Shadee Elmasry – If Allah Creates Actions, How’re Criminals Guilty Ashari Aqida Answers

We're gonna start by responding to a video essentially mocking the

sad al Qaeda. And unfortunately, if you run amok, you need to get

your facts straight first and you need to understand this Imam what

he's saying here is that the ASHA Ira holds that Allah is the

Creator of all things, he's the only creator and that even your

action is a creation of Allah and that when and he gives the example

of striking a bottle, if I were to strike a bottle, then my striking

is created the breaking of the bottle is created and Allah

created both simultaneously. But I should not believe according to

the SID, if he's correct about this, that I have power to break

the bottle, nor does the law of gravity nor any of these physical

laws have any creative power in themselves. This is our attitude

and our belief. So what he says now he's a you know who likes this

optina criminals because criminal could come in court and said, Oh

Allah, I didn't kill him, but his killing happened at the same time

as I shot him. Okay, the first thing is Allah subhanaw taala

attributes all creation to himself, that he como la hora

Bukom, La ilaha illa who Kalia cuckoo Lishui

is the Creator of all things and your actions is one of them. How

about the next one? Well lo kala Coco even more explicit when Matt

maroon, and Allah created you and what you do, therefore my actions

are creations therefore. So what do I have? Now? Let's go to the

AIDS and cusp, the red one. What does it mean when I just did this

or I lifted my phone or I spoke? It's called CASP is to earn that

with your intent, Lucha Marchesa, but while Aicha Makita, civet,

each gains whatever good it has done, and suffers either

punishment of the bad that it has gained. Right you have gained that

you haven't created it. And what's the ruling on saying that other

than Allah can create? Allah says, I'm Jai Lulu he showed aka kala KU

culty he have they made for Allah partners who created a creation

similar to his creation. So therefore that's the shadow of the

day right there. Who associates or attributes created creative power

to other than Allah subhana wa Tada. He's given a divine

attribute to created being and that would be Schick and this

doctrine that things can have impact on the world, or they can

create or they have the power in them, or even that Allah put the

power of creation in them. At that point, number one, we don't need

Allah then, at that point, there are multiple creators all over the

Earth at any given time, millions of creators at that point of

divine attribute has been installed into another creation.

This is a mortality doctrine 110%. And by the way, let me tell you

this, too. It's not even the humbly creed. Let me read you this

even appeal humbly says there are studies in the Orthodox henna, but

I believe in the same doctrine of caste, which is in the contrast to

what had been Timmy had preached. We'll call it a Sharia in Albury

coyly call upon the fit him we'll call Phil CASB mechana. The SRE

said about cusp, what we said essentially the show ahead of that

is what the shadow said and what the Hanabi has said, is one in the

same on the matter of caste and what the reality of it is that

what he's citing is evident to me his view and and it's also the

Morteza his view, the HANA biller hold this view that we're just

talked about the Aesha IDs which are the magic is in the Chevy's

and the HANA fees, which are the Metro DD So who would you leave

out? And you're mocking them? How about have some common senses

Okay, that's an opinion whatsoever. It's not even opinion

it's it's not the nostril Quran halaman Kala Coronavirus Allah

Sheikh Imran are Hanafi teacher said the man in the video he says

that a criminal comes shoot somebody and says no Allah, I

didn't shoot. Okay, my action was created. It's just He died at the

same time my bullet hit him. Wait a second. You're using shooting as

an example did not Allah say in the Quran? You did not fire the

arrow but Allah fired it will mount I might be able to meet

showing us the hotkey of things. Yes, you you have the cusp of that

me. But the hulk of the Remi is for Allah wa made to ever meet

Wella can Allah Rama so on our belief in our Arcada which is very

simple, based on two as of one a of Quran is enough for this is

that no one brings anything out of existence except Allah subhanaw

taala every single thing is created by Allah to Allah and what

we humans do is called cusp. So when I say you broke the bottle, I

mean by that you earned that. You did it, meaning you earned it, not

you created it. And it is lawful to speak in terminology that

sounds like like creation, it is lawful, is ALLAH SubhanA which

Allah says in the Quran, the angel of death, who takes your souls,

but we believe that he's a means

Not the end to the taking of the souls. He's a means and not the

end. So that gives us permission to say you saved my life with the

belief that you are a means of saving my life, not the source.

How simple is that? Tell that brother, whoever that Imam is

you're legally responsible for castes but not creation. Allah

subhanaw taala also says yeah, you and us with guru Namath Allah

Alikum Hellman Hala Coronavirus, Allah, it's right at the top of

suited sub. Is there a creator besides Allah, a theater whole

Hulk? We say we have no impact. We haven't we don't bring anything

out of non existence only Allah brings anything out of existence.

Are we done with this? I think I think we've got everything right.