, put it that way. So how do you respond to like, make you seem
out to be a bigot? From because like, that's, like, appeal to an
emotion again, right? What would you say? Like, I say something to
me. Like, you please. I would love to help. You could write very much
you could? Maybe, why why? If I believe you're going to *, it's
my worse of a person. You could I can go to * to write Yeah. So
then like, true and false is not about feelings. True and False is
about revelation from God either accepting or rejecting it. Right?
And understanding it properly.
Okay, but are you saying that like Osama bin Laden gets to go to
heaven, but I can't? He could. Yeah, he couldn't. He'll be taking
all your older name to it's possible alone.
I don't know how he died. On what Dean on what so hate on what he I
don't know. He could be this possibilities. But you're going to
bring me something ridiculous. I'm going to bring you something
ridiculous back like him taken all your hotel aid. Right? Or I'll
take your older name if I make it.
Because you know, everyone's created with agenda and the *.
So if you didn't make it to your agenda, we take your spoils of war
everyone has their place in Jannah. And they're placed in
hellfire.
If you did not make it to your place agenda, all that is open
spoils of war, we're taking it. Okay. What about this? Like,
what's the what about the person? How far like, does it go to
someone else that like, you might get it too
I would say
it's actually
it's true. You get double the other, right, you're gonna take my
other because you're bothering me
and your brother and all the Muslims.
So you get their other
angel. The Vania may say okay, this or that was listed for all
right, Habib said, where is he now? He's in heaven. All right.
This is listed for
what's that guy's name that Dawkins Dawkins or let's just have
you say it's either let's give it to Dawkins. Dawkins, come here.
smasher for him. Okay.
Let that British accent benefit, you know,
Queen's English. Let it benefit. You know what, we're smashing your
forehead.
Okay, you don't like to have them? Do they believe in it? They
shouldn't be offended by this. This joke shouldn't offend them.
He doesn't believe in gender in the first place. If you believe in
it, how about avoiding it, right.
Raj from Connecticut.
Remember who he visited long dua in sujood. In Arabic versus the
old language in the Maliki method you can say, dua in sujood in your
own language, if you cannot speak Arabic, or express you can maybe
speak Arabic You can express yourself, then you could put it
and sometimes you can express some things and you can express other
things. Right? Then in that case, you could you can you know, lower
lower my video and put the Hadith on top. How's that?
Right but the Hadith on top and lower our video. So sometimes you
can't express
it keep going down. Good. You can express sometimes yourself in
Arabic.
You can say to Serbia, you can say other things, but you can express
yourself in Arabic. You're allowed to express yourself in your other
language. So what about like what if you feel like you don't know
what to say? But you feel like you're in need, like you ask Allah
to inspire me with the words. Inspire me with the words. I have
feelings.
I don't know what to say inspire me with the words that I should
say. Can Can someone do like an internal door like that except
Yeah, but with what just a feeling? No like, like, say like
you have a dialogue within your mouth. Yeah. And like you're
saying like yellow like you're making dogs. You can say it. Yeah.
You can say
louder. Someone's asking do you recommend watching Muhammad hijab
hijabs debates, his debates with Christians? I never watched him,
but I think I heard they're very successful. You watch them? Yeah.
Yeah. You did a good job in Baltimore. From what I've heard.
Yeah, he's done a good job in a lot of things.
I think some people just don't like him because he says
everything straight up like he doesn't sugarcoat it. I personally
like him.
I don't know what he's is he admitted Tamia is he? I don't know
that. And I don't care. Right. But if he's, I don't know about his
like, where he stands on those things. Right. But as a general
person, okay, I like him. And I like his theatrics to taking his
shirt off throwing it out the Chinese Embassy. It's great
theater. Right. And you think like, we don't need as many
supporters as we can get and fighters out there. And he's a
huge, he's done so much. And he himself says, I'm just an activist
like he,
himself lowers from his own self and his own contribution to the
OMA. And that's a sign of a sincere person in my opinion.
I don't know what his idea is again, so that part of it because
he doesn't, I don't think he teaches off data online. Right. So
I don't know about that.
But his activism and his debates are I think they're good. Someone
is asking modern SATs early SATs. I don't know what is modern mean?
What is early SATs mean? I don't know about that. But the SATs
today are assayed for do you want to get his videos you go to
Mohammed bin Mustafa Mohammed Omar Mustafa is YouTube channel has a
whole bunch of side food videos with subtitles. Next question.
Louder in the mic
what what is the reference of the narration English in Sahih?
Muslim? The reference? Yeah.
It's so um, so hey, Muslim, you want the number or something that
I don't have for you? Right? I don't have the number, the Hadith
number because all the books number it differently anyway.
Okay, what's the difference between a dua that's accepted,
answered and what Allah will give it to you and will not give you
what you asked?
The Prophet SAW, I said, have answered that question. And he
said, Allah will answer you.
Until you rush. What is rushing almost of Allah is to stop making
dua and say,
I asked but Allah didn't answer.
So you will get your answer of your DUA. Allah will satisfy your
heart and you will be happy with the results.
until or unless you quit, and say I'm not I tried and Allah didn't
answer me if you reach as long as you never give up on it and not
giving up is such a quality that is so important. And some youth
they have enough's right, and their neffs keeps falling into
temptations. And they ask why is this happening? Because, okay,
they because Allah is teaching you how to not give up
with your own knifes your own little snake inside of you or your
own dog inside of you. Don't give up. You go on with life year, one
next year, two years, five years, 10 years, I've been fighting my
knifes. Allah is teaching you not to give up. And if you can do
that, and win that battle and see that one day your neffs will come
and stop. And that dog will just kill What's the word for dogs? Is
it heal or to
heal? And he heals you Wow, that took me 15 years.
