Shadee Elmasry – Is God Bound By Logic

Is Allah bound by logic? Why can't he do anything illogical? It's not

Allah that's bound by logic. You are bound by logic. Your speech is

bound by logic. That's what's bound by logic. So when we say,

Can Allah create a triangle with five sides, we're not saying that

Allah is bound by logic. We're saying your speech, your question

itself, has to be thrown on the garbage. It's nonsensical. Logic

and speech are one thing. Speech is the expression of thought. The

thought has to be bound by rules. It has to be sensible thought.

Every word has a meaning, the whole construction of the sentence

and the passage should not contradict itself. Essential two

rules of guiding your thought. So it's not Allah that's bound by

that your speech is about my logic. So rephrase the question

and bring me a better question, a sensible question. He's here. You

broke the rule of identity. You said triangle, then you said five

sides. That's a contradiction, so don't ask for that.