Hadith 681 – Book of Transactions – Part 2

share this pageShare Page
Ibrahim Nuhu

Channel: Ibrahim Nuhu

Episode Notes

681. Narrated Abu Huraira – The Prophet said, “Do not tie up the udders of camels and goats. He who buys them after that (has been done) has two choices open to him after milking them: he may keep them if he wishes, or may return them along with one Sa’ of dates.” (Agreed upon].
Muslim has:
“He has three days in which to decide whether to keep them or
not.” Another narration by Muslim, which Al-Bukhiiri reported as Mu’llaq (with a broken chain), has: “He must return with it one Sa’ of any grain but wheat.” (Al-Bukhiiri said, “(One Sa’ of) dates” is mentioned in more narrations than not].

Episode Transcript

© No part of this transcript may be copied or referenced or transmitted in any way whatsoever. Transcripts are auto-generated and thus will be be inaccurate. We are working on a system to allow volunteers to edit transcripts in a controlled system.


00:00:01--> 00:00:02

Hi Rahim.

00:00:03--> 00:00:11

hamdulillah hinomoto understanding ohana structural. Whenever the belay machinery and personnel Miss Aisha Molina de la Vela Medina.

00:00:13--> 00:00:20

De La la la, la la la la la la la la Cala or Sharona Mohammedan Abu Rasul

00:00:21--> 00:00:26

Allah Dena Amanita la casa de la temujin a la on to Muslim moon

00:00:27--> 00:01:00

sutopo Kamala de Holla Holla Holla caminhada with me no marriage and Cyrano de la Sol Luna de la harm in the lock on our local Raka Yeah, you're gonna topple Ah, Hulu colenso de de la cama cama kilmacolm de novo, Omani de la solo confianza frozen aldila modified knuckleheaded Nikita will la wa sallam howdy howdy Muhammad sallallahu alayhi wa salam o Shara mala, Madiba Hakuna Matata gembira loka la vida de la la la la la la la la

00:01:06--> 00:01:09

last week, we were

00:01:10--> 00:01:13

discussing the Hadees of Abu huraira la Han

00:01:15--> 00:01:21

honkala and in the V center Allah Allah, Allah Allah La to Saru La Bella

00:01:22--> 00:01:29

weligama family Taha bow at another run by Danny Alba.

00:01:30--> 00:01:34

inshallah, I'm Sokka and shout out the house army in temple.

00:01:35--> 00:01:45

Last week, we talked about the general understanding of the Hadith. So today inshallah we'll move on to the commentary mentioned by Allah medicina.

00:01:46--> 00:01:57

Kala Rahim Allah oscillators really helps you call this array to mA inhabits to Alessia view here up to a coffee and Nakata wish it was alcohol

00:01:59--> 00:02:00

halabi ha

00:02:01--> 00:02:02

ha

00:02:03--> 00:02:03

ha.

00:02:05--> 00:02:08

Sort of lol masurian America harder to

00:02:09--> 00:02:11

Colombia the Quran, Hadith Al Baqarah.

00:02:12--> 00:02:15

So last week, we talked about the definition which is

00:02:16--> 00:02:44

the first you mentioned by Alameda Sinani supported by the definition given by Imam Shafi. So whatever a person does, to the place, the breast of a camel or animal or whatever animal that somebody wants to buy from the domestic animal where milk is needed is one of the intent and the maqasid of that transaction. If somebody does something to increase the milk,

00:02:45--> 00:02:54

this is what Tesla is all about. So last week, I guess we talked about this issue without is enough Carnival Howdy.

00:02:56--> 00:03:01

Na Na ve sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, and it was written in haiwan either either by

00:03:02--> 00:03:19

no kawara tequila right in the sidecar. What are the tequila who feel watching this IB loves, beloved LA to San Juan Manuel. So let me listen. And he said, this is restricted to the circumstances where somebody wants to sell the animal.

00:03:21--> 00:04:00

They get it because there is a Tesla, which is based on what the owner of the camera or the animal just want more milk. And then he does that he gives me something or he do the normal way to get the milk increase. So in this Hadith of the Prophet sallallahu alayhi salam are restricted to the circumstances of selling, and when a person who wants to sell his animal, but he does that, so that what he called the buyer will be deceived will think that this one has a lot of milk, or this is the culture or the nature of these animals. If I buy it, I'm going to get a lot of milk from it.

00:04:01--> 00:04:28

Whereas the case is not like that. So she's going to take the milk for the first time the second time he might not get anything. So this Hadith of the Prophet sallallahu sola collected by a woman as I said, this is restricted to the time of what the sale if you are not selling then you can do it. We're going to hear inshallah the sentiment of the scholars concerning that matter of theorizing. Lahu Inaba Hydra camicia will look hotter.

00:04:29--> 00:04:30

Ha, ha ha.

00:04:33--> 00:04:40

Roger in the zoo, de la Italia bit leads to al Qaeda, Al Qaeda in the neelum.

