Shadee Elmasry – Hadiths lead people astray How

			That's why you need context. And
this is why thematic scholars
		

			always say, and I've said it, I've
heard it directly. Al Hadith
		

			Humala, right they didn't say
Matera they said Muhammad Allah.
		

			And I thought that's a strange,
that's a harsh thing to say. And
		

			Hadith medulla means hadith is a
source of people going astray.
		

			Okay. And I thought that was
really hard. So why don't you say
		

			metabo that getting lost, like
confused or lost? There's a big
		

			difference being confused and
lost, could be confused is one
		

			thing to go astray. Okay, big
difference between just being
		

			confused or lost and astray. No,
they say it is a cause for people
		

			to go astray. Why? Because none
contextualized and unexplained
		

			Hadith could create for you an
image which is so untrue. And I'm
		

			going to prepare actually a couple
of videos on Hadith that are found
		

			in Rio de Sala Hain very popular
Hadith, that if you read them
		

			isolated without an explanation,
you would take away a very harsh
		

			image of the Prophet peace be upon
him and untrue. image of the
		

			messenger of allah sallallahu
sunnah, right? And that's why
		

			Hadith require a need and
necessitate contextualization. We
		

			have great Tebow, ain and Tibet
Sebin. Like Webb, good. He went to
		

			medic Ibn NS and Latham and Sam
sat. And he said that if it wasn't
		

			for lathe and Malik, I would have
went astray. Right in my Eman
		

			because of Hadith. Not because of
because of on contextualized and
		

			unexplained Hadith, so many a
hadith, that out of context with
		

			just a Muslim be like, how, right,
and there are also so many Hadith
		

			that are so here, okay, that we
don't know the context. And we
		

			don't really know the meaning, but
scholars have suspended their
		

			meaning. So we don't we don't say
that anyone here is a liar. We
		

			don't say the Prophet didn't say
it. But the meaning to us, we
		

			don't know how to fit it. We don't
know what to make sense of it. And
		

			it is a solitary chain Hadith. And
as a result of that, we don't have
		

			to obligate belief in it. The
mimetic does this with the Hadith,
		

			which is found in body of that
said that Adam was 60 yards tall?
		

			Could it be Yes, right? Could it?
		

			Are there challenges to that?
Possibly, right? So mimetic
		

			himself did not obligate, he said,
We don't reject that it's a
		

			hadith. We don't say that they're
liars. But because it's a single
		

			solitary chain, meaning one or two
Sahaba narrated it, not a lot of
		

			Sahaba narrated it, right. So we
don't have the context, we don't
		

			have the full meaning behind that.
Good. So we cannot rule by this
		

			hadith, we cannot make a judgment,
we cannot obligate belief in it.
		

			That's the meaning behind. That's
the way in which the scholars
		

			interact with those such heavy so
when you don't, when it's not
		

			flushed out, and we don't really
know the meaning you leave it
		

			suspended. That's the right way to
handle those heavies. The wrong
		

			way to handle it is to force a
belief on a statement where you
		

			don't know much around left or
right. Okay, so this is also how
		

			why Hanafi and matagi FIP in terms
of their ritual law and their
		

			other law, that they quote,
unquote, contradict certain Hadith
		

			their rulings contradict certain
Hadith so many people get wonder,
		

			Oh my god, the Prophet said
something but the Imam said
		

			something else. No, because the
Imam has other evidences such as
		

			multiple actions by many, many,
many Sahaba. Okay, upon a matter,
		

			so therefore, that hadith must be
an exception, or it must have some
		

			context, it must be limited, and
it's not the norm. So in that
		

			respect, people have to understand
how single change and solitary
		

			Hadith that come from just one or
two sources that don't have any
		

			context, how we accept them, we
believe that they're from the
		

			prophet but we don't have the
context to apply them. Okay. And
		

			that's lit literally limited to
just the solitary narrations.
		

			Now we go to the next section
here, it says welcome agile hockey
		

			molded by happy you