Then anything that takes you five years is easy. Right after that,
because you've taught yourself for 15 years. Next question.
Why do we have to make Dora why doesn't Allah just give anyway?
Why do we have to make dua why does it Allah give anyway? Same
reason why do you have to eat? Okay? Because there's a value in
the journey. That's why,
who asked us the question, tell me the name.
I live either live unseen, because there's value in the journey.
There's a human growth in the journey. Why does it Allah calm my
neffs in the first place? Because Allah wants you to learn certain
things on the way to that. So there's value in the journey.
There's growth of human in the journey.
David was the fool. David
is immuno Kodama humbly Yes, he's a pure humbly David Wood. I'll
tell you why he's a fool. He said, he put out a video, a challenge to
all Muslims. Show me the explicit verse in which Allah says that the
Bible has been altered. There's so many verses in which Allah accused
of it but he said no, it has to say the engine has been altered.
When you say Allah does not have to use the words that you chose.
That's number one. Number one, there are many verses I can give
you other verses there are many Hadith that in general show that
the previous texts have all been altered. But let me give you
something else. The Allah subhanaw taala.
Just as epistemology, you do not need to say get something from
transmission that is an observable reality, the Quran is transmission
does not need to tell you observable reality.
If you're asking me that, Where's the proof that the Quran has been?
Or that the Injeel is altered? The Bible is altered. I asked you show
me the NGO in the first place. You don't have it. The original Bible,
where is it? The Bible, this Bible that you all have is just seated
books, no offense to the Catholic people because I have a lot of
Catholic associates that we get along well with. I like them as
persons as an individual. Of course, their their their their
religious differences are known. But for these Protestants who are
like rabid dogs and the Wahhabis of Christianity, okay. These
evangelicals not all of them again, because some people maybe
have envy angelical parents and they don't want to get upset fine.
Show me the actual engine. That Prophet Jesus recited with his own
mouth. Okay, you don't have it. You have translations of the
Sierra the Sierra the book of like what is it marked Paul Luke
you don't even have the original forget alteration you lost the
whole thing
a so illogical and then on top of that,
they acknowledge it and they acknowledge it it's like divinely
inspired by so and so on. Yeah, exactly. I that's what I studied
at Georgetown and Rutgers.
Hilarious there's a new we have a new emoji that Alex made the
gender Bell remember the gender Bell we used to ring that bell
every time someone brings up gender
there's a gender it's on the YouTube chat there Alright next
question
Prophet Muhammad but not in sujood Correct.
Repeat
do I take you It recommends to send solo on prophet Mohamed
salah.
But not in sujood I don't understand let me say
is saying draw and who I have no clue. Draw etiquette
etiquette etiquette by
NAMM I guess that is
to send Salah on the messenger sallallahu alayhi wa salam it is
you can mix a lot on the Prophet and sujood could his da Allahumma
salli wa sallam better gotta say the company
actually, actually have a question Do you have like anything written
on like when you shouldn't is upon us. When should you not say Salah
on the messenger sallallahu alayhi wa sallam. You should not say
Salah on the messenger. You should not mention the Prophet in front
of someone who is so angry. He may say something against the Prophet.
It's haram to bring up Deen in front of someone who's so angry
that he may say something inappropriate. It's haram to make
Salah on the prophets mcru in any manner or way that is
inappropriate or in a place that is filthy things like that. Yeah,
those types of things. I know that enough, they actually haven't done
this. You haven't seen an Aberdeen like he listed out like certain
situations that you shouldn't be saying so like, like when you're
scared, you shouldn't be saying so. Um, so that'd be like all of a
sudden, like, really? Yeah. What's the reason for that? I'm not sure
what's his demeanor on that. But I know there's other things too,
like you shouldn't say out loud in the second football. It's
specifically to the NFL. I'm not sure if it's, we don't have any of
that stuff.
We don't have that. When you're scared not to mix on the Prophet,
like someone like jumpscares you all of a sudden, and what is he
going to say? What else would you say?
Hmm? I don't understand that. Maybe he has a logic but I don't
understand it.
Caitlin, I made this Takata
I didn't get an answer yet. What's the point? At what point am I
wasting my time? I asked you Caitlin. How bad do you want it?
If you really want what you're asking for, you're willing to
wait. Simple answer, right?
Hmm.
How bad do you want it?
If you want it bad enough, you'll wait for it. That's the rule.
You'll wait 1000 years for it.
Okay, go. Next question. Can you give me the charger? Rick?
Do I request from what I've had them in May Allah subhanho wa
Taala give him Jannetty for the dose. I mean, do out for these
people. It's almost like an honor for us to be making dua for them.
May Allah subhana wa Tada given genitive for the dose. He was the
inheritor of Morava Ted Hodges teaching position, and may Allah
subhanho wa taala. Give him genesis for those without any sub
and may Allah Tada. Give him like an inheritor like he has many sons
and their his inheritors of the teaching positions.
Can you recite Sinatra watching TV? You can make light vicar while
doing other things. That's a position generally you can make
light vicar while doing other things but it may not be as
effective
69 degrees
freezing
no we do 7171 69 Seven years ago
next question
Oh my goodness. We got to go swimming class Avantika la
homovanillic Michelle dunlea Illa Illa Santa Ana stuff we're gonna
do with a class in Santa Fe of course Illa Latina Amendola,
Minnesota hurt what? So Bill happening whatsoever. So the sub
was set
Modula he was about to
run
my goodness.
US