00:04:41--> 00:05:00

Susa mamasan. He said, in another region, the Prophet salallahu alaihe salam says if somebody sells a sheet he sheep or a camel the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam I said, let him take the mode first. So that the one who buys it will not be deceived because if I'm willing

00:05:00--> 00:05:43

It it will be empty right it will be empty. So, the guy will know whether it has milk or not. And also he will be able to make a right decision is Elijah which you will regret in the future Anwar Raja in the jungle and this is the opinion of the vast majority of the scholars that this area is only restricted to the circumstance of of sale of a transaction. Where it Delilah Italia Louisville Harare, what tiddly. And I made us and it said one of the the fact that supported this is the totality of the justification mentioned by the scholars, concerning the matter of the provision of this kind of what he call attitude, they said the the basis of that the ground for that is what

00:05:43--> 00:06:34

Teddy's the least is treated right to this world. And also, a person doesn't know whether it will continue or not. There is no certainty in it right? So the professor la Silva said you shouldn't do it colloca para amines and it said this is what is said by the scholars, very seldom are Italian edema matsusaka. But I couldn't find where this tiny decertification is mentioned from the Sunnah of the Prophet salla Salah. And as usual, I will also dwell on this part mean to warn everyone and we have to open our eyes you have two kinds of justifications in Islam. In fact, you get it you have two kinds of tally Tally. I mean two kinds of alien in a lemon sauce, Allah wilderman Susan Carmen

00:06:34--> 00:06:51

Susannah, do you have those justification which Sherry I mentioned, what I mean by justification, Allah make something prohibited, and he says because of this and that, so we know the cause of that is this, if this is gone, you might say the hokum is God, because the guy that says what

00:06:52--> 00:06:55

can we do? man that he will do then

00:06:57--> 00:07:27

that is totally there in comes a suffocation comes? And then Sharia says this hair comb is tightened by this justification, if there is not there, in the movie got K, like a woman cannot pray if she's if she is in the, in the in the state of mentors, inspiration. So the blood during the period of the blood, she will not pray, if the blood is gone. What happened? We said how can we do Roma tea would you know blah, then she prays now

00:07:29--> 00:07:45

the most apparent example is the example of the hanafis with the majority of the scholars, when the majority of the scholars said the only water you can use to purify yourself or to cleanse yourself from the dead nyjah that affects your clothes or your body is

00:07:47--> 00:07:47

the whole

00:07:48--> 00:08:01

city Giovanni Kanata hora while a scimitar him, he was an akuna Tara what a scimitar? Hidden, they said it has to meet the whole not just to get it not just

00:08:03--> 00:08:18

why did they say that they have their own evidence. But they have said no. You can remove an adjuster with them. That is not the whole but it is tired. As long as it is not the adjuster you can remove it. For example you buy

00:08:21--> 00:08:38

you buy food in the restaurant. No sometimes they give you a lot of soup right? You come home you couldn't eat it. This is just an example right? Nobody does that. I'm just giving an example. Right? So you have an adjust on your skin instead of using your water. You use the soup and remove it.

00:08:40--> 00:08:42

According to the majority lemon test

00:08:44--> 00:08:48

you must bring clear water like this and clean it

00:08:49--> 00:09:10

once and administer my Eman ora k according to a half they said no. When you remove it you put the soup The first one is going to be mixed with damages. I will take it away you put the second one also. Then adjust is gone. There is no adjuster they said is okay. It used to come to Sally who

00:09:11--> 00:09:33

said this is the best mother in this issue. Why is that? Because all of them believe in the guy that says and he'll call me a doula and let's he will do the wider until legislation sadly you cannot pray to Allah smarter as long as there is an agenda on you right? What is the what is the reason why you cannot pray to Allah smarter because of the ledgers on you by now there is no data

00:09:36--> 00:10:00

can you pray this year because the data has gone low taberner Allah subhanho wa Taala Benin sauce Katya if Allah smarter says yes, we have to worship Him by using this kind of water and when it comes to cleaning ourselves, we will say yes, this talent from the universe is useless. But if we hit it, we couldn't find enough. I mean a text from the Sharia saying this then we have to

00:10:00--> 00:10:29

Say, no the Kira is I mean, the continuous we have to go with the application of the Kidal. How can you do it? Would you rather? So this is the power of the LM suzani. that the most important thing that you can see Ella that she says this is the law, then we have to follow the agenda. But if Sharia doesn't mention the Illa, we have to be very careful when we say this is the law, we have to mention what this is what appears to be the law.

00:10:31--> 00:10:36

Okay, please do understand this concept properly. This is what appears to us to be there in law.

00:10:37--> 00:10:39

What does that mean? We're not sure.

00:10:40--> 00:10:43

You know what happened? Because if you say this is their ela,

00:10:45--> 00:11:12

and then tomorrow, the ELA is gone. What does that mean? the hokum also is gone. But did Allah tell you this is the ELA know, that the prophets, Allah Azza wa Taala? This is a no, that's why you find nowadays those people who believes in rebar, they're looking for anything to justify the river. So, they will say to you, they have rebar in this thing is this. So my question always is, where does Why is it mentioned in the Sharia, that this is a law?

00:11:14--> 00:11:21

Do you get it? Because if I say this is the agenda, then they will say nowadays the agenda is gone, there has been there is no divide this,

00:11:23--> 00:12:03

but this Allah who wrote it, I am the one who understood Allah did not tell me that the prophet SAW somebody not tell me that he has the understanding of some sometimes also contemporary scholars, not even the old scholars, no contemporary scholars, this is what they understood to be the ALA and they will make it their ala again, your hamedan resource bilotta to hammer home. So this is a very important point when he says well, LEM are talebi Hema matsusaka he said although it is very apparent, but I did not see where it is mentioned by the Sharia. That this is the law concerning the matter. What does that mean? It means in a sense shaky. It is still shaky is not confirmed, but

00:12:03--> 00:12:06

could be the law or law. Or metacity

00:12:08--> 00:12:20

metacity lol by Bally HTML Halle boo in FL Maliki for who over in Canada he either only haiwan illa. And the hula is that he is around for us

