Hatem al-Haj – The Hanbali School Part 2 Usul
AI: Summary ©
AI: Transcript ©
Mila from the Samsung
can be in the when it comes to the RP the certainly the honeyberries
have been known to be mostly or predominantly Hathor is
there are a few things that I want to say here because this is
something that I have to train myself to train myself all the
time to do this. Sometimes partisanship can be can be an
intellectual disability
because it prevents us from trying to understand. And basically we
wish like, we shut down and we just don't attempt to have a
proper understanding
about the Hanbury school from the time of Imam Asmat
has been heavily sad because of the mammoth mud was all about
asada and was all about the dispraise of Kalam.
He
and it's, you know, it's also the generation and it depends on what
you mean by Kalam and whether like certain Kalam would be accepted
and not all Kalam and so on.
But the idea that Imam Muhammad was against against
Kalam and was all for SR
as I think, an established idea
we can come later and talk about you know, what we mean by current
because I personally and
ironically, there's actually
that I may an approach that I made in school which is basically more
accepting of Calum and warmer to color Amanda Humphries but
the man himself he's he's always like you know mass amount you
haven't heard that the US you know, foreign who the mama mad we
didn't talk about it also No, I didn't talk about also but if you
want to we can
if he wants to go into a suit of his method, if you feel that it's
a priority do that before opt EDA we can do that.
Okay, let's do it. Since you brought it up. Why don't we bring
it i It was my chapter beforehand Anyway, before opting to anyone
has to be well suited. So let's, let's do that.
Wanted to ask about the Sunnah many times when I meet Showa
Shafia and Hannah villa, they don't actually realize that the
henna via medical schools have sources they consider stronger
than the single change. So here Hadith, okay.
And they look a bit bit surprised sometimes when they do not accept
that
the single change Hadith to offer an exception
to something that's come down in the Quran and oftentimes the the
very concept of
Pattaya and Danny is, is the completely unaware of right, of
course, any anyone who grows up in a certain milieu is not going to
be aware of certain, you know, matters of also. So that's, you
know, forgivable in that respect. The idea here that
if you could talk a little bit about that, and how is it that the
humbly school recognizes the Son How does it define the son I
should say, that's really the question, how does it how many
school define what is the order of matters within the Sunnah we know
of course, the medic, you have the Ahmed, of course, right? And
that's a big thing. We know that if they have this concept of the
cutlery and the money. So if you can expound on the Sunnah in the
humbly school,
the Sunday School
is
certainly the scope of what is considered authoritative in terms
of the sun and the homebody school is wider. We do have the same
recognition of Qatari and Zani in terms of transmission.
However, this is solely
this site disagreement that is not necessarily defined along math
lines, whether for instance, the
Mustapha Collie
Hadees that are reported by both Bukhari and Muslim
are Katai and transmission definitive or speculative and
transmission and the murderer also the UN or the majority of them
would consider themselves to be Vani and transmission, not
definitive speculative.
But it is it is a controversial issue and you will find people
like salah, Tamia and Eben Hunter and so on considering the agreed
upon Hadees as pottery
when it comes to the Hanbury school I was waiting to
finish the color Sahabi because I was going to come back to the Sun
after Palace hobby. There's part of the Sunnah.
In the Hanbury school, the Sunnah that is authentic comes certainly
before Congress Sahabi and Imam Muhammad would not leave the
statement of the prophesy Salman for any statement.
But according to an MMR mat,
and that is where it becomes a little bit controversial.
According to Mr. Matt, he accepts the wave holidays
he ranks mobile if hobbies above appears he does not however, rank
above if Hadith above power Sahabi or prepositions are imported from
the sahaba. Yet, there could be some contention here which live
Hadith are we talking about?
Different people positive different things during the time
of the mama met,
the three prank classification
had not come into the picture yet. This was introduced the by actor
movie and the generation of an amateur movie.
So during the time of edema, the sort of the concept of it Hassan,
they recognized that you know there is that certainly it is a
scope. It is a spectrum and the ahaadeeth fall on that spectrum.
And even within the one category of a person, you have an Hassan a
person, a Euro, and so people who say that Mr. Muhammad accepted of
a leaf Hadith that
a Buddha would would call solidarity judge which is weaker
than what their Maisy would call Hassan.
So,
basically, considerable or can be used for corroboration, or
something of that nature.
If people if the people who say that Mr. Muhammad would accept
those are hobbies, they will certainly place them after a
couple of Sahabi the people who say that Dyneema would accept what
it Timothy would later call Hassan, or at least the Hudson
River era, and that people have different thoughts about this and
it seems that the Mohammed does accept all of them, including what
Abu they would call sort of deja vu which is even a little weaker
than it has under it. But whatever meaning that it can be
corroborated, it can be basically
supported by other reports or by countless hobby or by something
else to be acceptable in the cam a Muhammad himself is that that we
verify that hadith when it comes to our cam and it was reported
that he even pointed with his thumbs up like this hadith and Cam
have to be you know, verifiable, but not in other areas.
