Shadee Elmasry – Hanafi Maliki Shafii Hanbali Ep. 4 Debunking Madhab Myths

Why are there four Imams why the why not others, those four Imams

came in an era after the first three generations that some of

them were of the end of the third generation. And some of them came

after, where knowledge began to get written down and systematized

that it began to systematize their knowledge, and they began to write

it down. And these were the leaders in that field.

In the realm of, let's say,

technology, technology generally came about computers, and that

love that type of tech came out a certain time, you ended up with

certain leaders. And today, you can count the people who make

computers, your hits, you're either gonna get an HP, you're

gonna get a Sony, you're gonna get a Mac, you're gonna get or

whatever else, Samsung, it's not 100 people who make computers, at

a certain point, they take up the whole market, and no, there's very

hard for anyone to enter the market. So what at the beginning

of a certain era, there come a lot of people who do it, but

eventually, some dominate over others. And at that time, could

say there were 11, that span of 100 200 years, there were 11

mothers,

loving, four of them survived. Seven of them just died out. They

didn't have enough followers, and their books are there, but we

don't revive them because we need certainty. We don't know who

transcribe those books. We don't know if there are mistakes, the

books a month app must be living. So the question of why are there

four, simply put it, these were the first to document and codify

knowledge and put it all in one methodology. And there were many,

but not all of them survived. Just like many people come into any

industry and make cars. You know how many car companies there were

in the 20s, and the 30s, in the 40s. But not all of them survived.

And you end up with a handful of car companies, it's very hard to

get into that market. So now, you end up that's how we ended up with

the four schools and the format.

As we said earlier, we talked about why meth labs exists

because of how they interpret the unneeded

texts in equally vehicle or speculative texts.

And we talked about how the new matters come about and we talked

about how they manage Hadith. These are the reasons why

metaphysics now, let me give you a simple example of how the format

ABS differ with one another. And this isn't exhaustive by any

means, but it will give you a good idea. First of all, the difference

of the opinion of Abu Hanifa regarding the Quran and the

Sunnah, is that a Quran is always is a superior source to the Sangha

is a superior source to the Sunnah, the end and Hadith, which

ends up being the Maliki School of SAP a school and the humbly school

even though it was from era. They say no, no. The Quran and Sunnah

are absolutely equal sources. Now, between medic and a chef a, they

differed on within the sun within the sun, what is the strongest

type of sun? They both agree that the sound Hadith that has many,

many chains is the number one source.

A different now on number two, Maddox said that the actions of

the scholars of Medina and their rulings

cannot possibly be wrong. It is equivalent with the first layer

what's called What's it what's a widespread a Safaree said no

citizen can't say that. And he prefers the solitary solitary

meets came down at one she prefers that over Maddix opinion about the

scholars of Medina Maddix logic was that a is what art is teachers

are doing and be that it's impossible for a whole generation

of scholars that close to the Prophet and the companions to have

made a mistake. It's impossible that they have thought 1000 from

1000 as arrabiata Reisa. So that's a difference between one of the

major differences between magic and a chef. What about Eva

Baphomet Eema Baphomet has a very unique take on this and he holds

all of it to the Sunnah. And every statement of a companion achmad

out of piety and honoring the companions did not want to judge

between them. All of that would be some that that's why whenever you

hear someone talking about how

Very school. They will say in one of the opinions of the company

school because ima achmad honored and respected every pinion of a

competitive

and he hold all of that to be son, Eddie membaca med honored Hadith

so much he preferred a solitary at Eve even a, a not so strong Hadith

over analogy, whereas none of the other three before him would do

that. If the report was not solid enough to make law up odd, they

prefer analogy over the week, Eddie, that's a basic summary on

why we ended up with four methods and how these four differ with one

another