00:12:23--> 00:12:29

chefs and amateur Syrian and bye, somebody who has his own sheep or camel and he wants to

00:12:30--> 00:12:56

collect the milk to get it. The way they do it. Sometimes the one the animal gets harmed somehow he get it. But there is a Muslim Hannah Moxon for it. And he was the one who he is the one who owns it. He says Fair Use that he is not harming somebody else. Get it at home, he has his own port, I mean ownership. It doesn't harm somebody else and the prophets Allah Subhan Allah da da

00:12:57--> 00:13:36

da da da da da da da da. So although this happens, I mean the either the harm takes place concerning the animal itself, but since there is a max that there is an objective when the person does it, the scholar said it should be let pass whether he will have it analyzed here in Nevada help me so we're going to right so there are other issues that a person does. They said concerning the matters of your animals. When you do something that benefits you in them which doesn't harm them that much. If it is not like tiny, he gets it without justification. Because like the

00:13:37--> 00:13:41

What do you call this one when they remove the testicle of the haiwan

00:13:43--> 00:13:58

haiwan Maxi together what I mean they do it for a while so that they can have the meat fresh okay you know you know goat you know goats right here in Malaysia as in the city events you go to see them on a television

00:14:00--> 00:14:19

you see the goat the male one carry the male one is past here just in front of the mother. How is a nice smell? You hear bad smell if the male goes not the sheep sheep is okay usually, but the goat if it is to pass through neither Moses I am telling you will know that this goat is passing

00:14:20--> 00:14:25

the smell is very strong. But when they remove the things that grandma koala, this smell is gone.

00:14:27--> 00:14:45

Again is during the process of removing the testicle. Does he get home? Yes, for sure. And not only that, you are going to harm his life. Because after that he cannot what I mean sexually and half he cannot have the sexual relationship with

00:14:47--> 00:14:59

and the female right? Don't say marriage more than no desire to have or not but get it so he can have this so you deprive him from his dunya right. Harmon dove have physical and emotional right? He just cry

00:15:00--> 00:15:18

People they're enjoying their life but he can do anything right. But is it permissible? Yeah, many scholars said is okay. And that's okay. Knowing that also in some narration the Prophet salallahu alaihe salam are the animals he is allowed to slaughter during the what he called for here is an animal that has this.

00:15:20--> 00:15:37

So will allow him so I just want you to understand the thing that if there is an objective, a noble objective, which surely I recognize, you get it, surely I recognize when the animal gets harmed, I mean a bit this one could be tolerated because in Islam you cannot harm anyone including the animals

00:15:38--> 00:15:47

unnecessarily you cannot harm your animal a lot smarter guide us to truth Allah was a hidden under who lays it here elaborate, they'll help me

00:15:49--> 00:15:51

follow the herd etc to be very helping.

00:15:53--> 00:16:21

So check that according to the literal understanding of the Hadees and, and who led Buddha to elaborate. You know, the prophecy last summer, the end of the Hadees he says, For whom heading Nevada, you have option either to go for it or to decline. So chef said according to the literal understanding of the Hadees this here can only take place after the person milk the thing first, and then the milk doesn't come back again.

00:16:22--> 00:16:48

You get it because when you milk it, it will have no milk right? We will not know we have to wait that's why you're going to hear sometime. I mean some scholars said this is one of the reason why the prophets that Allahu Allah Usama said you have a choice for three days because it will not be clearly understood in the duration which is below three days.

00:16:49--> 00:17:08

Because if I milk I finished the milk right? And it doesn't just come like this like like tap I just finished it It comes in automatically. Now we have to wait for us then if it is I mean true it will come again. Anyone will come and replace it right? So Karla the hill had

00:17:09--> 00:17:10

a bottle handy

00:17:12--> 00:17:14

when he began helping

00:17:15--> 00:17:21

if you're going to have the tulcea which is going to be a parent without and help from zero gravity also

00:17:23--> 00:17:25

I mean, the milk was there

00:17:26--> 00:17:27

and then

00:17:28--> 00:17:30

suddenly disappeared.

00:17:31--> 00:18:00

already used right? This one usually doesn't happen. So if I'm going to see this I still have the option even if I don't milk it it has a milk and then I look for the milk there wasn't any milk it goes that's mean something fishy is is that was brutal here the column busy hottie baby Alma sobre. Pipe if somebody sells the camel or the sheep, this transaction this act itself, is it valid or invalid?

00:18:01--> 00:18:09

scholar said it is valid. Because the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam I said, the buyer has an option.

00:18:10--> 00:18:54

That's mean the transaction is valid, because if it is not valid, the processor will tell them the transaction from the beginning is is God is bought it. But he says you have a choice. Either you go for it or you decline that's mean the transaction is is okay. You get it. Because if the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam says something is when he when he actually attacked you, according to the general ruling, if the if there is a prohibition from the Sharia, this one necessitate what necessity to hurry it means you have to stay away from it right. But there are some negations which you will understand through the means of inferences, that the act is itself is valid, but the

00:18:54--> 00:19:06

condition or the way it is carried on is what he call is illegal. So the Sharia will give that person who will get involved in it and option whether to go for it or to decline. Carlos, how do you feel a little

00:19:08--> 00:19:16

bit of creativity you an alpha v califa will be fed another interview on attacking him in various ways ie the Alibaba chef,

00:19:17--> 00:19:22

Pharaoh Ilan who Allah terra cotta, he sallallahu alayhi wa sallam a fellow who was a

00:19:24--> 00:20:00

minister and he said we understand also from the Hadith, that word to be translated only. If you find that you are cheated, the milk is not there. The scholar said you have to immediately take it back. You cannot delay. That's the meaning of the Foley for remains, it has to take place immediately. So promptness is is needed. You must do it on the spot. If you wait and delay then you have no right. You're right. We got that as the opinion of some of the scholars of Shafi but the vast majority of the scholars said though it is for the therapy because the

00:20:00--> 00:20:14

Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam I said fella who Thiago salata he has an option, and he has a choice. He can choose whether to go for it or to decline for three days. The prophet SAW someone gave him three days. What does that mean? As mean it is not alone, Arnulfo?

