Shadee Elmasry – How is fair that some people never got the message
![Shadee Elmasry](https://artwork.muslimcentral.com/shadee-elmasry-150x150.jpg)
AI: Summary ©
AI: Transcript ©
Yeah, so there's a kid who was born in India and never met a
Muslim never heard of a prophet. Everyone pressured him to worship
an idol. And he persisted that way until he died. How was he guilty?
But there's a snug premise in there. In logic, you have to look
for the snug premise. It's not premise, which means an idea that
was snuck into the question. The idea is Who told you he's gone to
*?
That's a snug premise. We know Abu Lahab is in *. We know Pharaoh
is in *, we know Satan is in *. Do you know anyone elses?
No, we know that they may have died on a path that is
unacceptable. Right? The pagan path leads to * for short, the
pagan path leads to *. Just because the path leads to *,
you don't you can you have no right to say the people on that
path who died on that path are in the hellfire. So part of our
constant doctrine of salvation, is that we're not we are not allowed
to make a comment on who's in * and who's not. So this nut premise
there is that they had no chance and they got put into *. Yeah,
maybe they had no chance. Maybe they never received a profit.
Maybe they did. But their family pressured them so much and their
intellect was weak. Okay, their personality was weak. Okay, that
might be Altru. We don't know how Allah is going to treat him in
Africa. So