So there is there is that controversy. So some according to
the My mathema would include everything that came from the
Prophet including the not very weak by the not very weak Hadith
but like I said he would favor coal as a hobby over the if Hadith
and certainly if it is Hassan or something then he would favor it
overpower the Sahaba so we said the Quran and we said the Sunnah
we said that it's man we talked about Cara Sahabi and he would
accept the statement of Sahabi
that is not basically
contested by others hobbies, but when it is contested then you
choose and sometimes when the sort of the disagreement is as hard for
him to set up then he would report all of them as valid positions and
then comes pay us and the mama does accept pls
but he uses it for the rubra you know when he does not find
anything else, no other reports nothing from the prophets on some
of the Sahaba the Tebay
then he would use PS
these are the ones that are clear cut we are very confident about
them. Certainly among Tamia Rahim Allah added to them he posited
that the mud and many would agree with him in the mouth hub, that
MMR also use the masala masala also using SAP the Varaha also
used SSN
as long as the Hammam retana consideration of public interest
and said the visa bulletin demeans the evil just in case somebody
listens to this.
And, and Stan would be juristic preference
and as this hub, the presumption of continuity, and even sort of
learner as well.
You know, the laws that were revealed or previous scriptures.
So now
that's that's contested, you know,
but certainly to a great extent
that us must law, how did you use
lambda as a standard Imam Shafi condemned but certainly, you know,
you know, different terms and different language games, they
have different uses. So that will be like, in a nutshell, the whole
sort of mama,
let's talk for a second and contrasts the hamady FIP and the
Chevy FIP because a lot of times
you hear comments and you notice that they're so similar. So in
their photo the results so could you contrast for us the some of
the differences between chef as the chef or Eagle soul and the
hamburger also, you know, the two big ones is not to diversify and
has studied that not consider Carlos a hobby to be a source.
Although some of the shafts I use would also disagree over this, but
that seems to be a change between us Kadeem in history lead.
And another one is that Imam Shafi does not consider yourself as our
our as in very much we do consider said that
those are two major differences I believe emulsify does not
necessarily state that life is acceptable.
You know, he does not prepare prioritize life over appear. So
the mama does.
These are Sunni differences, certainly, in Ferrara we there
could be like 10,000 differences between the cafe and Betty math
hubs, but when it comes to also do you do have some to some degrees
significant differences? Can you can you give an example of where
some of these differences manifest in the furore
between those two methods in particular
well, and you know, like, for for take, for example, Southern mama
mud wood block that means, like BiOp lemania camera and for
instance, selling grapes to someone who would,
who would the
use them or make mine out of them.
So, the Mavic is and honeyberries they have a much stronger like
consideration for southern Morocco, the Maliki's and
honeyberries they have a much stronger consideration for
my password in a man and my password and our code. This will
be
in fact intense. In all intents and contracts
the magic is our hamburgers, for instance would make a snap or
exclusion by intent in oath. So if you make an oath and in your in
your intent you
Have you exclude something from that oath they would consider that
exclusion, a valid exclusion from the oath.
So
intense and Olson in contracts. Certainly, the Safa emails have in
terms of contracts, they they focus a lot more on the form of
the contract than the honeyberries or the Maliki's for that matter.
Terms of contemporary issues, we noticed that the full ca and the
Mufti of team and the Federal Council's oftentimes have to dip
into the lawsuit, the methodologies and the
precedent set across the board.
Notice this
in Is there a Mehsana that you can talk to us about that sort of
requires a reliance on somebody also or how many principles that
touches our daily lives
a lot there are a lot
basically
they have used the humbly masa a lot in different Madonna and in
different councils and different Sharia boards in the area of mama
that in the area of contracts. Because bodies are very flexible
with conditions.
You know,
say want to end this route am endless or tannheimer Mahalalel
AHA man.
So Muslims abide by their conditions or honor their
conditions except a condition that makes Halal haram or haram halal.
And the honeyberries take this to heart and they apply this in our
code and they even apply this in marriage like in Prenuptial
agreements. For instance,
you can have a woman in the Hanbury madhhab stipulate that
that her that her husband would not have a second wife of hers
that she will not have a co wife. And if he does not honor that
condition, then honeyberries, unlike of me,
would give her the right to divorce.
They use this sometimes in certain laws and certain Muslim countries.
But in our code in particular, particularly when it comes to
Islamic finance, the humbly mazhab is used a lot to allow different
conditions that would not otherwise be allowed in the other
Messiah.
But the mannequin Masada has given Islamic finance, like
a basically depends on whether you like a shift like a reality, for
instance, in Libya would not agree with the idea of Eduardo and
Monson, which is the binding promise, particularly when it's
mutually binding from both parties. But the Maliki method,
Islamic finance would not survive without the binding promise the
concept of a binding promise, because in all the other mazahub
The promise is not binding. So you know, sale for the purchase order
which is by Anwar Bahauddin, Mr. Bashara sale for the purchase
order that would have not survived at all without binding promise
even declining co ownership. If there is no binding promise to
buy, that would not survive that sort of contract or model of
Islamic financing could not survive. They have taken all of
this from the Maliki mouth. But anyway, the hambar is with with
allow for conditions unless the condition is clearly
you know, stipulate is haram is clearly haram it's
you know, positively forbidden and the Crown arson
Okay, good. Do you have any other comments on the lawsuit point? I
think that was a pretty brief chapter and doesn't really require
much, you know, depth into it.