00:20:16--> 00:20:18

karlovo whoa Jeeva

00:20:19--> 00:20:24

Carlos calavo jiba mintaro fukai bill Foley and adeleke mamula

00:20:26--> 00:20:27

homosassa

00:20:28--> 00:20:47

illogicality, nanocarbon, halacha lanphier Academy, Danica jaws and Oksana de serafina. If you have a D, those people who said is alpha, all you have to do underscore, they said, No, this opinion of the majority is wrong. And now and their justification also is wrong.

00:20:49--> 00:21:10

Why did they mention this because they say the Prophet Allahu Allah yourself, I gave them three days, not because we need the three days and the person can delay the return, they said no, but but the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam was basing that ruling on the norm, because it is not easy to understand the reality within two days.

00:21:12--> 00:21:57

It has to go for three days. Why? Because sometimes some animals, not even animals, even humankind, those people who have children will tell you this, a woman when she eats something, to have a lot of milk, get it when she eats something to have less milk, animals also like that, and the same process right? breastfeeding. So the type of the food also has an impact and effect also in the issue. So sometimes you might give it some kind of food, which will have an impact in the milk, it will not grow will not increase. So you will understand the deficiency but it wasn't because of the attitude of the seller. No, it was because of the food you're giving, right? But in three days, everything is

00:21:57--> 00:22:00

going to be clear whether it has or it doesn't have right

00:22:01--> 00:22:32

to you good idea, because that the seller might give it something without any intention right? You just give it food normal food and then it happens that this food walks in that manner, the milk increases right. So you come in by that moment. So you will understand the reality and the truth within three days. So the scholars of this opinion who believes in that alpha Ria they said because usually this type of cheating or deception cannot be discovered within I mean, a period which is less than three days.

00:22:33--> 00:23:03

That was their opinion on Allah to Allah Murphy aka lemon Valley College was in Santa Fe, Santa Fe. Alavi when we will end the theory of matter what how we for who will be had never any be theory either and yahooza our Rhoda so they're trying to defend their opinion they said in their way of imama how we murder him Humala. It is mentioned that the professor last summer said for who will be a Heidi another a he has one of the two options. He got it.

00:23:05--> 00:23:10

Bill Chiarella and yahooza until the time he decided to keep it or

00:23:12--> 00:23:14

or to return it back immediately.

00:23:15--> 00:23:44

It means he has two options, either to keep it or to return it so when the prophet SAW said you have two options either to keep it or to return it that means the professor someone did not give you a chance to stay and think when you discover the cheating either you take it back or you keep it with you. So when you keep it without taking it back we understand that you decide to keep it with you. All right, and you don't have any choice later on to go on. claim any deficiency in the in the in the item you bought it

00:23:47--> 00:23:50

to sell it for V 11. For Kayla,

00:23:51--> 00:23:59

at work a lemon and delicate pie we take three days according to the Hadith of the Prophet salallahu alaihe salam, when do we begin

00:24:00--> 00:24:06

these three days begins from when some scholars said from the time you discover the teslin

00:24:08--> 00:24:13

Some scholars said no, you should start calculating from the time of the

00:24:15--> 00:24:21

war kilometer for some scholars said from the time you depart it you are separated from each other.

00:24:23--> 00:24:28

The one who says from the time of Austria for example. I bought it today

00:24:29--> 00:24:48

and then I realized that Tanzania tomorrow. Tomorrow, Sunday right? So I start calculating from tomorrow because tomorrow I know that this animal I mean it was Massara. So the calculation should begin from tomorrow. The one who says me works in

00:24:49--> 00:24:59

the from the time where the when the contract was established. When do I start calculating from today because today I finalize the contract

00:25:00--> 00:25:43

Get it the one who says minute differ from the time who is separated in the thing happened in the market from the time I left the market. And also you have to apply on this differ recall. So, the old controversy of the scholars that says, who wished for broke the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam is talking about in transaction, he says Albion even here Mr. Limited Baraka, he said the two contracting parties, each and every one of them is upon what yarmulke metaphoric as long as they're not separated from from each other. You get it to what what separation the professor someone is talking about. The jury of the scholars said what, at the federal COVID wha hoo, la shala? The one

00:25:43--> 00:25:45

who says at the federal court,

00:25:46--> 00:25:54

the physical kind of separation, not spiritual. Some of them said no at the federal COVID awkward separation

00:25:56--> 00:26:03

through the words and based on the words, for example, I want to buy something from from drama

00:26:04--> 00:26:07

of drama, and how much is this drama told me tendering?

00:26:09--> 00:26:50

Okay, I pay nine doing it? No, no, you have to add weight Bergin until the time he agrees 950. Right. I agree. I agree. Right? And then I start asking, man, how was the class yesterday? Did you manage to go to this? I mean, I change the topic, we are first buying and selling something now I change the topic. They said, This is the fourth book that the Prophet Allah is all about. It means Carlos, we finished the deal. Now we get engaged in something else. At this moment, if I decline, it will not be permissible for me to take my money back after a man has a right to tell me No, I will not give you the money back. If I understood the productivity farooqui Allah call, because I already

00:26:50--> 00:27:29

changed the topic, I started talking about something else, which is not part of the transaction. But according to the majority of the scholars, they said no, until you are completely and physically separated. To get I buy from you here. And then I go out of your shop, finish. If I want to return it back, I have to come through the means of Jakarta, Jakarta means I have to beg you, if you agree, you return back the money and I give you back the item I take back my money if you agree, but I cannot force you to agree after the separation. And this is what is intended by the professor law. So but now, the problem we have is, if you buy in the places where there's a third row, I mean, it

00:27:29--> 00:27:41

could be prolonged, like in the aeroplane, you traveled 12 hours, you know they have some sales in inside, right? You buy something? Where's the margin is locked in the aeroplane.

00:27:43--> 00:27:50

When this happened, when you land at the airport, after what after how long? 12 hours, for example.

00:27:51--> 00:28:06

So let's say they brought the thing right after we take off. You get the started distribution and I bought at that moment. I did not tell them I don't want until 15 minutes before the landing.

00:28:08--> 00:28:16

Then I call those crews I tell him while I decline. How come? I told him the professor last summer said I'll be here.

00:28:17--> 00:28:21

Well, let me taraka the Do you think he will agree? No, I would never

00:28:23--> 00:28:54

there will be conflict between me and him. That's why some scholars said because according to the NUS the Hadith of the Prophet, Sal sama, I have a right to decline. Because still we are not separated yet. We are still in the midst of Act. But also Islam says then a sense of Sharia says what law one other under us and he will get home. Because if I decline at the very beginning, he might find somebody to buy it from him. But if now I decline colors, who's gonna buy at the last minute,

00:28:55--> 00:29:08

so he will get home. That's why the scholar said it is always better for them when we look at it the dinosaurs amorite but it's always best for the seller to have a condition

00:29:10--> 00:29:21

there is no decline as long as as soon as you pay and I give you the receipt, the case is closed, you cannot return it back. If I agree he agrees, then this is okay.

00:29:22--> 00:29:24

I can only return it back if there is a deficiency.

00:29:26--> 00:29:59

If there is a deficiency, I still have my own choice to return it back. But other than that, I cannot just return it back just because I decided to take another way. Is that clear? So that's the difference. So whatever you believe in this is what the scholars have mentioned, some scholars said that philosophy should begin from the time of the test Leah. But if you look at the text of the Hadees philadephia means from the time you discover the cheating, you have three days to do what three days to decide whether to take it back or to return it but am mccannon

00:30:00--> 00:30:01

Last year,

00:30:02--> 00:30:23

there is somebody who who said that amongst the scholars, either we start calculating from the time where the transaction is finalized or we start calculating from the time where the cheating is discovered. Always that calculating the days three days from the time where we got separated from each other, Allah Allah Kala Waddell, how do you know who your

00:30:25--> 00:30:26

Nissan min temporary?

00:30:27--> 00:30:35

Buhari yubikey design meantime in the Rajya Sabha you write a temporary Likoni why the thermometer no

00:30:37--> 00:30:50

way the saboteur new euro dollar Mr. Issa military philomath masala tea fella sasakwa. So he said we understood also from this hadith that a person who wants to return back the item because of the cheating he discovered.

00:30:52--> 00:30:57

He has to return along with that. What do you call the camel? He has to return one else return.

00:30:59--> 00:31:03

Assad have a date, which we discussed also last last week.

00:31:04--> 00:31:25

He says Allah minister Ronnie, we conclude this issue since we have to return back the date right we get from the Hadees that we have to give a tumble right but there are other narration which says Tom food without any sophisticated specification. So he said we found that the scholars argue concerning the matter.

00:31:26--> 00:31:40

We get it we have three aquat here the first one is the opinion of the vast majority of the scholars minister however to tap in or be bad at what Dylan Masada. So majority of the scholars from the companions of the Prophet sallallahu Sallam on the tablet

00:31:41--> 00:31:52

and viral? They said yes, we have we do have a right according to the Hadith to return back down to more together to work together with the PSA, that kind of

00:31:53--> 00:32:18

a date, the measurement of the date, we have to return back the animal with the date, that amount of detail. So on kind of level, looky here in our calendar, whether the milk you got from it is little or more. What terminal quarterly availability? Whether the timer is the food of the people or not, like here in Malaysia tomorrow, is it food? No, is fruit.

00:32:20--> 00:32:24

Food. Food means something that you eat when you're hungry.

00:32:25--> 00:32:30

And that's why I find it strange when the scholars differentiate between code and the normal food.

00:32:32--> 00:33:06

To get my actor to wholeness, and he when I when I see you and I asked you where you go and you tell me I'm very hungry. So where are you going? I'm going to the restaurant to do what? To eat some apples. I will say what, brother you're not hungry. Just looking for something camellia tried, but he told me I'm going to eat rice bread. Yes, people eat that. So he a tumbler is not the food of the people here. But in the Arabian Peninsula, tamales raw food. Right? The Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam I said

00:33:08--> 00:33:14

what he called the tumbler you get it with the Halle. The prophets Allah sama said is a complete media

00:33:16--> 00:33:25

and the Addison in Abuja we discussed that last time so get the book and understand inshallah you will be very healthy and you forget about this Japanese

00:33:27--> 00:33:31

instruction. They tell you the eating the way they eat, you will live longer, it doesn't go like that.

00:33:33--> 00:33:49

They can be similar to the visa La Silla. Take this and now the Prophet Allah, Allah you will succeed with a lighter color with terracotta Leanna Bella damla, with tiny little had a year. The second opinion is some scholars who says to rock the Massara Kingdom calobra dilemma.

00:33:50--> 00:34:07

The first opinion says we return back the animal and we return back along with it also this amount of timber the second opinion says what No, we return the animal but we will not return along with it the date but we return the love and it's up

00:34:08--> 00:34:20

the milk as long as you don't drink it yet you return it back. We're only in Canada can even sell that. Our miserable if you already consume it. They say you return but similar.

00:34:21--> 00:34:59

Yet it's similar to that. In Canada elephant if you already destroy that our key mucha who yo Miranda hice una mujer method. You tried to find an equal amount you couldn't find? Then you evaluate the level the time you are returning back to the animal. How much is that? Not the time you bought the animal because the time you bought the animal, the price might differ from the time you're returning back to the animal to get that's why they said yoma your morality. So that's been similar to the opinion of the vast majority of the scholars but they say you don't return back date you return back what you return back. The lemon itself if you can return it, if it is not there.

00:35:00--> 00:35:07

You buy lemon similar to that you give it to the owner. If you cannot do that, then you pay the Kima the value of that which you consume.

00:35:09--> 00:35:20

Directly I know Takara Belmont slough in Canada, Miss Lee and Fabian Miss Lee, they go with the general ruling right. And this is the problem right? I'm going to have a general comment when I read you the Hannity's.

00:35:21--> 00:35:22

Also.

00:35:23--> 00:35:33

You see, sometimes we we depend so much and excessively akiza chaos, chaos, chaos, chaos, chaos, and you have no source of sherea get about the issue, right?

00:35:35--> 00:35:35

It's a lot

00:35:37--> 00:35:54

of us. Right? But those calls me excuse them, because in many cases they don't see than us. sure we're gonna see that in Sharla. But this opinion says takala follow suit. They say we already have it establish according to the legal Maxim, another man and Luffy.

00:35:55--> 00:36:04

In Canada, Miss Lee infamously and Mattila is the destroyed item, item that you destroy, I destroy your car.

00:36:05--> 00:36:19

How do I paid it back to you car in kanamycin information. What is understood by this call us is if I destroy your property, if this property has something similar to it, then I have to buy similar and give it back to you.

00:36:21--> 00:36:47

You get it you have a brand new car. Mercedes, for example, I destroy it, I have to buy the same thing. I give it back to you in chemistry, and if I really miss it, I killed your camel, I have to buy another camel and give it to you. Initially. We're in Canada, KB and fibula Kima there are some other things which you cannot return back similar. any animal somehow is like that to cover exactly the same animal as almost impossible.

00:36:49--> 00:37:21

Right? Exactly the same thing that's almost impossible. So sometimes you have to go for what? For Kiba in some items you cannot find similar, then you go for what you go for Kiva. Kiva means the value will Lebanon encana Miss Lee and domina Mythili. They said Likewise, we we say concerning the lemon, if we cannot, if we can find the lemon, we just buy the lemon and pay for that. Or in Canada, Kimmy and Kuma via had an accident, it is something that we cannot find. It's similar in the market, then we have to pay the value.

00:37:24--> 00:37:36

Okay, for you the model be temporary. Our top it says if this is a case, we already understand this. And all of the scholars agree upon this. How can we pay 11? With what with

00:37:38--> 00:37:43

your drunk level but your pain? With tomorrow? They said it doesn't go like that.

00:37:45--> 00:37:45

Now,

00:37:46--> 00:37:50

maybe there is no see. That's why then no Kevin was

00:37:52--> 00:37:59

11. And also they said also look at it and watch it according to the scholars is you pay according to what you consume.

00:38:00--> 00:38:06

I just drank one cup. For sure. The tumbler is more valuable than the cup.

00:38:08--> 00:38:10

How do you ask me to pay one side of the table?

00:38:13--> 00:38:42

Do you get it? So these are these are their justification. They have other justification which I don't want to go through them right. So this is a second opinion. The first one said what we follow the Hadees Exactly. And his opinion of who companions of the Prophet sallallahu Sallam Tyrone and many other scholars, right. We return it back and we return back along with it tomorrow, right? The second opinion says yes, we return it back. But we don't return tomorrow but we return

00:38:43--> 00:38:46

a milk he has to go and buy milk and give it to to the owner.

00:38:54--> 00:38:56

Carla, and I'm in Santa Ana says okay.

00:38:57--> 00:39:01

Well gee Viviana tiasa Tada Munna

00:39:02--> 00:39:25

Allah remover fishermen with lava. He says we just tell us how do we are those Muslim scholars who I mean are saying this right we tell them even this class of yours is wrong. Because to generalize, where specification is needed, this call us when they say that we are mentioning they don't they don't say that in everything.

00:39:28--> 00:39:29

What are their castle?

00:39:30--> 00:39:50

What are the Beingness? He says even if we agree with the legal maximum you're talking about but this is a specific mention by the professor last summer we have to understand it within that restriction or hasakah devananda you have cos general and you have specific which one takes the preference. Of course the costs

00:39:51--> 00:40:00

you get is of course the cost. I mean the prophets Allah sama said everyone is included and then he gets extracted one we gave that person

00:40:00--> 00:40:04

instruction we don't include it in their home because the nurse says it is not included

00:40:05--> 00:40:48

kawamata Kurosawa naka de Rosario the Add factor shadow really added you know, they said what they said we have to pay the I mean, the the value of what we consume? Not like we just asked him to pay that amount even if the consumption is little Allah miticide he said no, we also have to understand that Sharia tries to block the means of discharge of a conflict, right? If I just live I mean to the two contracting parties, they will never agree because the buyer wants to sell and he doesn't want it to be the time he will say okay, my lemon costs 100,000 and even the cover itself is 50,000

00:40:49--> 00:40:51

otherwise you take it back to the to the

00:40:52--> 00:40:58

How can you do that? You tell them Okay, take it back to the place otherwise you pay 100,000

00:41:00--> 00:41:13

the professor last summer to close the page. He please both right? You You want your money to come back. And this guy lost his milk which is inside and we cannot take it back. So let us compensate him he said pay him sir. Meantime.

00:41:14--> 00:41:46

You get it? Regardless of the amount the professor last summer closer page and if we know if we have the submission, right, we know that Sharia is the one who says this we have to submit a lot smarter says fella I want to pick up now you know nahata you have chemo coffee machines or amino thermography emphysema, hydrogen mockolate, where you sell the motors NEMA. That's Islam. Nobody will be a true believer in a loss of power to Allah. Until he makes the prophets Allah Allah who sama a judge in all of his affairs.

00:41:47--> 00:41:53

By in the time of the Prophet Allah salamander companions, they go back to him in our time. How do you do that?

00:41:54--> 00:42:38

Can we yes, we do towards the sooner because when the companions I mean seek the judgment of the prophet SAW somewhere or were they looking for so now from the prophets Allah Salah, so that's a nice properly documented for us that a heck of a lot sooner than me, Sarah Laszlo, kala Himalaya geography emphysema, Rajan Nima of it. And also a Muslim, a true believer in Allah shouldn't find any complication. Any worry, you get any annoyance concerning the matter of taking from the province that Allahu alayhi wa sallam, he shouldn't find any any any problem with that. What do you sell the motus Lima and also they have to submit completely to the decision of the prophets Allah Allah. So

00:42:38--> 00:43:12

if we have the prophets, Allah sama saying What sir, our main terminal, what does that mean? It means sock should be maintained and normalcy is going to argue, right? So that was the justification actually, if we are I mean refutes the opinion of those scholars who are saying we didn't know how much to pay and how much you consume. We will tell them no Sharia already decide and the decision of Sharia take place right. Kalia de la COVID de la caja Catherine levani. Joseph salata, Hebei, hydrazine bidorbuy Takata Sheree Nisa aka Dara hadden, la rue de la

00:43:14--> 00:43:14

la

00:43:15--> 00:43:31

la la la ever rough and La Suma de Vaca de julio the corruption 11 in Cana potency daddy Casa de la Aqua, he says also look at the wisdom of Sharia when she asked me to pay a lot more to ask you to pay with

00:43:32--> 00:43:32

temple

00:43:33--> 00:44:05

because the closest thing to temple in terms of code is liberty. How does the Arab it double we live in. That's why the prophet SAW some I call it Carmen and Halima Camila Tama sallallahu alayhi wa sallam for he says Katara who be a Kirby Shay in Illinois 11 finder who find the home mechanic booth and phenolic ism and they were the food to the table the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, when he heard that Herman Allah officially it

00:44:07--> 00:44:25

Who are the managing it kalamoon and he says we have also similar applications in sha Allah if Allah smarter Wish we will live. Get it we will live thus first. And also we are still here in Malaysia we are going to see this moment. The time we will study kuttabul Jeanette

00:44:26--> 00:44:28

and tabel Jeanette I think

00:44:29--> 00:44:34

last year when when when did we start this global moron

00:44:35--> 00:44:37

I think before you were born right.

00:44:39--> 00:45:00

So Alhamdulillah we are in the third major lead right the beginning of the third major lead we finished to July so we have one more after this. So two more now. Right. So that one was ages. I don't know how many years were love Island. So that's why I said if I lost my job I wish we will see the time and we are still alive. To see the time where we will study together.

00:45:00--> 00:45:19

Regina Jeannette, you will see similar application these people they have a problem How come I lost my heart Allah ask you to pay Leben with Tamar amines and it says here in some other places which you also believe in that Allah asked you to pay something which something which is not, which is not the same, like in what do you call a movie.

00:45:21--> 00:45:28

These are the jahad that take place on the heads or in the body of humankind. They get it usually in that

00:45:30--> 00:45:44

movie. Again, these are the type of injuries, the one that just removed the skin and it shows the bone or sometimes it cuts the bone also you can see the brain yet each and every one of them How do you pay that? How do you make this house?

00:45:46--> 00:45:48

How do you do a sauce in this?

00:45:49--> 00:45:56

Because Allah says determinada him via an f7 fc while I while I'm febrile amfi

00:45:57--> 00:46:08

was Sydney Sydney, one euro happy sauce. You see a sin and then of sabinus soul with a soul because you can do causes

00:46:09--> 00:46:14

right? He killed Carlos we don't need to take any precaution. He also has to go

00:46:15--> 00:46:18

unless a business will lie in a blind

00:46:19--> 00:47:06

eye with an eye can I remove the eye of a person and he's still live? Yes. Can this one also survive so the other person also we can remove it? That's cases as well unprivileged knows he removed somebody else's nose his also has to go Allah very beautiful Sharia or live this is going to be practice I'm telling you you will see everyone maintaining his life and good will happen. That's why last month he says welcome felucca sassy hyah you live lies in the law of retaliation. What does that mean? Notice as no life Do we see the application of this? Yes, you guys will lie surgeon will never do that. You take a person to jail he stays for ages and then he comes out and do a celebrate

00:47:07--> 00:47:38

and the surgeon also doesn't work doesn't fix the person nowadays there was June there was what the surgeon do what they destroy more. That's why I see in some countries they color celebrate now no more Jain finish. Why? Because it doesn't educate. It destroys more a person's going to meet some evil people. By the time he comes out he became more evil instead of getting fixed. But look at the lower last quarter he killed you bring him in presence of others and kill him

00:47:39--> 00:47:41

tomorrow nobody will care.

00:47:42--> 00:47:45

I'm telling you if the authority does that tomorrow nobody will do that.

00:47:47--> 00:48:00

Yet it's some of the brothers wash they said they couldn't sleep an hour she needs to see that it's coded by the friends they watch. They couldn't sleep one of them told us that he closed his eyes at night you see a lot of heads coming

00:48:02--> 00:48:13

that's where last winter says will a shout out Obama if he needed more money because it was there by the Sharia to be acting as a deterrent right to deter people from doing the same thing

00:48:14--> 00:48:55

get it so if we keep it in that people are not good that's why last month as is your life is in that no Chris has no life. Color nessa Venus will enter the line while amphibians while although will somebody cut up the ears of somebody who is also has to go was sin a sin and also somebody pull out the sits the teeth of another person, his tooth, we also should remove his world your hockey sauce. So these are the basis I mean, whatever could be possibly removed from that person who is a criminal. We do the same thing right? Because he's not better than that person right? So he removed somebody else's part we remove is also a same thing. Tomorrow, another person will not do it.

00:48:57--> 00:49:14

But there are things which cases is not possible. It's very dangerous to do SAS because SAS means a new file a bill, bill bill Gianni mithila McFarland bill Martinelli to do the same thing he does he did with the the person whom he committed crime abort.

00:49:16--> 00:49:17

Right. Like

00:49:19--> 00:49:34

when you have a group of I mean a person who killed another person and the family agree that cases shall be afflicted upon him. But there is one person amongst the family members who is among das, who says, I forgive.

00:49:36--> 00:49:37

Can we do the sauce? No.

00:49:38--> 00:49:47

Because if we do the kisses, we have to kill that person. But we have to keep the part which is owned by that person who forgives alive.

00:49:48--> 00:49:52

Let's say he owns the ice so we have to remove the ice and ice keep on looking right.

00:49:53--> 00:49:56

Is that possible? It's impossible. That's why the whole thing will be gone.

00:49:58--> 00:49:59

The sauce will be jeopardized.

00:50:00--> 00:50:05

Get it to what he demanded. He was looking for the idea has to be paid.

00:50:06--> 00:50:33

Getting somebody hate another person it removed the bones. You can see the brain. We bring somebody to do the causes is very dangerous. You can touch the brain and then the guy will you got he dies. He did not kill the first one. And we killed him. That's wrong. That's why she says we go forward. We go for chemo. You go for DHEA and then Sharia will tell you the prescribed amount of money you should pay.

00:50:34--> 00:50:48

To get idea this is how she is so accurate. And this is to tell you that this is from Allah smart Allah. He says Allah to the Buddha Allah Quran Hello Can Amina in delay delay. Now Voyager 250 11 cathedra.

00:50:49--> 00:51:23

That Sharia Rabbani urbania from Allah subhanaw taala that's why you don't have any discrepancies in it is a complete Chilean unique Chilean very accurate Sharia. So the medicine and is telling us here at this college they should remember that in Sharia also we have similar issues where last minute Allah He asked you to pay something other than what you did, like here. We didn't. We didn't pay the I mean, we didn't ask that person to come and sit down on the weekend of his head in the way I mean some part of his head in the way he did with the majan era. We don't do that can move more.

00:51:26--> 00:51:27

inertia modern

00:51:29--> 00:51:32

maxilla Phil, Phil bikini basically

00:51:33--> 00:51:49

fill keep it was very, it says that the judge is supposed to describe how much somebody is going to pay according to the what he called the size of of the injury. Or pg&e, Max levy. And also you have the genie for the person hits.

00:51:50--> 00:52:08

I mean, is the cause of the body called the miscarriage of a woman. How much you shall pay the deer. The deer is what is one 10th of the complete deer kurata abdeen alhama that's what the professor Lazzara said in the Hadees of those two sisters. unsaleable highly

00:52:10--> 00:52:12

men to women they were they were to Shara

00:52:13--> 00:52:46

alpha Mahajan, Robertson corabi for katella Tamati. Battaglia, who hadn't mentioned this. So these two sisters are fighting each other one of them got angry and mad at the other ones, she took a stone, she throw it on the on the on the other one, she killed that woman together with the genie. The Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam I said the family of that woman should pay the deer for the for the for the woman completely. And also for the Janine they should pay one 10th of the deer This is garota abdon arama you see this Jenny might be big.

00:52:47--> 00:52:54

While be small, maybe this might be that but the professor last summer said the DA is is the same regardless of the nature of the journey.

00:52:56--> 00:53:27

Well hickmott fee value for calida for Tisha he said that the wisdom behind that will love our enemies to avoid conflict that might arise among the Muslim ummah. So I will stop here in sha Allah La next class, I plan to go to the next Hadees but I don't think time will permit us. So next class we will complete the recall the discussion on the opinions of the scholars and then we will move on to the Hadith of the lion Massoud is in light Allah barakallahu combs Hannukah la ma vmdk Chateau la in Atlantis different cartoons